Improving Microcirculation is More Effective Than Substitution of Red Blood Cells to Correct Metabolic Disorder in Experimental Hemorrhagic Shock

Pathophysiology of Hemorrhage as It Relates to the Warfighter

Saving lives of wounded military Warfighters often depends on the ability to resolve or mitigate the pathophysiology of hemorrhage, specifically diminished oxygen delivery to vital organs that leads to multi-organ failure and death. However, caring for hemorrhaging patients on the battlefield presents unique challenges that extend beyond applying a tourniquet and giving a blood transfusion, especially when battlefield care must be provided for a prolonged period. This review will describe these challenges and potential strategies for treating hemorrhage on the battlefield in a prolonged casualty care situation.

Resuscitation After Hemorrhagic Shock in the Microcirculation: Targeting Optimal Oxygen Delivery in the Design of Artificial Blood Substitutes

Microcirculatory preservation is essential for patient recovery from hemorrhagic shock. In hemorrhagic shock, microcirculatory flow and pressure are greatly reduced, creating an oxygen debt that may eventually become irreversible. During shock, tissues become hypoxic, cellular respiration turns to anaerobic metabolism, and the microcirculation rapidly begins to fail. This condition requires immediate fluid resuscitation to promote tissue reperfusion. The choice of fluid for resuscitation is whole blood; however, this may not be readily available and, on a larger scale, may be globally insufficient. Thus, extensive research on viable alternatives to blood has been undertaken in an effort to develop a clinically deployable blood substitute. This has not, as of yet, achieved fruition, in part due to an incomplete understanding of the complexities of the function of blood in the microcirculation. Hemodynamic resuscitation is acknowledged to be contingent on a number of factors other than volume expansion. The circulation of whole blood is carefully regulated to optimize oxygen delivery to the tissues via shear stress modulation through blood viscosity, inherent oxygen-carrying capacity, cell-free layer variation, and myogenic response, among other variables. Although plasma expanders can address a number of these issues, hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers (HBOCs) introduce a method of replenishing the intrinsic oxygen-carrying capacity of blood. There continue to be a number of issues related to HBOCs, but recent advances in the next-generation HBOCs show promise in the preservation of microcirculatory function and limiting toxicities. The development of HBOCs is now focused on viscosity and the degree of microvascular shear stress achieved in order to optimize vasoactive and oxygen delivery responses by leveraging the restoration and maintenance of physiological responses to blood flow in the microcirculation. Blood substitutes with higher viscous properties tend to improve oxygen delivery compared to those with lower viscosities. This review details current concepts in blood substitutes, particularly as they relate to trauma/hemorrhagic shock, with a specific focus on their complex interactions in the microcirculation.

Role of albumin in the preservation of endothelial glycocalyx integrity and the microcirculation: a review

The endothelial glycocalyx comprises a complex layer of membrane-bound proteoglycans, secreted glycosaminoglycans, glycoproteins, glycolipids and bound plasma proteins such as albumin and antithrombin associated with the endothelial surface. The glycocalyx plays an important role in vascular homeostasis, regulating vascular permeability and cell adhesion, and acts as a mechanosensor for hemodynamic shear stresses; it also has antithrombotic and anti-inflammatory functions. Plasma proteins such as albumin are physiologically bound within the glycocalyx, thus contributing to stability of the layer. Albumin is the major determinant of plasma colloid osmotic pressure. In addition, albumin transports sphingosine-1-phosphate which has protective endothelial effects, acts as a free radical scavenger, and has immunomodulatory and anti-inflammatory effects. This review examines the physiological function of the endothelial glycocalyx and the role of human albumin in preserving glycocalyx integrity and the microcirculation.

Colloids and the Microcirculation

Colloid solutions have been advocated for use in treating hypovolemia due to their expected effect on improving intravascular retention compared with crystalloid solutions. Because the ultimate desired effect of fluid resuscitation is the improvement of microcirculatory perfusion and tissue oxygenation, it is of interest to study the effects of colloids and crystalloids at the level of microcirculation under conditions of shock and fluid resuscitation, and to explore the potential benefits of using colloids in terms of recruiting the microcirculation under conditions of hypovolemia. This article reviews the physiochemical properties of the various types of colloid solutions (eg, gelatin, dextrans, hydroxyethyl starches, and albumin) and the effects that they have under various conditions of hypovolemia in experimental and clinical scenarios.

Impact of plasma viscosity on microcirculatory flow after traumatic haemorrhagic shock: A prospective observational study

BACKGROUND

Preclinical studies report that higher plasma viscosity improves microcirculatory flow after haemorrhagic shock and resuscitation, but no clinical study has tested this hypothesis.

OBJECTIVE

We investigated the relationship between plasma viscosity and sublingual microcirculatory flow in patients during resuscitation for traumatic haemorrhagic shock (THS).

METHODS

Sublingual video-microscopy was performed for 20 trauma patients with THS as soon as feasible in hospital, and then at 24 h and 48 h. Values were obtained for total vessel density, perfused vessel density, proportion of perfused vessels, microcirculatory flow index (MFI), microcirculatory heterogeneity index (MHI), and Point of Care Microcirculation (POEM) scores. Plasma viscosity was measured using a Wells-Brookfield cone and plate micro-viscometer. Logistic regression analyses examined relationships between microcirculatory parameters and plasma viscosity, adjusting for covariates (systolic blood pressure, heart rate, haematocrit, rate and volume of fluids, and rate of noradrenaline).

RESULTS

Higher plasma viscosity was not associated with improved microcirculatory parameters. Instead, there were weakly significant associations between higher plasma viscosity and lower (poorer) MFI (p = 0.040), higher (worse) MHI (p = 0.033), and lower (worse) POEM scores (p = 0.039).

CONCLUSIONS

The current study did not confirm the hypothesis that higher plasma viscosity improves microcirculatory flow dynamics in patients with THS. Further clinical investigations are warranted to determine whether viscosity is a physical parameter of importance during resuscitation of these patients.

