T cell and B cell tolerance to GALalpha1,3GAL-expressing heart xenografts is achieved in alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase-deficient mice by nonmyeloablative induction of mixed chimerism

Progress in xenotransplantation: overcoming immune barriers

A major limitation of organ allotransplantation is the insufficient supply of donor organs. Consequently, thousands of patients die every year while waiting for a transplant. Progress in xenotransplantation that has permitted pig organ graft survivals of years in non-human primates has led to renewed excitement about the potential of this approach to alleviate the organ shortage. In 2022, the first pig-to-human heart transplant was performed on a compassionate use basis, and xenotransplantation experiments using pig kidneys in deceased human recipients provided encouraging data. Many advances in xenotransplantation have resulted from improvements in the ability to genetically modify pigs using CRISPR-Cas9 and other methodologies. Gene editing has the capacity to generate pig organs that more closely resemble those of humans and are hence more physiologically compatible and less prone to rejection. Despite such modifications, immune responses to xenografts remain powerful and multi-faceted, involving innate immune components that do not attack allografts. Thus, the induction of innate and adaptive immune tolerance to prevent rejection while preserving the capacity of the immune system to protect the recipient and the graft from infection is desirable to enable clinical xenotransplantation.

Cellular Immune Responses in Islet Xenograft Rejection

Porcine islets surviving the acute injury caused by humoral rejection and IBMIR will be subjected to cellular xenograft rejection, which is predominately mediated by CD4⁺ T cells and is characterised by significant infiltration of macrophages, B cells and T cells (CD4⁺ and CD8⁺). Overall, the response is different compared to the alloimmune response and more difficult to suppress. Activation of CD4⁺ T cells is both by direct and indirect antigen presentation. After activation they recruit macrophages and direct B cell responses. Although they are less important than CD4⁺ T cells in islet xenograft rejection, macrophages are believed to be a major effector cell in this response. Rodent studies have shown that xenoantigen-primed and CD4⁺ T cell-activated macrophages were capable of recognition and rejection of pancreatic islet xenografts, and they destroyed a graft via the secretion of various proinflammatory mediators, including TNF-α, reactive oxygen and nitrogen species, and complement factors. B cells are an important mediator of islet xenograft rejection via xenoantigen presentation, priming effector T cells and producing xenospecific antibodies. Depletion and/or inhibition of B cells combined with suppressing T cells has been suggested as a promising strategy for induction of xeno-donor-specific T- and B-cell tolerance in islet xenotransplantation. Thus, strategies that expand the influence of regulatory T cells and inhibit and/or reduce macrophage and B cell responses are required for use in combination with clinical applicable immunosuppressive agents to achieve effective suppression of the T cell-initiated xenograft response.

Chimerism-Based Tolerance to Kidney Allografts in Humans: Novel Insights and Future Perspectives

Chronic rejection and immunosuppression-related toxicity severely affect long-term outcomes of kidney transplantation. The induction of transplantation tolerance – the lack of destructive immune responses to a transplanted organ in the absence of immunosuppression – could potentially overcome these limitations. Immune tolerance to kidney allografts from living donors has been successfully achieved in humans through clinical protocols based on chimerism induction with hematopoietic cell transplantation after non-myeloablative conditioning. Notably, two of these protocols have led to immune tolerance in a significant fraction of HLA-mismatched donor-recipient combinations, which represent the large majority of cases in clinical practice. Studies in mice and large animals have been critical in dissecting tolerance mechanisms and in selecting the most promising approaches for human translation. However, there are several key differences in tolerance induction between these models and humans, including the rate of success and stability of donor chimerism, as well as the relative contribution of different mechanisms in inducing donor-specific unresponsiveness. Kidney allograft tolerance achieved through durable full-donor chimerism may be due to central deletion of graft-reactive donor T cells, even though mechanistic data from patient series are lacking. On the other hand, immune tolerance attained with transient mixed chimerism-based protocols initially relies on Treg-mediated suppression, followed by peripheral deletion of donor-reactive recipient T-cell clones under antigenic pressure from the graft. These conclusions were supported by data deriving from novel high-throughput T-cell receptor sequencing approaches that allowed tracking of alloreactive repertoires over time. In this review, we summarize the most important mechanistic studies on tolerance induction with combined kidney-bone marrow transplantation in humans, discussing open issues that still need to be addressed and focusing on techniques developed in recent years to efficiently monitor the alloresponse in tolerance trials. These cutting-edge methods will be instrumental for the development of immune tolerance protocols with improved efficacy and to identify patients amenable to safe immunosuppression withdrawal.

Mixed xenogeneic porcine chimerism tolerizes human anti-pig natural antibody-producing cells in a humanized mouse model

BACKGROUND

A major obstacle to the success of organ transplantation from pigs to humans, necessitated by the shortage of human organs, is robust humoral immune rejection by pig-reactive human antibodies. Mixed xenogeneic hematopoietic chimerism induces xenoreactive B cell tolerance in rodents, but whether mixed pig/human chimerism could induce tolerance of human B cells to pig xenoantigens is unknown.

METHODS

We investigated this question using a humanized mouse model in which durable mixed (pig-human) xenogeneic chimerism can be established.

RESULTS

Human natural anti-pig cytotoxic antibodies, predominantly IgM, are detectable in non-chimeric humanized mouse serum, and pig-reactive antibodies were reduced in mixed chimeric versus non-chimeric humanized mice. This difference required persistent mixed chimerism and was not due to the adsorption of antibodies on pig cells in vivo. Furthermore, human B cells from spleens of mixed chimeric mice produced lower levels of anti-pig antibodies when stimulated in vitro compared with those from non-chimeric mice.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings demonstrate that mixed chimerism reduces human natural antibodies to pig xenoantigens, providing the first in vivo evidence of human B cell tolerance induction by mixed xenogeneic chimerism and supporting further evaluation of this approach for inducing human B cell tolerance to xenografts.

