Anticancer vaccination strategies

Extracellular Vesicles and Their Current Role in Cancer Immunotherapy

Simple Summary

In recent years, immunotherapy has shown great advancement, becoming a powerful tool to combat cancer. In this context, the use of biologically derived vesicles has also acquired importance for cancer immunotherapy. Extracellular vesicles are thus proposed to transport molecules able to trigger an immune response and thus fight cancer cells. As a particular immunotherapeutic approach, a new technique also consists in the exploitation of extracellular vesicles as new cancer vaccines. The present review provides basic notions on cancer immunotherapy and describes several clinical trials in which therapeutic anticancer vaccines are tested. In particular, the potential of extracellular vesicles-based therapeutic vaccines in the treatment of cancer patients is highlighted, even with advanced stage-cancer. A focus on the clinical studies, already completed or still in progress, is offered and a systematic collection and reorganization of the present literature on this topic is proposed to the reader.

Abstract

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are natural particles formed by the lipid bilayer and released from almost all cell types to the extracellular environment both under physiological conditions and in presence of a disease. EVs are involved in many biological processes including intercellular communication, acting as natural carriers in the transfer of various biomolecules such as DNA, various RNA types, proteins and different phospholipids. Thanks to their transfer and targeting abilities, they can be employed in drug and gene delivery and have been proposed for the treatment of different diseases, including cancer. Recently, the use of EVs as biological carriers has also been extended to cancer immunotherapy. This new technique of cancer treatment involves the use of EVs to transport molecules capable of triggering an immune response to damage cancer cells. Several studies have analyzed the possibility of using EVs in new cancer vaccines, which represent a particular form of immunotherapy. In the literature there are only few publications that systematically group and collectively discuss these studies. Therefore, the purpose of this review is to illustrate and give a partial reorganization to what has been produced in the literature so far. We provide basic notions on cancer immunotherapy and describe some clinical trials in which therapeutic cancer vaccines are tested. We thus focus attention on the potential of EV-based therapeutic vaccines in the treatment of cancer patients, overviewing the clinically relevant trials, completed or still in progress, which open up new perspectives in the fight against cancer.

Vaccine immunotherapy in breast cancer treatment: promising, but still early

Cancer vaccine-based immunotherapy should potentiate immunosurveillance function, preventing and protecting against growing tumors. Tumor cells usually activate the immune system, including T lymphocytes and natural killer cells, which are able to eliminate the transformed cells. Immunosubversion mechanisms related to tumor cells antigenic immunoediting induces mechanisms of tolerance and immunoescape. This condition impairs not only host-generated immunosurveillance, but also attempts to harness the immune response for therapeutic purposes. Most trials evaluating breast cancer vaccines have been carried out in patients in the metastatic and adjuvant setting. The aim of this review is to analyze the activity of vaccination strategies in current clinical trials. We summarize the differential approaches, protein-based and cell-based vaccines, focusing on vaccines targeting HER2/neu protein. Another focus of the review is to provide the reader with future challenges in the field, taking into account both the immunological and clinical aspects to better target the goal.

WT1 (Wilms' Tumor 1) Peptide Immunotherapy for Renal Cell Carcinoma

Tumor-specific immunotherapy with a Wilms' tumor 1 (WT1) peptide has been on clinical trial for leukemia, myelodysplastic syndrome, breast and lung cancers and is producing promising results. In this study, we treated three patients with renal cell carcinoma with an anchor modified, HLA-A*2402 binding WT1 peptide which was emulsified in Freund's incomplete adjuvant. In two patients tumor growth was suppressed and clinical response was evaluated as stable disease by the RECIST criteria after 3 months of weekly immunizations. Notably, development of new metastases has stopped in these patients for a prolonged period. No deleterious side effects were observed. Peptide-specific T cells were expanded in PBMCs of the patients and a substantial fraction of them bore the surface phenotype consistent with a CD8+ cytotoxic effector population. Although established tumors did not regress further, considering the component of the vaccine, i.e. peptide alone, the stabilization effect suggested the potential of WT1 peptide to develop into a more effective vaccine. To our knowledge, this is the first report of WT1 immunotherapy for renal cell carcinoma. Hopefully, the results will stimulate more extensive clinical studies.

