A model of corrective gene transfer in X-linked ichthyosis

Treatments for Non-Syndromic Inherited Ichthyosis, Including Emergent Pathogenesis-Related Therapy

The term 'inherited ichthyosis' refers to a heterogeneous group of mendelian disorders of cornification that involve the integument with varying degrees of scaling. The management of ichthyosis poses a challenge for most physicians. Treatment options proposed in the literature include moisturizers, topical keratolytics, topical and systemic vitamin D analogues, and topical and systemic retinoids; however, some of these modalities are less reliable than others. Despite the therapeutic impasse imposed by the options above, the emergence of pathogenesis-based treatments along with novel gene therapies appear promising and hold the potential to halt or even revert disorders that arise from single genetic mutations, although research is still quite lacking in this domain. Hence, this review aims to highlight the various treatment modalities available for the management of the cutaneous manifestations of non-syndromic inherited ichthyosis, with an added emphasis on pathogenesis-targeted therapies.

New developments in the molecular treatment of ichthyosis: review of the literature

Ichthyosis covers a wide spectrum of diseases affecting the cornification of the skin. In recent years, new advances in understanding the pathophysiology of ichthyosis have been made. This knowledge, combined with constant development of pathogenesis-based therapies, such as protein replacement therapy and gene therapy, are rather promising for patients with inherited skin diseases. Several ongoing trials are investigating the potency of these new approaches and various studies have already been published. Furthermore, a lot of case series report that biological therapeutics are effective treatment options, mainly for Netherton syndrome and autosomal recessive congenital ichthyosis. It is expected that some of these new therapies will prove their efficacy and will be incorporated in the treatment of ichthyosis.

Current Strategies for the Gene Therapy of Autosomal Recessive Congenital Ichthyosis and Other Types of Inherited Ichthyosis

Mutations in genes such as transglutaminase-1 (TGM1), which are responsible for the formation and normal functioning of a lipid barrier, lead to the development of autosomal recessive congenital ichthyosis (ARCI). ARCIs are characterized by varying degrees of hyperkeratosis and the presence of scales on the body surface since birth. The quality of life of patients is often significantly affected, and in order to alleviate the manifestations of the disease, symptomatic therapy with moisturizers, keratolytics, retinoids and other cosmetic substances is often used to improve the condition of the patients' skin. Graft transplantation is commonly used to correct defects of the eye. However, these approaches offer symptomatic treatment that does not restore the lost protein function or provide a long-term skin barrier. Gene and cell therapies are evolving as promising therapy for ARCIs that can correct the functional activity of altered proteins. However, these approaches are still at an early stage of development. This review discusses current studies of gene and cell therapy approaches for various types of ichthyosis and their further prospects for patient treatment.

Cellular therapy options for genetic skin disorders with a focus on recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa

INTRODUCTION

Combinatorial cell and gene therapies for life-threatening inherited skin disorders have shown tremendous potential for preclinical and clinical implementation with significant progress made for recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa (RDEB). To date, various cell lineages including resident skin cells and adult stem cells have been investigated for gene and cell therapy for RDEB reaching the clinical trial stage.

SOURCES OF DATA

Sources of data are key recent literature, ClinicalTrials.gov, Clinicaltrialsregister.eu and pharma press releases.

AREAS OF AGREEMENT

Cell-based gene transfer using autologous patients' cells has demonstrated positive outcomes in preclinical and clinical trials and highlighted the importance of targeting resident skin stem cells to achieve a meaningful long-term effect. Additionally, adult stem cells, such as mesenchymal stromal cells, have the potential to ameliorate systemic manifestations of the disease.

AREAS OF CONTROVERSY

While proven safe, the clinical trials of localized treatment have reported only modest and transient improvements. On the other hand, the risks associated with systemic therapies remain high and should be carefully weighed against the potential benefits. It is unclear to what extent adult stem cells can contribute to skin regeneration/wound healing.

GROWING POINTS

Further research is warranted in order to fulfil the potential of cellular therapies for RDEB. The development of combinatorial gene and cell-based approaches is required to achieve long-term clinical benefits.

AREAS TIMELY FOR DEVELOPING RESEARCH

Induced pluripotent stem cells can potentially provide a valuable source of autologous patient material for cellular therapies. In addition, recent advances in the field of gene editing can overcome hurdles associated with conventional gene addition approaches.

DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT

No new data were generated or analysed in support of this review.

Gene Therapy and its Application in Dermatology

Gene therapy is an experimental technique to treat genetic diseases. It is based on the introduction of nucleic acid with the help of a vector, into a diseased cell or tissue, to correct the gene expression and thus prevent, halt, or reverse a pathological process. It is a promising treatment approach for genetic diseases, inherited diseases, vaccination, cancer, immunomodulation, as well as healing of some refractory ulcers. Both viral and nonviral vectors can be used to deliver the correct gene. An ideal vector should have the ability for sustained gene expression, acceptable coding capacity, high transduction efficiency, and devoid of mutagenicity. There are different techniques of vector delivery, but these techniques are still under research for assessment of their safety and effectiveness. The major challenges of gene therapy are immunogenicity, mutagenicity, and lack of sustainable therapeutic benefit. Despite these constraints, therapeutic success was obtained in a few genetic and inherited skin diseases. Skin being the largest, superficial, easily accessible and assessable organ of the body, may be a promising target for gene therapy research in the recent future.

CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing for genodermatoses: progress and perspectives

Genodermatoses constitute a clinically heterogeneous group of devastating genetic skin disorders. Currently, therapy options are largely limited to symptomatic treatments and although significant advances have been made in ex vivo gene therapy strategies, various limitations remain. However, the recent technical transformation of the genome editing field promises to overcome the hurdles associated with conventional gene addition approaches. In this review, we discuss the need for developing novel treatments and describe the current status of gene editing for genodermatoses, focusing on a severe blistering disease called epidermolysis bullosa (EB), for which significant progress has been made. Initial research utilized engineered nucleases such as transcription activator-like effector nucleases and meganucleases. However, over the last few years, clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats/CRISPR-associated protein 9 (CRISPR/Cas9) have upstaged older generation gene editing tools. We examine different strategies for CRISPR/Cas9 application that can be employed depending on the type and position of the mutation as well as the mode of its inheritance. Promising developments in the field of base editing opens new avenues for precise correction of single base substitutions, common in EB and other genodermatoses. We also address the potential limitations and challenges such as safety concerns and delivery efficiency. This review gives an insight into the future of gene editing technologies for genodermatoses.

Management of ichthyosis and related conditions gene-based diagnosis and emerging gene-based therapy

Knowledge of the molecular basis of many inherited diseases has grown exponentially during the past decade. Inherited skin diseases, including the ichthyoses and related conditions, benefited from that explosion of information, much of which has relevance for the clinical setting. In this section, the authors review the genes now known to be involved in ichthyosis, the methods for detecting mutations in those genes in the clinical diagnostic laboratory, options for using that information for diagnosis and pregnancy/family planning decisions, and current and future therapies based on the knowledge of the molecular basis of the ichthyosis.

Bioengineered skin substitutes

Bioengineered skin has great potential for use in regenerative medicine for treatment of severe wounds such as burns or chronic ulcers. Genetically modified skin substitutes have also been used as cell-based devices or "live bioreactors" to deliver therapeutics locally or systemically. Finally, these tissue constructs are used as realistic models of human skin for toxicological testing, to speed drug development and replace traditional animal-based tests in a variety of industries. Here we describe a method of generating bioengineered skin based on a natural scaffold, namely, decellularized human dermis and epidermal stem cells.

Sulfatase activities towards the regulation of cell metabolism and signaling in mammals

In higher vertebrates, sulfatases belong to a conserved family of enzymes that are involved in the regulation of cell metabolism and in developmental cell signaling. They cleave the sulfate from sulfate esters contained in hormones, proteins, and complex macromolecules. A highly conserved cysteine in their active site is post-translationally converted into formylglycine by the formylglycine-generating enzyme encoded by SUMF1 (sulfatase modifying factor 1). This post-translational modification activates all sulfatases. Sulfatases are extensively glycosylated proteins and some of them follow trafficking pathways through cells, being secreted and taken up by distant cells. Many proteoglycans, glycoproteins, and glycolipids contain sulfated carbohydrates, which are sulfatase substrates. Indeed, sulfatases operate as decoding factors for a large amount of biological information contained in the structures of the sulfated sugar chains that are covalently linked to proteins and lipids. Modifications to these sulfate groups have pivotal roles in modulating specific signaling pathways and cell metabolism in mammals.

X-linked ichthyosis: an oculocutaneous genodermatosis

X-linked ichthyosis (XLI) is an X-linked recessive disorder of cutaneous keratinization with possible extracutaneous manifestations. It was first described as a distinct type of ichthyosis in 1965. XLI is caused by a deficiency in steroid sulfatase activity, which results in abnormal desquamation and a retention hyperkeratosis. XLI is usually evident during the first few weeks of life as polygonal, loosely adherent translucent scales in a generalized distribution that desquamate widely. These are quickly replaced by large, dark brown, tightly adherent scales occurring primarily symmetrically on the extensor surfaces and the side of the trunk. In addition, extracutaneous manifestations such as corneal opacities, cryptorchidism, and abnormalities related to contiguous gene syndromes may be observed. Diagnosis of XLI is usually made clinically, as the histopathology is nonspecific, but confirmation may be obtained through either biochemical or genetic analysis. Treatment should focus on cutaneous hydration, lubrication, and keratolysis and includes topical moisturizers and topical retinoids.

An approach to achieve long-term expression in skin gene therapy

For gene therapy purposes, the skin is an attractive organ to target for systemic delivery of therapeutic proteins to treat systemic diseases, skin diseases, or skin cancer. To achieve long-term stable expression of a therapeutic gene in keratinocytes (KC), we have developed an approach using a bicistronic retroviral vector expressing the desired therapeutic gene linked to a selectable marker (multidrug resistant gene, MDR) that is then introduced into KC and fibroblasts (FB) to create genetically modified human skin equivalent (HSE). After grafting the HSE onto immunocompromised mice, topical colchicine treatment is used to select and enrich for genetically modified keratinocyte stem cells (KSC) that express MDR and are resistant to colchicine's antimitotic effects. Both the apparatus for topical colchicine delivery and the colchicine doses have been optimized for application to human skin. This approach can be validated by systemic delivery of therapeutic factors such as erythropoietin and the antihypertensive atrial natriuretic peptide.

Efficient retroviral gene transfer to epidermal stem cells

Skin is an attractive target for gene modification to treat skin diseases, wound healing, or even systemic disorders. Although retroviral transduction results in permanent genetic modification, differentiation and eventually loss of the transduced cells from the epidermis and in temporary transgene expression. Therefore, it is important to develop methods that promote gene transfer to epidermal stem cells, which self-renew and regenerate the epidermis for extended periods of time. Here we describe an efficient protocol that results in high levels of retroviral gene transfer to human epidermal stem cells by immobilizing retrovirus on a recombinant fibronectin (rFN) fragment. In contrast to the traditional method, transduction on rFN promotes gene transfer to epidermal stem cells and prevents loss of clonogenic potential due to exposure of cells to retroviral supernatant. Notably, transduction on rFN does not require addition of toxic polycations such as polybrene. Overall this method provides a simple, fast, and efficient means to modify human epidermal stem cells for cutaneous gene therapy and for biological studies that require stable genetic modification.

