Serum-induced suppression of interferon (IFN) activity. Lack of evidence for the presence of specific autoantibodies to IFN-alpha in normal human sera

Interferon system deficiencies exacerbating severe pandemic virus infections

Pandemics are caused by novel pathogens to which pre-existing antibody immunity is lacking. Under these circumstances, the body must rely on innate interferon-mediated defenses to limit pathogen replication and allow development of critical humoral protection. Here, we highlight studies on disease susceptibility during H1N1 influenza and COVID-19 (SARS-CoV-2) pandemics. An emerging concept is that genetic and non-genetic deficiencies in interferon system components lead to uncontrolled virus replication and severe illness in a subset of people. Intriguingly, new findings suggest that individuals with autoantibodies neutralizing the antiviral function of interferon are at increased risk of severe COVID-19. We discuss key questions surrounding how such autoantibodies develop and function, as well as the general implications of diagnosing interferon deficiencies for personalized therapies.

Improving Adaptive and Memory Immune Responses of an HIV/AIDS Vaccine Candidate MVA-B by Deletion of Vaccinia Virus Genes (C6L and K7R) Blocking Interferon Signaling Pathways

Poxvirus vector Modified Vaccinia Virus Ankara (MVA) expressing HIV-1 Env, Gag, Pol and Nef antigens from clade B (termed MVA-B) is a promising HIV/AIDS vaccine candidate, as confirmed from results obtained in a prophylactic phase I clinical trial in humans. To improve the immunogenicity elicited by MVA-B, we have generated and characterized the innate immune sensing and the in vivo immunogenicity profile of a vector with a double deletion in two vaccinia virus (VACV) genes (C6L and K7R) coding for inhibitors of interferon (IFN) signaling pathways. The innate immune signals elicited by MVA-B deletion mutants (MVA-B ΔC6L and MVA-B ΔC6L/K7R) in human macrophages and monocyte-derived dendritic cells (moDCs) showed an up-regulation of the expression of IFN-β, IFN-α/β-inducible genes, TNF-α, and other cytokines and chemokines. A DNA prime/MVA boost immunization protocol in mice revealed that these MVA-B deletion mutants were able to improve the magnitude and quality of HIV-1-specific CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T cell adaptive and memory immune responses, which were mostly mediated by CD8⁺ T cells of an effector phenotype, with MVA-B ΔC6L/K7R being the most immunogenic virus recombinant. CD4⁺ T cell responses were mainly directed against Env, while GPN-specific CD8⁺ T cell responses were induced preferentially by the MVA-B deletion mutants. Furthermore, antibody levels to Env in the memory phase were slightly enhanced by the MVA-B deletion mutants compared to the parental MVA-B. These findings revealed that double deletion of VACV genes that act blocking intracellularly the IFN signaling pathway confers an immunological benefit, inducing innate immune responses and increases in the magnitude, quality and durability of the HIV-1-specific T cell immune responses. Our observations highlighted the immunomodulatory role of the VACV genes C6L and K7R, and that targeting common pathways, like IRF3/IFN-β signaling, could be a general strategy to improve the immunogenicity of poxvirus-based vaccine candidates.

Anti-cytokine autoantibodies in autoimmune diseases

An overview of the current literature is showing that autoantibodies (AutoAbs) against cytokines are produced in several pathological conditions, including autoimmune diseases, but can also be detected in healthy individuals. In autoimmune diseases, these AutoAbs may also be prognostic markers, either negative (such as AutoAbs to IL-8 and IL-1α in rheumatoid arthritis) or positive (such as AutoAbs to IL-6 in systemic sclerosis and those to osteopontin in rheumatoid arthritis). They may have neutralizing activity and influence the course of the physiological and pathological immune responses. High levels of AutoAbs against cytokines may even lead to immunodeficiency, such as those to IL-17 in autoimmune polyendocrine syndrome type I or those to IFN-γ in mycobacterial infections. Their role in human therapy may be exploited not only through passive immunization but also through vaccination, which may improve the costs for long lasting treatments of autoimmune diseases. Detection and quantification of these AutoAbs can be profoundly influenced by the technique used and standardization of these methods is needed to increase the value of their analysis.

