Influence of the additional injection of host-type bone marrow on the immune tolerance of minor antigen-mismatched chimeras: possible involvement of double-negative (natural killer) T cells

Recipient lymphocyte infusion in MHC-matched bone marrow chimeras induces a limited lymphohematopoietic host-versus-graft reactivity but a significant antileukemic effect mediated by CD8+ T cells and natural killer cells

BACKGROUND

Challenge of MHC-mismatched murine bone marrow chimeras with recipient-type lymphocytes (recipient lymphocyte infusion) produces antileukemic responses in association with rejection of donor chimerism. In contrast, MHC-matched chimeras resist eradication of donor chimerism by recipient lymphocyte infusion. Here, we investigated lymphohematopoietic host-versus-graft reactivity and antileukemic responses in the MHC-matched setting, which is reminiscent of the majority of clinical transplants.

DESIGN AND METHODS

We challenged C3H→AKR radiation chimeras with AKR-type splenocytes (i.e. recipient lymphocyte infusion) and BW5147.3 leukemia cells. We studied the kinetics of chimerism using flowcytometry and the mechanisms involved in antileukemic effects using in vivo antibody-mediated depletion of CD8(+) T and NK cells, and intracellular cytokine staining.

RESULTS

Whereas control chimeras showed progressive evolution towards high-level donor T-cell chimerism, recipient lymphocyte infusion chimeras showed a limited reduction of donor chimerism with delayed onset and long-term preservation of lower-level mixed chimerism. Recipient lymphocyte infusion chimeras nevertheless showed a significant survival benefit after leukemia challenge. In vivo antibody-mediated depletion experiments showed that both CD8(+) T cells and NK cells contribute to the antileukemic effect. Consistent with a role for NK cells, the proportion of IFN-γ producing NK cells in recipient lymphocyte infusion chimeras was significantly higher than in control chimeras.

CONCLUSIONS

In the MHC-matched setting, recipient lymphocyte infusion elicits lymphohematopoietic host-versus-graft reactivity that is limited but sufficient to provide an antileukemic effect, and this is dependent on CD8(+) T cells and NK cells. The data indicate that NK cells are activated as a bystander phenomenon during lymphohematopoietic T-cell alloreactivity and thus support a novel type of NK involvement in anti-tumor responses after post-transplant adoptive cell therapy.

Tolerance and immunity following in utero transplantation of allogeneic fetal liver cells: the cytokine shift

Although in utero transplantation (IUT) has resulted in donor-specific tolerance to posnatal solid organ transplantation, the mechanisms of this tolerance remain poorly understood. Our recent findings demonstrate that under specific conditions prenatal injection of allogeneic cells may lead to allosensitization instead of tolerance. These laboratory observations were supported by clinical findings as well, and therefore suggested that, depending on the conditions of prenatal transplantation, tolerance or immunity may develop. The present study explored the role of CD4 cells, cytokines, and I-E superantigen in developing tolerance vs. immunity after in utero transplantation. Sixteen animals survived IUT (40-60% survival rate) and were free from any signs of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Mice were considered tolerant when their antidonor and antihost CTL responses were similar, sensitized when antidonor responses were significantly higher than antihost and anti-third-party responses, and nontolerant when antidonor responses in transplanted and control mice were similar. The TH1 --> TH2 shift was associated with tolerance and TH2 --> TH1 shift with allosensitization. Our results showed that tolerant BALB/c (H-2d, I-E+) --> CS7BL/6 (H-2b, I-E-) (2/7) mice showed higher IL-4 (p < 0.05) in antidonor MLR, and partial deletion of recipient I-E-reactive T cells (CD3Vbeta11) (p < 0.045). On the other hand, nontolerant animals (5/7) demonstrated high production of IFN-gamma (p < 0.05) without deletion of CD3Vbeta11 T cells. In C57CBL/6 (H-2b, I-E-) --> C3H (H-2k, I-E+) mice CD3Vbeta11 T cells do not play any role in tolerance induction because they are deleted in the C3H background. Tolerant mice (4/9) showed an overproduction of IL-4 (p < 0.05) in antidonor MLR whereas allosensitized animals (5/9) demonstrated high level of IFN-gamma (p < 0.05). Suppressor cells seem to play no role in tolerant C57BL/6 --> C3H as demonstrated by suppressor assay. Hence, a shift from TH1 --> TH2 or TH2 --> TH1 cytokines may determine whether tolerance or immunity develops.

