Calibration methods for a multi-channel multi-frequency EIT system

Robust electrical impedance tomography for biological application: A mini review

Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) has been used by researchers across several areas because of its low-cost and no-radiation properties. Researchers use complex conductivity in bioimpedance experiments to evaluate changes in various indicators within the image target. The diverse volumes and edges of biological tissues and the large impedance range impose dedicated demands on hardware design. The EIT hardware with a high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), fast scanning and suitable for the impedance range of the image target is a fundamental foundation that EIT research needs to be equipped with. Understanding the characteristics of this technique and state-of-the-art design will accelerate the development of the robust system and provide a guidance for the superior performance of next-generation EIT. This review explores the hardware strategies for EIT proposed in the literature.

Parasitic Effects on Electrical Bioimpedance Systems: Critical Review

Parasitic capacitance represents the main error source in measurement systems based on electrical impedance spectroscopy. The capacitive nature of electrodes' impedance in tetrapolar configuration can give origin to phase errors when electrodes are coupled to parasitic capacitances. Nevertheless, reactive charges in tissue excitation systems are susceptible to instability. Based on such a scenario, mitigating capacitive effects associated with the electrode is a requirement in order to reduce errors in the measurement system. A literature review about the main compensation techniques for parasitic capacitance was carried out. The selected studies were categorized into three groups: (i) compensation in electronic instrumentation; (ii) compensation in measurement processing, and (iii) compensation by negative impedance converters. The three analyzed methods emerged as effective against fixed capacitance. No method seemed capable of mitigating the effects of electrodes' capacitance, that changes in the frequency spectrum. The analysis has revealed the need for a method to compensate varying capacitances, since electrodes' impedance is unknown.

Characteristics and topic trends on electrical impedance tomography hardware publications

Objective: Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) is a technique to measure electrical properties of tissue. With the progress of modern integrated circuits and microchips, EIT instrumentation becomes an active research area to improve all aspects of device performance. Plenty of studies on EIT hardware have been presented in prestigious journals. This study explores publications on EIT hardware to identify the developing hotspots and trends. Method: Publications covering EIT hardware on the Web of Science Core Collection (WoSCC) database from 1989 to 2021 were collected for bibliometric analysis. CiteSpace and VOS viewer were used to study the characteristics of the publications. Main results: A total of 592 publications were analyzed, showing that the number of annual publications steadily increased. China, England, and South Korea were the most prolific countries on EIT hardware publications with productive native institutions and authors. Research topics spread out in "bio-electrical impedance imaging", "hardware optimization", "algorithms" and "clinical applications" (e.g., tissue, lung, brain, and oncology). Hardware research in "pulmonary" and "hemodynamic" applications focused on monitoring and were represented by silhouette recognition and dynamic imaging while research in "tumor and tissue" and "brain" applications focused on diagnosis and were represented by optimization of precision. Electrode development was a research focus through the years. Imaging precision and bioavailability of hardware optimization may be the future trend. Conclusion: Overall, system performance, particularly in the areas of system bandwidth and precision in applications may be the future directions of hardware research.

Practical Implementation of a Novel Output Impedance Measurement Technique for EIT System While Attached to a Load. ANNUAL INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE OF THE IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY SOCIETY. IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY SOCIETY. ANNUAL INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE 2021;2021:3952-3956. [PMID: 34892096 PMCID: PMC9310546 DOI: 10.1109/embc46164.2021.9629839] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

A novel method for measuring the output impedance of current sources in an EIT system is implemented and tested. The paper shows that the proposed method can be used at the time of operation while the load is attached to the EIT system. the results also show that performance of the system improves when the shunt impedance values from the proposed technique are used to set the adaptive sources as opposed to the shunt impedance values acquired through open circuit measurements.

Measuring Current Source Output Impedance in EIT Systems while Attached to a Load

A novel method for measuring the shunt impedance of current sources in Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) systems is introduced. In an EIT system, electrical currents with theoretical sum of zero, are applied to the body and any mismatch between the currents results in current going through an extra grounded electrode. Since the N - 1 current patterns applied in an N-electrode EIT system are orthogonal to each other, by introducing an additional linearly- independent current pattern, a system of linear equations can be established from which the unknown shunt impedances can be calculated. The framework of the proposed scheme is introduced and its effectiveness is validated through both simulation and practical implementation. The experimental results show that by measuring the shunt impedances with the proposed method and using those values to adjust the current sources, the current passing through the grounded electrode is significantly reduced.

