The epidemiology of factor VIII inhibitors

Immunogenicity of Therapeutic Biological Modalities - Lessons from Hemophilia A Therapies

The introduction and development of biologics such as therapeutic proteins, gene-, and cell-based therapy have revolutionized the scope of treatment for many diseases. However, a significant portion of the patients develop unwanted immune reactions against these novel biological modalities, referred to as immunogenicity, and no longer benefit from the treatments. In the current review, using Hemophilia A (HA) therapy as an example, we will discuss the immunogenicity issue of multiple biological modalities. Currently, the number of therapeutic modalities that are approved or recently explored to treat HA, a hereditary bleeding disorder, is increasing rapidly. These include, but are not limited to, recombinant factor VIII proteins, PEGylated FVIII, FVIII Fc fusion protein, bispecific monoclonal antibodies, gene replacement therapy, gene editing therapy, and cell-based therapy. They offer the patients a broader range of more advanced and effective treatment options, yet immunogenicity remains the most critical complication in the management of this disorder. Recent advances in strategies to manage and mitigate immunogenicity will also be reviewed.

Hemophilia A subjects with an intron-22 gene inversion mutation show CD4+ T-effector responses to multiple epitopes in FVIII

Background

Almost half of severe hemophilia A (HA) is caused by an intron 22 inversion mutation (Int22Inv), which disrupts the 26-exon F8 gene. Inverted F8 mRNA exons 1-22 are transcribed, while F8B mRNA, containing F8 exons 23-26, is transcribed from a promoter within intron 22. Neither FVIII activity nor FVIII antigen (cross-reacting material, CRM) are detectable in plasma of patients with an intron-22 inversion.

Objectives

To test the hypothesis that (putative) intracellular synthesis of FVIII proteins encoded by inverted F8 and F8B mRNAs confers T-cell tolerance to almost the entire FVIII sequence, and to evaluate the immunogenicity of the region encoded by the F8 exon 22-23 junction sequence.

Patients/Methods

Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from 30 severe or moderate HA subjects (17 with an Int22Inv mutation) were tested by ELISPOT assays to detect cytokine secretion in response to FVIII proteins and peptides and to map immunodominant T-cell epitopes. Potential immunogenicity of FVIII sequences encoded by the F8 exon 22-23 junction region was also tested using peptide-MHCII binding assays.

Results

Eight of the Int22Inv subjects showed robust cytokine secretion from PBMCs stimulated with FVIII proteins and/or peptides, consistent with earlier publications from the Conti-Fine group. Peptide ELISPOT assays identified immunogenic regions of FVIII. Specificity for sequences encoded within F8 mRNA exons 1-22 and F8B mRNA was confirmed by staining Int22Inv CD4⁺ T cells with peptide-loaded HLA-Class II tetramers. FVIII peptides spanning the F8 exon 22-23 junction (encoding M2124-V2125) showed limited binding to MHCII proteins and low immunogenicity, with cytokine secretion from only one Int22Inv subject.

Conclusions

PBMCs from multiple subjects with an Int22Inv mutation, with and without a current FVIII inhibitor, responded to FVIII epitopes. Furthermore, the FVIII region encoded by the exon 22-23 junction sequence was not remarkably immunoreactive and is therefore unlikely to contain an immunodominant, promiscuous CD4⁺ T-cell epitope. Our results indicate that putative intracellular expression of partial FVIII proteins does not confer T-cell tolerance to FVIII regions encoded by inverted F8 mRNA or F8B mRNA.

Inhibitor; An Uncommon But Vexing Challenge In North Indian Patients With Hemophilia A

Factor VIII replacement is the mainstay of treatment in hemophilia A but may lead to the development of inhibitors. While a vexing clinical problem, some observations suggest that the presence of inhibitors may not necessarily portend a higher bleeding risk. Our aim was to assess the prevalence and clinicopathological correlates of inhibitors in a well characterized cohort of Indian patients with HA patients. We retrospectively reviewed the clinical details and laboratory findings of consecutive hemophilia A patients attending a north-Indian tertiary-care center from 2010 to 2020. Among 592 patients with HA, inhibitors were detected in 35 patients (5.9%). Prevalence of inhibitors in moderate and severe hemophilia was 4.2% and 6.7%, respectively. Most patients with inhibitors had history of transfusion with factor VIII alone (54.3%) or a combination of factor VIII concentrate and other blood-products (42.9%). Intracranial bleed was significantly more frequent in patients with inhibitors compared to those without inhibitors (20% vs. 4.1%; p-0.001). Time dependent and immediately acting inhibitors were seen in 60% and 40% patients, respectively. High-titre (> 5 BU) and low-titre inhibitors (< 5 BU) were detected in 28 (80%) and 7 (20%) patients, respectively. Prevalence of inhibitors in our cohort was 5.9% and most had high-titre, time dependent inhibitors. These patients may have a higher risk of intracranial bleeding.

