Histone hyperacetylation is accompanied by changes in DNA topology in vivo

Analysis of DNA topology in yeast chromatin

Topology of closed circular DNA is affected by its packaging into nucleosomes and potentially by alteration of nucleosome structure. Changes in topology that reflect alterations in chromatin structure can be measured and quantified using closed circular plasmids from living yeast. Here we describe detailed protocols for measuring DNA topology in yeast chromatin.

Molecular mechanism of rat NHE3 gene promoter regulation by sodium butyrate

Sodium butyrate (NaB) stimulates sodium and water absorption by inducing colonic Na+/H+exchange. NaB induces Na+/H+exchanger (NHE)3 activity and protein and mRNA expression both in vivo and in vitro. Our previously published observations indicated that this induction is Ser/Thr kinase dependent and that NaB-responsive elements were localized within −320/−34 bp of the rat NHE3 promoter. Here we further delineate the mechanism of NaB-mediated NHE3 gene transcription. Transient and stable transfection of Caco-2 cells with NHE3 gene reporter constructs identified Sp binding site SpB at position −58/−55 nt as critical for NaB-mediated induction. Gel mobility shift (GMSA) and DNA affinity precipitation assays indicated NaB-induced binding of Sp3 and decreased binding of Sp1 to SpB element. While no changes in expression of Sp1 or Sp3 were noted, NaB induced phosphorylation of Sp1 and acetylation of Sp3. Sp3 was a more potent inducer of NHE3 gene transcription, which suggested that change in balance, favoring binding of Sp3 to the SpB site, would result in significant increase in NHE3 promoter activity. Small interfering RNA studies in Caco-2 cells and data from NaB-treated SL2 cells used as a reconstitution model confirmed this hypothesis. In addition to the SpB site, which played a permissive role, an upstream novel butyrate response element located at −196/−175 nt was necessary for maximal induction. GMSA identified a protein-DNA complex with a −196/−175 nt probe; this interaction was not affected by NaB treatment, thus suggesting that in response to NaB Sp3 binding to site SpB precedes and results in recruitment of the putative factor to this upstream site.

DNA-loop formation on nucleosomes shown by in situ scanning force microscopy of supercoiled DNA

The flexibility of the chromatin structure, necessary for the processing of the genomic DNA, is controlled by a number of factors where flexibility and mobility of the nucleosomes is essential. Here, the influence of DNA supercoiling on the structure of single nucleosomes is investigated. Circular supercoiled plasmid DNA sub-saturated with histones was visualized by scanning force microscopy (SFM) in aqueous solution. SFM-imaging compared with topological analysis indicates instability of nucleosomes when the salt concentration is raised from 10 mM to 100 mM NaCl. Nucleosomes were observed after the deposition to the used scanning surface, i.e. mica coated with polylysine. On the images, the nucleosomes appear with a high probability in end-loops near the apices of the superhelices. In 100 mM NaCl but not in 10 mM NaCl, a significant number of complexes present the nucleosomes on superhelical crossings mainly located adjacent to an end-loop. The morphology of these structures and statistical analysis suggest that DNA loops were formed on the histone octamers, where the loop size distribution shows a pronounced peak at 50 nm. Recently, the formation and diffusion of loops on octamers has been discussed as a mechanism of translocations of nucleosomes along DNA. The presented data likely confirm the occurrence of loops, which may be stabilized by supercoiling. Analysis of the structure of regular nucleosomes not located on crossings indicates that reducing the salt concentration leads to more conformations, where DNA is partially unwrapped from the distal ends of the octamer.

