Complement depletion with Naje haje cobra venom factor limits prostaglandin release and improves visceral perfusion in porcine endotoxic shock

Endotoxic fever: New concepts of its regulation suggest new approaches to its management

Endotoxic fever is regulated by endogenous factors that provide pro- and anti-pyretic signals at different points along the febrigenic pathway, from the periphery to the brain. Current evidence indicates that the febrile response to invading Gram-negative bacteria and their products is initiated upon their arrival in the liver via the circulation and their uptake by Kupffer cells (Kc). These pathogens activate the complement cascade on contact, hence generating complement component 5a. It, in turn, very rapidly stimulates Kc to release prostaglandin (PG)E2. Pyrogenic cytokines (TNF-alpha, etc.) are produced later and are no longer considered to be the immediate triggers of fever. The Kc-generated PGE2 either (1) may be transported by the bloodstream to the ventromedial preoptic-anterior hypothalamus (POA, the locus of the temperature-regulating center), presumptively diffusing into it and acting on thermoregulatory neurons; PGE2 is thus taken to be the final, central fever mediator. Or (2) it may activate hepatic vagal afferents projecting to the medulla oblongata, thence to the POA via the ventral noradrenergic bundle. Norepinephrine consequently secreted stimulates alpha1-adrenoceptors on thermoregulatory neurons, rapidly evoking an initial rise in core temperature (Tc) not associated with any change in POA PGE2; this neural, PGE2-independent signaling pathway is quicker than the blood-borne route. Elevated POA PGE2 and a secondary Tc rise occur later, consequent to alpha2 stimulation. Endogenous counter-regulatory factors are also elaborated peripherally and centrally at different points during the course of the febrile response; they are, therefore, anti-pyretic. These multiple interacting pathways are the subject of this review.

Kupffer cell-generated PGE2triggers the febrile response of guinea pigs to intravenously injected LPS

Because the onset of fever induced by intravenously (iv) injected bacterial endotoxic lipopolysaccharides (LPS) precedes the appearance in the bloodstream of pyrogenic cytokines, the presumptive peripheral triggers of the febrile response, we have postulated previously that, in their stead, PGE2could be the peripheral fever trigger because it appears in blood coincidentally with the initial body core temperature (Tc) rise. To test this hypothesis, we injected Salmonella enteritidis LPS (2 μg/kg body wt iv) into conscious guinea pigs and measured their plasma levels of LPS, PGE2, TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-6 before and 15, 30, 60, 90, and 120 min after LPS administration; Tcwas monitored continuously. The animals were untreated or Kupffer cell (KC) depleted; the essential involvement of KCs in LPS fever was shown previously. LPS very promptly (<10 min) induced a rise of Tcthat was temporally correlated with the elevation of plasma PGE2. KC depletion prevented the Tcand plasma PGE2rises and slowed the clearance of LPS from the blood. TNF-α was not detectable in plasma until 30 min and in IL-1β and IL-6 until 60 min after LPS injection. KC depletion did not alter the times of appearance or magnitudes of rises of these cytokines, except TNF-α, the maximal level of which was increased approximately twofold in the KC-depleted animals. In a follow-up experiment, PGE2antiserum administered iv 10 min before LPS significantly attenuated the febrile response to LPS. Together, these results support the view that, in guinea pigs, PGE2rather than pyrogenic cytokines is generated by KCs in immediate response to iv LPS and triggers the febrile response.

LPS-activated complement, not LPS per se, triggers the early release of PGE2by Kupffer cells

The intravenous injection of LPS rapidly evokes fever. We have hypothesized that its onset is mediated by prostaglandin (PG)E2quickly released by Kupffer cells (Kc). LPS, however, does not stimulate PGE2production by Kc as rapidly as it induces fever; but complement (C) activated by LPS could be the exciting agent. To test this hypothesis, we injected LPS (2 or 8 μg/kg) or cobra venom factor (CVF, an immediate activator of the C cascade that depletes its substrate, ultimately causing hypocomplementemia; 25 U/animal) into the portal vein of anesthetized guinea pigs and measured the appearance of PGE2, TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-6 in the inferior vena cava (IVC) over the following 60 min. LPS (at both doses) and CVF induced similar rises in PGE2within the first 5 min after treatment; the rises in PGE2due to CVF returned to control in 15 min, whereas PGE2rises due to LPS increased further, then stabilized. LPS given 3 h after CVF to the same animals also elevated PGE2, but after a 30- to 45-min delay. CVF per se did not alter basal PGE2and cytokine levels and their responses to LPS. These in vivo effects were substantiated by the in vitro responses of primary Kc from guinea pigs to C (0.116 U/ml) and LPS (200 ng/ml). These results indicate that LPS-activated C rather than LPS itself triggers the early release of PGE2by Kc.

