Deletion of nonconserved helices near the 3' end of the rRNA intron of Tetrahymena thermophila alters self-splicing but not core catalytic activity

Prebiotic chiral transfer from self-aminoacylating ribozymes may favor either handedness

Modern life is essentially homochiral, containing D-sugars in nucleic acid backbones and L-amino acids in proteins. Since coded proteins are theorized to have developed from a prebiotic RNA World, the homochirality of L-amino acids observed in all known life presumably resulted from chiral transfer from a homochiral D-RNA World. This transfer would have been mediated by aminoacyl-RNAs defining the genetic code. Previous work on aminoacyl transfer using tRNA mimics has suggested that aminoacylation using D-RNA may be inherently biased toward reactivity with L-amino acids, implying a deterministic path from a D-RNA World to L-proteins. Using a model system of self-aminoacylating D-ribozymes and epimerizable activated amino acid analogs, we test the chiral selectivity of 15 ribozymes derived from an exhaustive search of sequence space. All of the ribozymes exhibit detectable selectivity, and a substantial fraction react preferentially to produce the D-enantiomer of the product. Furthermore, chiral preference is conserved within sequence families. These results are consistent with the transfer of chiral information from RNA to proteins but do not support an intrinsic bias of D-RNA for L-amino acids. Different aminoacylation structures result in different directions of chiral selectivity, such that L-proteins need not emerge from a D-RNA World.

Sub-3-Å cryo-EM structure of RNA enabled by engineered homomeric self-assembly

High-resolution structural studies are essential for understanding the folding and function of diverse RNAs. Herein, we present a nanoarchitectural engineering strategy for efficient structural determination of RNA-only structures using single-particle cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM). This strategy-ROCK (RNA oligomerization-enabled cryo-EM via installing kissing loops)-involves installing kissing-loop sequences onto the functionally nonessential stems of RNAs for homomeric self-assembly into closed rings with multiplied molecular weights and mitigated structural flexibility. ROCK enables cryo-EM reconstruction of the Tetrahymena group I intron at 2.98-Å resolution overall (2.85 Å for the core), allowing de novo model building of the complete RNA, including the previously unknown peripheral domains. ROCK is further applied to two smaller RNAs-the Azoarcus group I intron and the FMN riboswitch, revealing the conformational change of the former and the bound ligand in the latter. ROCK holds promise to greatly facilitate the use of cryo-EM in RNA structural studies.

Conditional and target-specific transgene induction through RNA replacement using an allosteric trans-splicing ribozyme

Gene therapeutic approaches are needed that can simultaneously induce the well-controlled expression of therapeutic genes and suppress the expression of disease-causing genes for maximization of their efficacy. To address this challenge, we designed an allosteric ribozyme that comprises a Tetrahymena group I-based trans-splicing ribozyme as an active domain for RNA replacement, a small molecule-specific RNA aptamer as a sensor domain, and a communication module as an active transfer domain. The effectiveness of this approach was assessed by constructing various ribozymes in combination with a theophylline-binding aptamer to identify an allosteric ribozyme, which is controlled by theophylline both in vitro and in cells. Moreover, we constructed adenoviral vectors encoding the ribozymes and validated allosteric regulation of trans-gene expression via theophylline-dependent RNA replacement in target RNA-expressing cells. Results demonstrate that an allosteric trans-splicing ribozyme is an applicable RNA-based framework for engineering external ligand-controlled gene expression regulatory systems that exhibit adjustable regulation, design modularity, and target specificity.

RNA synthesis and purification for structural studies

RNAs play pivotal roles in the cell, ranging from catalysis (e.g., RNase P), acting as adaptor molecule (tRNA) to regulation (e.g., riboswitches). Precise understanding of its three-dimensional structures has given unprecedented insight into the molecular basis for all of these processes. Nevertheless, structural studies on RNA are still limited by the very special nature of this polymer. The most common methods for the determination of 3D RNA structures are NMR and X-ray crystallography. Both methods have their own set of requirements and give different amounts of information about the target RNA. For structural studies, the major bottleneck is usually obtaining large amounts of highly pure and homogeneously folded RNA. Especially for X-ray crystallography it can be necessary to screen a large number of variants to obtain well-ordered single crystals. In this mini-review we give an overview about strategies for the design, in vitro production, and purification of RNA for structural studies.