Gut dysbiosis modulates the immune response to factor VIII in murine hemophilia A

The development of neutralizing FVIII antibodies is the most serious complication of hemophilia A treatment. The currently known patient- and treatment-related risk factors for inhibitor development do not accurately predict this adverse event in all patients. The composition of the gut microbiota has been shown to influence immune-mediated diseases at distant anatomical sites (eg, lungs, brain, and joints). We demonstrate that a disrupted gut microbiota can be created in a mouse model of hemophilia A using a broad-spectrum antibiotic. Under controlled conditions, this sustained dysbiosis was associated with an increase in splenic B cells and the development of higher titer, FVIII-specific immunoglobulin G antibodies after FVIII challenge. Splenic and mesenteric lymph node cytokines, T cells, and dendritic cells were unaffected before administration of FVIII. However, the immune transcriptome of both aforementioned secondary lymphoid organs was significantly modified. Short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs), which are immunomodulatory microbial metabolites, were depleted in cecal contents of the dysbiotic mice. Furthermore, supplementation of the drinking water with butyrate, the most immunologically active SCFA, successfully achieved attenuation of the FVIII immune response. Collectively, data from this exploratory study suggest that the composition of the gut microbiota alters the FVIII immune response via the action of specific microbial metabolites on the immune cell transcriptome and that oral supplementation with butyrate effectively reduces the FVIII immune response.

Long-Term Antithrombotic Treatments Prescribed for Cardiovascular Diseases in Patients with Hemophilia: Results from the French Registry

Cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) are a major issue in aging patients with hemophilia (PWHs). Antithrombotic agents are widely used in the general population for CVD treatment, but this recommendation is not fully applicable to PWHs. To improve treatment strategies, a prospective case-control study (COCHE) that analyzed CVD management and follow-up (2 years/patient) in PWHs was performed in France from 2011 to 2018. In total, 68 PWHs (median age: 65 years [39-89]; 48 mild, 10 moderate, and 10 severe hemophilia) were included (n = 50 with acute coronary syndrome, n = 17 with atrial fibrillation, n = 1 with both). They were matched with 68 control PWHs without antithrombotic treatment. In our series, bleeding was significantly influenced by (1) hemophilia severity, with a mean annualized bleeding ratio significantly higher in COCHE patients than in controls with basal clotting factor level up to 20%, (2) antihemorrhagic regimen (on-demand vs. prophylaxis) in severe (hazard ratio [HR] = 16.69 [95% confidence interval, CI: 8.2-47.26]; p < 0.0001) and moderate hemophilia (HR = 42.43 [95% CI: 1.86-966.1]; p = 0.0028), (3) type of antithrombotic treatment in mild hemophilia, with a significantly higher risk of bleeding in COCHE patients than in controls for dual-pathway therapy (HR = 15.64 [95% CI: 1.57-115.8]; p = 0.019), anticoagulant drugs alone (HR = 9.91 [95% CI: 1.34-73.47]; p = 0.0248), dual antiplatelet therapy (HR = 5.31 [95% CI: 1.23-22.92]; p = 0.0252), and single antiplatelet therapy (HR = 3.76 [95% CI: 1.13-12.55]; p = 0.0313); and (4) HAS-BLED score ≥3 (odds ratio [OR] = 33 [95% CI: 1.43-761.2]; p = 0.0065). Gastrointestinal bleeding was also significantly higher in COCHE patients than in controls (OR = 15 [95% CI: 1.84-268]; p = 0.0141). The COCHE study confirmed that antithrombotic treatments in PWHs are associated with increased bleeding rates in function of hemophilia-specific factors and also of known factors in the general population.

The societal burden of haemophilia A. I - A snapshot of haemophilia A in Australia and beyond

INTRODUCTION

Few studies, both in Australia and overseas, have examined the social impacts of living with haemophilia A (HA) or the economic costs associated with the disorder. The purpose of this paper is to examine the epidemiology and societal burden of people with HA (PwHA) in Australia, with a particular focus on men with this disorder.

METHODS

The epidemiology and societal burden of HA in Australia, with a particular focus on men with this disorder, were assessed, using data available in the Australian and international literature and publicly available data.

RESULTS

The mean annual prevalence of HA is approximately 1-2 per 10 000 males. Prophylactic treatment is used in one-quarter (25.1%) of people with moderate HA, and 82.2% of people with severe HA. Within the latter group, 16.1% have inhibitors for Factor VIII, predisposing them to worse morbidity, mortality and quality of life when compared to the non-inhibitor population. Joint pain and joint disease occur commonly in PwHA, with up to 70% of adults with HA experiencing joint problems. HA is associated with poor physical health, and PwHA miss school and work due to bleeding-related events.

CONCLUSION

HA is associated with substantial economic burden; with large differences in costs reported between countries. Overall, HA imposes a significant burden of disease on PwHA, their families and the community at large.

Role of lupus anticoagulants in immediate acting inhibitor positivity in congenital haemophilia A patients

OBJECTIVES

Presence of lupus anticoagulants (LA) in haemophilia and their interference in coagulation assays is well-known. Factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors are generally time and temperature dependent whereas LAs are immediate acting inhibitors (IAIs). The present study reports the challenges in laboratory detection of both progressive and non-progressive, specific FVIII inhibitors in the presence of LA.

