Genetic testing in individuals with cerebral palsy

Comprehensive whole-genome sequence analyses provide insights into the genomic architecture of cerebral palsy

We performed whole-genome sequencing (WGS) in 327 children with cerebral palsy (CP) and their biological parents. We classified 37 of 327 (11.3%) children as having pathogenic/likely pathogenic (P/LP) variants and 58 of 327 (17.7%) as having variants of uncertain significance. Multiple classes of P/LP variants included single-nucleotide variants (SNVs)/indels (6.7%), copy number variations (3.4%) and mitochondrial mutations (1.5%). The COL4A1 gene had the most P/LP SNVs. We also analyzed two pediatric control cohorts (n = 203 trios and n = 89 sib-pair families) to provide a baseline for de novo mutation rates and genetic burden analyses, the latter of which demonstrated associations between de novo deleterious variants and genes related to the nervous system. An enrichment analysis revealed previously undescribed plausible candidate CP genes (SMOC1, KDM5B, BCL11A and CYP51A1). A multifactorial CP risk profile and substantial presence of P/LP variants combine to support WGS in the diagnostic work-up across all CP and related phenotypes.

Causation in cerebral palsy: Parental beliefs and associated emotions

AIM

To better understand parents' beliefs about causation in cerebral palsy (CP) and the emotions related to those beliefs.

METHOD

We surveyed 226 parents of children with CP aged 1 to 18 years, recruited from the Victorian Cerebral Palsy Register, to evaluate their beliefs about the causes of CP, including genetic causes, causes specific to their own child, and their attitudes and emotions in relation to these.

RESULTS

Although 92% of participants reported that understanding the causes of their child's CP was important, uncertainty about the cause was expressed by 13%. The most frequently endorsed causal factors, in general and in their own child respectively, were intrapartum hypoxia (81%, 36%) or brain damage (69%, 22%), brain damage during pregnancy (73%, 28%), and preterm birth (66%, 28%). Genetic causes were deemed relevant by 13% of participants and hospital or professional error by 16%. Parents shared related feelings of anger (59%), sadness (80%), guilt (61%), and confusion (53%); parental anger was more likely when their child's CP was attributed to intrapartum events.

INTERPRETATION

Substantial parental interest in understanding the causes of CP, together with uncertainty about the causes, parents' causal attributions, and significant emotional sequelae, highlight a strong need for provision of information and support for families of children recently diagnosed with CP.

WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS

Understanding the causes of their child's cerebral palsy (CP) was important to parents. Parents most often endorsed intrapartum factors as a cause of CP. Parents reported experiencing strong emotions about the causes of their child's CP.

Clinical actionability of genetic findings in cerebral palsy

Background and objectives

Single gene mutations are increasingly recognized as causes of cerebral palsy (CP) phenotypes, yet there is currently no standardized framework for measuring their clinical impact. We evaluated Pathogenic/Likely Pathogenic (P/LP) variants identified in individuals with CP to determine how frequently genetic testing results would prompt changes in care.

Methods

We analyzed published P/LP variants in OMIM genes identified in clinical (n = 1,345 individuals) or research (n = 496) cohorts using exome sequencing of CP patients. We established a working group of clinical and research geneticists, developmental pediatricians, genetic counselors, and neurologists and performed a systematic review of existing literature for evidence of clinical management approaches linked to genetic disorders. Scoring rubrics were adapted, and a modified Delphi approach was used to build consensus and establish the anticipated impact on patient care. Overall clinical utility was calculated from metrics assessing outcome severity if left untreated, safety/practicality of the intervention, and anticipated intervention efficacy .

Results

We found 140/1,841 (8%) of individuals in published CP cohorts had a genetic diagnosis classified as actionable , defined as prompting a change in clinical management based on knowledge related to the genetic etiology. 58/243 genes with P/LP variants were classified as actionable; 16 had treatment options targeting the primary disease mechanism , 16 had specific prevention strategies , and 26 had specific symptom management recommendations. The level of evidence was also graded according to ClinGen criteria; 44.6% of interventions had evidence class "D" or below. The potential interventions have clinical utility with 97% of outcomes being moderate-high severity if left untreated and 62% of interventions predicted to be of moderate-high efficacy . Most interventions (71%) were considered moderate-high safety/practicality .

