Diffraction Effects and Compensation in Passive Acoustic Mapping

Quantifying the Effect of Acoustic Parameters on Temporal and Spatial Cavitation Activity: Gauging Cavitation Dose

OBJECTIVE

Cavitation-enhanced delivery of therapeutic agents is under development for the treatment of cancer and neurodegenerative and cardiovascular diseases, including sonothrombolysis for deep vein thrombosis. The objective of this study was to quantify the spatial and temporal distribution of cavitation activity nucleated by Definity infused through the EKOS catheter over a range of acoustic parameters controlled by the EKOS endovascular system.

METHODS

Three insonation protocols were compared in an in vitro phantom mimicking venous flow to measure the effect of peak rarefactional pressure, pulse duration and pulse repetition frequency on cavitation activity energy, location and duration. Inertial and stable cavitation activity was quantified using passive cavitation imaging, and a metric of cavitation dose based on energy density was defined.

RESULTS

For all three insonation protocols, cavitation was sustained for the entire 30 min Definity infusion. The evolution of cavitation energy during each pulse duration was similar for all three protocols. For insonation protocols with higher peak rarefactional acoustic pressures, inertial and stable cavitation doses also increased. A complex relationship between the temporal behavior of cavitation energy within each pulse and the pulse repetition frequency affected the cavitation dose for the three insonation protocols. The relative predominance of stable or inertial cavitation dose varied according to insonation schemes. Passive cavitation images revealed the spatial distribution of cavitation activity.

CONCLUSION

Our cavitation dose metric based on energy density enabled the impact of different acoustic parameters on cavitation activity to be measured. Depending on the type of cavitation to be promoted or suppressed, particular pulsing schemes could be employed in future studies, for example, to correlate cavitation dose with sonothrombolytic efficacy.

Initiating and imaging cavitation from infused echo contrast agents through the EkoSonic catheter

Ultrasound-enhanced delivery of therapeutic-loaded echogenic liposomes is under development for vascular applications using the EkoSonic Endovascular System. In this study, fibrin-targeted echogenic liposomes loaded with an anti-inflammatory agent were characterized before and after infusion through an EkoSonic catheter. Cavitation activity was nucleated by Definity or fibrin-targeted, drug-loaded echogenic liposomes infused and insonified with EkoSonic catheters. Passive cavitation imaging was used to quantify and map bubble activity in a flow phantom mimicking porcine arterial flow. Cavitation was sustained during 3-min infusions of Definity or echogenic liposomes along the distal 6 cm treatment zone of the catheter. Though the EkoSonic catheter was not designed specifically for cavitation nucleation, infusion of drug-loaded echogenic liposomes can be employed to trigger and sustain bubble activity for enhanced intravascular drug delivery.

Assessment of bubble activity generated by histotripsy combined with echogenic liposomes

Objective.Histotripsy is a form of focused ultrasound therapy that uses the mechanical activity of bubbles to ablate tissue. While histotripsy alone degrades the cellular content of tissue, recent studies have demonstrated it effectively disrupts the extracellular structure of pathologic conditions such as venous thrombosis when combined with a thrombolytic drug. Rather than relying on standard administration methods, associating thrombolytic drugs with an ultrasound-triggered echogenic liposome vesicle will enable targeted, systemic drug delivery. To date, histotripsy has primarily relied on nano-nuclei inherent to the medium for bubble cloud generation, and microbubbles associated with echogenic liposomes may alter the histotripsy bubble dynamics. The objective of this work was to investigate the interaction of histotripsy pulse with echogenic liposomes.Approach.Bubble clouds were generated using a focused source in anin vitromodel of venous flow. Acoustic emissions generated during the insonation were passively acquired to assess the mechanical activity of the bubble cloud. High frame rate, pulse inversion imaging was used to track the change in echogenicity of the liposomes following histotripsy exposure.Main results.For peak negative pressures less than 20 MPa, acoustic emissions indicative of stable and inertial bubble activity were observed. As the peak negative pressure of the histotripsy excitation increased, harmonics of the excitation were observed in OFP t-ELIP solutions and plasma alone. Additional observations with high frame rate imaging indicated a transition of bubble behavior as the pulse pressure transitioned to shock wave formation.Significance.These observations suggest that a complex interaction between histotripsy pulses and echogenic liposomes that may be exploited for combination treatment approaches.

