Comparison of the solution conformations of a human immunodeficiency virus peptidomimetic and its retro-inverso isomer using 1H NMR spectroscopy

Peptide and protein mimetics by retro and retroinverso analogs

Retroinverso analog of a natural polypeptide can sometimes mimic the structure and function of the natural peptide. The additional advantage of using retroinverso analog is that it is resistant to proteolysis. The retroinverso analogs have peptide sequence in reverse direction with respect to natural peptide and also have chirality of amino acid inverted from L to D. The D amino acids cannot be recognized by common proteases of the body; therefore, these peptides will not be degraded easily and have a longer-lasting effect as vaccine and inhibitor drugs. There have been many contested propositions about the geometric relationship between a peptide and its retro, inverso, or retroinverso analog. A retroinverso analog sometimes fails to adopt the structure that can mimic the function of the natural peptide. In such cases, partial retroinverso analog and other modifications can help in achieving the desired structure and function. Here, we review the theory, major experimental attempts, prediction methods, and alternative strategies related to retroinverso peptidomimetics.

Interaction energy analysis of peptide can predict the possibilities of mimetics by its retroinverso isomer

It has been previously reported that the retroinverso analog of S peptide cannot mimic the S peptide, whereas the retroinverso analog of foot-and-mouth disease virus antigen can mimic the foot-and-mouth disease virus antigen. The structures of S peptide, foot-and-mouth disease virus antigen, and their retroinverso analogs are known. Here, we have attempted to explain the structural basis of mimetics at the level of atomic interactions by elaborating upon the Guptasarma's hypothesis. Using interaction energy analysis of S peptide and foot-and-mouth disease virus antigen, we propose that if the energy of the CO and NH backbone atoms' non-covalent interactions with all other atoms is negligible as compared with the energy of other non-covalent interactions, then the retroinverso isomer can mimic the original peptide/protein. Previous work has established that the structure of the inverso analog of a protein will be the mirror image of the protein, and it will only recognize the respective mirror image substrate/binding partner. The retro peptide conformation that can be superimposed on all side chains in any conformation of the original peptide does not exist in the conformational space of the peptides.

Retroinverso mimetics of S peptide

The S peptide from ribonuclease S was used as a model system to explore the relationship between the native peptide and its retroinverso (RI) analog. As probed by circular dichroism, the conformations of S peptide and retroinverso S peptide (RIS peptide) are each right-handed helical conformation. The helical propensity of retro S peptide is greater than S peptide, in trifluoroethanol (TFE). In 70% TFE, the S peptide possesses greater helicity at pH 4 than at pH 7, whereas RIS peptide possesses greater helicity at pH 7 than at pH 4. The RIS peptide does not mimic the S peptide in binding to S protein. Specifically, the RIS peptide does not mimic the S peptide to effect RNase activity with S protein and it also does not inhibit the RNase activity of S peptide with S protein. The biological mimicry between the S peptide and its RIS analog depends on the conformation and relatedness of both the side chain and backbone substructures. The backbones in the S peptide and its RIS analog are reverted with respect to each other; however, the side chain patterns are predicted to be similar. Importantly, if the molecular interactions of backbone atoms of the S peptide and its binding to S protein, then the RIS analog would be unlikely to mimic this parent peptide.

Structural and functional studies on Ribonuclease S, retro S and retro-inverso S peptides

Ribonuclease S peptide and S protein offer a unique complementation system to understand the finer features of molecular recognition. In the present study the S peptide (1-16), and its retro and retro-inverso analogs have been analyzed for their structural and biological attributes. RPHPLC, CD, and NMR analyses have revealed that the physicochemical and conformational properties of the S peptide are distinct from those of its retro and retro-inverso analogs. On the functional side, while the S peptide complemented the S protein to give RNase activity, was recognized by anti-S peptide antibodies and induced T cell proliferation, neither the retro nor the retro-inverso S peptides could do so.

Structural analogues of smoothened intracellular loops as potent inhibitors of Hedgehog pathway and cancer cell growth

Smoothened is a critical component of the Hedgehog pathway that is essential for stem cell renewal and is dysregulated in many cancer types. We have found synthetic analogues of the second and third intracellular loops of smoothened to be potent inhibitors of the Hedgehog pathway. Palmitoylated peptides as short as 10 residues inhibited melanoma cells growth with IC50 in the low nanomolar range. The compounds are promising drug candidates and convenient tools for solving mechanisms of Hedgehog signaling.

