Maudsley reactive and non-reactive rats differ in exploratory behavior but not in learning

Modeling heritability of temperamental differences, stress reactivity, and risk for anxiety and depression: Relevance to research domain criteria (RDoC)

Animal models provide important tools to study biological and environmental factors that shape brain function and behavior. These models can be effectively leveraged by drawing on concepts from the National Institute of Mental Health Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) Initiative, which aims to delineate molecular pathways and neural circuits that underpin behavioral anomalies that transcend psychiatric conditions. To study factors that contribute to individual differences in emotionality and stress reactivity, our laboratory utilized Sprague-Dawley rats that were selectively bred for differences in novelty exploration. Selective breeding for low versus high locomotor response to novelty produced rat lines that differ in behavioral domains relevant to anxiety and depression, particularly the RDoC Negative Valence domains, including acute threat, potential threat, and loss. Bred Low Novelty Responder (LR) rats, relative to their High Responder (HR) counterparts, display high levels of behavioral inhibition, conditioned and unconditioned fear, avoidance, passive stress coping, anhedonia, and psychomotor retardation. The HR/LR traits are heritable, emerge in the first weeks of life, and appear to be driven by alterations in the developing amygdala and hippocampus. Epigenomic and transcriptomic profiling in the developing and adult HR/LR brain suggest that DNA methylation and microRNAs, as well as differences in monoaminergic transmission (dopamine and serotonin in particular), contribute to their distinct behavioral phenotypes. This work exemplifies ways that animal models such as the HR/LR rats can be effectively used to study neural and molecular factors driving emotional behavior, which may pave the way toward improved understanding the neurobiological mechanisms involved in emotional disorders.

High novelty-seeking rats are resilient to negative physiological effects of the early life stress

Exposure to early life stress dramatically impacts adult behavior, physiology, and neuroendocrine function. Using rats bred for novelty-seeking differences and known to display divergent anxiety, depression, and stress vulnerability, we examined the interaction between early life adversity and genetic predisposition for high- versus low-emotional reactivity. Thus, bred Low Novelty Responder (bLR) rats, which naturally exhibit high anxiety- and depression-like behavior, and bred High Novelty Responder (bHR) rats, which show low anxiety/depression together with elevated aggression, impulsivity, and addictive behavior, were subjected to daily 3 h maternal separation (MS) stress postnatal days 1-14. We hypothesized that MS stress would differentially impact adult bHR/bLR behavior, physiology (stress-induced defecation), and neuroendocrine reactivity. While MS stress did not impact bHR and bLR anxiety-like behavior in the open field test and elevated plus maze, it exacerbated bLRs' already high physiological response to stress - stress-induced defecation. In both tests, MS bLR adult offspring showed exaggerated stress-induced defecation compared to bLR controls while bHR offspring were unaffected. MS also selectively impacted bLRs' (but not bHRs') neuroendocrine stress reactivity, producing an exaggerated corticosterone acute stress response in MS bLR versus control bLR rats. These findings highlight how genetic predisposition shapes individuals' response to early life stress. Future work will explore neural mechanisms underlying the distinct behavioral and neuroendocrine consequences of MS in bHR/bLR animals.

