Investigating Cardiorespiratory Interaction Using Ballistocardiography and Seismocardiography-A Narrative Review

Ballistocardiography (BCG) and seismocardiography (SCG) are non-invasive techniques used to record the micromovements induced by cardiovascular activity at the body's center of mass and on the chest, respectively. Since their inception, their potential for evaluating cardiovascular health has been studied. However, both BCG and SCG are impacted by respiration, leading to a periodic modulation of these signals. As a result, data processing algorithms have been developed to exclude the respiratory signals, or recording protocols have been designed to limit the respiratory bias. Reviewing the present status of the literature reveals an increasing interest in applying these techniques to extract respiratory information, as well as cardiac information. The possibility of simultaneous monitoring of respiratory and cardiovascular signals via BCG or SCG enables the monitoring of vital signs during activities that require considerable mental concentration, in extreme environments, or during sleep, where data acquisition must occur without introducing recording bias due to irritating monitoring equipment. This work aims to provide a theoretical and practical overview of cardiopulmonary interaction based on BCG and SCG signals. It covers the recent improvements in extracting respiratory signals, computing markers of the cardiorespiratory interaction with practical applications, and investigating sleep breathing disorders, as well as a comparison of different sensors used for these applications. According to the results of this review, recent studies have mainly concentrated on a few domains, especially sleep studies and heart rate variability computation. Even in those instances, the study population is not always large or diversified. Furthermore, BCG and SCG are prone to movement artifacts and are relatively subject dependent. However, the growing tendency toward artificial intelligence may help achieve a more accurate and efficient diagnosis. These encouraging results bring hope that, in the near future, such compact, lightweight BCG and SCG devices will offer a good proxy for the gold standard methods for assessing cardiorespiratory function, with the added benefit of being able to perform measurements in real-world situations, outside of the clinic, and thus decrease costs and time.

Changes in Forcecardiography Heartbeat Morphology Induced by Cardio-Respiratory Interactions

The cardiac function is influenced by respiration. In particular, various parameters such as cardiac time intervals and the stroke volume are modulated by respiratory activity. It has long been recognized that cardio-respiratory interactions modify the morphology of cardio-mechanical signals, e.g., phonocardiogram, seismocardiogram (SCG), and ballistocardiogram. Forcecardiography (FCG) records the weak forces induced on the chest wall by the mechanical activity of the heart and lungs and relies on specific force sensors that are capable of monitoring respiration, infrasonic cardiac vibrations, and heart sounds, all simultaneously from a single site on the chest. This study addressed the changes in FCG heartbeat morphology caused by respiration. Two respiratory-modulated parameters were considered, namely the left ventricular ejection time (LVET) and a morphological similarity index (MSi) between heartbeats. The time trends of these parameters were extracted from FCG signals and further analyzed to evaluate their consistency within the respiratory cycle in order to assess their relationship with the breathing activity. The respiratory acts were localized in the time trends of the LVET and MSi and compared with a reference respiratory signal by computing the sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV). In addition, the agreement between the inter-breath intervals estimated from the LVET and MSi and those estimated from the reference respiratory signal was assessed via linear regression and Bland-Altman analyses. The results of this study clearly showed a tight relationship between the respiratory activity and the considered respiratory-modulated parameters. Both the LVET and MSi exhibited cyclic time trends that remarkably matched the reference respiratory signal. In addition, they achieved a very high sensitivity and PPV (LVET: 94.7% and 95.7%, respectively; MSi: 99.3% and 95.3%, respectively). The linear regression analysis reported almost unit slopes for both the LVET (R² = 0.86) and MSi (R² = 0.97); the Bland-Altman analysis reported a non-significant bias for both the LVET and MSi as well as limits of agreement of ±1.68 s and ±0.771 s, respectively. In summary, the results obtained were substantially in line with previous findings on SCG signals, adding to the evidence that FCG and SCG signals share a similar information content.

