A case-control comparison of the results of renal transplantation from heart-beating and non-heart-beating donors

Protection From Second Warm Ischemic Injury Using a Thermal Barrier Bag in Kidney Transplantation

Second warm ischemic injury during vascular anastomosis not only adversely affects immediate posttransplant function but also affects long-term patient and graft survival. We developed a pouch-type thermal barrier bag (TBB) composed of a transparent, biocompatible insulation material suitably designed for kidneys and conducted the first-in-human clinical trial.

Methods

A living-donor nephrectomy was performed using a minimum skin incision procedure. After back table preparation, the kidney graft was placed inside the TBB and preserved during vascular anastomosis. The graft surface temperature was measured before and after vascular anastomosis using a noncontact infrared thermometer. After completion of the anastomosis, the TBB was removed from the transplanted kidney before graft reperfusion. Clinical data, including patient characteristics and perioperative variables, were collected. The primary endpoint was safety, which was assessed by evaluating adverse events. The secondary endpoints were the feasibility, tolerability, and efficacy of the TBB in kidney transplant recipients.

Results

Ten living-donor kidney transplant recipients with a median age of 56 y (range, 39-69 y) were enrolled in this study. No serious adverse events related to the TBB were observed. The median second warm ischemic time was 31 (27-39) min, and the median graft surface temperature at the end of anastomosis was 16.1 °C (12.8-18.7 °C).

Conclusions

TBB can maintain transplanted kidneys at a low temperature during vascular anastomosis, which contributes to the functional preservation of transplanted kidneys and stable transplant outcomes.

Recent Methods of Kidney Storage and Therapeutic Possibilities of Transplant Kidney

Kidney transplantation is the standard procedure for the treatment of end-stage renal disease (ESRD). During kidney storage and before implantation, the organ is exposed to damaging factors which affect the decline in condition. The arrest of blood circulation results in oxygen and nutrient deficiency that lead to changes in the cell metabolism from aerobic to anaerobic, damaging organelles and cell structures. Currently, most kidney grafts are kept in a cold preservation solution to preserve low metabolism. However, there are numerous reports that machine perfusion is a better solution for organ preservation before surgery. The superiority of machine perfusion was proved in the case of marginal donor grafts, such as extended criteria donors (ECD) and donation after circulatory death (DCD). Different variant of kidney machine perfusions are evaluated. Investigators look for optimal conditions to protect kidneys from ischemia-reperfusion damage consequences by examining the best temperature conditions and comparing systems with constant or pulsatile flow. Moreover, machine perfusion brings additional advantages in clinical practice. Unlike cold static storage, machine perfusion allows the monitoring of the parameters of organ function, which gives a real possibility to make a decision prior to transplantation concerning whether the kidney is suitable for implantation. Moreover, new pharmacological therapies are sought to minimize organ damage. New components or cellular therapies can be applied, since perfusion solution flows through the organ. This review outlines the pros and cons of each machine perfusion technique and summarizes the latest achievements in the context of kidney transplantation using machine perfusion systems.

Advances in Kidney Preservation Techniques and Their Application in Clinical Practice

The use of cold preservation solutions to rapidly flush and cool the kidney followed by static cold storage in ice has been the standard kidney preservation technique for the last 50 y. Nonetheless, changing donor demographics that include organs from extended criteria donors and donation after circulatory death donors have led to the adoption of more diverse techniques of preservation. Comparison of hypothermic machine perfusion and static cold storage techniques for deceased donor kidneys has long been debated and is still contested by some. The recent modification of hypothermic machine perfusion techniques with the addition of oxygen or perfusion at subnormothermic or near-normothermic temperatures are promising strategies that are emerging in clinical practice. In addition, the use of normothermic regional perfusion to resuscitate abdominal organs of donation after circulatory death donors in situ before cold flushing is also increasingly being utilized. This review provides a synopsis of the different types of preservation techniques including their mechanistic effects and the outcome of their application in clinical practice for different types of donor kidney.

Implementation of donation after circulatory death kidney transplantation can safely enlarge the donor pool: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Donation after circulatory death (DCD) kidney transplantation has been introduced to address organ shortage. However, DCD kidneys are not accepted worldwide due to concerns about inferior quality. To investigate whether these concerns are justified, we performed a systematic review and meta-analysis to investigate DCD graft outcomes compared to donation after brain death (DBD).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

EMBASE, Medline, Cochrane, Web of Science and Google Scholar were searched from database inception until September 2020. Exclusion criteria were studies reporting on pediatric/dual kidney transplants, multi-organ transplants or studies including normothermic perfusion techniques. The primary outcome was graft survival. Secondary outcomes were primary non-function (PNF), delayed graft function (DGF), 3-months biopsy-proven acute rejection (BPAR), 1-year estimated Glomerular Filtration Rate (eGFR), patient survival, and urologic complications. A random-effects model was used for meta-analysis. Meta-regression analysis was performed in case of high between-study heterogeneity.

RESULTS

Fifty-one studies were included, comprising 73,454 DCD and 518,229 DBD recipients. One-year graft loss was increased in DCD recipients (death-censored: risk ratio (RR) 1.10 (95%-confidence interval (CI) 1.04-1.16), all-cause: RR 1.13 (95%-CI 1.08-1.19)). Ten-year graft loss was similar to DBD (death-censored: RR 1.02 (95%-CI 0.92-1.13), all-cause: RR 1.03 (95%-CI 0.94-1.13)). DCD recipients had an increased risk of PNF (RR 1.43 (95%-CI 1.26-1.62)), DGF (RR 2.02 (95%-CI 1.88-2.16)), and 1-year mortality (RR 1.10 (95%-CI 1.01-1.21)). No differences were observed for 3-months BPAR, ureter stenosis/leakage, 1-year eGFR and 10-year mortality.

