Anti-skeletal muscle glycolipid antibodies in human heart transplantation as markers of acute rejection. Correlation with endomyocardial biopsy

Outcome-based Risk Assessment of Non-HLA Antibodies in Heart Transplantation: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Current monitoring after heart transplantation (HT) employs repeated invasive endomyocardial biopsies (EMB). Although positive EMB confirms rejection, EMB fails to predict impending, subclinical, or EMB-negative rejection events. While non-human leukocyte antigen (non-HLA) antibodies have emerged as important risk factors for antibody-mediated rejection after HT, their use in clinical risk stratification has been limited. A systematic review of the role of non-HLA antibodies in rejection pathologies has the potential to guide efforts to overcome deficiencies of EMB in rejection monitoring.

METHODS

Databases were searched to include studies on non-HLA antibodies in HT recipients. Data collected included the number of patients, type of rejection, non-HLA antigen studied, association of non-HLA antibodies with rejection, and evidence for synergistic interaction between non-HLA antibodies and donor-specific anti-human leukocyte antigen antibody (HLA-DSA) responses.

RESULTS

A total of 56 studies met the inclusion criteria. Strength of evidence for each non-HLA antibody was evaluated based on the number of articles and patients in support versus against their role in mediating rejection. Importantly, despite previous intense focus on the role of anti-major histocompatibility complex class I chain-related gene A (MICA) and anti-angiotensin II type I receptor antibodies (AT1R) in HT rejection, evidence for their involvement was equivocal. Conversely, the strength of evidence for other non-HLA antibodies supports that differing rejection pathologies are driven by differing non-HLA antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

This systematic review underscores the importance of identifying peri-HT non-HLA antibodies. Current evidence supports the role of non-HLA antibodies in all forms of HT rejection. Further investigations are required to define the mechanisms of action of non-HLA antibodies in HT rejection.

A role for antibodies to human leukocyte antigens, collagen-V, and K-α1-Tubulin in antibody-mediated rejection and cardiac allograft vasculopathy

BACKGROUND

We determined the role of donor-specific antibodies (DSA) and antibodies (Abs) to self-antigens, collagen-V (Col-V), and K-α1-Tubulin (KAT) in pathogenesis of acute antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) and cardiac allograft vasculopathy (CAV) after human heart transplantation (HTx).

METHODS

One hundred thirty-seven HTx recipients, with 60 early period (≤ 12 months) and 77 late period (>12 months), were enrolled in this study. Circulating DSA was determined using LUMINEX. Abs against Col-I, II, IV, V, and KAT were measured using ELISA. Frequency of CD4+T helper cells (CD4+Th) secreting interferon (IFN)-γ, interleukin (IL)-5, -10, or -17 specific to self-antigens were determined using Enzyme Linked Immunosorbent Spot assay.

RESULTS

A significant association between AMR and DSA was demonstrated. Development of DSA in AMR patients correlated well with the development of auto-Abs to Col-V (AMR[+]: 383 ± 72 μg/mL, AMR[-]: 172 ± 49 μg/mL, P=0.033) and KAT (AMR[+]: 252 ± 49 μg/mL, AMR[-]: 61 ± 21 μg/mL, P=0.014). Patients who developed AMR demonstrated increased frequencies of CD4+Th secreting IFN-γ and IL-5 with reduction in IL-10 specific for Col-V/KAT. Patients diagnosed with CAV also developed DSA and auto-Abs to Col-V (CAV[+]: 835 ± 142 μg/mL, CAV[-]: 242 ± 68 μg/mL, P=0.025) and KAT (CAV[+]: 768 ± 206 μg/mL, CAV[-]: 196 ± 72 μg/mL, P=0.001) with increased frequencies of CD4+Th secreting IL-17 with reduction in IL-10 specific for Col-V/KAT. CONCLUSIONS.: Development of Abs to human leukocyte antigens and self-antigens are associated with increases in CD4+Th secreting IFN-γ and IL-5 in AMR and IL-17 in CAV, with reduction in CD4+Th secreting IL-10 in both AMR and CAV.

Report from a consensus conference on antibody-mediated rejection in heart transplantation

BACKGROUND

The problem of AMR remains unsolved because standardized schemes for diagnosis and treatment remains contentious. Therefore, a consensus conference was organized to discuss the current status of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) in heart transplantation.

METHODS

The conference included 83 participants (transplant cardiologists, surgeons, immunologists and pathologists) representing 67 heart transplant centers from North America, Europe, and Asia who all participated in smaller break-out sessions to discuss the various topics of AMR and attempt to achieve consensus.

