Polyreactive autoantibodies purified from human intravenous immunoglobulins prevent the development of experimental autoimmune diseases

Interaction with 2,4-dinitrophenol correlates with polyreactivity, self-binding, and stability of clinical-stage therapeutic antibodies

Therapeutic antibodies should cover particular physicochemical and functional requirements for successful entry into clinical practice. Numerous experimental and computational approaches have been developed for early identification of different unfavourable features of antibodies. Immune repertoires of healthy humans contain a fraction of antibodies that recognize nitroarenes. These antibodies have been demonstrated to manifest antigen-binding polyreactivity. Here we observed that >20 % of 112 clinical stage therapeutic antibodies show pronounced binding to 2,4-dinitrophenol conjugated to albumin. This interaction predicts a number of unfavourable functional and physicochemical features of antibodies such as polyreactivity, tendency for self-association, stability and expression yields. Based on these findings we proposed a simple approach that may add to the armamentarium of assays for early identification of developability liabilities of antibodies intended for therapeutic use.

Harnessing the Therapeutic Potential of 'Rogue' Antibodies

Therapeutic antibodies have revolutionized modern medicine. At present, antibodies are successfully used for treatment of diverse human diseases, ranging from cancer to viral infections. All clinically approved antibodies rely on highly specific recognition of their target antigen. Antigen-binding promiscuity, binding to autoantigens, and propensity for self-binding (homophilic interaction) are highly undesirable characteristics of antibody drug candidates. Nevertheless, the immune system of all healthy individuals constantly produces and uses large quantities of antibodies that can be classified as inappropriate for development as drugs. Here, I provide arguments that antibodies with 'aberrant' properties have therapeutic potential. They could be useful in certain complex pathological conditions, thus enriching our armamentarium for treatment of human diseases.

The Modified Vaccination Technique

In addition to active and passive immunizations, there is a third method of immunization, the modified vaccination technique, which is based on injecting a combination of target antigens and antibodies against this antigen. The vaccine is essentially comprised of immune complexes with pre-determined immune-inducing components. When such an immune complex (target antigen × antibody against the target antigen) with a slight antigen excess is administered, it evokes a corrective immune response by the production of the same antibody with the same specificity against the target antigen that is present in the immune complex (pre-determined immune response).

Natural and disease-specific autoantibodies in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

Autoimmunity may contribute to the pathogenesis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Studies have identified disease-specific autoantibodies (DSAAbs) in COPD patients, but natural autoantibodies (NAAbs) may also play a role. Previous studies have concentrated on circulating autoantibodies, but lung-associated autoantibodies may be most important. Our aim was to investigate NAAbs and DSAAbs in the circulation and lungs of COPD smoking (CS) patients compared to smokers (S) without airway obstruction and subjects who have never smoked (NS). Immunoglobulin (Ig)G antibodies that bind to lung tissue components were significantly lower in the circulation of CS patients than NS (with intermediate levels in S), as detected by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The levels of antibodies to collagen-1 (the major lung collagen) detected by ELISA were also reduced significantly in CS patients’ sera compared to NS. The detection of these antibodies in NS subjects indicates that they are NAAbs. The occurrence of DSAAbs in some CS patients and S subjects was indicated by high levels of serum IgG antibodies to cytokeratin-18 and collagen-5; furthermore, antibodies to collagen-5 eluted from homogenized lung tissue exposed to low pH (0·1 M glycine, pH 2·8) were raised significantly in CS compared to S and NS. Thus, this study supports a role in COPD for both NAAbs and DSAAbs.

Intravenous immunoglobulin for the treatment of Alzheimer's disease: current evidence and considerations

Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a devastating neurodegenerative form of dementia with increasing incidence rates in most countries. AD is characterized by amyloid plaques and neurofibrillary tangles in the brains of AD individuals accompanied by global neuronal loss. The peptide amyloid-β (Aβ) aggregates to amyloid plaques in AD brains. As a result, many therapeutic approaches target Aβ. Human plasma and the plasma product intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) contain naturally-occurring anti-Aβ antibodies (Nabs-Aβ) that appear to reduce risks of developing AD. IVIG sequesters Aβ and thus interferes with AD progression. This study reviews the role of different Aβ species, Nabs-Aβ, preclinical data, and clinical studies of IVIG as potential AD treatments. The focus of this study is the outcomes of a recent Gammaglobulin Alzheimer's Partnership Phase III trial that did not reach primary endpoints, as well as efforts to compare IVIG with current anti-Aβ monoclonals such as bapineuzumab, solanezumab, and BIIB037. Moreover, this study critically examines current market and ethical consequences of potential off-label uses of IVIG, limits in IVIG supply, and subsequent challenges.