CONCLUSION

Long-term DCD kidney transplant outcomes are similar to DBD despite a higher risk of PNF, DGF, and a 13% increased risk of graft loss in the first year after transplantation. These results should encourage implementation of DCD programs.

Development of a Successful Non—Heart-Beating Organ Donation Program

To help alleviate the organ shortage, transplant centers are using organs from expanded-criteria donors, who were considered unsuitable just a few years ago, such as Non—Heart-beating donors. In 1998, we made a concerted effort to increase the number of Non—Heart-beating donors recovered by our organ procurement organization. In this paper, we discuss the steps in establishing this program, including transplant center support, estimating the number of potential Non—Heart-beating donors, organ procurement support, protocol development, hospital development, education, putting the protocol into practice, follow-up, and effect of the program on organ procurement. With the establishment of this program, the number of Non—Heart-beating donors increased from 2% to 5% per year to over 10% for the past 2 years. From these donors, 61 of 82 recovered kidneys were transplanted into 58 patients, and 18 of 20 recovered livers were transplanted. A Non—Heart-beating donor program can significantly add to the number of organ transplants and successful transplantations.

Non-Heartbeating Organ Donation: A Review

Organ transplantation is one of the groundbreaking achievements in medicine in the 20th century. In the early days of transplantation, organs were obtained from non-heartbeating (NHB) cadavers. With time, better options for organ sources became available (for example, living-related and “brain dead” donors), and the practice of obtaining organs from NHB cadavers fell out of favor. Improvements in the field of transplantation have led to an increased demand for organs. Various strategies have been employed recently to increase the supply, one of them being non-heartbeating organ donation (NHBOD). NHBOD can take place in controlled or uncontrolled circum-stances. Recently, national organizations have supported and proposed guidelines for NHBOD and to aid clinicians in identifying potential donors. Outcomes of organs obtained from NHB cadavers are comparable to those obtained from heartbeating donors. The practice of NHBOD is increasing and has proven that it can contribute to increasing organ availability.

A novel rodent model of severe renal ischemia reperfusion injury

Renal ischemia reperfusion injury (IRI) is a major problem, currently without treatments in clinical use. This reflects the failure of animal models to mimic the severity of IRI observed in clinical practice. Most described models lack both the ability to inflict a permanent reduction in renal function and the sensitivity to demonstrate the protective efficacy of different therapies in vivo. To test novel cell-based therapies, we have developed a model of renal IRI in Fisher 344 rats. Animals were subjected to 120 min of unilateral warm ischemia, during which they underwent an intra-renal artery infusion of therapeutic agents or vehicle. At either 2 or 6 weeks post-surgery, animals underwent terminal glomerular filtration rate (GFR) studies by inulin clearance to most accurately quantify renal function. Harvested kidneys underwent histological analysis. Compared to sham operations, saline treated animals suffered a long-term reduction in GFR of ≈50%. Histology revealed short- and long-term disruption of renal architecture. Despite the injury severity, post-operative animal losses are <5%. This model produces a severe, consistent renal injury that closely replicates the pathological processes encountered in clinical medicine. Renal artery infusion mimics the route likely employed in clinical transplantation, where the renal artery is accessible. Inulin clearance characterizes GFR, allowing full assessment of therapeutic intervention. This model is useful for screening therapeutic agents prior to testing in a transplant model. This reduces animal numbers needed to test drugs for clinical transplantation and allows for refinement of dosing schedules.

Transplantation of kidneys from uncontrolled donation after circulatory determination of death: comparison with brain death donors with or without extended criteria and impact of normothermic regional perfusion

The aim of this study was to compare the outcomes of kidney transplants from uncontrolled DCD (uDCD) with kidney transplants from extended (ECD) and standard criteria donors (SCD). In this multicenter study, we included recipients from uDCD (n = 50), and from ECD (n = 57) and SCD (n = 102) who could be eligible for a uDCD program. We compared patient and graft survival, and kidney function between groups. To address the impact of preservation procedures in uDCD, we compared in situ cold perfusion (ICP) with normothermic regional perfusion (NRP). Patient and graft survival rates were similar between the uDCD and ECD groups, but were lower than the SCD group (P < 0.01). Although delayed graft function (DGF) was more frequent in the uDCD group (66%) than in the ECD (40%) and SCD (27%) groups (P = 0.08 and P < 0.001), graft function was comparable between the uDCD and ECD groups at 3 months onwards post-transplantation. The use of NRP in the uDCD group (n = 19) was associated with a lower risk of DGF, and with a better graft function at 2 years post-transplantation, compared to ICP-uDCD (n = 31) and ECD. In conclusion, the use of uDCD kidneys was associated with post-transplantation results comparable to those of ECD kidneys. NRP preservation may improve the results of uDCD transplantation.

A comparison of inflammatory, cytoprotective and injury gene expression profiles in kidneys from brain death and cardiac death donors

BACKGROUND

The superior long-term survival of kidneys from living donors (LDs) compared with kidneys from donation-after-brain-death (DBD) and donation-after-cardiac-death (DCD) donors is now well established. However, comparative studies on transcriptional changes that occur at organ retrieval and during and after cold ischemia (CI) are sparse.

METHODS

Using a rat model, we used qRT-PCR to examine expression levels of inflammatory, cytoprotective, and injury genes at different time points after organ retrieval. Cleaved caspase-3 was used to evaluate early apoptosis in DCD and DBD kidneys.