Intra-bone bone marrow transplantation from hCD47 transgenic pigs to baboons prolongs chimerism to >60 days and promotes increased porcine lung transplant survival

BACKGROUND

We have recently demonstrated that human-CD47 (hCD47) expressed on endothelial cells of porcine lung xenografts extended median graft survival from 3.5 days to 8.7 days in baboons. Intra-bone bone marrow transplantation (IBBMTx) in a pig-to-baboon model was previously shown to markedly prolong the duration of macrochimerism up to 21 days from 1 to 4 days by intravenous BMTx. We now examined whether the use of hCD47 transgenic (Tg) BM further prolonged the duration of chimerism following IBBMTx. We then tested if lung xenograft survival was prolonged following IBBMTx.

METHODS

Baboons received GalTKO-hCD47/hCD55Tg (n = 5) or -hCD55Tg (n = 1) or -hCD46/HLA-E Tg (n = 1) pig IBBMTx. Macrochimerism, anti-pig T cells and antibody responses were assessed. Animals received lung xenografts from either hCD47+ or hCD47- porcine lungs 1-3 months later.

RESULTS

All baboons that received hCD47Tg porcine IBBM maintained durable macrochimerism >30 days, and two maintained chimerism for >8 weeks. Notably, anti-pig antibody levels decreased over time and anti-pig cellular unresponsiveness developed following IBBMTx. Lungs from hCD47Tg IBBMTx matched pigs were transplanted at day 33 or day 49 after IBBMTx. These animals showed extended survival up to 13 and 14 days, while animals that received lungs from hCD47 negative pigs displayed no prolonged survival (1-4 days).

CONCLUSION

This is the first report demonstrating durable macrochimerism beyond 8 weeks, as well as evidence for B cell tolerance in large animal xenotransplantation. Using hCD47Tg pigs as both IBBMTx and lung donors prolongs lung xenograft survival. However, additional strategies are required to control the acute loss of lung xenografts.

Xenotransplantation tolerance: applications for recent advances in modified swine

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The aim of this study was to review the recent progress in xenotransplantation achieved through genetic engineering and discuss the potential of tolerance induction to overcome remaining barriers to extended xenograft survival.

RECENT FINDINGS

The success of life-saving allotransplantation has created a demand for organ transplantation that cannot be met by the supply of human organs. Xenotransplantation is one possible solution that would allow for a nearly unlimited supply of organs. Recent genetic engineering of swine has decreased the reactivity of preformed antibodies to some, but not all, potential human recipients. Experiments using genetically modified swine organs have now resulted in survival of life-supporting kidneys for over a year. However, the grafts show evidence of antibody-mediated rejection on histology, suggesting additional measures will be required for further extension of graft survival. Tolerance induction through mixed chimerism or thymic transplantation across xenogeneic barriers would be well suited for patients with a positive crossmatch to genetically modified swine or relatively negative crossmatches to genetically modified swine, respectively.

SUMMARY

This review highlights the current understanding of the immunologic processes in xenotransplantation and describes the development and application of strategies designed to overcome them from the genetic modification of the source animal to the induction of tolerance to xenografts.

IXA Honorary Member Lecture, 2017: The long and winding road to tolerance

The last 15 years or so have seen exciting progress in xenotransplantation, with porcine organ grafts surviving months or even years in non-human primates. These advances reflect the application of new scientific knowledge, improved immunosuppressive agents, and genetic engineering. The field has recently enjoyed a renaissance of interest and hope, largely due to the exponential increase in our capacity to genetically engineer porcine source animals. However, immune responses to xenografts are very powerful and widespread clinical application of xenotransplantation will depend on the ability to suppress these immune responses while preserving the capacity to protect both the recipient and the graft from infectious microorganisms. Our work over the last three decades has aimed to engineer the immune system of the recipient in a manner that achieves specific tolerance to the xenogeneic donor while preserving otherwise normal immune function. Important proofs of principle have been obtained, first in rodents, and later in human immune systems in "humanized mice" and finally in non-human primates, demonstrating the capacity and potential synergy of mixed xenogeneic chimerism and xenogeneic thymic transplantation in tolerizing multiple arms of the immune system. Considering the fact that clinical tolerance has recently been achieved for allografts and the even greater importance of avoiding excessive immunosuppression for xenografts, it is my belief that it is both possible and imperative that we likewise achieve xenograft tolerance. I expect this to be accomplished through the availability of targeted approaches to recipient immune conditioning, understanding of immunological mechanisms of tolerance, advanced knowledge of physiological incompatibilities, and the availability of inbred miniature swine with optimized use of genetic engineering.

Tolerance in xenotransplantation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review describes recent progress in tolerance-inducing strategies across xenogeneic immunological barriers as well as the potential benefit of a tolerance strategy for islets and kidney xenotransplantation.

RECENT FINDINGS

Using advanced gene editing technologies, xenotransplantation from multitransgenic alpha-1,3-galactosyltransferase knockout pigs has demonstrated marked prolongation of renal xenograft survival, ranging from days to greater than several months for life-supporting kidneys, and more than 2 years in a heterotopic nonlife-supporting cardiac xenograft model. Continuous administration of multiple immunosuppressive drugs has been required and attempts to taper immunosuppression have been unsuccessful. It appears likely that low levels of T cell dependent antibodies and activation of innate responses are responsible for xenograft loss. Mixed chimerism and thymic transplantation approaches have achieved xenogeneic tolerance in pig-to-mouse models and both have recently been extended to pig-to-baboon models. Encouraging results have been reported, including persistence of macrochimerism, prolonged pig skin graft survival, donor-specific unresponsiveness in vitro and detection of recent T cell emigrants in vivo.

