Significant Evolutionary Constraints on Neuron Cells Revealed by Single-Cell Transcriptomics

Functional Optimization in Distinct Tissues and Conditions Constrains the Rate of Protein Evolution

Understanding the main determinants of protein evolution is a fundamental challenge in biology. Despite many decades of active research, the molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying the substantial variability of evolutionary rates across cellular proteins are not currently well understood. It also remains unclear how protein molecular function is optimized in the context of multicellular species and why many proteins, such as enzymes, are only moderately efficient on average. Our analysis of genomics and functional datasets reveals in multiple organisms a strong inverse relationship between the optimality of protein molecular function and the rate of protein evolution. Furthermore, we find that highly expressed proteins tend to be substantially more functionally optimized. These results suggest that cellular expression costs lead to more pronounced functional optimization of abundant proteins and that the purifying selection to maintain high levels of functional optimality significantly slows protein evolution. We observe that in multicellular species both the rate of protein evolution and the degree of protein functional efficiency are primarily affected by expression in several distinct cell types and tissues, specifically, in developed neurons with upregulated synaptic processes in animals and in young and fast-growing tissues in plants. Overall, our analysis reveals how various constraints from the molecular, cellular, and species' levels of biological organization jointly affect the rate of protein evolution and the level of protein functional adaptation.

Human-unique brain cell clusters are associated with learning disorders and human episodic memory activity

The advanced evolution of the human cerebral cortex forms the basis for our high-level cognitive functions. Through a comparative analysis of single-nucleus transcriptome data from the human neocortex and that of chimpanzees, macaques, and marmosets, we discovered 20 subgroups of cell types unique to the human brain, which include 11 types of excitatory neurons. Many of these human-unique cell clusters exhibit significant overexpression of genes regulated by human-specific enhancers. Notably, these specific cell clusters also express genes associated with disease risk, particularly those related to brain dysfunctions like learning disorders. Furthermore, genes linked to cortical thickness and human episodic memory encoding activities show heightened expression within these cell subgroups. These findings underscore the critical role of human brain-unique cell clusters in the evolution of human brain functions.

Single-mitochondrion sequencing uncovers distinct mutational patterns and heteroplasmy landscape in mouse astrocytes and neurons

BACKGROUND

Mitochondrial (mt) heteroplasmy can cause adverse biological consequences when deleterious mtDNA mutations accumulate disrupting "normal" mt-driven processes and cellular functions. To investigate the heteroplasmy of such mtDNA changes, we developed a moderate throughput mt isolation procedure to quantify the mt single-nucleotide variant (SNV) landscape in individual mouse neurons and astrocytes. In this study, we amplified mt-genomes from 1645 single mitochondria isolated from mouse single astrocytes and neurons to (1) determine the distribution and proportion of mt-SNVs as well as mutation pattern in specific target regions across the mt-genome, (2) assess differences in mtDNA SNVs between neurons and astrocytes, and (3) study co-segregation of variants in the mouse mtDNA.

RESULTS

(1) The data show that specific sites of the mt-genome are permissive to SNV presentation while others appear to be under stringent purifying selection. Nested hierarchical analysis at the levels of mitochondrion, cell, and mouse reveals distinct patterns of inter- and intra-cellular variation for mt-SNVs at different sites. (2) Further, differences in the SNV incidence were observed between mouse neurons and astrocytes for two mt-SNV 9027:G > A and 9419:C > T showing variation in the mutational propensity between these cell types. Purifying selection was observed in neurons as shown by the Ka/Ks statistic, suggesting that neurons are under stronger evolutionary constraint as compared to astrocytes. (3) Intriguingly, these data show strong linkage between the SNV sites at nucleotide positions 9027 and 9461.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that segregation as well as clonal expansion of mt-SNVs is specific to individual genomic loci, which is important foundational data in understanding of heteroplasmy and disease thresholds for mutation of pathogenic variants.