Quantifying Respiration Effects on Cardiac Vibrations using Teager Energy Operator and Gradient Boosted Trees

This work proposes a novel beat scoring system for quantifying the effects of exhalation and inhalation on the seismocardiogram (SCG) signals in rest and physiologically modulated conditions. Data from 19 subjects during rest, listening to classical music and recovery states were used. First, the SCG and electrocardiogram (ECG) signals were segmented into exhalation and inhalation phases using the respiration signal; and a representative SCG beat for each exhale and inhale phase was constructed using the ECG R-peak locations. Second, the significant differences across the exhalation- and inhalation-induced SCG beats were detected and extracted using the Teager- Kaiser energy operator. Finally, a gradient-based beat scoring system was developed using extreme gradient boosted trees and monotonic mapping. For the rest, classical music and recovery sessions, the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve was found to be 0.978, 0.874, 0.985, respectively. On the other hand, the kernel density estimation distributions of the inhalation and exhalation scores had an overlap of 14.2%, 41.2%, 10.6%, respectively. Overall, our results show that different physiological modulations directly change the effect of respiration on the SCG morphology, thus standardization across the beats should be studied for achieving more reliable and accurate investigation of cardiovascular parameters. Clinical relevance - Such a system can potentially allow for more informed and clinically useful SCG analysis by providing valuable insights regarding the intra-recording variability caused by the respiratory system.

The Latest Progress and Development Trend in the Research of Ballistocardiography (BCG) and Seismocardiogram (SCG) in the Field of Health Care

The current status of the research of Ballistocardiography (BCG) and Seismocardiogram (SCG) in the field of medical treatment, health care and nursing was analyzed systematically, and the important direction in the research was explored, to provide reference for the relevant researches. This study, based on two large databases, CNKI and PubMed, used the bibliometric analysis method to review the existing documents in the past 20 years, and made analyses on the literature of BCG and SCG for their annual changes, main countries/regions, types of research, frequently-used subject words, and important research subjects. The results show that the developed countries have taken a leading position in the researches in this field, and have made breakthroughs in some subjects, but their research results have been mainly gained in the area of research and development of the technologies, and very few have been actually industrialized into commodities. This means that in the future the researchers should focus on the transformation of BCG and SCG technologies into commercialized products, and set up quantitative health assessment models, so as to become the daily tools for people to monitor their health status and manage their own health, and as the main approaches of improving the quality of life and preventing diseases for individuals.

A Comprehensive Review on Seismocardiogram: Current Advancements on Acquisition, Annotation, and Applications

In recent years, cardiovascular diseases are on the rise, and they entail enormous health burdens on global economies. Cardiac vibrations yield a wide and rich spectrum of essential information regarding the functioning of the heart, and thus it is necessary to take advantage of this data to better monitor cardiac health by way of prevention in early stages. Specifically, seismocardiography (SCG) is a noninvasive technique that can record cardiac vibrations by using new cutting-edge devices as accelerometers. Therefore, providing new and reliable data regarding advancements in the field of SCG, i.e., new devices and tools, is necessary to outperform the current understanding of the State-of-the-Art (SoTA). This paper reviews the SoTA on SCG and concentrates on three critical aspects of the SCG approach, i.e., on the acquisition, annotation, and its current applications. Moreover, this comprehensive overview also presents a detailed summary of recent advancements in SCG, such as the adoption of new techniques based on the artificial intelligence field, e.g., machine learning, deep learning, artificial neural networks, and fuzzy logic. Finally, a discussion on the open issues and future investigations regarding the topic is included.

