Telomerase activity in thyroid malignancy

Cribriform-morular variant of papillary thyroid carcinoma: a distinctive type of thyroid cancer

The aim of this systematic review is to study the features of cribriform-morular variant of papillary thyroid carcinoma (CMV-PTC) by analysing the 129 documented cases in the English literature. The disease occurred almost exclusively in women. The median age of presentation for CMV-PTC was 24 years. Slightly over half of the patients with CMV-PTC had familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP). CMV-PTC presented before the colonic manifestations in approximately half of the patients with FAP. Patients with FAP often have multifocal tumours in the thyroid. Microscopic examination of CMV-PTC revealed predominately cribriform and morular pattern of cancer cells with characteristic nuclear features of papillary thyroid carcinoma. Psammoma body is rare. On immunohistochemical studies, β-catenin is diffusely positive in CMV-PTC. The morular cells in CMV-PTC are strongly positive for CD10, bcl-2 and E-cadherin. Pre-operative diagnosis of CMV-PTC by fine-needle aspiration biopsy could be aided by cribriform architecture, epithelial morules and β-catenin immunostaining. Mutations of APC gene are found in the patients with CMV-PTC associated with FAP. In addition, mutations in CTNNB1, RET/PTC rearrangement and PI3K3CA mutations have been reported. BRAF mutation is negative in all CMV-PTC tested. Compared to conventional papillary thyroid carcinoma, CMV-PTC had a lower frequency of lymph node metastases at presentation (12%) and distant metastases (3%) as well as lower recurrence rates (8.5%) and patients' mortality rates (2%). To conclude, patients with CMV-PTC have distinctive clinical, pathological and molecular profiles when compared to conventional papillary thyroid carcinoma.

Genetic alterations in poorly differentiated and undifferentiated thyroid carcinomas

Thyroid gland presents a wide spectrum of tumours derived from follicular cells that range from well differentiated, papillary and follicular carcinoma (PTC and FTC, respectively), usually carrying a good prognosis, to the clinically aggressive, poorly differentiated (PDTC) and undifferentiated thyroid carcinoma (UTC).It is usually accepted that PDTC and UTC occur either de novo or progress from a pre-existing well differentiated carcinoma through a multistep process of genetic and epigenetic changes that lead to clonal expansion and neoplastic development. Mutations and epigenetic alterations in PDTC and UTC are far from being totally clarified. Assuming that PDTC and UTC may derive from well differentiated thyroid carcinomas (WDTC), it is expected that some PDTC and UTC would harbour genetic alterations that are typical of PTC and FTC. This is the case for some molecular markers (BRAF and NRAS) that are present in WDTC, PDTC and UTC. Other genes, namely P53, are almost exclusively detected in less differentiated and undifferentiated thyroid tumours, supporting a diagnosis of PDTC or, much more often, UTC. Thyroid-specific rearrangements RET/PTC and PAX8/PPARγ, on the other hand, are rarely found in PDTC and UTC, suggesting that these genetic alterations do not predispose cells to dedifferentiation. In the present review we have summarized the molecular changes associated with the two most aggressive types of thyroid cancer.

Telomerase and the endocrine system

Telomeres are nucleoprotein complexes located at the ends of chromosomes that have a critical role in the maintenance of chromosomal integrity. This involvement is based on complex secondary and tertiary structures that rely on DNA-DNA, DNA-protein and protein-protein interactions. De novo synthesis and maintenance of telomere repeats is controlled by telomerase, a specialized complex that consists of a telomerase RNA component and a protein component--telomerase reverse transcriptase. When telomerase is silent (its default state in differentiated somatic cells), chromosomes shorten with every cell division, thus limiting the lifespan of the cells (the process of senescence) and preventing unlimited cell proliferation, which might eventually lead to the development of cancer. During this process, occasionally, a cell can activate telomerase, which stabilizes short telomeres and enables immortalization-a process essential for malignant transformation. Thus, although telomere erosion is a barrier to malignant progression, paradoxically, in certain circumstances it might also trigger tumorigenesis. A number of studies have demonstrated unequivocally that reactivation of telomerase in the presence of short telomeres is one of the most common features of human cancers, including those of the endocrine system.