Cutaneous gene delivery

Over the past decade, many approaches to transferring genes into the skin have been investigated. However, most such approaches have been specifically aimed against genodermatosis, and have not produced sufficient results. The goal of such research is to develop a method in which genes are transferred easily, efficiently and stably into keratinocytes, especially into keratinocyte stem cells, and in which the transgene expression persists without a reaction from the host immune response. Although accidental development of cancer has occurred in trials of gene therapy for X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (X-SCID), resulting in slowing of the progress of this research, the lessons of these setbacks have been applied to further research. Moreover, combined with the techniques acquired from tissue engineering, recent developments in our knowledge about stem cells will lead to new treatments for genodermatoses. The present review summarizes the methods by which therapeutic genes can be transferred into keratinocytes, with discussion of how gene transfer efficiency can be improved, with particular emphasis on disruption of the skin barrier function. It concludes with discussion of the challenges and prospects of keratinocyte gene therapy, in terms of achieving efficient and long-lasting therapeutic effects.

Adenoviral gene delivery to primary human cutaneous cells and burn wounds

The adenoviral transfer of therapeutic genes into epidermal and dermal cells is an interesting approach to treat skin diseases and to promote wound healing. The aim of this study was to assess the in vitro and in vivo transfection efficacy in skin and burn wounds after adenoviral gene delivery. Primary keratinocytes (HKC), fibroblasts (HFB), and HaCaT cells were transfected using different concentrations of an adenoviral construct (eGFP). Transfection efficiency and cytotoxicity was determined up to 30 days. Expression was quantified by FACS analysis and fluorimeter. Cytotoxicity was measured using the trypan blue exclusion method. 45 male Sprague Dawley rats received 2x10(8) pfu of Ad5-CMV-LacZ or carrier control intradermally into either superficial partial thickness scald burn or unburned skin. Animals were euthanized after 48 h, 7 or 14 days posttreatment. Transgene expression was assessed using immunohistochemistry and bioluminescent assays. The highest transfection rate was observed 48 h posttransfection: 79% for HKC, 70% for HFB, and 48% for HaCaT. The eGFP expression was detectable in all groups over 30 days (P>0.05). Cytotoxic effects of the adenoviral vector were observed for HFB after 10 days and HaCaT after 30 days. Reporter gene expression in vivo was significantly higher in burned skin compared with unburned skin (P=0,004). Gene expression decreases from 2 to 7 days with no significant expression after 14 days. This study demonstrates that effective adenoviral-mediated gene transfer of epidermal primary cells and cell-lines is feasible. Ex vivo gene transfer in epithelial cells might have promise for the use in severely burned patients who receive autologous keratinocyte sheets. Transient cutaneous gene delivery in burn wounds using adenoviral vectors causes significant concentrations in the wound tissue for at least 1 week. Based on these findings, we hypothesize that transient cutaneous adenoviral gene delivery of wound healing promoting factors has potential for clinical application.

Gene transfer in human skin with different pseudotyped HIV-based vectors

Pseudotyping lentiviral vector with other viral surface proteins could be applied for treating genetic anomalies in human skin. In this study, the modification of HIV vector tropism by pseudotyping with the envelope glycoprotein from vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), the Zaire Ebola (EboZ) virus, murine leukemia virus (MuLV), lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV), Rabies or the rabies-related Mokola virus encoding LacZ as a reporter gene was evaluated qualitatively and quantitatively in human skin xenografts. High transgene expression was detected in dermal fibroblasts transduced with VSV-G-, EboZ- or MuLV-pseudotyped HIV vector with tissue irregularities in the dermal compartments following repeated injections of EboZ- or LCMV-pseudotyped vectors. Four weeks after transduction, double-labeling immunofluorescence of beta-galactosidase and involucrin or integrin beta1 demonstrated that VSV-G-, EboZ- or MuLV-pseudotyped HIV vector effectively targeted quiescent epidermal stem cells which underwent terminal differentiation resulting in transgene expression in their progenies. Among the six different pseudotyped HIV-based vectors evaluated, VSV-G-pseudotyped vector was found to be the most efficient viral glycoprotein for cutaneous transduction as demonstrated by the highest level of beta-galactosidase expression and genome copy number evaluated by TaqMan PCR.

Gene-modified tissue-engineered skin: the next generation of skin substitutes

Tissue engineering combines the principles of cell biology, engineering and materials science to develop three-dimensional tissues to replace or restore tissue function. Tissue engineered skin is one of most advanced tissue constructs, yet it lacks several important functions including those provided by hair follicles, sebaceous glands, sweat glands and dendritic cells. Although the complexity of skin may be difficult to recapitulate entirely, new or improved functions can be provided by genetic modification of the cells that make up the tissues. Gene therapy can also be used in wound healing to promote tissue regeneration or prevent healing abnormalities such as formation of scars and keloids. Finally, gene-enhanced skin substitutes have great potential as cell-based devices to deliver therapeutics locally or systemically. Although significant progress has been made in the development of gene transfer technologies, several challenges have to be met before clinical application of genetically modified skin tissue. Engineering challenges include methods for improved efficiency and targeted gene delivery; efficient gene transfer to the stem cells that constantly regenerate the dynamic epidermal tissue; and development of novel biomaterials for controlled gene delivery. In addition, advances in regulatable vectors to achieve spatially and temporally controlled gene expression by physiological or exogenous signals may facilitate pharmacological administration of therapeutics through genetically engineered skin. Gene modified skin substitutes are also employed as biological models to understand tissue development or disease progression in a realistic three-dimensional context. In summary, gene therapy has the potential to generate the next generation of skin substitutes with enhanced capacity for treatment of burns, chronic wounds and even systemic diseases.

