Bipolar Disorder and Gender Are Associated with Frontolimbic and Basal Ganglia Dysconnectivity: A Study of Topological Variance Using Network Analysis

Age Trajectories of the Structural Connectome in Child and Adolescent Offspring of Individuals With Bipolar Disorder or Schizophrenia

Background

Offspring of parents with severe mental illness (e.g., bipolar disorder or schizophrenia) are at elevated risk of developing psychiatric illness owing to both genetic predisposition and increased burden of environmental stress. Emerging evidence indicates a disruption of brain network connectivity in young offspring of patients with bipolar disorder and schizophrenia, but the age trajectories of these brain networks in this high-familial-risk population remain to be elucidated.

Methods

A total of 271 T1-weighted and diffusion-weighted scans were obtained from 174 offspring of at least 1 parent diagnosed with bipolar disorder (n = 74) or schizophrenia (n = 51) and offspring of parents without severe mental illness (n = 49). The age range was 8 to 23 years; 97 offspring underwent 2 scans. Anatomical brain networks were reconstructed into structural connectivity matrices. Network analysis was performed to investigate anatomical brain connectivity.

Results

Offspring of parents with schizophrenia had differential trajectories of connectivity strength and clustering compared with offspring of parents with bipolar disorder and parents without severe mental illness, of global efficiency compared with offspring of parents without severe mental illness, and of local connectivity compared with offspring of parents with bipolar disorder.

Conclusions

The findings of this study suggest that familial high risk of schizophrenia is related to deviations in age trajectories of global structural connectome properties and local connectivity strength.

Diagnostic value of structural, functional and effective connectivity in bipolar disorder

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this systematic review is to assess the functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies of bipolar disorder (BD) patients that characterize differences in terms of structural, functional, and effective connectivity between the patients with BD, patients with other psychiatric disorders and healthy controls as possible biomarkers for diagnosing the disorder using neuroimaging.

METHODS

Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA), guidelines a systematic search for recent (since 2015) original studies on connectivity in bipolar disorder was conducted in PUBMED and SCOPUS.

RESULTS

A total of 60 studies were included in this systematic review: 20 of the structural connectivity, 33 of the functional connectivity, and only 7 of the studies focused on effective connectivity complied with the inclusion and exclusion criteria.

DISCUSSION

Despite the great heterogeneity in the findings, there are several trends that emerge. In structural connectivity studies, the main abnormalities in bipolar disorder patients were in the frontal gyrus, anterior, as well as posterior cingulate cortex and differences in emotion and reward-related networks. Cerebellum (vermis) to cerebrum functional connectivity was found to be the most common finding in BD. Moreover, prefrontal cortex and amygdala connectivity as part of the rich-club hubs were often reported to be disrupted. The most common findings based on effective connectivity were alterations in salience network, default mode network and executive control network. Although more studies with larger sample sizes are needed to ascertain altered brain connectivity as diagnostic biomarker, there is a perspective that the method could be used as a single marker of diagnosis in the future, and the process of adoption could be accelerated by using approaches such as semiunsupervised machine learning.

Multi-Site Statistical Mapping of Along-Tract Microstructural Abnormalities in Bipolar Disorder with Diffusion MRI Tractometry

Investigating alterations in brain circuitry associated with bipolar disorder (BD) may offer a valuable approach to discover brain biomarkers for genetic and interventional studies of the disorder and related mental illnesses. Some diffusion MRI studies report evidence of microstructural abnormalities in white matter regions of interest, but we lack a fine-scale spatial mapping of brain microstructural differences along tracts in BD. We also lack large-scale studies that integrate tractometry data from multiple sites, as larger datasets can greatly enhance power to detect subtle effects and assess whether effects replicate across larger international datasets. In this multisite diffusion MRI study, we used BUndle ANalytics (BUAN, Chandio 2020), a recently developed analytic approach for tractography, to extract, map, and visualize profiles of microstructural abnormalities on 3D models of fiber tracts in 148 participants with BD and 259 healthy controls from 6 independent scan sites. Modeling site differences as random effects, we investigated along-tract white matter (WM) microstructural differences between diagnostic groups. QQ plots showed that group differences were gradually enhanced as more sites were added. Using the BUAN pipeline, BD was associated with lower mean fractional anisotropy (FA) in fronto-limbic, interhemispheric, and posterior pathways; higher FA was also noted in posterior bundles, relative to controls. By integrating tractography and anatomical information, BUAN effectively captures unique effects along white matter (WM) tracts, providing valuable insights into anatomical variations that may assist in the classification of diseases.