Sequence-simplification and chimeric assembly: new models of peptide antigen modification

Sequence-simplified variants of a 15-mer peptide antigen, identified by amino acid side chains in alternating positions were synthesized introducing glycine residues alternatively in the parent peptide sequence and used to induce antibodies in rabbit. They reacted to a significant extent with anti-parent peptide antibodies, and in addition, affinity purified antibodies against these halved forms recognized with similar affinity and specificity, the starting peptide in affinity chromatography, optical biosensor and enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) experiments, while no cross-reactivity was detected between reduced antigens. These findings suggest that a peptide antigen can display two molecular surfaces of recognition, identified by side chains of residues in alternating positions. Each surface can even take part in antigen/antibody interaction independently, thus indicating the possibility to select and assembly sequence-simplified forms belonging to different epitopes, also deriving from different molecules, to generate new structures incorporating a two-fold antigen/antibody specificity. Two "chimeric" forms were then synthesized starting from the P15 and P13 complementary peptides, both able to bind interleukin 2. These structures, showing simultaneously trans-surfaces of recognition belonging to both parent forms, have been found to retain antigenic properties against antibodies of simplified P15 derivatives showing the same molecular surface of recognition. In addition, anti-chimeric antibodies recognized both P15 and P13 starting peptides, while no cross-antibody recognition was observed between chimeric antigens.

Structural characterization of peptide hormone/receptor interactions by NMR spectroscopy

The structural characterization of peptide hormones and their interaction with G-protein (guanine nucleotide-binding regulatory protein) coupled receptors by high-resolution nmr is described. The general approaches utilized can be categorized into three different classes based on their target: the ligand, the receptor, and the ligand/receptor complex. Examples of these different approaches, aimed at facilitating the rational design of peptides and peptidomimetics with improved pharmacological profiles, based on work carried out in our own laboratory, are given. In the ligand-based approach, the high-resolution structures of bradykinin analogues allowing for the development of a structure-activity relationship for activation of the B1 receptor are described. Studies targeting the receptor are to a large extent theoretical, based on computational molecular modeling. However, experimentally based structural features provided by high-resolution nmr can be used to great advantage, providing insight into the mechanism of receptor function, as illustrated here with results from parathyroid hormone. A similar combination of theoretical methods, supplemented by high-resolution structures from nmr has been utilized to probe the formation and stabilization of the ligand/receptor complex both for parathyroid hormone and cholecystokinin. In each of these three approaches, the importance of well-designed peptide mimetics and accurate structural analysis by high-resolution nmr, will be highlighted.

Comparison of the solution conformations of a cell-adhesive peptide LBE and its reverse sequence EBL

T-cell adhesion is mediated by an ICAM-1/LFA-1 interaction; this interaction plays a crucial role in T-cell activation during immune response. LBE peptide, which is derived from the beta-subunit of LFA-1, has been shown to inhibit ICAM-1/LFA-1-mediated T-cell adhesion. In this work, we studied the solution conformations of LBE peptide and its reverse sequence (EBL) by NMR, CD and molecular dynamics simulations. Reverse peptides have been used as controls in biological studies. The effect of reversing the sequence of LBE to EBL peptides on their respective conformations is important in understanding their biological properties in vitro or in vivo. The NMR studies for these peptides were carried out in water and in TFE/water solvent systems. In 40% TFE/water, both peptides exhibited helical conformation. CD studies suggested that the LBE exhibits 30% helical conformation, while the EBL exhibits 20% helical conformation. From the NMR and MD simulation studies, it was evident that the peptides exhibited a stable helical conformation; a stable helical structure was found at Leu6 to Leu15 for LBE and at Gly9 to Leu17 for EBL. The helical conformations of LBE and EBL may be in equilibrium with other possible conformers; the other conformers contain loop and turn structures. Both peptides bind to divalent cations because the LBE is derived from the cation-binding region of the LFA-1. This study shows that reversing the peptide sequence did not alter the secondary structure of the corresponding sequence. Hence, caution must be exercised when using reverse peptides as controls in biological studies. This report will improve our ability to design a better inhibitor of ICAM-1/LFA-1 interaction.

