The heterogeneity of human IgE exemplified by the passive transfer of D2O sensitivity

History of Histamine-Releasing Factor (HRF)/Translationally Controlled Tumor Protein (TCTP) Including a Potential Therapeutic Target in Asthma and Allergy

Histamine-releasing factor (HRF) also known as translationally controlled tumor protein (TCTP) is a highly conserved, ubiquitous protein that has both intracellular and extracellular functions. Here we will highlight the subcloning of the molecule, its clinical implications, as well as an inducible-transgenic mouse. Particular attention will be paid to its extracellular functioning and its potential role as a therapeutic target in asthma and allergy. The cells and the cytokines that are produced when stimulated or primed by HRF/TCTP will be detailed as well as the downstream signaling pathway that HRF/TCTP elicits. While it was originally thought that HRF/TCTP interacted with IgE, the finding that cells not binding IgE also respond to HRF/TCTP called this interaction into question. HRF/TCTP or at least its mouse counterpart appears to interact with some, but not all IgE and IgG molecules. HRF/TCTP has been shown to activate multiple human cells including basophils, eosinophils, T cells, and B cells. Since many of the cells that are activated by HRF/TCTP participate in the allergic response, the extracellular functions of HRF/TCTP could exacerbate the allergic, inflammatory cascade. Particularly exciting is that small molecule agonists of the phosphatase SHIP-1 have been shown to modulate the P13 kinase/AKT pathway and may control inflammatory disorders. This review discusses this possibility in light of HRF/TCTP.

Potential role of histamine releasing factor (HRF) as a therapeutic target for treating asthma and allergy

Histamine releasing factor (HRF), also known as translationally controlled tumor protein (TCTP), is a highly conserved, ubiquitous protein that has both intracellular and extracellular functions. Here, we will highlight the history of the molecule, its clinical implications with a focus on its extracellular functioning, and its potential role as a therapeutic target in asthma and allergy. The cells and cytokines produced when stimulated or primed by HRF/TCTP are detailed as well as the downstream signaling pathway that HRF/TCTP elicits. While it was originally thought that HRF/TCTP interacted with IgE, the finding that cells not binding IgE also respond to HRF/TCTP called this interaction into question. HRF/TCTP, or at least its mouse counterpart, appears to interact with some, but not all IgE and IgG molecules. HRF/TCTP has been shown to activate multiple human cells including basophils, eosinophils, T cells, and B cells. Since many of the cells activated by HRF/TCTP participate in the allergic response, extracellular functions of HRF/TCTP may exacerbate the allergic, inflammatory cascade. Particularly exciting is that small molecule agonists of Src homology 2-containing inositol phosphatase-1 have been shown to modulate the phosphoinositide 3-kinase/AKT pathway and may control inflammatory disorders. This review discusses this possibility in light of HRF/TCTP.

Histamine-releasing factor/translationally controlled tumor protein (HRF/TCTP)-induced histamine release is enhanced with SHIP-1 knockdown in cultured human mast cell and basophil models

Previously, we demonstrated a negative correlation between histamine release to histamine-releasing factor/translationally controlled tumor protein (HRF/TCTP) and protein levels of SHIP-1 in human basophils. The present study was conducted to investigate whether suppressing SHIP-1 using small interfering (si)RNA technology would alter the releasability of culture-derived mast cells and basophils, as determined by HRF/TCTP histamine release. Frozen CD34+ cells were obtained from the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center (Seattle, WA, USA). Cells were grown in StemPro-34 medium containing cytokines: mast cells with IL-6 and stem cell factor (100 ng/ml each) for 6-8 weeks and basophils with IL-3 (6.7 ng/ml) for 2-3 weeks. siRNA transfections were performed during Week 6 for mast cells and Week 2 for basophils with siRNA for SHIP-1 or a negative control siRNA. Changes in SHIP-1 expression were determined by Western blot. The functional knockdown was measured by HRF/TCTP-induced histamine release. siRNA knockdown of SHIP-1 in mast cells ranged from 31% to 82%, mean 65 +/- 12%, compared with control (n=4). Histamine release to HRF/TCTP was increased only slightly in two experiments. SHIP-1 knockdown in basophils ranged from 34% to 69%, mean 51.8 +/- 7% (n=4). Histamine release to HRF/TCTP in these basophils was dependent on the amount of SHIP knockdown. Mast cells and basophils derived from CD34+ precursor cells represent suitable models for transfection studies. Reducing SHIP-1 protein in cultured mast cells and in cultured basophils increases releasability of the cells.