Polyreactive antibodies plus complement enhance the phagocytosis of cells made apoptotic by UV-light or HIV

Polyreactive antibodies are a major component of the natural antibody repertoire and are capable of binding a variety of structurally unrelated antigens. Many of the properties attributed to natural antibodies, in fact, are turning out to be due to polyreactive antibodies. In humans, each day, billions of cells undergo apoptosis. In the present experiments, we show by ImageStream technology that although polyreactive antibodies do not bind to live T cells they bind to both the plasma membrane and cytoplasm of late apoptotic cells, fix complement, generate the anaphylatoxin C5a and increase by as much as 5 fold complement-mediated phagocytosis by macrophages. Of particular importance, T cells undergoing apoptosis following infection with HIV also bind polyreactive antibodies and are phagocytosed. We conclude that the polyreactive antibodies in the natural antibody repertoire contribute in a major way to the clearance of cells made apoptotic by a variety of natural and infectious processes.

In vitro and in vivo properties differ among liquid intravenous immunoglobulin preparations

Objective To compare in vitro and in vivo biological and biochemical properties of five liquid intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) preparations licensed for therapeutic use in Europe.

Methods ClairYg® was compared in a blinded manner to four other liquid IVIg preparations licensed in Europe (Octagam®, Kiovig®, Gamunex®, Privigen®). Three batches of each preparation were tested, except for the IgG repertoires and the animal model.

Results Levels of anti-A and anti-B antibodies were lower in ClairYg® (0·11/0·11) relative to a positive EDQM standard and Octagam® (0·11/0·08) than in other preparations (0·33–0·69/0·42–0·46). IgG in ClairYg® recognized 365 and 416 protein spots in HEp-2 cell and Escherichia coli protein extracts vs. 230–330 and 402–842 protein spots, respectively, for IgG in other preparations. IgA content (301 vs. 165–820 ng/mg of IgG), Factor XI and Factor XII antigen (0·46 vs. 0·85–2·40 mU/mg of IgG and 7·8 vs. 20·0–46·2 lU/mg of IgG) C1q binding (0·42 vs. 0·67–1·89 arbitrary units) and C5a uptake (0·41 vs. 0·45–0·66% of activation) were lower in ClairYg® than in other preparations. Finally, intravenous infusion of ClairYg®, Gamunex® and Privigen® had no major effect on arterial blood pressure in spontaneously hypertensive rats.

Conclusions Our results evidence some differences in the biological and biochemical properties among licensed liquid IVIg preparations.

Plasmodium riboprotein PfP0 induces a deviant humoral immune response in Balb/c mice

Passive immunization with antibodies to recombinant Plasmodium falciparum P0 riboprotein (rPfP0, 61–316 amino acids) provides protection against malaria. Carboxy-terminal 16 amino acids of the protein (PfP0C0) are conserved and show 69% identity to human and mouse P0. Antibodies to this domain are found in 10–15% of systemic lupus erythematosus patients. We probed the nature of humoral response to PfP0C0 by repeatedly immunizing mice with rPfP0. We failed to raise stable anti-PfP0C0 hybridomas from any of the 21 mice. The average serum anti-PfP0C0 titer remained low (5.1 ± 1.3 × 10⁴). Pathological changes were observed in the mice after seven boosts. Adsorption with dinitrophenyl hapten revealed that the anti-PfP0C0 response was largely polyreactive. This polyreactivity was distributed across all isotypes. Similar polyreactive responses to PfP0 and PfP0C0 were observed in sera from malaria patients. Our data suggests that PfP0 induces a deviant humoral response, and this may contribute to immune evasion mechanisms of the parasite.

IVIg-mediated inhibition of antigen presentation: predominant role of naturally occurring cationic IgG

The infusion of high doses of intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIg) produce anti-inflammatory effects in a diversity of autoimmune disorders. The need for such high doses suggests that only a small fraction of IgG is responsible for the anti-inflammatory effects. We recently showed that IVIg was internalized in APCs to compete with antigens for loading on MHC II molecules, leading to reduced antigen-specific T cell responses. Here we show that highly cationic IgG molecules present in IVIg are internalized more efficiently than IVIg in mouse P388D1 cells. We also show that the increased internalization correlates with the extent of inhibition of antigen presentation. Chemically cationized IVIg similarly showed improved internalization and inhibition of antigen presentation properties compared to IVIg. These observations suggest that highly cationic IgG are important mediators of the anti-inflammatory effects of IVIg resulting from inhibition of antigen presentation, such as the reduction in T cell activation and autoantibody production.

