Critical assessment of pan-genomic analysis of metagenome-assembled genomes

Screening of promising molecules against potential drug targets in Yersinia pestis by integrative pan and subtractive genomics, docking and simulation approach

This study focuses on Yersinia pestis, the bacterium responsible for plague, which posed a severe threat to public health in history. Despite the availability of antibiotics treatment, the emergence of antibiotic resistance in this pathogen has increased challenges of controlling the infections and plague outbreaks. The development of new drug targets and therapies is urgently needed. This research aims to identify novel protein targets from 28 Y. pestis strains by the integrative pan-genomic and subtractive genomics approach. Additionally, it seeks to screen out potential safe and effective alternative therapies against these targets via high-throughput virtual screening. Targets should lack homology to human, gut microbiota, and known human 'anti-targets', while should exhibit essentiality for pathogen's survival and virulence, druggability, antibiotic resistance, and broad spectrum across multiple pathogenic bacteria. We identified two promising targets: the aminotransferase class I/class II domain-containing protein and 3-oxoacyl-[acyl-carrier-protein] synthase 2. These proteins were modeled using AlphaFold2, validated through several structural analyses, and were subjected to molecular docking and ADMET analysis. Molecular dynamics simulations determined the stability of the ligand-target complexes, providing potential therapeutic options against Y. pestis.

Unveiling intraspecific diversity and evolutionary dynamics of the foodborne pathogen Bacillus paranthracis through high-quality pan-genome analysis

Understanding the evolutionary dynamics of foodborne pathogens throughout host-associated habitats is of utmost importance. Bacterial pan-genomes, as dynamic entities, are strongly influenced by ecological lifestyles. As a phenotypically diverse species in the Bacillus cereus group, Bacillus paranthracis is recognized as an emerging foodborne pathogen and a probiotic simultaneously. This poorly understood species is a suitable study model for adaptive pan-genome evolution. In this study, we determined the biogeographic distribution, abundance, genetic diversity, and genotypic profiles of key genetic elements of B. paranthracis. Metagenomic read recruitment analyses demonstrated that B. paranthracis members are globally distributed and abundant in host-associated habitats. A high-quality pan-genome of B. paranthracis was subsequently constructed to analyze the evolutionary dynamics involved in ecological adaptation comprehensively. The open pan-genome indicated a flexible gene repertoire with extensive genetic diversity. Significant divergences in the phylogenetic relationships, functional enrichment, and degree of selective pressure between the different components demonstrated different evolutionary dynamics between the core and accessory genomes driven by ecological forces. Purifying selection and gene loss are the main signatures of evolutionary dynamics in B. paranthracis pan-genome. The plasticity of the accessory genome is characterized by horizontal gene transfer (HGT), massive gene losses, and weak purifying or positive selection, which might contribute to niche-specific adaptation. In contrast, although the core genome dominantly undergoes purifying selection, its association with HGT and positively selected mutations indicates its potential role in ecological diversification. Furthermore, host fitness-related dynamics are characterized by the loss of secondary metabolite biosynthesis gene clusters (BGCs) and CAZyme-encoding genes and the acquisition of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and virulence genes via HGT. This study offers a case study of pan-genome evolution to investigate the ecological adaptations reflected by biogeographical characteristics, thereby advancing the understanding of intraspecific diversity and evolutionary dynamics of foodborne pathogens.

Seven quick tips for gene-focused computational pangenomic analysis

Pangenomics is a relatively new scientific field which investigates the union of all the genomes of a clade. The word pan means everything in ancient Greek; the term pangenomics originally regarded genomes of bacteria and was later intended to refer to human genomes as well. Modern bioinformatics offers several tools to analyze pangenomics data, paving the way to an emerging field that we can call computational pangenomics. Current computational power available for the bioinformatics community has made computational pangenomic analyses easy to perform, but this higher accessibility to pangenomics analysis also increases the chances to make mistakes and to produce misleading or inflated results, especially by beginners. To handle this problem, we present here a few quick tips for efficient and correct computational pangenomic analyses with a focus on bacterial pangenomics, by describing common mistakes to avoid and experienced best practices to follow in this field. We believe our recommendations can help the readers perform more robust and sound pangenomic analyses and to generate more reliable results.