SUMMARY

Although tolerance induction in vivo has not yet been achieved in pig-to-baboon models, recent results are encouraging that this goal will be attainable through genetic engineering of porcine donors.

Xenotransplantation: immunological hurdles and progress toward tolerance

The discrepancy between organ need and organ availability represents one of the major limitations in the field of transplantation. One possible solution to this problem is xenotransplantation. Research in this field has identified several obstacles that have so far prevented the successful development of clinical xenotransplantation protocols. The main immunologic barriers include strong T-cell and B-cell responses to solid organ and cellular xenografts. In addition, components of the innate immune system can mediate xenograft rejection. Here, we review these immunologic and physiologic barriers and describe some of the strategies that we and others have developed to overcome them. We also describe the development of two strategies to induce tolerance across the xenogeneic barrier, namely thymus transplantation and mixed chimerism, from their inception in rodent models through their current progress in preclinical large animal models. We believe that the addition of further beneficial transgenes to Gal knockout swine, combined with new therapies such as Treg administration, will allow for successful clinical application of xenotransplantation.

Role of xenotransplantation in cardiac transplantation

This review will discuss the history and development of the field of genetic modification, up to the most recent scientific discoveries, and will also consider the current uses of genetic therapy.

Emerging concepts in haematopoietic cell transplantation

Haematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) is the most widely used form of cellular therapy. It is the only known cure for some haematological malignancies and has recently been used in additional clinical settings, such as allograft tolerance induction and treatment of autoimmune diseases. Recent advances have enabled HCT in a wider range of patients with improved outcomes. This Review summarizes the latest developments in this therapy, focusing on issues that will affect future advancement.

Innate and adaptive immune responses are tolerized in chimeras prepared with nonmyeloablative conditioning

BACKGROUND

Mixed chimerism is an effective approach for tolerance induction in transplantation. Strategies to achieve mixed chimerism with relatively low toxicity have significantly expanded the clinical use of chimerism.

METHODS

Allogeneic bone marrow transplants were performed between B6 (H2(b)) and BALB/c (H2(d)) mice. Recipient B6 mice were nonmyeloablatively conditioned with anti-αβ-T-cell receptor, anti-CD154, or rapamycin alone or in different combinations. A total of 15 × 10(6) BALB/c bone marrow cells were transplanted after varying doses of cGy of total body irradiation.

RESULTS

Pretreatment of recipients with anti-CD154 and rapamycin with or without T-cell lymphodepletion reduced the total body irradiation requirement to 100 cGy for establishing stable mixed chimerism. The mixed chimeras accepted donor islet allografts long term. Lymphocytes from mixed chimeras did not respond to host or donor antigens, yet were reactive to major histocompatibility complex-disparate third-party alloantigens, demonstrating functional donor-specific T-cell tolerance. No antibodies against donor and host were detected in mixed chimeras, suggesting humoral tolerance. Mixed chimeras showed no cytotoxicity to donor cells, but a similar rapid killing rate for major histocompatibility complex disparate third-party B10.BR cells compared with T-cell-deficient and wild-type controls in in vivo cytotoxicity assays, suggesting donor-specific tolerance in the innate immune cells was achieved in mixed chimeras.

CONCLUSIONS

Mixed chimeras prepared with low-intensity nonmyeloablative conditioning exhibit systemic tolerance in innate immunity and tolerance in adaptive T- and B-cell immune responses.

Current progress in xenogeneic tolerance

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The present review updates the current status of research regarding the immunologic responses of the recipient following xenotransplantation. Additionally, we present the recent progress with attempts to induce xenogeneic tolerance induction.

RECENT FINDINGS

There continues to be great interest in xenotransplantation. Recently, descriptions of the mechanisms responsible for attempted T-cell xenogeneic tolerance in both large and small animal models have improved xenogeneic graft survivals. Additionally, the cellular signaling mechanisms, such as those involving CD39, CD44, and CD47, are proving to be highly important. Using the mixed chimerism approach to tolerance in xenogeneic model may be encouraging, especially given the recent clarification of the role for macrophage-induced phagocytosis of xenogeneic donor cells.

SUMMARY

Induction of tolerance to xenogeneic antigens has been accomplished only in small animals; however, graft survivals in large animal models continue to improve. Further clarification of both the adaptive and innate immune responses to xenogeneic antigens is required for success to continue.

CD47 in xenograft rejection and tolerance induction

Robust immune responses to xenografts remain a major obstacle to clinical translation of xenotransplantation, which could otherwise be a potential solution to the worldwide shortage of organ donors. The more vigorous xenograft rejection relative to allograft rejection is largely accounted for by the extensive genetic disparities between the donor and recipient. Xenografts activate host immunity not only by expressing immunogenic xenoantigens that provide the targets for immune recognition and rejection, but also by lacking ligands for the host immune inhibitory receptors. This review is focused on recent findings regarding the role of CD47, a ligand of an immune inhibitory receptor SIRPalpha, in xenograft rejection and induction of xenotolerance.

Xenotransplantation: where are we in 2008?