Human IgE+ and IgE- are not equivalent to mouse highly cytokinergic IgE

BACKGROUND

We have previously defined IgE+ as the IgE on basophils from a subset of highly allergic asthmatic subjects that release histamine after stimulation with histamine-releasing factor (HRF). The mechanism of IgE+ remains an enigma. Recently, there have been reports of monomeric highly cytokinergic IgEs causing mediator release, cytokine release, and phosphorylation events in cultured rodent and human mast cells in the absence of antigen.

OBJECTIVE

We investigated whether human IgE+ might exist as highly cytokinergic IgE in the human system.

METHODS

IgE+ was defined as causing greater than 10% histamine release by using HRF as a stimulus of human basophils. By definition, IgE- did not support histamine release to HRF. Once defined, serum and various purified human IgEs were used to stimulate purified human basophils or cultured human mast cells. The cells were examined for histamine release, extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) phosphorylation, and IL-13 secretion.

RESULTS

We found that neither IgE+ nor IgE- induced ERK phosphorylation, histamine release, and IL-13 release from freshly isolated basophils in the absence of a specific antigen. However, human IgE alone did stimulate ERK phosphorylation in cultured human mast cells and IL-3-primed human basophils.

CONCLUSION

Human IgE+ is not an equivalent of the mouse highly cytokinergic IgE. However, human IgE did have effects on cultured mast cells and basophils. The effect of highly cytokinergic IgE on ERK phosphorylation and cytokine secretion might be due to the priming effect of human basophils and mast cells.

Association of the Src homology 2 domain-containing inositol 5' phosphatase (SHIP) to releasability in human basophils

During the study of the biology of the Human recombinant Histamine Releasing Factor (HrHRF), we uncovered a hyperreleasable phenotype of basophils from HrHRF-responder donors. Basophils from these donors released histamne to HrHRF, IL-3 and D(2)O. While there has been a significant amount of work elucidating signal transduction events in human basophils, the reason for this hyperreleasable phenotype remained illusive. A clue to the releasability of these highly allergic, asthmatic HrHRF-responder donor basophils was demonstrated in studies using SHIP knockout mice. Bone marrow-derived mast cells from the SHIP knockout mice demonstrated hyperreleasability to stimuli through the IgE receptor and alteration of subsequent signal transduction events. We have demonstrated a highly significant negative correlation between the amount of SHIP protein per cell equivalent and maximum histamine release to HrHRF. These results provide a clue to the hyperreleasable phenotype and implicate SHIP as an additional regulator of secretion in human basophils.

Src homology 2 domain-containing inositol 5' phosphatase is negatively associated with histamine release to human recombinant histamine-releasing factor in human basophils

BACKGROUND

The human recombinant histamine-releasing factor (HrHRF) acts as a complete stimulus for histamine release and IL-4 secretion from a subpopulation of highly allergic donor basophils, termed IgE(+) basophils. Additionally, IgE(+) basophils release histamine to other secretogues, IL-3, and deuterium oxide. We hypothesized that IgE(+) basophils were hyperreleasable.

OBJECTIVE

Deficiencies in early signal transduction events associated with Fc(epsilon)RI lead to a nonreleasable phenotype, whereas the Src homology 2 domain--containing inositol 5' phosphatase (SHIP) knockout mice have hyperreleasable mast cells. The purpose of this study was to ascertain whether a difference in intracellular signaling molecules could explain the hyperreleasable phenotype of human IgE(+) basophils.