Discussion

Our findings indicate that actionable genetic findings occur in 8% of individuals referred for genetic testing with CP. Evaluation of potential efficacy , outcome severity , and intervention safety / practicality indicates moderate-high clinical utility of these genetic findings. Thus, genetic sequencing to identify these individuals for precision medicine interventions could improve outcomes and provide clinical benefit to individuals with CP. The relatively limited evidence base for most interventions underscores the need for additional research.

Redefining cerebral palsies as a diverse group of neurodevelopmental disorders with genetic aetiology

Cerebral palsy is a clinical descriptor covering a diverse group of permanent, non-degenerative disorders of motor function. Around one-third of cases have now been shown to have an underlying genetic aetiology, with the genetic landscape overlapping with those of neurodevelopmental disorders including intellectual disability, epilepsy, speech and language disorders and autism. Here we review the current state of genomic testing in cerebral palsy, highlighting the benefits for personalized medicine and the imperative to consider aetiology during clinical diagnosis. With earlier clinical diagnosis now possible, we emphasize the opportunity for comprehensive and early genomic testing as a crucial component of the routine diagnostic work-up in people with cerebral palsy.

Uncertainties regarding cerebral palsy diagnosis: opportunities to operationalize the consensus definition

Background and Objectives

Cerebral palsy (CP), the most common motor disability of childhood, is variably diagnosed. We hypothesized that child neurologists and neurodevelopmentalists, often on the frontlines of CP diagnosis in North America, harbor uncertainties regarding the practical application of the most recent CP consensus definition from 2006.

Methods

We conducted a cross-sectional survey of child neurologists and neurodevelopmentalists at the 2022 Child Neurology Society Annual Meeting. Attendees were provided the 2006 CP consensus definition and asked whether they had any uncertainties about the practical application of the definition across four hypothetical clinical vignettes.

Results

Of 230 attendees, 164 responded to the closing survey questions (71%). 145/164 (88%) expressed at least one uncertainty regarding the clinical application of the 2006 definition. Overwhelmingly, these areas of uncertainty focused on: 1) Age, both with regards to the minimum age of diagnosis and the maximum age of brain disturbance or motor symptom onset, (67/164, 41%), and 2) Interpretation of the term "non-progressive" (48/164, 29%). The vast majority of respondents (157/164, 96%) answered 'Yes' to the question: Do you think we should revise the 2006 consensus definition of CP?

Discussion

We propose that the uncertainties we identified could be addressed by operationalizing the 2006 consensus definition to support a more uniform CP diagnosis. To address the most common CP diagnostic uncertainties we identified, we propose 3 points of clarification based on the available literature: 1) Motor symptoms/signs should be present by 2 years old; 2) CP can and should be diagnosed as early as possible, even if activity limitation is not yet present, if motor symptoms/signs can be reasonably predicted to yield activity limitation (e.g. by using standardized examination instruments, Brain MRI, and a suggestive clinical history); and 3) The clinical motor disability phenotype should be non-progressive through 5 years old. We anticipate that operationalizing the 2006 definition of CP in this manner could clarify the uncertainties we identified among child neurologists and neurodevelopmentalists and reduce the diagnostic variability that currently exists.

Predictors of whole exome sequencing in dystonic cerebral palsy and cerebral palsy-like disorders

INTRODUCTION

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a group of permanent disorders attributed to non-progressive disturbances that occurred in the developing fetal or infant brain. Cerebral palsy-like (CP-like) disorders may clinically resemble CP but do not fulfill CP criteria and have often a progressive course and/or neurodevelopmental regression. To assess which patients with dystonic CP and dystonic CP-like disorder should undergo Whole Exome Sequencing (WES), we compared the rate of likely causative variants in individuals regarding their clinical picture, co-morbidities, and environmental risk factors.

METHOD

Individuals with early onset neurodevelopmental disorder (ND) manifesting with dystonia as a core feature were divided into CP or CP-like cohorts based on their clinical picture and disease course. Detailed clinical picture, co-morbidities, and environmental risk factors including prematurity, asphyxia, SIRS, IRDS, and cerebral bleeding were evaluated.

RESULTS

A total of 122 patients were included and divided into the CP group with 70 subjects (30 males; mean age 18y5m±16y6m, mean GMFCS score 3.3 ± 1.4), and the CP-like group with 52 subjects (29 males; mean age 17y7m±1y,6 m, mean GMFCS score 2,6 ± 1,5). The WES-based diagnosis was present in 19 (27.1%) CP patients and 30 CP-like patients (57.7%) with genetic conditions overlap in both groups. We found significant differences in diagnostic rate in CP individuals with vs. without risk factors (13.9% vs. 43.3%); Fisher's exact p = 0.0065. We did not observe the same tendency in CP-like (45.5% vs 58.5%); Fisher's exact p = 0.5.