METHODS

From 2012 through 2015, 4900 HA patients were screened for inhibitors. APTT based inhibitor screening tests and Nijmegen-modified Bethesda assay (NBA) were done in all samples. LA test and FVIII inhibitors by ELISA were done in patients with IAIs.

RESULTS

Out of 451 patients positive for inhibitors in the initial screening tests, classical and progressive FVIII inhibitors were observed in 398 patients while 53 had IAIs showing no/partial correction in 1:1 mixtures of NPP and patient plasma. In 27 patients, both FVIII and FIX activity levels were <1%, resulting in difficulty in diagnosis. In 48 HA patients with IAIs, 42 were LA positive. 4 patients were found to have only LA with false positive results in NBA while 38 had a combination of LA and FVIII inhibitors. Six patients were LA negative and had only FVIII IAIs. Five (62.5%) of 8 HA patients initiated on immune tolerance induction (ITI) also were positive for IAIs.

CONCLUSION

The findings emphasizes the presence of specific FVIII inhibitors in congenital HA with absence of time dependent inactivation kinetics in a small proportion of cases. ELISA or chromogenic assays along with LA testing can offer accurate laboratory diagnosis in patients with coexisting LA.

Genotypes, phenotypes and whole genome sequence: Approaches from the My Life Our Future haemophilia project

INTRODUCTION

Information from the genes encoding factor VIII (F8) and IX (F9) is used in reproductive planning and to inform inhibitor formation, bleeding severity and response to therapies. Advances in technology and our understanding of the human genome now allows more comprehensive methods to study genomic variation and its impact on haemophilia.

AIMS

The My Life Our Future (MLOF) programme was begun in 2012 to provide genetic analysis and to expand research in haemophilia through a research repository.

METHODS

MLOF enrolled haemophilia A and B patients followed at haemophilia treatment centers in the U.S., including, since 2015, known and potential genetic carriers. Initial F8 and F9 DNA analysis was performed utilizing a next generation sequencing approach which allowed simultaneous detection of F8 inversions and other variants. Candidate variants were confirmed using a second method and multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification was used to detect structural variants.

RESULTS

The initial phase of MLOF completed enrollment in December 2017 with 11,356 patients, genetic carriers, and potential carriers enrolled. In the 9453 subjects in whom analysis is complete, 687 unique previously unreported variants were found. Simultaneous sequencing of the F8 and F9 genes resulted in identification of non-deleterious variants previously reported as causative in haemophilia. DNA from 5141 MLOF subjects has undergone whole genome sequencing through the NHLBI TOPMed programme of the U.S. NIH.

CONCLUSION

MLOF has provided genetic information for patients and their families to help inform clinical care and has established a repository of data and biospecimens to further advance haemophilia research.

Early cellular interactions and immune transcriptome profiles in human factor VIII-exposed hemophilia A mice

Essentials Initial immune cell interactions leading to factor (F) VIII immunity are not well characterized. We assessed cellular interactions and expression profiles in hemophilia A mice. MARCO+, followed by SIGLEC1+ and SIGNR1+ macrophages co-localize most with human FVIII. The splenic transcriptome highlights potential therapeutic targets to prevent inhibitors.

SUMMARY

Background Developing factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitory antibodies is the most serious complication in hemophilia A treatment, representing a significant health and economic burden. A better understanding of the early events in an immune response leading to this outcome may provide insight into inhibitor development. Objective To identify early mediators of FVIII immunity and to detail immune expression profiles in the spleen and liver. Methods C57Bl/6 F8 E16 knockout mice were infused with 5-20 μg (2000-8000 IU kg-1 ) of recombinant FVIII. Spleens were frozen at various time-points post-infusion and stained for FVIII and cellular markers. Splenic and liver RNA expression analysis was performed 3 h post-infusion of 0.6 μg (240 IU kg-1 ) FVIII by nCounter technology using a 561-gene immunology panel. Results FVIII localization in the spleen did not change over 2.5 h. We observed significantly higher co-localization of FVIII with MARCO+ cells compared with SIGLEC1+ and SIGNR1+ in the splenic marginal zone. FVIII exhibited little co-localization with CD11c+ dendritic cells and the macrophage mannose receptor, CD206. Following FVIII infusion, the splenic mRNA profiling identified genes such as Tnfaip6 and Il23r, which are implicated in chemotaxis and a proinflammatory Th17 response, respectively. In contrast, an upregulation of Gfi1 in the liver suggests an anti-inflammatory environment. Conclusions FVIII co-localizes predominantly with marginal zone macrophages (MARCO+ ) in the murine spleen following intravenous infusion. Targeting pathways that are implicated in the early FVIII innate immune response in the spleen may lead to therapeutic interventions to prevent inhibitor formation.