Activation of transiently transfected reporter genes in 3T3 Swiss cells by the inducers of differentiation/apoptosis - dimethylsulfoxide, hexamethylene bisacetamide and trichostatin A

Despite decades of investigation, the primary site of action of the prototypical inducers of differentiation, dimethylsulfoxide and hexamethylene bisacetamide (HMBA), has not been delineated. During studies designed to analyze cis-acting elements responsible for induction of stage-specific globin genes, we discovered the capacity of HMBA and dimethylsulfoxide to enhance the expression of transiently transfected reporter genes derived from globin and nonglobin gene promoters, prominently in nonerythroid 3T3 Swiss cells. The action of HMBA and dimethylsulfoxide in the transient transfection system resembled that of the inhibitor of histone deacetylases (HDACs), trichostatin A (TSA), in that the three agents enhanced reporter gene expression (a) regardless of the promoter employed, (b) with similar kinetics and (c) with an increase in the steady-state level of reporter mRNA. Transiently transfected DNA was assembled rapidly into a chromatinized structure in 3T3 cells, suggesting that transcription of reporter genes was at least in part repressed by chromatin organization. Nuclear run-on analyses indicated that dimethylsulfoxide and HMBA enhanced transcriptional initiation of the reporter and p21/WAF1/Cip1 genes. In contrast, TSA produced negligible effects on nuclear run-on transcription of these genes. HMBA and dimethylsulfoxide did not change the acetylation, phosphorylation, or methylation status of histones and did not activate stably transfected genes. Despite these differences, the three agents modulated the expression of common sets of cellular genes and induced differentiation or apoptosis in intact cells. The findings imply that HMBA and dimethylsulfoxide modulate transcription by a mechanism independent of histone acetylation.

Trichostatin A reduces hormone-induced transcription of theMMTVpromoter and has pleiotropic effects on its chromatin structure

The deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A (TSA) has long been used to study the relationship between gene transcription and the acetylation status of chromatin. We have used Xenopus laevis oocytes to study the effects of TSA on glucocorticoid receptor (GR)-dependent transcription and we have related these effects to changes in the chromatin structure of a reporter mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) promoter. We show that TSA induces a low level of constitutive transcription. This correlates with a change of acetylation pattern and a more open chromatin structure over the MMTV chromatin, and with specific acetylation and remodeling events in the promoter region. Specifically, a repositioning of initially randomly positioned nucleosomes along the distal MMTV long terminal repeat is seen. This nucleosome rearrangement is similar to the translational nucleosome positioning that occurs upon hormone activation. We also note a reduced hormone response in the presence of TSA. TSA effects have for a long time been associated with transcriptional activation and chromatin opening through inhibition of the deacetylation of histones. However, our results and those of others show that TSA-induced changes in expression and chromatin structure can be quite different in different promoter contexts and, thus, the effects of TSA are more complex than previously believed.

Suppression of promoter-dependent transcriptional activity of inducible nitric oxide synthase by sodium butyrate in colon cancer cells

Butyrate suppresses the growth of colon cancer cells, inducing differentiation and apoptosis in vitro. Increased expression of inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) and cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2) has been suggested to be closely involved in colon carcinogenesis. In this study, effects of sodium butyrate on the promoter-dependent transcriptional activity of iNOS and COX-2 genes were investigated in a colon cancer cell line, DLD-1, using a reporter gene assay system. Sodium butyrate significantly reduced promoter-dependent iNOS transcriptional activity dose-dependently at concentrations higher than 0.1 mM. COX-2 transcriptional activity was not suppressed, but slightly increased. While hyperacetylated histones appeared at concentrations of sodium butyrate suppressing iNOS gene promoter activity, promoter-dependent transcriptional activities of iNOS and COX-2 genes were both increased by the histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A. These results suggested that sodium butyrate exhibits differential effects on iNOS and COX-2 genes, acting to suppress iNOS expression via mechanisms independent of histone acetylation.

Chromatin condensation and sensitivity of DNA in situ to denaturation during cell cycle and apoptosis--a confocal microscopy study

