Cyclosporin A in the treatment of severe acute aplastic anaemia

Cyclosporine monotherapy for severe aplastic anemia: a developing country experience

BACKGROUND

Immunosuppression is the most effective treatment for aplastic anemia after hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Although the combination of cyclosporine and antithymocyte globulin (ATG) is superior to either agent alone, cyclosporine monotherapy is an easily available, safe and cheap immunosuppressive therapy (IST) option. These advantages are particularly valuable in developing countries where ATG is frequently not available.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In the referral hematology center in Yemen, 20 patients (16 males and 4 females) with severe aplastic anemia (SAA) were prospectively identified and managed with cyclosporine monotherapy during the period between April 2001 and November 2004.

RESULTS

Data from 14 patients who received cyclosporine for at least 3 months were analyzed. At 6 months, 2 (14.3%) patients achieved complete remission (CR) and 5 (35.7%) patients achieved partial remission (PR) and at 1 year, 4 (28.6%) patients achieved CR and 3 (21.4%) patients remained in PR. The overall response rate was 50% and the cumulative survival rate at 1 year was 78.6%. The median time to remission was 120 days (range, 46 to 131 days). Side effects were modest and easily monitored.

CONCLUSION

Our results support findings that cyclosporine monotherapy is an effective and safe immunosuppressive therapy for SAA, and that it could be a reasonable IST option for patients in developing countries.

Clinical aspects of aplastic anemia

Severe aplastic anemia is a disorder characterized by peripheral pancytopenia and marrow hypoplasia. Although its pathophysiology is understood poorly, the majority of patients appear to have some immunologic destruction or suppression of hematopoietic cells. The only curative therapy to date is allogeneic stem cell transplantation, although the success of palliative immunosuppressive therapies has improved over the last two decades. Making the best therapy choice is complex and often requires balancing very divergent toxicity profiles, both acute and long-term.

Cyclosporin A in aplastic anemia--report of a workshop

The management of aplastic anemia continues to challenge clinical investigators. With bone marrow transplantation or immunosuppression the prognosis of the patient with aplastic anemia has improved remarkably. For patients who are not eligible for bone marrow transplantation, antilymphocyte globulin has become the standard treatment. There is growing evidence that some patients also respond to immunosuppression with cyclosporin A. Further data suggest that combination of cyclosporin A with antilymphocyte globulin or androgens might be beneficial. An international workshop summarized the data on cyclosporin A treatment in aplastic anemia and attempted to create guidelines for the use of cyclosporin A in the management of aplastic anemia.

Aplastic anaemia: pathogenetic mechanisms and treatment with special reference to immunomodulation

Aplastic anaemia (AA) has been defined as a syndrome in which the presence of pancytopenia is accompanied by marrow hypocellularity. Ample laboratory data and clinical observations continue to make immune mediation of bone-marrow failure an attractive hypothesis. Recent progress in the practice of bone-marrow transplantation has led to a survival rate of approximately 80% in the best cases, but such a treatment is only amenable in young patients (less than 45-50 years) with HLA-identical bone-marrow donors. Anti-lymphocyte and thymocyte globulin treatment has been surprisingly effective for AA, resulting in transfusion independence in 40-80% of patients. The mechanism of action is unknown, although effects on immunosuppression appear to be the most likely candidates. Long-term results for patients receiving cyclosporin A treatment will soon be available, and preliminary data show an effect similar to that of antithymocyte globulin. In contrast to successful bone-marrow transplantation, improvement following immunomodulation leaves quantitative abnormalities in all haematopoietic cell lines, and patients are prone to develop clonal (malignant) disease.

