Automatic Path-Planning Techniques for Minimally Invasive Stereotactic Neurosurgical Procedures-A Systematic Review

This review systematically examines the recent research from the past decade on diverse path-planning algorithms tailored for stereotactic neurosurgery applications. Our comprehensive investigation involved a thorough search of scholarly papers from Google Scholar, PubMed, IEEE Xplore, and Scopus, utilizing stringent inclusion and exclusion criteria. The screening and selection process was meticulously conducted by a multidisciplinary team comprising three medical students, robotic experts with specialized knowledge in path-planning techniques and medical robotics, and a board-certified neurosurgeon. Each selected paper was reviewed in detail, and the findings were synthesized and reported in this review. The paper is organized around three different types of intervention tools: straight needles, steerable needles, and concentric tube robots. We provide an in-depth analysis of various path-planning algorithms applicable to both single and multi-target scenarios. Multi-target planning techniques are only discussed for straight tools as there is no published work on multi-target planning for steerable needles and concentric tube robots. Additionally, we discuss the imaging modalities employed, the critical anatomical structures considered during path planning, and the current status of research regarding its translation to clinical human studies. To the best of our knowledge and as a conclusion from this systematic review, this is the first review paper published in the last decade that reports various path-planning techniques for different types of tools for minimally invasive neurosurgical applications. Furthermore, this review outlines future trends and identifies existing technology gaps within the field. By highlighting these aspects, we aim to provide a comprehensive overview that can guide future research and development in path planning for stereotactic neurosurgery, ultimately contributing to the advancement of safer and more effective neurosurgical procedures.

Design Optimization and Tradeoff Analysis of an Actuated Continuum Probe for Pulmonary Nodule Localization and Resection

Pulmonary nodules are abnormal tissue masses in the lungs, typically less than 3.0 cm in diameter, commonly detected during imaging of the chest and lungs. While most pulmonary nodules are not cancerous, surgical resection may be required if growth is detected between scans. This resection is typically performed without the benefit of intraoperative imaging, making it difficult for surgeons to confidently provide appropriate margins. To enhance the efficacy of wedge resection, researchers have developed a modified ultrasound imaging approach that utilizes both multiple scattering (MS) and single scattering (SS) to enhance the accuracy of margin delineation. Clinical deployment of this novel ultrasound technology requires a highly maneuverable ultrasound probe, ideally one that could be deployed and actuated with minimal invasiveness. This study details the design optimization and tradeoff analysis of an actuated continuum probe for pulmonary nodule localization and resection. This device, deployed through intercostal ports, would enable the intraoperative imaging and precise mapping of nodules for improved margin delineation and patient outcomes. To achieve this objective, multiple objective genetic algorithms (MOGAs) and a design of experiments (DOE) study are used to explore the design space and quantify key dimensional relationships and their effects on probe actuation.

A Novel Extensible Continuum Robot with Growing Motion Capability Inspired by Plant Growth for Path-Following in Transoral Laryngeal Surgery

This article presents a novel extensible continuum robot (ECR) with growing motion capability for improved flexible access in transoral laryngeal procedures. The robot uses an extensible continuum joint with a staggered V-shaped notched structure as the backbone, driven by the pushing and pulling of superelastic Nitinol rods. The notched structure is optimized to achieve a wide range of extension/contraction and bending motion for the continuum joint. The successive and uniform deflection of the notches provides the continuum joint with excellent constant curvature bending characteristics. The bidirectional rod-driven approach expands the robot's extension capabilities with both pushing and pulling operations, and the superelasticity of the driving rods preserves the robot's bending performance. The ECR significantly increases motion dexterity and reachability through its variable length, which facilitates collision-free access to deep lesions by following the anatomy. To further exploit the advantages of the ECR in path-following for flexible access, a growing motion approach inspired by the plant growth process has been proposed to minimize the path deviation error. Characterization experiments are conducted to verify the performances of the proposed ECR. The extension ratio achieves up to 225.92%, and the average distal positioning error and hysteresis error values are 2.87% and 0.51% within the ±120° bending range. Compared with the typical continuum robot with a fixed length, the path-following deviation of this robot is reduced by more than 58.30%, effectively reducing the risk of collision during access. Phantom experiments validate the feasibility of the proposed concept in flexible access procedures.