Molecular markers in thyroid cancer diagnostics

Although fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNA) remains the mainstay of the preoperative workup of thyroid nodules, it does not provide a diagnosis in up to 20% of nodules. This group of indeterminate lesions, including lesions with cellular atypia, suspicious cytology, and demonstrating a follicular pattern, provides one of the greatest challenges to researchers in thyroid cancer today. Over the last 2 decades, considerable work has been done to find molecular markers to resolve this diagnostic dilemma. This article explores some of the markers including galectin-3, HBME-1, BRAF, RET/PTC, PAX8-PPARgamma, hTERT, telomerase, miRNA, and microarray and multigene assays. Although no one marker has proven to be a panacea, several combinations of markers have shown great promise as an adjunct to FNA.

Telomeres and thyroid cancer

Telomeres are specialized structures at the ends of chromosomes, consisting of hundreds of repeated hexanucleotides (TTAGGG)n. Genetic integrity is partly maintained by the architecture of telomeres and it is gradually lost as telomeres progressively shorten with each cell replication, due to incomplete lagging DNA strand synthesis and oxidative damage. Telomerase is a reverse transcriptase enzyme that counteracts telomere shortening by adding telomeric repeats to the G-rich strand. It is composed of a telomerase RNA component and a protein component, telomerase reverse transcriptase. In the absence of telomerase or when the activity of the enzyme is low compared to the replicative erosion, apoptosis is triggered. Patients who have inherited genetic defects in telomere maintenance seem to have an increased risk of developing familial benign diseases or malignant diseases. At the somatic level, telomerase is reactivated in the majority of human carcinomas, suggesting that telomerase reactivation is a critical step for cancerogenesis.In sporadic thyroid carcinoma telomerase activity is detectable in nearly 50% of thyroid cancer tissues and some authors proposed that the detection of telomerase activity may be used for differentiating between benign and malignant thyroid tumours. Recently a germline alteration of telomere-telomerase complex has been identified in patients with familial papillary thyroid cancer, characterized by short telomeres and increased expression and activity of telomerase compared to patients with sporadic papillary thyroid cancer.In this report, we will review the role of telomere-telomerase complex in sporadic and familial thyroid cancer.

Thyroglobulin may affect telomerase activity in thyroid follicular cells

Telomerase (TA) activity is known to be present in malignant tumor cells, but not in most somatic differentiated cells. TA shows relatively high activity in thyroid cancer cells, but reports vary. This fact prompted us to elucidate whether cell component inhibitors of TA in the thyroid follicles can modulate its activity. The activity of TA extracted from Hela cells was inhibited by mixing with the supernatant fraction of human thyroid tissue extract. To examine the effect of iodine, thyroid hormones (l-T3 and l-T4) and human thyroglobulin (hTg) contained in the thyroid follicles, l-T3, l-T4 and hTg were added to the TRAP assay system in vitro, using TA from Hela cells. Iodine, l-T3 and l-T4 did not affect TA activity, but hTg inhibited the TA activity in a dose-dependent manner (IC(50) of hTg: ca 0.45 microM: inhibiting concentration of hTg was from 0.15 microM to 3.0 microM). The hTg inhibition was not evident in the RT-PCR system, suggesting no effect of hTg on Taq DNA polymerase activity. The hTg inhibition of TA activity was attenuated by dNTP but not significantly by TS primer. These data suggest that hTg contained in thyroid follicular cells of various thyroid diseases may affect the TA activity measured in biopsied thyroid specimens, and that the reduction of the TA activity by hTg may induce slow progression and growth, and low grade malignancy of thyroid cancer, particularly differentiated carcinoma.