RESULTS

A tentative pathology diagnosis of AMR was established, however, the pathologist felt that further discussion was needed prior to a formal recommendation for AMR diagnosis. One of the most important outcomes of this conference was that a clinical definition for AMR (cardiac dysfunction and/or circulating donor-specific antibody) was no longer believed to be required due to recent publications demonstrating that asymptomatic (no cardiac dysfunction) biopsy-proven AMR is associated with subsequent greater mortality and greater development of cardiac allograft vasculopathy. It was also noted that donor-specific antibody is not always detected during AMR episodes as the antibody may be adhered to the donor heart. Finally, recommendations were made for the timing for specific staining of endomyocardial biopsy specimens and the frequency by which circulating antibodies should be assessed. Recommendations for management and future clinical trials were also provided.

CONCLUSIONS

The AMR Consensus Conference brought together clinicians, pathologists and immunologists to further the understanding of AMR. Progress was made toward a pathology AMR grading scale and consensus was accomplished regarding several clinical issues.

Autoimmunity to vimentin potentiates graft vasculopathy in murine cardiac allografts

BACKGROUND

There is increasing evidence for a role for autoimmunity in transplant rejection. It has previously been shown that autoantibodies to vimentin (Vim) accelerate acute rejection of murine cardiac allografts. We have investigated whether autoimmunity to Vim contributes to development of cardiac allograft vasculopathy (CAV).

METHODS

Two well-established minor mismatch murine models of CAV were used, transplantation of 129/sv hearts into T-cell-depleted C57Bl/6 (B6) recipients and transplantation of FVB hearts into nonimmunosuppressed DBA/1 recipients. Recipients were immunized with recombinant mouse Vim in complete Freunds adjuvant, and controls received hen egg lysozyme 2 weeks before transplantation. T cell and antibody responses to Vim were assessed by ELISPOT and ELISA, respectively. CAV within transplanted hearts was assessed by quantitative morphometry of occluded vessels, presence of smooth muscle cells, deposition of C3d, and confocal microscopy.

RESULTS

Allografts were harvested from B6 recipients at days 30 and 45 and from DBA/1 recipients at days 18 and 35. At all days, there was significantly more intimal occlusion of arteries of Vim -immunized mice than controls. There was significantly more smooth muscle cell alpha actin in vessels from Vim-immunized mice, and more C3d deposited in hearts from Vim-immunized mice. Confocal microscopy demonstrated colocalization of Vim with C3d on endothelial cells, leukocytes, and platelets in allogeneic but not syngeneic hearts. Serum from Vim-immunized mice, but not controls, caused platelet/leukocyte conjugation when added to mouse leukocytes.

CONCLUSION

The autoimmune response to Vim accelerates CAV progression in these minor-mismatched models.

Characterization of immune responses to cardiac self-antigens myosin and vimentin in human cardiac allograft recipients with antibody-mediated rejection and cardiac allograft vasculopathy

BACKGROUND

Herein we study the role of donor-specific antibodies (DSA) to mismatched human leukocyte antigen (HLA) and antibodies (Abs) to the cardiac self-antigens myosin (MYO) and vimentin (VIM) in the pathogenesis of acute antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) in the early post-transplant period (EP, <12 months) and cardiac allograft vasculopathy (CAV) in the late post-transplant period (LP, >12 months) after heart transplantation (HTx).

METHODS

One hundred forty-eight HTx recipients (65 in EP, 83 in LP) were enrolled in the study. Development of DSA was determined by Luminex. Circulating Abs against MYO and VIM in sera were measured using enzyme-linked immunoassay (ELISA). Frequency of CD4+ T-helper cells (CD4+ Th) secreting interferon (IFN)-γ, interleukin (IL)-17, IL-10 or IL-5 specific to either MYO or VIM were analyzed in vitro using ELISpot assays.