Pancreatic Ductal Adenocarcinoma: Current and Emerging Therapeutic Uses of Focused Ultrasound

Simple Summary

Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) is an increasingly prevalent form of cancer with a low patient survival rate following diagnosis. Focused Ultrasound is an emerging modality that provides exciting opportunities in treating PDAC. This review provides an overview of the clinical application and scientific research of therapeutic focused ultrasound for the treatment of PDAC for use by clinicians and scientific researchers. In addition to providing a description of various physical mechanism underlying therapeutic applications, the current benefits, challenges, and possible future avenues for the application and development of focused ultrasound in the treatment of PDAC are summarized.

Abstract

Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) diagnosis accompanies a somber prognosis for the patient, with dismal survival odds: 5% at 5 years. Despite extensive research, PDAC is expected to become the second leading cause of mortality by cancer by 2030. Ultrasound (US) has been used successfully in treating other types of cancer and evidence is flourishing that it could benefit PDAC patients. High-intensity focused US (HIFU) is currently used for pain management in palliative care. In addition, clinical work is being performed to use US to downstage borderline resectable tumors and increase the proportion of patients eligible for surgical ablation. Focused US (FUS) can also induce mechanical effects, which may elicit an anti-tumor response through disruption of the stroma and can be used for targeted drug delivery. More recently, sonodynamic therapy (akin to photodynamic therapy) and immunomodulation have brought new perspectives in treating PDAC. The aim of this review is to summarize the current state of those techniques and share our opinion on their future and challenges.

Time-Resolved Passive Cavitation Mapping Using the Transient Angular Spectrum Approach

Passive cavitation mapping (PCM), which generates images using bubble acoustic emission signals, has been increasingly used for monitoring and guiding focused ultrasound surgery (FUS). PCM can be used as an adjunct to magnetic resonance imaging to provide crucial information on the safety and efficacy of FUS. The most widely used algorithm for PCM is delay-and-sum (DAS). One of the major limitations of DAS is its suboptimal computational efficiency. Although frequency-domain DAS can partially resolve this issue, such an algorithm is not suitable for imaging the evolution of bubble activity in real time and for cases in which cavitation events occur asynchronously. This study investigates a transient angular spectrum (AS) approach for PCM. The working principle of this approach is to backpropagate the received signal to the domain of interest and reconstruct the spatial-temporal wavefield encoded with the bubble location and collapse time. The transient AS approach is validated using an in silico model and water bath experiments. It is found that the transient AS approach yields similar results to DAS, but it is one order of magnitude faster. The results obtained by this study suggest that the transient AS approach is promising for fast and accurate PCM.

Passive Cavitation Mapping by Cavitation Source Localization From Aperture-Domain Signals-Part I: Theory and Validation Through Simulations

Passive cavitation mapping (PCM) algorithms for diagnostic ultrasound arrays based on time exposure acoustics (TEA) exhibit poor axial resolution, which is in part due to the diffraction-limited point spread function of the imaging system and poor rejection by the delay-and-sum beamformer. In this article, we adapt a method for speed of sound estimation to be utilized as a cavitation source localization (CSL) approach. This method utilizes a hyperbolic fit to the arrival times of the cavitation signals in the aperture domain, and the coefficients of the fit are related to the position of the cavitation source. Wavefronts exhibiting poor fit to the hyperbolic function are corrected to yield improved source localization. We demonstrate through simulations that this method is capable of accurate estimation of the origin of coherent spherical waves radiating from cavitation/point sources. The average localization error from simulated microbubble sources was 0.12 ± 0.12mm ( 0.15 ± 0.14λ₀ for a 1.78-MHz transmit frequency). In simulations of two simultaneous cavitation sources, the proposed technique had an average localization error of 0.2mm ( 0.23λ₀ ), whereas conventional TEA had an average localization error of 0.81mm ( 0.97λ₀ ). The reconstructed PCM-CSL image showed a significant improvement in resolution compared with the PCM-TEA approach.

Use of the Cross-Spectral Density Matrix for Enhanced Passive Ultrasound Imaging of Cavitation

Passive ultrasound imaging is of great interest for cavitation monitoring. Spatiotemporal monitoring of cavitation bubbles in therapeutic applications is possible using an ultrasound imaging probe to passively receive the acoustic signals from the bubbles. Fourier-domain (FD) beamformers have been proposed to process the signals received into maps of the spatial localization of cavitation activity, with reduced computing times with respect to the time-domain approach, and to take advantage of frequency selectivity for cavitation regime characterization. The approaches proposed have been mainly nonadaptive, and these have suffered from low resolution and contrast, due to the many reconstruction artifacts. Inspired by the array-processing literature and in the context of passive ultrasound imaging of cavitation, we propose here a robust estimation of the second-order statistics of data through spatial covariance matrices in the FD or cross-spectral density matrices (CSMs). The benefits of such formalism are illustrated using advanced reconstruction algorithms, such as the robust Capon beamformer, the Pisarenko class beamformer, and the multiple signal classification approach. Through both simulations and experiments in a water tank, we demonstrate that enhanced localization of cavitation activity (i.e., improved resolution and contrast with respect to nonadaptive approaches) is compatible with the rapid and frequency-selective approaches of the FD. Robust estimation of the CSM and the derived adaptive beamformers paves the way to the development of powerful passive ultrasound imaging tools.