The goal of this study was to construct high resolution 3D confocal images of regions of condensed and extended chromatin in cell nuclei and individual chromosomes. It has been shown previously that sensitivity of DNA in situ to denaturation correlates with chromatin condensation and varies during cell cycle and apoptosis. Thus, detection of DNA which was partially denatured in situ provided a means to image areas of condensed chromatin. DNA denaturation was detected using a metachromatic dye acridine orange (AO) which differentially stains single stranded (ss) and double-stranded (ds) DNA sections. Early studies of denaturability of cellular DNA utilized flow cytometry and standard fluorescence microscopy. These techniques could not reveal small local differences in DNA denaturability within cell nucleus or in individual chromosomes. For instance, it was not possible to detect the initial points of chromosome condensation in G2-phase of the division cycle or in apoptosis. In order to achieve this goal we have recently extended these studies by applying confocal microscopy. We investigated DNA denaturability in normal human fibroblasts and HL-60 leukemic cells, at different stages of cell cycle and apoptosis. Following removal of RNA and partial denaturation of DNA with acid cells were stained with AO. Green (530 nm) and red (640 nm) fluorescence (exc. 457 nm) of non-denatured and denatured DNA was imaged by confocal microscopy. Blind deconvolution was used to further improve the quality of 3D images. Photobleaching of AO fluorescence was minimized and a correction for chromatic aberration and register shift was implemented. Nuclei of interphase cells exhibited predominantly green fluorescence representing AO binding to ds DNA. Punctuate areas of red fluorescence representing AO binding to denatured DNA and most likely associated with local regions of condensed chromatin were also present in all interphase nuclei. The proportion of denatured DNA increased in cells entering mitosis. In prophase individual condensing chromosomes exhibited varied proportions of green and red fluorescence indicating different content of denatured chromatin. In some chromosomes bands of denatured and denaturation-resistant chromatin were clearly resolved. In metaphase and anaphase chromosomes exhibited red fluorescence along all length of their arms indicating the highest and uniform susceptibility to denaturation. In telophase chromosomes contained predominantly denaturation-resistant DNA again and denaturated regions were significantly less abundant. At cytokinesis some decondensing chromosomes were still resolved. At this stage almost all regions of denatured DNA were located close to nuclear envelope. These regions may correspond to pockets of heterochromatin reforming at nuclear periphery. In early apoptosis condensation of chromatin appeared to commence in several distinct regions within nucleus. Some apoptotic bodies contained condensed chromatin surrounding central regions of extended chromatin. At late stages of apoptosis the whole volume of apoptotic bodies was occupied by condensed chromatin.

Nuclear Factor-κB and cAMP Response Element Binding Protein Mediate Opposite Transcriptional Effects on the Flk-1/KDR Gene Promoter

Abstract —The vascular endothelial growth factor receptor Flk-1/KDR is highly expressed during development and almost disappears in adult tissues. Despite its biological relevance, little is known about the molecular mechanisms controlling its expression. In the present work, it is shown that cAMP response element binding protein (CREB) and nuclear factor-κB (NF-κB)–related antigens bind specific sequences in the Flk-1/KDR promoter. Functional studies demonstrate that cAMP represses whereas tumor necrosis factor-α, an activator of NF-κB, stimulates promoter activity. Histone acetyltransferases (HATs) P/CAF and CBP/p300 together with p65/RelA, the catalytic subunit of NF-κB, increase Flk-1/KDR promoter activity 10- to 20-fold. Consistently, inhibition by cAMP is reverted by increasing intracellular HATs and is completely abolished by site-specific mutagenesis of the cAMP response element. In contrast, specific mutations in the NF-κB response element abolish responsiveness to p65/RelA and HATs without affecting cAMP-dependent repression. These results suggest that opposing signaling pathways, activating NF-κB or CREB and requiring HAT molecules, control Flk-1/KDR promoter activity. The full text of this article is available at http://www.circresaha.org.

Effect of in vivo histone hyperacetylation on the state of chromatin fibers

We evaluated the contribution of in vivo histone acetylation to the folding of chromatin into its higher-order structures. We have compared high-order folding patterns of hyperacetylated vs. unmodified chromatin in living green monkey kidney cells (CV1 line) using intercalator chloroquine diphospate to induce alterations in the twist of internucleosomal linker DNA. We have shown that histone hyperacetylation induced by antibiotic Trichostatin A significantly alters intercalator-mediated chromatin folding pattern.