Targeted agents in non-small cell lung cancer therapy: What is there on the horizon?

Lung cancer is a heterogeneous group of diseases. There has been much research in lung cancer over the past decade which has advanced our ability to treat these patients with a more personalized approach. The scope of this paper is to review the literature and give a broad understanding of the current molecular targets for which we currently have therapies as well as other targets for which we may soon have therapies. Additionally, we will cover some of the issues of resistance with these targeted therapies. The molecular targets we intend to discuss are epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), anaplastic large-cell lymphoma kinase (ALK), KRAS, C-MET/RON, PIK3CA. ROS-1, RET Fibroblast growth factor receptor (FGFR). Ephrins and their receptors, BRAF, and immunotherapies/vaccines. This manuscript only summarizes the work which has been done to date and in no way is meant to be comprehensive.

Phage display--a powerful technique for immunotherapy: 2. Vaccine delivery

Phage display is a powerful technique in medical and health biotechnology. This technology has led to formation of antibody libraries and has provided techniques for fast and efficient search of these libraries. The phage display technique has been used in studying the protein-protein or protein-ligand interactions, constructing of the antibody and antibody fragments and improving the affinity of proteins to receptors. Recently phage display has been widely used to study immunization process, develop novel vaccines and investigate allergen-antibody interactions. This technology can provide new tools for protection against viral, fungal and bacterial infections. It may become a valuable tool in cancer therapies, abuse and allergies treatment. This review presents the recent advancements in diagnostic and therapeutic applications of phage display. In particular the applicability of this technology to study the immunization process, construction of new vaccines and development of safer and more efficient delivery strategies has been described.

Protective antitumor immunity induced by tumor cell lysates conjugated with diphtheria toxin and adjuvant epitope in mouse breast tumor models

Cancer cell vaccine-based immunotherapy has received increasing interest in many clinical trials involving patients with breast cancer. Combining with appropriate adjuvants can enhance the weak immunogenic properties of tumor cell lysates (TCL). In this study, diphtheria toxin (DT) and two tandem repeats of mycobacterial heat shock protein 70 (mHSP70) fragment 407-426 (M₂) were conjugated to TCL with glutaraldehyde, and the constructed cancer cell vaccine was named DT-TCL-M₂. Subcutaneous injection of DT-TCL-M₂ in mice effectively elicited tumor-specific polyclonal immune responses, including humoral and cellular immune responses. High levels of antibodies against TCL were detected in the serum of immunized mice with ELISA and verified with Western blot analyses. The splenocytes from immunized mice showed potent cytotoxicity on Ehrlich ascites carcinoma cells. Moreover, the protective antitumor immunity induced by DT-TCL-M₂ inhibited tumor growth in a mouse breast tumor model. DT-TCL-M₂ also attenuated tumor-induced angiogenesis and slowed tumor growth in a mouse intradermal tumor model. These findings demonstrate that TCL conjugated with appropriate adjuvants induced effective antitumor immunity in vivo. Improvements in potency could further make cancer cell vaccines a useful and safe method for preventing cancer recurrence after resection.

Lung cancer vaccines

To date, in lung cancer, early attempts to modulate the immune system via vaccine-based therapeutics have been unsuccessful. An improved understanding of tumor immunology has facilitated the production of more sophisticated lung cancer vaccines. It is anticipated that it will likely require multiple epitopes of a diverse set of genes restricted to multiple haplotypes to generate a truly effective vaccine that is able to overcome the various immunologic escape mechanisms that tumors employ. Other issues to overcome include optimal patient selection, which adjuvant agent to use, and how to adequately monitor for an immunologic response. This review discusses the most promising vaccination strategies for non-small cell lung cancer including the allogeneic tumor cell vaccine belagenpumatucel-L, which is a mixture of 4 allogeneic non-small cell lung cancer cell lines genetically modified to secrete an antisense oligonucleotide to transforming growth factor β2 and 3 other target protein-specific vaccines designed to induce responses against melanoma-associated antigen A3, mucin 1, and epidermal growth factor.