Advanced Fusion and Empirical Mode Decomposition-Based Filtering Methods for Breathing Rate Estimation from Seismocardiogram Signals

Breathing Rate (BR), an important deterioration indicator, has been widely neglected in hospitals due to the requirement of invasive procedures and the need for skilled nurses to be measured. On the other hand, biomedical signals such as Seismocardiography (SCG), which measures heart vibrations transmitted to the chest-wall, can be used as a non-invasive technique to estimate the BR. This makes SCG signals a highly appealing way for estimating the BR. As such, this work proposes three novel methods for extracting the BR from SCG signals. The first method is based on extracting respiration-dependent features such as the fundamental heart sound components, S1 and S2 from the SCG signal. The second novel method investigates for the first time the use of data driven methods such as the Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) method to identify the respiratory component from an SCG signal. Finally, the third advanced method is based on fusing frequency information from the respiration signals that result from the aforementioned proposed methods and other standard methods. The developed methods in this paper are then evaluated on adult recordings from the combined measurement of ECG, the Breathing and Seismocardiograms database. Both fusion and EMD filter-based methods outperformed the individual methods, giving a mean absolute error of 1.5 breaths per minute, using a one-minute window of data.

Respiration Monitoring via Forcecardiography Sensors

In the last few decades, a number of wearable systems for respiration monitoring that help to significantly reduce patients’ discomfort and improve the reliability of measurements have been presented. A recent research trend in biosignal acquisition is focusing on the development of monolithic sensors for monitoring multiple vital signs, which could improve the simultaneous recording of different physiological data. This study presents a performance analysis of respiration monitoring performed via forcecardiography (FCG) sensors, as compared to ECG-derived respiration (EDR) and electroresistive respiration band (ERB), which was assumed as the reference. FCG is a novel technique that records the cardiac-induced vibrations of the chest wall via specific force sensors, which provide seismocardiogram-like information, along with a novel component that seems to be related to the ventricular volume variations. Simultaneous acquisitions were obtained from seven healthy subjects at rest, during both quiet breathing and forced respiration at higher and lower rates. The raw FCG sensor signals featured a large, low-frequency, respiratory component (R-FCG), in addition to the common FCG signal. Statistical analyses of R-FCG, EDR and ERB signals showed that FCG sensors ensure a more sensitive and precise detection of respiratory acts than EDR (sensitivity: 100% vs. 95.8%, positive predictive value: 98.9% vs. 92.5%), as well as a superior accuracy and precision in interbreath interval measurement (linear regression slopes and intercepts: 0.99, 0.026 s (R² = 0.98) vs. 0.98, 0.11 s (R² = 0.88), Bland–Altman limits of agreement: ±0.61 s vs. ±1.5 s). This study represents a first proof of concept for the simultaneous recording of respiration signals and forcecardiograms with a single, local, small, unobtrusive, cheap sensor. This would extend the scope of FCG to monitoring multiple vital signs, as well as to the analysis of cardiorespiratory interactions, also paving the way for the continuous, long-term monitoring of patients with heart and pulmonary diseases.

Chest-Worn Inertial Sensors: A Survey of Applications and Methods

Inertial Measurement Units (IMUs) are frequently implemented in wearable devices. Thanks to advances in signal processing and machine learning, applications of IMUs are not limited to those explicitly addressing body movements such as Activity Recognition (AR). On the other hand, wearing IMUs on the chest offers a few advantages over other body positions. AR and posture analysis, cardiopulmonary parameters estimation, voice and swallowing activity detection and other measurements can be approached through chest-worn inertial sensors. This survey tries to introduce the applications that come with the chest-worn IMUs and summarizes the existing methods, current challenges and future directions associated with them. In this regard, this paper references a total number of 57 relevant studies from the last 10 years and categorizes them into seven application areas. We discuss the inertial sensors used as well as their placement on the body and their associated validation methods based on the application categories. Our investigations show meaningful correlations among the studies within the same application categories. Then, we investigate the data processing architectures of the studies from the hardware point of view, indicating a lack of effort on handling the main processing through on-body units. Finally, we propose combining the discussed applications in a single platform, finding robust ways for artifact cancellation, and planning optimized sensing/processing architectures for them, to be taken more seriously in future research.