In search of the elusive epidermal stem cell

Recent studies are beginning to reveal that our basic concepts of epidermal stem cell biology may be based on somewhat tenuous ground. For example, it is often assumed that colony-forming cells represent epidermal stem cells, although this has not proved to be the case in hematopoietic cell lineages. In addition, although most stem cells are not cycling, label-retaining cells are used as a primary measure of epidermal stem cells. Moreover, the locations of stem cell niches in epidermis are still being debated. Finally, while putative stem cell markers abound, the most effective isolation procedure for stem cells has not been determined, and the relative efficiency of various methods of stem cell isolation remains unknown. With a functional assay for epidermal stem cells (analogous to the in-vivo competitive assay used for hematopoiesis), we appear to be in a better position to more clearly define the molecular signature of the true long-term repopulating cell/stem cell of the epidermis. Nonetheless, significant progress has been made in regenerative therapy of the epidermis for ulcer and burn treatment, and for corrective gene therapy for inherited skin diseases.

Microbubble-enhanced ultrasound for gene transfer into living skin equivalents

BACKGROUND

Gene transfer to skin is an attractive therapeutic approach because of the accessibility of the skin and the high rate of cure for many cutaneous diseases. However, safety concerns over viral vectors and the low efficiency of most non-viral gene transfer techniques have encumbered their clinical application for gene transfer. By contrast, efficient gene transfers into various cell types using microbubble-enhanced ultrasound has been reported.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to investigate whether ultrasound with microbubble enhancement allowed effective transfer of foreign genes into living skin equivalents (LSEs).

METHODS

Microbubbles and plasmid DNA encoding green fluorescent protein (GFP) were added to the dermal-epidermal junctions of LSEs, which were then exposed to ultrasound. The LSEs were harvested at different time points to investigate transgene expression using confocal laser microscopy. Transfected LSEs were also transplanted onto nude mice, and the in vivo transgene expression was observed.

RESULTS

From days 2 to 7 after transfection, most GFP-positive cells continued to migrate upward from the basal layer, while other GFP-positive cells lagged behind or remained in the basal layer on days 5 and 7. Transfection resulted in 20-30% GFP-positive cells. Multiple transfections further increased the percentage of transfected cells and resulted in multi-layer transgene expression. Grafts from the transfected LSEs survived on nude mice and continued to express GFP up to 2 weeks post-transplantation.

CONCLUSION

Gene transfer into LSE using ultrasound with microbubble enhancement is an effective alternative to viral and non-viral methods.

Efficient Gene Transfer to Human Epidermal Keratinocytes on Fibronectin: In Vitro Evidence for Transduction of Epidermal Stem Cells

The epidermis is an attractive target for gene therapy because it is easily accessible and has great potential as an ectopic site for protein delivery in vivo. Genetically modified keratinocytes can be expanded in culture and used to generate three-dimensional skin equivalents, which can deliver therapeutic proteins either locally or systemically for the treatment of wounds or systemic diseases. Here we present an optimum protocol that yields consistently high retroviral gene transfer on a substrate of recombinant fibronectin (rFN). Gene transfer on rFN depends strongly on virus concentration and the density of target cells. Interestingly, the kinetics of gene transfer varies depending upon the origin--mouse or human--of virus-producer cells. Most notably, long-term growth and clonogenic assays show that transduction on rFN promotes gene transfer to epidermal stem cells and prevents loss of clonogenic potential due to exposure of cells to retroviral supernatant. In contrast, the traditional protocol transduces mostly differentiated keratinocytes. We also show that skin equivalents prepared from genetically modified keratinocytes display high levels of transgene expression, mainly in the suprabasal layers. Our results are important for cutaneous gene therapy and for biological studies that require efficient and permanent genetic modification.

Molecular genetics of the ichthyoses

The ichthyoses are a large, clinically, genetically, and etiologically heterogeneous group of disorders of cornification due to abnormal differentiation and desquamation of the epidermis. Although they differ in clinical features, inheritance, and structural and biochemical abnormalities of the epidermis, they often pose a diagnostic challenge. For each of the 12 ichthyoses and related disorders described here, the major disease genes have been identified and genotype-phenotype correlation have begun to emerge. The molecular findings reveal the functional importance and interactions of many different epidermal proteins and metabolic pathways, including major structural proteins (keratins, loricrin), enzymes involved in lipid metabolism (transglutaminase 1, lipoxygenases, fatty aldehyde dehydrogenase, steroid sulfatase, glucocerebrosidase, Delta8-Delta7 sterol isomerase, 3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase), and protein catabolism (LEKTI), peroxisomal transport and processing (Peroxin 7 receptor, Phytanoyl-CoA hydroxylase) and DNA repair (proteins of the transcription repair complex). This review highlights the spectacular advances in the molecular genetics and biology of heritable ichthyoses over the past decade. It illustrates the power of molecular diagnostics for refining disease classification, providing prenatal diagnosis, improving genetic counseling, and clinical management.

Gene therapy and the skin

Significant progress has been made during the past decade in corrective gene therapy of the skin. This includes advances in vector technology, targeted gene expression, gene replacement, gene correction, and the availability of appropriate animal models for a variety of candidate diseases. While non-viral integration of large genes such as essential basement membrane proteins has been mastered, new challenges such as the control of immune responses lie ahead of the research community. Among the first skin diseases, patients with junctional epidermolysis bullosa (JEB) and xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) will enter clinical trials.