Treatment of aplastic anaemia with antilymphocyte globulin and high-dose methylprednisolone

Twenty-three consecutive adults with bone marrow aplasia who, apart from one individual, lacked a sibling suitable for allogeneic transplantation, received five daily infusions of 50 mg/kg of antilymphocyte globulin (ALG) concurrently with high-dose (500 mg) methylprednisolone (HDMP), followed by oral prednisone at a dose of 30 mg until day 30. One patient died early so that response could not be determined, but data are available and included in the toxicity as well as survival analysis. Haematological response occurred in 13 of the remaining 22 (59%). This followed a single course of treatment in 12, with complete response achieved in five of this group and a second course required in one. At a median follow-up of 20 months (range 5-60), there have been five relapses and 13 patients are alive, including 12 responders who have Karnofsky ratings between 90% and 100%. Of the other nine individuals, only two are alive, with 1 at 12 months still requiring active support and the second, after failing further courses of treatment, at 41 months having a partial response to lymphocytapheresis and plasma exchange. Failure to respond was a significant adverse predictor for survival (P = 0.022). This study involved two distinct batches of ALG, with response occurring in 1/7 (14%) patients treated with the first lot, but in 12/15 (80%) of those individuals who were treated with the second (P = 0.007). Only a pretreatment mean cell volume (MCV) greater than 100 fL predicted for response (P = 0.0088). Confirmation is hereby provided for the efficacy of ALG used in combination with HDMP for treatment of aplastic anaemia, with further support for the observation that not all batches of this product are comparable in bringing about haematologic response in these individuals.

Therapy of aplastic anemia with sequential antithymocyte globulin and cyclosporin

Five consecutive patients with severe aplastic anemia were treated with antithymocyte globulin followed by cyclosporin A. All received antithymocyte globulin initially, and because of lack of response within a 4 week period, cyclosporin was administered subsequently. Hematologic improvement occurred within four months of initiation of cyclosporin. Four patients no longer require blood product support, while one remains transfusion-dependent. In two patients, thrombocytopenia developed when the cyclosporin was tapered but re-institution of the drug resulted in a prompt improvement of counts. These observations indicate that the sequential use of antithymocyte globulin and cyclosporin may be an effective therapeutic approach in the treatment of severe aplastic anemia.

Multiple responses of aplastic anemia to low-dose cyclosporine therapy despite development of a myelodysplastic syndrome

A 55-year-old white woman presented in July 1984 with severe aplastic anemia refractory to anti-thymocyte globulin, corticosteroids, and danazol. In December 1984, oral cyclosporine therapy was begun, and a partial remission was achieved with persistent thrombocytopenia and transfusion independence. The cyclosporine dosage was tapered and then stopped in May 1986 when the platelet count was 35,000/L. In October 1986 the platelet count was only 16,000/L, and the bone marrow showed evidence of a myelodysplastic syndrome; cytogenetic analysis revealed deletion of the long arm of chromosome 13 (previous cytogenetic findings had been normal). After cyclosporine therapy was resumed, platelet count promptly increased to 36,000/L. A subsequent attempt to taper the cyclosporine dosage resulted in a decreased platelet count. The platelet count responded to cyclosporine again and was maintained at 54,000/L and higher with cyclosporine therapy at only 25 mg/day. This information suggests that, despite the development of a myelodysplastic syndrome, immune mechanisms were still operative in the pathogenesis of our patient's thrombocytopenia. Immune modulation may have an important role in preventing progression of myelodysplastic syndromes to more severe forms or to acute leukemia.

Oral cyclosporin-A is effective treatment for untreated and also for previously immunosuppressed patients with severe bone marrow failure

16 patients with transfusion-dependent, life-threatening bone marrow failure (14 with severe aplastic anaemia, 1 with systemic lupus erythematosus and 1 with pure red cell aplasia) were treated with cyclosporin-A (Cy-A) after either lack of response to conventional immunosuppression with antithymocyte-globulin/high-dose methylprednisolone for 95 to 1190 days (median 186.5) (group I, 8 patients) or as a primary treatment due to ineligibility for conventional immunosuppression (group II, 8 pat.). Cyclosporin-A was given orally to maintain trough levels of 200 to 300 ng/ml (RIA). In group I, 6 out of 8 patients responded 30 to 480 d (median 53) and are currently alive 627 to 1482 d (median 731) after initiation of Cy-A, respectively. In 3 of the responders Cy-A has been withdrawn, without relapse. In group II, 5 of 8 patients responded 26 to 170 d (median 63) and are currently alive 142 to 697 (median 420) d following initiation of Cy-A, respectively. These data indicate a place for cyclosporin-A in the management of patients with life-threatening bone marrow failure in whom a) immunosuppressive therapy with antithymocyte-globulin and high-dose methylprednisolone had failed and b) who are not candidates for vigorous immunosuppression or bone marrow transplantation, for medical or other reasons.