METHODS

Basophils were purified by means of double Percoll gradients and negative selection with magnetic beads. Cell lysates were Western blotted for the tyrosine kinases Lyn and Syk and the phosphatase SHIP. Additionally, histamine release to HrHRF was performed in addition to real-time RT-PCR to investigate mRNA for SHIP.

RESULTS

We show a striking negative correlation between the amount of SHIP protein per cell equivalent, but not Lyn or Syk, and maximum histamine release to HrHRF. This deficiency of SHIP was observed in basophils, but not lymphocytes or monocytes, of these IgE(+) donors. Additionally, levels of mRNA for SHIP did not differ between IgE(+) and IgE(-) donor basophils, which is consistent with a posttranscriptional mechanism of protein regulation. SHIP and phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase reciprocally regulate phosphatidylinositol (3,4,5) triphosphate levels. We also demonstrated that Ly294002, the phosphatidylinositol 3 kinase inhibitor, prevented HrHRF-induced histamine release in IgE(+) donor basophils.

CONCLUSION

Taken together, these data suggest that the hyperreleasability of IgE(+) donors is associated with low levels of SHIP and implicate SHIP as an additional regulator of secretion in human basophils.

Pharmacologic regulation of histamine release by the human recombinant histamine-releasing factor

BACKGROUND

The recently cloned human recombinant IgE-dependent histamine releasing factor (HrHRF) was initially thought to stimulate histamine release from human basophils from a subpopulation of allergic donors by interacting with the IgE molecules on the surface of these cells. Additional data suggest that HrHRF exerts its biologic effects by binding to a distinct cell surface structure and not to IgE.

OBJECTIVE

To address the hypothesis that the HrHRF signaling pathway is distinct from the classical high-affinity IgE receptor (FcepsilonRI) pathway, we used pharmacologic agents known to affect basophil histamine release.

METHODS

In this report we compared the effect of staurosporine, Bis II, Gö 6976, rottlerin, and pertussis toxin on histamine release from human basophils mediated by the following stimuli: HrHRF, polyclonal human anti-IgE antibody, and antigen, as well as the IgE-independent stimulus, FMLP.

RESULTS

None of these modulators, except rottlerin, could differentiate histamine release induced by anti-IgE or antigen from that induced by HrHRF. Rottlerin enhanced HrHRF-mediated histamine release and dose dependently blocked FMLP-mediated release without affecting basophil activation by either anti-IgE or antigen.

CONCLUSION

These data suggest a unique signaling pathway for HrHRF and thus strengthen the hypothesis that HrHRF binds to a specific receptor other than IgE.

The human recombinant histamine releasing factor: functional evidence that it does not bind to the IgE molecule

BACKGROUND

We have previously shown that the human recombinant histamine releasing factor (HrHRF) caused histamine release from a subset of basophils from donors with allergy, and this release seemed to be dependent on the presence of a certain type of IgE, termed IgE+. IgE molecules that did not support HrHRF-induced histamine release were termed IgE-. However, subsequently we demonstrated that HrHRF primes anti-IgE-antibody-induced histamine release from all basophils, irrespective of the type of IgE on the cell surface.

OBJECTIVE

Because these data suggested that HrHRF does not exert its biologic effects by binding to IgE, but rather that it interacted with a surface receptor on the basophil, we wanted to obtain functional evidence that HrHRF did or did not bind to the IgE molecule.

METHODS

The rat basophilic leukemia cell line (RBL-SX38), which has been transfected to express a functional human FcepsilonRI (alpha-, beta-, and gamma-chains of the receptor) in addition to the normal rat FcepsilonRI, was used. The presence of the human FcepsilonRI receptor enables these cells to be sensitized with human IgE. Cells were passively sensitized with 1000 ng/mL human IgE+ or 1000 ng/mL human IgE- for 60 minutes at 37 degrees C. Unsensitized cells served as a control. After the cells were washed, 1 x l0(5) cells were stimulated in the presence of 1 mmol/L Ca2+ with 0.1 microg/mL anti-IgE, 40 microg/mL HrHRF, or 40 microg/mL mouse recombinant HRF (MrHRF), which has 96% homology to HrHRF.