Gene transfer to epidermal stem cells: implications for tissue engineering

The skin is an attractive target for gene therapy because it is easily accessible and shows great potential as an ectopic site for protein delivery in vivo. Genetically modified epidermal cells can be used to engineer three-dimensional skin substitutes, which when transplanted can act as in vivo 'bioreactors' for delivery of therapeutic proteins locally or systemically. Although some gene transfer technologies have the potential to afford permanent genetic modification, differentiation and eventual loss of genetically modified cells from the epidermis results in temporary transgene expression. Therefore, to achieve stable long-term gene expression, it is critical to deliver genes to epidermal stem cells, which possess unlimited growth potential and self-renewal capacity. This review discusses the recent advances in epidermal stem cell isolation, gene transfer and engineering of skin substitutes. Recent efforts that employ gene therapy and tissue engineering for the treatment of genetic diseases, chronic wounds and systemic disorders, such as leptin deficiency or diabetes, are reviewed. Finally, the use of gene-modified tissue-engineered skin as a biological model for understanding tissue development, wound healing and epithelial carcinogenesis is also discussed.

RETRACTED: Progress and prospects of skin gene therapy: a ten year history

Significant progress has been made in corrective gene therapy of the skin in the last decade. This includes advances in vector technology, targeted gene expression, gene replacement, gene correction, and the availability of appropriate animal models for a variety of candidate diseases. While non-viral integration of large genes such as essential basement membrane proteins has been mastered, new challenges such as the control of immune responses lie ahead of the research community until skin gene therapy will become clinical reality. Among the first skin diseases patients with junctional epidermolysis bullosa and xeroderma pigmentosum have entered clinical trials.

Lentivirus-mediated gene transfer to human epidermis

For long-term cutaneous gene therapy, the therapeutic gene must be targeted to stem cells and be stably transmitted to and expressed in descendant cells. Retroviral vectors are highly efficient in gene transfer to human keratinocyte stem cells in culture; however, they cannot transduce quiescent stem cells in vivo. As lentiviral vectors (LVV) transduce non-proliferating cells, their ability to target human epidermal stem cells was evaluated. LVV were highly efficient in gene transfer to clonogenic keratinocytes in vitro. Despite higher transgene DNA content and comparable levels of transgene mRNA, levels of transgene product directed by lentivectors were 3-folds lower than that of retrovectors. When transduced keratinocytes were grafted onto mice, transgene expression persisted for at least 20 wk; however, transgene product was detected primarily in the uppermost layers of epidermis. Inclusion of an element that is known to facilitate nuclear export of intron-less transcripts, resulted in enhanced transgene expression in keratinocytes. In vivo transduction of xenografted human skin with these vectors resulted in efficient gene transfer to epidermal progenitor cells. These results demonstrate stem cell transduction by LVV and point out the utility of using these vectors for direct gene transfer to and sustained expression in human epidermis.

Sustainable correction of junctional epidermolysis bullosa via transposon-mediated nonviral gene transfer

Sustainable correction of severe human genetic disorders of self-renewing tissues, such as the blistering skin disease junctional epidermolysis bullosa (JEB), is facilitated by stable genomic integration of therapeutic genes into somatic tissue stem cells. While integrating viral vectors can achieve this, they suffer from logistical and biosafety concerns. To circumvent these limitations, we used the Sleeping Beauty transposable element to integrate the LAMB3 cDNA into genomes of epidermal holoclones from six unrelated JEB patients. These cells regenerate human JEB skin that is normalized at the level of laminin 5 protein expression, hemidesmosome formation and blistering. Transposon-mediated gene delivery therefore affords an opportunity for stable gene delivery in JEB and other human diseases.

Suppression of the immune response against exogenous desmoglein 3 in desmoglein 3 knockout mice: an implication for gene therapy

Gene therapies for recessive genetic diseases may provoke unwanted immune responses against the introduced gene product because patients, especially those with null mutation of a certain protein, have no tolerance for the protein of interest. This study used desmoglein 3 knockout (Dsg3-/-) mice as a disease model for a genetic defect in DSG3, to investigate whether nonviral gene therapy induces an immune response against Dsg3 and whether the reaction against Dsg3 can be prevented. When mouse Dsg3 cDNA was injected in the skin of Dsg3-/- mice, 50% of treated Dsg3-/- mice developed anti-Dsg3 IgG, which can bind native Dsg3 in vivo. To prevent this response, we used an anti-CD40L monoclonal antibody, MR1, which blocks the costimulatory interaction between CD40 and CD40L. To evaluate the effect of MR1, we grafted Dsg3+/+skin on Dsg3-/- mice, to mimic stable gene transfer of Dsg3. After skin grafting, all the recipient Dsg3-/- mice were treated with either MR1 (n=8) or control hamster IgG (n=8). All of the control IgG-treated mice developed circulating anti-Dsg3 IgG about 2 wk after grafting, and IgG deposition was observed on the surfaces of keratinocytes in the grafted Dsg3+/+skin. Such anti-Dsg3 IgG production was significantly prevented, however, when the recipient mice were treated with MR1. These findings suggested that gene therapies for recessive diseases may provoke an immune response against the transgene product, and that the CD40-CD40L interaction might be a reasonable target for effective prevention of such undesirable immune responses, leading, in turn, to a successful gene therapy.

Injection of genetically engineered fibroblasts corrects regenerated human epidermolysis bullosa skin tissue

Current therapeutic strategies for genetic skin disorders rely on the complex process of grafting genetically engineered tissue to recipient wound beds. Because fibroblasts synthesize and secrete extracellular matrix, we explored their utility in recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa (RDEB), a blistering disease due to defective extracellular type VII collagen. Intradermal injection of RDEB fibroblasts overexpressing type VII collagen into intact RDEB skin stably restored correctly localized type VII collagen expression in vivo and normalized hallmark RDEB disease features, including subepidermal blistering and anchoring fibril defects. This article was published online in advance of the print edition. The date of publication is available from the JCI website, http://www.jci.org.