Allogeneic cell-mediated immunotherapy of leukemia with immune donor lymphocytes to upregulate antitumor effects and downregulate antihost responses

Donor lymphocyte infusion mediates most effective graft- versus-leukemia (GVL) effects following induction of host-versus-graft tolerance by transplantation of donor stem cells. This study was designed to maximize GVL effects across both major (MHC) and minor (mHgs) histocompatibility barriers in recipients inoculated with murine B-cell leukemia (BCL1), using specifically immune donor lymphocytes. GVL effects were induced with donor spleen cells from mice immunized across MHC or mHgs barriers with BCL/1 cells or normal BALB/c spleen cells. Our data suggest that spleen cells from donor mice immunized against murine B-cell leukemia of BALB/c origin, or to a lesser extent against normal host alloantigens, induce better therapeutic GVL effects with less great-versus-host disease (GVHD) across both mHgs and MHC. The cytokine profile of effector cells inducing predominantly GVL effects with reduced GVHD across MHC and mHg barriers consisted preferentially of upregulated IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-10 and IL-12 in donors, implying a Th-1 to Th-2 cytokine shift. We hypothesize that immunotherapy with immune donor lymphocytes sensitized in vivo or in vitro with allogeneic tumor cells or normal host cells together with allogeneic BMT may provide an effective approach for amplifying GVL effects, while reducing procedure-related morbidity and mortality due to uncontrolled GVHD.

Complete freedom from rejection after intestinal transplantation using a new tolerogenic protocol combined with low immunosuppression

BACKGROUND

Intestinal transplantation (Itx) remains the most difficult form of transplantation. This is due to the high immunogenicity of the bowel that currently obligates Itx patients to heavy immunosuppression, which causes infection, posttransplant lymphoproliferative disease (PTLD), and drug toxicity. Wider application of Itx depends on the development of tolerogenic strategies to promote engraftment while reducing the need for immunosuppression. We applied a strategy to clinical Itx that combines intraportal donor-specific blood transfusion with a deliberately low immunosuppression protocol (no high-dose steroids; lower tacrolimus level).

METHODS

A 55-year-old patient received a combined liver/Itx. Donor-specific whole blood was taken from the donor during procurement and transfused in the recipient portal vein after graft reperfusion. For induction immunosuppression, no intravenous bolus of steroids was given; only two doses of anti-interleukin 2 receptor antibody were administered. The patient received posttransplantation maintenance immunosuppression with lower tacrolimus levels than average (15 ng/ml first month; 5-10 ng/ml thereafter), low-dose azathioprine (1 mg/kg first to third months; 0.5 mg/kg thereafter), and low-dose steroids (Medrol 8 mg twice daily first and second months; 4 mg twice thereafter). The patient was monitored for rejection, graft-versus-host disease, infection, and PTLD. Protocol biopsy specimens were taken from the distal ileum (2 per week).

RESULTS

Clinical, endoscopic, and histologic signs of rejection did not develop. Chimerism was identified at day 28. Graft-versus-host disease was absent clinically. Chimerism was self-limiting and disappeared without modifying baseline immunosuppression and without observing a change in graft function. The patient remained free of systemic opportunistic infections, PTLD, and drug toxicity. Total parenteral nutrition was stopped at 7 weeks after transplantation. The patient remains free of total parenteral nutrition and free of rejection at 14 months after transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

We describe an Itx patient who remained rejection free despite receiving significantly lower immunosuppression than average. We hypothesize that intraoperative immunomodulation via intraportal donor-specific blood transfusion in the absence of nonspecific overimmunosuppression promoted Itx acceptance.

An overview of real-time quantitative PCR: applications to quantify cytokine gene expression

The analysis of cytokine profiles helps to clarify functional properties of immune cells, both for research and for clinical diagnosis. The real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) is becoming widely used to quantify cytokines from cells, body fluids, tissues, or tissue biopsies. Being a very powerful and sensitive method it can be used to quantify mRNA expression levels of cytokines, which are often very low in the tissues under investigation. The method allows for the direct detection of PCR product during the exponential phase of the reaction, combining amplification and detection in one single step. In this review we discuss the principle of real-time RT-PCR, the different methodologies and chemistries available, the assets, and some of the pitfalls. With the TaqMan chemistry and the 7700 Sequence Detection System (Applied Biosystems), validation for a large panel of murine and human cytokines and other factors playing a role in the immune system is discussed in detail. In summary, the real-time RT-PCR technique is very accurate and sensitive, allows a high throughput, and can be performed on very small samples; therefore it is the method of choice for quantification of cytokine profiles in immune cells or inflamed tissues.