The immune response to tumors as a tool toward immunotherapy

Until recently cancer medical therapy was limited to chemotherapy that could not differentiate cancer cells from normal cells. More recently with the remarkable mushroom of immunology, newer tools became available, resulting in the novel possibility to attack cancer with the specificity of the immune system. Herein we will review some of the recent achievement of immunotherapy in such aggressive cancers as melanoma, prostatic cancer, colorectal carcinoma, and hematologic malignancies. Immunotherapy of tumors has developed several techniques: immune cell transfer, vaccines, immunobiological molecules such as monoclonal antibodies that improve the immune responses to tumors. This can be achieved by blocking pathways limiting the immune response, such as CTLA-4 or Tregs. Immunotherapy may also use cytokines especially proinflammatory cytokines to enhance the activity of cytotoxic T cells (CTLs) derived from tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs). The role of newly discovered cytokines remains to be investigated. Alternatively, an other mechanism consists in enhancing the expression of TAAs on tumor cells. Finally, monoclonal antibodies may be used to target oncogenes.

Immunizing against breast cancer: a new swing for an old sword

Therapeutic potential of vaccination has been explored in many clinical trials involving patients with breast cancer. A large variety of cancer immunogens have been tested. The majority of clinical vaccination studies have been carried out in patients with metastatic breast cancer, characterized by extremely aggressive malignant tumors, resistant to all standard cytotoxic treatments and with longest-lasting disease. With active specific immunotherapy, tumor-associated antigens coupled to appropriate adjuvant can elicit a powerful antitumor responses. The potential advantages of therapeutic cancer vaccines are that they can augment an established immunogenic response to the tumor (which is generally weak in breast cancer), they target specific tumor antigens (although there are few), they are potentially non-toxic, they can be combined with conventional therapies and/or other immunotherapies, and they elicit immunologic memory to prevent recurrence of the tumor. It is unclear whether therapeutic vaccines for cancer prolong survival. Data of clinical activity have been observed by using vaccines targeting HER-2/neu protein, human telomerase reverse transcriptase, carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), and carbohydrate antigen given after stem cell rescue. A better understanding of the relation between innate and adaptive immune responses, and of the immune escape mechanisms employed by tumor cells, the discovery of mechanisms underlying immunological tolerance, and acknowledgment of the importance of both cell-mediated and humoral adaptive immunity for the control of tumour growth are necessary for leading to a more comprehensive immunotherapeutic approach in breast cancer.

Cytomegalovirus vaccination of leukemia and lymphoma patients after allogeneic stem cell transplantation--validation of a peptide vaccine

Peptide vaccination constitutes a novel immunotherapeutical approach for the treatment of patients with solid tumors, lymphoma and leukemia. Moreover it might be of use in hematooncological patients for the prevention and therapy of infections like cytomegalovirus (CMV) reactivation due to immunosuppression. To meet good manufacturing practice (GMP) criteria, we introduce here a bio-assay to validate peptide vaccines for peptide content and bio-activity. As a paradigm for peptide vaccine preparation the immunogenic CMV peptide 495-503 NLVPMVATV lyophilisate was resolubilized in dimethyl sulfoxide, phosphate buffered saline and admixed with Montanide. Addition of different amounts of peptide (10-80 microg) to a mixed lymphocyte peptide culture (MLPC) resulted in the generation of interferon (IFN) gamma and granzyme B releasing CD8(+) CMV tetramer(+) T cells in a dose dependent manner. The combination of FACS and ELISPOT results allowed the definition of the peptide amount in a vaccine preparation. Storage at +/-4 degrees C over 24 h did not result in a significant change of the immunogenicity of the vaccine. In contrast, cryopreservation of the vaccine at -20 degrees C resulted in a loss of immunogenicity. Quantitation of tumor/viral antigen peptides admixed with adjuvants, such as incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA), is feasible through bio-assays as the modified ELISPOT/FACS assay described here, meeting GMP criteria for multi-center trials.