Manual therapy in the treatment of patients with hemophilia B and inhibitor

BACKGROUND

The main clinical manifestations of hemophilia are muscle and joint bleeding. Recurrent bleeding leads to a degenerative process known as hemophilic arthropathy. The development of inhibitors (antibodies against FVIII/FIX concentrates) is the main complication in the treatment of hemophilia. The objective was to assess the safety and efficacy of manual therapy treatment in a patient with hemophilia and inhibitor.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 26-year-old patient with hemophilia B and inhibitor received physiotherapy treatment based on manual therapy for 3 months, with a frequency of 2 sessions per week. The joint status was evaluated using the Hemophilia Joint Health Score; pain was assessed with the Visual Analog Scale; and the range of movement was evaluated using a universal goniometer. The patient developed no joint bleeding in the knees or ankles as a result of the physiotherapy treatment. Following treatment, improvements were noted in the range of movement of knees and ankles, the perception of pain in both knees, and ankle functionality.

CONCLUSIONS

Until now, manual therapy using joint traction was contraindicated in patients with hemophilia and inhibitor, as it was feared to cause possible joint bleeding. This is the first case study to address the safety and efficacy of manual therapy in a patient with hemophilia and an inhibitor. The results of this study may help to establish which manual therapy treatments are indicated in patients with hemophilic arthropathy and inhibitors. Thus, a physiotherapy program based on manual therapy may be safe in patients with hemophilia and inhibitor and such therapy may improve joint condition, pain, and joint range of motion in patients with hemophilia and inhibitor. Randomized clinical trials are needed to confirm the results of this case study.

Total joint replacement in inhibitor-positive haemophilia: Long-term outcome analysis in fifteen patients

AIM

To collect data from joint replacement in inhibitor patients, evaluate haemostatic and patient outcomes, and analyse the costs.

METHODS

We report our 21-year, single-centre cumulative experience of 15 joint arthroplasties in six inhibitor patients.

RESULTS

Two low responder inhibitor patients were in the early days treated with FVIII, whereas bypassing agents were used in the rest of the high responder patients. The primary haemostatic outcome was good in 8/15, fair in 4/15 and poor in 3/15 operations. The overall patient outcome, including joint health and patient satisfaction, was good in 10/15, fair 4/15 and poor in 1/15. No deep infections were observed. Cost analysis was most beneficial in low responders and in two immune-tolerized, high responder patients. In all cases, factor replacement comprised the main treatment costs.

CONCLUSION

Our experience supports the initial use of bypassing agents as well as preoperative immune-tolerance induction when possible. Despite the challenges of haemostasis and severe joint disease, total joint arthroplasty can reach a good outcome, even in inhibitor patients. The risk for deep infection might be smaller than previously reported. Individual planning, intense multidisciplinary teamwork and execution of operations should be centralised in a professional unit.

The role of recombinant activated factor VII in the haematological management of elective orthopaedic surgery in haemophilia A patients with inhibitors

The clinical profile and expectations of haemophilic patients with inhibitors have changed over the last three decades, mainly because of the prolongation of life-expectancy, often resulting in an increase of the orthopaedic burden. Recombinant activated factor VII (rFVIIa) is the most frequently used bypassing agent in haemophilia patients with inhibitors during elective orthopaedic surgery. For nearly 30 years, rFVIIa has been successfully used to control haemostasis in several major and minor surgical procedures. Clinical trials, case series, reports and surveys were progressively aimed at optimising rFVIIa usage in very demanding conditions managed in highly specialised centres. Recommendations from consensus opinions and guidelines have been provided on the basis of this clinical experience.

A close insight to factor VIII inhibitor in the congenital hemophilia A

INTRODUCTION

Hemophilia A (HA) has an X-linked pattern of inheritance and is the most common of the hemorrhagic disorders. HA is caused by a decreased or deficiency of the functional clotting factor VIII (FVIII) and effects 1 in 5000-10,000 male births. The common treatment for hemophilia is replacement therapy by plasma-derived or recombinant FVIII. Approximately 20-30% of people with a severe type of HA develop an inhibitor and this phenomenon is the main challenge in the management of these patients. Genetic factors and environmental determinants contribute to inhibitor development. Here, the roles of various genetic and environmental factors such as the type of FVIII concentrate used, the number of exposure days, and peak treatment time will be discussed in detail. It seems this information is helpful for hematologists.

AREAS COVERED

A literature review was done in January 2016 on PubMed and Scopus using the following keywords:' h(a)emophilia A & factor VIII inhibitor', 'h(a)emophilia A & factor VIII alloantibody', 'h(a)emophilia A & inhibitor'. There was no time limitation; however, there was an English language limitation placed on the articles selected. Expert commentary: Influential genetic and environmental factors in developing inhibitors have been discussed. Most of the risk factors are related to previously untreated patients with hemophili.

Thrombin generation and bleeding in haemophilia inhibitor patients during immune tolerance induction

BACKGROUND

Inhibitor formation complicates haemophilia treatment and requires immune tolerance induction to rid inhibitors over 5 BU. In the prospective, randomized International Immune Tolerance Study, immune tolerance induction was equally effective with high-dose (HD) (200 IU kg^-1 day^-1 ) and low-dose (LD) (50 IU kg^-1 3× per week) factor VIII, but haemorrhages were twofold higher in the LD arm. This finding was unexpected as inhibitors neutralize FVIII activity. We hypothesized that the thrombin generation assay (TGA), a global measure of clot formation, might predict bleeding better than FVIII levels.