Low telomerase activity: possible role in the progression of human medullary thyroid carcinoma

Maintenance of telomere length has been reported to be an absolute requirement for unlimited growth of human tumour cells and in about 85% of cases, this is achieved by reactivation of telomerase, the enzyme that elongates telomeres. Only in rare cases, like in human medullary thyroid carcinomas (MTC), telomerase activity (TA) is low or undetectable; however, this does not limit tumours to become clinically significant. Here, we report that very low TA (below 5% of HEK293) observed in MTC cell strains derived from different patients, although not sufficient for immortalising the cells, is necessary for prolonging their replicative life span. Telomere erosion led to induction of a crisis period after long-term in vitro cultivation, which was reached earlier when treating the cells with MST-312, a telomerase inhibitor at non-toxic concentrations. Crisis was bypassed either by ectopic hTERT introduction or by infrequent spontaneous immortalisation, the latter of which was always associated with telomerase reactivation and changes of the cellular phenotype. While confirming the high importance of telomerase for tumour development, these data draw attention to the relevance of low TA: although insufficient for telomere stabilisation, it allows MTC cells to reach more population doublings, increasing both cell numbers as well as the risk of accumulating mutations and thus might support the development of clinically significant MTC.

Novel molecular markers in well-differentiated thyroid cancers

Conventional cytopathology is an excellent tool for distinguishing benign from malignant thyroid nodules with high sensitivity and specificity. However, significant numbers of cases are indeterminate, resulting in many ultimately unnecessary diagnostic thyroidectomies. Numerous molecular markers have been studied in an attempt to improve the diagnostic accuracy of thyroid fine-needle aspiration cytology. Several markers, such as galectin-3 and thyroid peroxidase, have been extensively assessed and shown not only to differentiate malignant tumors from benign thyroid lesions with high sensitivity and specificity, but also to identify tumors associated with poor outcome. More recently, four other genes (PTTG, PBF, BRAF and MUC1) have been identified that show real promise as potential molecular markers in thyroid cancer, offering discrimination between tumor subtypes and providing valuable prognostic information. However, larger, well-controlled studies are needed before their introduction into routine clinical practice. The search for molecular markers represents one of the most exciting areas in translational thyroid cancer research. We are optimistic that molecular markers will be used in the near future as adjuncts to conventional histological techniques to improve diagnostic accuracy of fine-needle aspiration cytology for thyroid lesions, particularly those that are cytologically indeterminate.

Human telomerase reverse transcriptase gene expression and the surgical management of suspicious thyroid tumors

PURPOSE

Patients with a preoperative cytologic diagnosis of a suspicious thyroid nodule present a therapeutic dilemma because surgery differs for benign and malignant lesions. To address this issue, several molecular markers, including human telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT), have been tested as markers of thyroid cancer. Because most studies select cases falling into well-defined categories to test new markers, they may overestimate their discriminatory power when applied to samples that are difficult to classify. Fine-needle aspirates (FNAs) of the thyroid with indeterminate cytology are an example of such cases.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

We examined whether assessing TERT mRNA by reverse transcription-PCR could have improved the surgical management in a cohort of 100 patients undergoing thyroidectomy for indeterminate FNA results.

RESULTS

Ninety percent of 48 cancers were TERT positive, as were 35% of 52 benign lesions. When 10 cases with concomitant lymphocytic thyroiditis were excluded, the overall sensitivity of TERT was 91% (95% confidence interval, 80-98%) and specificity was 79% (64-90%). No clinical or tumor variable contributed to the predictive ability of TERT except for tumor size, which added only marginally. Basing the surgical approach on the TERT assay alone would have reduced lobectomies performed for malignant disease from 11 to 4 cases and reduced total thyroidectomies for benign lesions from to 15 to 9, an overall 50% reduction in suboptimal treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall performance of preoperative differential diagnosis for thyroid tumors with indeterminate FNA results can be substantially improved by the inclusion of molecular markers such as TERT.