Vaccination with IL-6 analogues induces autoantibodies to IL-6 and influences experimentally induced inflammation

IL-6 is involved in inflammation and a therapeutic target. 0.1% of Danish blood donors have nanomolar plasma concentrations of polyclonal, picomolar affinity and in vitro as well as in vivo neutralizing IgG autoantibodies to IL-6 (aAb-IL-6). Such donors are assumed to be severely IL-6 deficient; yet they appear healthy and do not exhibit overt clinical or laboratory abnormalities. We induced comparable levels of aAb-IL-6 in different mouse strains by vaccination with immunogenic IL-6 analogues. We observed that the induced aAb-IL-6 protected against collagen-induced arthritis and experimental allergic encephalitis. Furthermore, aAb-IL-6 carrying mice displayed increased plasma TNFalpha concentrations upon challenge with LPS. Taken together, induction of IL-6 autoantibodies was possible in different mouse strains. The autoantibodies influenced experimental inflammation. This immunotherapeutic principle might be a viable alternative in immune competent humans suffering from disorders driven by IL-6.

IFN-alpha antibodies in patients with age-related macular degeneration treated with recombinant human IFN-alpha2a

We tested for development of binding and neutralizing antibodies to interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha) during IFN-alpha2a therapy of patients with age-related macular degeneration (AMD) of the eyes. Antibodies were investigated retrospectively in sera of 34 patients treated with 3 x 10(6) IU IFN-alpha2a (Roceron-A), Hoffmann La-Roche, Basel, Switzerland) three times weekly for periods of 8-16 weeks with or without a drug-free 4-12-week intermission. Additionally, 10 patients were investigated prospectively; 7 received 1.5-6 x 10(6) IU IFN-alpha2a three times weekly for 12 months, and 3 received placebo. Binding antibodies were tested by molecular size and protein G affinity chromatography using 125I-IFN-alpha2a. Neutralizing activities were tested by antiviral neutralization bioassay. IgG antibodies were detected in 24 of 34 IFN-alpha2a-treated patients (71%). Significantly higher anti-IFN-alpha levels were observed in patients who after discontinuation were readministered IFN-alpha2a (p < 0.02). Three of the IFN-alpha2a-treated patients in the prospective study had high and 1 had low antibody titers. Neutralizing antibody titers were high against IFN-alpha2a and IFN-alpha2c and low against lymphoblastoid and leukocyte IFN-alpha. Impaired clinical responses were observed in antibody-positive patients (p < 0.01). The development of neutralizing anti-IFN-alpha antibodies in patients with AMD during recombinant human IFN-alpha therapy may explain the often poor clinical effect of IFN-alpha treatment.

Natural and therapeutically-induced antibodies to cytokines

Serum samples obtained from non-immunocompromised patients treated therapeutically with recombinant cytokines (e.g. Il-1alpha; Il-1beta; Il-2 to Il-18; IFNalpha; GM-CSF; G-CSF; etc.) often reveal the presence of high affinity anti-cytokine antibodies. Antibody Fab binding in a saturable manner by ELISA and RIA or western immunoblotting prove their specificity. Antibody level often increases in these patients with repeated cytokine administration, suggesting boosts of antigen stimulation. However, the appearance in circulation of auto-antibodies to exogenous cytokine is not always associated with a decreased clinical response to therapy. The demonstration that non-neutralizing auto-antibodies to several natural cytokines can be found even in sera of normal healthy individuals never treated before with cytokines and particularly during the last trimester of pregnancy and in cord-blood, suggests that these naturally- occurring and therapeutically-induced auto-antibodies may exert different functions, not only as inhibitors or antagonists but also as beneficial physiological cytokine carriers or regulators of their activity.