Structure-function analysis from the outside in: long-range tertiary contacts in RNA exhibit distinct catalytic roles

The conserved catalytic core of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme is encircled by peripheral elements. We have conducted a detailed structure-function study of the five long-range tertiary contacts that fasten these distal elements together. Mutational ablation of each of the tertiary contacts destabilizes the folded ribozyme, indicating a role of the peripheral elements in overall stability. Once folded, three of the five tertiary contact mutants exhibit defects in overall catalysis that range from 20- to 100-fold. These and the subsequent results indicate that the structural ring of peripheral elements does not act as a unitary element; rather, individual connections have distinct roles as further revealed by kinetic and thermodynamic dissection of the individual reaction steps. Ablation of P14 or the metal ion core/metal ion core receptor (MC/MCR) destabilizes docking of the substrate-containing P1 helix into tertiary interactions with the ribozyme's conserved core. In contrast, ablation of the L9/P5 contact weakens binding of the guanosine nucleophile by slowing its association, without affecting P1 docking. The P13 and tetraloop/tetraloop receptor (TL/TLR) mutations had little functional effect and small, local structural changes, as revealed by hydroxyl radical footprinting, whereas the P14, MC/MCR, and L9/P5 mutants show structural changes distal from the mutation site. These changes extended into regions of the catalytic core involved in docking or guanosine binding. Thus, distinct allosteric pathways couple the long-range tertiary contacts to functional sites within the conserved core. This modular functional specialization may represent a fundamental strategy in RNA structure-function interrelationships.

The P5abc peripheral element facilitates preorganization of the tetrahymena group I ribozyme for catalysis

Phylogenetic comparisons and site-directed mutagenesis indicate that group I introns are composed of a catalytic core that is universally conserved and peripheral elements that are conserved only within intron subclasses. Despite this low overall conservation, peripheral elements are essential for efficient splicing of their parent introns. We have undertaken an in-depth structure-function analysis to investigate the role of one of these elements, P5abc, using the well-characterized ribozyme derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron. Structural comparisons using solution-based free radical cleavage revealed that a ribozyme lacking P5abc (E(DeltaP5abc)) and E(DeltaP5abc) with P5abc added in trans (E(DeltaP5abc).P5abc) adopt a similar global tertiary structure at Mg(2+) concentrations greater than 20 mM [Doherty, E. A., et al. (1999) Biochemistry 38, 2982-90]. However, free E(DeltaP5abc) is greatly compromised in overall oligonucleotide cleavage activity, even at Mg(2+) concentrations as high as 100 mM. Further characterization of E(DeltaP5abc) via DMS modification revealed local structural differences at several positions in the conserved core that cluster around the substrate binding sites. Kinetic and thermodynamic dissection of individual reaction steps identified defects in binding of both substrates to E(DeltaP5abc), with > or =25-fold weaker binding of a guanosine nucleophile and > or =350-fold weaker docking of the oligonucleotide substrate into its tertiary interactions with the ribozyme core. These defects in binding of the substrates account for essentially all of the 10(4)-fold decrease in overall activity of the deletion mutant. Together, the structural and functional observations suggest that the P5abc peripheral element not only provides stability but also positions active site residues through indirect interactions, thereby preferentially stabilizing the active ribozyme structure relative to alternative less active states. This is consistent with the view that peripheral elements engage in a network of mutually reinforcing interactions that together ensure cooperative folding of the ribozyme to its active structure.