Cytokines, PGE2 and endotoxic fever: a re-assessment

The innate immune system serves as the first line of host defense against the deleterious effects of invading infectious pathogens. Fever is the hallmark among the defense mechanisms evoked by the entry into the body of such pathogens. The conventional view of the steps that lead to fever production is that they begin with the biosynthesis of pyrogenic cytokines by mononuclear phagocytes stimulated by the pathogens, their release into the circulation and transport to the thermoregulatory center in the preoptic area (POA) of the anterior hypothalamus, and their induction there of cyclooxygenase (COX)-2-dependent prostaglandin (PG)E(2), the putative final mediator of the febrile response. But data accumulated over the past 5 years have gradually challenged this classical concept, due mostly to the temporal incompatibility of the newer findings with this concatenation of events. Thus, the former studies generally overlooked that the production of cytokines and the transduction of their pyrogenic signals into fever-mediating PGE(2) proceed at relatively slow rates, significantly slower certainly than the onset latency of fever produced by the i.v. injection of bacterial endotoxic lipopolysaccharides (LPS). Here, we review the conflicts between the earlier and the more recent findings and summarize new data that reconcile many of the contradictions. A unified model based on these data explicating the generation and maintenance of the febrile response is presented. It postulates that the steps in the production of LPS fever occur in the following sequence: the immediate activation by LPS of the complement (C) cascade, the stimulation by the anaphylatoxic C component C5a of Kupffer cells, their consequent, virtually instantaneous release of PGE(2), its excitation of hepatic vagal afferents, their transmission of the induced signals to the POA via the ventral noradrenergic bundle, and the activation by the thus, locally released norepinephrine (NE) of neural alpha(1)- and glial alpha(2)-adrenoceptors. The activation of the first causes an immediate, PGE(2)-independent rise in core temperature (T(c)) [the early phase of fever; an antioxidant-sensitive PGE(2) rise, however, accompanies this first phase], and of the second a delayed, PGE(2)-dependent T(c) rise [the late phase of fever]. Meanwhile-generated pyrogenic cytokines and their consequent upregulation of blood-brain barrier cells COX-2 also contribute to the latter rise. The consecutive steps that initiate the febrile response to LPS would now appear, therefore, to occur in an order different than conceived originally.

Pyrogenic signaling via vagal afferents: what stimulates their receptors?

Although there is good evidence that pyrogenic messages may be conveyed from the periphery to the brain via vagal afferents, the exact nature of the factors that activate their sensory terminals is unclear. Since IL-1beta and PGE2 have established roles in fever production and since their receptors have been identified on or near vagal nerves, they are potential candidate mediators. A difficulty, however, is that (1) IL-1beta is not expressed constitutively in mononuclear phagocytes, their presumed cell source upon stimulation by exogenous pyrogens, e.g. endotoxin, and (2) similarly, the isoform of the enzyme that selectively mediates the production and release of PGE2 by endotoxin-stimulated macrophages, COX-2, is also not constitutively expressed in these cells. Since the transcription and translation of these factors significantly lags the onset of fever induced by endotoxin administered intravenously, in particular, it is possible that a secondary, quickly-acting mediator evoked in almost immediate reaction to the presence of endotoxin excites, directly or indirectly, the sensory neurons. We have evidence that the complement component C5 contributes importantly to the initiation of the febrile response to endotoxin. This article briefly reviews the prevailing concepts of pyrogen sensing and signaling, examines their shortcomings particularly in terms of the temporal discrepancy between the very rapid onset of the febrile response to intravenously administered endotoxin and the significant delay in the elaboration of the putative mediators of fever, and presents newer data that may help to integrate the various preposed mechanisms.

Pyrogen sensing and signaling: old views and new concepts

Fever is thought to be caused by endogenous pyrogenic cytokines, which are elaborated and released into the circulation by systemic mononuclear phagocytes that are activated by exogenous inflammatory agents and transported to the preoptic-anterior hypothalamic area (POA) of the brain, where they act. Prostaglandin (PG) E2 is thought to be an essential, proximal mediator in the POA, and induced by these cytokines. It seems unlikely, however, that these factors could directly account for early production of PGE2 following the intravenous administration of bacterial endotoxic lipopolysaccharides (LPS), because PGE2 is generated before the cytokines that induce it are detectable in the blood and the before cyclooxygenase-2, the synthase that they stimulate, is expressed. Hence other, more quickly evoked mediators are presumed to be involved in initiating the febrile response; moreover, their message may be conveyed to the brain by a neural rather than a humoral pathway. This article reviews current conceptions of pyrogen signalling from the periphery to the brain and presents new, developing hypotheses about the mechanism by which LPS initiates fever.