METHODS

We evaluated TGA using relipidated tissue factor (TF) on 83 thawed, recalcified corn trypsin inhibitor/citrate plasma samples from 31 subjects (17 HD, 14 LD) who participated on the ITI study, and who had sufficient sample available and appropriate informed consent.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in peak thrombin, estimated thrombin potential, maximum rate or lag time between HD and LD arms; between pre-, during and post-ITI time points, or after FVIII spiking. In 19 subjects (12 HD, 7 LD) with anti-FVIII<1.0 BU, the prevalence of non-neutralizing antibody (NNA) and neutralizing antibody (NA) was 89.5% (17/19), and the latter strongly correlated with anti-VIII titer, r = 0.73 [95% CI: 0.55, 0.88].

CONCLUSION

In haemophilia inhibitor patients, thrombin generation is present, but does not predict bleeding risk. Following tolerance induction, NNA remains detectable in the majority.

To clear or to fear: An innate perspective on factor VIII immunity

•

FVIII inhibitor development involves a combination of innate immune modulators.

•

Clearance and immunity is influenced at 3 levels: the protein, cell, and location.

•

Cells associated with FVIII half-life may influence the immune response against FVIII.

The enigma that is factor VIII immunogenicity remains ever pertinent in the treatment of hemophilia A. Development of neutralizing antibodies against the therapeutic protein in 25–30% of patients likely depends on the appropriate activation of the innate immune response shortly following antigen encounter. Our understanding of this important immunological synapse remains ill-defined. In this review, we examine the three distinct factors contributing to the fate of factor VIII almost immediately after infusion: the characteristics of the protein, the cell, and the microenvironment. We propose a continuum between clearance and antigen presentation that facilitates removal of FVIII from circulation leading to either tolerance or immunity.

Expanding the ortholog approach for hemophilia treatment complicated by factor VIII inhibitors

BACKGROUND

The formation of neutralizing antibodies (inhibitors) directed against human coagulation factor VIII (hFVIII) is a life-threatening pathogenic response that occurs in 20-30% of severe congenital hemophilia A patients and 0.00015% of the remaining population (i.e. acquired hemophilia A). Interspecies amino acid sequence disparity among FVIII orthologs represents a promising strategy to mask FVIII from existing inhibitors while retaining procoagulant function. Evidence for the effectiveness of this approach exists in clinical data obtained for porcine FVIII (pFVIII) products, which have demonstrated efficacy in the setting of congenital and acquired hemophilia.

OBJECTIVES

In the current study, recombinant (r) ovine FVIII (oFVIII) was evaluated for antigenicity and procoagulant activity in the context of human patient-derived and murine model-generated FVIII inhibitors.

METHODS

The antigenicity of roFVIII was assessed using (i) inhibitor patient plasma samples, (ii) murine anti-FVIII MAbs, (iii) immunized murine hemophilia A plasmas and (iv) an in vivo model of acquired hemophilia A.

RESULTS

Overall, roFVIII demonstrated reduced reactivity to, and inhibition by, anti-hFVIII immunoglobulin in patient plasmas. Additionally, several hFVIII epitopes were predicted and empirically shown not to exist within roFVIII. In a murine hemophilia A model designed to mimic clinical inhibitor formation, it was demonstrated that inhibitor titers to roFVIII were significantly reduced when compared with the orthologous immunogens, rhFVIII or rpFVIII. Furthermore, in a murine model of acquired hemophilia A, roFVIII administration conferred protection from bleeding following tail transection.

CONCLUSION

These data support the investigation of FVIII orthologs as treatment modalities in both the congenital and acquired FVIII inhibitor settings.

Genomics of bleeding disorders

Molecular genetic tools are widely applied in inherited bleeding disorders. New genes involved in haemorrhagic disorders have been identified by genome wide linkage analysis on families with a specific phenotype. LMNA1 or MCFD in combined FV/FVIII-deficiency and VKORC1 in vitamin K coagulation factor deficiency type 2 are two examples. Identification of the causative gene mutation has become standard for most bleeding disorders. Knowledge of the causative mutation allows genetic counselling in affected families and most importantly adds to the pathophysiological understanding of phenotypes. Haemophilia A represents a model as the F8 gene mutation predicts the risk of developing an inhibitor and more recently also the bleeding phenotype. In this review novel genetic diagnostic strategies for bleeding disorders are outlined and inhibitor formation is presented as an example for clinical relevant phenotype/genotype correlation studies.

Design of the INHIBIT trial: preventing inhibitors by avoiding 'danger', prolonging half-life and promoting tolerance

Inhibitor formation is among the most serious complications of hemophilia treatment. With the US FDA licensure of the novel long-lasting recombinant factor VIII (FVIII) Fc fusion protein, Eloctate, which prolongs FVIII half-life, we propose an innovative approach to prevent inhibitor formation. In this paper, we describe a multicenter, Phase II, single-arm, 48-week trial, the INHIBIT trial, to determine if Eloctate, begun before a bleed and continued as once weekly prophylaxis, will reduce inhibitor formation in children with hemophilia A. We hypothesize that avoiding 'danger,' that is, immune activation by a bleed at first factor exposure and prolonging FVIII half-life will prevent inhibitors and promote FVIII-specific T-cell tolerance. If successful, this approach will suggest a new paradigm in clinical practice.