Animal models of anxiety

Animal models for anxiety-related behavior are based on the assumption that anxiety in animals is comparable to anxiety in humans. Being anxious is an adaptive response to an unfamiliar environment, especially when confronted with danger or threat. However, pathological variants of anxiety can strongly impede the daily life of those affected. To unravel neurobiological mechanisms underlying normal anxiety as well as its pathologi- cal variations, animal models are indispensable tools. What are the characteristics of an ideal animal model? First, it should display reduced anxiety when treated with anxiolytics (predictive validity). Second, the behavioral response of an animal model to a threatening stimulus should be comparable to the response known for humans (face validity). And third, the mechanisms underlying anxiety as well as the psychological causes should be identical (construct validity). Meeting these three requirements is difficult for any animal model. Since both the physiological and the behavioral response to aversive (threatening) stimuli are similar in humans and animals, it can be assumed that animal models can serve at least two distinct purposes: as (1) behavioral tests to screen for potential anxiolytic and antidepressant effects of new drugs and (2) tools to investigate specific pathogenetic aspects of cardinal symptoms of anxiety disorders. The examples presented in this chapter have been selected to illustrate the potential as well as the caveats of current models and the emerging possibilities offered by gene technology. The main concepts in generating animal models for anxiety-that is, selective breeding of rat lines, experience-related models, genetically engineered mice, and phenotype-driven approaches-are concisely introduced and discussed. Independent of the animal model used, one major challenge remains, which is to reliably identify animal behavioral characteristics. Therefore, a description of behavioral expressions of anxiety in rodents as well as tests assays to measure anxiety-related behavior in these animals is also included in this chapter.

Persistent behavioral and autonomic supersensitivity to stress following prenatal stress exposure in rats

Prenatal restraint stress (PS) has been suggested as an attractive chronic model of anxiety. Here, we characterized the behavioral and autonomic responsivity to acute stress exposure in adult PS subjects. In Wistar rats, locomotor activity, as well as spontaneous behavior in an established animal model of anxiety, the elevated plus-maze, was unaffected by PS. However, the anxiogenic-like response normally seen on the plus-maze following a restraint stress was markedly potentiated in adult PS subjects, despite indistinguishable corticosterone responses. In addition, we assessed the tail skin temperature response to a mild social stressor, transient social mixing. The diazepam-sensitive, late phase of the temperature response was markedly potentiated in adult PS subjects. In summary, PS induces a persistent phenotype of increased behavioral and autonomic sensitivity to stress. This paradigm might serve as an attractive screening model for anti-anxiety compounds.

Molecular pathways of anxiety revealed by knockout mice

Anxiety is a normal reaction to threatening situations, and serves a physiological protective function. Pathological anxiety is characterized by a bias to interpret ambiguous situations as threatening, by avoidance of situations that are perceived to be harmful, and/or by exaggerated reactions to threat. Although much evidence indicates the involvement of the gamma-aminobutyric acid, serotonin, norepinephrine, dopamine, and neuropeptide transmitter systems in the pathophysiology of anxiety, little is known about how anxiety develops and what genetic/environmental factors underlie susceptibility to anxiety. Recently, inactivation of several genes, associated with either chemical communication between neurons or signaling within neurons, has been shown to give rise to anxiety-related behavior in knockout mice. Apart from confirming the involvement of serotonin, gamma-aminobutyric acid, and corticotrophin-releasing hormone as major mediators of anxiety and stress related behaviors, two novel groups of anxiety-relevant molecules have been revealed. The first group consists of neurotrophic-type molecules, such as interferon gamma, neural cell adhesion molecule, and midkine, which play important roles in neuronal development and cell-to-cell communication. The second group comprises regulators of intracellular signaling and gene expression, which emphasizes the importance of gene regulation in anxiety-related behaviors. Defects in these molecules are likely to contribute to the abnormal development and/or function of neuronal networks, which leads to the manifestation of anxiety disorders.

Differences in central noradrenergic and behavioural responses of Maudsley non-reactive and Maudsley reactive inbred rats on exposure to an aversive novel environment

The present experiments compared the noradrenaline and behavioural responses of inbred Maudsley reactive (MR) and non-reactive (MNRA) rats when they are exposed to the light or dark arena of a light/dark shuttle-box. Behavioural scores confirmed that both strains of rats perceived the light arena to be more aversive than the dark one. Using in vivo microdialysis, exposure to the light, but not the dark, arena was found to increase noradrenaline efflux in both the frontal cortex and the hypothalamus of MNRA and MR rats. However, whereas the increase in the frontal cortex of both strains and the hypothalamus of MR rats was transient, the hypothalamic response in MNRA rats was maintained throughout exposure to the test zone. Strain differences in activity/visit and time/visit were evident but it was not possible to discern whether this could be attributed to the strain difference in the hypothalamic noradrenaline response. Nevertheless, it remains possible that, by comparison with MR rats, the prolonged noradrenaline response in the hypothalamus of MNRA rats could contribute to their well-documented, greater resistance to aversive environmental stimuli.

