Patient grouping for dose surveys and establishment of diagnostic reference levels in paediatric computed tomography

Establishment of local diagnostic reference levels for paediatric abdominal-pelvis and Chest-abdominal-pelvis computed tomography in Morocco: suggests the need for improved optimization efforts

The purpose of the current study was to derive the local diagnostic reference levels (LDRLs) for paediatric abdominal-pelvis (AP) and chest-abdominal-pelvis (CAP) computed tomography in Morocco. The data were gathered retrospectively from two hospitals for 6 months. The LDRLs were defined by volume CT dose index (CTDIvol), dose-length product (DLP) per sequence, DLP per procedure and size-specific dose estimates (SSDE). The SSDE assessment was based on the effective diameters of patients scanned. A total of 630 CT examinations were collected involving 324 AP and 306 CAP scans. The proposed LDRLs for AP, in terms of CTDIvol (mGy), were 6.9, 8.5, 8.5 and 8.5 for < 1, 1 to < 5, 5 to < 10 and 10 to < 15 y age groups, respectively. In terms of DLP (mGy.cm) per procedure, they were 436.3, 534.5, 687.9 and 961.7. In terms of SSDE (mGy), thet were 16.73, 16.83, 17.5 and 15.8 for < 1, 1 to < 5, 5 to < 10 and 10 to < 15 y, respectively. The corresponding LDRLs for CAP, in terms of CTDIvol (mGy), were 7.3, 7.3, 7.3 and 10.35. In terms of DLP (mGy.cm) per procedure, they were 531, 622.5, 705 and 936. In terms of SSDE (mGy), they were 16.22, 15.05, 14.47 and 15.2, respectively, for the four age groups. The derived dose levels were mostly higher than those found in other studies, which demonstrates the need for dose optimization and paediatric protocol standardization as well as the timeliness of the intent to establish not only local DRLs but national ones in the near future.

Sample Size and Estimation of Standard Radiation Doses for Pediatric Brain CT

Estimation of the standard radiation dose at each imaging facility is required for radiation dose management, including establishment and utilization of the diagnostic reference levels. We investigated methods to estimate the standard dose for pediatric brain computed tomography (CT) using a small number of data. From 980 pediatric brain CT examinations, 25, 50, and 100 examinations were randomly extracted to create small, medium, and large datasets, respectively. The standard dose was estimated by applying grouping and curve-fitting methods for 20 datasets of each sample size. For the grouping method, data were divided into groups according to age or body weight, and the standard dose was defined as a median value in each group. For the curve-fitting methods, logarithmic, power, and bilinear functions were fitted to plots of radiation dose against age or weight, and the standard dose was calculated at the designated age or weight using the derived equation. When the sample size was smaller, the random variations of the estimated standard dose were larger. Better estimation of the standard dose was achieved with the curve-fitting methods than with the grouping method. Power fitting appeared to be more effective than logarithmic and bilinear fittings for suppressing random variation. Determination of the standard dose for pediatric brain CT by the curve-fitting method is recommended to improve radiation dose optimization at facilities performing the imaging procedure infrequently.

ESTABLISHMENT OF LOCAL DIAGNOSTIC REFERENCE LEVEL FOR ROUTINE PAEDIATRIC COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY EXAMINATIONS IN BAFOUSSAM WEST CAMEROON

The main purpose of this study was to determine local diagnostic reference level (LDRL) for routine computed tomography (CT) examination in Bafoussam, western Cameroon. The exposure parameters and dose quantities were collected manually. This retrospective, evaluative and comparative study was conducted to determine LDRLs for routine head CT examination in Bafoussam, to optimize these procedures in the region. The 75th percentile values of the calculated volume CT dose index (CTDIvol) and dose length product (DLP) were proposed as LDRL. The sample was classified in four age groups: < 1, 1-5, 5-10 and 10-15 y. The LDRLs obtained for the four age groups were: 24 mGy and 381.32 mGy.cm, 42.5 mGy and 875.55 mGy.cm, 45.85 mGy and 939.62 mGy.cm, 57.12 mGy and 1222.3 mGy.cm, respectively. The 75th percentile CTDIvol and DLP dose values for this study are higher than international values. We propose a coordinating discussions and collaboration about patient's and specific equipment's change information's, between radiologists, medical imaging technicians and medical physicist, which can reduce absorbed doses and improved medical practice in hospitals.