High rate of spontaneous inhibitor clearance during the long term observation study of a single cohort of 524 haemophilia A patients not undergoing immunotolerance

BACKGROUND

The natural history of inhibitors in patients with haemophilia A not undergoing immune tolerance induction (ITI) is largely unknown. A recent randomized controlled trial suggests that the higher the FVIII dose used for ITI, the faster the clearance and the lower the rate of bleeding, without any difference in the rate of tolerance. We aimed at assessing the rate of spontaneous inhibitor clearance in a large cohort of patients not undergoing ITI.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of anti-FVIII inhibitors of long-term registry data in a single centre cohort of 524 haemophilia A patients considered for synovectomy was performed. Patients were tested for inhibitors before and 15 days after any and each surgical episode and thereafter did not undergo immune tolerance at any time.

RESULTS

The cumulative incidence of inhibitors overall was 34% (180 out of 524) with the highest percentage of 39% (168 out of 434) in severe patients which represented 83% of the cohort. Among the 180 inhibitor patients: 63 had permanent inhibitors; 70 fulfilled current criteria for transient inhibitors but a third category of 47 additional patients cleared the alloantibody spontaneously in >6 months. At logistic regression, both the inhibitor titre and the gene mutation were shown to predict time to clearance.

CONCLUSIONS

Spontaneous clearance of inhibitors over variable time in the absence of ITI treatment was found in up to 2/3 of the cases.

Low prevalence of inhibitor antibodies in the Canadian haemophilia population

Annual reporting of inhibitors to factors (FVIII) and IX (FIX) to the Canadian Haemophilia Registry has suggested a lower prevalence than that published in the literature. We performed a prospective study to determine the prevalence of patients with inhibitors directed against either FVIII or FIX. Patients with inhibitors were classified as: (i) inhibitor test positive; (ii) inhibitor test negative but on immune tolerance induction (ITI); (iii) inhibitor test negative but bypass treatment recommended; or (iv) inhibitor resolved. One year later, the cohort was re-classified. The prevalence of inhibitors on 1 May, 2007 was 3.3% for haemophilia A, 0.6% for haemophilia B and 8.9% and 2.1% for severe haemophilia A and B. One year later 17 individuals gained and 11 individuals lost inhibitor status (10 of these with ITI). This study suggests that the prevalence of inhibitors in our population is lower than that was previously published. We hypothesize that this is primarily due to the increased use of ITI, but other factors may be the unselected nature of the cohort and the restriction of the study to one date thereby conforming as close as practical to the definition of prevalence rather than incidence. The classification system used in this study was easy for clinics to apply and was important in defining the population with inhibitors.

Survey of current prophylaxis practices and bleeding characteristics of children with severe haemophilia A in US haemophilia treatment centres

Every other day (qod) factor VIII prophylaxis prevents joint bleeds in children with severe haemophilia A. Although three times weekly or qod prophylaxis is recommended by the National Hemophilia Foundation (NHF), how widely these practices have been adopted is not known. We sought to define current prophylaxis practices at US haemophilia treatment centres (HTCs). An email survey was distributed to US HTCs, utilizing web-based membership rosters of the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) and the Hemostasis Thrombosis Research Society (HTRS). Of 62 HTCs responding, prophylaxis is initiated on a three times weekly schedule in 29 (46.8%), twice weekly in 13 HTCs (21.0%) and once weekly in 20 HTCs (32.2%). Central venous catheters are used to infuse factor prophylactically at 55 HTCs (88.7%), including in 100% of children initiating prophylaxis at 19 HTCs (30.6%) and in 50% of those at 41 HTCs (66.1%), but avoided altogether at seven HTCs (11.3%). Prophylaxis is initiated after one or more bleeds in 56 HTCs (90.3%), but after the first bleed in only 28 HTCs (25.2%). Among 226 newborns with severe haemophilia A in 62 HTCs, 1.82 births/HTC/year, the median age at first bleed, excluding circumcision, is 7 months. Of the 113 (53.5%) newborns who underwent circumcision, 62 (54.9%) bled. Despite a recommended standard of three times weekly prophylaxis, over half of surveyed HTCs do not follow these guidelines, and nearly one-third begin prophylaxis on a once weekly schedule to delay or avoid the need for central venous access.

Low risk of inhibitor formation in haemophilia A patients following en masse switch in treatment to a third generation full length plasma and albumin-free recombinant factor VIII product (ADVATE®)