RESULTS

AMR patients were more likely DSA positive (AMR-: 15%; AMR+: 70%; p = 0.03) and demonstrated increased Abs to MYO (AMR-: 144 ± 115 μg/ml; AMR+: 285 ± 70 μg/ml; p = 0.033) and VIM (AMR-: 37 ± 19 μg/ml; AMR+: 103 ± 43 μg/ml; p = 0.014). AMR patients demonstrated increased IL-5 CD4+ Th cells specific to MYO (5.2 ± 0.9 fold, p = 0.003) and VIM (7.3 ± 2.9-fold, p = 0.004) and decreased IL-10 CD4+ Th cells specific to MYO (2.2 ± 0.4-fold, p = 0.009) and VIM (1.7 ± 0.2-fold, p = 0.03). CAV patients were more likely DSA positive (CAV-): 25%; CAV+: 79%; p = 0.03) and demonstrated increased Abs to MYO (CAV-: 191 ± 120 μg/ml; CAV+: 550 ± 98 μg/ml; p = 0.025) and VIM (CAV-: 55 ± 25 μg/ml; CAV+: 255 ± 49 μg/ml; p = 0.001). CAV patients demonstrated increased IL-17 CD4+ Th cells specific to MYO (10.5 ± 7.3-fold, p = 0.002) and VIM (7.0 ± 3.9-fold, p = 0.003).

CONCLUSIONS

The presence of DSA in AMR and CAV is significantly associated with development of Abs to MYO and VIM in post-HTx patients. Induction of high CD4+ Th cells specific to cardiac self-antigens that secrete predominantly IL-5 and IL-17 plays a significant role in the development of Abs to self-antigens leading to AMR and CAV, respectively.

Autoantibodies to vimentin cause accelerated rejection of cardiac allografts

Autoimmune responses to vimentin occur after solid organ transplantation, but their pathogenic effects are unclear. The aim of these studies was to investigate the effects of vimentin preimmunization on allogeneic and isografted hearts in a murine transplant model. Immunization of C57BL/6 mice with murine vimentin in complete Freund's adjuvant resulted in anti-vimentin antibodies and vimentin-reactive Th-1 cells. Transplantation of 129/sv hearts into vimentin-immunized C57BL/6 recipients resulted in accelerated rejection (8.4 +/- 1.5 days; n = 18), compared with hen egg lysozyme-immunized C57BL/6 (13.3 +/- 2.2 days; n = 10; P < 0.0001, log-rank test). In contrast, isografts continued to beat beyond 90 days. Immunohistochemical analysis of allografts from vimentin/complete Freund's adjuvant mice demonstrated increased numbers of T cells and enhanced microvascular deposition of C3d, CD41, and P-selectin compared with controls. Antibodies were necessary for accelerated rejection, shown by the fact that vimentin-immunized B-cell-deficient IgH6 mice did not show accelerated rejection of 129/sv allografts, but rejection was restored by adoptive transfer of serum containing anti-vimentin antibodies. Eluates from donor hearts placed in vimentin/complete Freund's adjuvant recipients contained anti-vimentin antibodies, shown by Western blotting. Confocal imaging of rejected hearts de-monstrated presence of vimentin and C3d on apoptosed leukocytes, endothelial cells, and platelet/leukocyte conjugates. These results demonstrate that autoantibodies to vimentin, in conjunction with the alloimmune response, have a pathogenic role in allograft rejection.

Acute Antibody-mediated Rejection of Cardiac Transplants

Under the direction of the International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation, a multidisciplinary review of the cardiac biopsy grading system was undertaken in 2004, with task forces examining the areas of histopathology of rejection, clinical issues, and research. An important new area addressed by the Immunopathology Task Force sub-committee was the clinical and diagnostic criteria for antibody-mediated rejection. This article is a companion paper to the revised working formulation for the standardization of nomenclature in the diagnosis of heart rejection and reviews the published literature documenting the serologic and morphologic evidence that antibody-mediated rejection is clinically significant and associated with graft loss, accelerated transplant-associated coronary artery disease, and death. This article also provides a more in-depth analysis of antibody-mediated rejection developed by the Immunopathology Task Force for revision of the 1990 working formulation for the standardization of nomenclature in the diagnosis of heart rejection.

The autoimmune response to vimentin after renal transplantation in nonhuman primates is immunosuppression dependent

BACKGROUND

Chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN) is a common late complication of kidney transplantation. Antibodies to both human leukocyte antigen and nonhuman leukocyte antigen antigens have been implicated in the development of this condition. Here we investigated the presence of antivimentin antibodies in nonhuman primate recipients of kidney allografts as a possible predictor of CAN and the effects of immunosuppression.

METHODS

Thirty seven rhesus monkeys received a kidney allograft to study the potency of several different immunosuppressive regimens (conventional immunosuppression, n=19, vs. costimulatory blockade, n=18). Monkeys were tested for antivimentin antibody by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and for anti-donor antibody by staining donor spleen cells with recipient serum. The appearance of antibodies was correlated with the graft pathology in biopsy and necropsy material.