Alteration of nucleosome structure as a mechanism of transcriptional regulation

The nucleosome, which is the primary building block of chromatin, is not a static structure: It can adopt alternative conformations. Changes in solution conditions or changes in histone acetylation state cause nucleosomes and nucleosomal arrays to behave with altered biophysical properties. Distinct subpopulations of nucleosomes isolated from cells have chromatographic properties and nuclease sensitivity different from those of bulk nucleosomes. Recently, proteins that were initially identified as necessary for transcriptional regulation have been shown to alter nucleosomal structure. These proteins are found in three types of multiprotein complexes that can acetylate nucleosomes, deacetylate nucleosomes, or alter nucleosome structure in an ATP-dependent manner. The direct modification of nucleosome structure by these complexes is likely to play a central role in appropriate regulation of eukaryotic genes.

Histone acetylation is required to maintain the unfolded nucleosome structure associated with transcribing DNA

Nucleosomes associated with transcribing chromatin of mammalian cells have an unfolded structure in which the normally buried cysteinyl-thiol group of histone H3 is exposed. In this study we analyzed transcriptionally active/competent DNA-enriched chromatin fractions from chicken mature and immature erythrocytes for the presence of thiol-reactive nucleosomes using organomercury-agarose column chromatography and hydroxylapatite dissociation chromatography of chromatin fractions labeled with [3H]iodoacetate. In mature and immature erythrocytes, the active DNA-enriched chromatin fractions are associated with histones that are rapidly highly acetylated and rapidly deacetylated. When histone deacetylation was prevented by incubating cells with histone deacetylase inhibitors, sodium butyrate or trichostatin A, thiol-reactive H3 of unfolded nucleosomes was detected in the soluble chromatin and nuclear skeleton-associated chromatin of immature, but not mature, erythrocytes. We did not find thiol-reactive nucleosomes in active DNA-enriched chromatin fractions of untreated immature erythrocytes that had low levels of highly acetylated histones H3 and H4 or in chromatin of immature cells incubated with inhibitors of transcription elongation. This study shows that transcription elongation is required to form, and histone acetylation is needed to maintain, the unfolded structure of transcribing nucleosomes.

Chromatin fiber structure: morphology, molecular determinants, structural transitions

Despite more than 20 years of research, the structure of the chromatin fiber and its molecular determinants remain enigmatic. Recent developments in high-resolution microscopic techniques, as well as the application of mathematical modeling to chromatin fiber structure, have allowed the acquisition of some new insights into the structure and its determinants. Here we present some of the newest data on the structure of the chromatin fiber in both its extended and compacted states, and bring together this new knowledge with older data in an attempt to provide a unified view of how chromatin components interact with each other to form its various conformations. The structural transitions that are believed to take place during transcriptional activation and its cessation are also discussed. It becomes obvious that despite some progress in our understanding of the fiber structure and its dynamics, huge gaps continue to exist. Bridging these gaps will require further improvements in already available techniques and the introduction of completely new approaches.

Nuclear matrix, dynamic histone acetylation and transcriptionally active chromatin

The nuclear matrix, the RNA-protein skeleton of the nucleus, has a role in the organization and function of nuclear DNA. Nuclear processes associated with the nuclear matrix include transcription, replication and dynamic histone acetylation. Nuclear matrix proteins, which are tissue and cell type specific, are altered with transformation and state of differentiation. Transcription factors are associated with the nuclear matrix, with the spectra of nuclear matrix bound factors being cell type specific. There is compelling evidence that the transcription machinery is anchored to the nuclear matrix, and the chromatin fiber is spooled through this complex. Transcriptionally active chromatin domains are associated with dynamically acetylated histones. The energy exhaustive process of dynamic histone acetylation has several functions. Acetylation of the N-terminal tails of the core histones alters nucleosome and higher order chromatin structure, aiding transcriptional elongation and facilitating the binding of transcription factors to nucleosomes associated with regulatory DNA sequences. Histone acetylation can manipulate the interactions of regulatory proteins that bind to the N-terminal tails of the core histones. Lastly, dynamic acetylation may contribute to the transient attachment of transcriptionally active chromatin to the nuclear matrix. Reversible histone acetylation is catalyzed by histone acetyltransferase and deacetylase, enzymes associated with the nuclear matrix. The recent isolation and characterization of histone acetyltransferase and deacetylase reveals that these enzymes are related to transcriptional regulators, providing us with new insights about how these enzymes are targeted to nuclear matrix sites engaged in transcription.