CONCLUSION

WES is a useful diagnostic method for patients with dystonic ND, regardless of their presentation as a CP or CP-like phenotype.

The Association of Placental Abruption and Pediatric Neurological Outcome: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Placental histopathology provides insights, or "snapshots", into relevant antenatal factors that could elevate the risk of perinatal brain injury. We present a systematic review and meta-analysis comparing frequencies of adverse neurological outcomes in infants born to women with placental abruption versus without abruption. Records were sourced from MEDLINE, Embase, and the CENTRAL Trials Registry from 1946 to December 2019. Studies followed the PRISMA guidelines and compared frequencies of neurodevelopmental morbidities in infants born to pregnant women with placental abruption (exposure) versus women without placental abruption (comparator). The primary endpoint was cerebral palsy. Periventricular and intraventricular (both severe and any grades of IVH) and any histopathological neuronal damage were the secondary endpoints. Study methodologic quality was assessed by the Ottawa-Newcastle scale. Estimated odds ratios (OR) and hazards ratio (HR) were derived according to study design. Data were meta-analyzed using a random effects model expressed as pooled effect sizes and 95% confidence intervals. We included eight observational studies in the review, including 1245 infants born to women with placental abruption. Results of the random effects meta-analysis show that the odds of infants born to pregnant women with placental abruption who experience cerebral palsy is higher than in infants born to pregnant women without placental abruption (OR 5.71 95% CI (1.17, 27.91); I² = 84.0%). There is no statistical difference in the odds of infants born to pregnant women with placental abruption who experience severe IVH (grade 3+) (OR 1.20 95% CI (0.46, 3.11); I² = 35.8%) and any grade of IVH (OR 1.20 95% CI (0.62, 2.32); I² = 32.3%) vs. women without placental abruption. There is no statistically significant difference in the odds of infants born to pregnant women with placental abruption who experience PVL vs. pregnant women without placental abruption (OR 6.51 95% CI (0.94, 45.16); I² = 0.0%). Despite our meta-analysis suggesting increased odds of cerebral palsy in infants born to pregnant women with placental abruption versus without abruption, this finding should be interpreted cautiously, given high heterogeneity and overall poor quality of the included studies.

Integrative Multi-Omics Research in Cerebral Palsy: Current Progress and Future Prospects

Cerebral palsy (CP) describes a heterogeneous group of non-progressive neurodevelopmental disorders affecting movement and posture. The etiology and diagnostic biomarkers of CP are a hot topic in clinical research. Recent advances in omics techniques, including genomics, epigenomics, transcriptomics, metabolomics and proteomics, have offered new insights to further understand the pathophysiology of CP and have allowed for identification of diagnostic biomarkers of CP. In present study, we reviewed the latest multi-omics investigations of CP and provided an in-depth summary of current research progress in CP. This review will offer the basis and recommendations for future fundamental research on the pathogenesis of CP, identification of diagnostic biomarkers, and prevention strategies for CP.

Cerebral palsy and related neuromotor disorders: Overview of genetic and genomic studies

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a debilitating condition characterized by abnormal movement or posture, beginning early in development. Early family and twin studies and more recent genomic investigations clearly demonstrate that genetic factors of major effect contribute to the etiology of CP. Most copy number variants and small alterations of nucleotide sequence that cause CP arise as a result of de novo mutations, so studies that estimate heritability on basis of recurrence frequency within families substantially underestimate genetic contributions to the etiology. At least 4% of patients with typical CP have disease-causing CNVs, and at least 14% have disease-causing single nucleotide variants or indels. The rate of pathogenic genomic lesions is probably more than twice as high among patients who have atypical CP, i.e., neuromotor dysfunction with additional neurodevelopmental abnormalities or malformations, or with MRI findings and medical history that are not characteristic of a perinatal insult. Mutations of many different genetic loci can produce a CP-like phenotype. The importance of genetic variants of minor effect and of epigenetic modifications in producing a multifactorial predisposition to CP is less clear. Recognizing the specific cause of CP in an affected individual is essential to providing optimal clinical management. An etiological diagnosis provides families an "enhanced compass" that improves overall well-being, facilitates access to educational and social services, permits accurate genetic counseling, and, for a subset of patients such as those with underlying inherited metabolic disorders, may make precision therapy that targets the pathophysiology available. Trio exome sequencing with assessment of copy number or trio genome sequencing with bioinformatics analysis for single nucleotide variants, indels, and copy number variants is clinically indicated in the initial workup of CP patients, especially those with additional malformations or neurodevelopmental abnormalities.