Hemorrhagic Shock and the Microvasculature

The microvasculature plays a central role in the pathophysiology of hemorrhagic shock and is also involved in arguably all therapeutic attempts to reverse or minimize the adverse consequences of shock. Microvascular studies specific to hemorrhagic shock were reviewed and broadly grouped depending on whether data were obtained on animal or human subjects. Dedicated sections were assigned to microcirculatory changes in specific organs, and major categories of pathophysiological alterations and mechanisms such as oxygen distribution, ischemia, inflammation, glycocalyx changes, vasomotion, endothelial dysfunction, and coagulopathy as well as biomarkers and some therapeutic strategies. Innovative experimental methods were also reviewed for quantitative microcirculatory assessment as it pertains to changes during hemorrhagic shock. The text and figures include representative quantitative microvascular data obtained in various organs and tissues such as skin, muscle, lung, liver, brain, heart, kidney, pancreas, intestines, and mesentery from various species including mice, rats, hamsters, sheep, swine, bats, and humans. Based on reviewed findings, a new integrative conceptual model is presented that includes about 100 systemic and local factors linked to microvessels in hemorrhagic shock. The combination of systemic measures with the understanding of these processes at the microvascular level is fundamental to further develop targeted and personalized interventions that will reduce tissue injury, organ dysfunction, and ultimately mortality due to hemorrhagic shock. Published 2018. Compr Physiol 8:61-101, 2018.

Transfusion of Blood Products Affects Outcome in Cardiac Surgery

There remains controversy as to when patients undergoing cardiac surgery should receive a transfusion and whether a low hematocrit and its treatment with a transfusion of red cells influences outcome. The data related to this controversy are reviewed. Although the risk of known viral transmission is currently low, stored red cells do not function normally, and each unit contains activated inflammatory cells and mediators. These changes cause limited oxygen release, impaired microcirculatory flow, and immune suppression. A number of studies have observed decreased survival associated with transfusions in trauma, coronary artery bypass grafting, and intensive care unit patients. Studies that show an adverse outcome associated with low hematocrit are not definitive, because they fail to distinguish between the impact of low hematocrit per se and the possible adverse effects of transfusion, for what the low hematocrit may simply be a surrogate. The observation that a low hematocrit is associated with an adverse outcome does not necessarily prove that “treatment” of the anemia with a red cell transfusion will improve the outcome. Stored platelets contain a highly activated mixture of platelets with storage lesions and inflammatory mediators. Two retrospective post hoc multifactorial analyses suggest that platelet transfusions are associated with substantial increased morbidity and mortality. Clearly, large prospective studies are required to define the proper trigger for blood product transfusion to balance the adverse effects of anemia and platelet deficiency or dysfunction with the adverse effects of transfusion of blood products on morbidity and mortality associated with cardiac surgery and anesthesia.

The effects of hyperoxaemia on tissue oxygenation in patients with a nadir haematocrit lower than 20% during cardiopulmonary bypass

Excessive haemodilution and the resulting anaemia during CPB is accompanied by a decrease in the total arterial oxygen content, which may impair tissue oxygen delivery. Hyperoxic ventilation has been proven to improve tissue oxygenation in different pathophysiological states of anaemic tissue hypoxia. The aim of this study was to examine the influence of arterial hyperoxaemia on tissue oxygenation during CPB. Records of patients undergoing isolated CABG with CPB were retrospectively reviewed. Patients with nadir haematocrit levels below 20% during CPB were included in the study. Tissue hypoxia was defined as hyperlactataemia (lactate >2.2 mmol/L) coupled with low ScVO2 (ScVO2 <70%) during CPB. One hundred patients with normoxaemia and 100 patients with hyperoxaemia were included in the study. Patients with hyperoxaemia had lower tissue hypoxia incidence than patients with normoxaemia (p<0.001). Compared with patients without tissue hypoxia, patients with tissue hypoxia had significantly lower PaO2 values (p<0.001) and nadir haematocrit levels (p<0.001). Nadir haematocrit levels <18% (OR: 5.3; 95% CI: 2.67-10.6; p<0.001) and hyperoxaemia (OR: 0.28; 95% CI: 0.14-0.56; p<0.001) were independently associated with tissue hypoxia.

CONCLUSIONS

Hyperoxaemia during CPB may be protective against tissue hypoxia in patients with nadir haematocrit levels <20%.

Therapeutic options to minimize allogeneic blood transfusions and their adverse effects in cardiac surgery: a systematic review

INTRODUCTION

Allogeneic blood is an exhaustible therapeutic resource. New evidence indicates that blood consumption is excessive and that donations have decreased, resulting in reduced blood supplies worldwide. Blood transfusions are associated with increased morbidity and mortality, as well as higher hospital costs. This makes it necessary to seek out new treatment options. Such options exist but are still virtually unknown and are rarely utilized.

OBJECTIVE

To gather and describe in a systematic, objective, and practical way all clinical and surgical strategies as effective therapeutic options to minimize or avoid allogeneic blood transfusions and their adverse effects in surgical cardiac patients.

METHODS

A bibliographic search was conducted using the MeSH term "Blood Transfusion" and the terms "Cardiac Surgery" and "Blood Management." Studies with titles not directly related to this research or that did not contain information related to it in their abstracts as well as older studies reporting on the same strategies were not included.

RESULTS

Treating anemia and thrombocytopenia, suspending anticoagulants and antiplatelet agents, reducing routine phlebotomies, utilizing less traumatic surgical techniques with moderate hypothermia and hypotension, meticulous hemostasis, use of topical and systemic hemostatic agents, acute normovolemic hemodilution, cell salvage, anemia tolerance (supplementary oxygen and normothermia), as well as various other therapeutic options have proved to be effective strategies for reducing allogeneic blood transfusions.

CONCLUSION

There are a number of clinical and surgical strategies that can be used to optimize erythrocyte mass and coagulation status, minimize blood loss, and improve anemia tolerance. In order to decrease the consumption of blood components, diminish morbidity and mortality, and reduce hospital costs, these treatment strategies should be incorporated into medical practice worldwide.

Traumatic coagulopathy--part 2: Resuscitative strategies

OBJECTIVE

To discuss the current resuscitative strategies for trauma-induced hemorrhagic shock and acute traumatic coagulopathy (ATC).

