A Physical Model Approach to Gecko Adhesion Opportunity and Constraint: How Rough Could It Be?

Get to the point: Claw morphology impacts frictional interactions on rough substrates

Claws are a common anatomical feature among limbed amniotes and contribute to a variety of functions including prey capture, locomotion, and attachment. Previous studies of both avian and non-avian reptiles have found correlations between habitat use and claw morphology, suggesting that variation in claw shape permits effective functioning in different microhabitats. How, or if, claw morphology influences attachment performance, particularly in isolation from the rest of the digit, has received little attention. To examine the effects of claw shape on frictional interactions, we isolated the claws of preserved specimens of Cuban knight anoles (Anolis equestris), quantified variation in claw morphology via geometric morphometrics, and measured friction on four different substrates that varied in surface roughness. We found that multiple aspects of claw shape influence frictional interactions, but only on substrates for which asperities are large enough to permit mechanical interlocking with the claw. On such substrates, the diameter of the claw's tip is the most important predictor of friction, with narrower claw tips inducing greater frictional interactions than wider ones. We also found that claw curvature, length, and depth influence friction, but that these relationships depend on the substrate's surface roughness. Our findings suggest that although claw shape plays a critical role in the effective clinging ability of lizards, its relative importance is dependent upon the substrate. Description of mechanical function, as well as ecological function, is critical for a holistic understanding of claw shape variation.

Gecko-Inspired Adhesive Mechanisms and Adhesives for Robots—A Review

Small living organisms such as lizards possess naturally built functional surface textures that enable them to walk or climb on versatile surface topographies. Bio-mimicking the surface characteristics of these geckos has enormous potential to improve the accessibility of modern robotics. Therefore, gecko-inspired adhesives have significant industrial applications, including robotic endoscopy, bio-medical cleaning, medical bandage tapes, rock climbing adhesives, tissue adhesives, etc. As a result, synthetic adhesives have been developed by researchers, in addition to dry fibrillary adhesives, elastomeric adhesives, electrostatic adhesives, and thermoplastic adhesives. All these adhesives represent significant contributions towards robotic grippers and gloves, depending on the nature of the application. However, these adhesives often exhibit limitations in the form of fouling, wear, and tear, which restrict their functionalities and load-carrying capabilities in the natural environment. Therefore, it is essential to summarize the state of the art attributes of contemporary studies to extend the ongoing work in this field. This review summarizes different adhesion mechanisms involving gecko-inspired adhesives and attempts to explain the parameters and limitations which have impacts on adhesion. Additionally, different novel adhesive fabrication techniques such as replica molding, 3D direct laser writing, dip transfer processing, fused deposition modeling, and digital light processing are encapsulated.

Parameters of the adhesive setae and setal fields of the Jamaican radiation of anoles (Dactyloidae: Anolis): potential for ecomorphology at the microscopic scale

The subdigital adhesive pads of Caribbean Anolis lizards are considered to be a key innovation that permits occupation of novel ecological niches. Although previous work has demonstrated that subdigital pad morphology and performance vary with habitat use, such investigations have only considered the macroscale aspects of these structures (e.g. pad area). The morphological agents of attachment, however, are arrays of hair-like fibres (setae) that terminate in an expanded tip (spatula) and have not been examined in a similar manner. Here we examine the setal morphology and setal field configuration of ecologically distinct species of the monophyletic Jamaican Anolis radiation from a functional and ecological perspective. We find that anoles occupying the highest perches possess greater setal densities and smaller spatulae than those exploiting lower perches. This finding is consistent with the concept of contact splitting, whereby subdivision of an adhesive area into smaller and more densely packed fibres results in an increase in adhesive performance. Micromorphological evidence also suggests that the biomechanics of adhesive locomotion may vary between Anolis ecomorphs. Our findings indicate that, in a similar fashion to macroscale features of the subdigital pad, its microstructure may vary in relation to performance and habitat use in Caribbean Anolis.

An investigation of gecko attachment on wet and rough substrates leads to the application of surface roughness power spectral density analysis

The roughness and wettability of surfaces exploited by free-ranging geckos can be highly variable and attachment to these substrates is context dependent (e.g., presence or absence of surface water). Although previous studies focus on the effect of these variables on attachment independently, geckos encounter a variety of conditions in their natural environment simultaneously. Here, we measured maximum shear load of geckos in air and when their toes were submerged underwater on substrates that varied in both surface roughness and wettability. Gecko attachment was greater in water than in air on smooth and rough hydrophobic substrates, and attachment to rough hydrophilic substrates did not differ when tested in air or water. Attachment varied considerably with surface roughness and characterization revealed that routine measurements of root mean square height can misrepresent the complexity of roughness, especially when measured with single instruments. We used surface roughness power spectra to characterize substrate surface roughness and examined the relationship between gecko attachment performance across the power spectra. This comparison suggests that roughness wavelengths less than 70 nm predominantly dictate gecko attachment. This study highlights the complexity of attachment in natural conditions and the need for comprehensive surface characterization when studying biological adhesive system performance.