CELEBRIMBOR: core and accessory genes from metagenomes

MOTIVATION

Metagenome-Assembled Genomes (MAGs) or Single-cell Amplified Genomes (SAGs) are often incomplete, with sequences missing due to errors in assembly or low coverage. This presents a particular challenge for the identification of true gene frequencies within a microbial population, as core genes missing in only a few assemblies will be mischaracterized by current pangenome approaches.

RESULTS

Here, we present CELEBRIMBOR, a Snakemake pangenome analysis pipeline which uses a measure of genome completeness to automatically adjust the frequency threshold at which core genes are identified, enabling accurate core gene identification in MAGs and SAGs.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

CELEBRIMBOR is published under open source Apache 2.0 licence at https://github.com/bacpop/CELEBRIMBOR and is available as a Docker container from this repository. Supplementary material is available in the online version of the article.

Capturing clinically relevant Campylobacter attributes through direct whole genome sequencing of stool

Campylobacter is the leading bacterial cause of infectious intestinal disease, but the pathogen typically accounts for a very small proportion of the overall stool microbiome in each patient. Diagnosis is even more difficult due to the fastidious nature of Campylobacter in the laboratory setting. This has, in part, driven a change in recent years, from culture-based to rapid PCR-based diagnostic assays which have improved diagnostic detection, whilst creating a knowledge gap in our clinical and epidemiological understanding of Campylobacter genotypes - no isolates to sequence. In this study, direct metagenomic sequencing approaches were used to assess the possibility of replacing genome sequences with metagenome sequences; metagenomic sequencing outputs were used to describe clinically relevant attributes of Campylobacter genotypes. A total of 37 diarrhoeal stool samples with Campylobacter and five samples with an unknown pathogen result were collected and processed with and without filtration, DNA was extracted, and metagenomes were sequenced by short-read sequencing. Culture-based methods were used to validate Campylobacter metagenome-derived genome (MDG) results. Sequence output metrics were assessed for Campylobacter genome quality and accuracy of characterization. Of the 42 samples passing quality checks for analysis, identification of Campylobacter to the genus and species level was dependent on Campylobacter genome read count, coverage and genome completeness. A total of 65% (24/37) of samples were reliably identified to the genus level through Campylobacter MDG, 73% (27/37) by culture and 97% (36/37) by qPCR. The Campylobacter genomes with a genome completeness of over 60% (n=21) were all accurately identified at the species level (100%). Of those, 72% (15/21) were identified to sequence types (STs), and 95% (20/21) accurately identified antimicrobial resistance (AMR) gene determinants. Filtration of stool samples enhanced Campylobacter MDG recovery and genome quality metrics compared to the corresponding unfiltered samples, which improved the identification of STs and AMR profiles. The phylogenetic analysis in this study demonstrated the clustering of the metagenome-derived with culture-derived genomes and revealed the reliability of genomes from direct stool sequencing. Furthermore, Campylobacter genome spiking percentages ranging from 0 to 2% total metagenome abundance in the ONT MinION sequencer, configured to adaptive sequencing, exhibited better assembly quality and accurate identification of STs, particularly in the analysis of metagenomes containing 2 and 1% of Campylobacter jejuni genomes. Direct sequencing of Campylobacter from stool samples provides clinically relevant and epidemiologically important genomic information without the reliance on cultured genomes.

MAGs-centric crack: how long will, spore-positive Frankia and most Protofrankia, microsymbionts remain recalcitrant to axenic growth?

Nearly 50 years after the ground-breaking isolation of the primary Comptonia peregrina microsymbiont under axenic conditions, efforts to isolate a substantial number of Protofrankia and Frankia strains continue with enduring challenges and complexities. This study aimed to streamline genomic insights through comparative and predictive tools to extract traits crucial for isolating specific Frankia in axenic conditions. Pangenome analysis unveiled significant genetic diversity, suggesting untapped potential for cultivation strategies. Shared metabolic strategies in cellular components, central metabolic pathways, and resource acquisition traits offered promising avenues for cultivation. Ecological trait extraction indicated that most uncultured strains exhibit no apparent barriers to axenic growth. Despite ongoing challenges, potential caveats, and errors that could bias predictive analyses, this study provides a nuanced perspective. It highlights potential breakthroughs and guides refined cultivation strategies for these yet-uncultured strains. We advocate for tailored media formulations enriched with simple carbon sources in aerobic environments, with atmospheric nitrogen optionally sufficient to minimize contamination risks. Temperature adjustments should align with strain preferences-28-29°C for Frankia and 32-35°C for Protofrankia-while maintaining an alkaline pH. Given potential extended incubation periods (predicted doubling times ranging from 3.26 to 9.60 days, possibly up to 21.98 days), patience and rigorous contamination monitoring are crucial for optimizing cultivation conditions.

