A systematic assessment of mycobacterial F1 -ATPase subunit ε's role in latent ATPase hydrolysis

Inhibition of M. tuberculosis and human ATP synthase by BDQ and TBAJ-587

Bedaquiline (BDQ), a first-in-class diarylquinoline anti-tuberculosis drug, and its analogue, TBAJ-587, prevent the growth and proliferation of Mycobacterium tuberculosis by inhibiting ATP synthase1,2. However, BDQ also inhibits human ATP synthase3. At present, how these compounds interact with either M. tuberculosis ATP synthase or human ATP synthase is unclear. Here we present cryogenic electron microscopy structures of M. tuberculosis ATP synthase with and without BDQ and TBAJ-587 bound, and human ATP synthase bound to BDQ. The two inhibitors interact with subunit a and the c-ring at the leading site, c-only sites and lagging site in M. tuberculosis ATP synthase, showing that BDQ and TBAJ-587 have similar modes of action. The quinolinyl and dimethylamino units of the compounds make extensive contacts with the protein. The structure of human ATP synthase in complex with BDQ reveals that the BDQ-binding site is similar to that observed for the leading site in M. tuberculosis ATP synthase, and that the quinolinyl unit also interacts extensively with the human enzyme. This study will improve researchers' understanding of the similarities and differences between human ATP synthase and M. tuberculosis ATP synthase in terms of the mode of BDQ binding, and will allow the rational design of novel diarylquinolines as anti-tuberculosis drugs.

GaMF1.39's antibiotic efficacy and its enhanced antitubercular activity in combination with clofazimine, Telacebec, ND-011992, or TBAJ-876

IMPORTANCE

New drugs are needed to combat multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. The electron transport chain (ETC) maintains the electrochemical potential across the cytoplasmic membrane and allows the production of ATP, the energy currency of any living cell. The mycobacterial engine F-ATP synthase catalyzes the formation of ATP and has come into focus as an attractive and rich drug target. Recent deep insights into these mycobacterial F1FO-ATP synthase elements opened the door for a renaissance of structure-based target identification and inhibitor design. In this study, we present the GaMF1.39 antimycobacterial compound, targeting the rotary subunit γ of the biological engine. The compound is bactericidal, inhibits infection ex vivo, and displays enhanced anti-tuberculosis activity in combination with ETC inhibitors, which promises new strategies to shorten tuberculosis chemotherapy.

Atomic insights of an up and down conformation of the Acinetobacter baumannii F1 -ATPase subunit ε and deciphering the residues critical for ATP hydrolysis inhibition and ATP synthesis

The Acinetobacter baumannii F1 FO -ATP synthase (α3 :β3 :γ:δ:ε:a:b2 :c10 ), which is essential for this strictly respiratory opportunistic human pathogen, is incapable of ATP-driven proton translocation due to its latent ATPase activity. Here, we generated and purified the first recombinant A. baumannii F1 -ATPase (AbF1 -ATPase) composed of subunits α3 :β3 :γ:ε, showing latent ATP hydrolysis. A 3.0 Å cryo-electron microscopy structure visualizes the architecture and regulatory element of this enzyme, in which the C-terminal domain of subunit ε (Abε) is present in an extended position. An ε-free AbF1 -ɑβγ complex generated showed a 21.5-fold ATP hydrolysis increase, demonstrating that Abε is the major regulator of AbF1 -ATPase's latent ATP hydrolysis. The recombinant system enabled mutational studies of single amino acid substitutions within Abε or its interacting subunits β and γ, respectively, as well as C-terminal truncated mutants of Abε, providing a detailed picture of Abε's main element for the self-inhibition mechanism of ATP hydrolysis. Using a heterologous expression system, the importance of Abε's C-terminus in ATP synthesis of inverted membrane vesicles, including AbF1 FO -ATP synthases, has been explored. In addition, we are presenting the first NMR solution structure of the compact form of Abε, revealing interaction of its N-terminal β-barrel and C-terminal ɑ-hairpin domain. A double mutant of Abε highlights critical residues for Abε's domain-domain formation which is important also for AbF1 -ATPase's stability. Abε does not bind MgATP, which is described to regulate the up and down movements in other bacterial counterparts. The data are compared to regulatory elements of F1 -ATPases in bacteria, chloroplasts, and mitochondria to prevent wasting of ATP.

Cryo-EM structure of the Mycobacterium abscessus F1-ATPase

The cases of lung disease caused by non-tuberculous mycobacterium Mycobacterium abscessus (Mab) are increasing and not reliably curable. Repurposing of anti-tuberculosis inhibitors brought the oxidative phosphorylation pathway with its final product ATP, formed by the essential F₁F_O-ATP synthase (subunits α₃:β₃:γ:δ:ε:a:b:b':c₉), into focus as an attractive inhibitor target against Mab. Because of the pharmacological attractiveness of this enzyme, we generated and purified a recombinant and enzymatically active Mab F₁-ATPase complex, including subunits α₃:β₃:γ:δ:ε (MabF₁-αβγδε) to achieve mechanistic, regulatory, and structural insights. The high purity of the complex enabled the first cryo-electron microscopy structure determination of the Mab F₁-ATPase complex to 7.3 Å resolution. The enzyme showed low ATP hydrolysis activity, which was stimulated by trypsin treatment. No effect was observed in the presence of the detergent lauryldimethylamine oxide.