Along-Tract Statistical Mapping of Microstructural Abnormalities in Bipolar Disorder: A Pilot Study

Investigating brain circuitry involved in bipolar disorder (BD) is key to discovering brain biomarkers for genetic and interventional studies of the disorder. Even so, prior research has not provided a fine-scale spatial mapping of brain microstructural differences in BD. In this pilot diffusion MRI dataset, we used BUndle ANalytics (BUAN)-a recently developed analytic approach for tractography-to extract, map, and visualize the profile of microstructural abnormalities on a 3D model of fiber tracts in people with BD (N=38) and healthy controls (N=49), and investigate along-tract white matter (WM) microstructural differences between these groups. Using the BUAN pipeline, BD was associated with lower mean fractional anisotropy (FA) in fronto-limbic and interhemispheric pathways and higher mean FA in posterior bundles relative to controls.Clinical Relevance- BUAN combines tractography and anatomical information to capture distinct along-tract effects on WM microstructure that may aid in classifying diseases based on anatomical differences.

Along-Tract Statistical Mapping of Microstructural Abnormalities in Bipolar Disorder: A Pilot Study

Investigating brain circuitry involved in bipolar disorder (BD) is key to discovering brain biomarkers for genetic and interventional studies of the disorder. Even so, prior research has not provided a fine-scale spatial mapping of brain microstructural differences in BD. In this pilot diffusion MRI dataset, we used BUndle ANalytics (BUAN), a recently developed analytic approach for tractography, to extract, map, and visualize the profile of microstructural abnormalities on a 3D model of fiber tracts in people with BD (N=38) and healthy controls (N=49), and investigate along-tract white matter (WM) microstructural differences between these groups. Using the BUAN pipeline, BD was associated with lower mean Fractional Anisotropy (FA) in fronto-limbic and interhemispheric pathways and higher mean FA in posterior bundles relative to controls. BUAN combines tractography and anatomical information to capture distinct along-tract effects on WM microstructure that may aid in classifying diseases based on anatomical differences.

Shared and Specific Patterns of Structural Brain Connectivity Across Affective and Psychotic Disorders

BACKGROUND

Altered brain structural connectivity has been implicated in the pathophysiology of psychiatric disorders including schizophrenia (SZ), bipolar disorder (BD), and major depressive disorder (MDD). However, it is unknown which part of these connectivity abnormalities are disorder specific and which are shared across the spectrum of psychotic and affective disorders. We investigated common and distinct brain connectivity alterations in a large sample (N = 1743) of patients with SZ, BD, or MDD and healthy control (HC) subjects.

METHODS

This study examined diffusion-weighted imaging-based structural connectome topology in 720 patients with MDD, 112 patients with BD, 69 patients with SZ, and 842 HC subjects (mean age of all subjects: 35.7 years). Graph theory-based network analysis was used to investigate connectome organization. Machine learning algorithms were trained to classify groups based on their structural connectivity matrices.

RESULTS

Groups differed significantly in the network metrics global efficiency, clustering, present edges, and global connectivity strength with a converging pattern of alterations between diagnoses (e.g., efficiency: HC > MDD > BD > SZ, false discovery rate-corrected p = .028). Subnetwork analysis revealed a common core of edges that were affected across all 3 disorders, but also revealed differences between disorders. Machine learning algorithms could not discriminate between disorders but could discriminate each diagnosis from HC. Furthermore, dysconnectivity patterns were found most pronounced in patients with an early disease onset irrespective of diagnosis.