ETIOLOGY

Hemorrhagic shock can be acutely fatal if not immediately and appropriately treated. The primary tenets of hemorrhagic shock resuscitation are to arrest hemorrhage and restore the effective circulating volume. Large volumes of isotonic crystalloids have been the resuscitative strategy of choice; however, data from experimental animal models and retrospective human analyses now recognize that large-volume fluid resuscitation in uncontrolled hemorrhage may be deleterious. The optimal resuscitative strategy has yet to be defined. In human trauma, implementing damage control resuscitation with damage control surgery for controlling ongoing hemorrhage, acidosis, and hypothermia; managing ATC; and restoring effective circulating volume is emerging as a more optimal resuscitative strategy. With hyperfibrinolysis playing an integral role in the manifestation of ATC, the use of antifibrinolytics (eg, tranexamic acid and aminocaproic acid) may also serve a beneficial role in the early posttraumatic period. Considering the sparse information regarding these resuscitative techniques in veterinary medicine, veterinarians are left with extrapolating information from human trials and experimental animal models.

DIAGNOSIS

Viscoelastic tests integrated with predictive scoring systems may prove to be the most reliable methods for early detection of ATC as well as for guiding transfusion requirements.

SUMMARY

Hemorrhage accounts for up to 40% of human trauma-related deaths and remains the leading cause of preventable death in human trauma. The exact proportion of trauma-related deaths due to exsanguinations in veterinary patients remains uncertain. Survivability depends upon achieving rapid definitive hemostasis, early attenuation of posttraumatic coagulopathy, and timely restoration of effective circulating volume. Early institution of damage control resuscitation in severely injured patients with uncontrolled hemorrhage has the ability to curtail posttraumatic coagulopathy and the exacerbation of metabolic acidosis and hypothermia and improve survival until definitive hemostasis is achieved.

The limit of anemia tolerance during hyperoxic ventilation with pure oxygen in anesthetized domestic pigs

BACKGROUND

During acellular replacement of an acute blood loss, hyperoxic ventilation (HV) increases the amount of O2 physically dissolved in the plasma and thereby improves O2 supply to the tissues. While this effect could be demonstrated for HV with inspiratory O2 fraction (FiO2) 0.6, it was unclear whether HV with pure oxygen (FiO2 1.0) would have an additional effect on the physiological limit of acute normovolemic anemia.

METHODS

Seven anesthetized domestic pigs were ventilated with FiO2 1.0 and subjected to an isovolemic hemodilution protocol. Blood was drawn and replaced by a 6% hydroxyethyl starch (HES) solution (130/0.4) until a sudden decrease of total body O2 consumption (VO2) indicated the onset of O2 supply dependency (primary endpoint). The corresponding hemoglobin (Hb) concentration was defined as 'critical Hb' (Hbcrit). Secondary endpoints were parameters of myocardial function, central hemodynamics, O2 transport and tissue oxygenation.

RESULTS

HV with FiO2 1.0 enabled a large blood-for-HES exchange (156 ± 28% of the circulating blood volume) until Hbcrit was met at 1.3 ± 0.3 g/dl. After termination of the hemodilution protocol, the contribution of O2 physically dissolved in the plasma to O2 delivery and VO2 had significantly increased from 11.7 ± 2 to 44.2 ± 9.7% and from 29.1 ± 4.2 to 66.2 ± 11.7%, respectively. However, at Hbcrit, cardiovascular performance was found to have severely deteriorated.

CONCLUSION

HV with FiO2 1.0 maintains O2 supply to tissues during extensive blood-for-HES exchange. In acute situations, where profound anemia must be tolerated (e.g. bridging an acute blood loss until red blood cells become available for transfusion), O2 physically dissolved in the plasma becomes an essential source of oxygen. However, compromised cardiovascular performance might require additional treatment.

Blood substitutes: evolution from noncarrying to oxygen- and gas-carrying fluids

The development of oxygen (O2)-carrying blood substitutes has evolved from the goal of replicating blood O2 transport properties to that of preserving microvascular and organ function, reducing the inherent or potential toxicity of the material used to carry O2, and treating pathologies initiated by anemia and hypoxia. Furthermore, the emphasis has shifted from blood replacement fluid to "O2 therapeutics" that restore tissue oxygenation to specific tissues regions. This review covers the different alternatives, potential and limitations of hemoglobin-based O2 carriers (HBOCs) and perfluorocarbon-based O2 carriers (PFCOCs), with emphasis on the physiologic conditions disturbed in the situation that they will be used. It describes how concepts learned from plasma expanders without O2-carrying capacity can be applied to maintain O2 delivery and summarizes the microvascular responses due to HBOCs and PFCOCs. This review also presents alternative applications of HBOCs and PFCOCs namely: 1) How HBOC O2 affinity can be engineered to target O2 delivery to hypoxic tissues; and 2) How the high gas solubility of PFCOCs provides new opportunities for carrying, dissolving, and delivering gases with biological activity. It is concluded that the development of current blood substitutes has amplified their applications horizon by devising therapeutic functions for O2 carriers requiring limited O2 delivery capacity restoration. Conversely, full, blood-like O2-carrying capacity reestablishment awaits the control of O2 carrier toxicity.

Examining and mitigating acellular hemoglobin vasoactivity

SIGNIFICANCE

There has been a striking advancement in our understanding of red cell substitutes over the past decade. Although regulatory oversight has influenced many aspects of product development in this period, those who have approached the demonstration of efficacy of red cell substitutes have failed to understand their implication at the level of the microcirculation, where blood interacts closely with tissue.

RECENT ADVANCES

The understanding of the adverse effects of acellular hemoglobin (Hb)-based oxygen carriers (HBOCs) has fortunately expanded from Hb-induced renal toxicity to a more complete list of biochemical mechanism. In addition, various unexpected adverse reactions were seen in early clinical studies. The effects of the presence of acellular Hb in plasma are relatively unique because of the convergence of mechanical and biochemical natures.

CRITICAL ISSUES

Controlling the variables using genetic engineering and chemical modification to change specific characteristics of the Hb molecule may allow for solving the complex multivariate problems of acellular Hb vasoactivity. HBOCs may never be rendered free of negative effects; however, quantifying the nature and extent of microvascular complications establishes a platform for designing new ameliorative therapies.

FUTURE DIRECTIONS

It is time to leave behind the study of vasoactivity and toxicity based on bench-top measurements of biochemical changes and those based solely on systemic parameters in vivo, and move to a more holistic analysis of the mechanisms creating the problems, complemented with meaningful studies of efficacy.