Radiation Dose Management in Pediatric Brain CT According to Age and Weight as Continuous Variables

The diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) for pediatric brain computed tomography (CT) are provided for groups divided according to age. We investigated the relationships of radiation dose indices (volume CT dose index and dose length product) with age and weight, as continuous variables, in pediatric brain CT. In a retrospective analysis, 980 pediatric brain CT examinations were analyzed. Curve fitting was performed for plots of the CT dose indices versus age and weight, and equations to estimate age- and weight-dependent standard dose indices were derived. Standard dose indices were estimated using the equations, and the errors were calculated. The results showed a biphasic increase in dose indices with increasing age and weight, characterized by a rapid initial and subsequent slow increase. Logarithmic, power, and bilinear functions were well fitted to the plots, allowing estimation of standard dose indices at an arbitrary age or weight. Error analysis suggested that weight was mildly better than age and that the best results were obtained with the bilinear function. Curve fitting of the relationship between CT dose indices and age or weight facilitates the determination of standard dose indices in pediatric brain CT at each facility and is expected to aid the establishment and application of the DRLs.

Estimation of radiation dose and establishment of local diagnostic reference levels for computed tomography of head in pediatric population

BACKGROUND

Pediatric population is more sensitive to the effects of radiation than adults. Establishing diagnostic reference level (DRL) is an efficient dose optimization technique implemented by many countries for reducing radiation dose during Computed Tomography (CT) examinations.

OBJECTIVES

To estimate radiation dose and establish a new local diagnostic reference level for CT head examination in the pediatric population.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We prospectively recruited 143 pediatric patients referred for CT head examination with age ranging from 0-5 years old. All patients had undergone CT head examination using the standard pediatric head protocol. Volumetric CT dose index (CTDIvol) and dose length product (DLP) were recorded. The effective dose was first calculated. Then, 75th percentile of dose indices was calculated to establish DRLs.

RESULTS

DRLs in terms of CTDIvol and DLP are 23.84 mGy, 555.99 mGy.cm for patients <1 years old and 28.65 mGy, 794.99 mGy.cm for patients from 1-5 years old, respectively. Mean effective doses for <1 years old patients and 1-5 years old patients are 2.91 mSv and 2.78 mSv respectively.

CONCLUSION

The study concludes that DRL in terms of CTDIvol is lower but DRL in terms of DLP and the effective dose is higher compared to a few other studies which necessitate the need for dose optimization.

Paediatric diagnostic reference levels for common radiological examinations using the European guidelines

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to explore the feasibility to determine regional diagnostic reference levels (RDRLs) for paediatric conventional and CT examinations using the European guidelines and to compare RDRLs derived from weight and age groups, respectively.

METHODS

Data were collected from 31 hospitals in 4 countries, for 7 examination types for a total of 2978 patients. RDRLs were derived for each weight and age group, respectively, when the total number of patients exceeded 15.

RESULTS

It was possible to derive RDRLs for most, but not all, weight-based and age-based groups for the seven examinations. The result using weight-based and age-based groups differed substantially. The RDRLs were lower than or equal to the European and recently published national DRLs.

CONCLUSION

It is feasible to derive RDRLs. However, a thorough review of the clinical indications and methodologies has to be performed previous to data collection. This study does not support the notion that DRLs derived using age and weight groups are exchangeable.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE

Paediatric DRLs should be derived using weight-based groups with access to the actual weight of the patients. DRLs developed using weight differ markedly from those developed with the use of age. There is still a need to harmonize the method to derive solid DRLs for paediatric radiological examinations.

Use of weight-based vs age-based groupings in the study of typical values of air kerma area product (PKA) for paediatric radiographs of chest and abdomen

OBJECTIVE

To compare age groupings versus weight groupings in the calculation of typical air kerma area product (P_KA) values in paediatric X-ray exams of chest and abdomen in our hospital.

METHODS

Data were analysed from 687 abdominal and 1374 chest X-ray examinations. The P_KA of exams was extracted with Radimetrics, and patient weights were collected from electronic records. Data were organised in different age groups and typical P_KA values were estimated. The process was repeated by organising data in different weight groups.

RESULTS

Typical P_KA values for the four younger age groups (<1m, 1m - < 4y, 4y - < 10y and 10y - < 14y) were comparable to typical values for their equivalent weight groups (<5 kg, 5-15 kg, 15-30 kg and 30-50 kg, respectively). However, typical P_KA values at the late adolescent age group (14y - < 18y) were much lower than its equivalent weight group (>50 kg).

CONCLUSIONS

Age and weight groupings were found at our site to be interchangeable for the calculation of typical paediatric P_KA values. The only exception was the late adolescent group, whose weight distribution can account for the difference in typical P_KA results within its equivalent weight group.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE

In calculating typical P_KA values for radiological paediatric body examinations, departments must ascertain if using age groups, which is typical practice, is equivalent to using weight groups. Otherwise, results may misrepresent local practice.