The molecular genetics of the genodermatoses: progress to date and future directions

The Human Genome Mapping Project and allied rapid advances in genetic technology over the past decade have facilitated accurate association of allelic variations in several genes with specific skin phenotypes. Currently the genetic bases of the majority of the more common genodermatoses have been elucidated. In scientific terms this work has been extraordinarily successful and has yielded many new biological insights. These advances, although exciting, have yet to be translated into direct benefit for patients with these diseases. Genetic counselling has been greatly aided by gene identification, by the better understanding of genotype-phenotype correlation and by the disclosure of unexpected genetic mechanisms in some families. Knowledge of the molecular basis of these disorders has also been vital in enabling DNA-based prenatal diagnosis in several conditions and DNA-based preimplantation diagnosis has been used in a selected few. While this successful period of gene mapping is now nearing completion, progress towards the next goal, that of developing therapeutic strategies based on the knowledge of these underlying genetic mechanisms, has proven frustratingly slow. Despite the ready access to the skin compared with solid internal organs, the challenges of cutaneous gene therapy are legion and many technical issues need to be surmounted to enable gene replacement or modification of gene expression to have a useful role in these disorders. In this article we make a comprehensive review of progress to date in gene identification, genotype-phenotype correlation, prenatal diagnosis and cutaneous gene therapy, and we examine future directions for research in this field.

Genetic reversion of inherited skin disorders

Human epidermis is a squamous stratified epithelium whose integrity relies on balanced processes of cell attachment, proliferation, and differentiation. In monogenic skin dermatoses, such as mecano-bullous diseases, or DNA repair deficiencies such as the xeroderma pigmentosum (XP), alterations of skin integrity may have devastating consequences as illustrated by the extremely high epidermal cancer proneness of XP patients. The lack of efficient pharmacological treatments, the easy accessibility of skin, and the possibility of long term culture and genetic manipulations ex vivo of epidermal keratinocytes, have encouraged approaches toward gene transfer and skin therapy prospects. We review here some of the human genetic disorders that exhibit major traits in skin, as well as requirements and difficulties inherent to approaches aimed at stable phenotypic correction.

Retroviral gene transfer to human epidermal keratinocytes correlates with integrin expression and is significantly enhanced on fibronectin

Human epidermal keratinocytes are an important target for gene therapy because they can be easily expanded in culture and used to generate skin substitutes for the treatment of wounds, genetic diseases of the skin, and for delivery of proteins to the systemic circulation. Although retroviral transduction results in permanent genetic modification, differentiation and loss of transduced cells from the epidermis results in temporary transgene expression. To ensure permanent genetic modification, epidermal stem cells must be transduced with high efficiency. We evaluated gene transfer on two different substrates and found that the efficiency of gene transfer is substantially higher on a substrate of recombinant fibronectin (FN), when compared to tissue culture plastic (TCP). The rate of retroviral transduction on FN is four times faster than transduction on tissue culture plates and is independent of polybrene (PB). The transduction efficiency correlates with the levels of expression of integrin subunits alpha5, alpha2, and beta1, which have been shown to correlate with stem cell phenotype. Notably, cells that adhere rapidly to FN are transduced more efficiently than slowly adherent cells. In addition, integrin-blocking antibodies decrease the efficiency of gene transfer in a dose-dependent manner. Our results suggest that FN may enhance retroviral gene transfer to the least differentiated cells, thereby increasing the potential of genetically modified keratinocytes to treat short- and long-term disease states.

Stable nonviral genetic correction of inherited human skin disease

Current gene-transfer technologies display limitations in achieving effective gene delivery. Among these limitations are difficulties in stably integrating large corrective sequences into the genomes of long-lived progenitor-cell populations. Current larger-capacity viral vectors suffer from biosafety concerns, whereas plasmid-based approaches have poor efficiency of stable gene transfer. These barriers hinder genetic correction of many severe inherited human diseases, such as the blistering skin disorder recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa (RDEB), caused by mutations in the large COL7A1 gene. To circumvent these barriers, we used the phi C31 bacteriophage integrase, which stably integrates large DNA sequences containing a specific 285-base-pair attB sequence into genomic 'pseudo-attP sites'. phi C31 integrase-based gene transfer stably integrated the COL7A1 cDNA into genomes of primary epidermal progenitor cells from four unrelated RDEB patients. Skin regenerated using these cells displayed stable correction of hallmark RDEB disease features, including Type VII collagen protein expression, anchoring fibril formation and dermal-epidermal cohesion. These findings establish a practical approach to nonviral genetic correction of severe human genetic disorders requiring stable genomic integration of large DNA sequences.

Animal models for skin blistering conditions: absence of laminin 5 causes hereditary junctional mechanobullous disease in the Belgian horse

Recent achievements in the genetic correction of keratinocytes isolated from patients with junctional epidermolysis bullosa have paved the way to a gene therapy approach for the disease. Because gene therapy protocols require preclinical validation in animals, we have characterized spontaneous animal models of junctional epidermolysis bullosa. In this study we have elucidated the genetic basis of the hereditary junctional mechanobullous disease in the Belgian horse, a condition characterized by blistering of the skin and mouth epithelia, and exungulation (loss of the hoof). Immunofluorescence analysis associated the condition to the absent expression of the gamma2 chain of laminin 5 and designated Lamc2 as the candidate gene. Comparative analysis of the nucleotide sequence of the full-length gamma2 cDNA isolated by reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction amplification of total RNA purified from the epithelium of a junctional epidermolysis bullosa foal and a healthy control disclosed a homozygous basepair insertion (1368insC) in the affected animal. Mutation 1368insC results in a downstream premature termination codon and is predicted to cause absent expression of the laminin gamma2 polypeptide. Our results also show that: (i) the horse junctional epidermolysis bullosa genetically corresponds to the severe Herlitz form of junctional epidermolysis bullosa in man; (ii) the amino acid sequence and structure of the horse laminin gamma2 chain are virtually identical to the human counterpart; (iii) the moderate eruption of skin blisters in the affected animals with respect to the human Herlitz junctional epidermolysis bullosa patients correlates with the protection provided by hair. Our observations suggest that the affected foals are a convenient source of epithelial cells from tissues that cannot be obtained from human junctional epidermolysis bullosa patients, and imply that hairless strains of animals with recessive skin disorders would be the best models for in vivo gene therapy approaches to skin blistering diseases.