The nuclear matrix and the regulation of chromatin organization and function

Nuclear DNA is organized into loop domains, with the base of the loop being bound to the nuclear matrix. Loops with transcriptionally active and/or potentially active genes have a DNase I-sensitive chromatin structure, while repressed chromatin loops have a condensed configuration that is essentially invisible to the transcription machinery. Core histone acetylation and torsional stress appear to be responsible for the generation and/or maintenance of the open potentially active chromatin loops. The transcriptionally active region of the loop makes several dynamic attachments with the nuclear matrix and is associated with core histones that are dynamically acetylated. Histone acetyltransferase and deacetylase, which catalyze this rapid acetylation and deacetylation, are bound to the nuclear matrix. Several transcription factors are components of the nuclear matrix. Histone acetyltransferase, deacetylase, and transcription factors may contribute to the dynamic attachment of the active chromatin domains with the nuclear matrix at sites of ongoing transcription.

Histone H4 and the maintenance of genome integrity

The normal progression of Saccharomyces cerevisiae through nuclear division requires the function of the amino-terminal domain of histone H4. Mutations that delete the domain, or alter 4 conserved lysine residues within the domain, cause a marked delay during the G2+M phases of the cell cycle. Site-directed mutagenesis of single and multiple lysine residues failed to map this phenotype to any particular site; the defect was only observed when all four lysines were mutated. Starting with a quadruple lysine-to-glutamine substitution allele, the insertion of a tripeptide containing a single extra lysine residue suppressed the G2+M cell cycle defect. Thus, the amino-terminal domain of histone H4 has novel genetic functions that depend on the presence of lysine per se, and not a specific primary peptide sequence. To determine the nature of this function, we examined H4 mutants that were also defective for G2/M checkpoint pathways. Disruption of the mitotic spindle checkpoint pathway had no effect on the phenotype of the histone amino-terminal domain mutant. However, disruption of RAD9, which is part of the pathway that monitors DNA integrity, caused precocious progression of the H4 mutant through nuclear division and increased cell death. These results indicate that the lysine-dependent function of histone H4 is required for the maintenance of genome integrity, and that DNA damage resulting from the loss of this function activates the RAD9-dependent G2/M checkpoint pathway.

Presence of negative torsional tension in the promoter region of the transcriptionally poised dihydrofolate reductase gene in vivo

DNA topology has been suggested to play an important role in the process of transcription. Negative torsional tension has been shown to stimulate both pre-initiation complex formation and promoter clearance on plasmid DNA in vitro. We recently showed that genomic DNA in human cells contains localized torsional tension. In the present study we have further characterized and mapped torsional tension in the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) gene in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells and investigated the effects of differential rates of transcription on the magnitude and location of this tension. Using psoralen photo-cross-linking in conjunction with X-irradiation, we found that relaxable psoralen hypersensitivity was specifically localized to the promoter region of the serum-regulated DHFR gene in serum-stimulated, but not in serum-starved, cells. Moreover, this hypersensitivity did not appear to be caused by transcription elongation, since it persisted in cells in which transcription of the DHFR gene had been reduced by the transcription inhibitor 5,6-dichloro-1-beta-D-ribofurano-sylbenzimidazole (DRB). We suggest that the generation of negative torsional tension in DNA may play an important role in gene regulation by poising genes for transcription.

Dependence of transcriptional repression on CpG methylation density

CpG methylation is known to suppress transcription. This repression is generally thought to be related to alterations of chromatin structure that are specified by the methylation. The nature of these chromatin alterations is unknown. Moreover, it has not been clear if the methylation repression occurs in an all-or-none fashion at some critical methylation density, or if intermediate densities of methylation can give intermediate levels of repression. Here I report a stable episomal system which recapitulates many dynamic features of methylation observed in the genome. I have determined the extent of transcriptional repression as a function of four densities of CpG methylation. I find that the repression is a graded but exponential function of the CpG methylation density such that low levels of methylation yield a 67 to 90% inhibition of gene expression. Higher levels of methylation extinguished gene expression completely. Transcription from methylated minichromosomes can be increased by butyrate treatment, suggesting that histone acetylation can reverse some of the repression specified by the methylated state. Sites of preferential demethylation occurred and may have resulted from transcription factor binding or DNA looping.