Deciphering brain cellular and behavioral mechanisms: Insights from single-cell and spatial RNA sequencing

The brain is a complex computing system composed of a multitude of interacting neurons. The computational outputs of this system determine the behavior and perception of every individual. Each brain cell expresses thousands of genes that dictate the cell's function and physiological properties. Therefore, deciphering the molecular expression of each cell is of great significance for understanding its characteristics and role in brain function. Additionally, the positional information of each cell can provide crucial insights into their involvement in local brain circuits. In this review, we briefly overview the principles of single-cell RNA sequencing and spatial transcriptomics, the potential issues and challenges in their data processing, and their applications in brain research. We further outline several promising directions in neuroscience that could be integrated with single-cell RNA sequencing, including neurodevelopment, the identification of novel brain microstructures, cognition and behavior, neuronal cell positioning, molecules and cells related to advanced brain functions, sleep-wake cycles/circadian rhythms, and computational modeling of brain function. We believe that the deep integration of these directions with single-cell and spatial RNA sequencing can contribute significantly to understanding the roles of individual cells or cell types in these specific functions, thereby making important contributions to addressing critical questions in those fields. This article is categorized under: RNA Evolution and Genomics > Computational Analyses of RNA RNA in Disease and Development > RNA in Development RNA in Disease and Development > RNA in Disease.

Single-Mitochondrion Sequencing Uncovers Distinct Mutational Patterns and Heteroplasmy Landscape in Mouse Astrocytes and Neurons

Background

Mitochondrial (mt) heteroplasmy can cause adverse biological consequences when deleterious mtDNA mutations accumulate disrupting 'normal' mt-driven processes and cellular functions. To investigate the heteroplasmy of such mtDNA changes we developed a moderate throughput mt isolation procedure to quantify the mt single-nucleotide variant (SNV) landscape in individual mouse neurons and astrocytes In this study we amplified mt-genomes from 1,645 single mitochondria (mts) isolated from mouse single astrocytes and neurons to 1. determine the distribution and proportion of mt-SNVs as well as mutation pattern in specific target regions across the mt-genome, 2. assess differences in mtDNA SNVs between neurons and astrocytes, and 3. Study cosegregation of variants in the mouse mtDNA.

Results

1. The data show that specific sites of the mt-genome are permissive to SNV presentation while others appear to be under stringent purifying selection. Nested hierarchical analysis at the levels of mitochondrion, cell, and mouse reveals distinct patterns of inter- and intra-cellular variation for mt-SNVs at different sites. 2. Further, differences in the SNV incidence were observed between mouse neurons and astrocytes for two mt-SNV 9027:G>A and 9419:C>T showing variation in the mutational propensity between these cell types. Purifying selection was observed in neurons as shown by the Ka/Ks statistic, suggesting that neurons are under stronger evolutionary constraint as compared to astrocytes. 3. Intriguingly, these data show strong linkage between the SNV sites at nucleotide positions 9027 and 9461.

Conclusion

This study suggests that segregation as well as clonal expansion of mt-SNVs is specific to individual genomic loci, which is important foundational data in understanding of heteroplasmy and disease thresholds for mutation of pathogenic variants.

Convergence of the dysregulated regulome in schizophrenia with polygenic risk and evolutionarily constrained enhancers

Enhancers play an essential role in the etiology of schizophrenia; however, the dysregulation of enhancer activity and its impact on the regulome in schizophrenia remains understudied. To address this gap in our knowledge, we assessed enhancer and gene expression in 1,382 brain samples comprising cases with schizophrenia and unaffected controls. Dysregulation of enhancer expression was concordant with changes in gene expression, and was more closely associated with schizophrenia polygenic risk, suggesting that enhancer dysregulation is proximal to the genetic etiology of the disease. Modeling the shared variance of cis-coordinated genes and enhancers revealed a gene regulatory program that was highly associated with genetic vulnerability to schizophrenia. By integrating coordinated factors with evolutionary constraints, we found that enhancers acquired during human evolution are more likely to regulate genes that are implicated in neuropsychiatric disorders and, thus, hold potential as therapeutic targets. Our analysis provides a systematic view of regulome dysregulation in schizophrenia and highlights its convergence with schizophrenia polygenic risk and human-gained enhancers.