High-titer interferon-alpha antibodies in a patient with pemphigus foliaceus

Among 13 patients with pemphigus or bullous pemphigoid, high titers of anti-interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha) antibodies were present in all serum samples of one patient suffering from pemphigus foliaceus. This patient was characterized by a relatively benign course of the disease. The IFN antibodies were of oligoclonal or polyclonal origin, predominantly of the IgG subtype, and displayed a broad spectrum of specificity including various natural and recombinant IFN-alpha subtypes as well as recombinant IFN-omega 1. In vitro, these antibodies neutralized both the antiviral and antiproliferative activities of the respective IFN types. Recognition of the patient's endogenous IFN-alpha demonstrated their autoantibody nature. The IFN antibodies were present at diagnosis and resistant to continued immunosuppressive treatment. Despite clinical remission, the IFN antibodies persisted, suggesting that they were not pathogenically related to the skin manifestations of the pemphigus. There were no sings of immune complex-mediated organ damage. IFN antibodies constitute a new class of autoantibodies that may occur in conjunction with pemphigus and likely interfere with the endogenous IFN system.

Cytokines and autoantibodies to cytokines

Cytokines are essential components of our defense and repair systems but also potentially harmful mediators of infectious and immunoinflammatory reactions. Clinically important cytokines function systemically as pleiotropic hormones with overlapping effects on many cell types. All engage in a complex network of agonists and antagonists. Some immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies have been found to be potent and specific regulators of cytokines. These antibodies bind interleukin (IL-1)alpha, IL-6, IL-10, leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF), and interferon (IFN)-alpha/beta with exceptional force. They neutralize their corresponding cytokines ex vivo and perhaps in vivo, although they may also function as cytokine carriers. The biological role of autoantibodies to cytokines is not yet understood, but they may provide a level of regulation not appreciated at present. Inappropriate production/function of such antibodies could be pathogenetically involved in immunoinflammatory and other diseases. Cytokine antibodies may also contribute to the anti-inflammatory effects of human IgG therapy.

High avidity IFN-neutralizing antibodies in pharmaceutically prepared human IgG

This paper demonstrates and characterizes naturally occurring antibodies to interferon (IFN) in human IgG preparations. In vitro neutralization of the antiviral effect of IFN alpha and IFN beta, but not IFN gamma, was observed in 12 of 15 normal IgG preparations. The neutralizing capacity was higher against rIFN alpha 2A and rIFN alpha 2C than against lymphoblastoid IFN alpha and IFN beta. Frühsommer meningoencephalitis hyperimmune IgG and hepatitis-B hyperimmune IgG showed potent neutralization, whereas anti-rhesus D-, anti-rabies-, and anti-tetanus IgG showed weak neutralization. Saturable binding of 125I-rIFN alpha 2A was demonstrated only in those IgG preparations found to neutralize the antiviral effect of IFN. Significant correlation between IFN binding and neutralization capacity was observed. The antibodies bound with Fab to rIFN alpha 2A with an avidity of approximately 30 pM; the majority was of the IgG1 subclass. Maximum binding capacity was 490 pg rIFN alpha 2A/mg IgG. Cross-binding of rIFN alpha 2C, lyIFN alpha N1 and IFN beta occurred with 10 and 100-200 times lower activities than that of rIFN alpha 2A. There was no cross-binding with rIFN gamma or rIL-6. IgG preparations containing anti-IFN antibodies blocked the binding of 125I-rIFN alpha 2A to A549 cells. In conclusion, pharmaceutically prepared human IgG preparations contain variable but significant levels of high-avidity IFN alpha and IFN beta neutralizing antibodies.

Cytokine autoantibodies in rheumatoid arthritis

Sera from 42 patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and 40 healthy controls (HC) were examined for cytokine autoantibodies (CK-aAb) by accurate and sensitive radioimmunoassays. The prevalences of detectable CK-aAb in RA (HC) were: aAb-IL-1 alpha = 36% (38%); aAb-IL-6 = 29% (13%), p = 0.06; aAb-IL-8 = 0% (0%); aAb-IFN alpha = 12% (3%), p = 0.11. The levels of the individual CK-aAb did not correlate, and there were no correlations between CK-aAb levels and clinical or laboratory variables. CK-aAb levels remained constant in 8 RA patients tested over a period of 6 months. With regard to alterations in aAb-IL-1 alpha levels, 4/11 HC were consistently positive over 18-36 months; 2/11 converted and became highly positive. The levels of aAb-IFN alpha and aAb-IL-6, but not aAb-IL-1 alpha, tended to be increased in RA patients; aAb-IL-8 were undetectable in both RA and HC.