Cutaneous gene transfer for skin and systemic diseases

Recent progress in molecular genetics has illuminated the basis for a wide variety of inherited and acquired diseases. Gene therapy offers an attractive therapeutic approach capitalizing upon these new mechanistic insights. The skin is a uniquely attractive tissue site for development of new genetic therapeutic approaches both for its accessibility as well as for the large number of diseases that are amenable in principle to cutaneous gene transfer. Amongst these opportunities are primary monogenic skin diseases, chronic wounds and systemic disorders characterized by low or absent levels of circulating polypeptides. For cutaneous gene therapy to be effective, however, significant progress is required in a number of domains. Recent advances in vector design, administration, immune modulation, and regulation of gene expression have brought the field much nearer to clinical utility.

The impact of gene therapy on dentistry: a revisiting after six years

BACKGROUND

Gene therapy is an emerging field of biomedicine that has commanded considerable scientific and popular attention. The procedure involves the transfer of genes to patients for clinical benefit. Transferred genes can b e used for either reparative or pharmacological purposes.

OVERVIEW

In 1995, the first author and a colleague described the potential impact of gene therapy on dentistry, on the basis of initial studies of gene transfer applications to salivary glands, keratinocytes and cancer cells. Their conclusion was that gene therapy would have a significant impact on the nature of dental practice within 20 years. In this article, the authors consider research progress since 1995 and reexamine the earlier conclusion.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

In the past six years, remarkable progress has been made in the field of gene therapy, including seven areas relevant to dental practice: bone repair, salivary glands, autoimmune disease, pain, DNA vaccinations, keratinocytes and cancer. While considerable problems remain, thus impeding the routine clinical use of gene transfer, gene therapy will have a pervasive and significant impact on areas of dental practice that are based in biological science. By 2015, this will translate into practitioners' having a wide range of novel biological treatment options for their patients.

Sustainable systemic delivery via a single injection of lentivirus into human skin tissue

The skin offers a tissue site accessible for delivery of gene-based therapeutics. To develop the capability for sustained systemic polypeptide delivery via cutaneous gene transfer, we generated and injected pseudotyped HIV-1 lentiviral vectors intradermally at a range of doses into human skin grafted on immune-deficient mice. Unlike Moloney murine leukemia virus (MLV)-based retrovectors, which failed to achieve detectable cutaneous gene transfer by this approach, lentivectors effectively targeted all major cell types within human skin tissue, including fibroblasts, endothelial cells, keratinocytes, and macrophages. After a single injection, lentivectors encoding human erythropoietin (EPO) produced dose-dependent increases in serum human EPO levels and hematocrit that increased rapidly within one month and remained stable subsequently. Delivered gene expression was confined locally at the injection site. Excision of engineered skin led to rapid and complete loss of human EPO in the bloodstream, confirming that systemic EPO delivery was entirely due to lentiviral targeting of cells within skin rather than via spread of the injected vector to visceral tissues. These findings indicate that the skin can sustain dosed systemic delivery of therapeutic polypeptides via direct lentivector injection and thus provide an accessible and reversible approach for gene-based delivery to the bloodstream.

In vivo restoration of laminin 5 beta 3 expression and function in junctional epidermolysis bullosa

The blistering disorder, lethal junctional epidermolysis bullosa (JEB), can result from mutations in the LAMB3 gene, which encodes laminin 5 beta3 (beta3). Appropriate expression of LAMbeta3 in JEB skin tissue could potentially ameliorate the symptoms of the underlying disease. To explore the utility of this therapeutic approach, primary keratinocytes from six unrelated JEB patients were transduced with a retroviral vector encoding beta3 and used to regenerate human skin on severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice. Tissue regenerated from beta3-transduced JEB keratinocytes produced phenotypically normal skin characterized by sustained beta3 expression and the formation of hemidesmosomes. Additionally, beta3 gene transfer corrected the distribution of a number of important basement membrane zone proteins including BPAG2, integrins beta4/beta1, and laminins alpha3/gamma2. Skin produced from beta3-negative (beta3[-]) JEB cells mimicked the hallmarks of the disease state and did not exhibit any of the aforementioned traits. Therefore, by effecting therapeutic gene transfer to beta3-deficient primary keratinocytes, it is possible to produce healthy, normal skin tissue in vivo. These data support the utility of gene therapy for JEB and highlight the potential for gene delivery in the treatment of human genetic skin disease.

Cutaneous gene transfer and therapy: the present and the future

The easy accessibility of the skin as a therapeutic target provides an exciting potential for this organ for the development of gene therapy protocols for cutaneous diseases and a variety of metabolic disorders. Thus far, full phenotypic reversion of a diseased phenotype has been achieved in vivo for junctional epidermolysis bullosa and X-linked or lamellar ichthyosis and in vitro for xeroderma pigmentosum. These recessive skin diseases are characterized by skin blistering, abnormalities in epidermal differentiation and increased development of skin cancers, respectively. Corrective gene delivery at both molecular and functional levels was achieved by transduction of cultured skin cells using retroviral vectors carrying the specific curative cDNA. These positive results should prompt clinical trials based on transplantation of artificial epithelia reconstructed ex vivo using genetically modified keratinocytes. Promising results have also been obtained in phenotypic reversion of cells isolated from patients suffering from a number of metabolic diseases such as gyrate atrophy, familial hypercholesterolemia or phenylketonuria. In these diseases transplantation of autologous artificial epithelia expressing the transgenes of interest or direct transfer of the DNA to the skin represents a potential therapeutic approach for the systemic delivery of active molecules. Successful cutaneous gene therapy trials, however, require development of protocols for efficient gene transfer to epidermal stem cells, and information about the host immune response to the recombinant polypeptides produced by the implanted keratinocytes. The availability of spontaneous animal models for genodermatoses will validate the gene therapy approach in preclinical trials.