Xenotransplantation holds promise to solve the ever increasing shortage of donor organs for allotransplantation. In the last 2 decades, major progress has been made in understanding the immunobiology of pig-into-(non)human primate transplantation and today we are on the threshold of the first clinical trials. Hyperacute rejection, which is mediated by pre-existing anti-alpha Gal xenoreactive antibodies, can in non-human primates be overcome by complement- and/or antibody-modifying interventions. A major step forward was the development of genetically engineered pigs, either transgenic for human complement regulatory proteins or deficient in the alpha1,3-galactosyltranferase enzyme. However, several other immunologic and nonimmunologic hurdles remain. Acute vascular xenograft rejection is mediated by humoral and cellular mechanisms. Elicited xenoreactive antibodies play a key role. In addition to providing B cell help, xenoreactive T cells may directly contribute to xenograft rejection. Long-term survival of porcine kidney- and heart xenografts in non-human primates has been obtained but required severe T and B cell immunosuppression. Induction of xenotolerance, e.g. through mixed hematopoietic chimerism, may represent the preferred approach, but although proof of principle has been delivered in rodents, induction of pig-to-non-human primate chimerism remains problematic. Finally, it is now clear that innate immune cells, in particular macrophages and natural killer cells, can mediate xenograft destruction, the determinants of which are being elucidated. Chronic xenograft rejection is not well understood, but recent studies indicate that non-immunological problems, such as incompatibilities between human procoagulant and pig anticoagulant components may play an important role. Here, we give a comprehensive overview of the currently known obstacles to xenografting: immune and non-immune problems are discussed, as well as the possible strategies that are under development to overcome these hurdles.

Rapidly induced, T-cell–independent xenoantibody production is mediated by marginal zone B cells and requires help from NK cells

Xenoantibody production directed at a wide variety of T lymphocyte–dependent and T lymphocyte–independent xenoantigens remains the major immunologic obstacle for successful xenotransplantation. The B lymphocyte subpopulations and their helper factors, involved in T-cell–independent xenoantibody production are only partially understood, and their identification will contribute to the clinical applicability of xenotransplantation. Here we show, using models involving T-cell–deficient athymic recipient mice, that rapidly induced, T-cell–independent xenoantibody production is mediated by marginal zone B lymphocytes and requires help from natural killer (NK) cells. This collaboration neither required NK-cell–mediated IFN-γ production, nor NK-cell–mediated cytolytic killing of xenogeneic target cells. The T-cell–independent IgM xenoantibody response could be partially suppressed by CD40L blockade.

Global unresponsiveness as a mechanism of natural killer cell tolerance in mixed xenogeneic chimeras

Mixed xenogeneic chimerism induces T- and B-cell tolerance in mice receiving T-cell-depleted rat bone marrow cells (BMC) following nonmyeloablative conditioning that includes alphabeta and gammadelta T cell and Natural killer (NK) cell-depleting mAbs. NK-cell depletion is essential to permit marrow engraftment, but NK-cell tolerance has not been previously assessed in mixed xenogeneic chimeras. We assessed NK-cell tolerance in rat --> mouse mixed xenogeneic chimeras using in vivo(125)I-5iodo-2-deoxyuridine assays. Additional rapid marrow rejection mechanisms resulted in a requirement for 10-fold more rat than ss2 microglobulin knockout (ss2M(-/-)) (MHC class I-deficient) mouse BMC to achieve engraftment in NK-cell-depleted mice. Both 12-week mixed xenogeneic chimeras and conditioned controls showed reduced resistance to engraftment of ss2M(-/-) mouse and rat BMC. While conditioned control mice recovered NK-cell-mediated resistance to ss2M(-/-) and rat BMC by 16 weeks, mixed chimeras lacked resistance to either, similar to NK-cell-deficient Ly49A transgenic mice. Thus, global NK-cell unresponsiveness is induced by mixed xenogeneic chimerism. Our data suggest that NK-cell anergy is induced by interactions with xenogeneic hematopoietic cells that express activating but not inhibitory ligands for recipient NK cells.

Immune tolerance: mechanisms and application in clinical transplantation

The achievement of immune tolerance, a state of specific unresponsiveness to the donor graft, has the potential to overcome the current major limitations to progress in organ transplantation, namely late graft loss, organ shortage and the toxicities of chronic nonspecific immumnosuppressive therapy. Advances in our understanding of immunological processes, mechanisms of rejection and tolerance have led to encouraging developments in animal models, which are just beginning to be translated into clinical pilot studies. These advances are reviewed here and the appropriate timing for clinical trials is discussed.

Carbohydrate residues downstream of the terminal Galalpha(1,3)Gal epitope modulate the specificity of xenoreactive antibodies

Carbohydrates are involved in many immunological responses including the rejection of incompatible blood, tissues and organs. Carbohydrate antigens with Galalpha(1,3)Gal epitopes are recognized by natural antibodies in humans and pose a major barrier for pig-to-human xenotransplantation. Genetically modified pigs have been established that have no functional alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase (alpha1,3GT), which transfers alphaGal to N-acetyllactosamine (LacNAc) type oligosaccharides. However, a low level of Galalpha(1,3)Gal is still expressed in alpha1,3GT knockout animals in the form of a lipid, isoglobotrihexosylceramide (iGb3), which is produced by iGb3 synthase on lactose (Lac) type core structures. Here, we define the reactivity of a series of monoclonal antibodies (mAb) generated in alpha1,3GT-/- mice immunized with rabbit red blood cells (RbRBC), as a rich source of lipid-linked antigens. Interestingly, one mAb (15.101) binds weakly to synthetic and cell surface-expressed Galalpha(1,3)Gal on LacNAc, but strongly to versions of the antigen on Lac cores, including iGb3. Three-dimensional models suggest that the terminal alpha-linked Gal binds tightly into the antibody-binding cavity. Furthermore, antibody interactions were predicted with the second and third monosaccharide units. Collectively, our findings suggest that although the terminal carbohydrate residues confer most of the binding affinity, the fine specificity is determined by subsequent residues in the oligosaccharide.