Genome-resolved metagenomics: a game changer for microbiome medicine

Recent substantial evidence implicating commensal bacteria in human diseases has given rise to a new domain in biomedical research: microbiome medicine. This emerging field aims to understand and leverage the human microbiota and derivative molecules for disease prevention and treatment. Despite the complex and hierarchical organization of this ecosystem, most research over the years has relied on 16S amplicon sequencing, a legacy of bacterial phylogeny and taxonomy. Although advanced sequencing technologies have enabled cost-effective analysis of entire microbiota, translating the relatively short nucleotide information into the functional and taxonomic organization of the microbiome has posed challenges until recently. In the last decade, genome-resolved metagenomics, which aims to reconstruct microbial genomes directly from whole-metagenome sequencing data, has made significant strides and continues to unveil the mysteries of various human-associated microbial communities. There has been a rapid increase in the volume of whole metagenome sequencing data and in the compilation of novel metagenome-assembled genomes and protein sequences in public depositories. This review provides an overview of the capabilities and methods of genome-resolved metagenomics for studying the human microbiome, with a focus on investigating the prokaryotic microbiota of the human gut. Just as decoding the human genome and its variations marked the beginning of the genomic medicine era, unraveling the genomes of commensal microbes and their sequence variations is ushering us into the era of microbiome medicine. Genome-resolved metagenomics stands as a pivotal tool in this transition and can accelerate our journey toward achieving these scientific and medical milestones.

RIBAP: a comprehensive bacterial core genome annotation pipeline for pangenome calculation beyond the species level

Microbial pangenome analysis identifies present or absent genes in prokaryotic genomes. However, current tools are limited when analyzing species with higher sequence diversity or higher taxonomic orders such as genera or families. The Roary ILP Bacterial core Annotation Pipeline (RIBAP) uses an integer linear programming approach to refine gene clusters predicted by Roary for identifying core genes. RIBAP successfully handles the complexity and diversity of Chlamydia, Klebsiella, Brucella, and Enterococcus genomes, outperforming other established and recent pangenome tools for identifying all-encompassing core genes at the genus level. RIBAP is a freely available Nextflow pipeline at github.com/hoelzer-lab/ribap and zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.10890871.

Sequencing-based analysis of microbiomes

Microbiomes occupy a range of niches and, in addition to having diverse compositions, they have varied functional roles that have an impact on agriculture, environmental sciences, and human health and disease. The study of microbiomes has been facilitated by recent technological and analytical advances, such as cheaper and higher-throughput DNA and RNA sequencing, improved long-read sequencing and innovative computational analysis methods. These advances are providing a deeper understanding of microbiomes at the genomic, transcriptional and translational level, generating insights into their function and composition at resolutions beyond the species level.

Putative genome contamination has minimal impact on the GTDB taxonomy

The Genome Taxonomy Database (GTDB) provides a species to domain classification of publicly available genomes based on average nucleotide identity (ANI) (for species) and a concatenated gene phylogeny normalized by evolutionary rates (for genus to phylum), which has been widely adopted by the scientific community. Here, we use the Genome UNClutterer (GUNC) software to identify putatively contaminated genomes in GTDB release 07-RS207. We found that GUNC reported 35,723 genomes as putatively contaminated, comprising 11.25 % of the 317,542 genomes in GTDB release 07-RS207. To assess the impact of this high level of inferred contamination on the delineation of taxa, we created 'clean' versions of the 34,846 putatively contaminated bacterial genomes by removing the most contaminated half. For each clean half, we re-calculated the ANI and concatenated gene phylogeny and found that only 77 (0.22 %) of the genomes were not consistent with their original classification. We conclude that the delineation of taxa in GTDB is robust to the putative contamination detected by GUNC.