Genetic correction of inherited epidermal disorders

Genetic correction of monogenic human skin disorders represents a potentially effective molecular therapy for severe diseases in which current therapy is only palliative. The stratified epithelium of the epidermis represents the tissue location with the largest number of genetic skin diseases yet characterized. Specific requirements of successful gene delivery in this setting include correct targeting within tissue, durability, and a lack of immunogenecity. Progress toward this goal has advanced from identification of disease genes to reintroduction of wild-type genes to patient cell lines and primary cells in vitro. This initial work has been extended to gene-based correction of diseased tissue regenerated in vivo in the form of human patient skin xenografts on immune-deficient mice. Efforts in this human tissue model have laid the foundation for future efforts to extend this progress toward ex vivo cutaneous gene therapy trials in humans.

Advances in skin gene therapy

Specific anatomical and biological properties make the skin a very interesting target organ for gene therapy approaches. Different cell types of the epidermis, such as keratinocytes, melanocytes, or dendritic cells, can be genetically modified to treat a broad spectrum of diseases, including genetically inherited skin disorders, tumour diseases, metabolic disorders and infectious diseases. The easy accessibility of skin suggests that different methods for gene delivery can be pursued, depending on the desired application. The approach used to deliver DNA to the skin will influence not only the efficiency of DNA delivery, but also the level and duration of transgene expression. Furthermore, the desired biological effect will also influence the decision of which gene transfer method is the best choice. Among the current challenges of cutaneous gene therapy are: optimising the efficiency of direct in vivo gene delivery; targeting specific epidermal cells, including keratinocyte stem cells; achieving sustained gene expression and regulating gene expression in vivo. This review summarises recent advances in the field of skin gene therapy and evaluates possible strategies to overcome obstacles and achieve successful clinical applications of skin gene therapy.

Development and characterization of a recombinant truncated type VII collagen "minigene". Implication for gene therapy of dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa

Dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa (DEB) is an inherited mechano-bullous disorder of skin caused by mutations in the type VII collagen gene. The lack of therapy for DEB provides an impetus to develop gene therapy strategies. However, the full-length 9-kilobase type VII collagen cDNA exceeds the cloning capacity of current viral delivery vectors. In this study, we produced a recombinant type VII minicollagen containing the intact noncollagenous domains, NC1 and NC2, and part of the central collagenous domain using stably transfected human 293 cell clones and purified large quantities of the recombinant minicollagen VII from culture media. Minicollagen VII was secreted as correctly-folded, disulfide-bonded, helical trimers resistant to protease degradation. Purified minicollagen VII bound to fibronectin, laminin-5, type I collagen, and type IV collagen. Furthermore, retroviral-mediated transduction of the minigene construct into DEB keratinocytes (in which type VII collagen was absent) resulted in persistent synthesis and secretion of a 230-kDa recombinant minicollagen VII. In comparison with parent DEB keratinocytes, the gene-corrected DEB keratinocytes demonstrated enhanced cell-substratum adhesion, increased proliferative potential, and reduced cell motility, features that reversed the DEB phenotype toward normal. We conclude that the use of the minicollagen VII may provide a strategy to correct the cellular manifestations of gene defects in DEB.

Gene therapy and dermatology: more than just skin deep

BACKGROUND

Recent advances in the molecular characterization of dermatologic disease have substantively augmented the understanding of the pathogenetic processes underlying disorders of the skin. This new knowledge coupled with progress in gene delivery technologies has paved the way for introducing cutaneous gene therapy into the dermatologic therapeutic armamentorium.

OBJECTIVE

This review article includes an overview of the current strategies for delivery of gene therapy with an emphasis on the potential role of cutaneous gene delivery in the treatment of skin and systemic diseases.

CONCLUSIONS

Accessibility for gene delivery, clinical evaluation, and topical modulation of gene expression render the skin a very attractive tissue for therapeutic gene delivery. However, there are several key hurdles to be overcome before cutaneous gene therapy becomes a viable clinical option. These include difficulties in inducing sustained expression of the desired gene in vivo, the challenge of targeting genes to long-lived stem cells, and the difficulty in achieving specific and uniform transfer to different compartments of the skin. However, these problems are not insurmountable and will likely be resolved in conjunction with ongoing advances in delineating gene expression profiles and other molecular properties of the skin, strategies for stem cell isolation, and improved approaches to regulating gene delivery and expression. These advances should create the framework for translating the enormous potential of cutaneous gene therapy into the clinical arena and, thereby, substantively improving the management of both cutaneous and systemic disease.

BP180 gene delivery in junctional epidermolysis bullosa

Epidermolysis bullosa (EB) comprises a family of inherited blistering skin diseases for which current therapy is only palliative. Junctional EB (JEB) involves dissociation of the dermal-epidermal junction and results from mutations in a number of genes that encode vital structural proteins, including BP180 (type XVII collagen/BPAG2). In order to develop a model of corrective gene delivery for JEB, we produced a retroviral expression vector for wild-type human BP180 and used it to restore BP180 protein expression to primary keratinocytes from BP180-negative patients with generalized atrophic JEB. Restoration of full-length BP180 protein expression was associated with adhesion parameter normalization of primary JEB keratinocytes in vitro. These cells were then used to regenerate human skin on immune-deficient mice. BP180 gene-transduced tissue demonstrated restoration of BP180 gene expression at the dermal-epidermal junction in vivo while untransduced regenerated JEB skin entirely lacked BP180 expression. These findings provide a basis for future efforts to achieve gene delivery in human EB skin tissue.