Conformational analysis of the melanin-concentrating hormone core by circular dichroic spectroscopy. Disulphide bridge and tyrosine contributions

Glycoconjugate vaccine batch consistency assessed by objective comparison of circular dichroism spectra

Circular dichroism (CD) spectra of biopharmaceutical protein, or protein conjugate, products contain information about their secondary and tertiary structures, which can answer to increasing regulatory interest in demonstrating consistent higher order structures of production batches. Widespread routine use of CD in a regulatory environment requires objective, statistically based, and validated methods to analyse and compare spectra against product specifications. Correlation approaches to compare spectra, developed and tested on monoclonal antibodies, are here used to assess the consistency of Hib PRP-CRM197 glycoconjugate immunogen batches, by analysis of historical data sets. Deconvolution of spectra into Gaussian peaks was used to model the spectrum and allow a more detailed description of spectral differences. Two groups of spectra [and hence samples] were distinguished. The analyses are discussed in the context of spectral comparison approaches, inter-laboratory studies, potential regulatory use and sources of uncertainty between spectra. Data analysis methods implemented here can also support stability and formulation studies.

Self-homodimerization of an actinoporin by disulfide bridging reveals implications for their structure and pore formation

The Trp111 to Cys mutant of sticholysin I, an actinoporin from Stichodactyla helianthus sea anemone, forms a homodimer via a disulfide bridge. The purified dimer is 193 times less hemolytic than the monomer. Ultracentrifugation, dynamic light scattering and size-exclusion chromatography demonstrate that monomers and dimers are the only independent oligomeric states encountered. Indeed, circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopies showed that Trp/Tyr residues participate in homodimerization and that the dimer is less thermostable than the monomer. A homodimer three-dimensional model was constructed and indicates that Trp147/Tyr137 are at the homodimer interface. Spectroscopy results validated the 3D-model and assigned 85° to the disulfide bridge dihedral angle responsible for dimerization. The homodimer model suggests that alterations in the membrane/carbohydrate-binding sites in one of the monomers, as result of dimerization, could explain the decrease in the homodimer ability to form pores.

High-throughput SRCD using multi-well plates and its applications

The sample compartment for high-throughput synchrotron radiation circular dichroism (HT-SRCD) has been developed to satisfy an increased demand of protein characterisation in terms of folding and binding interaction properties not only in the traditional field of structural biology but also in the growing research area of material science with the potential to save time by 80%. As the understanding of protein behaviour in different solvent environments has increased dramatically the development of novel functions such as recombinant proteins modified to have different functions from harvesting solar energy to metabolonics for cleaning heavy and metal and organic molecule pollutions, there is a need to characterise speedily these system.

Characterisation of Conformational and Ligand Binding Properties of Membrane Proteins Using Synchrotron Radiation Circular Dichroism (SRCD)

Membrane proteins are notoriously difficult to crystallise for use in X-ray crystallographic structural determination, or too complex for NMR structural studies. Circular dichroism (CD) is a fast and relatively easy spectroscopic technique to study protein conformational behaviour in solution. The advantage of synchrotron radiation circular dichroism (SRCD) measured with synchrotron beamlines compared to the CD from benchtop instruments is the extended spectral far-UV region that increases the accuracy of secondary structure estimations, in particular under high ionic strength conditions. Membrane proteins are often available in small quantities, and for this SRCD measured at the Diamond B23 beamline has successfully facilitated molecular recognition studies. This was done by probing the local tertiary structure of aromatic amino acid residues upon addition of chiral or non-chiral ligands using long pathlength cells (1-5 cm) of small volume capacity (70 μl-350 μl). In this chapter we describe the use of SRCD to qualitatively and quantitatively screen ligand binding interactions (exemplified by Sbma, Ace1 and FsrC proteins); to distinguish between functionally similar drugs that exhibit different mechanisms of action towards membrane proteins (exemplified by FsrC); and to identify suitable detergent conditions to observe membrane protein-ligand interactions using stabilised proteins (exemplified by inositol transporters) as well as the stability of membrane proteins (exemplified by GalP, Ace1). The importance of the in solution characterisation of the conformational behaviour and ligand binding properties of proteins in both far- andnear-UV regions and the use of high-throughput CD (HT-CD) using 96- and 384-well multiplates to study the folding effects in various protein crystallisation buffers are also discussed.

CD spectroscopy: an essential tool for quality control of protein folding

The production of diffraction quality protein crystals for X-ray crystallography has been greatly accelerated by the development of high-throughput protein (HTP) methods, which enable a large number of crystallization conditions to be rapidly investigated. Monitoring sample quality and the effect of crystallization buffers on protein behavior in solution should be considered as part of the crystallization experiment. Circular Dichroism (CD) spectroscopy is the ideal technique for these tasks as it can be operated in a high-throughput mode. Using CD to screen ligand binding interactions could show whether protein function/activity is retained, altered, or lost under different crystallization conditions. In this chapter, several methods for high-throughput CD (HTCD) applied to the preparation of proteins for crystallization will be presented. Quality control (QC) of protein batches in terms of conformational folding is often disregarded in protein production. Examples of batch-to-batch variation in the local tertiary structure of aromatic side chain residues revealed by CD will be discussed. In some of the examples, the fact that ligand binding properties were affected by changes in folding clearly shows that the characterization of folding of recombinant protein batches should not be ignored but be implemented as an important part of protein quality control.