Tumor suppressor gene allelic loss profiles of the variants of papillary thyroid carcinoma

Papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTCa) is a relatively common, indolent tumor that usually has an excellent prognosis. While the diagnosis of conventional PTCa is relatively straightforward, encapsulated tumors with follicular growth pattern and unusual or incomplete cytologic features of papillary carcinoma can be diagnostically challenging. Encapsulated, noninvasive tumors are particularly controversial as the differential diagnosis includes a nonneoplastic nodule, a benign follicular adenoma, and papillary carcinoma. In this study, we performed molecular genotyping to identify loss of heterozygosity of tumor suppressor genes in conventional PTCa and in several different morphologic variants, including follicular variant, tall cell variant, and oncocytic variant. Our data demonstrate that conventional PTCas have the lowest frequency of allelic loss (7%), as compared with follicular, oncocytic, and tall cell variants (19%, 34%, and 20%, respectively). Frequency of allelic loss increased with increasing size of the tumors, but did not correlate with age, gender, extrathyroidal extension, or lymph node metastases. Though it is unlikely that these results will enable the distinction between different variants of papillary carcinoma, the finding of significant rates ofallelic loss in the variants of PTCa provides additional evidence of malignancy and may be useful in distinguishing encapsulated tumors from nonneoplastic or benign nodules.

Topoisomerase II alpha and telomerase expression in papillary thyroid carcinomas

BACKGROUND

Altered topoisomerase II alpha (Topo II alpha) expression and telomerase activity (TA) reflect tumour cell growth and malignant transformation.

METHODS

We examined TA by using a TRAP assay and expression of Topo II alpha by immunohistochemical analysis in a series of 27 cases of papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC).

RESULTS

Topo II alpha labelling index (LI) ranged from 0.1 to 4.2% and was significantly associated with patient age (r=-0.42, p=0.003), with higher levels of Topo II alpha in patients under 40 years. There was no relationship between Topo II alpha LI, AGES score or other clinical outcome. TA was detected in 14 PTC, with relative levels ranging from 1.2 to 102 units. A significant positive correlation between the multiplicity of tumoral foci and the TA levels (p<10(-2)) was noted.

CONCLUSION

We concluded that Topo II alpha cannot be used as a marker of tumour aggressiveness. Furthermore, enhanced Topo II alpha expression in PTCs from patients less than 40 years old suggests that this age group might benefit from Topo II inhibitor chemotherapy.

Telomerase activity in surgical specimens and fine-needle aspiration biopsies from hyperplastic and neoplastic human thyroid tissues

BACKGROUND

Telomerase activity (TA) indicates malignancy, but activated lymphocytes also express TA. Correlation between TA in thyroid tissues and fine-needle aspiration (FNA) samples and knowledge about TA in adjacent tissue are of importance.

METHODS

The telomeric repeat amplification protocol assay followed by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay detection was performed on 78 thyroid cases including 53 suspected malignancies, preoperative and perioperative FNA specimens, and adjacent tissue.

RESULTS

Benign lesions in cancer-suspected cases were TA negative. Eight of 13 papillary (62%) and 4 of 5 follicular (80%) tumors were TA positive (TA+). Lower TA was observed in conventional papillary cancer than in follicular, tall cell variant of papillary and anaplastic cancers. Adjacent tissues with lymphocyte infiltration were TA+ in 9 of 17 cases (53%). Nine of 65 adjacent tissues (14%) were TA+. Three of 6 preoperative and 9 of 11 perioperative FNA samples from malignant tumors corresponded to the tissue TA. CONCLUSIONS; High TA may reflect more severe thyroid cancer. Telomerase activity in FNA biopsies does not add reliable diagnostic information, and presence of lymphocytes can give false-positive results.