Assessment of Collaborative Robot (Cobot)-Assisted Histotripsy for Venous Clot Ablation

OBJECTIVE

The application of bubble-based ablation with the focus ultrasound therapy histotripsy is gaining traction for the treatment of venous thrombosis, among other pathologies. For extensive clot burden, the histotripsy source must be translated to ensure uniform bubble activity throughout the vascular obstruction. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the targeting accuracy of a histotripsy system comprised of a focused source, ultrasound image guidance, and a collaborative robot (cobot) positioner. The system was designed with a primary emphasis for treating deep vein thrombosis.

METHODS

Studies to test treatment planning and targeting bubble activity with the histotripsy-cobot system were conducted in an in vitro clot model. A tissue-mimicking phantom was also targeted with the system, and the predicted and actual areas of liquefaction were compared to gauge the spatial accuracy of ablation.

RESULTS

The system provided submillimeter accuracy for both tracking along an intended path (within 0.6 mm of a model vessel) and targeting bubble activity within the venous clot model (0.7 mm from the center of the clot). Good correlation was observed between the planned and actual liquefaction locations in the tissue phantom, with an average Dice similarity coefficient of 77.8%, and average Hausdorff distance of 1.6 mm.

CONCLUSION

Cobots provide an effective means to apply histotripsy pulses over a treatment volume, with the ablation precision contingent on the quality of image guidance.

SIGNIFICANCE

Overall, these results demonstrate cobots can be used to guide histotripsy ablation for targets that extend beyond the natural focus of the transducer.

Cavitation Emissions Nucleated by Definity Infused through an EkoSonic Catheter in a Flow Phantom

The EkoSonic endovascular system has been cleared by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for the controlled and selective infusion of physician specified fluids, including thrombolytics, into the peripheral vasculature and the pulmonary arteries. The objective of this study was to explore whether this catheter technology could sustain cavitation nucleated by infused Definity, to support subsequent studies of ultrasound-mediated drug delivery to diseased arteries. The concentration and attenuation spectroscopy of Definity were assayed before and after infusion at 0.3, 2.0 and 4.0 mL/min through the EkoSonic catheter. PCI was used to map and quantify stable and inertial cavitation as a function of Definity concentration in a flow phantom mimicking the porcine femoral artery. The 2.0 mL/min infusion rate yielded the highest surviving Definity concentration and acoustic attenuation. Cavitation was sustained throughout each 15 ms ultrasound pulse, as well as throughout the 3 min infusion. These results demonstrate a potential pathway to use cavitation nucleation to promote drug delivery with the EkoSonic endovascular system.

Dual-Array Passive Acoustic Mapping for Cavitation Imaging With Enhanced 2-D Resolution

Passive acoustic mapping (PAM) techniques have been developed for the purposes of detecting, localizing, and quantifying cavitation activity during therapeutic ultrasound procedures. Implementation with conventional diagnostic ultrasound arrays has allowed planar mapping of bubble acoustic emissions to be overlaid with B-mode anatomical images, with a variety of beamforming approaches providing enhanced resolution at the cost of extended computation times. However, no passive signal processing techniques implemented to date have overcome the fundamental physical limitation of the conventional diagnostic array aperture that results in point spread functions with axial/lateral beamwidth ratios of nearly an order of magnitude. To mitigate this problem, the use of a pair of orthogonally oriented diagnostic arrays was recently proposed, with potential benefits arising from the substantially expanded range of observation angles. This article presents experiments and simulations intended to demonstrate the performance and limitations of the dual-array system concept. The key finding of this study is that source pair resolution of better than 1 mm is now possible in both dimensions of the imaging plane using a pair of 7.5-MHz center frequency conventional arrays at a distance of 7.6cm. With an eye toward accelerating computations for real-time applications, channel count reductions of up to a factor of eight induce negligible performance losses. Modest sensitivities to sound speed and relative array position uncertainties were identified, but if these can be kept on the order of 1% and 1 mm, respectively, then the proposed methods offer the potential for a step improvement in cavitation monitoring capability.