Xenotransplantation: current status and a perspective on the future

Xenotransplantation using pigs as the transplant source has the potential to resolve the severe shortage of human organ donors. Although the development of relatively non-toxic immunosuppressive or tolerance-inducing regimens will be required to justify clinical trials using pig organs, recent advances in our understanding of the biology of xenograft rejection and zoonotic infections, and the generation of alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase-deficient pigs have moved this approach closer to clinical application. This Review highlights the major obstacles impeding the translation of xenotransplantation into clinical therapies and the potential solutions, providing a perspective on the future of clinical xenotransplantation.

Recent Progress in Tolerance Induction through Mixed Chimerism

Organ transplant recipients require life-long treatment with immunosuppressive drugs. Currently available immunosuppression is associated with substantial morbidity and mortality, and is ineffective in inhibiting chronic rejection and graft loss. Therefore, a permanent state of donor-specific tolerance remains a primary goal for transplantation research. The induction of mixed hematopoietic chimerism is an attractive concept in this regard. Hematopoietic chimerism modulates the immunologic repertoire by extending the mechanisms of self-tolerance to donor-specific allotolerance. Despite recent progress in developing nontoxic bone marrow transplantation protocols for rodents, translation to large animals has remained difficult. Here, we outline the concept of tolerance via mixed chimerism, and review recent progress and remaining challenges in bringing this approach to the clinical setting.

American society of transplantation symposium on B cells in transplantation: harnessing humoral immunity from rodent models to clinical practice

There is growing awareness that B cells and alloantibodies are important mediators of both acute and chronic allograft injury. Unfortunately, few therapies are clinically available to mitigate the function of B cells or the effects of established alloantibody. As a result, many sensitized people await transplantation without a suitable donor, and several rejection syndromes are emerging that appear to involve B cells either as antibody producers or as antigen-presenting cells. In recognition of this unmet need in transplantation, the American Society of Transplantation organized a Symposium on B cells in Organ Transplantation to foster interest in this topic amongst basic researchers attending the annual meeting of the American Association of Immunologists. This manuscript will give an overview of the presentations from this symposium including the current risks of allosensitization, adaptive accommodation, approaches toward B-cell tolerance for allo- and xenoantigens and clinical application of these concepts in ABO incompatible neonatal cardiac transplantation.

Clinical xenotransplantation of organs: why aren't we there yet?

Mohiuddin discusses the lessons learned from large animal xenograft models and why the immunological barrier is still the most important hurdle preventing clinical xenotransplantation of organs.

B-cell extrinsic CR1/CR2 promotes natural antibody production and tolerance induction of anti-alphaGAL-producing B-1 cells

B-1b cells produce IgM natural antibodies against alpha1-3Galbeta1-4GlcNAc (alphaGal). These can be tolerized by nonmyeloablative induction of mixed chimerism using alphaGal-positive (alphaGal+) donor marrow. We assessed the role of CR1/2 in this model for induction of tolerance of B-1b cells. Mixed hematopoietic chimerism was induced in alpha1-3galactosyltransferase (GalT-/-) and GalT-/-Cr2-/- mice with alphaGal+ BALB/c marrow donors. Anti-alphaGal Ab and anti-alphaGal Ab-producing B cells became undetectable in GalT-/- chimeras, whereas they persisted in chimeric GalT-/-Cr2-/- mice. To determine whether CR1/2 expression on stromal cells and/or hematopoietic cells was critical for B-1-cell tolerance, we generated GalT-/- radiation chimeras in which CR1/CR2 was expressed on either stromal cells, hematopoietic cells, neither, or both. After induction of mixed chimerism from alphaGal+ allogeneic bone marrow (BM) donors, anti-alphaGal-producing B cells were rendered tolerant in reconstituted recipients expressing only stromal CR1/CR2. Our results suggest a possible role for follicular dendritic cells that pick up immune complexes via CR1/CR2 receptors in the tolerization of B-1b cells.

Long-term survival of xenogeneic heart grafts achieved by costimulatory blockade and transient mixed chimerism

BACKGROUND

Xenotransplantation holds great promise in clinical medicine, but is limited by the vigorous rejection response elicited against solid organs transplanted across species barriers. In this study, we investigated the role of anti-CD40L monoclonal antibody (mAb) in inducing xenogeneic mixed chimerism and donor-specific heart transplantation tolerance.

METHODS

One day before heart transplantation, mice were injected intraperitoneally with anti-mouse CD8/NK1.1/Thy1.2 mAbs. On day 0, the mice received 3 Gy total body irradiation (TBI), an intravenous injection of unseparated bone marrow (BM) harvested from F344 rats, and an intraperitoneal injection of hamster antimouse CD40L mAb, MR1. Heart grafts from F344 rats were heterotopically transplanted into the abdomen of B6 mouse recipients. Using flow cytometric analysis of peripheral white blood cells, we assessed donor hematopoiesis at various times after bone marrow transplantation (BMT).

RESULTS

Chimerism subsided gradually and disappeared completely 18 weeks after BMT. The cardiac graft survived permanently, even after the mixed chimerism disappeared. To determine if the mice acquired donor-specific tolerance, second rat heart grafts were transplanted 120 days after the first heart transplantation. The second transplanted hearts were also accepted over 60 days. Histological analysis revealed no remarkable vasculopathy in the coronary vessels at any stage.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings clearly show that costimulatory blockade plays an important role in inducing xenochimerism, and that transient mixed chimerism can induce permanent acceptance of rat to mouse cardiac xenografts. Transplantation of xenogeneic bone marrow cells under costimulatory blockade at the time of heart transplantation may induce transplantation tolerance.

B-cell tolerance

Autoreactive B cells are actively tolerized to more abundant self-antigens by a series of checkpoints involving receptor editing, deletion, anergy and competition for growth factors. In contrast, B cells reactive against rare, sequestered or tissue specific self-antigens remain functionally naïve. During an immune response, the autoimmune danger from these cells is countered by a variety of mechanisms comprising control of self-antigen presentation, limitation of immunogenic and tolerogenic costimuli including T cell help, homeostatic control of growth and strict regulation of germinal centre reactions. In this overview we consider how knowledge of these checkpoints may be used to gain a better understanding of transplant tolerance and the generation of alloantibodies.