Effects of plasma viscosity modulation on cardiac function during moderate hemodilution

Background

Previous studies have found that increasing plasma viscosity as whole blood viscosity decrease has beneficial effects in microvascular hemodynamics. As the heart couples with systemic vascular network, changes in plasma and blood viscosity during hemodilution determine vascular pressure drop and flow rate, which influence cardiac function. This study aimed to investigate how changes in plasma viscosity affect on cardiac function during acute isovolemic hemodilution.

Materials and Methods

Plasma viscosity was modulated by hemodilution of 40% of blood volume with three different plasma expanders (PEs). Dextran 2000 kDa (Dx2M, 6.3 cP) and dextran 70 kDa (Dx70, 3.0 cP) were used as high and moderate viscogenic PEs, respectively. Polyethylene glycol conjugated with human serum albumin (PEG-HSA, 2.2 cP) was used as low viscogenic PE. The cardiac function was assessed using a miniaturized pressure-volume conductance catheter.

Results

After hemodilution, pressure dropped to 84%, 79%, and 78% of baseline for Dx2M, Dx70 and PEG-HSA, respectively. Cardiac output markedly increased for Dx2M and PEG-HSA. Dx2M significantly produced higher stroke work relative to baseline and compared to Dx70.

Conclusion

Acute hemodilution with PEG-HSA without increasing plasma viscosity provided beneficial effects on cardiac function compared to Dx70, and similar to those measured with Dx2M. Potentially negative effects of increasing peripheral vascular resistance due to the increase in plasma viscosity were prevented.

The effect of erythropoietin on microcirculation perfusion and tissue bioenergetics of the small intestine in a hemorrhagic shock and resuscitation rat model

BACKGROUND

Erythropoietin (EPO) can exert acute hemodynamic and anti-inflammatory effects in addition to erythropoiesis. We tested the hypothesis that EPO given at resuscitation with saline will improve capillary perfusion and tissue oxygenation in the gut using a hemorrhagic shock model.

METHODS

Sprague-Dawley rats were bled 30 mL/kg to maintain a mean arterial blood pressure of 40 mm Hg for 50 minutes and then randomized to one of four resuscitation groups (n = 6 per group): blood, blood + recombinant human EPO (rHuEPO), saline, and saline + rHuEPO. Intravenous rHuEPO (1,000 U/kg) was given at the start of resuscitation. Intravital microscopy was used to measure perfused capillary density, flow motion of red blood cell (RBC), and tissue NADH fluorescence 60 minutes after resuscitation. Venous oxygenation saturation (Svo2) was also measured in a second experiment.

RESULTS

In the blood +/- rHuEPO resuscitation group, the perfused capillary density, RBC flow motion scores, and NADH fluorescence returned to near normal values. The saline + rHuEPO group compared with the saline group demonstrated an increased RBC flow motion score (2.32 vs. 1.60; p < 0.01); however, the perfused capillary density was not significantly increased (23.03 Cap/mm vs. 21.61 Cap/mm; p = 0.40). The saline + rHuEPO group also demonstrated statistically significant lower NADH fluorescence than the saline group after shock following resuscitation (110% +/- 3.64% vs. 122% +/- 4.26%; p < 0.05) suggesting decreased tissue dysoxia. The Svo2 in the saline + rHuEPO group was higher when compared with the saline group (45% vs. 38% by continuous oximetry; 38% vs. 29% by co-oximetry; p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that the addition of rHuEPO at the time of saline resuscitation may have beneficial effects in hemorrhagic shock by improving tissue perfusion and decreasing dysoxia in the gut.

Perfusion vs. oxygen delivery in transfusion with "fresh" and "old" red blood cells: the experimental evidence

We review the experimental evidence showing systemic and microvascular effects of blood transfusions instituted to support the organism in extreme hemodilution and hemorrhagic shock, focusing on the use of fresh vs. stored blood as a variable. The question: "What does a blood transfusion remedy?" was analyzed in experimental models addressing systemic and microvascular effects showing that oxygen delivery is not the only function that must be addressed. In extreme hemodilution and hemorrhagic shock blood transfusions simultaneously restore blood viscosity and oxygen carrying capacity, the former being critically needed for re-establishing a functional mechanical environment of the microcirculation, necessary for obtaining adequate capillary blood perfusion. Increased oxygen affinity due to 2,3 DPG depletion is shown to have either no effect or a positive oxygenation effect, when the transfused red blood cells (RBCs) do not cause additional flow impairment due to structural malfunctions including increased rigidity and release of hemoglobin. It is concluded that fresh RBCs are shown to be superior to stored RBCs in transfusion, however increased oxygen affinity may be a positive factor in hemorrhagic shock resuscitation. Although experimental studies seldom reproduce emergency and clinical conditions, nonetheless they serve to explore fundamental physiological mechanisms in the microcirculation that cannot be directly studied in humans.

Effects of different resuscitation fluids on the rheologic behavior of red blood cells, blood viscosity and plasma viscosity in experimental hemorrhagic shock

BACKGROUND

Hemorrhagic shock is associated with severe rheological abnormalities. We hypothesized that in the setting of hemorrhagic shock, resuscitation can alter hemorheological characteristics dramatically, and different fluids cause different effects. The aim of this study was to investigate whether the type of fluid administered has an impact on hemorheological characteristics at the early stage of resuscitation in a rodent model of hemorrhagic shock.

METHODS

Animals were randomized into five groups: (1) sham hemorrhage (SHAM); (2) shock and sham resuscitation (SHOCK); (3) shock and resuscitation with normal saline 32 ml/kg (NS); (4) shock and resuscitation with 7.5% hypertonic saline 4 ml/kg (HS); (5) shock and resuscitation with 7.5% hypertonic saline/6% Dextran 70 4 ml/kg (HSD). Hemorheological characteristics were measured at 60 min after resuscitation.

RESULTS

Results showed that NS resuscitation deteriorated red blood cell (RBC) deformability compared with the SHOCK group. The HS group showed improved RBC deformability compared with the NS group, although the differences were not statistically significant. There were significant improvements of RBC deformability at all shear rates in the HSD group compared with the NS group. Whole blood and plasma viscosities decreased significantly in the SHOCK group compared with the SHAM group. At shear rates of 60 and 150 s(-1), the NS group decreased whole blood viscosity compared with the SHOCK group. The HSD group showed elevated plasma viscosity compared with the SHOCK, NS and HS groups.