CONCLUSIONS

We found shared and specific signatures of structural white matter dysconnectivity in SZ, BD, and MDD, leading to commonly reduced network efficiency. These results showed a compromised brain communication across a spectrum of major psychiatric disorders.

Associations of leptin and corticostriatal connectivity in bipolar disorder

Bipolar disorder (BD) and metabolic disturbance represent a chronic state of low-grade inflammation and corticostriatal circuitry alterations. Herein, we aimed to investigate whether plasma leptin, an adipokine that plays a key role in the interplay of metabolism and inflammation, is associated with corticostriatal connectivity in patients with BD. Twenty-eight BD I patients, 36 BD II patients and 66 healthy controls were enrolled and completed the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale, the Young Mania Rating Scale, and the Recent Life Change Questionnaire. Fasting plasma leptin and C-reactive protein (CRP) levels were measured, and corticostriatal connectivity was examined using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). The relationships between leptin, CRP and body mass index (BMI) identified in the controls and BD II patients were absent in the BD I patients. We did not find a significant group difference in the leptin level; nevertheless, the negative correlation between leptin level and corticostriatal connectivity (ventrolateral prefrontal cortex and inferior temporal gyrus) observed in the healthy controls was absent in the BD patients. The disproportionate increase in leptin level with increasing BMI in BD indicated a potential inflammatory role of white adipose tissue in BD. Furthermore, higher CRP levels in BD I patients might induce leptin resistance. Collectively, our results implied vulnerability to inflammatory and metabolic diseases in patients with BD, especially BD I.

Topological alteration is associated with non-dependent alcohol use in bipolar disorder

INTRODUCTION

Structural alterations in cortical thickness and the microstructural organisation of white matter are independently associated with non-dependent alcohol consumption and bipolar disorder(BD). Identifying their interactive and network level effects on brain topology may identify the impact of alcohol on reward and emotion circuitry, and its contribution to relapse in BD.

METHODS

Thirty-four BD-I (DSM-IV-TR) and 38 healthy controls underwent T1 and diffusion-weighted MRI scanning, and the AUDIT-C to assess alcohol use. Connectomes comprised of 34 cortical and nine subcortical nodes bilaterally (Freesurfer v5.3) connected by fractional anisotropy-weighted edges derived from non-tensor based deterministic constrained spherical deconvolution tractography (ExploreDTI v4.8.6) underwent permutation-based topological analysis (NBS v1.2) and were examined for effects of alcohol use and diagnosis-by-alcohol use accounting for age, sex and diagnosis.

RESULTS

Alcohol was significantly related to a subnetwork, encompassing connections between fronto-limbic, basal ganglia and temporal nodes (Frange=5-8.4, p=0.031) and was not detected to have an effect on global brain integration or segregation. A portion of this network (18%), involving cortico-limbic and basal ganglia connections, was differentially impacted by alcohol in the BD relative to the control group (Frange=5-8.8, p=0.033), despite the groups' consuming similar amounts of alcohol (BD: mean±SD 4.95±3.0; HC 3.62±3.0, T=1.88, p=0.06).

DISCUSSION

Non-dependent alcohol use impacts brain architectural organization and connectivity within salience, reward, and affective circuitry. The relationship between alcohol use and topology of the network in BD suggests an interactive effect between specific biological vulnerability and alcohol use, which may explain susceptibility to increased risk of relapse in the disorder.

Aberrant Subnetwork and Hub Dysconnectivity in Adult Bipolar Disorder: A Multicenter Graph Theory Analysis

Neuroimaging evidence implicates structural network-level abnormalities in bipolar disorder (BD); however, there remain conflicting results in the current literature hampered by sample size limitations and clinical heterogeneity. Here, we set out to perform a multisite graph theory analysis to assess the extent of neuroanatomical dysconnectivity in a large representative study of individuals with BD. This cross-sectional multicenter international study assessed structural and diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging data obtained from 109 subjects with BD type 1 and 103 psychiatrically healthy volunteers. Whole-brain metrics, permutation-based statistics, and connectivity of highly connected nodes were used to compare network-level connectivity patterns in individuals with BD compared with controls. The BD group displayed longer characteristic path length, a weakly connected left frontotemporal network, and increased rich-club dysconnectivity compared with healthy controls. Our multisite findings implicate emotion and reward networks dysconnectivity in bipolar illness and may guide larger scale global efforts in understanding how human brain architecture impacts mood regulation in BD.