F1·Fo ATP Synthase/ATPase: Contemporary View on Unidirectional Catalysis

F1·Fo-ATP synthases/ATPases (F1·Fo) are molecular machines that couple either ATP synthesis from ADP and phosphate or ATP hydrolysis to the consumption or production of a transmembrane electrochemical gradient of protons. Currently, in view of the spread of drug-resistant disease-causing strains, there is an increasing interest in F1·Fo as new targets for antimicrobial drugs, in particular, anti-tuberculosis drugs, and inhibitors of these membrane proteins are being considered in this capacity. However, the specific drug search is hampered by the complex mechanism of regulation of F1·Fo in bacteria, in particular, in mycobacteria: the enzyme efficiently synthesizes ATP, but is not capable of ATP hydrolysis. In this review, we consider the current state of the problem of “unidirectional” F1·Fo catalysis found in a wide range of bacterial F1·Fo and enzymes from other organisms, the understanding of which will be useful for developing a strategy for the search for new drugs that selectively disrupt the energy production of bacterial cells.

Structural Elements Involved in ATP Hydrolysis Inhibition and ATP Synthesis of Tuberculosis and Nontuberculous Mycobacterial F-ATP Synthase Decipher New Targets for Inhibitors

The F₁F_O-ATP synthase is required for the viability of tuberculosis (TB) and nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) and has been validated as a drug target. Here, we present the cryo-EM structures of the Mycobacterium smegmatis F₁-ATPase and the F₁F_O-ATP synthase with different nucleotide occupation within the catalytic sites and visualize critical elements for latent ATP hydrolysis and efficient ATP synthesis. Mutational studies reveal that the extended C-terminal domain (αCTD) of subunit α is the main element for the self-inhibition mechanism of ATP hydrolysis for TB and NTM bacteria. Rotational studies indicate that the transition between the inhibition state by the αCTD and the active state is a rapid process. We demonstrate that the unique mycobacterial γ-loop and subunit δ are critical elements required for ATP formation. The data underline that these mycobacterium-specific elements of α, γ, and δ are attractive targets, providing a platform for the discovery of species-specific inhibitors.

Atomic solution structure of Mycobacterium abscessus F-ATP synthase subunit ε and identification of Ep1MabF1 as a targeted inhibitor

Mycobacterium abscessus (Mab) is a nontuberculous mycobacterium of increasing clinical relevance. The rapidly growing opportunistic pathogen is intrinsically multi-drug-resistant and causes difficult-to-cure lung disease. Adenosine triphosphate, generated by the essential F1 FO ATP synthase, is the major energy currency of the pathogen, bringing this enzyme complex into focus for the discovery of novel antimycobacterial compounds. Coupling of proton translocation through the membrane-embedded FO sector and ATP formation in the F1 headpiece of the bipartite F1 FO ATP synthase occurs via the central stalk subunits γ and ε. Here, we used solution NMR spectroscopy to resolve the first atomic structure of the Mab subunit ε (Mabε), showing that it consists of an N-terminal β-barrel domain (NTD) and a helix-loop-helix motif in its C-terminal domain (CTD). NMR relaxation measurements of Mabε shed light on dynamic epitopes and amino acids relevant for coupling processes within the protein. We describe structural differences between other mycobacterial ε subunits and Mabε's lack of ATP binding. Based on the structural insights, we conducted an in silico inhibitor screen. One hit, Ep1MabF1, was shown to inhibit the growth of Mab and bacterial ATP synthesis. NMR titration experiments and docking studies described the binding epitopes of Ep1MabF1 on Mabε. Together, our data demonstrate the potential to develop inhibitors targeting the ε subunit of Mab F1 FO ATP synthase to interrupt the coupling process.

Mutational Analysis of Mycobacterial F-ATP Synthase Subunit δ Leads to a Potent δ Enzyme Inhibitor

While many bacteria are able to bypass the requirement for oxidative phosphorylation when grown on carbohydrates, Mycobacterium tuberculosis is unable to do so. Differences of amino acid composition and structural features of the mycobacterial F-ATP synthase (α₃:β₃:γ:δ:ε:a:b:b':c₉) compared to its prokaryotic or human counterparts were recently elucidated and paved avenues for the discovery of molecules interfering with various regulative mechanisms of this essential energy converter. In this context, the mycobacterial peripheral stalk subunit δ came into focus, which displays a unique N-terminal 111-amino acid extension. Here, mutants of recombinant mycobacterial subunit δ were characterized, revealing significant reduction in ATP synthesis and demonstrating essentiality of this subunit for effective catalysis. These results provided the basis for the generation of a four-feature model forming a δ receptor-based pharmacophore and to identify a potent subunit δ inhibitor DeMF1 via in silico screening. The successful targeting of the δ subunit demonstrates the potential to advance δ's flexible coupling as a new area for the development of F-ATP synthase inhibitors.