Relation between complement and the febrile response of guinea pigs to systemic endotoxin

We reported recently that the complement (C) system may play a role in the febrile response of guinea pigs to intravenous lipopolysaccharide (LPS) administration because C depletion abolished the LPS-induced rise in core temperature (T(c)). The present study was designed to investigate further the relation between C reduction [induced by cobra venom factor (CVF); 20, 50, 100, and 200 U/animal iv] and the fever of adult, conscious guinea pigs produced by LPS injected intravenously (2 microg/kg) or intraperitoneally (8, 16, 32 microg/kg) 18 h after CVF; control animals received pyrogen-free saline. Serum C levels were measured as total hemolytic C activity before and 18 h after CVF injection and expressed as CH(100) units. In other experiments, serum C levels were determined at various intervals after the intravenous and intraperitoneal injections at different doses of LPS alone. LPS produced fevers generally of similar heights but of different onset latencies and durations, depending on the dose and route of administration. CVF caused dose-related reductions in serum C, from approximately 1,136 U to below detection. These reductions proportionately attenuated the fevers induced by intraperitoneal LPS, but not by intravenous LPS. Intravenous and intraperitoneal LPS per se caused reductions in serum C of 25 and 40%, respectively, indicating activation of the C cascade. These decreases were transient, however, occurring early during the febrile rise approximately 30 min after LPS injection. These data thus support the notion that the C system may be critically involved in the febrile response of guinea pigs to systemic, particularly intraperitoneal, LPS.

Afferent pathways of pyrogen signaling

We and others recently showed that fever induced by intravenously or intraperitoneally injected lipopolysaccharide (LPS) may involve brain signaling via hepatic vagal afferents. This suggests that LPS fever may be initiated by mediators released mainly by cells in the liver, presumably macrophages (Kupffer cells, Kc). To verify this possibility, we disabled the Kc of conscious guinea pigs with gadolinium chloride and monitored their core temperature and associated preoptic prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) responses to i.v. LPS. Gadolinium chloride pretreatment significantly attenuated both the febrile and PGE2 rises, thus supporting the hypothesis. Additionally, fluorescein-labeled LPS was detected in Kc 15 minutes after its i.v. administration. Paradoxically, however, the label was also present in gadolinium chloride-pretreated guinea pigs. Thus, either Kc are not the primary source of pyrogenic mediators or LPS does not provide the stimulus for their production. Because the i.v. injection of LPS elicits virtually immediately the production of complement fragments, and Kc express their receptors and produce various mediators on their activation, we hypocomplemented guinea pigs with cobra venom factor. The core temperature rises produced by i.v. LPS were reduced by complement depletions > 60%. LPS i.v. per se decreased complement, that is, complement was consumed by 12% within 10 minutes. Thus, the onset of LPS fever may involve complement system and Kc activation, but their precise roles await clarification.

Complement reduction impairs the febrile response of guinea pigs to endotoxin

Although it is generally believed that circulating exogenous pyrogens [e.g., lipopolysaccharides (LPS)] induce fever via the mediation of endogenous pyrogens (EP) such as cytokines, the first of these, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, is usually not detectable in blood until at least 30 min after intravenous administration of LPS, whereas the febrile rise begins within 15 min after its administration. Moreover, although abundant evidence indicates that circulating LPS is cleared primarily by liver macrophages [Kupffer cells (KC)], these do not secrete EP in immediate response. This would imply that other factors, presumably evoked earlier than EP, may mediate the onset of the febrile response to intravenous LPS. It is well known that blood-borne LPS very rapidly activates the intravascular complement (C) system, some components of which in turn stimulate the quick release into blood of various substances that have roles in the acute inflammatory reaction. KC contain receptors for C components and are in close contact with afferent vagal terminals in the liver; the involvement of hepatic vagal afferents in LPS-induced fever has recently been shown. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that the initiation of fever by intravenous LPS involves, sequentially, the C system and KC. To test this postulated mechanism, we measured directly the levels of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) in the interstitial fluid of the preoptic anterior hypothalamus (POA), the presumptive site of the fever-producing controller, of conscious guinea pigs over their entire febrile course, before and after C depletion by cobra venom factor (CVF) and before and after elimination of KC by gadolinium chloride (GdCl3). CVF and GdCl3 pretreatment each individually attenuated the first of the biphasic core temperature (Tc) rises after intravenous LPS, inverted the second into a Tc fall, and greatly reduced the usual fever-associated increase in POA PGE2. We conclude, therefore, that C activation may indeed be pivotal in the induction of fever by intravenous LPS and that substance(s) generated presumably by KC in almost immediate reaction to the presence of LPS and/or C may transmit pyrogenic signals via hepatic vagal afferents to the POA, where they rapidly induce the production of PGE2 and, hence, fever.