Simplified size adjusted dose reference levels for adult CT examinations: A regional study

PURPOSE

To investigate retrospective classification of adult patients into small, average, and large based on effective diameter (EDia) from localizer image of computed tomography (CT) scans and to develop regional diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) and achievable doses (AD).

METHOD

The patients falling within the mean ± standard deviation (SD) of EDia were classified as average; those below this range as small and above as large. The CTDI_vol,dose-length-product (DLP) and size-specific dose estimates (SSDE) of all adult patients undergoing CT examinations in 8 CT facilities for 11 months (Dec. 2019 - Oct. 2020) were evaluated. The 75th and 50th percentile values were compared with national and international values.

RESULTS

Of the total of 69,434 CT examinations, nearly 80% fell within average size. The 75th percentile values of CTDI_vol and DLP for small patients for abdomen-pelvic exams were nearly half of average sized patients. Similarly, the 75th percentile values for large patients were nearly double. Similar findings were not found for chest exams. Analysis of image quality and dose factors such as noise, mean axial length, slice thickness, mean number of sequences, use of iterative reconstruction and tube current modulation (TCM) resulted in identification of opportunities for improvement and optimization of different CT facilities.

CONCLUSIONS

DRLs for adult patients were found to vary widely with patient size and thus establishing DRLs only for standard sized patient is not adequate. Simplified and intuitive methods for size classification was shown to provide meaningful information for optimization for patients outside the standard size adult.

Establishment of Local Diagnostic Reference Levels of Pediatric Abdominopelvic and Chest CT Examinations Based on the Body Weight and Size in Korea

OBJECTIVE

The purposes of this study were to analyze the radiation doses for pediatric abdominopelvic and chest CT examinations from university hospitals in Korea and to establish the local diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) based on the body weight and size.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

At seven university hospitals in Korea, 2494 CT examinations of patients aged 15 years or younger (1625 abdominopelvic and 869 chest CT examinations) between January and December 2017 were analyzed in this study. CT scans were transferred to commercial automated dose management software for the analysis after being de-identified. DRLs were calculated after grouping the patients according to the body weight and effective diameter. DRLs were set at the 75th percentile of the distribution of each institution's typical values.

RESULTS

For body weights of 5, 15, 30, 50, and 80 kg, DRLs (volume CT dose index [CTDIvol]) were 1.4, 2.2, 2.7, 4.0, and 4.7 mGy, respectively, for abdominopelvic CT and 1.2, 1.5, 2.3, 3.7, and 5.8 mGy, respectively, for chest CT. For effective diameters of < 13 cm, 14-16 cm, 17-20 cm, 21-24 cm, and > 24 cm, DRLs (size-specific dose estimates [SSDE]) were 4.1, 5.0, 5.7, 7.1, and 7.2 mGy, respectively, for abdominopelvic CT and 2.8, 4.6, 4.3, 5.3, and 7.5 mGy, respectively, for chest CT. SSDE was greater than CTDIvol in all age groups. Overall, the local DRL was lower than DRLs in previously conducted dose surveys and other countries.

CONCLUSION

Our study set local DRLs in pediatric abdominopelvic and chest CT examinations for the body weight and size. Further research involving more facilities and CT examinations is required to develop national DRLs and update the current DRLs.

Development of image quality related reference doses called acceptable quality doses (AQD) in paediatric CT exams in Qatar

OBJECTIVES

To describe first experience of integrating assessment of image quality in paediatric X-ray computed tomography (CT) with analysis of the radiation dose indices to develop reference doses called acceptable quality dose (AQD).

METHODS

Image quality was scored by the radiologists at a tertiary care hospital in Qatar on a scale of 0 to 4 using the recently published scoring criteria. The patients undergoing head, chest and abdomen CT were divided in different weight groups as follows: < 5 kg, 5-< 15 kg, 15-< 30 kg, 30-< 50 kg, 50-< 80 kg and > 80 kg. The images that were clinically acceptable (score of 3) were included for assessment of median values of CTDIvol and DLP to obtain AQDs in different weight groups.

RESULTS

After initial training in image quality scoring of CT images of 49 patients by three radiologists, the study on 715 patients indicated 665 studies (93%) were clinically acceptable as per scoring criteria. The median CTDIvol values for the above weight groups were 16, 20, 22, 22, 27 and 27 mGy and the median DLP values for these weight groups were 271, 377, 463, 486, 568 and 570 mGy cm, respectively, for head CT. Similar values are presented for chest and abdomen CTs.