Previous studies have suggested that development of inhibitors in previously treated patients (PTPs) may be attributable to a switch in factor VIII (FVIII) therapeutic product. Consequently, it is widely recognized that inhibitor development must be assessed in PTPs following the introduction of any new FVIII product. Following a national tender process in 2006, all patients with haemophilia A in Ireland changed their FVIII treatment product en masse to a plasma and albumin-free recombinant full-length FVIII product (ADVATE(®)). In this study, we retrospectively reviewed the case records of Irish PTPs to evaluate risk of inhibitor formation following this treatment switch. One hundred and thirteen patients participated in the study. Most patients (89%) had severe haemophilia. Only one of 96 patients with no inhibitor history developed an inhibitor. Prior to the switch in his recombinant FVIII (rFVIII) treatment of choice, this child had only experienced three exposure days (EDs). Consequently, in total he had only received 6 EDs when his inhibitor was first diagnosed. In keeping with this lack of de novo inhibitor development, we observed no evidence of any recurrent inhibitor formation in any of 16 patients with previously documented inhibitors. Similarly, following a previous en masse switch, we have previously reported that changing from a Chinese hamster ovary cell-produced to a baby hamster kidney cell-produced rFVIII was also associated with a low risk of inhibitor formation in PTPs. Our cumulative findings from these two studies clearly emphasizes that the risk of inhibitor development for PTPs following changes in commercial rFVIII product is low, at least in the Irish population.

Hemostatic management of an infant with severe hemophilia A and tetralogy of Fallot for cardiac bypass surgery

We present the hemostatic management of severe hemophilia A of an infant with high risk of inhibitor development who underwent cardiac surgery for correction of tetralogy of Fallot. Continuous infusion of recombinant factor VIII resulted in good hemostasis during surgery and postoperatively. Unfortunately, the patient had inhibitor development 2 months after cardiothoracic surgery. Although cardiac surgery is successful, exposure to factor concentrates in severe hemophilia early in life might predispose a patient to inhibitor development.

How I treat age-related morbidities in elderly persons with hemophilia

In persons with hemophilia, life expectancy is now approaching that of the general male population, at least in countries that can afford regular replacement therapy with coagulation factor concentrates. The new challenges for comprehensive treatment centers are thus to provide optimal health care for this aging population of patients, who often present not only with the comorbidities typically associated with hemophilia (arthropathy, chronic pain, blood-borne infections), but also with common age-related illnesses such as cardiovascular disease and cancer. There are no evidence-based guidelines for the management of these conditions, which often require drugs that interfere with hemostasis, enhance the bleeding tendency, and warrant more intensive replacement therapy. At the moment, elderly patients with hemophilia affected by other diseases should be managed like their age-group peers without hemophilia, provided replacement therapy is tailored to the heightened risk of bleeding associated with the need for invasive procedures and drugs that further compromise the deranged hemostasis. More detailed advice is provided on the schedules of replacement therapy needed to tackle cardiovascular diseases, such as acute coronary syndromes and nonvalvular atrial fibrillation, because these conditions will become more and more frequent challenges for the comprehensive treatment centers.

Polymorphisms in genes involved in autoimmune disease and the risk of FVIII inhibitor development in Italian patients with haemophilia A

One of the most severe and important complication in the treatment of patients with haemophilia A is the formation of neutralizing antibodies (FVIII inhibitors) that inhibit the clotting activity of substituted FVIII. Both genetic and environmental factors influence the susceptibility of patients to develop inhibitors. The objective of this study was to evaluate whether polymorphisms in different genes involved in the regulation of the immune system may confer susceptibility to inhibitor development in patients with HA. We analysed the distribution of polymorphisms in the CTLA4, PTPN22, IL10, TNFalpha, FOXP3 and IRF5 genes that have been reported to be associated with a number of autoimmune disease. In addition, we evaluated the distribution of IL10 haplotypes in haemophilic patients and healthy controls to assess whether specific polymorphisms in IL10 gene were associated to the risk of inhibitor development. We focused on a cohort of Italian unrelated haemophilic patients with and without a history of inhibitors. Genotyping was carried out with standard methods including RFLP, real time PCR and direct DNA sequencing. Our data show that, considering single nucleotide variations, genotype frequencies in patients with inhibitors were not significantly different from those observed in patients without inhibitors, suggesting a lack of association between these polymorphisms and the development of inhibitors. Moreover, no relationship was found between specific combinations of IL10 alleles and the antibody production. Previous contradictory association studies may depend on the different genetic background of the population examined. Further studies may contribute to a clearer understanding of this process.

Immune response to FVIII in hemophilia A: an overview of risk factors

Development of inhibitors is perhaps the most serious complication of factor VIII (FVIII) replacement therapy, which can practically preclude efficient clinical management of patients with hemophilia A. Much effort therefore has been focused both in improving our understanding of the reasons for the formation of FVIII antibodies and to find alternative methods of treatment. Several patient-related factors have been related to the risk of inhibitor development such as ethnicity, FVIII gene mutation type, family history of inhibitors, HLA haplotype, polymorphisms in the promoter regions of IL 10 gene, single nucleotide polymorphisms of tumor necrosis factor alpha gene, and so on. In addition to the genetic determinants, there are several nongenetic factors which mainly include treatment characteristics like the type and purity of coagulation factor concentrates used for treatment, age at the time of initial treatment, initial doses of concentrate, mode of infusion, surgery, frequency of dosing prior to inhibitor development, and intensity of treatment or regular prophylaxis. Inflammatory processes in early childhood are under discussion as being an environmental factor that may modify the immune response to a foreign antigen. The genetic risks cannot be changed, while environmental factors may increase or decrease the inhibitor risk in an individual patient. In addition, there are other causes of inhibitor development against FVIII like stress, age, malignancy, infection, pregnancy, antibiotics, etc. Development of inhibitors in such cases happens in individuals who are not hemophilic and have normal plasma FVIII levels. Acquired inhibitors to FVIII in nonhemophiliacs (autoantibodies) pose a further challenge to treatment, as this is often associated with significant morbidity and mortality. Prognosis in case of autoantibodies is related to the underlying disease process and is associated with high mortality. Improved understanding of these complex interactions may lead to the development of preventive measures to minimize FVIII inhibitor formation. The modifiable risk factors for inhibitor formation may provide the key to predict and perhaps prevent the formation of inhibitors in hemophilia patients.