Automatic Respiratory Phase Identification Using Tracheal Sounds and Movements During Sleep

One of the most important signals to assess respiratory function, especially in patients with sleep apnea, is airflow. A convenient method to estimate airflow is based on analyzing tracheal sounds and movements. However, this method requires accurate identification of respiratory phases. Our goal is to develop an automatic algorithm to analyze tracheal sounds and movements to identify respiratory phases during sleep. Data from adults with suspected sleep apnea who were referred for in-laboratory sleep studies were included. Simultaneously with polysomnography, tracheal sounds and movements were recorded with a small wearable device attached to the suprasternal notch. First, an adaptive detection algorithm was developed to localize the respiratory phases in tracheal sounds. Then, for each phase, a set of morphological features from sound energy and tracheal movement were extracted to classify the localized phases into inspirations or expirations. The average error and time delay of detecting respiratory phases were 7.62% and 181 ms during normal breathing, 8.95% and 194 ms during snoring, and 13.19% and 220 ms during respiratory events, respectively. The average classification accuracy was 83.7% for inspirations and 75.0% for expirations. Respiratory phases were accurately identified from tracheal sounds and movements during sleep.

Neural Network-based Classification of Static Lung Volume States using Vibrational Cardiography

Non-invasive health monitoring has the potential to improve the delivery and efficiency of medical treatment.

OBJECTIVE

This study was aimed at developing a neural network to classify the lung volume state of a subject (i.e. high lung volume (HLV) or low lung volume (LLV), where the subject had fully inhaled or exhaled, respectively) by analyzing cardiac cycles extracted from vibrational cardiography (VCG) signals.

METHODS

A total of 15619 cardiac cycles were recorded from 50 subjects, of which 9989 cycles were recorded in the HLV state and the remaining 5630 cycles were recorded in the LLV state. A 1D convolutional neural network (CNN) was employed to classify the lung volume state of these cardiac cycles.

RESULTS

The CNN model was evaluated using a train/test split of 80/20 on the data. The developed model was able to correctly classify the lung volume state of 99.4% of the testing data.

CONCLUSION

VCG cardiac cycles can be classified based on lung volume state using a CNN.

SIGNIFICANCE

These results provide evidence of a correlation between VCG and respiration volume, which could inform further analysis into VCG-based cardio-respiratory monitoring.

A Unified Methodology for Heartbeats Detection in Seismocardiogram and Ballistocardiogram Signals

This work presents a methodology to analyze and segment both seismocardiogram (SCG) and ballistocardiogram (BCG) signals in a unified fashion. An unsupervised approach is followed to extract a template of SCG/BCG heartbeats, which is then used to fine-tune temporal waveform annotation. Rigorous performance assessment is conducted in terms of sensitivity, precision, Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) and Mean Absolute Error (MAE) of annotation. The methodology is tested on four independent datasets, covering different measurement setups and time resolutions. A wide application range is therefore explored, which better characterizes the robustness and generality of the method with respect to a single dataset. Overall, sensitivity and precision scores are uniform across all datasets ( p > 0.05 from the Kruskal–Wallis test): the average sensitivity among datasets is 98.7%, with 98.2% precision. On the other hand, a slight yet significant difference in RMSE and MAE scores was found ( p < 0.01 ) in favor of datasets with higher sampling frequency. The best RMSE scores for SCG and BCG are 4.5 and 4.8 ms, respectively; similarly, the best MAE scores are 3.3 and 3.6 ms. The results were compared to relevant recent literature and are found to improve both detection performance and temporal annotation errors.

Wearable Cardiorespiratory Monitoring Employing a Multimodal Digital Patch Stethoscope: Estimation of ECG, PEP, LVETand Respiration Using a 55 mm Single-Lead ECG and Phonocardiogram