Anaerostipes hadrus, a butyrate-producing bacterium capable of metabolizing 5-fluorouracil

Anaerostipes hadrus (A. hadrus) is a dominant species in the human gut microbiota and considered a beneficial bacterium for producing probiotic butyrate. However, recent studies have suggested that A. hadrus may negatively affect the host through synthesizing fatty acid and metabolizing the anticancer drug 5-fluorouracil, indicating that the impact of A. hadrus is complex and unclear. Therefore, comprehensive genomic studies on A. hadrus need to be performed. We integrated 527 high-quality public A. hadrus genomes and five distinct metagenomic cohorts. We analyzed these data using the approaches of comparative genomics, metagenomics, and protein structure prediction. We also performed validations with culture-based in vitro assays. We constructed the first large-scale pan-genome of A. hadrus (n = 527) and identified 5-fluorouracil metabolism genes as ubiquitous in A. hadrus genomes as butyrate-producing genes. Metagenomic analysis revealed the wide and stable distribution of A. hadrus in healthy individuals, patients with inflammatory bowel disease, and patients with colorectal cancer, with healthy individuals carrying more A. hadrus. The predicted high-quality protein structure indicated that A. hadrus might metabolize 5-fluorouracil by producing bacterial dihydropyrimidine dehydrogenase (encoded by the preTA operon). Through in vitro assays, we validated the short-chain fatty acid production and 5-fluorouracil metabolism abilities of A. hadrus. We observed for the first time that A. hadrus can convert 5-fluorouracil to α-fluoro-β-ureidopropionic acid, which may result from the combined action of the preTA operon and adjacent hydA (encoding bacterial dihydropyrimidinase). Our results offer novel understandings of A. hadrus, exceptionally functional features, and potential applications.

IMPORTANCE

This work provides new insights into the evolutionary relationships, functional characteristics, prevalence, and potential applications of Anaerostipes hadrus.

Comparative genomic analyses of Cutibacterium granulosum provide insights into genomic diversity

Cutibacterium granulosum, a commensal bacterium found on human skin, formerly known as Propionibacterium granulosum, rarely causes infections and is generally considered non-pathogenic. Recent research has revealed the transferability of the multidrug-resistant plasmid pTZC1 between C. granulosum and Cutibacterium acnes, the latter being an opportunistic pathogen in surgical site infections. However, there is a noticeable lack of research on the genome of C. granulosum, and the genetic landscape of this species remains largely uncharted. We investigated the genomic features and evolutionary structure of C. granulosum by analyzing a total of 30 Metagenome-Assembled Genomes (MAGs) and isolate genomes retrieved from public databases, as well as those generated in this study. A pan-genome of 6,077 genes was identified for C. granulosum. Remarkably, the 'cloud genes' constituted 62.38% of the pan-genome. Genes associated with mobilome: prophages, transposons [X], defense mechanisms [V] and replication, recombination and repair [L] were enriched in the cloud genome. Phylogenomic analysis revealed two distinct mono-clades, highlighting the genomic diversity of C. granulosum. The genomic diversity was further confirmed by the distribution of Average Nucleotide Identity (ANI) values. The functional profiles analysis of C. granulosum unveiled a wide range of potential Antibiotic Resistance Genes (ARGs) and virulence factors, suggesting its potential tolerance to various environmental challenges. Subtype I-E of the CRISPR-Cas system was the most abundant in these genomes, a feature also detected in C. acnes genomes. Given the widespread distribution of C. granulosum strains within skin microbiome, our findings make a substantial contribution to our broader understanding of the genetic diversity, which may open new avenues for investigating the mechanisms and treatment of conditions such as acne vulgaris.

MRGM: an enhanced catalog of mouse gut microbial genomes substantially broadening taxonomic and functional landscapes