Role of caveolin-1 in metabolic programming of fetal brain

Mice lacking caveolin-1 (Cav1), a key protein of plasma membrane, exhibit brain aging at an early adult stage. Here, integrative analyses of metabolomics, transcriptomics, epigenetics, and single-cell data were performed to test the hypothesis that metabolic deregulation of fetal brain due to the ablation of Cav1 is linked to brain aging in these mice. The results of this study show that lack of Cav1 caused deregulation in the lipid and amino acid metabolism in the fetal brain, and genes associated with these deregulated metabolites were significantly altered in the brain upon aging. Moreover, ablation of Cav1 deregulated several metabolic genes in specific cell types of the fetal brain and impacted DNA methylation of those genes in coordination with mouse epigenetic clock. The findings of this study suggest that the aging program of brain is confounded by metabolic abnormalities in the fetal stage due to the absence of Cav1.

Evolution and dysfunction of human cognitive and social traits: A transcriptional regulation perspective

Evolutionary changes in brain and craniofacial development have endowed humans with unique cognitive and social skills, but also predisposed us to debilitating disorders in which these traits are disrupted. What are the developmental genetic underpinnings that connect the adaptive evolution of our cognition and sociality with the persistence of mental disorders with severe negative fitness effects? We argue that loss of function of genes involved in transcriptional regulation represents a crucial link between the evolution and dysfunction of human cognitive and social traits. The argument is based on the haploinsufficiency of many transcriptional regulator genes, which makes them particularly sensitive to loss-of-function mutations. We discuss how human brain and craniofacial traits evolved through partial loss of function (i.e. reduced expression) of these genes, a perspective compatible with the idea of human self-domestication. Moreover, we explain why selection against loss-of-function variants supports the view that mutation-selection-drift, rather than balancing selection, underlies the persistence of psychiatric disorders. Finally, we discuss testable predictions.

Epigenetic regulation of fetal brain development in pig

How fetal brain development is regulated at the molecular level is not well understood. Due to ethical challenges associated with research on the human fetus, large animals particularly pigs are increasingly used to study development and disorders of fetal brain. The pig fetal brain grows rapidly during the last ∼ 50 days before birth which is around day 60 (d60) of pig gestation. But what regulates the onset of accelerated growth of the brain is unknown. The current study tests the hypothesis that epigenetic alteration around d60 is involved in the onset of rapid growth of fetal brain of pig. To test this hypothesis, DNA methylation changes of fetal brain was assessed in a genome-wide manner by Enzymatic Methyl-seq (EM-seq) during two gestational periods (GP): d45 vs. d60 (GP1) and d60 vs. d90 (GP2). The cytosine-guanine (CpG) methylation data was analyzed in an integrative manner with the RNA-seq data generated from the same brain samples from our earlier study. A neural network based modeling approach was implemented to learn changes in methylation patterns of the differentially expressed genes, and then predict methylations of the brain in a genome-wide manner during rapid growth. This approach identified specific methylations that changed in a mutually informative manner during rapid growth of the fetal brain. These methylations were significantly overrepresented in specific genic as well as intergenic features including CpG islands, introns, and untranslated regions. In addition, sex-bias methylations of known single nucleotide polymorphic sites were also identified in the fetal brain ide during rapid growth.

An Alternative Class of Targets for microRNAs Containing CG Dinucleotide

Simple Summary

MicroRNAs are ~23 nt, highly conserved non-coding RNA molecules involved in the regulation of target gene expression. Most of the microRNA-target prediction algorithms rely heavily on seed rules and evolutionary conservation. However, such strategies suffer from missing the non-canonical target sites. The aim of this study is to identify the general features of non-canonical targets and their interactions with microRNAs. We found that the bulge-targets were preferentially associated with the microRNAs containing CG dinucleotides in their seed region. This finding indicates that non-canonical targets could be rich due to high mutation frequency of CG within the target mRNAs. Multi-step validation, which included evolutionary, overexpression, correlation, and CLASH data analysis, supports the interactome between the microRNAs with CG dinucleotides in the seed region and their bugle targets. Thus, a major novelty of this work is the identification of a sequence motif, CG dinucleotides, in the seed region of microRNAs, is strongly correlated to bulge targeting patterns.