Bacterial F-type ATP synthases follow a well-choreographed assembly pathway

F-type ATP synthases are multiprotein complexes composed of two separate coupled motors (F₁ and F_O) generating adenosine triphosphate (ATP) as the universal major energy source in a variety of relevant biological processes in mitochondria, bacteria and chloroplasts. While the structure of many ATPases is solved today, the precise assembly pathway of F₁F_O-ATP synthases is still largely unclear. Here, we probe the assembly of the F₁ complex from Acetobacterium woodii. Using laser induced liquid bead ion desorption (LILBID) mass spectrometry, we study the self-assembly of purified F₁ subunits in different environments under non-denaturing conditions. We report assembly requirements and identify important assembly intermediates in vitro and in cellula. Our data provide evidence that nucleotide binding is crucial for in vitro F₁ assembly, whereas ATP hydrolysis appears to be less critical. We correlate our results with activity measurements and propose a model for the assembly pathway of a functional F₁ complex.

ATPases are the macromolecular machines for cellular energy production. Here the authors investigate factors that govern the assembly of the F₁ complex from a bacterial F-type ATPase and relate differences in activity of complexes assembled in cells and in vitro to structural changes.

Targeting Mycobacterial F-ATP Synthase C-Terminal α Subunit Interaction Motif on Rotary Subunit γ

Mycobacteria regulate their energy (ATP) levels to sustain their survival even in stringent living conditions. Recent studies have shown that mycobacteria not only slow down their respiratory rate but also block ATP hydrolysis of the F-ATP synthase (α₃:β₃:γ:δ:ε:a:b:b’:c₉) to maintain ATP homeostasis in situations not amenable for growth. The mycobacteria-specific α C-terminus (α533-545) has unraveled to be the major regulative of latent ATP hydrolysis. Its deletion stimulates ATPase activity while reducing ATP synthesis. In one of the six rotational states of F-ATP synthase, α533-545 has been visualized to dock deep into subunit γ, thereby blocking rotation of γ within the engine. The functional role(s) of this C-terminus in the other rotational states are not clarified yet and are being still pursued in structural studies. Based on the interaction pattern of the docked α533-545 region with subunit γ, we attempted to study the druggability of the α533-545 motif. In this direction, our computational work has led to the development of an eight-featured α533-545 peptide pharmacophore, followed by database screening, molecular docking, and pose selection, resulting in eleven hit molecules. ATP synthesis inhibition assays using recombinant ATP synthase as well as mycobacterial inverted membrane vesicles show that one of the hits, AlMF1, inhibited the mycobacterial F-ATP synthase in a micromolar range. The successful targeting of the α533-545-γ interaction motif demonstrates the potential to develop inhibitors targeting the α site to interrupt rotary coupling with ATP synthesis.

Structure of the ATP synthase from Mycobacterium smegmatis provides targets for treating tuberculosis

The structure has been determined by electron cryomicroscopy of the adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthase from Mycobacterium smegmatis This analysis confirms features in a prior description of the structure of the enzyme, but it also describes other highly significant attributes not recognized before that are crucial for understanding the mechanism and regulation of the mycobacterial enzyme. First, we resolved not only the three main states in the catalytic cycle described before but also eight substates that portray structural and mechanistic changes occurring during a 360° catalytic cycle. Second, a mechanism of auto-inhibition of ATP hydrolysis involves not only the engagement of the C-terminal region of an α-subunit in a loop in the γ-subunit, as proposed before, but also a "fail-safe" mechanism involving the b'-subunit in the peripheral stalk that enhances engagement. A third unreported characteristic is that the fused bδ-subunit contains a duplicated domain in its N-terminal region where the two copies of the domain participate in similar modes of attachment of the two of three N-terminal regions of the α-subunits. The auto-inhibitory plus the associated "fail-safe" mechanisms and the modes of attachment of the α-subunits provide targets for development of innovative antitubercular drugs. The structure also provides support for an observation made in the bovine ATP synthase that the transmembrane proton-motive force that provides the energy to drive the rotary mechanism is delivered directly and tangentially to the rotor via a Grotthuss water chain in a polar L-shaped tunnel.

The Unique C-Terminal Extension of Mycobacterial F-ATP Synthase Subunit α Is the Major Contributor to Its Latent ATP Hydrolysis Activity

Mycobacterial F₁F_o-ATP synthases (α₃:β₃:γ:δ:ε:a:b:b':c₉ ) are incapable of ATP-driven proton translocation due to their latent ATPase activity. This prevents wasting of ATP and altering of the proton motive force, whose dissipation is lethal to mycobacteria. We demonstrate that the mycobacterial C-terminal extension of nucleotide-binding subunit α contributes mainly to the suppression of ATPase activity in the recombinant mycobacterial F₁-ATPase. Using C-terminal deletion mutants, the regions responsible for the enzyme's latency were mapped, providing a new compound epitope.