Noninvasive, simultaneous, and continuous measurements of stroke volume and tidal volume using EIT: feasibility study of animal experiments

Currently, there is no noninvasive method available for simultaneous measurements of tidal volume and stroke volume. Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) has been used for regional lung ventilation imaging. Cardiac EIT imaging, however, has not been successful due to the technical difficulty in extracting weak cardiogenic components. Instead of regional imaging, in this paper, we use the EIT technique to simultaneously measure two global variables of tidal volume and stroke volume. Time-varying patterns of boundary voltage data originating from lung ventilation and cardiac blood flow were extracted from measured boundary voltage data using the principal component analysis (PCA) and independent component analysis (ICA). The source consistency theory was adopted to separately synthesize time-series of boundary voltage data associated with lung ventilation and cardiac blood flow. The respiratory volume signal (RVS) and cardiac volume signal (CVS) were extracted from reconstructed time-difference EIT images of lung ventilation and cardiac blood flow, respectively. After calibrating the volume signals using the mechanical ventilator and the invasive transpulmonary thermodilution (TPTD) method, tidal volume and stroke volume were computed as valley-to-peak values of the RVS and CVS, respectively. The difference in the tidal volume data between EIT and mechanical ventilator was within ± 20 ml from six pigs. The difference in the stroke volume data between EIT and TPTD was within ± 4.7 ml from the same animals. The results show the feasibility of the proposed method as a new noninvasive cardiopulmonary monitoring tool for simultaneous continuous measurements of stroke volume and tidal volume that are two most important vital signs.

Integrated EIT system for functional lung ventilation imaging

Background

Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) has been used for functional lung imaging of regional air distributions during mechanical ventilation in intensive care units (ICU). From numerous clinical and animal studies focusing on specific lung functions, a consensus about how to use the EIT technique has been formed lately. We present an integrated EIT system implementing the functions proposed in the consensus. The integrated EIT system could improve the usefulness when monitoring of mechanical ventilation for lung protection so that it could facilitate the clinical acceptance of this new technique.

Methods

Using a custom-designed 16-channel EIT system with 50 frames/s temporal resolution, the integrated EIT system software was developed to implement five functional images and six EIT measures that can be observed in real-time screen view and analysis screen view mode, respectively. We evaluated the performance of the integrated EIT system with ten mechanically ventilated porcine subjects in normal and disease models.

Results

Quantitative and simultaneous imaging of tidal volume (TV), end-expiratory lung volume change (\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\triangle$$\end{document}▵EELV), compliance, ventilation delay, and overdistension/collapse images were performed. Clinically useful parameters were successfully extracted including anterior/posterior ventilation ratio (A/P ratio), center of ventilation (\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\mathrm{CoV}}_{{x}}$$\end{document}CoVx, \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\mathrm{CoV}}_{{y}}$$\end{document}CoVy), global inhomogeneity (GI), coefficient of variation (CV), ventilation delay and percentile of overdistension/collapse. The integrated EIT system was demonstrated to suggest an optimal positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) for lung protective ventilation in normal and in the disease model of an acute injury. Optimal PEEP for normal and disease model was 2.3 and \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$7.9 \, {\mathrm{cmH}}_{2}\mathrm{O}$$\end{document}7.9cmH2O, respectively.

Conclusions

The proposed integrated approach for functional lung ventilation imaging could facilitate clinical acceptance of the bedside EIT imaging method in ICU. Future clinical studies of applying the proposed methods to human subjects are needed to show the clinical significance of the method for lung protective mechanical ventilation and mechanical ventilator weaning in ICU.