Aberrant brain network topology in the frontoparietal-limbic circuit in bipolar disorder: a graph-theory study

Characterizing the properties of brain networks across mood states seen in bipolar disorder (BP) can provide a deeper insight into the mechanisms involved in this type of affective disorder. In this study, graph theoretical methods were used to examine global, modular and nodal brain network topology in the resting state using functional magnetic resonance imaging data acquired from 95 participants, including those with bipolar depression (BPD; n = 30) and bipolar mania (BPM; n = 39) and healthy control (HC) subjects (n = 26). The threshold value of the individual subjects' connectivity matrix varied from 0.15 to 0.30 with steps of 0.01. We found that: (1) at the global level, BP patients showed a significantly increased global efficiency and synchronization and a decreased path length; (2) at the nodal level, BP patients showed impaired nodal parameters, predominantly within the frontoparietal and limbic sub-network; (3) at the module level, BP patients were characterized by denser FCs (edges) between Module III (the front-parietal system) and Module V (limbic/paralimbic systems); (4) at the nodal level, the BPD and BPM groups showed state-specific differences in the orbital part of the left superior-frontal gyrus, right putamen, right parahippocampal gyrus and left fusiform gyrus. These results revealed abnormalities in topological organization in the whole brain, especially in the frontoparietal-limbic circuit in both BPD and BPM. These deficits may reflect the pathophysiological processes occurring in BP. In addition, state-specific regional nodal alterations in BP could potentially provide biomarkers of conversion across different mood states.

Resting-State Network Patterns Underlying Cognitive Function in Bipolar Disorder: A Graph Theoretical Analysis

Background: Synchronous and antisynchronous activity between neural elements at rest reflects the physiological processes underlying complex cognitive ability. Regional and pairwise connectivity investigations suggest that perturbations in these activity patterns may relate to widespread cognitive impairments seen in bipolar disorder (BD). Here we take a network-based perspective to more meaningfully capture interactions among distributed brain regions compared to focal measurements and examine network-cognition relationships across a range of commonly affected cognitive domains in BD in relation to healthy controls. Methods: Resting-state networks were constructed as matrices of correlation coefficients between regionally averaged resting-state time series from 86 cortical/subcortical brain regions (FreeSurferv5.3.0). Cognitive performance measured using the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale, Cambridge Automated Neuropsychological Test Battery (CANTAB), and Reading the Mind in the Eyes tests was examined in relation to whole-brain connectivity measures and patterns of connectivity using a permutation-based statistical approach. Results: Faster response times in controls (n = 49) related to synchronous activity between frontal, parietal, cingulate, temporal, and occipital regions, while a similar response times in BD (n = 35) related to antisynchronous activity between regions of this subnetwork. Across all subjects, antisynchronous activity between the frontal, parietal, temporal, occipital, cingulate, insula, and amygdala regions related to improved memory performance. No resting-state subnetworks related to intelligence, executive function, short-term memory, or social cognition performance in the overall sample or in a manner that would explain deficits in these facets in BD. Conclusions: Our results demonstrate alterations in the intrinsic connectivity patterns underlying response timing in BD that are not specific to performance or errors on the same tasks. Across all individuals, no strong effects of resting-state global topology on cognition are found, while distinct functional networks supporting episodic and spatial memory highlight intrinsic inhibitory influences present in the resting state that facilitate memory processing. Impact Statement Regional and pairwise-connectivity investigations suggest altered interactions between brain areas may contribute to impairments in cognition that are observed in bipolar disorder. However, the distributed nature of these interactions across the brain remains poorly understood. Using recent advances in network neuroscience, we examine functional connectivity patterns associated with multiple cognitive domains in individuals with and without bipolar disorder. We discover distinct patterns of connectivity underlying response-timing performance uniquely in bipolar disorder and, independent of diagnosis, inhibitory interactions that relate to memory performance.

