Electrical nerve and muscle stimulation by radio frequency surgery: role of direct current loops around the active electrode

Risk assessment of neuromuscular stimulation by energy-based transurethral resection devices: an ex vivo test standard

Background

During transurethral resection of bladder tumours (TURB), radio-frequency (RF) currents can lead to adverse neuromuscular stimulation (NMS). Here we present a novel ex vivo method to determine the risk of RF generators and their bipolar TURB modes to cause NMS. We aimed to develop an experimental platform for safety evaluation of new RF generators and their modes with a newly established test standard, suitable for replacement or reduction of animal testing.

Methods

We tested four contemporary RF generators with their bipolar modes for TURB in saline. A two-stage ex vivo approach was pursued: First, we recorded voltages at possible positions of the obturator nerve behind a porcine bladder wall in a TURB model using 18 RF applications per generator. Second, these voltage records were used as stimuli to evoke nerve compound action potentials (CAPs) in isolated porcine axillary nerves. The NMS potential was defined as the ratio between the observed area under the CAPs and the theoretical CAP area at maximum response and a firing rate of 250 Hz, which would reliably induce tetanic muscle responses in most human subjects. The measurement protocol was tailored to optimise reproducibility of the obtained NMS potentials and longevity of the nerve specimens.

Results

As prerequisite for the clinical translation of our results, the robustness of our test method and reproducibility of the NMS potential are demonstrated with an excellent correlation (r = 0.93) between two sets of identical stimuli (n = 72 each) obtained from 16 nerve segments with similar diameters (4.2 ± 0.37 mm) in the nerve model. The RF generators differed significantly (p < 0.0001) regarding NMS potential (medians: 0–3%).

Conclusions

Our test method is suitable for quantifying the NMS potential of different electrosurgical systems ex vivo with high selectivity at a reasonable degree of standardization and with justifiable effort. Our results suggest that the clinical incidence of NMS is considerably influenced by the type of RF generator. Future generations of RF generators take advantage from the proposed test standard through higher safety and less animal testing. Health professionals and treated patients will benefit most from improved RF surgery using generators with a low NMS risk.

Waveform Dependent Electrosurgical Effects on Soft Hydrated Tissues

Electrosurgical procedures are ubiquitously used in surgery. The commonly used power modes, including the coagulation and blend modes, utilize non-sinusoidal or modulated current waveforms. For the same power setting, the coagulation, blend and pure cutting modes have different heating and thermal damage outcomes due to the frequency dependence of electrical conductivity of soft hydrated tissues. In this paper, we propose a multi-physics model of soft tissues to account for the effects of multi-frequency electrosurgical power modes within the framework of a continuum thermomechanical model based on mixture theory. Electrical and frequency spectrum results from different power modes at low and high power settings are presented. Model predictions are compared with in vivo electrosurgical heating experiments on porcine liver tissue. The accuracy of the model in predicting experimentally observed temperature profiles is found to be overall greater when frequency-dependence is included. An Arrhenius type model indicates that more tissue damage is correlated with larger duty cycles in multi-frequency modes.

Remote electrical stimulation by means of implanted rectifiers

Miniaturization of active implantable medical devices is currently compromised by the available means for electrically powering them. Most common energy supply techniques for implants – batteries and inductive couplers – comprise bulky parts which, in most cases, are significantly larger than the circuitry they feed. Here, for overcoming such miniaturization bottleneck in the case of implants for electrical stimulation, it is proposed to make those implants act as rectifiers of high frequency bursts supplied by remote electrodes. In this way, low frequency currents will be generated locally around the implant and these low frequency currents will perform stimulation of excitable tissues whereas the high frequency currents will cause only innocuous heating. The present study numerically demonstrates that low frequency currents capable of stimulation can be produced by a miniature device behaving as a diode when high frequency currents, neither capable of thermal damage nor of stimulation, flow through the tissue where the device is implanted. Moreover, experimental evidence is provided by an in vivo proof of concept model consisting of an anesthetized earthworm in which a commercial diode was implanted. With currently available microelectronic techniques, very thin stimulation capsules (diameter <500 µm) deliverable by injection are easily conceivable.

A true to life simulation of electrosurgery

A laboratory simulation has been devised for use in developing and testing physiologic monitoring systems' performance in the presence of electrosurgical interference. This facilitated the development through iterative optimization of an EEG based parameter whose performance is improved during electrosurgery. The system was found to have an improvement of 94% in response to electrosurgery interference in the laboratory simulation. It was found to be improved 78% from all interference sources when tested clinically during actual surgery. This demonstrates the efficacy of the simulation.

A spark counter as a control unit of a radio frequency surgery device

A new approach in radio frequency (rf) electrosurgery, used for tissue treatment, is achieved by using a new process control method. An external control unit allows a commonly available rf-generator to automatically supply the appropriate power for differing tissue types, thus ensuring best cutting quality. The sparks, generated during the scalpel electrode interaction with the tissue, appear statistically distributed. The spark rate depends on various factors and is monotonic with the supplied electrical power. This allows it to be used as the controlled variable in the cutting process. The ac current passing through the tissue is evaluated by an external control unit using an analyzation algorithm to determine the number of sparks. The external unit is comprised of a system, which measures the spark rate, and a subsequent proportional integral (P.I.) controller. The functionality of the control method as well as the electrical circuitry is verified through cuts with different degrees of carbonization and cuts through tissue heterojunctions.

Spark erosion myectomy in hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy

The design features of the cutting electrode and the electrical characteristics of a monopolar electrosurgical device were specially adapted for performing a septal myectomy in patients with hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy. Both the cutting behavior and electrode design were found to facilitate myectomy.