Fiberbots: Robotic fibers for high-precision minimally invasive surgery

Precise manipulation of flexible surgical tools is crucial in minimally invasive surgical procedures, necessitating a miniature and flexible robotic probe that can precisely direct the surgical instruments. In this work, we developed a polymer-based robotic fiber with a thermal actuation mechanism by local heating along the sides of a single fiber. The fiber robot was fabricated by highly scalable fiber drawing technology using common low-cost materials. This low-profile (below 2 millimeters in diameter) robotic fiber exhibits remarkable motion precision (below 50 micrometers) and repeatability. We developed control algorithms coupling the robot with endoscopic instruments, demonstrating high-resolution in situ molecular and morphological tissue mapping. We assess its practicality and safety during in vivo laparoscopic surgery on a porcine model. High-precision motion of the fiber robot delivered endoscopically facilitates the effective use of cellular-level intraoperative tissue identification and ablation technologies, potentially enabling precise removal of cancer in challenging surgical sites.

A Concentric Tube Steerable Drilling Robot for Minimally Invasive Spinal Fixation of Osteoporotic Vertebrae

Spinal fixation with rigid pedicle screws have shown to be an effective treatment for many patients. However, this surgical option has been proved to be insufficient and will eventually fail for patients experiencing osteoporosis. This failure is mainly attributed to the lack of dexterity in the existing rigid drilling instruments and the complex anatomy of vertebrae, forcing surgeons to implant rigid pedicle screws within the osteoporotic regions of anatomy. To address this problem, in this article, we present the design, fabrication, and evaluation of a unique flexible yet structurally strong concentric tube steerable drilling robot (CT-SDR). The CT-SDR is capable of drilling smooth and accurate curved trajectories through hard tissues without experiencing buckling and failure; thus enabling the use of novel flexible pedicle screws for the next generation of spinal fixation procedures. Particularly, by decoupling the control of bending and insertion degrees of freedom (DoF) of the CT-SDR, we present a robotic system that (i) is intuitive to steer as it does not require an on-the-fly control algorithm for the bending DoF, and (ii) is able to address the contradictory requirements of structural stiffness and dexterity of a flexible robot interacting with the hard tissue. The robust and repeatable performance of the proposed CT-SDR have been experimentally evaluated by conducting various drilling procedures on simulated bone materials and animal bone samples. Experimental results indicate drilling times as low as 35 seconds for curved trajectories with 41 mm length and remarkable steering accuracy with a maximum 2% deviation error.

Design and Experimental Validation of a 3D-Printed Embedded-Sensing Continuum Robot for Neurosurgery

A minimally-invasive manipulator characterized by hyper-redundant kinematics and embedded sensing modules is presented in this work. The bending angles (tilt and pan) of the robot tip are controlled through tendon-driven actuation; the transmission of the actuation forces to the tip is based on a Bowden-cable solution integrating some channels for optical fibers. The viability of the real-time measurement of the feedback control variables, through optoelectronic acquisition, is evaluated for automated bending of the flexible endoscope and trajectory tracking of the tip angles. Indeed, unlike conventional catheters and cannulae adopted in neurosurgery, the proposed robot can extend the actuation and control of snake-like kinematic chains with embedded sensing solutions, enabling real-time measurement, robust and accurate control of curvature, and tip bending of continuum robots for the manipulation of cannulae and microsurgical instruments in neurosurgical procedures. A prototype of the manipulator with a length of 43 mm and a diameter of 5.5 mm has been realized via 3D printing. Moreover, a multiple regression model has been estimated through a novel experimental setup to predict the tip angles from measured outputs of the optoelectronic modules. The sensing and control performance has also been evaluated during tasks involving tip rotations.