Frontolimbic, Frontoparietal, and Default Mode Involvement in Functional Dysconnectivity in Psychotic Bipolar Disorder

BACKGROUND

Functional abnormalities, mostly involving functionally specialized subsystems, have been associated with disorders of emotion regulation such as bipolar disorder (BD). Understanding how independent functional subsystems integrate globally and how they relate with anatomical cortical and subcortical networks is key to understanding how the human brain's architecture constrains functional interactions and underpins abnormalities of mood and emotion, particularly in BD.

METHODS

Resting-state functional magnetic resonance time series were averaged to obtain individual functional connectivity matrices (using AFNI software); individual structural connectivity matrices were derived using deterministic non-tensor-based tractography (using ExploreDTI, version 4.8.6), weighted by streamline count and fractional anisotropy. Structural and functional nodes were defined using a subject-specific cortico-subcortical mapping (using Desikan-Killiany Atlas, FreeSurfer, version 5.3). Whole-brain connectivity alongside a permutation-based statistical approach and structure-function coupling were employed to investigate topological variance in individuals with predominantly euthymic BD relative to psychiatrically healthy control subjects.

RESULTS

Patients with BD (n = 41) exhibited decreased (synchronous) connectivity in a subnetwork encompassing frontolimbic and posterior-occipital functional connections (T > 3, p = .048), alongside increased (antisynchronous) connectivity within a frontotemporal subnetwork (T > 3, p = .014); all relative to control subjects (n = 56). Preserved whole-brain functional connectivity and comparable structure-function coupling among whole-brain and edge-class connections were observed in patients with BD relative to control subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

This study presents a functional map of BD dysconnectivity that differentially involves communication within nodes belonging to functionally specialized subsystems-default mode, frontoparietal, and frontolimbic systems; these changes do not extend to be detected globally and may be necessary to maintain a remitted clinical state of BD. Preserved structure-function coupling in BD despite evidence of regional anatomical and functional deficits suggests a dynamic interplay between structural and functional subnetworks.

Neuroanatomical Dysconnectivity Underlying Cognitive Deficits in Bipolar Disorder

BACKGROUND

Graph theory applied to brain networks is an emerging approach to understanding the brain's topological associations with human cognitive ability. Despite well-documented cognitive impairments in bipolar disorder (BD) and recent reports of altered anatomical network organization, the association between connectivity and cognitive impairments in BD remains unclear.

METHODS

We examined the role of anatomical network connectivity derived from T1- and diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging in impaired cognitive performance in individuals with BD (n = 32) compared with healthy control individuals (n = 38). Fractional anisotropy- and number of streamlines-weighted anatomical brain networks were generated by mapping constrained spherical deconvolution-reconstructed white matter among 86 cortical/subcortical bilateral brain regions delineated in the individual's own coordinate space. Intelligence and executive function were investigated as distributed functions using measures of global, rich-club, and interhemispheric connectivity, while memory and social cognition were examined in relation to subnetwork connectivity.

RESULTS

Lower executive functioning related to higher global clustering coefficient in participants with BD, and lower IQ performance may present with a differential relationship between global and interhemispheric efficiency in individuals with BD relative to control individuals. Spatial recognition memory accuracy and response times were similar between diagnostic groups and associated with basal ganglia and thalamus interconnectivity and connectivity within extended anatomical subnetworks in all participants. No anatomical subnetworks related to episodic memory, short-term memory, or social cognition generally or differently in BD.

CONCLUSIONS

Results demonstrate selective influence of subnetwork patterns of connectivity in underlying cognitive performance generally and abnormal global topology underlying discrete cognitive impairments in BD.