Human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) gene expression in FNA samples from thyroid neoplasms

Identifying a tumor marker that can help distinguish benign from malignant thyroid tumors is crucial, because up to 30% of thyroid fine-needle aspirations (FNA) are diagnosed as 'suspicious' or follicular neoplasm for malignancy. Recently, the detection of human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) gene expression in thyroid FNA samples has been identified as a promising diagnostic marker in distinguishing benign and malignant thyroid tumors. Twenty-seven FNA samples from thyroid tumors that were suspected to be malignant were collected preoperatively, hTERT gene expression was examined by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), and the cytological and histological results were compared. The results demonstrated that 13 (92.8%) of 14 thyroid carcinomas, including eight of eight papillary, three of four follicular, and two of two Hürthle cell thyroid carcinomas have corresponding FNA samples that were positive for hTERT. Meanwhile, eight (61.5%) of 13 benign thyroid nodules, including three of six nodular goiter, two of two Graves' disease, two of two Hürthle cell adenomas, and one of three follicular adenomas were positive for hTERT. In conclusion, hTERT was more prevalent in malignant thyroid FNA samples than in the benign thyroid FNA samples. Notably, the extent of the differences in hTERT expression between benign and malignant follicular thyroid tumors require further investigation. Moreover, further information including semi-quantitative real-time RT-PCR, is required to verify whether hTERT mRNA expression could serve as an adjunctive molecular marker for the preoperative diagnosis of thyroid malignancies.

Establishment and characterization of OCUT-1, an undifferentiated thyroid cancer cell line expressing high level of telomerase

BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVES

Undifferentiated thyroid cancer is one of the most aggressive human malignancies, and the prognoses that have been reported are extremely poor. A number of studies have described the clinicopathologic features of this tumor and analyzed its biologic background to explain the extraordinarily aggressive nature of the tumor. Still the mechanism of cellular aggressiveness in undifferentiated thyroid cancer is not yet fully understood.

METHODS

We established and characterized an undifferentiated thyroid cancer cell line, OCUT-1, derived from the surgical specimen obtained from a 74-year-old Japanese woman with advanced undifferentiated thyroid cancer.

RESULTS

The cell line had already maintained over 100 passages and was stably cultured for more than a year. The cell line was observed to maintain not only its morphologic similarity to the primary cancer cells, but also its aggressive nature, including high proliferative activity, numerous genetic abnormalities, and cytokine production. Further, we have demonstrated the expression of telomerase activity in the cell, which could represent one of the responsible mechanisms for the cellular aggressiveness of this type of tumor.

CONCLUSIONS

This cell line might be useful for further study concerning the correlation between telomerase activation and disease progression or anaplastic change in thyroid cancer.

Excessive survivin expression in thyroid lymphomas

Thyroid lymphoma occurs most commonly in the thyroid glands with a background of Hashimoto's thyroiditis. Therefore, it is occasionally difficult to distinguish lymphoma from Hashimoto's thyroiditis because of some cellular and histologic similarities. We have examined whether survivin or human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) expression can differentiate between the 2 disorders. Surgically removed tissue samples from 6 patients with thyroid lymphoma and 6 patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis were analyzed for mRNA levels of survivin and hTERT by real-time quantitative reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction. Expression of survivin protein was examined by immunohistochemical stain using a polyclonal antibody. Survivin mRNA levels were greater in thyroid lymphoma than in Hashimoto's thyroiditis: 49.1 +/-36.4 versus 6.6 +/-2.7 pg/ng rRNA (mean +/- SD) (P <0.005). Immunohistochemical stain confirmed an abundance of survivin protein in lymphoid cells of thyroid lymphoma. The amount of hTERT mRNA did not differ in the 2 disorders. Our study shows that measuring survivin mRNA levels or immunohistochemistry of the protein expression can be useful to aid the diagnosis of thyroid lymphoma when histologic diagnosis is difficult.