Transforming growth factor-beta inhibits lymphokine activated killer cytotoxicity of bone marrow cells: implications for the graft-versus-leukemia effect in irradiation allogeneic bone marrow chimeras

BACKGROUND

We have previously shown that allogeneic bone marrow (BM) chimeras preconditioned with total lymphoid irradiation and low-dose total body irradiation (TLI/TBI) develop a stronger graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) effect than chimeras preconditioned with high-dose total body irradiation only (TBI). Here, we report on the possible role of cytokines in the mechanism underlying this GVL effect.

METHODS

Splenic mRNA levels of the cytokines interleukin (IL)-1, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-7, IL-10, IL-12, IL-15, interferon-gamma, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, and transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta), and of inducible nitric oxide synthetase were determined by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction in TLI/TBI- or TBI-conditioned C3H/AKR BM chimeras challenged with AKR-type BW5147.3 leukemia cells. Ex vivo TGF-beta protein production by splenocytes was determined using ELISA. The possibility that cytokines influence the GVL effect by modulating the activity of IL-2-activated lymphocytes (LAK cells) was investigated by in vitro assays on donor-type BM cells.

RESULTS

Of all cytokine mRNA levels studied, those of TGF-beta and IL-7 were different between groups; both were significantly more elevated in TBI- than in TLI/ TBI-conditioned or normal mice. Differences were apparent after conditioning and were not influenced by additionally injected BM or leukemia cells. Cultured splenocytes of TBI-conditioned animals produced significantly more TGF-beta protein than those of TLI/TBI-conditioned ones or normal controls. r-TGF-beta but not r-IL-7 suppressed in vitro LAK activity of donor-type BM cells against BW5147.3 cells in a dose-dependent way.

CONCLUSIONS

High-dose TBI-induced, host-derived splenic TGF-beta may inhibit generation of LAK cells from subsequently transplanted donor BM cells, suppressing their capacity to generate cytotoxicity upon injection of leukemia cells. The cytokine profile, induced by irradiation in host hematopoietic organs, can significantly modify posttransplant immunological processes such as the GVL effect and graft-versus-host disease (GVHD).

Graft-versus-leukemia effect in minor antigen mismatched chimeras given delayed donor leucocyte infusion: immunoregulatory aspects and role of donor T and ASGM1-positive cells

BACKGROUND

Previous studies have demonstrated that delayed donor leukocyte infusion (DLI) can increase graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) without increasing graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD) in MHC mismatched bone marrow (BM) chimeras. In our report, the immune status of minor antigen mismatched BM chimeras given DLI was studied. Particularly the role of donor ASGM1 positive or T cells in the graft-versus-leukemia effect (GVL) was investigated.

METHODS

AKR mice (H2k, Mls1a, Thy1.1) received TBI (9,5 Gy) and T cell-depleted (TCD) C3H (H2k, Mls2a, Thy1.2) BM alone (BM chimeras), or TCD BM together with immunocompetent C3H spleen cells at the time of BM transplantation (BM+SP chimeras), or TCD BM and 3 weeks later C3H spleen cells (DLI chimeras). Chimerism and T lymphocyte subsets were scored using FACS and anti-Thy, anti-Vbeta6, anti-IL2-beta receptor, anti-CD4, anti-CD3, and anti-CD8 mAbs. Leukemia challenge consisted of 5 x 10(6) AKR T cell lymphoma (BW4157) cells injected i.v. ASGM1 positive (ASGM1+) cells and T cells were depleted using anti-ASGM1 or anti-Thy1.2 antibodies, respectively. Immune tolerance was studied using MLR and CML tests.

RESULTS

BM + SP chimeras developed acute and lethal GVHD, whereas DLI chimeras were totally free from GVHD. In DLI chimeras, host-reactive cytotoxic T cells (CTL) could not be induced and host-reactive CD8Vbeta6 cells were deleted whereas CD4Vbeta6 cells and MLR reactivity persisted temporarily. In contrast, in BM+SP chimeras, anti-host CTL were easily generated and an expansion of both host-reactive CD8Vbeta6 and CD4Vbeta6 T cells was found as well as high anti-host MLR reactivity. Depletion of either ASGM1 + cells or T cells from the DLI inoculum resulted in an abrogation of GVL reactivity, suggesting that both cell populations were involved in the protection against BW4157 leukemia. Three weeks after DLI, the GVL effect waned which correlated with the disappearance of host-reactive CD4 cells and MLR reactivity.

CONCLUSION

In minor antigen mismatched BM chimeras, anti-host reactivity after DLI is characterized by (1) an absence of clinical GVHD, (2) clonal deletion of host-reactive CD8 cells, (3) an absence of anti-host CTL induction, and ( 4) a temporary persistence of host-reactive CD4 T cells and of MLR reactivity. In addition, either donor ASGM1+ cells or an interaction between these cells and T cells contribute to the GVL effect.