The Relationship Between the Grading of Reflective Journals and Student Honesty in Reflective Journal Writing

Reflective based learning for nursing ethical competency during clinical practices

BACKGROUND

A combination of theoretical and practical approaches is required to learn and acquire ethical competencies in caring. Occasionally, reflection on practical action differs from theoretical learning. In the context of reflective learning, issues such as ethical values can be discussed since they evoke conflict among nursing students.

AIM

To identify ethical conflicts encountered by nursing students during clinical placements and to determine their cooperation strategies.

RESEARCH DESIGN

Qualitative study with a content analysis according to Elo and Kinglas framework.

PARTICIPANTS AND RESEARCH CONTEXT

Students enrolled in a nursing program at a Spanish university aged between 22 and 35, mainly women.

METHODOLOGY

The study includes 134 ethical reflections from nursing students in the last year of the nursing program, written during their clinical practices in a variety of learning environments. The research team analyzed the reflections using an inductive content analysis method.

ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS

Ethical permission was obtained by the management center according to Law 3/2028, and all the participants accepted to participate through the informed consent form.

FINDINGS

Three main categories emerged from the analysis of the ethical reflections: (1) evaluation of professional performance and patient care; (2) the student as the protagonist of the dilemma; (3) student coping. Student dilemmas and concerns are related to ignorance, student-patient communication, mistakes made and self-confidence. Some situations conflict with the autonomy of patients and their rights, and can contribute to stressful situations for patients. Stress factors include hospital routines, which the patient cannot modify, and asymmetric relationships with staff, which encourage passivity.

CONCLUSION

All ethical problems detected by the students begin with the professional-patient relationship, including issues related to bad news, errors or malpractice. Reflection on the ethical values of nursing, both in the classroom and in clinical practices, allows students to develop a greater ethical awareness of care, enhancing their decision-making skills in ethical dilemmas.

Differential Grading of Reflective Writing Between Clinical Instructors and Faculty Type

BACKGROUND

It is important for instructors to give equivalent grades for comparable student performances on an assignment. Students complain of differential grading, especially when multiple instructors grade a course assignment.

METHOD

This descriptive comparative study examined clinical instructor-assigned grades for reflective thinking and writing components. Grades for 480 critical reflective papers by 80 undergraduate nursing students were assessed for differences between clinical group instructors and part-time versus full-time instructors.

RESULTS

Despite evidence of comparable student performance on the assignment across both groups, grades differed among the 10 instructors on both components. Grades differed between part-time and full-time faculty on reflective thinking but not writing, with part-time faculty grading reflective thinking higher than full-time faculty.

CONCLUSION

Differential grading was identified between clinical instructors and type of faculty. The merit of multiple instructors grading a single course assignment warrants reconsideration. Enhanced grading training is recommended for part-time instructors who are expected to grade written assignments. [J Nurs Educ. 2023;62(2):101-104.].

Correlates, motivating factors, and barriers of engaging in regular self-reflection among public health students in higher education-A mixed methods approach

Despite the wide implementation of self-reflection in higher education, the body of literature has predominantly focused on students from the clinical health sciences rather than public health. The objective of this study was to evaluate the correlates as well as to explore the motivating factors and barriers of engaging in regular self-reflection among public health students in higher education. We used a mixed methods approach (explanatory sequential design), comprising a cross-sectional survey (quantitative phase) followed by in-depth interviews (qualitative phase). We evaluated the association between reflection frequency as well as the perceptions and facilitators in reflection using the modified Breslow-Cox proportional hazards regression model. Prevalence ratio (PR) was generated. Thematic data analysis was carried out to analyse the qualitative data. Quantitative findings revealed being a regular reflector was positively associated with being more motivated to learn when one applied self-reflection (adjusted PR 1.60, 95% CI 1.17-2.20), the perception of being more prepared for a public health career in the future (adjusted PR 1.28, 95% CI 1.02-1.60), as well as being given enough opportunities to carry out self-reflection in the public health modules (adjusted PR 1.24, 95% CI 1.05-1.45). Qualitative findings revealed most students started their self-reflection mainly due to extrinsic factors such as institutional support, social support, teacher influence and environmental influence. Of these, the most prominent was teacher influence, indicating that they are key agents in promoting self-reflection. Students expressed that it would be important to cultivate intrinsic motivation to sustain their practice of self-reflection along the learning journey such as for the development of career-related professional skills. Other than intrinsic motivation, environmental influences were also important to promote continual reflection among students such as the availability of ample opportunities. Prominent barriers to address included external student factors such as the imbalanced power relationship between teacher and student, and internal student factors such as the perception that self-reflection was too cumbersome and time consuming.