Dependence of transcriptional repression on CpG methylation density

CpG methylation is known to suppress transcription. This repression is generally thought to be related to alterations of chromatin structure that are specified by the methylation. The nature of these chromatin alterations is unknown. Moreover, it has not been clear if the methylation repression occurs in an all-or-none fashion at some critical methylation density, or if intermediate densities of methylation can give intermediate levels of repression. Here I report a stable episomal system which recapitulates many dynamic features of methylation observed in the genome. I have determined the extent of transcriptional repression as a function of four densities of CpG methylation. I find that the repression is a graded but exponential function of the CpG methylation density such that low levels of methylation yield a 67 to 90% inhibition of gene expression. Higher levels of methylation extinguished gene expression completely. Transcription from methylated minichromosomes can be increased by butyrate treatment, suggesting that histone acetylation can reverse some of the repression specified by the methylated state. Sites of preferential demethylation occurred and may have resulted from transcription factor binding or DNA looping.

Gene expression within a chromatin domain: the role of core histone hyperacetylation

Scaffold-attached regions (SAR elements) increase transcriptional rates for integrated but not episomal templates, and this effect can be potentiated by using an epigenetically active reagent, butyrate. The action of butyrate is a direct one, not involving de novo protein synthesis, and can be mimicked by using a novel and highly specific inhibitor of histone deacetylases, (R)-trichostatin A. This leads to a model in which SAR elements serve to stabilize the chromosomal topology arising as a consequence of hyperacetylation of histone cores. The synergistic effects of histone hyperacetylation and SARs are mediated by promoter upstream elements since, for a simple TATA box, the response to both parameters is an additive one.

Effects of histone acetylation on chromatin topology in vivo

Recently a model for eukaryotic transcriptional activation has been proposed in which histone hyperacetylation causes release of nucleosomal supercoils, and this unconstrained tension in turn stimulates transcription (V. G. Norton, B. S. Imai, P. Yau, and E. M. Bradbury, Cell 57:449-457, 1989; V. G. Norton, K. W. Marvin, P. Yau, and E. M. Bradbury, J. Biol. Chem. 265:19848-19852, 1990). These studies analyzed the effect of histone hyperacetylation on the change in topological linking number which occurs during nucleosome assembly in vitro. We have tested this model by determining the effect of histone hyperacetylation on the linking number change which occurs during assembly in vivo. We find that butyrate treatment of cells infected with simian virus 40 results in hyperacetylation of the histones of the extracted viral minichromosome as expected. However, the change in constrained supercoils of the minichromosome DNA is minimal, a result which is inconsistent with the proposed model. These results indicate that the proposed mechanism of transcriptional activation is unlikely to take place in the cell.

Effects of histone acetylation on chromatin topology in vivo

Recently a model for eukaryotic transcriptional activation has been proposed in which histone hyperacetylation causes release of nucleosomal supercoils, and this unconstrained tension in turn stimulates transcription (V. G. Norton, B. S. Imai, P. Yau, and E. M. Bradbury, Cell 57:449-457, 1989; V. G. Norton, K. W. Marvin, P. Yau, and E. M. Bradbury, J. Biol. Chem. 265:19848-19852, 1990). These studies analyzed the effect of histone hyperacetylation on the change in topological linking number which occurs during nucleosome assembly in vitro. We have tested this model by determining the effect of histone hyperacetylation on the linking number change which occurs during assembly in vivo. We find that butyrate treatment of cells infected with simian virus 40 results in hyperacetylation of the histones of the extracted viral minichromosome as expected. However, the change in constrained supercoils of the minichromosome DNA is minimal, a result which is inconsistent with the proposed model. These results indicate that the proposed mechanism of transcriptional activation is unlikely to take place in the cell.