Crystals by design: a strategy for crystallization of a ribozyme derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron

Recently, the 2.8 A crystal structure of one domain of the self-splicing Tetrahymena group I intron was reported. Although it revealed much about RNA tertiary interactions, it contained only half of the active site. We have now designed a series of larger molecules that contain about 70% of the intron and all of the catalytic core. These RNAs were efficient in cleavage of a substrate RNA, consisting of the approximately 100 nucleotides from the 5' end of the intron, at a site corresponding to the 5' splice site. A sparse matrix was designed specifically for large RNAs and used to screen for preliminary crystallization conditions. Of the six RNAs initially tested, five were crystallized in this initial trial. Two of these crystals were further examined. The first diffracted X-rays to only approximately 16 A resolution, even when the crystal were very large. The second diffracted as high as 3.5 A, but the crystals were twinned and therefore unusable for structural studies. Site-specific mutagenesis was performed on the latter RNA to disrupt interactions that might have been responsible for the twinning. One of these mutant RNAs produced large, single, diffraction-quality crystals. The crystals belong to the tetragonal space group P42212 and have large unit cell dimensions, a=b=178 A and c=199 A. Thus, by variation of both sequence elements and crystallization conditions, crystals of a 247 nucleotide catalytic RNA were obtained.

Long-range interaction between the P2.1 and P9.1 peripheral domains of the Tetrahymena ribozyme

The Tetrahymena ribozyme possesses peripheral domains, termed P9.1 and P9.2. They are nonessential in the mechanism of the catalytic reaction but contribute to enhance the catalytic activity of the ribozyme. It has been postulated that P9.1 is capable of forming Watson-Crick base pairings with another peripheral domain, P2.1. We report here the existence of long-range base pairings between the loop regions of these two domains and show that this interaction apparently plays a role in enhancing the catalytic activity of the ribozyme.

Replacement of RNA hairpins by in vitro selected tetranucleotides

An in vitro selection method based on the autolytic cleavage of yeast tRNA(Phe) by Pb2+ was applied to obtain tRNA derivatives with the anticodon hairpin replaced by four single-stranded nucleotides. Based on the rates of the site-specific cleavage by Pb2+ and the presence of a specific UV-induced crosslink, certain tetranucleotide sequences allow proper folding of the rest of the tRNA molecule, whereas others do not. One such successful tetramer sequence was also used to replace the acceptor stem of yeast tRNA(Phe) and the anticodon hairpin of E.coli tRNA(Phe) without disrupting folding. These experiments suggest that certain tetramers may be able to replace structurally nonessential hairpins in any RNA.

Directed evolution of an RNA enzyme

An in vitro evolution procedure was used to obtain RNA enzymes with a particular catalytic function. A population of 10(13) variants of the Tetrahymena ribozyme, a group I ribozyme that catalyzes sequence-specific cleavage of RNA via a phosphoester transfer mechanism, was generated. This enzyme has a limited ability to cleave DNA under conditions of high temperature or high MgCl2 concentration, or both. A selection constraint was imposed on the population of ribozyme variants such that only those individuals that carried out DNA cleavage under physiologic conditions were amplified to produce "progeny" ribozymes. Mutations were introduced during amplification to maintain heterogeneity in the population. This process was repeated for ten successive generations, resulting in enhanced (100 times) DNA cleavage activity.

Three-dimensional folding of Tetrahymena thermophila rRNA IVS sequence: a proposal

We studied the Tetrahymena thermophila rRNA IVS sequence with the aim of obtaining a model of the structure characterized by the bases proximity of the self-reactions sites. The considered sequence kept up those fragments essential for its catalytic activity as demonstrated by deletion mutants. The first step was the theoretical analysis with a computer method previously proposed, to find optimal free energy secondary structures with the required features, under the suitable constrains. Then we tried folding the obtained secondary structures, in low resolution tertiary models, which kept up the proximity of the catalytic sites also in the space. The proposed tertiary folding seems to provide for a better explanation to the transesterification mechanisms and moreover it is in good agreement with the experimental data (activity of mutants, enzymatic cleavages, phylogenetically conserved regions).

Minimum secondary structure requirements for catalytic activity of a self-splicing group I intron

We have completed a comprehensive deletion analysis of the Tetrahymena ribozyme in order to define the minimum secondary structure requirements for phosphoester transfer activity of a self-splicing group I intron. A total of 299 nucleotides were removed in a piecewise fashion, leaving a catalytic core of 114 nucleotides that form 7 base-paired structural elements. Among the various deletion mutants are a 300-nucleotide single-deletion mutant and a 281-nucleotide double-deletion mutant whose activity exceeds that of the wild type when tested under physiologic conditions. Consideration of those structural elements that are essential for catalytic activity leads to a simplified secondary structure model of the catalytic core of a group I intron.