CONCLUSION

These results suggested that at the early stage of hemorrhagic shock resuscitation, hypertonic-hyperoncotic resuscitation could improve RBC deformability compared with isotonic crystalloid resuscitation. Dextran 70 could elevate plasma viscosity to nearly baseline level. These effects of hypertonic-hyperoncotic resuscitation could be beneficial to maintain microcirculation.

Microvascular experimental evidence on the relative significance of restoring oxygen carrying capacity vs. blood viscosity in shock resuscitation

The development of volume replacement fluids for resuscitation in hemorrhagic shock comprises oxygen carrying and non carrying fluids. Non oxygen carrying fluids or plasma expanders are used up to the transfusion trigger, and upon reaching this landmark either blood, and possibly in the near future oxygen carrying blood substitutes, are used. An experimental program in hemorrhagic shock using the hamster chamber window model allowed to compare the relative performance of most fluids proposed for shock resuscitation. This model allows investigating simultaneously the microcirculation and systemic reactions, in the awake condition, in a tissue isolated from the environment. Results from this program show that in general plasma expanders such as Ringer's lactate and dextran 70 kDa do not sufficiently restore blood viscosity upon reaching the transfusion trigger, causing microvascular collapse. This is in part restored by a blood transfusion, independently of the oxygen carrying capacity of red blood cells. These results lead to the proposal that effective blood substitutes must be designed to prevent microvascular collapse, manifested in the decrease of functional capillary density. Achievement of this goal, in combination with the increase of oxygen affinity, significantly postpones the need for a blood transfusion, and lowers the total requirement of restoration of intrinsic oxygen carrying capacity.

Survival time in severe hemorrhagic shock after perioperative hemodilution is longer with PEG-conjugated human serum albumin than with HES 130/0.4: a microvascular perspective

Introduction

Preoperative hemodilution is an established practice that is applied to reduce surgical blood loss. It has been proposed that polyethylene glycol (PEG) surface decorated proteins such as PEG-conjugated human serum albumin may be used as non-oxygen-carrying plasma expanders. The purpose of this study was to determine whether there is any difference in survival time after severe hemorrhagic shock following extreme hemodilution using a conventional hydroxyethyl starch (HES)-based plasma expander or PEG-albumin.

Methods

Experiments were performed using the hamster skinfold window preparation. Human serum albumin that was surface decorated with PEG was compared with Voluven 6% (Fresenius Kabi, Austria; a starch solution that is of low molecular weight and has a low degree of substitution; HES). These plasma expanders were used for a 50% (blood volume) exchange transfusion to simulate preoperative hemodilution. Exchange transfusion was followed by a 60% (blood volume) hemorrhage to reproduce a severe surgical bleed over a 1 hour period. Observation of the animal was continued for another hour during the shock phase.

Results

The PEG-albumin group exhibited significantly greater survival rate than did the HES group, in which none of the animals survived the hemorrhage phase of the experiment. Among the treatment groups there were no changes in mean arterial pressure and heart rate from baseline after hemodilution. Both groups experienced gradual increases in arterial oxygen tension and disturbance in acid-base balance, but this response was more pronounced in the HES group during the shock period. Mean arterial pressure remained elevated after the initial hemorrhage period in the PEG-albumin group but not in the HES group. Maintenance of a greater mean arterial pressure during the initial stages of hemorrhage is proposed to be in part due to the improved volume expansion with PEG-albumin, as indicated by the significant decrease in systemic hematocrit compared with the HES group. PEG-albumin treatment yielded higher functional capillary density during the initial stages of hemorrhage as compared with HES treatment.

Conclusion

The ability of PEG-albumin to prolong maintenance of microvascular function better than HES is a finding that would be significant in a clinical setting involving preoperative blood management and extreme blood loss.

RESUSCITATION FROM HEMORRHAGIC SHOCK WITH HYDROXYETHYL STARCH AND COAGULATION CHANGES

Administration of fluids to maintain or restore intravascular volume is a common intervention after hemorrhagic shock, but there is uncertainty whether the choice of fluid significantly influences outcome. Systemic parameters, microvascular perfusion, and functional capillary density were used to characterize resuscitation from hemorrhagic shock with hydroxyethyl starch (HES) of different molecular weights. Studies were made in the hamster window chamber model to determine their effects on blood rheological properties, restoration of perfusion and coagulation changes. Moderate hemorrhagic shock was induced by controlled arterial bleeding of 50% of blood volume, and hypovolemia was maintained for 1 h before resuscitation. Twenty-five percent of blood volume was restituted, and recovery was followed over 60 min. Low-molecular weight (MW) HES (L-HES) 130 kd, degree of substitution (DS) 0.40, and high-MW HES (H-HES) 670 kd, DS 0.75, were used as resuscitation fluids. Microthrombi formation was induced by endothelial laser irradiation. H-HES improved systemic conditions, microcirculatory flow, and metabolic recovery after resuscitation when compared with L-HES. Mean arterial pressure was significantly improved after resuscitation with H-HES compared with L-HES, but lower than baseline and the sham group. Thrombus formation was impaired in both groups after resuscitation compared with sham. There was no difference in microthrombi formation between low- and H-HES for medium and large laser endothelial injuries. Our results indicate that fluid resuscitation with HES may increase the risk of bleeding, but not necessarily caused by the properties (MW and DS) of the colloid. Impairment of thrombus formation seems to be in part related to altered hemodynamics and transport inherent to hemodilution, leading to lowered platelet availability due to hemodilution and increased shear stress at the vessel wall when plasma viscosity is increased. The HES MW does not seem to be a factor in compromising platelet adherence on stimulated endothelium. The longer initial intravascular persistence of H-HES might result in longer-lasting volume effects.