Real-Time Passive Acoustic Mapping Using Sparse Matrix Multiplication

Passive acoustic mapping enables the spatiotemporal monitoring of cavitation with circulating microbubbles during focused ultrasound (FUS)-mediated blood-brain barrier opening. However, the computational load for processing large data sets of cavitation maps or more complex algorithms limit the visualization in real-time for treatment monitoring and adjustment. In this study, we implemented a graphical processing unit (GPU)-accelerated sparse matrix-based beamforming and time exposure acoustics in a neuronavigation-guided ultrasound system for real-time spatiotemporal monitoring of cavitation. The system performance was tested in silico through benchmarking, in vitro using nonhuman primate (NHP) and human skull specimens, and demonstrated in vivo in NHPs. We demonstrated the stability of the cavitation map for integration times longer than 62.5 [Formula: see text]. A compromise between real-time displaying and cavitation map quality obtained from beamformed RF data sets with a size of 2000 ×128 ×30 (axial [Formula: see text]) was achieved for an integration time of [Formula: see text], which required a computational time of 0.27 s (frame rate of 3.7 Hz) and could be displayed in real-time between pulses at PRF = 2 Hz. Our benchmarking tests show that the GPU sparse-matrix algorithm processed the RF data set at a computational rate of [Formula: see text]/pixel/sample, which enables adjusting the frame rate and the integration time as needed. The neuronavigation system with real-time implementation of cavitation mapping facilitated the localization of the cavitation activity and helped to identify distortions due to FUS phase aberration. The in vivo test of the method demonstrated the feasibility of GPU-accelerated sparse matrix computing in a close to a clinical condition, where focus distortions exemplify problems during treatment. These experimental conditions show the need for spatiotemporal monitoring of cavitation with real-time capability that enables the operator to correct or halt the sonication in case substantial aberrations are observed.

Spatiotemporal Assessment of the Cellular Safety of Cavitation-Based Therapies by Passive Acoustic Mapping

Many useful therapeutic bio-effects can be generated using ultrasound-induced cavitation. However, cavitation is also capable of causing unwanted cellular and vascular damage, which should be monitored to ensure treatment safety. In this work, the unique opportunity provided by passive acoustic mapping (PAM) to quantify cavitation dose across an entire volume of interest during therapy is utilised to provide setup-independent measures of spatially localised cavitation dose. This spatiotemporally quantifiable cavitation dose is then related to the level of cellular damage generated. The cavitation-mediated destruction of equine red blood cells mixed with one of two types of cavitation nuclei at a variety of concentrations is investigated. The blood is placed within a 0.5-MHz ultrasound field and exposed to a range of peak rarefactional pressures up to 2 MPa, with 50 to 50,000 cycle pulses maintaining a 5% duty cycle. Two co-planar linear arrays at 90° to each other are used to generate 400-µm-resolution frequency domain robust capon beamforming PAM maps, which are then used to generate estimates of cavitation dose. A relationship between this cavitation dose and the levels of haemolysis generated was found which was comparable regardless of the applied acoustic pressure, pulse length, cavitation agent type or concentration used. PAM was then used to monitor cellular damage in multiple locations within a tissue phantom simultaneously, with the damage-cavitation dose relationship being similar for the two experimental models tested. These results lay the groundwork for this method to be applied to other measures of safety, allowing for improved ultrasound monitoring of cavitation-based therapies.

Compensation of array lens effects for improved co-registration of passive acoustic mapping and B-mode images for cavitation monitoring

Passive acoustic mapping (PAM) techniques offer a simple means of spatio-temporal cavitation monitoring during therapeutic ultrasound procedures. Implementation with a conventional diagnostic ultrasound system allows natural integration of PAM with B-mode imaging. However, the refracting properties of diagnostic array lenses may introduce PAM image registration errors that could lead to inaccuracies in treatment monitoring and guidance. To address these concerns, this paper presents lens characterization of two different array designs, analytical estimation of lens-induced source mapping errors in simple media, and experimental demonstration and correction of lens effects, reducing the depth-averaged image co-registration errors to no more than 0.52 mm.