Tolerance induction by lentiviral gene therapy with a nonmyeloablative regimen

Antibodies (Abs) directed at the Galα1,3Galβ1,4GlcNAc-R (αGal) carbohydrate epitope initiate xenograft rejection. Previously, we have shown that bone marrow transplantation (BMT) with lentivirus-mediated gene transfer of porcine α1,3 galactosyltransferase (GalT) is able to induce tolerance to αGal-expressing heart grafts following a lethal dose of irradiation. Here we show the first demonstration of permanent survival of αGal+ hearts following transplantation with autologous, lentivirus-transduced BM using a nonmyeloablative regimen. Autologous BM from GalT knockout (GalT–/–) mice was transduced with a lentiviral vector expressing porcine GalT and transplanted into sublethally irradiated (3 Gy) GalT–/– mice. Chimerism in the peripheral blood cells (PBCs) remained low but was higher in the BM, especially within the stromal cell population. Mice reconstituted with GalT did not produce anti-αGal Abs over time. We immunized these mice with αGal-expressing cells and assessed humoral immune responses. Anti-αGal xenoantibodies were not produced in mice reconstituted with GalT, but normal Ab responses to other xenoantigens were detected. Mice reconstituted with GalT accepted αGal+ heart grafts over 100 days. Transduction with lentiviral vectors results in chimerism at levels sufficient to induce long-term tolerance under nonmyeloablative conditions.

Decay-Accelerating Factor Prevents Acute Humoral Rejection Induced by Low Levels of Anti-αGal Natural Antibodies

BACKGROUND

Hyperacute and delayed vascular rejection due to natural antibodies (NAb) present major obstacles in pig-to-primate xenotransplantation. Although "supraphysiologic" expression of human complement regulatory proteins (CRPs) can prevent hyperacute rejection in discordant xenogenic recipients, their physiologic role in the homologous setting is undefined. We have evaluated the effect of the absence of decay-accelerating factor (DAF) on cardiac allograft rejection in the presence of different levels of antidonor antibodies (Ab).

METHODS

DAF1-deficient (DAF KO; B6129F2 H-2) mice were used as heart graft donors to alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase deficient (GalT KO; B6, H-2) recipients. Heterotopic heart grafting was performed with or without presensitization. Graft survival, histology, and anti-alphaGal Ab levels were monitored.

RESULTS

DAF knockout (KO) but not wild-type (WT) grafts showed hyperacute or acute humoral rejection in nonsensitized GalT KO mice with low levels of anti-alphaGal IgM NAb. However, humoral rejection of both DAF KO and DAF WT donor grafts occurred in presensitized GalT KO recipients.

CONCLUSIONS

The expression of DAF prevents hyperacute rejection in mice with low titers of anti-alphaGal antibody. These studies demonstrate the physiologic role of DAF in preventing humoral rejection in the presence of low levels of NAb and have implications for transplantation of discordant vascularized xenografts.

Differing mechanisms of early and late B cell hyporesponsiveness induced by mixed chimerism

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism induced via nonmyeloablative bone marrow transplantation (BMT) leads to unresponsiveness of anti-Gal alpha1,3Gal beta1,4G1cNAc (Gal) natural antibody (NAb)-producing cells in alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase deficient (GalT(-/-)) mice. We analyzed the mechanisms of anti-Gal-producing B cell unresponsiveness induced by Gal(+/+) BMT. C57BL/6 (B6) GalT(-/-) mice received 3Gy whole-body irradiation and BMT from B6-CD45 congenic mice. BMT led to marked reductions in serum anti-Gal IgM levels and in the numbers of splenic anti-Gal-producing cells by 2 weeks post-BMT. B cells with anti-Gal Ig receptors were present in the spleens of 2-week but not 12-week chimeras. In vitro studies and adoptive transfer studies using B6 GalT(-/-)B cell-deficient recipients showed that B cell hyporesponsiveness to Gal at 2 weeks, but not 12 weeks, depended on persistent Gal antigen. Thus, pre-existing B-1 cells are anergic when there is continuous exposure to Gal, whereas long-term unresponsiveness does not require persistent antigen, implicating clonal deletion and/or receptor editing. These results have implications for the potential use of mixed hematopioetic chimerism as an approach to performing organ transplantation in recipients with pre-existing anti-donor IgM antibodies.

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism for the simultaneous induction of T and B cell tolerance

Nonmyeloablative induction of mixed hematopoietic chimerism provides a strategy for inducing T cell tolerance across allogeneic and xenogeneic barriers. We have utilized alpha1-3Gal transferase (GalT) knockout mice, which, like humans, produce anti-Gal natural antibodies, to investigate the ability of mixed chimerism to tolerize B cells producing antibodies of this important specificity, which limits xenotransplantation by causing hyperacute and delayed xenograft rejection. Mixed allogeneic or xenogeneic chimerism indeed tolerizes both preexisting anti-Gal-producing B cells and those developing de novo after establishment of mixed chimerism, even in presensitized mice. We present evidence that different mechanisms are involved in the tolerization of the preexisting and newly-developing antibody-secreting cells.

Effects of a Short Course of Leflunomide on T-Independent B-Lymphocyte Xenoreactivity and on Susceptibility of Xenografts to Acute or Chronic Rejection

BACKGROUND

Leflunomide is a novel immunosuppressive agent with promising activity for xenotransplantation. It is not clear yet which mechanisms of action of leflunomide are responsible for that.