Tissue oxygen monitoring in rodent models of shock

Tissue Po2 (tPo2) reflects the balance between local O2 supply and demand and, thus, could be a useful monitoring modality. However, the consistency and amplitude of the tPo2 response in different organs during different cardiorespiratory insults is unknown. Therefore, we investigated the effects of endotoxemia, hemorrhage, and hypoxemia on tPo2 measured in deep and peripheral organ beds. We compared arterial pressure, blood gas and lactate levels, descending aortic and renal blood flow, and tPo2 in skeletal muscle, bladder epithelium, liver, and renal cortex during 1) LPS infusion (10 mg/kg), 2) sequential removal of 10% of circulating blood volume, and 3) reductions in inspired O2 concentration in an anesthetized Wistar rat model with values measured in sham-operated animals. Different patterns were seen in each of the shock states, with condition-specific variations in the degree of acidemia, lactatemia, and tissue O2 responses between organs. Endotoxemia resulted in a rise in bladder tPo2 and an early fall in liver tPo2 but no significant change in muscle and renal cortical tPo2. Progressive hemorrhage, however, produced proportional declines in liver, muscle, and bladder tPo2, but renal cortical tPo2 was maintained until profound blood loss had occurred. By contrast, progressive hypoxemia resulted in proportional decreases in tPo2 in all organ beds. This study highlights the heterogeneity of responses in different organ beds during different shock states that are likely related to local changes in O2 supply and utilization. Whole body monitoring is not generally reflective of these changes.

Pleural liquid during hemorrhagic hypotension

The effect of approximately 25% or 35% blood loss (b.l.) on volume, pressure, and protein concentration of pleural liquid has been determined in anesthetized rabbits in lateral or supine posture. Volume and pressure of pleural liquid did not change with 25% b.l. 30 and 60 min after beginning of hemorrhage, and with 35% b.l. at 30 min (bleeding time approximately 10 and 12 min, respectively). With 35% b.l. protein concentration of pleural liquid was 85% greater (P<0.01) than control; moreover, percent albumin was smaller (P<0.05), and percent globulin greater (P<0.05) than control. Decrease in arterial plasma protein concentration, hematocrit, and pH after hemorrhage fit literature data. Ventilation at 15 and 30 min increased (P<0.01) by 16% and 23%, respectively, with 25% b.l., but it did not change with 35% b.l., a condition borderline to survival in anesthetized rabbits without ad hoc treatment. Pleural liquid seems protected against derangements from hemorrhage up to 25% b.l. for periods shorter than 1 h.

Hemorrhagic shock resuscitation with carbon monoxide saturated blood

The response to exchange transfusion with red blood cells (RBCs) saturated with carbon monoxide (CO) in amelioration of microvascular function and providing tissue protection in hemorrhagic shock resuscitation was investigated in the hamster chamber window model. Shock was induced by the withdrawal of 50% of blood volume (BV). Blood volume was restored 1 h after hemorrhage with a single volume infusion (resuscitation) of 25% BV with fresh RBCs (saturated or unsaturated with CO) suspended in human serum albumin (HSA). Hemorrhage, shock and resuscitation were monitored continuously in terms of mean arterial pressure (MAP), microvascular blood flow, capillary perfusion and systemic gas parameters. Eight hours after resuscitation, Annexin V and propidium iodide (PI) were injected into the window chamber to study tissue viability, and labeled cells were observed by using intravital epifluorescence microscopy. TUNEL staining was performed on the tissue to confirm in vivo results. Systemic and microvascular restoration were not different with or without CO up to 90 min after resuscitation. CO concentration decreased over 90 min, increasing oxygen carrying capacity and gradually reoxygenating the tissue. CO saturated blood partially mitigated cell injury at 8 h after resuscitation. The precise cellular mechanisms involved require further elucidation. CO is a novel experimental strategy to improve tissue viability and requires the appropriated preclinical studies to confirm its efficacy.

Early resuscitation with polymerized bovine hemoglobin reverses acidosis, but not peripheral tissue oxygenation, in a severe hamster shock model

Awake hamsters equipped with the dorsal window chamber preparation were subjected to hemorrhage of 50% of the estimated blood volume. Initial resuscitation (25% of estimated blood volume) with polymerized bovine hemoglobin (PBH) or 10% hydroxyethyl starch (HES) occurred in concert with an equivolumetric bleeding to simulate the early, prehospital setting (exchange transfusion). Resuscitation (25% of estimated blood volume) without bleeding was performed with PBH, HES, or autologous red blood cells (HES-RBCs). Peripheral microcirculation, tissue oxygenation, and systemic hemodynamic and blood gas parameters were assessed. After exchange transfusion, base deficit was -8.6 +/- 3.7 mmol/L (PBH) and -5.1 +/- 5.3 mmol/L (HES) (not significant). Functional capillary density was 17% +/- 6% of baseline (PBH) and 31% +/- 11% (HES) (P < 0.05) and arteriolar diameter 73% +/- 3% of baseline (PBH) and 90% + 5% (HES) (P < 0.01). At the end, hemoglobin levels were 3.7 +/- 0.3 g/dL with HES, 8.2 +/- 0.6 g/dL with PBH, and 10.4 +/- 0.8 g/dL with HES-RBCs (P < 0.01 HES vs. PBH and HES-RBCs, P < 0.05 PBH vs. HES-RBCs). Base excess was restored to baseline with PBH and HES-RBCs, but not with HES (P < 0.05). Functional capillary density was 46% +/- 5% of baseline (PBH), 62% + 20% (HES-RBCs), and 36% +/- 19% (HES) (P < 0.01 HES-RBCs vs. HES). Peripheral oxygen delivery and consumption was highest with HES-RBCs, followed by PBH (P < 0.05 HES-RBCs vs. PBH, P < 0.01 HES-RBCs and PBH vs. HES). In conclusion, the PBH led to a correction of base deficit comparable to blood transfusion. However, oxygenation of the peripheral tissue was inferior with PBH. This was attributed to its negative impact on the peripheral microcirculation caused by arteriolar vasoconstriction.

MICROVASCULAR PERSPECTIVE OF OXYGEN-CARRYING AND -NONCARRYING BLOOD SUBSTITUTES

The development of an alternative to natural blood has evolved from the initial goal of replicating blood properties to the current objective of formulating a fluid that can be used to replace blood while preserving microvascular function and delivering oxygen. The properties of this fluid are counterintuitive and different from blood because it has high viscosity, oxygen affinity, and a low oxygen carrier concentration when compared with blood. The optimal oxygen carrier devised presently is poly-ethylene-conjugated human hemoglobin, a material demonstrated to be vasoinactive and void of the toxicities present in previous hemoglobin formulations. A feature of this material is that it is effective in small quantities, and therefore amplifies the equivalent supply of blood derived from blood donations.