Mouse gut microbiome research is pivotal for understanding the human gut microbiome, providing insights into disease modeling, host-microbe interactions, and the dietary influence on the gut microbiome. To enhance the translational value of mouse gut microbiome studies, we need detailed and high-quality catalogs of mouse gut microbial genomes. We introduce the Mouse Reference Gut Microbiome (MRGM), a comprehensive catalog with 42,245 non-redundant mouse gut bacterial genomes across 1,524 species. MRGM marks a 40% increase in the known taxonomic diversity of mouse gut microbes, capturing previously underrepresented lineages through refined genome quality assessment techniques. MRGM not only broadens the taxonomic landscape but also enriches the functional landscape of the mouse gut microbiome. Using deep learning, we have elevated the Gene Ontology annotation rate for mouse gut microbial proteins from 3.2% with orthology to 60%, marking an over 18-fold increase. MRGM supports both DNA- and marker-based taxonomic profiling by providing custom databases, surpassing previous catalogs in performance. Finally, taxonomic and functional comparisons between human and mouse gut microbiota reveal diet-driven divergences in their taxonomic composition and functional enrichment. Overall, our study highlights the value of high-quality microbial genome catalogs in advancing our understanding of the co-evolution between gut microbes and their host.

PanDelos-frags: A methodology for discovering pangenomic content of incomplete microbial assemblies

Pangenomics was originally defined as the problem of comparing the composition of genes into gene families within a set of bacterial isolates belonging to the same species. The problem requires the calculation of sequence homology among such genes. When combined with metagenomics, namely for human microbiome composition analysis, gene-oriented pangenome detection becomes a promising method to decipher ecosystem functions and population-level evolution. Established computational tools are able to investigate the genetic content of isolates for which a complete genomic sequence is available. However, there is a plethora of incomplete genomes that are available on public resources, which only a few tools may analyze. Incomplete means that the process for reconstructing their genomic sequence is not complete, and only fragments of their sequence are currently available. However, the information contained in these fragments may play an essential role in the analyses. Here, we present PanDelos-frags, a computational tool which exploits and extends previous results in analyzing complete genomes. It provides a new methodology for inferring missing genetic information and thus for managing incomplete genomes. PanDelos-frags outperforms state-of-the-art approaches in reconstructing gene families in synthetic benchmarks and in a real use case of metagenomics. PanDelos-frags is publicly available at https://github.com/InfOmics/PanDelos-frags.

Host specific adaptations of Ligilactobacillus aviarius to poultry

The genus Ligilactobacillus encompasses species adapted to vertebrate hosts and fermented food. Their genomes encode adaptations to the host lifestyle. Reports of gut microbiota from chicken and turkey gastrointestinal tract have shown a high persistence of Ligilactobacillus aviarius along the digestive system compared to other species found in the same host. However, its adaptations to poultry as a host has not yet been described. In this work, the pan-genome of Ligilactobacillus aviarius was explored to describe the functional adaptability to the gastrointestinal environment. The core genome is composed of 1179 gene clusters that are present at least in one copy that codifies to structural, ribosomal and biogenesis proteins. The rest of the identified regions were classified into three different functional clusters of orthologous groups (clusters) that codify carbohydrate metabolism, envelope biogenesis, viral defence mechanisms, and mobilome inclusions. The pan-genome of Ligilactobacillus aviarius is a closed pan-genome, frequently found in poultry and highly prevalent across chicken faecal samples. The genome of L. aviarius codifies different clusters of glycoside hydrolases and glycosyltransferases that mediate interactions with the host cells. Accessory features, such as antiviral mechanisms and prophage inclusions, variate amongst strains from different GIT sections. This information provides hints about the interaction of this species with viral particles and other bacterial species. This work highlights functional adaptability traits present in L. aviarius that make it a dominant key member of the poultry gut microbiota and enlightens the convergent ecological relation of this species to the poultry gut environment.

Human Pangenomics: Promises and Challenges of a Distributed Genomic Reference

A pangenome is a collection of the common and unique genomes that are present in a given species. It combines the genetic information of all the genomes sampled, resulting in a large and diverse range of genetic material. Pangenomic analysis offers several advantages compared to traditional genomic research. For example, a pangenome is not bound by the physical constraints of a single genome, so it can capture more genetic variability. Thanks to the introduction of the concept of pangenome, it is possible to use exceedingly detailed sequence data to study the evolutionary history of two different species, or how populations within a species differ genetically. In the wake of the Human Pangenome Project, this review aims at discussing the advantages of the pangenome around human genetic variation, which are then framed around how pangenomic data can inform population genetics, phylogenetics, and public health policy by providing insights into the genetic basis of diseases or determining personalized treatments, targeting the specific genetic profile of an individual. Moreover, technical limitations, ethical concerns, and legal considerations are discussed.