Thyroid carcinomas that express telomerase follow a more aggressive clinical course in children and adolescents

With each cell division, DNA is lost from the telomeres, limiting the number of divisions, and leading to senescence. Malignant tumors maintain immortality by expressing a specific DNA repair enzyme, telomerase, that replaces this DNA. We hypothesized that tumors which express telomerase would have the highest recurrence risk and we tested this by determining telomerase expression in 27 papillary thyroid carcinomas (PTC), 5 follicular thyroid carcinomas (FTC) and 13 benign thyroid lesions from children and adolescents. Patients were 6-21 yr of age (mean+/-SE=16.6+/-4.1 yr) and followed from 0-14.1 yr (mean+/-SE=4.71+/-3.5 yr). Original tumors were sectioned, and immunostained for telomerase. Telomerase-specific staining was determined by two independent, blind examiners and graded from absent (Grade 0) to intense (Grade 3). Telomerase was detected in a similar majority of benign (11/13, 85%) and malignant tumors (24/32, 75%). However, the intensity of telomerase expression was greater among FTC (mean+/-SE=2.4+/-0.5 relative intensity) followed by PTC (mean+/-SE=1.9+/-1.0 relative intensity) and benign tumors (mean+/-SE=1.8+/-1.0 relative intensity). Autoimmune lesions had lower telomerase expression (mean+/-SE=1.25+/-0.5 relative intensity) compared to FTC (p=0.01), PTC (p=0.06) and benign lesions (p=0.15). Among PTC, 19 (70%) expressed telomerase, and 8 (30%) did not. Direct invasion (no.=4, 21%), distant metastasis (no.=2, 10%) and recurrence (no.=7, 37%) developed exclusively in PTC that expressed telomerase (p=0.02). Disease-free survival was also shorter for PTC that expressed telomerase (p=0.06). Recurrence developed in 1/2 (50%) FTC that expressed telomerase. We conclude that childhood thyroid cancers which express telomerase have an increased risk of tissue invasion, metastasis, and recurrence.

Alternative lengthening of telomeres in mammalian cells

Some immortalized mammalian cell lines and tumors maintain or increase the overall length of their telomeres in the absence of telomerase activity by one or more mechanisms referred to as alternative lengthening of telomeres (ALT). Characteristics of human ALT cells include great heterogeneity of telomere size (ranging from undetectable to abnormally long) within individual cells, and ALT-associated PML bodies (APBs) that contain extrachromosomal telomeric DNA, telomere-specific binding proteins, and proteins involved in DNA recombination and replication. Activation of ALT during immortalization involves recessive mutations in genes that are as yet unidentified. Repressors of ALT activity are present in normal cells and some telomerase-positive cells. Telomere length dynamics in ALT cells suggest a recombinational mechanism. Inter-telomeric copying occurs, consistent with a mechanism in which single-stranded DNA at one telomere terminus invades another telomere and uses it as a copy template resulting in net increase in telomeric sequence. It is possible that t-loops, linear and/or circular extrachromosomal telomeric DNA, and the proteins found in APBs, may be involved in the mechanism. ALT and telomerase activity can co-exist within cultured cells, and within tumors. The existence of ALT adds some complexity to proposed uses of telomere-related parameters in cancer diagnosis and prognosis, and poses challenges for the design of anticancer therapeutics designed to inhibit telomere maintenance.

Telomerase activity in small cell esophageal carcinoma

Small cell carcinoma of the esophagus is a rare and aggressive malignant tumor. Telomerase activation is common in human cancers. There is a lack of data on telomerase activity in esophageal small cell cancers. The present report studied the role of telomerase activity in esophageal small cell carcinoma. The clinicopathologic data of five patients with small cell carcinoma of the esophagus who underwent primary surgical treatment between 1991 and 2000 were studied. Telomeric repeat amplification protocol assays were used to investigate telomerase activity in these tumors. The proliferative activity (MIB-1) and p53 expression of these tumors were also studied using immunohistochemistry and correlated with the telomerase activity. All five small cell carcinomas showed detectable telomerase activity in the primary tumor. Two out of the five morphologically normal esophageal mucosae adjacent to the primary tumor had detectable telomerase activity. There was no correlation between the p53 expression, tumor stage, survival of patients, and the presence of telomerase activity. High MIB-1 expression in esophageal small cell carcinomas was associated with high telomerase activity. Telomerase activation is common in small cell carcinoma of the esophagus. This fact may find application in anti-telomerase treatment for this aggressive tumor.