Cardiovascular diseases are the main cause of death worldwide, with sleep disordered breathing being a further aggravating factor. Respiratory illnesses are the third leading cause of death amongst the noncommunicable diseases. The current COVID-19 pandemic, however, also highlights the impact of communicable respiratory syndromes. In the clinical routine, prolonged postanesthetic respiratory instability worsens the patient outcome. Even though early and continuous, long-term cardiorespiratory monitoring has been proposed or even proven to be beneficial in several situations, implementations thereof are sparse. We employed our recently presented, multimodal patch stethoscope to estimate Einthoven electrocardiogram (ECG) Lead I and II from a single 55 mm ECG lead. Using the stethoscope and ECG subsystems, the pre-ejection period (PEP) and left ventricular ejection time (LVET) were estimated. ECG-derived respiration techniques were used in conjunction with a novel, phonocardiogram-derived respiration approach to extract respiratory parameters. Medical-grade references were the SOMNOmedics SOMNO HDTM and Osypka ICON-CoreTM. In a study including 10 healthy subjects, we analyzed the performances in the supine, lateral, and prone position. Einthoven I and II estimations yielded correlations exceeding 0.97. LVET and PEP estimation errors were 10% and 21%, respectively. Respiratory rates were estimated with mean absolute errors below 1.2 bpm, and the respiratory signal yielded a correlation of 0.66. We conclude that the estimation of ECG, PEP, LVET, and respiratory parameters is feasible using a wearable, multimodal acquisition device and encourage further research in multimodal signal fusion for respiratory signal estimation.

Classification of Aortic Stenosis Using Time-Frequency Features From Chest Cardio-Mechanical Signals

OBJECTIVES

This paper introduces a novel method for the detection and classification of aortic stenosis (AS) using the time-frequency features of chest cardio-mechanical signals collected from wearable sensors, namely seismo-cardiogram (SCG) and gyro-cardiogram (GCG) signals. Such a method could potentially monitor high-risk patients out of the clinic.

METHODS

Experimental measurements were collected from twenty patients with AS and twenty healthy subjects. Firstly, a digital signal processing framework is proposed to extract time-frequency features. The features are then selected via the analysis of variance test. Different combinations of features are evaluated using the decision tree, random forest, and artificial neural network methods. Two classification tasks are conducted. The first task is a binary classification between normal subjects and AS patients. The second task is a multi-class classification of AS patients with co-existing valvular heart diseases.

RESULTS

In the binary classification task, the average accuracies achieved are 96.25% from decision tree, 97.43% from random forest, and 95.56% from neural network. The best performance is from combined SCG and GCG features with random forest classifier. In the multi-class classification, the best performance is 92.99% using the random forest classifier and SCG features.

CONCLUSION

The results suggest that the solution could be a feasible method for classifying aortic stenosis, both in the binary and multi-class tasks. It also indicates that most of the important time-frequency features are below 11 Hz.

SIGNIFICANCE

The proposed method shows great potential to provide continuous monitoring of valvular heart diseases to prevent patients from sudden critical cardiac situations.

Recent development of respiratory rate measurement technologies

Respiratory rate (RR) is an important physiological parameter whose abnormality has been regarded as an important indicator of serious illness. In order to make RR monitoring simple to perform, reliable and accurate, many different methods have been proposed for such automatic monitoring. According to the theory of respiratory rate extraction, methods are categorized into three modalities: extracting RR from other physiological signals, RR measurement based on respiratory movements, and RR measurement based on airflow. The merits and limitations of each method are highlighted and discussed. In addition, current works are summarized to suggest key directions for the development of future RR monitoring methodologies.

Recent Advances in Seismocardiography

Cardiovascular disease is a major cause of death worldwide. New diagnostic tools are needed to provide early detection and intervention to reduce mortality and increase both the duration and quality of life for patients with heart disease. Seismocardiography (SCG) is a technique for noninvasive evaluation of cardiac activity. However, the complexity of SCG signals introduced challenges in SCG studies. Renewed interest in investigating the utility of SCG accelerated in recent years and benefited from new advances in low-cost lightweight sensors, and signal processing and machine learning methods. Recent studies demonstrated the potential clinical utility of SCG signals for the detection and monitoring of certain cardiovascular conditions. While some studies focused on investigating the genesis of SCG signals and their clinical applications, others focused on developing proper signal processing algorithms for noise reduction, and SCG signal feature extraction and classification. This paper reviews the recent advances in the field of SCG.