A Versatile Continuum Gripping Robot with a Concealable Gripper

Continuum robots with their inherent compliance provide the potential for crossing narrow unstructured workspace and safely grasping various objects. However, the display gripper increases the size of the robots, and therefore, it tends to get stuck in constrained environments. This paper proposes a versatile continuum grasping robot (CGR) with a concealable gripper. The CGR can capture large objects with respect to the robot's scale using the continuum manipulator and can grasp various objects using the end concealable gripper especially in narrow and unstructured workspaces. To perform the cooperative operation of the concealable gripper and the continuum manipulator, a global kinematic model based on screw theory and a motion planning approach referred to as "multi-node synergy method" for the CGR are presented. The simulation and experimental results show that objects of different shapes and sizes can be captured by the same CGR even in complex and narrow environments. Finally, in the future, the CGR is expected to serve for satellite capture in harsh space environments such as high vacuum, strong radiation, and extreme temperatures.

Continuum Robots for Medical Interventions

Continuum robots are not constructed with discrete joints but, instead, change shape and position their tip by flexing along their entire length. Their narrow curvilinear shape makes them well suited to passing through body lumens, natural orifices, or small surgical incisions to perform minimally invasive procedures. Modeling and controlling these robots are, however, substantially more complex than traditional robots comprised of rigid links connected by discrete joints. Furthermore, there are many approaches to achieving robot flexure. Each presents its own design and modeling challenges, and to date, each has been pursued largely independently of the others. This article attempts to provide a unified summary of the state of the art of continuum robot architectures with respect to design for specific clinical applications. It also describes a unifying framework for modeling and controlling these systems while additionally explaining the elements unique to each architecture. The major research accomplishments are described for each topic and directions for the future progress needed to achieve widespread clinical use are identified.

Design and Modeling of a Bio-Inspired Compound Continuum Robot for Minimally Invasive Surgery

The continuum robot is a new type of bionic robot which is widely used in the medical field. However, the current structure of the continuum robot limits its application in the field of minimally invasive surgery. In this paper, a bio-inspired compound continuum robot (CCR) combining the concentric tube continuum robot (CTR) and the notched continuum robot is proposed to design a high-dexterity minimally invasive surgical instrument. Then, a kinematic model, considering the stability of the CTR part, was established. The unstable operation of the CCR is avoided. The simulation of the workspace shows that the introduction of the notched continuum robot expands the workspace of CTR. The dexterity indexes of the robots are proposed. The simulation shows that the dexterity of the CCR is 1.472 times that of the CTR. At last, the length distribution of the CCR is optimized based on the dexterity index by using a fruit fly optimization algorithm. The simulations show that the optimized CCR is more dexterous than before. The dexterity of the CCR is increased by 1.069 times. This paper is critical for the development of high-dexterity minimally invasive surgical instruments such as those for the brain, blood vessels, heart and lungs.

Visual servoing of continuum robots: Methods, challenges, and prospects

BACKGROUND

Recent advancements in continuum robotics have accentuated developing efficient and stable controllers to handle shape deformation and compliance. The control of continuum robots (CRs) using physical sensors attached to the robot, particularly in confined spaces, is difficult due to their limited accuracy in three-dimensional deflections and challenging localisation. Therefore, using non-contact imaging sensors finds noticeable importance, particularly in medical scenarios. Accordingly, given the need for direct control of the robot tip and notable uncertainties in the kinematics and dynamics of CRs, many papers have focussed on the visual servoing (VS) of CRs in recent years.

METHODS

The significance of this research towards safe human-robot interaction has fuelled our survey on the previous methods, current challenges, and future opportunities.

RESULTS

Beginning with actuation modalities and modelling approaches, the paper investigates VS methods in medical and non-medical scenarios.

CONCLUSIONS

Finally, challenges and prospects of VS for CRs are discussed, followed by concluding remarks.