Telomerase in endocrine and endocrine-dependent tumors

Telomerase, the ribonucleoprotein enzyme that elongates chromosomal ends, or telomeres, is repressed in most normal somatic cells but reactivated in transformed cells to compensate for the progressive erosion of the telomeres during cell divisions. In accordance with this hypothesis, the presence of telomerase activity has been reported in more than 90% of human cancers, whereas most normal tissues or benign tumors contain low or undetectable telomerase activity. Reactivation of telomerase has also been widely reported in endocrine neoplasms and in hormone-related cancers. In the present study, we review the most recent publications on telomerase in these types of tumors. The hormonal regulation of telomerase activity and the possible strategies for cancer therapy based on the inhibition of telomerase has also been discussed.

In situ detection of hTERT mRNA relates to Ki-67 labeling index in papillary thyroid carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Telomerase is activated in most human cancers but is inactivate in adult somatic tissues except for some proliferating cell lineages. The maintenance of telomerase activity may be a critical step of cellular immortalization and transformation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We analyzed the expression of human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) using in situ hybridization and compared it to Ki-67 immunoreactivity in 29 cases of papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) and 17 cases of benign thyroid disease.

RESULTS

The hTERT messenger RNA (mRNA) was expressed in the cytoplasm of carcinoma cells with moderate (n = 10) to strong intensity (n = 10) in 69% (20 of 29) PTC cases. Human TERT was found in only 29% (5 of 17) cases of benign thyroid disease. Human TERT gene expression was preferentially detected in PTC (P = 0.021). The Ki-67 labeling index was observed in 16 cases of PTC (16 of 29; 55.2%). This result was significantly different from that of benign thyroid disease (P = 0.014). The Ki-67 labeling index related to the intensity of hTERT mRNA expression (r = 0.51; P = 0.005) and was inversely associated with the follicular variant of PTC (r = -0.413; P = 0.026). No statistically significant difference was found between hTERT expression and histological subtype of PTC.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results demonstrated that expression of hTERT could be detected using in situ hybridization in PTCs and was significantly distinguishable from that of benign thyroid disease. Human TERT expression was related to the Ki-67 labeling index, indicating that coupling of telomerase activation with cell proliferation was the associated mechanism for tumorigenesis.

Telomerase activity and telomere length in thyroid neoplasia: biological and clinical implications

Despite several recent studies, the biological status and clinical relevance of telomerase expression in tumours derived from the thyroid follicular cell remain controversial. This study has analysed a series of normal, benign, and malignant thyroid samples using two novel approaches: the use of purified epithelial cell fractions to eliminate false-positives due to telomerase-positive infiltrating lymphocytes; and the simultaneous measurement of telomere length to provide a clearer interpretation of telomere dynamics in thyroid neoplasia. The data obtained support the prediction that the epithelial component of non-neoplastic thyroid and of follicular adenomas is telomerase-negative, any positive results being explicable by lymphocyte infiltration. In contrast, many malignant tumours, both follicular and papillary, were telomerase-positive. However, serial dilution of extracts indicated a wide spectrum of activity in these cancers, possibly related to variation in the proportion of telomerase-positive cells. Furthermore, an unexpectedly high proportion were telomerase-negative, a finding which was not explicable by technical problems such as TRAP (telomeric repeat amplification protocol) assay sensitivity. Many of these apparently telomerase-negative tumours had abnormally long telomeres. Correlation of telomerase and telomere length data suggests that thyroid cancers fall into three biological groups: telomerase-positive lesions, consistent with the conventional model of telomere erosion followed by telomerase reactivation; telomerase-negative tumours, which maintain telomere length by a mechanism independent of telomerase; and telomerase-negative tumours which are still undergoing telomere erosion and may therefore be composed of mortal cancer cells. From a clinical standpoint, it is concluded that telomerase detection on unfractionated tissue, such as fine needle aspirates, is of no value as a marker of malignancy in follicular lesions, due to both low sensitivity and specificity.