Providing a Primary Care Medical Home for Children and Youth With Cerebral Palsy

Cerebral palsy (CP) is the most common motor disorder of childhood, with prevalence estimates ranging from 1.5 to 4 in 1000 live births. This clinical report seeks to provide primary care physicians with guidance to detect children with CP; collaborate with specialists in treating the patient; manage associated medical, developmental, and behavioral problems; and provide general medical care to their patients with CP.

Making waves: The changing tide of cerebral palsy

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a broad diagnosis unbound by aetiology and is based on a clinical examination demonstrating abnormalities of movement or posture. CP represents a static neurological condition, provided that neurodegenerative conditions, leukoencephalopathies and neuromuscular disorders are excluded. In paediatrics, the genetic conditions associated with CP are rapidly increasing, with primary and overlapping neurodevelopmental conditions perhaps better categorised by the predominant clinical feature such as CP, intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorder or epilepsy. Progress in molecular genetics may challenge what constitutes CP, but a genetic diagnosis does not negate the CP diagnosis. As clinicians working in the field, we discuss the changing tide of CP. Neuroimaging provides essential information through pattern recognition and demonstration of static brain changes. We present examples of children where a layered clinical diagnosis or dual aetiologies are appropriate. We also present examples of children with genetic causes of CP to highlight the challenges and limitations of neuroimaging to provide an aetiological diagnosis. In consultation with a geneticist, access to genomic testing (exome or genome sequencing) is now available in Australia under Medicare billing for children under the age of 10 with dysmorphic features, one or more major structural organ anomalies, (an evolving) intellectual disability or global developmental delay. We encourage the uptake of genomic testing in CP, because it can be difficult to tell whether a child has an environmental or genetic cause for CP. A specific genetic diagnosis may change patient management, reduce guilt and enable more distinctive research in the future to assist with understanding disease mechanisms.

The NESHIE and CP Genetics Resource (NCGR): A database of genes and variants reported in neonatal encephalopathy with suspected hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy (NESHIE) and consequential cerebral palsy (CP)

Neonatal encephalopathy (NE) with suspected hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy (HIE) (NESHIE) is a complex syndrome occurring in newborns, characterised by altered neurological function. It has been suggested that genetic variants may influence NESHIE susceptibility and outcomes. Unlike NESHIE, for which a limited number of genetic studies have been performed, many studies have identified genetic variants associated with cerebral palsy (CP), which can develop from severe NESHIE. Identifying variants in patients with CP, as a consequence of NESHIE, may provide a starting point for the identification of genetic variants associated with NESHIE outcomes. We have constructed NCGR (NESHIE and CP Genetics Resource), a database of genes and variants reported in patients with NESHIE and CP (where relevant to NESHIE), for the purpose of collating and comparing genetic findings between the two conditions. In this paper we describe the construction and functionality of NCGR. Furthermore, we demonstrate how NCGR can be used to prioritise genes and variants of potential clinical relevance that may underlie a genetic predisposition to NESHIE and contribute to an understanding of its pathogenesis.

Human Cerebellar Development and Transcriptomics: Implications for Neurodevelopmental Disorders

Developmental abnormalities of the cerebellum are among the most recognized structural brain malformations in human prenatal imaging. Yet reliable information regarding their cause in humans is sparse, and few outcome studies are available to inform prognosis. We know very little about human cerebellar development, in stark contrast to the wealth of knowledge from decades of research on cerebellar developmental biology of model organisms, especially mice. Recent studies show that multiple aspects of human cerebellar development significantly differ from mice and even rhesus macaques, a nonhuman primate. These discoveries challenge many current mouse-centric models of normal human cerebellar development and models regarding the pathogenesis of several neurodevelopmental phenotypes affecting the cerebellum, including Dandy-Walker malformation and medulloblastoma. Since we cannot model what we do not know, additional normative and pathological human developmental data are essential, and new models are needed.