RESULTS

Immediately after retrieval, we found massive up-regulation of proinflammatory genes interleukin-1β, interleukin-6, tumor necrosis factor-α, monocyte chemotactic protein-1, P-selectin, and E-selectin in DBD compared with LD and DCD kidneys. A significant increase in the expression of injury markers Kim-1, p21, and the cytoprotective gene heme oxygenase-1 accompanied this. Bax was increased in DCD kidneys, and Bcl-2 was decreased in DBD kidneys. After 2 hr of CI in the LD group and 18 hr in the DBD and DCD groups, gene expression levels were similar to those found after retrieval. During 18 hr of cold storage, expression levels of these genes did not change. In DCD and DBD kidneys, early apoptosis increased after CI.

DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION

The gene expression profile in DBD kidneys represents an inflammatory and injury response to brain death. In contrast, DCD kidneys show only mild up-regulation of inflammatory and injury genes. These results may imply why delayed graft function in DCD kidneys does not have the deleterious effect it has on DBD kidneys.

Amniotic fluid-derived mesenchymal stem cells prevent fibrosis and preserve renal function in a preclinical porcine model of kidney transplantation

It is well known that ischemia/reperfusion injuries strongly affect the success of human organ transplantation. Development of interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy is the main deleterious phenomenon involved. Stem cells are a promising therapeutic tool already validated in various ischemic diseases. Amniotic fluid-derived mesenchymal stem cells (af-MSCs), a subpopulation of multipotent cells identified in amniotic fluid, are known to secrete growth factors and anti-inflammatory cytokines. In addition, these cells are easy to collect, present higher proliferation and self-renewal rates compared with other adult stem cells (ASCs), and are suitable for banking. Consequently, af-MSCs represent a promising source of stem cells for regenerative therapies in humans. To determine the efficiency and the safety of af-MSC infusion in a preclinical porcine model of renal autotransplantation, we injected autologous af-MSCs in the renal artery 6 days after transplantation. The af-MSC injection improved glomerular and tubular functions, leading to full renal function recovery and abrogated fibrosis development at 3 months. The strong proof of concept generated by this translational porcine model is a first step toward evaluation of af-MSC-based therapies in human kidney transplantation.

Stem cells and their role in renal ischaemia reperfusion injury

BACKGROUND

Ischaemia-reperfusion injury (IRI) remains one of the leading causes of acute kidney injury (AKI). IRI is an underlying multifactorial pathophysiological process which affects the outcome in both native and transplanted patients. The high morbidity and mortality associated with IRI/AKI and disappointing results from current available clinical therapeutic approaches prompt further research. Stem cells (SC) are undifferentiated cells that can undergo both renewal and differentiation into one or more cell types which can possibly ameliorate IRI.

AIM

To carry out a detailed literature analysis and construct a comprehensive literature review addressing the role of SC in AKI secondary to IRI.

METHODS

Evidence favouring the role of SC in renal IRI and evidence showing no benefits of SC in renal IRI are the two main aspects to be studied. The search strategy was based on an extensive search addressing MESH terms and free text terms.

RESULTS

The majority of studies in the field of renal IRI and stem cell therapy show substantial benefits.

CONCLUSIONS

Studies were mostly conducted in small animal models, thus underscoring the need for further pre-clinical studies in larger animal models, and results should be taken with caution. SC therapy may be promising though controversy exists in the exact mechanism. Thorough scientific exploration is required to assess mechanism, safety profile, reproducibility and methods to monitor administered SC.

Ischaemic/reperfusion injury: Role of infliximab

Ischaemia/reperfusion (I/R) injury is an underlying complex interrelated patho-physiological process which effects the outcome of many clinical situations, in particular transplantation. Tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α is a pleiotropic inflammatory cytokine; a trimeric protein encoded within the major histocompatibility complex which plays a pivotal role in this disease process. This review is based at looking into an update, particularly the new insights in the mechanisms of action of TNF antagonist such as infliximab. Infliximab may thus play a dual role in the field of transplantation where it might not only down regulate the I/R injury, it may also have a beneficial role in the reduction of acute rejection.

Expansion of the kidney donor pool by using cardiac death donors with prolonged time to cardiorespiratory arrest

Donation after Cardiac Death (DCD) is an increasingly important source of kidney transplants, but because of concerns of ischemic injury during the agonal phase, many centers abandon donation if cardiorespiratory arrest has not occurred within 1 h of controlled withdrawal of life-supporting treatment (WLST). We report the impact on donor numbers and transplant function using instead a minimum 'cut-off' time of 4 h. The agonal phase of 173 potential DCD donors was characterized according to the presence or absence of: acidemia; lactic acidosis; prolonged (>30 min) hypotension, hypoxia or oliguria, and the impact of these characteristics on 3- and 12-month transplant outcome evaluated by multivariable regression analysis. Of the 117 referrals who became donors, 27 (23.1%) arrested more than 1 h after WLST. Longer agonal-phase times were associated with greater donor instability, but surprisingly neither agonal-phase instability nor its duration influenced transplant outcome. In contrast, 3- and 12-month eGFR in the 190 transplanted kidneys was influenced independently by donor age, and 3-month eGFR by cold ischemic time. DCD kidney numbers are increased by 30%, without compromising transplant outcome, by lengthening the minimum waiting time after WLST from 1 to 4 h.