An ultraviolet-inducible adenosine-adenosine cross-link reflects the catalytic structure of the Tetrahymena ribozyme

When a shortened enzymatic version of the Tetrahymena self-splicing intervening sequence (IVS) RNA is placed under catalytic conditions and irradiated at 254 nm, a covalent cross-link forms with high efficiency. The position of the cross-link was mapped by using three independent methods: RNase H digestion, primer extension with reverse transcriptase, and partial hydrolysis of end-labeled RNA. The cross-link is chemically unusual in that it joins two adenosines, A57 and A95. Formation of this cross-link depends upon the identity and concentration of divalent cations present and upon heat-cool renaturation of the IVS in a manner that parallels conditions required for optimal catalytic activity. Furthermore, cross-linking requires the presence of sequences within the core structure, which is conserved among group I intervening sequences and necessary for catalytic activity. Together these correlations suggest that a common folded structure permits cross-linking and catalytic activity. The core can form this structure independent of the presence of P1 and elements at the 3' end of the IVS. The cross-linked RNA loses catalytic activity under destabilizing conditions, presumably due to disruption of the folded structure by the cross-link. One of the nucleotides participating in this cross-link is highly conserved (86%) within the secondary structure of group I intervening sequences. We conclude that A57 and A95 are precisely aligned in a catalytically active conformation of the RNA. A model is presented for the tertiary arrangement in the vicinity of the cross-link.

Mechanism of 3' splice site selection by the catalytic core of the sunY intron of bacteriophage T4: the role of a novel base-pairing interaction in group I introns

The catalytic core of the sunY intron of bacteriophage T4 is separated from its 3' exon by 837 nucleotides, most of which are part of an open reading frame (ORF). Here, we report that transcripts truncated within the sunY ORF self-splice in vitro to a variety of sites in the segment immediately 3' of the core. Recognition of these proximal splice sites is shown to depend on (1) the presence on the intron side of a terminal G, which must not be part of a secondary structure; and (2) the ability of the penultimate intron nucleotide to base-pair with a 3' splice site-binding sequence (3'SSBS) located within the core. The counterpart of the 3'SSBS can be identified in most group I introns. The possible significance of such alternative splicing events for in vivo expression of intron-encoded proteins is discussed.

Deletion-tolerance and trans-splicing of the bacteriophage T4 td intron. Analysis of the P6-L6a region

Non-directed mutagenesis and phylogenetic comparison suggest that certain elements of the bacteriophage T4 td group Ia intron are dispensable to self-splicing. The L6-P6a-L6a region was identified as a potential non-essential element, and was removed by sequential deletions extending from the L6a loop toward the P6 pairing. Assays for splicing indicate that as long as the P6 pairing is maintained, the 1016 nucleotide td intron can be reduced to less than 250 nucleotides while maintaining function in vivo and in vitro. The P6 pairing appears to be essential for splicing while P6a is not. In addition, a spontaneous pseudorevertant of a splicing-defective deletion was isolated and shown to result from a single nucleotide change in the predicted L6a loop. This genetic suppressor mimics the ability of Mg2+ to reverse the phenotype of the deletion, suggesting that function is restored by structural stabilization of P6. The tolerance of this region to deletion prompted us to split the ribozyme core in L6a, to generate precursors that might function in trans. Indeed, the two half-molecules do associate to form a bimolecular complex that yields accurately ligated exons both in vitro and in vivo. The biological implications of these results, as well as the usefulness of trans-splicing for generating unprocessed precursors in vitro are discussed.

Miniribozymes, small derivatives of the sunY intron, are catalytically active

The self-splicing sunY intron from bacteriophage T4 has the smallest conserved core secondary structure of any of the active group I introns. Here we show that several nonconserved regions can be deleted from this intron without complete loss of catalytic activity. The 3' stems P9, P9.1, and P9.2 can be deleted while retaining 5' cleaving activity. Two base-paired stems (P7.1 and P7.2) that are peculiar to the group IA introns can also be deleted; however, the activities of the resulting derivatives depend greatly on the choice of replacement sequences and their lengths. The smallest active derivative is less than 180 nucleotides long. These experiments help to define the minimum structural requirements for catalysis.