RESULTS

Antivimentin antibodies were found in 31 of 37 animals, whereas only 15 of 32 animals made anti-donor antibodies. Conventional immunosuppression did not prevent antivimentin antibody formation. Costimulation blockade, in particular blocking CD40 and CD86, significantly delayed or prevented antivimentin antibody formation, but did not prevent CAN. Antivimentin antibodies were not significantly associated with development of CAN.

CONCLUSIONS

We postulate that vimentin acts as an autoantigen after renal transplantation; it elicits an autoimmune response that is not regulated by cyclosporine. This autoimmune response may be part of the complex immunologic events occurring posttransplantation and may contribute to the development of CAN, but cannot be considered as a major cause of CAN because this condition also develops without antivimentin antibodies.

Activation of autoimmune B cells and chronic rejection

Allotransplantation into immunosuppressed individuals results in long-term survival of grafts. However, the grafts are damaged, probably at many stages before, during and after implantation. The hypothesis to be presented is that release of antigens and autoantigens from the chronically damaged graft results in breaking tolerance to self-antigens and an autoimmune response. There is experimental evidence that autoimmune responses following allotransplantation are damaging and cause accelerated graft rejection.

DETECTION OF VIMENTIN-SPECIFIC AUTOREACTIVE CD8+ T CELLS IN CARDIAC TRANSPLANT PATIENTS

BACKGROUND

Evidence is emerging that autoimmunity can play a role in allograft rejection. Reports have described the presence of autoantibodies in transplant patients and CD4+ autoreactive T cells in rodent models of allograft rejection. The objective of this study was to seek evidence of CD8+ T-cell-mediated autoimmunity in the transplant setting. The author have previously observed autoimmunity to the non-polymorphic cytoskeletal protein vimentin in cardia transplant patients. In this study, vimentin antibody positive patients were screened for the presence of vimentin-specific self-major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted CD8+ T cells.

METHODS

Two peptide sequences from vimentin that bound HLA-A*0201 were identified and fluorochrome-labeled A*0201 tetramers with each peptide were constructed to screen for vimentin-specific T cells.

RESULTS

Tetramer-binding CD8+ T cells were detected in peripheral blood lymphocytes from two of six patients after expansion by in vitro stimulation with peptide. Tetramer-binding T cells produced interferon-gamma in an antigen-specific fashion. No autoreactive T cells specific for vimentin were detected after peptide stimulation of T cells from eight healthy A*0201-positive volunteers.

CONCLUSIONS

This finding is the first evidence of CD8+ T-cell-mediated autoimmunity in human transplant patients.

Anti-human skeletal muscle glycolipid antibodies in unstable angina

BACKGROUND

We studied whether the level of anti-skeletal muscle glycolipid antibodies (AGA), a marker of acute rejection in heart transplantation, may be associated with an adverse prognosis in unstable angina.

METHODS AND RESULTS

The in-hospital evolution of 50 patients with unstable angina (Braunwald class III B) was assessed. We determined the incidence of death, myocardial infarction, and refractory angina. Blood was collected at admission and 24 hours later for determination of AGA levels by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Twenty-three patients showed a decrease in the AGA level at 24 hours after admission. Ten in-hospital cardiac events occurred in these patients (43.4%) as compared with 4 (14.8%) in the 27 patients who did not show a decrease (P =.025). In patients with previous myocardial infarction (n = 26), the AGA assay was a powerful predictor of outcome. In this subgroup, 66.6% of patients who had decreased AGA levels (8 of 12) had cardiac events as compared with 14.2% (2 of 14) of those who did not have that decrease (P =.001).

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that a decrease of AGA levels 24 hours after admission is associated with a complicated in-hospital course. This finding may provide new insights in the phenomenon of plaque instability involved in the development of acute coronary syndromes.

Cardiac myosin autoantibodies and acute rejection after heart transplantation in patients with dilated cardiomyopathy

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether humoral autoimmune responses associated with dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) influence the postoperative clinical course following cardiac transplantation.

METHODS

ELISA levels of preformed cardiac myosin (CM) autoantibodies (Abs) in patients with a pretransplant diagnosis of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) (n=64) and ischemic heart disease (IHD, n=53) were correlated with cardiac rejection, immunosuppression, and the incidence of endocardial infiltrates after transplantation.