Deficiency of complement factor C5 reduces early mortality but does not prevent organ damage in an animal model of multiple organ dysfunction syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the role of complement factor C5 in a model of zymosan-induced multiple organ dysfunction syndrome.

DESIGN

Experimental animal study.

SETTING

Central animal laboratory of a university hospital.

SUBJECTS

Twenty-five C5-deficient B2D10/Old and 25 C5-sufficient B2D10/New mice.

INTERVENTIONS

On day 0, all mice received an intraperitoneal injection with zymosan suspended in paraffin in a dose of 1 mg/g body weight.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Between days 0 and 12, biological parameters (temperature, body weight, and clinical condition) were measured daily and mortality was monitored. Clinical condition was assessed as a symptom score by blindly grading the degree of lethargy, conjunctivitis, diarrhea, and ruffled fur of each mouse on a 2-point scale (maximum score of 4). On day 12, all surviving mice were killed and relative organ weights of lungs, liver, spleen, and kidneys were calculated. Relative organ weight was defined as (organ weight/body weight) x 100%. Zymosan administration induced a typical triphasic illness. Deterioration of the clinical condition, as indicated by the symptom score, and the decrease in temperature and body weight in the acute phase were all significantly less severe in C5-deficient mice (p < .005). In the late phase, no differences could be noticed in the courses of these biological parameters. Overall mortality was 2 (8%) of 25 in C5-deficient mice and 8 (32%) of 25 in C5-sufficient mice (p = .049), a difference that was mainly due to a difference in the acute phase. Organ damage, assessed as the relative organ weights, did not show any statistical differences for any organ between both strains.

CONCLUSIONS

Complement factor C5 appears to play an important role in the acute hyperdynamic septic response in this model. However, deficiency of C5 could not prevent organ damage in the late multiple organ dysfunction syndrome phase. This finding suggests that other factors must be more important in the development of the inflammatory response leading to multiple organ dysfunction syndrome.

Sequential release of tumour necrosis factor, platelet activating factor and eicosanoids during endotoxin shock in anaesthetized pigs: protective effects of indomethacin

1. The effects of indomethacin were investigated on haemodynamics, haematological and blood glucose values, and the release of tumour necrosis factor (TNF), platelet activating factor (PAF) and eicosanoids in anaesthetized pigs receiving 5 micrograms kg-1 E. coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS) over 60 min into the superior mesenteric artery. The animals were observed for an additional period of 2 h after the termination of LPS infusion. 2. Eight of the 17 animals infused with LPS and not treated with indomethacin died within 30 min after the beginning of LPS infusion (non-survivors), while the other 9 survived the experimental period of 3 h though in a state of shock (survivors). 3. No alterations were observed in plasma concentrations of PAF and eicosanoids (thromboxane B2 (TXB2), 6-keto prostaglandin F1 alpha (6-keto PGF1 alpha) and leukotriene B4 (LTB4] in non-survivors. However, a marked increase was detected in TNF release. A significant, though transient, increase in concentrations of PAF, TNF and eicosanoids occurred in the survivors. The peak in the concentrations of PAF and TXB2 preceded the maximum in TNF values in survivors. 4. Another group of 7 LPS-infused pigs was treated with indomethacin (2 mg kg-1, i.v. bolus 60 min before the start of LPS infusion, followed by a continuous infusion of 3 mg kg-1 h-1). This treatment prevented death and shock despite the high concentrations of circulating TNF and PAF. Concentrations of cyclo-oxygenase enzyme products were reduced, whereas LTB4 release was not affected. The effect of indomethacin on haemodynamic changes occurred earlier than on cyclo-oxygenase products.5. In another group of 6 pigs indomethacin (2mg kg- 1, i.v.) was given 20-25 min after the start of LPS infusion at which time mean arterial blood pressure (MABP) had decreased below 40mmHg indicating imminent death. This indomethacin treatment immediately reversed the hypotension, restored the organ perfusion, delayed the haemoconcentration and thrombocytopenia and prevented death. However, TNF and PAF concentrations remained elevated. Concentrations of cyclo-oxygenase products studied were reduced by the end of the observation period, whereas LTB4 production was unaffected.6. The decrease in MABP induced by exogenous PAF was temporarily prevented by indomethacin.7. These data indicate that the beneficial effect of indomethacin in LPS-induced septic shock is related to cyclo-oxygenase inhibition as well as to a direct vasoconstrictor property of the drug.