Increased anxiety of mice lacking the serotonin1A receptor

Brain serotonin (5-HT) has been implicated in a number of physiological processes and pathological conditions. These effects are mediated by at least 14 different 5-HT receptors. We have inactivated the gene encoding the 5-HT1A receptor in mice and found that receptor-deficient animals have an increased tendency to avoid a novel and fearful environment and to escape a stressful situation, behaviors consistent with an increased anxiety and stress response. Based on the role of the 5-HT1A receptor in the feedback regulation of the 5-HT system, we hypothesize that an increased serotonergic neurotransmission is responsible for the anxiety-like behavior of receptor-deficient animals. This view is consistent with earlier studies showing that pharmacological activation of the 5-HT system is anxiogenic in animal models and also in humans.

Behavioural and intestinal responses to novelty in rats selected for diverging reactivity in the open field test

There are indications that the severity of functional gastrointestinal disturbances in humans is linked to individual coping styles. In rodents, the open field test can be used to assess individual differences in behavioural responsivity to novel challenges. Two groups of Wistar rats were selected for high (HA) and low (LA) locomotor activity in a novel open field and fitted with electrodes on the proximal colon. During subsequent exposure to a novel box, a smaller locomotor activation in LA was accompanied by a greater increase in colonic spike burst activity compared to HA rats, even though this novel stressful challenge did not result in a clear defecation response in either group. In contrast, no marked behavioural differences between HA and LA were seen in the shock prod paradigm. Although detection of divergent behavioural responsivity in HA and LA rats may depend on stimulus quality or intensity, combined use of behavioural selection and intestinal motility recording in freely moving rats may offer a model to study individual vulnerability to stress-related disturbances of intestinal function.

Administration of antidepressants, diazepam and psychomotor stimulants further confirms the utility of Flinders Sensitive Line rats as an animal model of depression

Flinders Sensitive Line (FSL) rats have been proposed as an animal model of depression because they resemble depressed humans in that they have elevated REM sleep, reduced activity, and increased immobility and anhedonia after exposure to stressors. The present paper reviews experiments on the drug treatment of FSL and control Flinders Resistant Line (FRL) rats related to their utility as an animal model of depression, and presents new information. FSL rats exhibited exaggerated immobility in the forced swim test which is counteracted by the tricyclic antidepressants imipramine and desipramine and the serotonin reuptake blocker sertraline; the low immobility exhibited by the FRL rats is generally unaffected by these compounds. In contrast to these "therapeutic" effects of well recognized antidepressants, lithium and bright light treatment did not alter the exaggerated immobility of FSL rats. Novel data indicated that neither FSL nor FRL rats exhibited alterations in swim test immobility following chronic administration of the psychomotor stimulant amphetamine (2 mg/kg) and the anticholinergic scopolamine (2 mg/kg), which typically reduce immobility after acute administration. However, it was found that the calcium channel blockers verapamil (5 and 15 mg/kg) and nicardipine (10 mg/kg) did reduce the exaggerated immobility in FSL rats following chronic administration, suggesting that these compounds need to be evaluated further in humans. Previous studies have indicated no differences between FSL and FRL rats evaluated in the elevated plus maze, either at baseline or after the administration of diazepam, suggesting that the FSL rat may not differ from controls in anxiety-related behavior. Another recently published study showed that the FSL rat also did not differ from normal Sprague-Dawley rats in startle tests, indicating that the FSL rats do not exhibit behaviors shown in animal models of schizophrenia. These findings confirm the utility of FSL rats as an animal model of depression because the FSL rats do not appear to exhibit behaviors analogous to anxiety or schizophrenia and because they respond "therapeutically" to antidepressants and not psychomotor stimulants.