Cyclosporine therapy of aplastic anaemia, congenital and acquired red cell aplasia

We treated 22 patients with severe aplastic anaemia refractory to antithymocyte globulin (ATG) with cyclosporine, alone or in combination with prednisone. Eight patients showed significant clinical improvement, all but one to transfusion-independence. Although cyclosporine alone was effective, the addition of prednisone resulted in prompter and fuller haematologic improvement. No patient with an absolute granulocyte count less than 0.2 x 10(9)/l responded to treatment. Haematologic remissions were sustained beyond the treatment period. Of nine patients with Diamond-Blackfan syndrome, one showed a complete response to two separate courses of cyclosporine and relapse with withdrawal of therapy, and a second achieved significant reduction in corticosteroid dose without relapse; however, seven cases failed to respond. Two of three adults with acquired pure red cell aplasia recovered. A combination of cyclosporine and corticosteroids may be effective therapy in patients with aplastic anaemia who have failed ATG treatment. Occasional cases of congenital and acquired pure red cell aplasia may also respond to cyclosporine.

Treatment of pure red-cell aplasia and aplastic anaemia with ciclosporin: long-term clinical effects

6 patients with pure red-cell aplasia were treated with Ciclosporin (Cyclosporine A; CS) alone or combined with prednisolone for a period of 9-46 (median 27) months. Prior to study, 5 cases had refractory disease, steroids were contraindicated in 1, and 4/6 patients, including 2 cases with congenital disease, had a disease duration exceeding 11 years. A complete haematological response was obtained in 5/6 subjects, and a partial response in 1. When the pre-treatment Hb levels (mean +/- S.D. = 64 +/- 13 g/l, range 41-80) for all 6 PRCA patients were compared with the Hb levels after 6 months of CS therapy (104 +/- 17 g/l, 80-125), a significant improvement was registered (p less than 0.005). In half of the patients, remission is maintained with CS as single drug in a dose-dependent manner. We also treated 5 patients with refractory severe aplastic anaemia with CS (1 case) or CS plus prednisolone (4 cases) for 3-27 (median 10) months. Only 1 patient responded. In this case, a complete haematological remission was induced with CS alone, and remission has been maintained for 27 months. Side effects of CS therapy were common but were dose-dependent and reversible, with the exception of persistent nephrotoxicity in 1 patient with pure red-cell aplasia. Based on our present results and a survey of the literature, we conclude that CS therapy is effective and indicated in refractory pure red-cell aplasia. In severe aplastic anaemia resistant to conventional immunosuppression, the response rate is lower, but a small proportion (around 15%) of patients may benefit from CS therapy. Longer treatment periods may, however, be needed to evaluate the role of CS in aplastic anaemia.

Immunomodulation therapy for severe aplastic anemia--ALG versus ALG plus cyclosporin A

Immunosuppressive treatment of aplastic anemia has been increasingly used as an alternative treatment to bone marrow transplantation. In this study, the additive effect of Cyclosporin A (CSA) (5mg/kg/day, at least 3 months) for maintenance of immunosuppression after antilymphocyte globulin (ALG) therapy (40mg/kg/day for 4 days) was compared to the previous ALG alone treatment (15mg/kg/day for 10 days). A high dose of methylprednisolone (20mg/kg/day for 5 days and 10mg/kg/day for 5 days) to the ALG group and a low dose of methylprednisolone (2mg/kg/day for 5 days) to the ALG plus CSA group were administered simultaneously. The results were as follows: 1) Sixteen (69.6%) out of twenty-three patients treated with ALG plus Cyclosporin A showed higher responses (CR: 48%, PR: 22%). On the contrary, nine out of nineteen in the ALG group showed lower responses (CR: 21%, PR: 26%). 2) Our data showed a tendency that male patients in age ranging from sixteen to thirty years showed an excellent response to ALG therapy (12/23: 52.2%). 3) The ALG plus CSA group revealed a faster response compared to the ALG alone group (15/16 within 6 months). 4) We speculate that ALG plus CSA therapy might be the treatment of choice for patients with a moderate degree of aplastic anemia. 5) Adding CSA to ALG increased the chance of infection, such as those with URI-like symptoms, but it did not affect the mortality rate. Our data suggest that the ALG plus CSA regimen may be a more useful therapeutic modality for patients with severe aplastic anemia who cannot be candidates for bone marrow transplantation and a randomized multicenter study is needed for confirmation of our preliminary study.