METHODS

In a hamster-to-C57BL/6 nude mouse heart transplantation model, a 2-week course of leflunomide was used after transplantation or for pretreating donors. Nontolerant B lymphocytes were transferred to recipients after transplantation of first or second xenogeneic heart grafts that were transplanted with or without leflunomide treatment.

RESULTS

Hamster xenogeneic hearts transplanted into athymic C57BL/6 nude mice receiving leflunomide did not induce immunoglobulin (Ig) M xenoantibodies (XAb) and survived without signs of chronic rejection. Second xenogeneic hearts transplanted 4 weeks after withdrawal of leflunomide survived without induction of XAb but developed chronic vascular lesions. After injection of naive B lymphocytes at 6 weeks after grafting a first or second hamster heart, only in the latter case were XAb induced. These were deposited in, and provoked acute rejection of, only the second grafts. Pretreatment of donors with leflunomide decreased the ex vivo xenoantibody deposition on the xenogeneic heart endothelia.

CONCLUSIONS

A short posttransplant course of leflunomide induces T-independent B-lymphocyte xenotolerance. Leflunomide treatment also influences xenoantigen expression, as nontolerant B lymphocytes provoke IgM XAb formation and rejection of only second xenografts (transplanted without leflunomide) and not of first xenografts (transplanted with leflunomide treatment). The ex vivo experiments that show that XAb deposition is decreased in leflunomide-pretreated xenografts further confirm this. The latter may also explain the resistance of first and not second xenografts against chronic rejection.

Porcine Hematopoietic Progenitor Cell Transplantation in Nonhuman Primates: A Review of Progress

The critical shortage of human donor organs for transplantation would be overcome if a suitable animal, e.g., the pig, could be used as an organ source. There are, however, several immune barriers that have to date resulted in limited function of pig organs transplanted into nonhuman primates. It would be beneficial, and indeed may be essential, to induce a state of tolerance in the primate recipient to the pig organ. In allotransplantation, the successful transplantation of hematopoietic progenitor cells with the development of mixed chimerism is associated with the induction of tolerance toward a donor-specific organ. For some years, this approach has been explored in the pig-to-nonhuman primate model. This experience is briefly reviewed. The problems of natural and elicited anti-pig antibodies, recipient platelet adhesion to pig hematopietic progenitor cells, and the rapid removal of these cells by the host macrophage-phagocytic system are highlighted. Recent experience with the use of hematopoietic cells from pigs homozygous for alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout is reported.

T Cells from Presensitized Donors Fail to Cause Graft-versus-Host Disease in a Pig-to-Mouse Xenotransplantation Model

BACKGROUND

The ability of T cells from pigs, the most suitable donors for clinical xenotransplantation, to induce graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) and to facilitate hematopoietic cell engraftment in highly disparate xenogeneic recipients remains unclear. In this article, the authors address these questions in a presensitized pig-to-mouse transplantation model using porcine cytokine-transgenic mice.

METHODS

Swine donors were presensitized by mouse skin grafting and boosted by the injection of mouse cells after the skin graft was rejected. Porcine peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and splenocytes were collected at various times after mouse skin grafting, and their potential to induce GVHD and to facilitate donor hematopoietic cell engraftment in conditioned murine recipients was evaluated.

RESULTS

Presensitization of donor pigs resulted in marked enhancement of anti-mouse responses, as reflected in augmented anti-mouse mixed lymphocyte responses, cell-mediated cytotoxicity, and antibody production. However, injection of high numbers of PBMC and splenocytes (>1 x 10(8)) with bone marrow cells from the presensitized pigs failed to induce detectable GVHD or long-term chimerism in mice that were treated with depleting anti-T-cell and natural killer cell antibodies, cobra venom factor, medronate-liposomes, and 4 Gy of whole-body and 7 Gy of thymic irradiation. Histologic analysis revealed no mononuclear cell infiltration or GVHD-associated lesions in the liver, intestine, lungs, or skin of the mouse recipients. Furthermore, the recipient mice had no detectable T cells or anti-pig immunoglobulin G antibodies in the blood by 6 weeks after injection of porcine cells.

CONCLUSION

These results demonstrate that porcine T-cell function is severely impaired in the xenogeneic murine microenvironment.

Application of xenogeneic stem cells for induction of transplantation tolerance: present state and future directions

Xenotransplantation using pig organs provides a possible solution to the severe shortage of allogeneic organ donors, one of the major limiting factors in clinical transplantation. However, because of the greater antigenic differences that exist between different species than within a species, the immune response to xenografts is much more vigorous than to allografts. Thus, tolerance induction is essential to the success of clinical xenotransplantation. Tolerance induced by mixed hematopoietic chimerism across the MHC barrier is remarkably robust, but its ability to induce tolerance across highly disparate xenogeneic barriers remains poorly studied. None of the current available regimens of host conditioning, which permit hematopoietic stem cell engraftment and chimerism induction in allogeneic or closely related (concordant) xenogeneic combinations, has been demonstrated to be effective in establishing porcine hematopoietic chimerism in a discordant xenogeneic species. Unlike bone marrow transplantation within the same species, the innate immune system and the species specificity of cytokines and adhesion molecules essential to hematopoiesis pose formidable obstacles to the establishment of donor hematopoiesis across discordant xenogeneic barriers. The genetic incompatibility between species may also impede xenograft tolerance induction by mixed chimerism. While we remain far from achieving tolerance in clinical xenotransplantation, recent studies using a transgenic mouse model have proven the principle that mixed hematopoietic chimerism may induce mouse and human T cell tolerance to porcine xenografts. This review article focuses on the barriers to porcine hematopoietic engraftment in highly disparate xenogeneic species and the possible application of mixed hematopoietic chimerism to xenograft tolerance induction.