Clonal T-cell response against autologous pleomorphic malignant fibrous histiocytoma antigen presented by retrieved HLA-A*0206

Towards the goal of identifying tumor-rejection antigens on eradicated tumors in bone and soft tissue sarcomas, we evaluated the immune response against antigens presented by lost HLA class I molecules. Tumor specimens and peripheral blood samples were obtained from a 70-year-old woman with pleomorphic malignant fibrous histiocytoma. Over 1-year culture, a tumor cell line (MFH2004) was established. A B-cell line infected with Epstein-Barr virus (B2004-EBV) was developed from the blood samples. HLA genotypes of B2004-EBVcells were A*0206/2402, B*4006/4601, and C*0102/0801, whereas MFH2004 cells were defective for A*0206, B*4006, and C*0102. Loss of HLA-A2 expression was also proved immunohistochemically in the primary tumor tissues. Lost HLA-A2 in MFH2004 cells was retrieved by transfection of HLA-A*0206 cDNA to develop MFH2004-A2. Attempts to induce CTLs by mixed culture with autologous T cells and MFH2004 cells resulted in failure. In contrast, those with MFH2004-A2 induced CTL clones CTL2004-c6 and CTL2004-c17. These CTL clones specifically killed MFH2004-A2 but not MFH2004 or B2004-EBV in an HLA-A2-restricted manner. These findings suggest that CTL2004-c6 and CTL2004-c17 recognize autologous tumor-rejection antigens presented by HLA-A*0206, which may have been expressed by tumor cells that had been eradicated by the host's immunosurveillance system.

Potent CTL induction by a whole cell pertussis vaccine in anti-tumor peptide immunotherapy

Promising yet limited clinical responses have been reported for peptide based immunotherapy against tumors. In order to induce more potent cytolytic CD8 T cell responses, we investigated the use of Bordetella pertussis vaccine as an adjuvant for peptide immunization. A whole cell (Wc) vaccine has been known to induce a Th1 biased immune response while an acellular (Ac) vaccine tends to induce that of the Th2 type. Natural infection by B. pertussis helps to maintain a robust Th1 memory in the host population. To examine the adjuvant activity of the pertussis vaccine, we immunized mice with an ovalbumin peptide as a model tumor antigen, and monitored the development of anti-tumor activities. The addition of either the Ac or the Wc vaccine helped expand the specific CD8 T cells. However, there was a marked difference in the induced cytolytic activity where the Wc vaccine was superior to the Ac. The Wc vaccine was also more effective in inducing in vivo tumor rejection. The adjuvant activity was not only effective against ovalbumin, but was also evident when an endogenous tumor antigen, Wilms' tumor 1 gene product, was targeted. These results indicate that, although the Wc vaccine does not share the same antigen specificity with tumor cells, it can aid in the development of highly cytolytic CD8 T cells as an adjuvant at the site of peptide immunization.

Immunology and breast cancer: therapeutic cancer vaccines

Cancer immunosurveillance is a process that results from activity of recognition and destruction of cancer cells by innate and adaptive immune effector cells and molecules. Cancer cells can avoid immunosurveillance through the immunoselection, that is the development of poorly immunogenic tumor-cell variants, and through subversion of the immune system (also known as immunosubversion). Identification of tumor antigens (Ags) that can be recognized by immune effector cells has opened the perspective of developing therapeutic vaccines in the field of breast cancer. Breast cancer vaccines can induce immunogenic response against tumors weakly immunogenic; usually have a good tolerance and safety profile and can induce a long-term immune memory, critical to prevent efficiently tumor recurrence. Several studies evaluating breast cancer vaccines have been performed in patients with extended metastatic breast cancer, usually refractory to other standard treatments so that clinical efficacy was difficult to achieve. Significant immune responses against tumor Ags induced upon vaccinations were described to several tumor Ag vaccines. A better understanding of the relation between innate and adaptive immune responses, of the immune escape mechanisms employed by tumor cells and acknowledgment of the importance of both cell-mediated and humoral adaptive immunity for the control of tumor growth are necessary for leading to a more comprehensive immunotherapeutic approach in breast cancer.