RESULTS

Mean anti-IgE-induced histamine release was 33% +/- 15%, and there was no difference between IgE+ sensitization (32% +/- 12%) and IgE- sensitization (34% +/- 18%). However, in contrast to human basophil experiments, neither HrHRF (0% +/- 0%) nor MrHRF (3% +/- 5%) caused histamine release in RBL cells sensitized with IgE+. In addition, priming the transfected RBL-SX38 cells or the parental cell line, RBL-2H3 cells, with HrHRF or MrHRF did not increase anti-IgE-induced histamine release.

CONCLUSION

The results indicate that HrHRF does not bind to IgE, either IgE+ or IgE-. Therefore it appears likely that rHRF signals through its own specific receptor, which is not expressed or functional on RBL-SX38 or RBL-2H3 cells, but which seems to be expressed on basophils of atopic and nonatopic donors.

Modulation of serum histamine releasing activity in chronic idiopathic urticaria

BACKGROUND

Sera of about 30% of patients with chronic idiopathic urticaria (CIU) have increased histamine releasing activity (HRA+) on normal basophils. It is not known whether other CIU sera would be HRA+ if a more sensitive histamine release assay was used. Although most HRA+ CIU sera appear to have anti Fc(epsilon)R1 activity, it is not known whether post-binding basophil intracellular events are similar to those after anti-IgE stimulation.

RESULTS

In the presence of D2O, the HR stimulated by 28 previously documented HRA- sera increased from 4+/-0.4 to 21+/-4% with 13 of the 28 sera now considered HRA+. No previous HRA sera was HRA+ with IL-3 treated cells. Histamine release induced by both HRA+ sera and anti-IgE were inhibited by genistein, and Ca2+/Mg2+ depletion but not by bisindoylmaleimide. HRA+ sera induced prominent HR from normal basophils with little surface IgE, but induced no increased HR from basophils unresponsive to anti-IgE.

CONCLUSIONS

Up to 61% of CIU sera will induce increased HR from normal basophils in a sufficiently sensitive assay system. HR induced by most HRA+ sera is more prominent in basophils with very little surface IgE. However, there may be similar post-binding intracellular activation pathways following stimulation by HRA+ sera and anti-IgE.

Nonspecific binding of IgE to allergens

Nonspecific IgE binding to allergens was observed in testing myeloma IgEs, namely, IgE-VL and IgE-PS, chimeric IgE (IgE-JW8), and the recombinant IgE Fc epsilon peptide CH1-CH4, in two different immunoassays. This binding was concentration-dependent but detectable only at higher IgE concentration. In RAST inhibition, IgE-allergen interactions could be reduced by using either matching or nonmatching allergens. In order to test whether the nonspecific binding of IgE to allergens was due to carbohydrate interaction, myeloma IgEs and the chimeric IgE were desialized with neuraminidase. Desialized samples were equally well recognized by xenogenic antibodies as native IgEs, but binding of IgE to Fc epsilon receptors on basophils was affected by the treatment, as shown in the histamine-release assay. Desialization of IgE affected also its binding capacity to allergens in RAST: binding of chimeric IgE was reduced, but nonspecific binding of myeloma IgE-VL was enhanced. Hence, nonspecific allergen-IgE binding may be partly due to a lectin-like interaction, but may depend mostly on the tertiary structure of IgE. Thus, nonspecific IgE-allergen interactions might present a problem 1) at high IgE concentration, and 2) depend on the grade of sialization of IgE, which might affect its conformation. This may explain why patients with elevated total IgE levels often have multiple weak positive RASTs with non-cross-reactive allergens.

Characteristics of histamine-releasing activity in the sera of patients with chronic idiopathic urticaria

BACKGROUND

The serum histamine-releasing activity (HRA) found in a sizable percentage of patients with chronic idiopathic urticaria (CIU) has been partially characterized. However, the variable effect of individual HRA+ sera in basophils of different donors and the relationship of HRA to the clinical course require further investigation.