CONCLUSIONS

The first ever experience of starting with image quality assessment and integrating it with analysis of dose indices to obtain AQD values shall provide a workable model for others and values for comparison within the facility and in other facilities leading to optimisation.

KEY POINTS

• The first study to integrate image quality assessment with analysis of patient dose indices shows feasibility for routine practice in other centres. • The values of acceptable quality dose (AQD) were provided for head, chest and abdomen CT of children divided into weight groups rather than age. They shall act as reference values for future studies. • Verification of our findings on proportional increase in exposure parameters (CTDIvol and DLP) with weight by other investigators shall be helpful.

EVALUATION OF ORGAN DOSE BASED ON PATIENT DATA IN EAST ASIAN DESCENT PEDIATRIC HEAD CT EXAMINATIONS

The purpose of this study was to investigate other indices estimating absorbed dose for eye lens and brain, using clinical images of East Asian pediatric patients. We simulated head computed tomography (CT ) examinations in 104 pediatric patients. Effective diameter (deff) and water equivalent diameter (dw) were measured on clinical images. Various size metrics and age were compared with absorbed dose normalised by CTDIvol (nD). The nD was estimated for eye and brain. The nD tended to decrease with advancing age. R2 between age and nD were 0.38 and 0.31 for eye and brain, respectively. Increasing head diameters decreased each nD. R2 between deff and dw, and nD were 0.20-0.24 and 0.51-0.53 for eye and brain, respectively. Head sizes allowed us to estimate absorbed dose in brain CT on East Asian pediatric patients. Scanning parameters for pediatric head CT may need to be based on individual patient information.

Long-term experience and analysis of data on diagnostic reference levels: the good, the bad, and the ugly

OBJECTIVES

To analyze 11-year data of France for temporal trends in dose indices and dose optimization and draw lessons for those who are willing to work on creation and update of diagnostic reference levels (DRLs).

METHODS

The data from about 3000 radiology departments leading to about 750,000 imaging exams between 2004 and 2015 was analyzed, and patterns of reductions in dose for those below and above the DRLs were estimated and correlated with technology change.

RESULTS

Dose optimization achieved was important and significant in departments which were above or just below the DRL (p = .006) but not in those which were around half of the DRL values. The decrease in 75th percentile value of Kerma air product (KAP) for chest radiography by 27.4% between 2004 and 2015 was observed with the number of flat panel detectors increase from 6 to 43%. A good correlation between the detector type distribution and the level of patient radiation exposure is observed. Otherwise, setting DRLs for standard-sized patient excludes patients lower and higher weighted than "standard."

CONCLUSIONS

The concept of DRL may become obsolete unless lessons drawn from the experience of users are taken into account. While establishing DRLs should be part of the regulations, setting up and updating values should be governed by bodies whose decision-making cycle is short, at the most 1 year. A local rather than national approach, taking into account body habitus and image quality, needs to be organized.

KEY POINTS

• The technology changes faster than regulations. Requirement of DRL establishment should be part of the regulations; however, setting and updating values should be the role of professional societies. • The concept of DRL, highlighting the 75th percentile values and dedicated to standard-sized adult, misses optimization opportunities in the majority of patients who are below the 75th percentile value and outside the range of standard-sized adult. • The ugly aspects of the DRL concept include its non-applicability to individuals, no customization to clinical indications, and lack of consideration of image quality.

Radiation dose optimisation for conventional imaging in infants and newborns using automatic dose management software: an application of the new 2013/59 EURATOM directive

Objective: The new 2013/59 EURATOM Directive (ED) demands dosimetric optimisation procedures without undue delay. The aim of this study was to optimise paediatric conventional radiology examinations applying the ED without compromising the clinical diagnosis.

METHODS

Automatic dose management software (ADMS) was used to analyse 2678 studies of children from birth to 5 years of age, obtaining local diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) in terms of entrance surface air kerma. Given local DRL for infants and chest examinations exceeded the European Commission (EC) DRL, an optimisation was performed decreasing the kVp and applying the automatic control exposure. To assess the image quality, an analysis of high-contrast resolution (HCSR), signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and figure of merit (FOM) was performed, as well as a blind test based on the generalised estimating equations method.

RESULTS

For newborns and chest examinations, the local DRL exceeded the EC DRL by 113%. After the optimisation, a reduction of 54% was obtained. No significant differences were found in the image quality blind test. A decrease in SNR (-37%) and HCSR (-68%), and an increase in FOM (42%), was observed.