Year in review 2009: Critical Care--cardiac arrest, trauma and disasters

During 2009, Critical Care published nine papers on various aspects of resuscitation, prehospital medicine, trauma care and disaster response. One article demonstrated that children as young as 9 years of age can learn cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) effectively, although, depending on their size, some may have difficulty performing it. Another paper showed that while there was a trend toward mild therapeutic hypothermia reducing S-100 levels, there was no statistically significant change. Another predictor study also showed a strong link between acute kidney injury and neurologic outcome while another article described a program in which kidneys were harvested from cardiac arrest patients and showed an 89% graft survival rate. One experimental investigation indicated that when a pump-less interventional lung assist device is present, leaving the device open (unclamped) while performing CPR has no harmful effects on mean arterial pressures and it may have positive effects on blood oxygenation and CO2 clearance. One other study, conducted in the prehospital environment, found that end-tidal CO2 could be useful in diagnosing pulmonary embolism. Three articles addressed disaster medicine, the first of which described a triage system for use during pandemic influenza that demonstrated high reliability in delineating patients with a good chance of survival from those likely to die. The other two studies, both drawn from the 2008 Sichuan earthquake experience, showed success in treating crush injured patients in an on-site tent ICU and, in the second case, how the epidemiology of earthquake injuries and related factors predicted mortality.

Pharmacological strategies against cold ischemia reperfusion injury

IMPORTANCE OF THE FIELD

Good organ preservation is a determinant of graft outcome after revascularization. The necessity of increasing the quality of organ preservation, as well as of extending cold storage time, has made it necessary to consider the use of pharmacological additives.

AREAS COVERED IN THIS REVIEW

The complex physiopathology of cold-ischemia-reperfusion (I/R) injury--and in particular cell death, mitochondrial injury and endoplasmic reticulum stress--are reviewed. Basic principles of the formulation of the different preservation solutions are discussed.

WHAT THE READER WILL GAIN

Current strategies and new trends in static organ preservation using additives such as trimetazidine, polyethylene glycols, melatonin, trophic factors and endothelin antagonists in solution are presented and discussed. The benefits and mechanisms responsible for enhancing organ protection against I/R injury are also discussed. Graft preservation was substantially improved when additives were added to the preservation solutions.

TAKE HOME MESSAGE

Enrichment of preservation solutions by additives is clinically useful only for short periods. For longer periods of cold ischemia, the use of such additives becomes insufficient because graft function deteriorates as a result of ischemia. In such conditions, the preservation strategy should be changed by the use of machine perfusion in normothermic conditions.

Kidney retrieval after sudden out of hospital refractory cardiac arrest: a cohort of uncontrolled non heart beating donors

Introduction

To counter the shortage of kidney grafts in France, a non heart beating donor (NHBD) program has recently been implemented. The aim of this study was to describe this pilot program for kidney retrieval from "uncontrolled" NHBD meaning those for whom attempts of resuscitation after a witnessed out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (CA) have failed (Maastricht 1 and 2), in a centre previously trained for retrieval from brain dead donors.

Methods

A prospective, monocentric, descriptive study concerning NHBD referred to our institution from February 2007 to June 2008. The protocol includes medical transport of refractory CA under mechanical ventilation and external cardiac massage, kidney protection by insertion of an intraaortic double-balloon catheter (DBC) with perfusion of a hypothermic solution, kidney retrieval and kidney preservation in a hypothermic pulsatile perfusion machine.

Results

122 potential NHBD were referred to our institution after a mean resuscitation attempt of 35 minutes (20–95). Regarding the contraindications, 63 were finally accepted and 56 had the DBC inserted. Organ retrieval was performed in 27 patients (43%) and 31 kidneys out of the 54 procured (57%) have been transplanted. Kidney transplantation exclusion was related to family refusal (n = 15), past medical history, time constraints, viral serology, high vascular ex vivo resistance of the graft and macroscopic abnormalities. The 31 kidneys exhibited an expected high delayed graft function rate (92%). Despite these initial results transplanted kidney had good creatinine clearance at six months (66 ± 24 ml/min) with a 89% graft survival rate at six months.

Conclusions

This study shows the feasibility and efficacy of an organ procurement program targeting NHBD allowing a 10% increase in the kidney transplantation rate over 17 months. With a six months follow-up period, the results of transplanted kidney function were excellent.

Donor kidney disease and transplant outcome for kidneys donated after cardiac death

Background

Although outcomes of kidney transplants following donation after cardiac death (DCD) and donation after brainstem death (DBD) are similar, generally only optimal younger DCD donors are considered. This study examined the impact of pre-existing donor kidney disease on the outcome of DCD transplants.

Methods

This retrospective study compared the outcome of all DCD kidney transplants performed during 1996–2006 with contemporaneous kidney transplants from DBD donors. Implantation biopsies were scored for glomerular, tubular, parenchymal and vascular disease (global histology score). There were 104 DCD and 104 DBD kidney transplants.

Results

Delayed graft function (DGF) occurred more frequently in DCD than DBD kidneys (64·4 versus 28·8 per cent; P &lt; 0·001). Long-term graft outcome was similar. The only donor factor that influenced outcome was baseline kidney disease, which was similar in both groups, even though DCD donors were younger, with a higher predonation estimated glomerular filtration rate. The global histology score predicted DGF (odds ratio 1·85 per unit; P = 0·006) and graft failure (relative risk 1·55 per unit; P = 0·001), although there was no difference for DCD and DBD kidneys.

Conclusion

Transplant outcomes for DCD and DBD kidneys are comparable. Baseline donor kidney disease influences DGF and graft survival but the impact is no greater for DCD kidneys.