USE OF LENTIVIRAL VECTORS TO INDUCE LONG-TERM TOLERANCE TO GAL+ HEART GRAFTS

BACKGROUND

Tolerance to organ grafts has been achieved by establishing a state of stable mixed-cell chimerism after bone marrow transplantation. Gene therapy has been applied to establish chimerism for cells expressing galactose alpha 1,3 galactose in alpha 1,3 galactosyltransferase deficient (gal knockout) mice using retroviral vectors. Limitations to the success of this methodology include short-term expression of the introduced gene and rejection of gal hearts transplanted into these animals within a month.

METHODS

Autologous bone marrow from gal knockout mice was transduced with a lentiviral vector expressing porcine alpha 1,3 galactosyltransferase and transplanted into lethally irradiated gal knockout mice. Chimerism was monitored by flow cytometry. Hearts from wild type mice (gal/) were transplanted into these animals and palpated daily. Xenoantibodies directed at the gal carbohydrate or porcine xenoantigens were detected by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.

RESULTS

Hearts from wild-type gal/ donors were permanently accepted in all mice receiving autologous, transduced bone marrow before heart transplantation. Control mice rejected gal hearts within 12 to 14 days. Histologic analysis demonstrated classical signs of rejection in controls and normal myocardium with no evidence of rejection in mice chimeric for the gal carbohydrate. Anti-gal xenoantibodies were not produced in gal chimeras, but normal antibody responses to other xenoantigens were detected. Specific tolerance for the gal carbohydrate was achieved by this procedure.

CONCLUSIONS

These experiments report the first demonstration of permanent survival of gal hearts after transplantation with autologous, transduced bone marrow. Transduction with lentiviral vectors results in long-term, stable chimerism at levels sufficient to induce long-term tolerance to heart grafts in mice.

Peritoneal cavity B cells are precursors of splenic IgM natural antibody-producing cells

Peritoneal cavity B-1 cells are believed to produce IgM natural Abs. We have used alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase-deficient (GalT(-/-)) mice, which, like humans, produce IgM natural Abs against the carbohydrate epitope Galalpha1,3Gal (Gal), to demonstrate that peritoneal cavity B-1b cells with anti-Gal receptors produce anti-Gal IgM Abs only after LPS stimulation. Likewise, peritoneal cavity cells of GalT(-/-) and wild-type mice do not produce IgM Abs of other specificities without LPS stimulation. Development of Ab-secreting capacity is associated with loss of CD11b/CD18 (Mac-1) expression. In contrast, there are large numbers of cells producing anti-Gal and other IgM Abs in fresh splenocyte preparations from GalT(-/-) and (for non-Gal specificities) wild-type mice. These cells are Mac-1(-) but otherwise B-1b-like in their phenotype. We therefore hypothesized a pathway wherein peritoneal cavity B cells migrate into the spleen after activation in vivo and lose Mac-1 expression to become IgM Ab-producing cells. Consistent with this possibility, splenectomy reduced anti-Gal Ab production after immunization of GalT(-/-) mice with Gal-positive rabbit RBC. Furthermore, splenectomized B6 GalT(-/-), Ig micro -chain mutant ( micro (-/-)) (both Gal- and B cell-deficient) mice produced less anti-Gal IgM than nonsplenectomized controls after adoptive transfer of peritoneal cavity cells from B6 GalT(-/-) mice. When sorted GalT(-/-) Mac-1(+) peritoneal cavity B cells were adoptively transferred to B6 GalT(-/-), micro (-/-) mice, IgM Abs including anti-Gal appeared, and IgM-producing and Mac1(-) B cells were present in the spleen 5 wk after transfer. These findings demonstrate that peritoneal cavity Mac-1(+) B-1 cells are precursors of Mac-1(-) splenic IgM Ab-secreting cells.

Pancreatic islet xenotransplantation: barriers and prospects

Dramatic clinical advances indicate that pancreatic islet transplants can reliably restore euglycemia in insulin-dependent patients. However, clinical success actually highlights the pronounced deficiency of allogeneic pancreata available for islet isolation. This pressing issue has revitalized ongoing efforts to develop surrogate donor sources. Xenogeneic donors form a potential alternative tissue source because they can be generated in large numbers and are amenable to genetic engineering. However, there is less understanding of the innate and adaptive immune barriers to islet xenografts relative to those encountered by allografts. Presented evidence indicates that both innate and antigen-specific adaptive immune responses significantly contribute to islet xenograft rejection. Recent evidence suggests that the capacity to induce tolerance to islet xenografts may not differ markedly from strategies used to induce allograft tolerance.

B cell tolerance to xenoantigens

Xenotransplantation of pig organs to humans is a possible solution to the shortage of donor organs for transplantation. Multiple immunologic barriers need to be overcome if pig-to-primate transplantation is to be successful. The presence, in humans, of natural antibodies (Abs) directed against Galalpha1-3Galbeta1-4GlcNAc epitopes on pig vascular endothelium provides the major barrier, as antibody-antigen binding initiates the process of hyperacute rejection. Even if hyperacute rejection is prevented, acute vascular rejection develops. Acute vascular rejection is also mediated, in part, by xenoreactive Abs and may be complement-independent. Efforts being made to overcome antibody-mediated rejection include depletion of antibody by extracorporeal immunoadsorption, prevention of an induced Ab response by pharmacologic reagents, B-cell and/or plasma cell depletion, depletion or inhibition of complement, and the use of organs from pigs transgenic for human complement regulatory proteins. The ultimate solution would be the induction of B-cell tolerance to xenogeneic antigens, which is being explored by attempting to induce xenogeneic hematopoietic chimerism. Here, we review the properties of the B cell types responding to xenoantigens and the strategies for tolerizing those B cells.