Activating Fc gamma receptors participate in the development of autoimmune diabetes in NOD mice

Type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1D) in humans is an organ-specific autoimmune disease in which pancreatic islet beta cells are ruptured by autoreactive T cells. NOD mice, the most commonly used animal model of T1D, show early infiltration of leukocytes in the islets (insulitis), resulting in islet destruction and diabetes later. NOD mice produce various islet beta cell-specific autoantibodies, although it remains a subject of debate regarding whether these autoantibodies contribute to the development of T1D. Fc gammaRs are multipotent molecules that play important roles in Ab-mediated regulatory as well as effector functions in autoimmune diseases. To investigate the possible role of Fc gammaRs in NOD mice, we generated several Fc gammaR-less NOD lines, namely FcR common gamma-chain (Fc Rgamma)-deficient (NOD.gamma(-/-)), Fc gammaRIII-deficient (NOD.III(-/-)), Fc gammaRIIB-deficient (NOD.IIB(-/-)), and both Fc Rgamma and Fc gammaRIIB-deficient NOD (NOD.null) mice. In this study, we show significant protection from diabetes in NOD.gamma(-/-), NOD.III(-/-), and NOD.null, but not in NOD.IIB(-/-) mice even with grossly comparable production of autoantibodies among them. Insulitis in NOD.gamma(-/-) mice was also alleviated. Adoptive transfer of bone marrow-derived dendritic cells or NK cells from NOD mice rendered NOD.gamma(-/-) animals more susceptible to diabetes, suggesting a possible scenario in which activating Fc gammaRs on dendritic cells enhance autoantigen presentation leading to the activation of autoreactive T cells, and Fc gammaRIII on NK cells trigger Ab-dependent effector functions and inflammation. These findings highlight the critical roles of activating Fc gammaRs in the development of T1D, and indicate that Fc gammaRs are novel targets for therapies for T1D.

B7 and 34B7 Monoclonal Antibodies: A Theoretical Approach to the Molecular Basis of Immunoglobulin Cross-Reactive Antibodies

Neonatal natural antibodies (NAbs) are characterized by their high degree of idiotypic cross reactivity, together with some restrictions in the genetic mechanisms of variable region diversity. We report here the immunogenetic analysis of two anti-idiotype antibodies (B7 and 34B7 monoclonal antibodies [MAbs]), which are also polyreactive as NAbs. Evidence of a process of somatic mutations were found for heavy and light chain variable regions of both antibodies. A phylogenetic analysis of the V(H)J558 family showed that the immunoglobulin cross-reactivity displayed by B7 and 34B7 MAbs is not restricted to a particular subgroup of this family. Moreover, we identified amino acid motifs in the CDR H1 and H2 of B7 and 34B7 MAbs that are also present in high proportion in immunoglobulin cross-reactive antibodies (ICRA) reported in the Kabat database. We propose that these regions are involved in ICRA activity.

Inflammation, demyelination, neurodegeneration and neuroprotection in the pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis

Although axonal loss has been observed in demyelinated multiple sclerosis (MS) lesions, there has been a major focus on understanding mechanisms of demyelination. However, identification of markers for axonal damage and development of new imaging techniques has enabled detection of subtle changes in axonal pathology and revived interest in the neurodegenerative component of MS. Axonal loss is generally accepted as the main determinant of permanent clinical disability. However, the role of axonal loss early in disease or during relapsing-remitting disease is still under investigation, as are the interactions and interdependency between inflammation, demyelination, neurodegeneration and neuroprotection in the pathogenesis of MS.

Effect of rat kidney fraction 3 (rKF3) antigen and specific IgM antibody against rKF3 on the progression of slowly progressive Heymann nephritis

The aim of the present study was to find out if specific IgM (M) antibody (directed against rat kidney fraction 3 (rKF3)) or rKF3 antigen were able to influence disease progression in an experimental autoimmune kidney disease called slowly progressive Heymann nephritis (SPHN). The level of circulating autoantibodies (aabs) and the morphological and functional changes to the kidney were studied in six groups of rats. All of the treatment components (except post-treatment with M) used in the SPHN pre- and post-treated rats and post-treated-only rats had measurable beneficial effects (even during restimulation with the chemically modified renal antigen, 22 weeks after the induction of the disease) as demonstrated by diminished pathogenic IgG aab production, less severe kidney lesions, and proteinuria reductions. The injected rKF3 minimized progression best in this experiment, especially when administered in a pre- and post-treatment regimen. It is thought that the effect of rKF3 in the reduced progression of SPHN was due to increased production of specific IgM aabs, which in turn limited pathogenic aab production and continuous buildup of immune complexes in the glomeruli by facilitating removal or blockage of nephritogenic autoantigens from the circulation.