Miniribozymes, small derivatives of the sunY intron, are catalytically active

The self-splicing sunY intron from bacteriophage T4 has the smallest conserved core secondary structure of any of the active group I introns. Here we show that several nonconserved regions can be deleted from this intron without complete loss of catalytic activity. The 3' stems P9, P9.1, and P9.2 can be deleted while retaining 5' cleaving activity. Two base-paired stems (P7.1 and P7.2) that are peculiar to the group IA introns can also be deleted; however, the activities of the resulting derivatives depend greatly on the choice of replacement sequences and their lengths. The smallest active derivative is less than 180 nucleotides long. These experiments help to define the minimum structural requirements for catalysis.

The conserved U.G pair in the 5' splice site duplex of a group I intron is required in the first but not the second step of self-splicing

Group I self-splicing introns have a 5' splice site duplex (P1) that contains a single conserved base pair (U.G). The U is the last nucleotide of the 5' exon, and the G is part of the internal guide sequence within the intron. Using site-specific mutagenesis and analysis of the rate and accuracy of splicing of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron, we found that both the U and the G of the U.G pair are important for the first step of self-splicing (attack of GTP at the 5' splice site). Mutation of the U to a purine activated cryptic 5' splice sites in which a U.G pair was restored; this result emphasizes the preference for a U.G at the splice site. Nevertheless, some splicing persisted at the normal site after introduction of a purine, suggesting that position within the P1 helix is another determinant of 5' splice site choice. When the U was changed to a C, the accuracy of splicing was not affected, but the Km for GTP was increased by a factor of 15 and the catalytic rate constant was decreased by a factor of 7. Substitution of U.A, U.U, G.G, or A.G for the conserved U.G decreased the rate of splicing by an even greater amount. In contrast, mutation of the conserved G enhanced the second step of splicing, as evidenced by a trans-splicing assay. Furthermore, a free 5' exon ending in A or C instead of the conserved U underwent efficient ligation. Thus, unlike the remainder of the P1 helix, which functions in both the first and second steps of self-splicing, the conserved U.G appears to be important only for the first step.

The catalytic core of the sunY intron of bacteriophage T4

The self-splicing sunY intron of bacteriophage T4 shares a common secondary structure with other group I introns. A long open reading frame within the intron is entirely 3' of the structural elements conserved in all group I introns. This catalytic core is the smallest yet described for a self-splicing intron. An internal deletion of 728 nucleotides (nt), leaving 196 nt at the 5' end and 109 nt at the 3' end, allows normal self-splicing. Transcripts terminating 196 nt 3' of the 5' splice site retain catalytic activity.

The conserved U.G pair in the 5' splice site duplex of a group I intron is required in the first but not the second step of self-splicing

Group I self-splicing introns have a 5' splice site duplex (P1) that contains a single conserved base pair (U.G). The U is the last nucleotide of the 5' exon, and the G is part of the internal guide sequence within the intron. Using site-specific mutagenesis and analysis of the rate and accuracy of splicing of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron, we found that both the U and the G of the U.G pair are important for the first step of self-splicing (attack of GTP at the 5' splice site). Mutation of the U to a purine activated cryptic 5' splice sites in which a U.G pair was restored; this result emphasizes the preference for a U.G at the splice site. Nevertheless, some splicing persisted at the normal site after introduction of a purine, suggesting that position within the P1 helix is another determinant of 5' splice site choice. When the U was changed to a C, the accuracy of splicing was not affected, but the Km for GTP was increased by a factor of 15 and the catalytic rate constant was decreased by a factor of 7. Substitution of U.A, U.U, G.G, or A.G for the conserved U.G decreased the rate of splicing by an even greater amount. In contrast, mutation of the conserved G enhanced the second step of splicing, as evidenced by a trans-splicing assay. Furthermore, a free 5' exon ending in A or C instead of the conserved U underwent efficient ligation. Thus, unlike the remainder of the P1 helix, which functions in both the first and second steps of self-splicing, the conserved U.G appears to be important only for the first step.