Urological complications and their impact on survival after kidney transplantation from deceased cardiac death donors

Urological complications after kidney transplantation may result in significant morbidity and mortality. However, the incidence of such complications after deceased cardiac death (DCD) donor kidney transplantation and their effect on survival is unknown. Purpose of this study was to estimate the incidence of urological complications after DCD kidney transplantation, and to estimate their impact on survival. Patient records of all 76 DCD kidney transplantations in the period 1997-2004 were reviewed for (urological) complications during the initial hospitalization until 30 days after discharge, and graft survival until the last hospital visit. Urological complications occurred in 32 patients (42.1%), with leakage and/or obstruction occurring in seven patients (9.2%). The latter seems to be comparable with the incidence reported in the literature for deceased heart-beating (DHB) transplantations (range 2.5-10%). Overall graft survival was 92% at 1 year and 88% at 3 years, comparable to the rates reported in the literature for kidneys from DHB donors, and was not affected by urological complications (chi(2) = 0.27, P = 0.61). Only a first warm-ischaemia time of 30 min or more reduced graft survival (chi(2) = 4.38, P < 0.05). We conclude that urological complications occur frequently after DCD kidney transplantation, but do not influence graft survival. The only risk factor for reduced graft survival in DCD transplant recipients was the first warm-ischaemia time.

Non heart-beating donors in England

When transplantation started all organs were retrieved from patients immediately after cardio-respiratory arrest, i.e. from non heart-beating donors. After the recognition that death resulted from irreversible damage to the brainstem, organ retrieval rapidly switched to patients certified dead after brainstem testing. These heart-beating-donors have become the principal source of organs for transplantation for the last 30 years. The number of heart-beating-donors are declining and this is likely to continue, therefore cadaveric organs from non-heart-beating donor offers a large potential of resources for organ transplantation. The aim of this study is to examine clinical outcomes of non-heart-beating donors in the past 10 years in the UK as an way of decreasing pressure in the huge waiting list for organs transplantation.

Experimental renal preservation by normothermic resuscitation perfusion with autologous blood

BACKGROUND

Normothermic perfusion (NP) has the potential to improve metabolic support and maintain the viability of ischaemically damaged organs. This study investigated the effects of NP compared with current methods of organ preservation in a model of controlled non-heart-beating donor (NHBD) kidneys.

METHODS

Porcine kidneys (n = 6 in each group) were subjected to 10 min warm ischaemia and then preserved as follows: 2 h cold storage (CS) in ice (CS2 group), 18 h CS (CS18 group), 18 h cold machine perfusion (CP group) or 16 h CS + 2 h NP (NP group). Renal haemodynamics and function were measured during 3 h reperfusion with autologous blood using an isolated organ perfusion system.

RESULTS

Increasing CS from 2 to 18 h reduced renal blood flow (mean(s.d.) area under the curve (AUC) 444(57) versus 325(70) ml per 100 g; P = 0.004), but this was restored by NP (563(119) ml per 100 g; P = 0.035 versus CS18). Renal function was also better in CS2, CP and NP groups than in the CS18 group (mean(s.d.) serum creatinine fall 92(6), 79(9) and 64(17) versus 44(13) per cent respectively; P = 0.001). The AUC for serum creatinine was significantly lower with CS for 2 h than for 18 h (mean(s.d.) 1102(2600) versus 2156(401) micromol/l.h; P = 0.001), although values in CP and NP groups were not significantly different from those in the CS2 group (1354(300) and 1756(280) micromol/l.h respectively). Two hours of NP increased the adenosine 3'-triphosphate : adenosine 3'-diphosphate ratio to a significantly higher level than the preperfusion values in all other groups (P = 0.046).

CONCLUSION

NP with oxygenated blood was able to restore depleted ATP levels and reverse some of the deleterious effects of CS.

Effects of erythropoietin on ischaemia/reperfusion injury in a controlled nonheart beating donor kidney model

Erythropoietin (EPO) has been shown to have an anti-apoptotic action and has the potential to protect against ischaemia/reperfusion injury. This study investigated the effect of high dose EPO (5000 U), administered as a bolus at the onset of reperfusion and at the onset of cold storage in a model of controlled nonheart beating donors kidneys. Porcine kidneys(n = 6) were subjected to 10min warm ischaemia and preserved as follows: Group 1:16 h Cold storage +2 h Normothermic perfusion (16 h CS + 2 h NP) Group 2:16 h CS + 2 h NP + EPO given at the onset of reperfusion Group 3:18 h CS (static hypothermic storage) Group 4:18 h CS + EPO given at the onset of cold storage Haemodynamic and functional parameters were assessed during 3-h reperfusion using autologous blood. Renal blood flow improved in Groups 1 and 2 vs. Groups 3 and 4 though no difference was noted between Groups 3 and 4 (563 +/- 119 vs. 491 +/- 95 vs. 325 +/- 70 vs. 418 +/- 112, respectively; P = 0.012). Total urine output showed no difference between Groups (271 +/- 172 vs. 359 +/- 184 vs. 302 +/- 21 vs. 421 +/- 88; P = 0.576). Percentage serum creatinine fall at 3 h was significantly better in Groups 1 and 2 vs. Group 3 (64 +/- 17 vs. 60 +/- 11 vs. 44 +/- 13 vs. 52 +/- 8; P = 0.04). Fractional-excretion of sodium was significantly lower for Groups 1 and 2 vs. Group 3 and 4 (17 +/- 14 vs. 18 +/- 9 vs. 49 +/- 21 vs. 45 +/- 16 respectively; P = 0.002). There was significant improvement in oxygen consumption in Groups 2 vs. Groups 3 and 4 (P = 0.037) (39 +/- 10 vs. 46 +/- 10 vs. 24 +/- 12 vs. 24 +/- 7 respectively). EPO added at the time of reperfusion improved oxygen consumption when added to NP in comparison to static hypothermic storage but did not exert any other major benefits.