Abstract

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are endogenous ~23 nt RNAs which regulate message RNA (mRNA) targets mainly through perfect pairing with their seed region (positions 2–7). Several instances of UTR sequence with an additional nucleotide that might form a bulge within the pairing region, can also be recognized by miRNA as their target (bugle-target). But the prevalence of such imperfect base pairings in human and their roles in the evolution are incompletely understood. We found that human miRNAs with the CG dinucleotides (CG dimer) in their seed region have a significant low mutation rate than their putative binding sites in mRNA targets. Interspecific comparation shows that these miRNAs had very few conservative targets with the perfect seed-pairing, while potentially having a subclass of bulge-targets. Compared with the canonical target (perfect seed-pairing), these bulge-targets had a lower negative correlation with the miRNA expression, and either were down-regulated in the miRNA overexpression experiment or up-regulated in the miRNA knock-down experiment. Our results show that the bulge-targets are widespread in the miRNAs with CG dinucleotide within their seed regions, which could in part explain the rare conserved targets of these miRNAs based on seed rule. Incorporating these bulge-targets, together with conservation information, could more accurately predict the entire targets of these miRNAs.

Genomics at cellular resolution: insights into cognitive disorders and their evolution

High-throughput genomic sequencing approaches have held the promise of understanding and ultimately leading to treatments for cognitive disorders such as autism spectrum disorders, schizophrenia and Alzheimer's disease. Although significant progress has been made into identifying genetic variants associated with these diseases, these studies have also uncovered that these disorders are mostly genetically complex and thus challenging to model in non-human systems. Improvements in such models might benefit from understanding the evolution of the human genome and how such modifications have affected brain development and function. The intersection of genome-wide variant information with cell-type-specific expression and epigenetic information will further assist in resolving the contribution of particular cell types in evolution or disease. For example, the role of non-neuronal cells in brain evolution and cognitive disorders has gone mostly underappreciated until the recent availability of single-cell transcriptomic approaches. In this review, we discuss recent studies that carry out cell-type-specific assessments of gene expression in brain tissue across primates and between healthy and disease populations. The emerging results from these studies are beginning to elucidate how specific cell types in the evolved human brain are contributing to cognitive disorders.

Evolutionary conservation and divergence of the human brain transcriptome

Background

Mouse models have allowed for the direct interrogation of genetic effects on molecular, physiological, and behavioral brain phenotypes. However, it is unknown to what extent neurological or psychiatric traits may be human- or primate-specific and therefore which components can be faithfully recapitulated in mouse models.

Results

We compare conservation of co-expression in 116 independent data sets derived from human, mouse, and non-human primate representing more than 15,000 total samples. We observe greater changes occurring on the human lineage than mouse, and substantial regional variation that highlights cerebral cortex as the most diverged region. Glia, notably microglia, astrocytes, and oligodendrocytes are the most divergent cell type, three times more on average than neurons. We show that cis-regulatory sequence divergence explains a significant fraction of co-expression divergence. Moreover, protein coding sequence constraint parallels co-expression conservation, such that genes with loss of function intolerance are enriched in neuronal, rather than glial modules. We identify dozens of human neuropsychiatric and neurodegenerative disease risk genes, such as COMT, PSEN-1, LRRK2, SHANK3, and SNCA, with highly divergent co-expression between mouse and human and show that 3D human brain organoids recapitulate in vivo co-expression modules representing several human cell types.

Conclusions

We identify robust co-expression modules reflecting whole-brain and regional patterns of gene expression. Compared with those that represent basic metabolic processes, cell-type-specific modules, most prominently glial modules, are the most divergent between species. These data and analyses serve as a foundational resource to guide human disease modeling and its interpretation.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13059-020-02257-z.