RESULTS

Alpha- and beta-CM autoantibody (IgG and IgM) levels were similar in DCM and IHD patients but were statistically higher than in controls. Distribution of preformed (beta-CM) IgM-Abs in patients with and without rejection in the first postoperative year differed in the two groups. DCM patients rejected earlier P=0.006, and the frequency of rejection at 3 months was statistically higher than in IHD patients. Frequency and reactivity of IgM-Abs in DCM patients with rejection [International Society for Heart and Lung Transplant (ISHLT) grade I and above] was 28% compared with 7% in rejection-free patients, P<0.05. IgM-positive patients had a greater frequency and severity of rejection episodes and required more immunosuppression. These patients had rejection earlier than Ab-negative patients, P<0.009. There was no correlation between antibody status and rejection in IHD patients or with IgG in either group. Distribution of IgG subclass differed in the two diseases. DCM patients had significantly higher IgG3 reactivity; 70% of this activity was present in patients who developed moderate rejection. IgG3-positive patients experienced more frequent rejections, as well as a greater incidence of grade 3A/B rejection as the first episode, than did Ab-negative patients (50% vs. 15%), P<0.05. Frequency of endocardial infiltrates was statistically higher in IgG3-positive patients.

CONCLUSION

Proinflammatory characteristics of preformed IgG3 and IgM antibodies in DCM patients may influence the frequency and severity of cardiac rejection after transplantation.

Anti-skeletal muscle glycolipid antibodies in human heart transplantation as predictors of acute rejection: comparison with other risk factors

In forty-five patients who underwent orthotopic heart transplantation, the titer of anti-human skeletal muscle glycolipid antibodies (AGA) present in the sera at the moment of transplantation was correlated with the number of histologically diagnosed cellular grade 3A and humoral acute rejection episodes during the first 120 days after transplantation. Determination of a cutoff value of 0.800 for the AGA level was determined by a receiver operating characteristic curve. Thirteen of 19 patients (68.4%) with an AGA titer above 0.800 developed 24 severe rejection episodes, and of the 26 patients with an AGA titer below 0.800, only 4 (15.3%) presented 6 severe rejection episodes during that time. This was especially evident for the humoral rejection episodes, which were diagnosed in only 1 of the 26 patients with AGA below 0.800 and in 7 of the 19 with AGA above 0.800. Comparison by univariate analysis of other well-known risk factors for a greater number of rejection episodes during the early posttransplant period with the AGA level at the moment of transplantation revealed that the latter distinguished a greater number of patients at risk than the other factors, such as a female donor, the lymphocyte direct cross-match, or the status of the patients at transplantation; the odds ratios were 6.33 for the AGA level, 3.17 for the direct cross-match, and 2.76 for the status at transplantation. By multiple logistic regression analysis, the only relevant risk factors in our group of patients were the AGA level (P=0.0009) and the status at transplantation (P=0.0285). These results indicate that determination of the AGA level at the moment of transplantation could represent a useful method for distinguishing which patients are at risk for a greater number of rejection episodes during the early posttransplant period, with a greater sensitivity than other risk factors.

Presence of anti-FKBP12 autoantibodies in patients with liver allografts: its association with allograft rejection

BACKGROUND

It was reported that autoantibodies against cyclophilin are present in sera from systemic lupus erythematosus. We hypothesized that autoantibodies against FKBP12, another immunophilin, may be present in the plasma of liver allograft recipients, which may affect the clinical outcome of liver allografts.

METHODS

We investigated the relationship between the presence of anti-FKBP12 autoantibodies and rejection episodes in 47 patients treated with FK506 after living-related partial liver transplantation (LRLT). The patients consisted of two groups: 22 with rejection [R(+) group] and 25 without rejection [R(-) group]. The autoantibodies were measured by an indirect ELISA, and the specificity was confirmed by absorption with antigen and immunoblotting.

RESULTS

The autoantibodies were detected in 13 of 22 in the R(+) group (IgG: 5; IgM: 6; both: 2) and in 6 of 25 in the R(-) group (IgG: 2; IgM: 3; both: 1) before LRLT (P=0.0193). After LRLT, they were also detected more frequently in the R(+) group (12 of 22; IgG: 1; IgM: 8; both: 3) than in the R(-) group (2 of 25; IgG: 1; IgM: 1) (P=0.001). In the R(+) group, the mortality of the patients who were positive and negative for the autoantibodies was 6 of 12 and 2 of 10, respectively. The autoantibodies were detected in all four patients with chronic or refractory acute rejection. The autoantibodies were not detected in any of the 34 healthy subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that the presence of the autoantibodies in patients before transplantation is related to rejection, and the presence after transplantation may be associated with patient outcome.