In defense of the reverence of all life: Heideggerean dissolution of the ethical challenges of organ donation after circulatory determination of death

During the past 50 years since the first successful organ transplant, waiting lists of potential organ recipients have expanded exponentially as supply and demand have been on a collision course. The recovery of organs from patients with circulatory determination of death is one of several effective alternative approaches recommended to reduce the supply-and-demand gap. However, renewed debate ensues regarding the ethical management of the overarching risks, pressures, challenges and conflicts of interest inherent in organ retrieval after circulatory determination of death. In this article, the author claims that through the engagement of a Heideggerean existential phenomenological and hermeneutic framework what are perceived as ethical problems dissolve, including collapse of commitment to the dead donor rule. The author argues for a revisioned socially constructed conceptual and philosophical responsibility of humankind to recognize the limits of bodily finitude, to responsibly use the capacity of the transplantable organs, and to grant enhanced or renewed existence to one with diminished or life-limited capacity; thereby making the locus of ethical concern the donor-recipient as unitary ''life.'' What ethically matters in the life-cycle (life-world) of donor-recipient is the viability of the organs transplanted; thereby granting reverence to all life.

Perspectives in organ preservation

Maintaining organ viability after donation until transplantation is critically important for optimal graft function and survival. To date, static cold storage is the most widely used form of preservation in every day clinical practice. Although simple and effective, it is questionable whether this method is able to prevent deterioration of organ quality in the present era with increasing numbers of organs retrieved from older, more marginal, and even non-heart-beating donors. This review describes principles involved in effective preservation and focuses on some basic components and methods of abdominal organ preservation in clinical and experimental transplantation. Concepts and developments to reduce ischemia related injury are discussed, including hypothermic machine perfusion. Despite the fact that hypothermic machine perfusion might be superior to static cold storage preservation, organs are still exposed to hypothermia induced damage. Therefore, recently some groups have pointed at the beneficial effects of normothermic machine perfusion as a new perspective in organ preservation and transplantation.

Non-heart beating organ donation: overview and future perspectives

New indications for organ transplantation combined with a stagnating number of available donor grafts have severely lengthened the waiting list for almost all types of transplantations. This has led to a renewed interest in non-heart beating (NHB) donation, as a possible solution to bridge the gap between supply and demand. In this review, we present an overview of current NHB donation practice, outcome, existing problems and future perspectives. We focus on possible improvements in donor management, recipient care and new methods of organ preservation that may be better suited for these marginal organs. Successful institution of NHB protocols depends on adapting current transplantation practice at all levels, which is one of the greatest challenges for researchers and professionals in this interesting re-emerging field.

Why hasn't eliminating acute rejection improved graft survival?

Although patients with end-stage renal disease can be maintained with dialysis therapy, the superiority of patient survival with renal transplantation makes transplantation the preferred method of renal replacement. Potent immunosuppressive therapies, particularly calcineurin inhibitors, have greatly reduced the incidence of acute rejection. However, long-term allograft survival remains limited. We discuss the impact of acute rejection on long-term allograft survival and discuss other factors leading to late allograft loss, including calcineurin inhibitor toxicity, chronic allograft nephropathy, and BK virus nephropathy, as well as donor and recipient factors associated with long-term allograft loss.

Non-heartbeating donation of kidneys for transplantation

There is a persistent shortage of kidneys available for transplantation. In the early 1980s, therefore, we published the concept of non-heartbeating (NHB) donation; that is, procurement of kidneys from donors whose death has been accompanied by irreversible circulatory arrest. NHB donors are generally categorized using four definitions; category III (awaiting cardiac arrest) and category IV (cardiac arrest while braindead)--or 'controlled'--donors are the most suitable for initiating NHB donation programs. Delayed graft function is associated with use of kidneys from such donors, but has no effect on graft survival in the short or long term. Use of kidneys from category I (dead upon arrival at hospital) and category II (unsuccessfully resuscitated), or 'uncontrolled', donors is likewise associated with delayed graft function, but also with an increased risk of primary nonfunction. Viability testing of donated organs from these sources is a prerequisite for transplantation. Machine preservation parameters and enzyme release measurements help to distinguish viable from nonviable kidneys. The proportion of NHB donor kidneys in the total pool of postmortem kidneys differs considerably between countries. In The Netherlands, the proportion is nearly 50%. This figure is markedly higher than that in the US and Canada, where national programs have now been initiated to increase rates of NHB donation. In the future, warm preservation techniques might facilitate better viability testing, thereby increasing NHB donation from category I and II donors and further reducing the shortage of kidneys available for transplantation.

Single-center experience with liver transplantation from controlled non-heartbeating donors: a viable source of grafts

BACKGROUND

To increase the number of livers available for transplantation a non-heartbeating donor (NHBD) liver transplant program was started after obtaining hospital ethical committee approval.

METHODS

Controlled donors with a warm ischemia of <30 minutes were considered. A 5-minute stand-off period was observed from asystole to skin incision. A super-rapid technique was used for the retrieval. Methods used to assess the suitability for transplantation included liver function tests, morphologic and histologic assessment, and hepatocyte viability testing.