Rapid restoration of microcirculatory blood flow with hyperviscous and hyperoncotic solutions lowers the transfusion trigger in resuscitation from hemorrhagic shock

Resuscitation from hemorrhagic shock relies on fluid retransfusion. However, the optimal properties of the fluid have not been established. The aim of the present study was to test the influence of the concentration of hydroxyethyl starch (HES) solution on plasma viscosity and colloid osmotic pressure (COP), systemic and microcirculatory recovery, and oxygen delivery and consumption after resuscitation, which were assessed in the hamster chamber window preparation by intravital microscopy. Awake hamsters were subjected to 50% hemorrhage and were resuscitated with 25% of the estimated blood volume with 5%, 10%, or 20% HES solution. The increase in concentration led to an increase in COP (from 20 to 70 and 194 mmHg) and viscosity (from 1.7 to 3.8 and 14.4 cP). Cardiac index and microcirculatory and metabolic recovery were improved with HES 10% and 20% when compared with 5% HES. Oxygen delivery and consumption in the dorsal skinfold chamber was more than doubled with HES 10% and 20% when compared with HES 5%. This was attributed to the beneficial effect of restored or increased plasma COP and plasma viscosity as obtained with HES 10% and 20%, leading to improved microcirculatory blood flow values early in the resuscitation period. The increase in COP led to an increase in blood volume as shown by a reduction in hematocrit. Mean arterial pressure was significantly improved in animals receiving 10% and 20% solutions. In conclusion, the present results show that the increase in the concentration of HES, leading to hyperoncotic and hyperviscous solutions, is beneficial for resuscitation from hemorrhagic shock because normalization of COP and viscosity led to a rapid recovery of microcirculatory parameters.

Hyperoxic ventilation increases the tolerance of acute normovolemic anemia in anesthetized pigs

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the impact of prophylactic hyperoxic ventilation with Fio2 0.6 on the physiologic limit of acute normovolemic anemia.

DESIGN

Prospective, controlled, randomized experimental study.

SETTING

Experimental animal laboratory of a university hospital.

SUBJECTS

Fourteen anesthetized domestic pigs.

INTERVENTIONS

Animals were randomly ventilated with either Fio2 0.21 (group 0.21, n = 7) or Fio2 0.6 (group 0.6, n = 7), and acute anemia was induced by isovolemic blood-for-hydroxy-ethylstarch (HES) exchange using a 6% HES solution (130/0.4).

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The blood-for-HES-exchange was continued until a sudden decrease of total body oxygen consumption indicated the onset of oxygen supply dependency (primary end point); the corresponding hemoglobin (Hb) concentration was defined as "critical" (Hb(crit)). Secondary end points were changes in myocardial function, central hemodynamics, oxygen transport, and tissue oxygenation. Compared with room air ventilation (Fio2 0.21), hyperoxic ventilation with Fio2 0.6 enabled a larger blood-for-HES-exchange (139%, 124/156) of circulating blood volume vs. 87% (68/94, p < .05), until Hb(crit) was reached (1.5 g/dL [1.4/2.1] vs. 2.4 g/dL [2.0/2.8], p < .05). At Hb 2.4 g/dL (i.e., Hb(crit) in group 0.21), animals of group 0.6 still presented with superior oxygen transport, tissue oxygenation, and hemodynamic stability. However, hemodynamic and oxygen transport variables were found deteriorated more severely at Hb 1.5 g/dL (i.e., Hb(crit) of group 0.6) compared with group 0.21 at Hb 2.4 g/dL.

CONCLUSION

During cell-free volume replacement, hyperoxic ventilation with Fio2 0.6 generates a readily usable plasmatic oxygen reserve and thereby increases the tolerance toward acute normovolemic anemia.

A new hypothesis for microvascular inflammation in shock and multiorgan failure: self-digestion by pancreatic enzymes

Shock is accompanied by a severe inflammatory cascade in the microcirculation, the origin of which has been hypothesized in the past to be associated with specific mediators such as endotoxin, oxygen free radicals, nitric oxide, cytokines, and lipid products. But no intervention with clinical effectiveness has been derived from these ideas to date. The authors propose here a new hypothesis suggesting that degradative enzymes, synthesized in the pancreas as part of normal digestion, may play a central role in shock and multiorgan failure. These powerful enzymes have the ability to digest almost every biological material. Self-digestion (i.e. autodegradation) is prevented by compartmentalizing the fully activated degradative enzymes in the intestinal lumen by the mucosal barrier. In shock, maintenance of the mucosal barrier is impaired and it becomes permeable to pancreatic enzymes. Digestive enzymes thereby gain access to the wall of the intestine and initiate self-digestion of submucosal extracellular matrix proteins and interstitial cells. The process leads to generation and release of a host of strong inflammatory mediators. The authors hypothesize that inhibition of pancreatic enzymes in the lumen of tile intestine can serve to attenuate formation of these inflammatory mediators in ischemic tissues following hemorrhagic shock, and consequently prevent cell and tissue injury as well as multiorgan failure.