Automatic Detection of Aortic Valve Opening Using Seismocardiography in Healthy Individuals

Accurate detection of fiducial points in a seismocardiogram (SCG) is a challenging research problem for its clinical application. In this paper, an automated method for detecting aortic valve opening (AO) instants using the dorso-ventral component of the SCG signal is proposed. This method does not require electrocardiogram (ECG) as a reference signal. After preprocessing the SCG, multiscale wavelet decomposition is carried out to get signal components in different wavelet subbands. The subbands having possible AO peaks are selected by a newly proposed dominant-multiscale-kurtosis- and dominant-multiscale-central-frequency-based criterion. The signal is reconstructed using selected subbands, and it is emphasized using the weights derived from the proposed relative squared dominant multiscale kurtosis. The Shannon energy followed by autocorrelation coefficients is computed for systole envelope construction. Finally, AO peaks are detected by a Gaussian-derivative-filtering-based scheme. The robustness of the proposed method is tested using clean and noisy SCG signals from the combined measurement of ECG, breathing, and SCG database. Evaluation results show that the method can achieve an average sensitivity of 94%, a prediction rate of 90%, and a detection accuracy of 86% approximately over 4585 analyzed beats.

On the Design of an Efficient Cardiac Health Monitoring System Through Combined Analysis of ECG and SCG Signals

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is a major public concern and socioeconomic problem across the globe. The popular high-end cardiac health monitoring systems such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), computerized tomography scan (CT scan), and echocardiography (Echo) are highly expensive and do not support long-term continuous monitoring of patients without disrupting their activities of daily living (ADL). In this paper, the continuous and non-invasive cardiac health monitoring using unobtrusive sensors is explored aiming to provide a feasible and low-cost alternative to foresee possible cardiac anomalies in an early stage. It is learned that cardiac health monitoring based on sole usage of electrocardiogram (ECG) signals may not provide powerful insights as ECG provides shallow information on various cardiac activities in the form of electrical impulses only. Hence, a novel low-cost, non-invasive seismocardiogram (SCG) signal along with ECG signals are jointly investigated for the robust cardiac health monitoring. For this purpose, the in-laboratory data collection model is designed for simultaneous acquisition of ECG and SCG signals followed by mechanisms for the automatic delineation of relevant feature points in acquired ECG and SCG signals. In addition, separate feature points based novel approach is adopted to distinguish between normal and abnormal morphology in each ECG and SCG cardiac cycle. Finally, a combined analysis of ECG and SCG is carried out by designing a Naïve Bayes conditional probability model. Experiments on Institutional Review Board (IRB) approved licensed ECG/SCG signals acquired from real subjects containing 12,000 cardiac cycles show that the proposed feature point delineation mechanisms and abnormal morphology detection methods consistently perform well and give promising results. In addition, experimental results show that the combined analysis of ECG and SCG signals provide more reliable cardiac health monitoring compared to the standalone use of ECG and SCG.

Combined Seismo- and Gyro-Cardiography: A More Comprehensive Evaluation of Heart-Induced Chest Vibrations

This paper reports on the combined analysis of seismocardiogram (SCG) and gyrocardiogram (GCG) recordings. An inertial measurement unit (IMU) consisting of a three-axis micro-electromechanical (MEMS) accelerometer and a three-axis MEMS gyroscope is used to record heart-induced mechanical vibrations from the chest wall of the subjects. An electrocardiogram and an impedance cardiogram (ICG) sensor are also used as references for segmenting the cardiac cycles and recording the aortic valve opening and closure (AO and AC) events, respectively. A simplified model is proposed to explain the mechanical coupling of the chest wall to the IMU. Correlations and time differences are analyzed for the annotation of GCG and its first derivative with respect to ICG and SCG as references. Experimental results indicate a precise identification of systolic points such as the AO and AC events. The left ventricular ejection time and pre-ejection period metrics calculated from gyroscope recordings are also shown to accurately track their corresponding trends acquired from ICG signals. Waveform similarity analyses indicate that the first derivative of GCG has a better similarity with SCG than the GCG signal itself. Experimental results also suggest that interdevice differences in GCG recordings would need to be addressed before this technology can gain widespread application.