RESULTS

Sixty livers were retrieved from NHBDs. Of these, 33 were judged suitable for transplantation. Of these one was exported and transplanted, and one could not be matched to a suitable recipient. A further 27 were not used because of liver appearance in 21, prolonged hypoxia and hypotension in 4, poor perfusion in 1, and donor malignancy in 1. Mean donor age was 39.4 years (range, 0.75-67 years). Causes of death were head trauma in 10 donors, intracranial bleed in 24, and anoxic/ischemic brain injury in 26. Mean warm ischemia time was 14.7 minutes (range, 7-40 minutes). Thirty-two patients were transplanted (one split liver), and the mean age of the recipients was 38.4 years (range, 0.7-72 years). All grafts had good early function except one right lobe split. There were 4 deaths resulting from ischemic brain injury, chronic rejection, biliary sepsis, and multiorgan failure following retransplantation for primary nonfunction. Overall patient and graft survival is 87% and 84%, respectively, at a median follow-up of 15 months.

CONCLUSIONS

Early results suggest that controlled NHBDs are a significant new source of grafts, but careful donor selection and short cold ischemia are mandatory.

Intensive Care Unit Extubation Does Not Preclude Extrarenal Organ Recovery from Donors after Cardiac Death

BACKGROUND

We have sought to increase the utilization of both renal and extrarenal organs from donors after cardiac death (DCD), including DCD donors with ICU extubation.

METHODS

Extubation occurred in the intensive care unit (ICU; n=15) and operating room (OR; n=5). The charts of donors were reviewed for demographics, cause of death, time of asystole and cold perfusion. Recipient's charts were reviewed for graft function, length of hospitalization, serum creatinine (Cr) at discharge and last follow-up. Peak transaminases, amylase, and lipase for liver and pancreas recipients were also reviewed. Data are presented as means+/-SEM.

RESULTS

From December 2002 until December 2004, 20 DCD donors were utilized yielding 34 kidney transplants (33 recipients), five liver (1 liver-kidney), and two pancreas (SPK) transplants. Mean follow-up overall is 260 days. ICU extubation occurred in 26/33 (78.8%) kidneys, 3/5(60%) livers and 1/2 (50%) pancreata performed. Time from extubation to asystole was 15.9+/-1.9 min and overall warm ischemia time was 12.5+/-1.0 min. Serum Cr at discharge and at last follow-up for renal grafts are 4.3+/-0.5 and 1.9+/-0.3 mg/dl, respectively. Peak AST and ALT levels after OLTx were 3620+/-951 and 1955+/-266 i.u., respectively. Peak and discharge total bilirubin were 8.1+/-0.9 and 2.5+/-0.5 mg/dl. Length of hospitalization was 9.6+/-1.0 and 15.8+/-2.3 days for kidney and liver recipients, respectively. Both pancreas recipients were insulin free after transplant.

CONCLUSIONS

ICU extubation should not eliminate extrarenal organs from consideration and may be preferable to OR extubation by improving family support and eliminating OR staff concerns about their role in end-of-life care.

Non???Heart-Beating Donor Kidneys in The Netherlands: Allocation and Outcome of Transplantation

BACKGROUND

Since February 1, 2001, kidneys from both heart-beating (HB) and non-heart-beating (NHB) donors in The Netherlands have been indiscriminately allocated through the standard renal-allocation system.

METHODS

Renal function and allograft-survival rate for kidneys from NHB and HB donors were compared at 3 and 12 months.

RESULTS

The outcomes of 276 renal transplants, 176 from HB donors and 100 from NHB III donors, allocated through the standard renal allocation system, Eurotransplant Kidney Allocation System, and performed between February 1, 2001 and March 1, 2002 were compared. Three months after transplantation, graft survival was 93.7% for HB kidneys and 85.0% for NHB kidneys (P<0.05). At 12 months, graft survival was 92.0% and 83.0%, respectively (P<0.03). Serum creatinine levels in the two groups were comparable at both 3 and 12 months. Multivariate analysis identified previous kidney transplantation (relative risk [RR] 3.33; P<0.005), donor creatinine (RR 1.01; P<0.005), and NHB (RR 2.38; P<0.05) as independent risk factors for transplant failure within 12 months. In multivariate analysis of NHB data, a warm ischemia time (WIT) of 30 minutes or longer (P<0.005; RR 6.16, 95% confidence interval 2.11-18.00) was associated with early graft failure. No difference in 12-month graft survival was seen between HB and NHB kidneys after excluding the kidneys that failed in the first 3 months.

CONCLUSION

Early graft failure was significantly more likely in recipients of kidneys from NHB donors. A prolonged WIT was strongly associated with this failure. Standard allocation procedures do not have a negative effect on outcome, and there is no reason to allocate NHB kidneys differently from HB kidneys.

Expression of adhesion molecules and RANTES in kidney transplant from nonheart-beating donors

The main difference between cadaveric kidneys from donors with a heartbeat (HBD) and kidneys from nonheart-beating donors (NHBD) is related to warm ischemia/reperfusion time which constitutes an acute inflammatory process. On the contrary, brain death induces in HBD expression of pro-inflammatory adhesion molecules, making it important to evaluate this kind of molecules in both types of donors. Human renal biopsies from NHBD, HBD and normal kidneys (ischemia time = 0) were taken and frozen just before transplant. A semi-quantitative RT-PCR method was used to determine intracellular adhesion molecule 1 (ICAM-1), vascular cell adhesion molecule 1 (VCAM-1), lymphocyte function associated antigen (LFA-1), LFA-3, CD40, CD40 ligand (CD40L) and RANTES (regulated upon activation, normal T-cell expressed and secreted) gene expression. We have detected an elevated relative gene expression of ICAM-1, VCAM-1 and RANTES in NHBD biopsies compared with normal kidneys. In the case of RANTES, the gene expression from NHBD biopsies was higher than observed in HBD biopsies. The rest of genes were not augmented in any group. Preliminary data about early outcome of transplants indicates a correlation between pretransplant RANTES high gene expression levels and early post-transplant acute rejection. The gene expression of pro-inflammatory molecules like adhesion molecules and RANTES is augmented in kidneys from cadaveric NBD just before transplant. The expression is higher probably because of the prolonged warm ischemia period. A larger clinical study is necessary to clarify the effects of these variable expressions on the transplant outcome.