Balanced Adjustable Mirrored Current Source with Common Mode Feedback and Output Measurement for Bioimpedance Applications

Bioimpedance methods are used in a variety of applications such as impedance tomography, electrodermal activity detection and vascular disease assessment. Recent developments in portable and unobtrusive biosignal acquisition systems facilitate the integration of wearable bioimpedance applications including sleep monitoring, respiration estimation and fluid monitoring. However, the less stable measurement situation in a wearable scenario increases the requirements for the system's accuracy and adaptability. The current source of a bioimpedance system needs to drive large complex loads subject to vast variations over time while maintaining a high level of accuracy. The widely used improved Howland current source suffers from multiple disadvantages when considered for an adaptive bioimpedance system. We propose an optimized mirrored architecture which allows for a simple output current adjustment and current measurement without an additional shunt resistor in the load path. The system implements a common mode feedback system which includes balancing of the mirrored sources. Our design is validated by calculation, SPICE simulation and complex load measurements. We achieved output impedances in excess of 3 MΩ and derived a simplified transconductance function valid for frequencies up to 1 MHz. We conclude that the presented architecture is an important step forward towards accurate wearable bioimpedance acquisition. Employing generalized impedance converters, the output impedance could be further optimized.

Portable multi-parameter electrical impedance tomography for sleep apnea and hypoventilation monitoring: feasibility study

OBJECTIVE

Quantitative ventilation monitoring and respiratory event detection are needed for the diagnosis of sleep apnea and hypoventilation. We developed a portable device with a chest belt, nasal cannula and finger sensor to continuously acquire multi-channel signals including tidal volume, nasal pressure, respiratory effort, body position, snoring sound, ECG and SpO₂. The unique feature of the device is the continuous tidal volume signal obtained from real-time lung ventilation images produced by the electrical impedance tomography (EIT) technique.

APPROACH

The chest belt includes 16 electrodes for real-time time-difference EIT imaging and ECG data acquisitions. It also includes a microphone, accelerometer, gyroscope, magnetometer and pressure sensor to acquire, respectively, snoring sound, respiratory effort, body position and nasal pressure signals. A separate finger sensor is used to measure SpO₂. The minute ventilation signal is derived from the tidal volume signal and respiration rate.

MAIN RESULTS

The experimental results from a conductivity phantom, four swine subjects and one human volunteer show that the developed multi-parameter EIT device could supplement existing polysomnography (PSG) and home sleep test (HST) devices to improve the accuracy of sleep apnea diagnosis. The portable device could be also used as a new tool for continuous hypoventilation monitoring of non-intubated patients with respiratory depression.

SIGNIFICANCE

Following the feasibility study in this paper, future validation studies in comparison with in-lab PSG, HST and end-tidal CO₂ devices are suggested to find its clinical efficacy as a sleep apnea diagnosis and hypoventilation monitoring tool.

An instrumental electrode model for solving EIT forward problems

An instrumental electrode model (IEM) capable of describing the performance of electrical impedance tomography (EIT) systems in the MHz frequency range has been proposed. Compared with the commonly used Complete Electrode Model (CEM), which assumes ideal front-end interfaces, the proposed model considers the effects of non-ideal components in the front-end circuits. This introduces an extra boundary condition in the forward model and offers a more accurate modelling for EIT systems. We have demonstrated its performance using simple geometry structures and compared the results with the CEM and full Maxwell methods. The IEM can provide a significantly more accurate approximation than the CEM in the MHz frequency range, where the full Maxwell methods are favoured over the quasi-static approximation. The improved electrode model will facilitate the future characterization and front-end design of real-world EIT systems.

The differential Howland current source with high signal to noise ratio for bioimpedance measurement system

The stability and signal to noise ratio (SNR) of the current source circuit are the important factors contributing to enhance the accuracy and sensitivity in bioimpedance measurement system. In this paper we propose a new differential Howland topology current source and evaluate its output characters by simulation and actual measurement. The results include (1) the output current and impedance in high frequencies are stabilized after compensation methods. And the stability of output current in the differential current source circuit (DCSC) is 0.2%. (2) The output impedance of two current circuits below the frequency of 200 KHz is above 1 MΩ, and below 1 MHz the output impedance can arrive to 200 KΩ. Then in total the output impedance of the DCSC is higher than that of the Howland current source circuit (HCSC). (3) The SNR of the DCSC are 85.64 dB and 65 dB in the simulation and actual measurement with 10 KHz, which illustrates that the DCSC effectively eliminates the common mode interference. (4) The maximum load in the DCSC is twice as much as that of the HCSC. Lastly a two-dimensional phantom electrical impedance tomography is well reconstructed with the proposed HCSC. Therefore, the measured performance shows that the DCSC can significantly improve the output impedance, the stability, the maximum load, and the SNR of the measurement system.