EARLY DIFFERENCE IN TISSUE PH AND MICROVASCULAR HEMODYNAMICS IN HEMORRHAGIC SHOCK RESUSCITATION USING POLYETHYLENE GLYCOL-ALBUMIN- AND HYDROXYETHYL STARCH-BASED PLASMA EXPANDERS

The hamster chamber window model was subjected to hemorrhagic shock by the withdrawal of 50% of blood volume (BV). BV was restored 1 h after hemorrhage with a single volume infusion (resuscitation) of 25% BV with polyethylene glycol (PEG)-conjugated bovine serum albumin (Alb) and hydroxyethyl starch (HES). Hemorrhage, shock, and resuscitation were monitored continuously in terms of mean arterial pressure (MAP), microvascular blood flow, capillary perfusion, and tissue pH. Blood samples for laboratory parameters were taken at baseline, shock, and resuscitation. Intravascular and tissue pO2 were assessed after resuscitation, and microvascular oxygen supply and extraction were calculated and corrected for pH effect on hemoglobin saturation. Resuscitation with PEG-Alb restored systemic and microvascular parameters up to the end of the observation period (90 min). HES was identical to PEG-Alb resuscitation during the initial 10 to 15 min, but was not sustained subsequently. The trend of recovery in MAP for HES persisted beyond the time when both function capillary density and tissue pH decreased, thus MAP was not indicative of early microvascular dysfunction. Hemoglobin oxygen saturation estimation showed a significant pH dependence. However, oxygen-dependant parameters corrected for pH varied less than 10% from uncorrected data. Early differences found at the microvascular levels suggest that decisions to amend end-result of resuscitation may be short and on the order of minutes. Furthermore, PEG-Alb appears to provide early and long-term sustained systemic and microvascular recovery when used to restitute perfusion and metabolic conditions after resuscitation from hemorrhagic shock.

Hyperosmotic-hyperoncotic versus hyperosmotic-hyperviscous: small volume resuscitation in hemorrhagic shock

The aim of this study was to test the effects of using a high-viscosity fluid after small-volume hyperosmotic resuscitation from hemorrhagic shock and to compare this to hyperosmotic followed by hyperoncotic resuscitation. Studies were made in the awake hamster window chamber preparation with the animals subjected to hemorrhage of 50% of blood volume and resuscitated with a small volume of a 7.5% NaCl solution, which was followed within minutes by infusion of 25% of withdrawn volume of either 0.7% or 0.8% alginate solutions (A0.7%, 7.6 cp; and A0.8%, 10.2 cp) or 5% hydroxyethyl starch (HES 5%, 2.1 cp). All modalities of resuscitation returned blood pressure to near baseline values in 5 min, which remained elevated after 90 min with A0.7% and A0.8% but returned to near shock values in 15 min with HES 5%. Microvascular flow and functional capillary density (FCD) followed the same pattern, being significantly higher for the alginate solutions than HES 5% after 90 min. Plasma viscosity 90 min after resuscitation was 2.1 and 2.6 cp for A0.7% and A0.8%, respectively, and 1.1 cP for HES 5%. There was an apparent directly proportional relationship between the concentration of alginate and blood pressure recovery, with blood pressure near normal with A0.8%, and approximately 20 mmHg lower with A0.7%. The recovery of microvascular flow and FCD, although showing a trend toward being more effective with A0.8%, was not significantly different from A0.7% but statistically different and improved relative to HES 5%. The high-viscosity fluids provide a novel small-volume method of resuscitation that maximizes microvascular perfusion for extended periods until surgical control of bleeding is possible. Results show that high-plasma-viscosity resuscitation provides a more consistent and prolonged resuscitation than hyperoncotic treatment. The increase in viscosity presents a gradual recovery in blood pressure and may be used as an alternative for small-volume hypotensive resuscitation, increasing tissue perfusion while potentially limiting hemorrhage in vascular injuries of the major blood vessels.

RESUSCITATION FROM HEMORRHAGIC SHOCK WITH MalPEG-ALBUMIN: COMPARISON WITH MalPEG-HEMOGLOBIN

Our aim was to determine the efficacy of polyethylene glycol-conjugated human albumin (MalPEG-Alb) in restoring circulatory volume after 1 h of hemorrhagic shock. Experiments were performed in the awake condition in the hamster skin fold preparation. Microhemodynamic parameters and tissue Po2 were assessed with intravital microscopy and the use of the phosphorescence quenching technique. One hour after shock induction by withdrawal of 50% of the blood volume, animals were resuscitated with MalPEG-Alb (n = 6). Systemic and microhemodynamic parameters following resuscitation were identical to those obtained with the same protocol using MalPEG-Hb (1). However, parameters related to microvascular oxygen distribution were significantly lower in the MalPEG-Alb group compared with the previous data from the MalPEG-Hb group in that tissue oxygen partial pressure was 5 +/- 2 mmHg (vs. 8 +/- 3 mmHg, P < 0.05), oxygen delivery was reduced to 60 +/- 27% (P < 0.05), and oxygen consumption was reduced to 69 +/- 28% (P < 0.05). Both molecules were matched in composition (4.2 g/dL) and surface chemistry. MalPEG-Alb colloid osmotic pressure was 37 mmHg (vs. 49 mmHg for MalPEG-Hb), and viscosity was 2.7 cP (vs. 2.5 cP for MalPEG-Hb). The present results show that both solutions are efficacious plasma expanders and that the hemoglobin-based solution provides improved oxygen distribution and tissue Po2 in the hamster chamber model.

HYPEROXIC VENTILATION REDUCES SIX-HOUR MORTALITY AFTER PARTIAL FLUID RESUSCITATION FROM HEMORRHAGIC SHOCK

Ventilation with 100% oxygen (Fio(2) 1.0; hyperoxic ventilation; HV) as an alternative to red blood cell transfusion enables survival in otherwise lethal normovolemic anemia. The aim of the present study was to investigate whether HV as a supplement to fluid infusion therapy could also restore adequate tissue oxygenation and prevent death in otherwise lethal hemorrhagic shock. In 14 anesthetized pigs ventilated on room air (Fio(2) 0.21), hemorrhagic shock was induced by controlled withdrawal of blood (target mean arterial pressure 35-40 mmHg) and maintained for 1 h. Subsequently, the animals were partially fluid-resuscitated (i.e., replacement of lost plasma volume) either with hydroxyethyl starch (6% HES, 200/0.5) alone (G 0.21) or with HES supplemented by HV (G 1.0). After completion of partial fluid resuscitation, all animals were followed up for the next 6 h. Five of seven animals of G 0.21 died within the 6-h observation period (i.e., 6-h mortality 71%). Death was preceded by a continuous increase of the serum concentrations of arterial lactate and persistent tissue hypoxia. In contrast to that, all animals of G 1.0 survived the 6-h observation period without lactic acidosis and with improved tissue oxygenation (i.e., 6-h mortality 0%; G 0.21 versus G 1.0 P < 0.05). In anesthetized pigs submitted to lethal hemorrhagic shock, the supplementation of partial fluid resuscitation with HV improved tissue oxygenation and enabled survival for 6 h.