Comparison of renal allograft fibrosis after transplantation from heart-beating and non-heart-beating donors

Background

Renal transplants from non-heart-beating donors (NHBDs) yield acceptable function and allograft survival rates in the medium term. However, the long-term results are less certain and there is a paucity of information relating to the development of chronic allograft nephropathy. The aim of this study was to compare allograft fibrosis in kidneys transplanted from NHBDs and conventional heart-beating donors (HBDs).

Methods

A series of 37 NHBD and 75 HBD renal transplants were studied. Protocol renal transplant biopsies were performed at 6 and 12 months after transplantation. Biopsy sections were stained with Sirius red to demonstrate interstitial extracellular matrix. Renal allograft fibrosis was quantified using a computerized image analysis system.

Results

The mean first warm ischaemia time for kidneys from NHBDs was 24 min. A significant delay in graft function occurred in eight of 75 recipients in the HBD group and 31 of 37 in the NHBD group (P &lt; 0·001). There were no significant differences in the level of allograft fibrosis between the two groups at any time point.

Conclusion

Despite high rates of delayed graft function secondary to a prolonged warm ischaemia time, NHBD kidneys do not appear to be more susceptible to the development of renal allograft fibrosis. This study supports the growing body of evidence that kidneys from NHBDs are an acceptable alternative to those from HBDs.

Kidney transplantation from non–heart-beating donors: Analysis of organ procurement and outcome

INTRODUCTION

Most donors in Japan have been non-heart-beating donors (NHBD), so-called "marginal donors." In Western countries kidney transplants from NHBD have also been increasing. We analyzed 120 kidneys harvested from NHBD with regard to organ procurement, renal function, graft survival, and the donor factors that affected graft survival.

METHODS

Donors were moved into the operating room after cardiac arrest. A double-balloon catheter was inserted into the abdominal aorta via laparotomy. In situ cooling by Euro-Collins solution was started at 500 mL/min. We did not performed cannulation into the femoral artery or vein prior to cardiac arrest.

RESULTS

Warm ischemia time (WIT) was 18.6 minutes. Among 108 kidneys (90%) used for transplantation, 102 kidneys functioned. There were no cases of bilateral nonfunctioning kidneys. The delayed graft function (DGF) rate was 86%; however, the death-censored graft survival was 80.0% at 5 years and 62.9% at 10 years. Kidneys implanted after more than 24 hours of total ischemia time required a significantly longer period of hemodialysis. Donor risk factors that affected graft survival included WIT >/= 20 minutes, donor age >/= 50 years, and serum creatinine level at admission > 1.0 mg/dL.

CONCLUSIONS

Organ procurement without cannulation prior to cardiac arrest entailed a long WIT and a high DGF rate. However, the graft survival was good. It has been necessary to use grafts from NHBD despite the inherent risk factors. It is important to reduce kidney damage both at the organ procurement and during the posttransplant management.

Successful non-heart-beating donor organ retrieval in a patient with a left ventricular assist device

Non-heart-beating donors (NHBD) represent an option to expand the organ supply with good results. We report a donor patient with a left ventricular assist device (LVAD) due to dilated cardiomyopathy in which controlled NHBD was performed. Due to the LVAD, a modified procurement technique was utilized. The liver and kidneys were procured and successfully transplanted. Patients and grafts are alive and well. Successful organ retrieval can be achieved on selected cases of NHBD with LVADs in which modifications of the procurement technique are implemented without jeopardizing the procurement and not increasing preservation injury.

Kidney transplantation from non heart-beating donors

The use of non heart-beating donor (NHBD) kidneys to expand transplant programmes offers an answer to the problem of donor shortage. This source of kidneys is utilised by very few renal transplant units despite longstanding and growing evidence of equivalent graft function and survival, compared with cadaveric donor organs. This article reviews the selection criteria, technical approaches and logistical organisation involved in NHBD kidney retrieval and transplantation and outlines the evidence for graft function and survival, and patient outcome. The ethical and legal implications of running a NHBD programme are discussed, and some areas of current and likely future research are covered.

Trends in organ preservation

Organ preservation aims to provide a viable graft with primary function post-transplant. The current basis of preservation for transplantation is static cold storage using specific preservation solutions which minimise cellular swelling and membrane pump activity, thus maintaining cellular ATP levels. The current organ shortage and consequent expansion of donor criteria places even greater reliance on minimising graft injury during preservation. This review focuses on current and future advances in preservation technology. The key areas of advance are additives to preservation solutions, alternatives/adjuncts to preservation solutions including perfluorocarbons. A major area of advance is in the modulation of organs during the storage period. This may be achieved by biochemical additives or genetic manipulation. Machine perfusion technology is improving, and this is discussed together with the recent concept of warm (normothermic) perfusion as an alternative means of preservation. The authors provide an overview over the current methods of organ preservation. Cold storage, effective in the short-term is insufficient for marginal organs, does not allow assessment of viability markers, and provokes ischaemic injury. Potential strategies for minimising ischaemic injury include additives to preservation solutions; the two-layer method with perfluorcarbons and UW solution-at present limited to pancreas preservation; organ modulation; organ preconditioning and genetic modification of organs. In particular, the authors illuminate the potential in a reappraisal of the concept of normothermic perfusion.