Multi-frequency electrical impedance tomography system with automatic self-calibration for long-term monitoring

Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) is a safe medical imaging technology, requiring no ionizing or heating radiation, as opposed to most other imaging modalities. This has led to a clinical interest in its use for long-term monitoring, possibly at the bedside, for ventilation monitoring, bleeding detection, gastric emptying and epilepsy foci diagnosis. These long-term applications demand auto-calibration and high stability over long time periods. To address this need we have developed a new multi-frequency EIT system called the KHU Mark2.5 with automatic self-calibration and cooperation with other devices via a timing signal for synchronization with other medical instruments. The impedance measurement module (IMM) for flexible configuration as a key component includes an independent constant current source, an independent differential voltmeter, and a current source calibrator, which allows automatic self-calibration of the current source within each IMM. We installed a resistor phantom inside the KHU Mark2.5 EIT system for intra-channel and inter-channel calibrations of all voltmeters in multiple IMMs. We show the deterioration of performance of an EIT system over time and the improvement due to automatic self-calibration. The system is able to maintain SNR of 80 dB for frequencies up to 250 kHz and below 0.5% reciprocity error over continuous operation for 24 hours. Automatic calibration at least every 3 days is shown to maintain SNR above 75 dB and reciprocity error below 0.7% over 7 days at 1 kHz. A clear degradation in performance results with increasing time between automatic calibrations allowing the tailoring of calibration to suit the performance requirements of each application.

Reconfigurable bioimpedance emulation system for electrical impedance tomography system validation

This paper presents a novel bioimpedance emulation method designed for electrical impedance tomography system validation. The proposed method can emulate the impedance frequency characteristics of various biological samples from user configurations. The bioimpedance emulation system is realized in a hardware prototype comprising current sensing circuitry, voltage generating circuitry, a USB controller and a field-programmable gate array (FPGA) for reconfigurable digital control of emulated impedance. Experimental validation shows that the emulation system exhibits good accuracy ( > 97% at 1 kOhm magnitude) in the frequency range 1 kHz to 1 MHz. The digitally configurability offers advantages in flexibility, repeatability, and cost-efficient compared to more traditional approaches, simplifying the validation process of electrical impedance tomography systems.

Investigation of voltage source design's for Electrical Impedance Mammography (EIM) Systems

According to Jossient, interesting characteristics of breast tissues mostly lie above 1MHz; therefore a wideband excitation source covering higher frequencies (i.e. above 1MHz) is required. The main objective of this research is to establish a feasible bandwidth envelope that can be used to design a constant EIM voltage source over a wide bandwidth with low output impedance for practical implementation. An excitation source is one of the major components in bio-impedance measurement systems. In any bio-impedance measurement system the excitation source can be achieved either by injecting current and measuring the resulting voltages, or by applying voltages and measuring the current developed. This paper describes three voltage source architectures and based on their bandwidth comparison; a differential voltage controlled voltage source (VCVS) is proposed, which can be used over a wide bandwidth (>15MHz). This paper describes the performance of the designed EIM voltage source for different load conditions and load capacitances reporting signal-to-noise ratio of approx 90dB at 10MHz frequency, signal phase and maximum of 4.75kΩ source output impedance at 10MHz. Optimum data obtained using Pspice® is used to demonstrate the high-bandwidth performance of the source.

Validation of weighted frequency-difference EIT using a three-dimensional hemisphere model and phantom

Frequency-difference (FD) electrical impedance tomography (EIT) using a weighted voltage difference has recently been proposed for imaging haemorrhagic stroke, abdominal bleeding and tumors. Although its feasibility was demonstrated through two-dimensional numerical simulations and phantom experiments, we should validate the method in three-dimensional imaging objects. At the same time, we need to investigate its robustness against geometrical modeling errors in boundary shapes and electrode positions. We performed a validation study of the weighted FD method through three-dimensional numerical simulations and phantom experiments. Adopting hemispherical models and phantoms whose admittivity distributions change with frequency, we investigated the performance of the method to detect an anomaly. We found that the simple FD method fails to detect the anomaly, whereas reconstructed images using the weighted FD method clearly visualize the anomaly. The weighted FD method is robust against modeling errors of boundary-shape deformations and displaced electrode positions. We also found that the method is capable of detecting an anomaly surrounded by a shell-shaped obstacle simulating the skull. We propose the weighted FD method for future studies of animal and human experiments.