Sequential release of eicosanoids during endotoxin-induced shock in anesthetized pigs

The release of eicosanoids during endotoxin shock was investigated in anesthetized pigs receiving 5 micrograms/kg Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS) over 60 min into the superior mesenteric artery. TXB2, 6-keto PGF1 alpha and LTB4 concentrations in blood obtained from the superior mesenteric vein (SMV), right ventricle (RV) and aorta, during LPS infusion and an additional period of 2 h, were assessed along with hemodynamic variables, blood gases and pH and laboratory parameters. Half of the animals died within 30 min after termination of LPS infusion (non-survivors, n = 8), while the other half survived the experimental period of 3 h, though in a shock state (survivors, n = 9). The non-surviving pigs demonstrated progressively reduced cardiac output, hypotension and hypoperfusion in all organs. The surviving pigs demonstrated also a reduced cardiac output, which however was compensated by an elevated systemic vascular resistance resulting in a maintenance of arterial blood pressure. After exhausting this compensation the flow to non-vital organs increased and consequently arterial blood pressure was reduced resulting in hypoperfusion. In survivors a marked, though, transient increase was measured in concentrations of TXB2 and 6-keto PGF1 alpha level. A significant increase was measured in plasma concentration of LTB4 in SMV without any elevation in RV and aorta. LTB4 production started when prostanoid release had decreased. In contrast to survivors, no changes could be observed in eicosanoid release for non-survivors. A correlation was observed between systemic vascular resistance and TXB2 to 6-keto PGF1 alpha ratio.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Right ventricular pump dysfunction with acute experimental septic shock

Right ventricular (RV) function has been poorly characterized at the onset of acute bacterial septic shock. Using a volumetric thermodilution catheter, previously validated in our laboratory, we serially measured RV function in a porcine model of acute septic shock. Six pigs (21.3 +/- 0.9 kg) were instrumented and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (3.4 x 10(8) cfu/ml, 0.3 ml/20 kg/min) was infused. RV ejection fraction, RV volumes, cardiac output, arterial pressure, central venous pressure, and pulmonary arterial pressure were measured at baseline and at 30, 60, 120, and 240 min after starting the bacterial infusion. RV ejection fraction and stroke volume were decreased at 30 min compared to baseline (21 +/- 5 vs 43 +/- 5% and 14 +/- 3 vs 23 +/- 3 ml, respectively; P less than 0.05) and remained depressed throughout the experiment. Mean arterial pressure was significantly reduced at 60, 120, and 240 min compared to baseline (P less than 0.05). There was a significant increase in pulmonary vascular resistance (1771 +/- 493 vs 301 +/- 99 dyn-sec-cm-5 at 30 min; P less than 0.05) and RV stroke work (5.7 +/- 1.1 vs 2.3 +/- 0.3 gm-m/beat at 30 min; P less than 0.05) while no significant change in RV end-diastolic volume or central venous pressure was observed. Thus, a decrease in RV pump performance was associated with an increase in afterload and no change in preload. These results suggest that severe RV pump dysfunction occurs early in acute septic shock. This was manifested by significant reductions in RV ejection fraction and increased in stroke work.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Laboratory models of sepsis and septic shock

That there are so many models of sepsis and septic shock is tacit evidence that none of them are perfect. Although sepsis presents in many forms clinically, most clinicians would probably agree that virtually all severely septic patients manifest respiratory failure and ventilator dependence. Furthermore, failure of organs other than the lungs typically occurs days to weeks after the onset of the septic process. Although early deaths occur commonly in some situations (e.g., meningococcemia, pneumococcal bacteremia in asplenic individuals, Gram-negative bacteremia in the setting of profound granulocytopenia), most deaths due to sepsis occur after a protracted course in an intensive care unit. Thus, for certain important experiments, there is a need for an animal model of severe chronic sepsis characterized by these features: persistent hypermetabolism, low systemic vascular resistance, respiratory failure severe enough to require mechanical ventilation, late (nonpulmonary) organ system failure, and death. Obviously, creation of such a model will require a major commitment of resources, because it will require, in essence, the creation of an animal intensive care unit. Nevertheless, we believe that progress in sepsis-related research would be substantially facilitated were such a model available. Even without such a model, progress will continue in this field. A wide variety of good animal models are already available to investigators. In the next decade, as new methods, such as the powerful tools of molecular biology, are applied to problems related to the sepsis syndrome, these models will be invaluable in improving our understanding of pathophysiology and in developing new and more effective approaches toward therapy.