Increased levels of IgE and autoreactive, polyreactive IgG in wild rodents: implications for the hygiene hypothesis

To probe the potential role of Th1 versus Th2 reactivity underlying the hygiene hypothesis, intrinsic levels of Th1-associated and Th2-associated antibodies in the serum of wild rodents were compared with that in various strains of laboratory rodents. Studies using rat lung antigens as a target indicated that wild rats have substantially greater levels of autoreactive, polyreactive immunoglobulin G (IgG), but not autoreactive, polyreactive IgM than do laboratory rats, both on a quantitative and qualitative basis. Increased levels of serum IgG and IgE were observed in both wild rats and wild mice relative to their laboratory-raised counterparts, with the effect being most pronounced for IgE levels. Further, wild rats had greater intrinsic levels of both Th1- and Th2-associated IgG subclasses than did lab rats. The habitat (wild versus laboratory raised) had a more substantial impact on immunoglobulin concentration than did age, strain or gender in the animals studied. The presence in wild rodents of increased intrinsic, presumably protective, non-pathogenic responses similar to both autoimmune (autoreactive IgG, Th1-associated) and allergic (IgE, Th2-associated) reactions as well as increased levels of Th1-associated and Th2-associated IgG subclasses points toward a generally increased stimulation of the immune system in these animals rather than a shift in the nature of the immunoreactivity. It is concluded that, at least to the extent that feedback inhibition is a controlling element of immunoreactivity, an overly hygienic environment may affect the threshold of both types of immune responses more so than the balance between the different responses.

Therapeutic intravenous immunoglobulins

Intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIg) are concentrated formulations of human IgG prepared by industrial fractionation of large pools of individual plasma donations. IVIg were developed 20 years ago for the prophylaxis support of immunodeficient patients. However, IVIg have been increasingly used since 10 years, in the treatment of many autoimmune and inflammatory diseases raising the possibility of product shortages and ever increasing costs in the near future. Surprisingly, the immunomodulatory mechanisms of action of IVIg are unclear because of the diversity and often contradictory Fc, F(ab')(2), and non-IgG-related mechanisms that have been proposed from clinical observations and from results obtained in various in vitro and in vivo experimental models. These concepts are reviewed here and we discuss in more details three areas of active research, namely the mechanisms of IVIg action in Idiopathic Thrombocytopenic Purpura (ITP), the effects of IVIg on activated B lymphocytes and the possible involvement of autoantibodies of IgG isotype (auto-IgG) in the immunomodulatory effects of IVIg. The elucidation of the mechanisms of action of IVIg is crucial for a more rationalized clinical use of IVIg and for developing substitutes for some of the immunomodulatory indications in order to ensure long-term availability of plasma-derived IVIg for immunodeficient patients.

Down-regulation of pathogenic autoantibody response in a slowly progressive Heymann nephritis kidney disease model

In the present article, we describe an antigen-specific down-regulation of a pathogenic autoantibody (aab)-mediated disease process in an experimental autoimmune kidney disease in rats called slowly progressive Heymann nephritis (SPHN). This autoimmune disease is initiated and maintained by pathogenic immunoglobulin G (IgG) autoantibodies (aabs), which cause an immune-complex (IC) glomerulonephritis associated with proteinuria. We achieved down-regulated pathogenic aab response in SPHN rats by injections of an IC containing the native nephritogenic antigen and specific high-titred nonpathogenic IgM aabs, in antigen excess. The injected IC increased the level of circulating nonpathogenic IgM aabs; the increased levels of specific IgM aabs in turn facilitated the removal of the injected altered nephritogenic and liberated autoantigens from the renal tubules and greatly diminished the production of pathogenic aabs and the build up of immune deposits in the glomeruli. While animals treated early had advantages over rats whose kidney disease was well established before treatment; animals treated late into the disease still manifested noticeable improvements in similar areas, i.e. with lessened proteinuria, kidney lesion reduction and a decreased pathogenic aab response. At the end of the experiment at 29 weeks, 80% of all the treated rats had insignificantly low levels of circulating IgG aabs, indicating cessation of pathogenic aab production and corresponding termination of the disease process. In contrast, most untreated rats with the kidney disease still had high levels of circulating pathogenic aabs at the end of the experiment, which maintained disease progression.

Effets immunomodulateurs des immunoglobulines intraveineuses

Intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIg) are therapeutic preparations of normal human IgG obtained from pools of more than 1000 healthy blood donors. They are currently used in the treatment of a wide range of auto-immune diseases, whether associated with auto-antibodies or auto-reactive T lymphocytes, as well as in the treatment of systemic inflammatory diseases. Several mechanisms of action have been identified during the last 20 years, including: (i) modulation of Fc receptors expression on leukocytes and endothelial cells; (ii) interaction with complement proteins; (iii) modulation of cytokines and chemokines synthesis and release; (iv) modulation of cell proliferation and apoptosis; (v) remyelinisation; (vi) neutralisation of circulating autoantibodies; (vii) selection of repertoires of B and T lymphocytes; (viii) interaction with other cell-surface molecules on lymphocytes and monocytes; (ix) corticosteroid sparing. These mechanisms of action are multiple and often intricate. However, they are still little known and further investigations are warranted.