Design of a microscopic electrical impedance tomography system using two current injections

We describe a novel design of a microscopic electrical impedance tomography (micro-EIT) system for long-term noninvasive monitoring of cell or tissue cultures. The core of the micro-EIT system is a sample container including two pairs of current-injection electrodes and 360 voltage-sensing electrodes. In designing the container, we took advantage of a hexagonal structure with fixed dimensions and electrode configuration. This eliminated technical difficulties related to the unknown irregular boundary geometry of an imaging object in conventional medical EIT. Attaching a pair of large current-injection electrodes fully covering the left and right sides of the hexagonal container, we generated uniform parallel current density inside the container filled with saline. The 360 voltage-sensing electrodes were placed on the front, bottom and back sides of the hexagonal container in three sets of 8 × 15 arrays with equal gaps between them. We measured voltage differences between all neighboring pairs along the direction of the parallel current pathway. For the homogeneous container, all measured voltages must be the same since the voltage changes linearly along that direction. Any anomaly in the container perturbed the current pathways and therefore equipotential lines to produce different differential voltage data. For conductivity image reconstructions, we adopted a lately developed image reconstruction algorithm for this electrode configuration to first produce projected conductivity images on the front, bottom and back sides. Using a backprojection method, we reconstructed three-dimensional conductivity images from those projection images. To improve the image quality and also to meet the mathematical requirement on the uniqueness of a reconstructed image, we used a second pair of thin and long current-injection electrodes located at the middle of the front and back sides. This paper describes the design and construction of such a micro-EIT system with experimental results. Proposing the novel micro-EIT system design, we suggest future studies of miniaturizing the sample container for true microscopic conductivity imaging of cell or tissue cultures.

Design of a novel digital phantom for EIT system calibration

This paper presented the design method of a novel digital phantom for electrical impedance tomography system calibration. By current sensing, voltage generating circuitry and digital processing algorithms implemented in FPGA, the digital phantom can simulate different impedances of tissues. The hardware of the digital phantom mainly consists of current sensing section, voltage generating section, electrodes switching section and a FPGA. Concerning software, the CORDIC algorithm is implemented in the FPGA to realize direct digital synthesis (DDS) technique and related algorithms. Simulation results show that the suggested system exhibits sufficient accuracy in the frequency range 10 Hz to 2 MHz. With the advantages offered by digital techniques, our approach has the potential of speed, accuracy and flexibility of the EIT system calibration process.

Factorization method and its physical justification in frequency-difference electrical impedance tomography

Time-difference electrical impedance tomography (tdEIT) requires two data sets measured at two different times. The difference between them is utilized to produce images of time-dependent changes in a complex conductivity distribution inside the human body. Frequency-difference EIT (fdEIT) was proposed to image frequency-dependent changes of a complex conductivity distribution. It has potential applications in tumor and stroke imaging since it can visualize an anomaly without requiring any time-reference data obtained in the absence of an anomaly. In this paper, we provide a rigorous analysis for the detectability of an anomaly based on a constructive and quantitative physical correlation between a measured fdEIT data set and an anomaly. From this, we propose a new noniterative frequency-difference anomaly detection method called the factorization method (FM) and elaborate its physical justification. To demonstrate its practical applicability, we performed fdEIT phantom imaging experiments using a multifrequency EIT system. Applying the FM to measured frequency-difference boundary voltage data sets, we could quantitatively evaluate indicator functions inside the imaging domain, of which values at each position reveal presence or absence of an anomaly. We found that the FM successfully localizes anomalies inside an imaging domain with a frequency-dependent complex conductivity distribution. We propose the new FM as an anomaly detection algorithm in fdEIT for potential applications in tumor and stroke imaging.