Biomarkers for the development of cancer vaccines: current status

Significant improvements in our knowledge of tumor immunology have resulted in more sophisticated vaccine approaches for the treatment of cancer. However, research into biomarkers that correlate with the clinical outcome of immunotherapy has lagged behind vaccine development. To this extent, very few immunological or other markers exist that can be used in clinical trials for immunotherapy. In this review, we discuss the current status of biomarker development specifically for the monitoring and development of cancer vaccines. This includes immunological biomarkers (measurement of T-cell and cytokine responses), autoimmunity as a correlate for treatment outcome, and the possible development of multiple biomarkers using high-throughput proteomics technologies. The generation of such biomarkers will allow us to make clinical decisions about patient treatment at an earlier stage and should aid in shortening the development time for vaccines.

Predicting tumor outcome following cancer vaccination by monitoring quantitative and qualitative CD8+ T cell parameters

Identification of reliable surrogate predictors for evaluation of cancer vaccine efficacy is a critical issue in immunotherapy. We analyzed quantitative and qualitative CD8+ T cell parameters in a large pool of BALB/c mice that were DNA-vaccinated against P1A self tumor-specific Ag. After immunization, mice were splenectomized and kept alive for a subsequent tumor challenge to correlate results of immune monitoring assays with tumor regression or progression in each individual animal, and to assess the prognostic value of the assays. The parameters tested were 1) percentage of in vivo vaccine-induced tumor-specific CD8+ T cells; 2) results of ELISPOT tests from fresh splenocytes; 3) percentage of tumor-specific CD8+ T cells in culture after in vitro restimulation; 4) in vitro increase of tumor-specific CD8+ T cell population expressed as fold of expansion; and 5) antitumor lytic activity of restimulated cultures. Except for the ELISPOT assay, each parameter tested was shown by univariate statistical analysis to correlate with tumor regression. However, multivariate analysis revealed that only in vitro percentage of Ag-specific CD8+ T cells was an independent prognostic factor that predicted tumor outcome. These findings should be considered in the design of new immune monitoring systems used in cancer immunotherapy studies.

Breast cancer vaccines: a clinical reality or fairy tale?

The characterization of tumor antigens recognized by immune effector cells has opened the perspective of developing therapeutic vaccines in the field of breast cancer. The potential advantages of the vaccines are: (i) the induction of a robust immune response against tumors that are spontaneously weekly immunogenic; (ii) the tumor specificity for some antigens; (iii) the good tolerance and safety profile and (iv) the long-term immune memory, critical to prevent efficiently tumor recurrence. Most trials evaluating breast cancer vaccines have been carried out in patients with extended metastatic breast cancer, characterized by aggressive tumors, resistant to standard cytotoxic treatments, so that clinical efficacy was difficult to achieve. However, some significant immune responses against tumor antigens induced upon vaccinations were recorded. The aim of this review is to analyze the activity of vaccination strategies in current clinical trials. Data of clinical activity have been observed by using vaccines targeting HER2/neu protein, human telomerase reverse transcriptase, carcinoembryonic antigen and carbohydrate antigen given after stem cell rescue. The review discusses possible future directions for vaccine development and applications in the adjuvant setting.

A quest for therapeutic antigens in bone and soft tissue sarcoma

Over the past three decades, there have been remarkable advances in the treatment of bone and soft tissue sarcomas. These include the introduction of adjuvant chemotherapy, establishment of guidelines for adequate surgical margins, and the development of post-excision reconstruction. There have also been advances in the field of immunotherapy against bone and soft tissue sarcomas, which, unfortunately, have received less attention. However, lack of progress in chemotherapy-based treatments for bone and soft tissue sarcomas has reignited interest in immunotherapeutic approaches. Here we summarize current progress in the immunotherapy of bone and soft tissue sarcomas including the strategies utilized to identify tumor-associated antigens, and the design of clinical trials.