Incline-dependent adjustments of toes in geckos inspire functional strategies for biomimetic manipulators

Geckos show versatility by rapidly maneuvering on diverse complex terrain because they benefit from their distributed, setae-covered toes and thus have the ability to generate reliable and adaptive attachment. Significant attention has been paid to their adhesive microstructures (setae), but the effectiveness of the gecko's adaptive attachment at the level of toes and feet remains unclear. In order to better understand the geckos' attachment, we first focused on the deployment of toes while challenging geckos to locomote on varying inclines. When the slope angle was less than 30°, their feet mainly interacted with the substrate using the bases of the toes and generated anisotropic frictional forces. As the slope angle increased to 90°, the participation of the toe bases was reduced. Instead, the setae contribution increased for the middle three toes of the front feet and for the first three toes of the hind feet. As the incline changed from vertical to inverted, the adhesive contribution of the toes of the front feet became more equal, whereas the effective adhesion contact of the hind feet gradually shifted to the toes oriented rearwards. Second, a mathematical model was established and then suggested the potential advantages of distributed control among the toes to regulate foot force. Finally, a physical foot model containing five compliant, adjustable toes was constructed and validated the discoveries with regard to the animals. Using the gecko toes' control strategies, the artificial foot demonstrated diverse behavior regulating attachment forces. The success of the foot prototype not only tested our understanding of the mechanism of biological attachment, but also provided a demonstration for the design and control of gecko-inspired attachment devices, grippers and other manipulators.

An insect-scale robot reveals the effects of different body dynamics regimes during open-loop running in feature-laden terrain

The transition from the lab to natural environments is an archetypal challenge in robotics. While larger robots can manage complex limb-ground interactions using sensing and control, such strategies are difficult to implement on small platforms where space and power are limited. The Harvard Ambulatory Microrobot (HAMR) is an insect-scale quadruped capable of effective open-loop running on featureless, hard substrates. Inspired by the predominantly feedforward strategy of rapidly-running cockroaches on uneven terrain (Sponberg, 2007), we used HAMR to explore open-loop running on two 3D printed heterogeneous terrains generated using fractional Brownian motion. The 'pocked' terrain had foot-scale features throughout while the 'jagged' terrain features increased in height in the direction of travel. We measured the performance of trot and pronk gaits while varying limb amplitude and stride frequency. The frequencies tested encompassed different dynamics regimes: body resonance (10-25 Hz) and kinematic running (30-40 Hz), with dynamics typical of biological running and walking, respectively, and limb-transmission resonance (45-60 Hz). On the featureless and pocked terrains, low mechanical cost-of-transport (mCoT) kinematic running combinations performed best without systematic differences between trot and pronk; indicating that if terrain features are not too tall, a robot can transition from homo-to heterogeneous environments in open-loop. Pronk bypassed taller features than trot on the jagged terrain, and higher mCoT, lower frequency running was more often effective. While increasing input power to the robot improved performance in general, lower frequency pronking on jagged terrain allowed the robot to bypass taller features compared with the same input power at higher frequencies. This was correlated with the increased variation in center-of-mass orientation occurring at frequencies near body resonance. This study established that appropriate choice of robot dynamics, as mediated by gait, frequency, and limb amplitude, can expand the terrains accessible to microrobots without the addition of sensing or closed-loop control.

Size, shape and orientation of macro-sized substrate protrusions affect the toe and foot adhesion of geckos

Geckos are excellent climbers using compliant, hierarchically arranged adhesive toes to negotiate diverse terrains varying in roughness at multiple size scales. Here, we complement advancements at smaller size scales with measurements at the macro scale. We studied the attachment of a single toe and whole foot of geckos on macroscale rough substrates by pulling them along, across and off smooth rods and spheres mimicking different geometric protrusions of substrates. When we pulled a single toe along rods, the force increased with the rod diameter, whereas the attachment force of dragging toes across rods increased from about 60% on small diameter rods relative to a flat surface to ∼100% on larger diameter rods, but showed no further increase as rod diameter doubled. Toe force also increased as the pulling changed from along-rod loading to across-rod loading. When toes were pulled off spheres, the force increased with increasing sphere diameter as observed for along-rod pulling. For feet with separated toes, attachment on spheres was stronger than that on rods with the same diameter. Attachment force of a foot decreased as rod and sphere size increased but remained sufficient to support the body weight of geckos. These results provide a bridge to the macroscale roughness seen in nature by revealing the importance of the dimension, shape and orientation of macroscale substrate features for compliant toe and foot function of geckos. Our data not only enhance our understanding of geckos' environmental adaptive adhesion but can also provide inspiration for novel robot feet in development.