Flexible Manipulator with Low-Melting-Point Alloy Actuation and Variable Stiffness

Flexible manipulators offer significant advantages over traditional rigid manipulators in minimally invasive surgery, because they can flexibly navigate around obstacles and pass cramped or tortuous paths. However, due to the inherent low stiffness, the ability to control/obtain higher stiffness when required remains to be further explored. In this article, we propose a flexible manipulator that exploits the phase transformation property of low-melting-point alloy to hydraulically drive and change the stiffness by heating and cooling. A prototype was fabricated, and experiments were conducted to evaluate the motion characteristics, stiffness performance, and rigid-flexible transition efficiency. The experimental results demonstrate that the proposed manipulator can freely adjust heading direction in the three-dimensional space. The experimental results also indicate that it took 9.2-10.3 s for the manipulator to transform from a rigid state to a flexible state and 15.4 s to transform from a flexible state to a rigid state. The lateral stiffness and flexural stiffness of the manipulator were 95.54 and 372.1 Ncm² in the rigid state and 7.26 and 0.78 Ncm² in the flexible state. The gain of the lateral stiffness and flexural stiffness was 13.15 and 477.05, respectively. In the rigid state, the ultimate force without shape deformation was more than 0.98 N in the straight condition (0°) and 1.36 N in the bending condition (90°). By assembling flexible surgical tools, the manipulator can enrich the diagnosis or treatment functions, which demonstrated the potential clinical value of the proposed manipulator.

Biopsy Needle System With a Steerable Concentric Tube and Online Monitoring of Electrical Resistivity and Insertion Forces

OBJECTIVE

Biopsies are the gold standard for clinical diagnosis. However, a discrepancy between the biopsy sample and target tissue because of misplacement of the biopsy spoon can lead to errors in the diagnosis and subsequent treatment. Thus, correctly determining whether the needle tip is in the tumor is crucial for accurate biopsy results.

METHODS

A biopsy needle system was designed with a steerable, flexible, and superelastic concentric tube; electrodes to monitor the electrical resistivity; and load cells to monitor the insertion force. The degrees of freedom were analyzed for two working modes: straight-line and deflection.

RESULTS

Experimental results showed that the system could perceive the tissue type in online based on the electrical resistivity. In addition, changes in the insertion force indicated transitions between the interfaces of adjacent tissue layers.

CONCLUSION

The two monitoring methods guarantee that the biopsy spoon is at the desired position inside the tumor during an operation.

SIGNIFICANCE

The proposed biopsy needle system can be integrated into an autonomous robotic biopsy system.

How close are we to anterior robotic skull base surgery?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The application of robotic surgery to anterior skull base disease has yet to be defined despite the potential for improved tumour resection with less morbidity in this region. Complex anatomy and restricted access have limited the development of robotic anterior skull base surgery.

RECENT FINDINGS

A limited number of transoral robotic surgical anterior skull base procedures have been undertaken; however, there are significant limitations to the utilization of this technology in the anterior skull base. In this article, the advantages, disadvantages and limitations of robotic anterior skull base surgery are discussed. Currently, the major limitation is the size of the robotic endoscope and of the available instrumentation. Technological advancements that provide promise for the future development of robotic anterior skull base surgery are in development, such as single-port robots, flexible instrument systems and miniaturization and growth of minimally invasive platforms.

SUMMARY

Although transnasal access to the skull base is not possible with the currently available robotic systems, promising technology does exist and is in development. Robotic anterior skull base surgery promises to provide greater access to skull base disease, improve oncologic results, reduce morbidity and to reduce the ergonomic burden on the surgeon.

Recent Advances in Design and Actuation of Continuum Robots for Medical Applications

Traditional rigid robot application in the medical field is limited due to the limited degrees of freedom caused by their material and structure. Inspired by trunk, tentacles, and snakes, continuum robot (CR) could traverse confined space, manipulate objects in complex environment, and conform to curvilinear paths in space. The continuum robot has broad prospect in surgery due to its high dexterity, which can reach circuitous areas of the body and perform precision surgery. Recently, many efforts have been done by researchers to improve the design and actuation methods of continuum robots. Several continuum robots have been applied in clinic surgical interventions and demonstrated superiorities to conventional rigid-link robots. In this paper, we provide an overview of the current development of continuum robots, including the design principles, actuation methods, application prospect, limitations, and challenge. And we also provide perspective for the future development. We hope that with the development of material science, Engineering ethics, and manufacture technology, new methods can be applied to manufacture continuum robots for specific surgical procedures.