Compensation of array lens effects for improved co-registration of passive acoustic mapping and B-mode images for cavitation monitoring

Passive acoustic mapping (PAM) techniques offer a simple means of spatio-temporal cavitation monitoring during therapeutic ultrasound procedures. Implementation with a conventional diagnostic ultrasound system allows natural integration of PAM with B-mode imaging. However, the refracting properties of diagnostic array lenses may introduce PAM image registration errors that could lead to inaccuracies in treatment monitoring and guidance. To address these concerns, this paper presents lens characterization of two different array designs, analytical estimation of lens-induced source mapping errors in simple media, and experimental demonstration and correction of lens effects, reducing the depth-averaged image co-registration errors to no more than 0.52 mm.

Passive Acoustic Mapping Using Data-Adaptive Beamforming Based on Higher Order Statistics

Sources of nonlinear acoustic emissions, particularly those associated with cavitation activity, play a key role in the safety and efficacy of current and emerging therapeutic ultrasound applications, such as oncological drug delivery, blood-brain barrier opening, and histotripsy. Passive acoustic mapping (PAM) is the first technique to enable real-time and non-invasive imaging of cavitation activity during therapeutic ultrasound exposure, through the recording and passive beamforming of broadband acoustic emissions using an array of ultrasound detectors. Initial limitations in PAM spatial resolution led to the adoption of optimal data-adaptive beamforming algorithms, such as the robust capon beamformer (RCB), that provide improved interference suppression and calibration error mitigation compared to non-adaptive beamformers. However, such approaches are restricted by the assumption that the recorded signals have a Gaussian distribution. To overcome this limitation and further improve the source resolvability of PAM, we propose a new beamforming approach termed robust beamforming by linear programming (RLPB). Along with the variance, this optimization-based method uses higher-order-statistics of the recorded signals, making no prior assumption on the statistical distribution of the acoustic signals. The RLPB is found via numerical simulations to improve resolvability over time exposure acoustics and RCB. In vitro experimentation yielded improved resolvability with respect to the source-to-array distance on the order of 22% axially and 13% transversely relative to RCB, whilst successfully accounting for array calibration errors. The improved resolution and decreased dependence on accurate calibration of RLPB is expected to facilitate the clinical translation of PAM for diagnostic, including super-resolution, and therapeutic ultrasound applications.

Characterization of cavitation-radiated acoustic power using diffraction correction

A method is developed for compensating absolute pressure measurements made by a calibrated passive cavitation detector (PCD) to estimate the average acoustic power radiated from a region of interest (ROI) defined to encompass all cavitating bubbles. A diffraction correction factor for conversion of PCD-measured pressures to cavitation-radiated acoustic power per unit area or volume is derived as a simple analytic expression, accounting for position- and frequency-dependent PCD sensitivity. This approach can be applied to measurements made by any PCD without precise knowledge of the number, spatial, or temporal distribution of cavitating bubbles. The diffraction correction factor is validated in simulation for a wide range of ROI dimensions and frequencies. The correction factor is also applied to emission measurements obtained during in vitro ultrasound-enhanced sonophoresis experiments, allowing comparison of stable cavitation levels between therapeutic configurations with different source center frequencies. Results incorporating sonication at both 0.41 and 2.0 MHz indicate that increases in skin permeability correlate strongly with the acoustic power of subharmonic emissions radiated per unit skin area.

Broadband Ultrasonic Attenuation Estimation and Compensation With Passive Acoustic Mapping

Several active and passive techniques have been developed to detect, localize, and quantify cavitation activity during therapeutic ultrasound procedures. Much of the prior cavitation monitoring research has been conducted using lossless in vitro systems or small animal models in which path attenuation effects were minimal. However, the performance of these techniques may be substantially degraded by attenuation between the internal therapeutic target and the external monitoring system. As a further step toward clinical application of passive acoustic mapping (PAM), this paper presents methods for attenuation estimation and compensation based on broadband cavitation data measured with a linear ultrasound array. Soft tissue phantom experiment results are used to illustrate: 1) the impact of realistic attenuation on PAM; 2) the possibility of estimating attenuation from cavitation data; 3) cavitation source energy estimation following attenuation compensation; and 4) the impact of sound speed uncertainty on PAM-related processing. Cavitation-based estimates of attenuation were within 1.5%-6.2% of the values found from conventional through-transmission measurements. Tissue phantom attenuation reduced the PAM energy estimate by an order of magnitude, but array data compensation using the cavitation-based attenuation spectrum enabled recovery of the PAM energy estimate to within 2.9%-5.9% of the values computed in the absence of the phantom. Sound speed uncertainties were found to modestly impact attenuation-compensated PAM energies, inducing errors no larger than 28% for a 40-m/s path-averaged speed error. Together, the results indicate the potential to significantly enhance the quantitative capabilities of PAM for ensuring therapeutic safety and efficacy.