Defining the inside and outside of a catalytic RNA molecule

Ribozymes are RNA molecules that catalyze biochemical reactions. Fe(II)-EDTA, a solvent-based reagent which cleaves both double- and single-stranded RNA, was used to investigate the structure of the Tetrahymena ribozyme. Regions of cleavage alternate with regions of substantial protection along the entire RNA molecule. In particular, most of the catalytic core shows greatly reduced cleavage. These data constitute experimental evidence that an RNA enzyme, like a protein enzyme, has an interior and an exterior. Determination of positions where the phosphodiester backbone of the RNA is on the inside or on the outside of the molecule provides major constraints for modeling the three-dimensional structure of the Tetrahymena ribozyme. This approach should be generally informative for structured RNA molecules.

A mobile group I intron in the nuclear rDNA of Physarum polycephalum

We have shown that a strain-specific group I intron (intron 3) in the nuclear extrachromosomal rDNA or Physarum polycephalum is a mobile element. Shortly after mating of amoebae from intron-lacking and intron-containing strains, intron 3 transposes in a site-specific manner into all available recipient molecules. The transposition appears to occur by gene conversion, as evidence by the co-conversion of adjacent sequences and by double strand breakage observed in some of the recipient rDNA molecules. We infer that the double strand break is induced by an endonuclease encoded by intron 3, since in vitro transcription and translation of the cloned intron leads to the synthesis of an enzymatically active, site-specific nuclease. This is the first demonstration of the transposition of a nuclear intron in an experimental setting, and provides a rare example of a protein encoded by an RNA polymerase I transcript.

Molecular genetics of group I introns: RNA structures and protein factors required for splicing--a review

In vivo and in vitro genetic techniques have been widely used to investigate the structure-function relationships and requirements for splicing of group-I introns. Analyses of group-I introns from extremely diverse genetic systems, including fungal mitochondria, protozoan nuclei, and bacteriophages, have yielded results which are complementary and highly consistent. In vivo genetic studies of fungal mitochondrial systems have served to identify cis-acting sequences within mitochondrial introns, and trans-acting protein products of mitochondrial and nuclear genes which are important for splicing, and to show that some mitochondrial introns are mobile genetic elements. In vitro genetic studies of the self-splicing intron within the Tetrahymena thermophila nuclear large ribosomal RNA precursor (Tetrahymena LSU intron) have been used to examine essential and nonessential RNA sequences and structures in RNA-catalyzed splicing. In vivo and in vitro genetic analysis of the intron within the bacteriophage T4 td gene has permitted the detailed examination of mutant phenotypes by analyzing splicing in vivo and self-splicing in vitro. The genetic studies combined with phylogenetic analysis of intron structure based on comparative nucleotide sequence data [Cech 73 (1988) 259-271] and with biochemical data obtained from in vitro splicing experiments have resulted in significant advances in understanding the biology and chemistry of group-I introns.

Determinants of the 3' splice site for self-splicing of the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA

Tetrahymena preribosomal RNA undergoes self-splicing in vitro. The structural components involved in recognition of the 5' splice site have been identified, but the mechanism by which the 3' splice site is recognized is not established. To identify some components of 3'splice site recognition, we have generated mutations near the 3' splice site and determined their effects on self-splicing. Alteration of the 3'-terminal guanosine of the intervening sequence (IVS), a conserved nucleotide in group I IVSs, almost eliminated 3' splice site activity; the IVS-3' exon splicing intermediate accumulated, and exon ligation was extremely slow. These mutations do not result in recruitment of cryptic 3' splice sites, in contrast to mutations that affect the 5' splice site. Alteration of the cytidine preceding the 3'-terminal guanosine or of the first two nucleotides of the 3' exon had similar but less severe effects on exon ligation. Most of the mutants showed some reduction (less than threefold) in GTP addition at the 5' splice site. A mutation that placed a new guanosine residue just upstream from the 3'-terminal guanosine misspliced to produce ligated exons with one extra nucleotide between the 5' and 3' exons. We conclude that multiple nucleotides, located both at the 3' end of the IVS and in the 3' exon, are required for 3' splice site recognition.