Sensitive antiproliferative neutralization assay for the detection of neutralizing IFN-alpha and IFN-beta antibodies

Antibodies to interferon (IFN) may compromise IFN treatment in some patients. In tumor therapy, a critical function of type I IFNs is their antiproliferative effect. For the quantification of neutralizing IFN antibodies we have developed an antiproliferative neutralization assay (APA) based on the reduction of IFN-mediated growth inhibition of Daudi cells by IFN-alpha and IFN-beta antibodies. Proliferation was quantified by [3H]thymidine incorporation, and the neutralizing potency of IFN antibody-positive sera was expressed as the neutralizing titer inhibiting 50% of the antiproliferative activity of 10 IU/ml of IFN (NT50). The APA is easy to perform, reproducible, and more sensitive than a well-established antiviral neutralization assay (AVA). All 30 sera with recombinant IFN-alpha 2a-binding antibodies proved to be neutralizing antibody-positive in the APA whereas seven were scored antibody-negative or uninterpretable in the AVA. The APA is recommended as a second or third line assay for the estimation of the neutralizing potency of spontaneous or treatment-induced IFN-alpha and IFN-beta-specific antibodies.

The detection and biological activity of human antibodies to IL-2 in normal donors

Antibodies to interleukin-2 (IL-2) have been reported in the sera of patients under therapies involving this cytokine and in the sera of patients infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Our study proves that auto-antibodies to IL-2 are present also, at a lower titre, in healthy individuals. These antibodies were affinity purified and studied for their capability to interfere with the in vitro biological activity of IL-2. Data obtained show that human anti-IL-2 antibodies can interfere with lymphocyte proliferation both in the lymphokine activated killer (LAK) cell assay and in the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). However, the kinetics of inhibition by anti-IL-2 antibodies differs from LAK cell assay to MLR as the former are always inhibited in a time-independent manner, and the latter only by adding antibodies at the outset of culture. The neutralizing activity observed in vitro suggests that such antibodies play a part in the elaborate cytokine network by which the immune system regulates the amplitude and duration of its response.

Binding of cytokines to pharmaceutically prepared human immunoglobulin

Pharmaceutically prepared IgG, pooled from sera of over 2,000 normal individuals, contained both monomeric and dimeric IgG. Each type of IgG bound 125I-labeled interleukin (IL)-1 alpha, IL-1 beta, IL-6, and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha. Increased binding to IgG was observed if 125I-IL-1 beta was denatured by heating to 39 degrees C. However, the binding of both nondenatured and denatured 125I-IL-1 beta was not inhibited by unlabeled IL-1 beta. In contrast, binding of 125I-IL-1 alpha, 125I-IL-6, and 125I-TNF alpha was inhibited by the corresponding unlabeled cytokine. Papain-digestion of IgG abolished binding of 125I-TNF alpha but failed to influence the displaceable binding of 125I-IL-1 alpha and 125I-IL-6. 125I-TNF alpha was a mixture of trimeric and monomeric forms, the latter being the predominant form at lower concentrations. The apparent saturability of 125I-TNF alpha was explained by a higher nonspecific binding of monomeric than of trimeric 125I-TNF alpha to IgG. The amounts of cytokine antibodies in IgG preparations would contribute approximately 2 micrograms anti-IL-1 alpha IgG and 1 microgram anti-IL-6 IgG per kg body wt during high dose immune globulin therapy. In conclusion, pharmaceutical preparations of human IgG contain specific and neutralizing, high affinity antibodies against IL-1 alpha and IL-6, but not against TNF alpha or IL-1 beta. There are significant methodological pitfalls that hamper detection of IgG autoantibodies against cytokines.