Studies on the relationship between structure and electrophoretic mobility of alpha-helical and beta-sheet peptides using capillary zone electrophoresis

The electrophoretic behaviour of a series of 33 different synthetic peptides has been investigated using free solution high-performance capillary zonal electrophoretic (HPCZE) methods. The dependency of the electrophoretic mobility, mu(em), on the peptide charge, q, and on the charge-to-size ratio parameter, zeta, determined according to several electromobility models, have been examined. Significant divergences from linearity in the mu(em) vs. q or the mu(em) vs. zeta plots were noted for several peptides, possibly due to the proclivity of specific arrangements of their amino acid sequences to assume preferred alpha-helical or beta-sheet conformational features rather than random coil structures under the HPCZE conditions. These results provide further demonstration of the facility of HPCZE procedures to probe the effects of compositional, sequential and conformational differences of closely-related peptides and their consequences on their physicochemical behaviour in solution.

Observations on the origin of the non-linear van't Hoff behaviour of polypeptides in hydrophobic environments

In this paper we describe a general procedure to determine the thermodynamic parameters associated with the interaction of polypeptides or proteins with immobilised lipophilic compounds such as non-polar n-octyl groups. To this end, the binding behaviour of an all L-alpha-polypeptide, 1, and its retro-inverso-isomer, 2, has been investigated with an n-octylsilica and water-organic solvent mixture containing different percentages of acetonitrile or methanol over the temperature range of 278-338 K. The results confirm that non-linear van'ts Hoff plots occur with this pair of polypeptide isomers, depending on the solvent composition. These findings are consistent with the changes in the thermodynamic parameters, enthalpy of association, delta Hoassoc,i, entropy of association, delta Soassoc,i, and heat capacity, delta Cop,i, all having significant temperature dependencies. Theoretical relationship linking the changes in the delta Hoassoc,i, delta Soassoc,i and delta Cop,i values of these polypeptide-non-polar ligate systems, as a function of temperature, T, have been validated. Significant differences were observed in the magnitudes of these thermodynamic quantities when acetonitrile or methanol was employed as the organic solvent. The origin of these solvent-dependent effects can be attributed to the hydrogen-bonding propensity of the respective solvent. Involvement of enthalpy-entropy compensation effects associated with the interaction of these polypeptides with the hydrophobic ligates has also been documented. Analysis of empirical extra-thermodynamic relationships associated with molecular structural properties of these polypeptides, such as the slope term, S, derived from the plots of the logarithmic capacity factor, log k'i, of these polypeptides vs. the volume fraction of the organic solvent, [symbol: see text] as a function of temperature, T, has also revealed similar correlations in terms of the interactive behaviour of polypeptides 1 and 2 under these experimental conditions. These findings provide an extended thermodynamic and extra-thermodynamic framework to examine the solvational, conformational and other equilibrium processes that polypeptides (or proteins) can undergo in the presence of n-alkylsilicas or other classes of immobilised hydrophobic surfaces. The experimental approach utilised in this study with these topologically similar polypeptides thus represents a generic procedure to explore the behaviour of polypeptides or proteins in non-polar environments in terms of their molecular properties and the associated linear free energy relationships that determine their interactive behaviour.

Solution structure of a retro-inverso peptide analogue mimicking the foot-and-mouth disease virus major antigenic site. Structural basis for its antigenic cross-reactivity with the parent peptide

The antigenic activity of a 19-mer peptide corresponding to the major antigenic region of foot-and-mouth disease virus and its retro-enantiomeric analogue was found to be completely abolished when they were tested in a biosensor system in trifluoroethanol. This suggests that the folding pattern, which is alpha-helix in trifluoroethanol (confirmed by CD measurement), does not correspond to the biologically relevant conformation(s) recognized by antibodies. The NMR structures of both peptides were thus determined in aqueous solution. These studies showed that the two peptides exhibit similar folding features, particularly in their C termini. This may explain in part the cross-reactive properties of the two peptides in aqueous solution. However, the retro-inverso analogue appears to be more rigid than the parent peptide and contains five atypical beta-turns. This feature may explain why retro-inverso foot-and-mouth disease virus peptides are often better recognized than the parent peptide by anti-virion antibodies.