OBJECTIVE

The study was performed to characterize the HRA found in sera of some members of a sizable group of carefully evaluated patients with CIU.

METHODS

Sera of 70 patients with CIU, evaluated with a standard protocol, were screened for increased HRA. HRA+ sera were fractionated, heated, and tested on unaltered and altered basophils obtained from a panel of normal donors. HRA levels were compared with concomitant clinical manifestations.

RESULTS

HRA+ sera were found in 30% of our patients with CIU, HRA was predominantly in the IgG fraction, sensitive to 56 degrees C heating for 4 hours, and generally reacted more with IgE-stripped basophils. Considerable variation in the degree of response to HRA+ sera in the basophils of different normal subjects did not correlate with the degree of response of these cells to heterologous anti-IgE antiserum. Serum HRA levels were generally much lower when symptoms decreased in these patients with CIU.

CONCLUSION

Serum HRA from patients with CIU appears to bind most commonly to the IgE receptor and may be a marker of clinical disease activity. HRA appears in an IgG-containing fraction of the serum and may contain IgE in some cases.

An immunoglobulin E-dependent recombinant histamine-releasing factor induces interleukin-4 secretion from human basophils

A novel recombinant histamine-releasing factor (rHFR), which stimulates secretion from a subpopulation of human basophils that express a particular type of immunoglobulin E (IgE) or IgE+, was found to induce interleukin-4 (IL-4) production from cells isolated from these same donors. The secretion of IL-4 protein induced by rHRF significantly correlated with histamine release and the amount of protein generated, and the kinetics were identical to those caused by anti-IgE activation. Furthermore, the ability of rHRF to induce IL-4 protein production from cells not normally responsive to this protein was transferred by passive sensitization with plasma containing IgE+ antibody. That this novel protein stimulates both mediator release and the secretion of IL-4 protein from human basophils suggests a prominent role for this molecule in allergic disease.

The determinants of airway hyperresponsiveness to hypertonic saline in atopic asthma in vivo. Relationship with sub-populations of peripheral blood leucocytes

In patients with asthma there is only a weak relationship between airway responsiveness to hypertonic saline and methacholine. We tested the hypothesis that airway responsiveness to hypertonic saline in asthma is related to the presence and activity of inflammatory cells in the peripheral blood. Nineteen atopic asthmatic adults (19-28 yr; PC20 0.06-12.4 mg/ml), not receiving steroid treatment, entered a metacholine and hypertonic saline period in random order. Dose-response curves to doubling doses of inhaled methacholine (0.03-256 mg/ml) or hypertonic saline (0.9-14.4% NaCl) were obtained twice in each period, 7 days apart. The response was measured by FEV1. Methacholine responsiveness was measured by PC20 METH of FEV1 and responsiveness to hypertonic saline was expressed as the percentage fall in FEV1 after 14.4% NaCl (HYP14.4%). Peripheral blood was collected before the second challenge test of each period. Apart from leucocyte counts and serum eosinophilic cationic protein (ECP) level, sub-sets of lymphocytes (CD4+/CD3+, CD8+/CD3+, CD25+/CD4+ and VLA-1+/CD4+) were determined using flow cytometry. HYP14.4% was positively correlated to basophil, eosinophil and monocyte counts (r = 0.64, 0.54 and 0.44, respectively; P < 0.05). The basophil count remained positively related to HYP14.4% when PC20METH or FEV1%pred were entered in multiple linear regression analyses (r = 0.66 and 0.75, respectively; P < 0.05). There were no significant relationships between HYP14.4% or PC20METH on one side and ECP level or T-lymphocyte subsets on the other (P > 0.05). We conclude that airway responsiveness to hypertonic saline is positively related to the number of peripheral blood basophils, eosinophils and monocytes. Basophil count is an independent correlate of responsiveness to hypertonic saline, after correction for methacholine responsiveness and baseline lung function. This fits in with active involvement of basophils in airway narrowing to hypertonic saline in vivo.