Diagnostic preferences include discussion of etiology for adults with cerebral palsy and their caregivers

AIM

To determine the views of individuals with cerebral palsy (CP) and their caregivers (CP community members) about carrying a CP diagnosis, an etiological diagnosis, or both diagnoses together.

METHOD

We surveyed CP community members across two registries querying their views on carrying a CP diagnosis, one type of etiological diagnosis (specifically, a genetic diagnosis), or both. Open-ended responses were analyzed using a conventional content analysis approach.

RESULTS

Of 197 respondents (108 adults with CP and 89 caregivers), most (75%) valued knowing the cause of their CP. Of those with a diagnostic preference, most preferred carrying both CP and etiological diagnoses together (68%). When compared with carrying an etiological diagnosis alone, significantly more respondents felt a CP diagnosis helped anticipate symptom evolution (84% vs 54%), explain symptoms to others (86% vs 48%), access services (86% vs 48%), and join support communities (78% vs 50%) (p <  0.01, χ² test).

INTERPRETATION

Most CP community members surveyed want to know the cause of their CP and would prefer carrying both CP and etiological diagnoses together. Clinical practice should evolve to meet these community needs.

Diagnostic sequencing to support genetically stratified medicine in a tertiary care setting

PURPOSE

The goal of stratified medicine is to identify subgroups of patients with similar disease mechanisms and specific responses to treatments. To prepare for stratified clinical trials, genome-wide genetic analysis should occur across clinical areas to identify undiagnosed genetic diseases and new genetic causes of disease.

METHODS

To advance genetically stratified medicine, we have developed and implemented broad exome sequencing infrastructure and research protocols at Columbia University Irving Medical Center/NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital.

RESULTS

We enrolled 4889 adult and pediatric probands and identified a primary result in 572 probands. The cohort was phenotypically and demographically heterogeneous because enrollment occurred across multiple specialty clinics (eg, epilepsy, nephrology, fetal anomaly). New gene-disease associations and phenotypic expansions were discovered across clinical specialties.

CONCLUSION

Our study processes have enabled the enrollment and exome sequencing/analysis of a phenotypically and demographically diverse cohort of patients within 1 tertiary care medical center. Because all genomic data are stored centrally with permission for longitudinal access to the electronic medical record, subjects can be recontacted with updated genetic diagnoses or for participation in future genotype-based clinical trials. This infrastructure has allowed for the promotion of genetically stratified clinical trial readiness within the Columbia University Irving Medical Center/NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital health care system.

Mendelian etiologies identified with whole exome sequencing in cerebral palsy

Objectives

Cerebral palsy (CP) is the most common childhood motor disability, yet its link to single‐gene disorders is under‐characterized. To explore the genetic landscape of CP, we conducted whole exome sequencing (WES) in a cohort of patients with CP.

Methods

We performed comprehensive phenotyping and WES on a prospective cohort of individuals with cryptogenic CP (who meet criteria for CP; have no risk factors), non‐cryptogenic CP (who meet criteria for CP; have at least one risk factor), and CP masqueraders (who could be diagnosed with CP, but have regression/progressive symptoms). We characterized motor phenotypes, ascertained medical comorbidities, and classified brain MRIs. We analyzed WES data using an institutional pipeline.

Results

We included 50 probands in this analysis (20 females, 30 males). Twenty‐four had cryptogenic CP, 20 had non‐cryptogenic CP, five had CP masquerader classification, and one had unknown classification. Hypotonic‐ataxic subtype showed a difference in prevalence across the classification groups (p = 0.01). Twenty‐six percent of participants (13/50) had a pathogenic/likely pathogenic variant in 13 unique genes (ECHS1, SATB2, ZMYM2, ADAT3, COL4A1, THOC2, SLC16A2, SPAST, POLR2A, GNAO1, PDHX, ACADM, ATL1), including one patient with two genetic disorders (ACADM, PDHX) and two patients with a SPAST‐related disorder. The CP masquerader category had the highest diagnostic yield (n = 3/5, 60%), followed by the cryptogenic CP category (n = 7/24, 29%). Fifteen percent of patients with non‐cryptogenic CP (n = 3/20) had a Mendelian disorder on WES.

Interpretation

WES demonstrated a significant prevalence of Mendelian disorders in individuals clinically diagnosed with CP, including in individuals with known CP risk factors.