Cyclosporin A for the treatment of aplastic anemia refractory to antithymocyte globulin

Antithymocyte globulin (ATG) is an established form of therapy for severe aplastic anemia (SAA). However, in patients who do not respond to this treatment and who are not candidates for bone marrow transplantation few successful therapeutic alternatives exist. We report two such patients who have shown a therapeutic response to Cyclosporin A (CSA) (Sandimmune, Sandoz). Case 1, a 15 year old male, and Case 2, a 34 year old female, were diagnosed as having SAA in September 1984 and May 1984 respectively. Treatment with high dose Methylprednisolone (MPN) and ATG in Case 1 and MPN, ATG and Oxymetholone in Case 2 for ten days was ineffective in both cases. Case 1 developed anaphylaxis with both repeat ATG and ALG (antilymphoblast globulin), and Case 2 failed to respond to repeat ATG. Both required frequent packed cells and platelet transfusions. At five and six months respectively following completion of ATG therapy, CSA was started at 10 mg/kg/day in divided doses orally. Renal and liver functions and CSA blood levels were followed. Within six weeks both patients exhibited a hematologic response and were no longer transfusion dependent. On maintenance therapy of 4 mg/kg/day (Case 1) and four months after discontinuing CSA (Case 2) the hematologic values are as follows: hemoglobin 160 and 130 g/L, absolute granulocyte count 3100 and 1640 X 10(9)/L, and platelets 132 and 84 X 10(9)/L respectively. Side effects included hypertrichosis, gingival hyperplasia and mild reversible nephrotoxicity. CSA appears to represent an effective form of therapy for patients with SAA refractory to ATG.

Cyclosporine A treatment in four cases of aplastic anemia

Cyclosporine A (CyA) treatment of 4 patients with severe aplastic anemia, who were ineligible for bone marrow transplantation, was carried out for periods of between 12 weeks to 20 months. A normalization of Hb and bone marrow, together with a marked improvement in WBC and platelet counts, were observed in only one of these four patients. The remission was maintained for 20 months under continuous treatment. A relapse occurred only when the patient himself interrupted treatment. No serious side effects were observed with CyA doses of 4-10 mg/kg/daily and blood concentrations of 200-400 ng/ml. No significant changes in T helper/T suppressor ratios were noted during the course of CyA treatment.

Treatment of aplastic anemia with cyclosporin A, methylprednisolone, and antithymocyte globulin

Twenty-three patients with aplastic anemia (18/23 with severe aplastic anemia) were treated with an immunosuppressive regimen consisting of cyclosporin A (CsA) and methylprednisolone (MP) (n = 7) or CsA, MP, and antithymocyte globulin (ATG; n = 16). Nineteen patients are alive with a follow-up of 4 to 25 months; three patients died of infections and one of a gastrointestinal hemorrhage. Within 3 months, improvement of hematopoiesis was seen in 14 patients (61%). First signs of a response after 23 to 88 days were followed by complete remission in eight patients, partial remission in three patients, and minimal improvement in three patients. Two of the patients with only minimal improvement were treated with a second course of immunosuppression and reached a complete remission and partial remission. Interestingly, remission proved to be dependent on the continued administration of CsA in four of five patients with partial or complete remission who could be evaluated up to now. Thus, CsA must have been effective in the induction and/or maintenance of remission in three patients. This observation is a very strong argument for the role of T cells in the pathogenesis of at least some cases of aplastic anemia and warrants further evaluation of the role of CsA in the treatment of aplastic anemia.