Tokay geckos (Gekkonidae: Gekko gecko) preferentially use substrates that elicit maximal adhesive performance

Gecko substrate use is likely influenced by adhesive performance, yet few studies have demonstrated this empirically. Herein, we examined the substrate use, adhesive performance and vertical clinging behaviour of Gekko gecko in captivity to investigate whether adhesive performance influences patterns of substrate use. We found that geckos were observed significantly more often on the substrate (glass) that elicited maximal adhesive performance relative to its availability within our experimental enclosures, indicating that geckos preferentially use substrates on which their adhesive performance is maximal. Our work here provides additional, yet crucial data establishing connections between adhesive performance and patterns of substrate use in captivity, suggesting the hypothesis that substrate preferences of free-ranging geckos should be correlated with adhesive performance. Clearly, further experimental and field research is necessary to test this hypothesis and identify other parameters that individually and/or collectively influence the habitat use of free-ranging geckos.

Role of multiple, adjustable toes in distributed control shown by sideways wall-running in geckos

Remarkable progress has been made characterizing one of nature's most integrated, hierarchical structures--the fibrillar adhesive system of geckos. Nonetheless, we lack an understanding of how multiple toes coordinate to facilitate geckos' acrobatic locomotion. Here, we tested the control function of gecko toes by running them on vertical substrates varying in orientation, friction and roughness. Sideways wall-running geckos realigned the toes of their top feet upward to resist gravity. Toe contact area was not compromised, but redistributed. Geckos aligned all toes upward to resist slipping when encountering low-friction patches during sideways wall-running. Negotiation of intermittent slippery strips showed an increased contribution of particular toes to compensate for toes that lost adhesion. Increasing substrate roughness using discrete rods perpendicular to sideways locomotion resulted in geckos bending and/or rotating toes to conform to and even grasp the rods, with potential forces more than five times body weight. Geckos increase their effectiveness of manoeuvrability in demanding environments by taking advantage of the distributed control afforded by multiple toes. Our findings provide insight on biological attachment and offer inspiration to advance gecko-inspired robotics and other biomimetic applications.

Attachment Beyond the Adhesive System: The Contribution of Claws to Gecko Clinging and Locomotion

Attachment is imperative for many biological functions, such as holding position and climbing, but can be challenged by natural conditions. Adhesive toe pads and claws have evolved in multiple terrestrial lineages as important dynamic attachment mechanisms, and some clades (e.g., geckos) exhibit both features. The functional relationship of these features that comprise a complex attachment system is not well-understood, particularly within lizards (i.e., if pads and claws are redundant or multifunctional). Geckos exhibit highly adept frictional adhesive toe pads that continue to fuel biological inquiry and inspiration. However, gecko claws (the ancestral lizard clinging condition) have received little attention in terms of their functional or evolutionary significance. We assessed claw function in Thecadactylus rapicauda using assays of clinging performance and locomotor trials on different surfaces (artificial and natural) and inclines with claws intact, then partially removed. Area root mean square height (Sq), a metric of 3D surface roughness, was later quantified for all test surfaces, including acrylic, sandpaper, and two types of leaves (smooth and hairy). Maximum clinging force significantly declined on all non-acrylic surfaces after claw removal, indicating a substantial contribution to static clinging on rough and soft surfaces. With and without claws, clinging force exhibited a negative relationship with Sq. However, claw removal had relatively little impact on locomotor function on surfaces of different roughness at low inclines (≤30°). High static and dynamic safety factor estimates support these observations and demonstrate the species’ robust frictional adhesive system. However, maximum station-holding capacity significantly declined on the rough test surface after partial claw removal, showing that geckos rely on their claws to maintain purchase on rough, steeply inclined surfaces. Our results point to a context-dependent complex attachment system within geckos, in which pads dominate on relatively smooth surfaces and claws on relatively rough surfaces, but also that these features function redundantly, possibly synergistically, on surfaces that allow attachment of both the setae and the claw (as in some insects). Our study provides important novel perspectives on gecko attachment, which we hope will spur future functional studies, new evolutionary hypotheses, and biomimetic innovation, along with collaboration and integration of perspectives across disciplines.

The Integrative Biology of Gecko Adhesion: Historical Review, Current Understanding, and Grand Challenges

Geckos are remarkable in their ability to reversibly adhere to smooth vertical, and even inverted surfaces. However, unraveling the precise mechanisms by which geckos do this has been a long process, involving various approaches over the last two centuries. Our understanding of the principles by which gecko adhesion operates has advanced rapidly over the past 20 years and, with this knowledge, material scientists have attempted to mimic the system to create artificial adhesives. From a biological perspective, recent studies have examined the diversity in morphology, performance, and real-world use of the adhesive apparatus. However, the lack of multidisciplinarity is likely a key roadblock to gaining new insights. Our goals in this paper are to 1) present a historical review of gecko adhesion research, 2) discuss the mechanisms and morphology of the adhesive apparatus, 3) discuss the origin and performance of the system in real-world contexts, 4) discuss advancement in bio-inspired design, and 5) present grand challenges in gecko adhesion research. To continue to improve our understanding, and to more effectively employ the principles of gecko adhesion for human applications, greater intensity and scope of interdisciplinary research are necessary.