CONCLUSION

ADMS allows the fast calculation of local DRLs and the performance of optimisation procedures in babies without delay. However, physical and clinical analyses of image quality remain to be needed to ensure the diagnostic integrity after the optimisation process. Advances in knowledge: ADMS are useful to detect radiation protection problems and to perform optimisation procedures in paediatric conventional imaging without undue delay, as ED requires.

Individual radiation exposure from computed tomography: a survey of paediatric practice in French university hospitals, 2010-2013

OBJECTIVES

To describe computed tomography (CT) scanning parameters, volume CT dose index (CTDIvol) and dose-length product (DLP) in paediatric practice and compare them to current diagnostic reference levels (DRLs).

METHODS

The survey was conducted in radiology departments of six major university hospitals in France in 2010-2013. Data collection was automatised to extract and standardise information on scanning parameters from DICOM-header files. CTDIvol and DLP were estimated based on Monte Carlo transport simulation and computational reference phantoms.

RESULTS

CTDIvol and DLP were derived for 4,300 studies, four age groups and 18 protocols. CTDIvol was lower in younger patients for non-head scans, but did not vary with age for routine head scans. Ratios of 95th to 5th percentile CTDIvol values were 2-4 for most body parts, but 5-7 for abdominal examinations and 4-14 for mediastinum CT with contrast, depending on age. The 75th percentile CTDIvol values were below the national DRLs for chest (all ages) and head and abdominal scans (≥10 years).

CONCLUSION

The results suggest the need for a better optimisation of scanning parameters for routine head scans and infrequent protocols with patient age, enhanced standardisation of practices across departments and revision of current DRLs for children.

KEY POINTS

 • CTDIvol varied little with age for routine head scans.  • CTDIvol was lowest in youngest children for chest or abdominal scans.  • Individual and inter-department variability warrant enhanced standardisation of practices.  • Recent surveys support the need for revised diagnostic reference levels.  • More attention should be given to specific protocols (sinuses, neck, spine, mediastinum).

Review of the current status of radiation protection in diagnostic radiology in Africa

The aim of this paper is to review the available published studies from African countries on patient doses and medical radiation protection and identify strengths, weaknesses, and challenges. Papers on radiation doses to patients published until 2016 pertaining to studies in African countries were reviewed. Radiography, interventional radiology, computed tomography (CT), and mammography modalities were covered. In radiography, the entrance surface air kerma values were below the established diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) provided by the International Atomic Energy Agency, European Commission, and National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements. Patient and staff doses in interventional procedures were not on the higher side when compared with other published reports from developed countries. The dose length product values in CT in many situations were higher than established DRLs. In mammography, the variations of clinical image quality and dose to standard breast between African countries and other countries were insignificant. In conclusion, like in any continent, not all countries in Africa are active, but some have produced good results. The potential for optimization of radiation protection using simple and inexpensive techniques has been demonstrated. The lack of medical physicists is one of the important challenges.

Dose surveys and DRLs: critical look and way forward

The main purpose of dose surveys has been to detect and bring down wide variation in radiation doses for any particular radiological examination and to avoid doses that are on higher side. Diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) have been used for over two decades as an aid in this objective. With very limited success that has been achieved through DRL, the author has recently described a new term 'acceptable quality dose' (AQD) that is aimed at optimisation within the DRL, is facility initiated and takes into account all three important parameters-image quality, dose and patient's body build. It is hoped that AQD will be found easy to establish, will be a useful tool to achieve optimisation in the facilities and will serve as the standard dose.

A study to establish international diagnostic reference levels for paediatric computed tomography

The article reports results from the largest international dose survey in paediatric computed tomography (CT) in 32 countries and proposes international diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) in terms of computed tomography dose index (CTDI vol) and dose length product (DLP). It also assesses whether mean or median values of individual facilities should be used. A total of 6115 individual patient data were recorded among four age groups: <1 y, >1-5 y, >5-10 y and >10-15 y. CTDIw, CTDI vol and DLP from the CT console were recorded in dedicated forms together with patient data and technical parameters. Statistical analysis was performed, and international DRLs were established at rounded 75th percentile values of distribution of median values from all CT facilities. The study presents evidence in favour of using median rather than mean of patient dose indices as the representative of typical local dose in a facility, and for establishing DRLs as third quartile of median values. International DRLs were established for paediatric CT examinations for routine head, chest and abdomen in the four age groups. DRLs for CTDI vol are similar to the reference values from other published reports, with some differences for chest and abdomen CT. Higher variations were observed between DLP values, based on a survey of whole multi-phase exams. It may be noted that other studies in literature were based on single phase only. DRLs reported in this article can be used in countries without sufficient medical physics support to identify non-optimised practice. Recommendations to improve the accuracy and importance of future surveys are provided.