Evolution of recombinant factor VIII safety: KOGENATE and Kogenate FS/Bayer

The use of factor VIII (FVIII) concentrates in the treatment of hemophilia A has raised important safety issues, historically of pathogen transmission and increasingly of inhibitor development to FVIII treatment. While manufacturing processes of current recombinant FVIII products have been shaped entirely around preventing pathogen transmission, the same modifications that afford a greater margin of safety could affect immunogenicity of the product, consequences of which could only be seen through long-term clinical experience. This review summarizes pathogen safety and inhibitor reports from clinical trials, post-marketing surveillance studies, and study reports on KOGENATE and its successor, Kogenate FS/Bayer. Although KOGENATE and Kogenate FS/Bayer are nearly identical products, subtle manufacturing improvements to address the need for greater margins of safety from a pathogen transmission perspective have also led to a potentially improved immunogenicity profile (15% in previously untreated/minimally treated patients with severe hemophilia A for Kogenate FS/Bayer). Notably, there has been no occurrence of pathogen contamination, and minimal de novo inhibitor formation in previously treated patients throughout the use of both products. Overall, KOGENATE and Kogenate FS/Bayer have a long history of safety in a variety of clinical settings, including treatment of bleeding, surgical management, and prophylaxis therapy.

Thrombin generation in haemophilia A patients with factor VIII inhibitors after infusion of recombinant factor VIIa

BACKGROUND

Development of factor VIII inhibitors is a serious complication in haemophilia A patients. Recombinant factor VIIa (rVIIa) is clinically effective, but its effects on haemostatic system need still to be fully elucidated.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In an open controlled study, we measured thrombin generation (peak thrombin) in venous blood and prothrombin fragment F1 + 2 (F1 + 2) and D-dimer in venous and in shed blood in five haemophilia A patients with inhibitors before and after rVIIa infusion. A total of five healthy individuals who did not receive rVIIa served as controls.

RESULTS

At baseline, patients had lower mean (min-max) peak thrombin levels than controls [0.12 (0.0-0.6) vs. 186.9 (116.0-254.4) nM, P = 0.001]. After infusion, peak thrombin levels increased in average to 40.7 (28.3-51.6) nM, which translates into 80.2% (95% CI 65.4-88.6%) lower levels compared to that of controls. Mean (min-max) F1 + 2 levels in venous blood did not differ significantly between patients and controls [160.7 (89.8-331.3) vs. 160.8 (104.4-242.3) pmol L(-1)], but increased in average (min-max) by 39.4% (14.1-58.5%) after infusion. In blood emerging from incisions made to determine the bleeding (shed blood), F1 + 2 levels were lower in patients than controls [1383.3 (906.4-2044.6) vs. 2981.7 (1610.0-4539.6) pmol L(-1); P = 0.04], but were not affected by rVIIa; D-dimer levels were significantly higher in haemophiliacs than in controls and remained unchanged after infusion.

CONCLUSIONS

Haemophilia A patients with factor VIII inhibitors have low thrombin generation. After rVIIa, the extent of coagulation activation as measured by levels of F1 + 2 is increased, but thrombin generation is restored to only 20%. Peak thrombin levels could reflect the effects of rVIIa on coagulation mechanisms, and their relevance with regard to the clinical coagulation defect of haemophilia A patients with factor VIII inhibitors might be evaluated.

Risk of inhibitors in haemophilia and the type of factor replacement

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Inhibitors in haemophilia are a serious complication that may render usual replacement therapy ineffective. The risk is greatest in previously untreated children with severe haemophilia A. The role of replacement factor VIII in this group is an important issue.

RECENT FINDINGS

Until now, few clinical studies have correctly taken into account the variety of cofactors involved in inhibitor development: genetic (familial antecedents, ethnicity, F8 and immune response genotypes), and environmental cofactors (age at first infusion, prophylaxis and intensity of treatment). This is a prerequisite to correctly evaluating the putative role of the type of factor replacement. Prospective cohort studies are therefore urgently needed. Depending on the expected inhibitor risk in the reference group, the intensity of the relationship between risk factor and endpoint, the duration of patient follow up, and the design of the study (balanced or unbalanced groups), cohorts including 200-500 previously untreated children should be sufficient to demonstrate an increased intensity of risk of about 2 or more with one product compared with another.

SUMMARY

Aside from clinical studies, fundamental research is essential to test the multiple hypotheses that could explain a difference in inhibitor risk between the currently available factor VIII concentrates in order to develop less immunogenic factor VIII.