Ligand- and drug-binding studies of membrane proteins revealed through circular dichroism spectroscopy

A great number of membrane proteins have proven difficult to crystallise for use in X-ray crystallographic structural determination or too complex for NMR structural studies. Circular dichroism (CD) is a fast and relatively easy spectroscopic technique to study protein conformational behaviour. In this review examples of the applications of CD and synchrotron radiation CD (SRCD) to membrane protein ligand binding interaction studies are discussed. The availability of SRCD has been an important advancement in recent progress, most particularly because it can be used to extend the spectral region in the far-UV region (important for increasing the accuracy of secondary structure estimations) and for working with membrane proteins available in only small quantities for which SRCD has facilitated molecular recognition studies. Such studies have been accomplished by probing in the near-UV region the local tertiary structure of aromatic amino acid residues upon addition of chiral or non-chiral ligands using long pathlength cells of small volume capacity. In particular, this review describes the most recent use of the technique in the following areas: to obtain quantitative data on ligand binding (exemplified by the FsrC membrane sensor kinase receptor); to distinguish between functionally similar drugs that exhibit different mechanisms of action towards membrane proteins (exemplified by secretory phospholipase A2); and to identify suitable detergent conditions to observe membrane protein-ligand interactions using stabilised proteins (exemplified by the antiseptic transporter SugE). Finally, the importance of characterising in solution the conformational behaviour and ligand binding properties of proteins in both far- and near-UV regions is discussed. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Structural and biophysical characterisation of membrane protein-ligand binding.

Modulation of antigenicity related to changes in antibody flexibility upon lyophilization

Lyophilization is frequently used to increase the shelf-life of biopharmaceuticals containing antibodies. A case in which an anti-idiotypic antibody, MMA 383, substantially lost its in vivo immunogenic properties although the protein was not degraded, is investigated. The scanning transmission electron microscope allowed the MMA 383 Fab and Fc moieties to be resolved. By averaging the single antibodies, the angle between the Fab moieties can be calculated. Non-lyophilized antibodies displayed a wider range of shapes than their reconstituted, lyophilized counterparts. Accordingly, the angle between the two Fab fragments varied more, indicating greater flexibility. The tryptophan steady-state fluorescence intensity, steady-state fluorescence anisotropy and fluorescence lifetime, were smaller for the lyophilized antibodies. These were also more resistant towards thermal denaturation/aggregation. Circular dichroism spectra detected temperature-dependent differences between the two antibody types in the 236 nm region. The subtle but reproducible structural changes induced by lyophilization may be related to the loss of in vivo immunogenic properties.

Analysis of the structural organization and thermal stability of two spermadhesins. Calorimetric, circular dichroic and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopic studies

The CUB domain is a widespread 110-amino-acid module found in functionally diverse, often developmentally regulated proteins, for which an antiparallel beta-barrel topology similar to that in immunoglobulin V domains has been predicted. Spermadhesins have been proposed as a subgroup of this protein family built up by a single CUB domain architecture. To test the proposed structural model, we have analyzed the structural organization of two members of the spermadhesin protein family, porcine seminal plasma proteins I/II (PSP-I/PSP-II) heterodimer and bovine acidic seminal fluid protein (aSFP) homodimer, using differential scanning calorimetry, far-ultraviolet circular dichroism and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy. Thermal unfolding of PSP-I/PSP-II and aSFP were irreversible and followed a one-step process with transition temperatures (Tm) of 60.5 degrees C and 78.6 degrees C, respectively. The calorimetric enthalpy changes (delta Hcat) of thermal denaturation were 439 kJ/mol for PSP-I/PSP-II and 660 kJ/mol for aSFP dimer. Analysis of the calorimetric curves of PSP-I/PSP-II showed that the entire dimer constituted the cooperative unfolding unit. Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy and deconvolution of circular dichroic spectra using a convex constraint analysis indicated that beta-structure and turns are the major structural element of both PSP-I/PSP-II (53% of beta-sheet, 21% of turns) and aSFP (44% of beta-sheet, 36% of turns), and that the porcine and the bovine proteins contain little, if any, alpha-helical structure. Taken together, our results indicate that the porcine and the bovine spermadhesin molecules are probably all-beta-structure proteins, and would support a beta-barrel topology like that predicted for the CUB domain. Other beta-structure folds, such as the Greek-key pattern characteristic of many carbohydrate-binding protein domains cannot be eliminated. Finally, the same combination of biophysical techniques was used to characterize the residual secondary structure of thermally denatured forms of PSP-I/PSP-II and aSFP, and to emphasize the aggregation tendency of these forms.

The importance of extended conformations and, in particular, the PII conformation for the molecular recognition of peptides

Crystallographic, isotopic labeling nmr and transferred nuclear Overhauser effect studies have highlighted the extended conformation as a very important element of secondary structure at the binding site of many peptide/protein complexes including peptide inhibitors-enzymes, B-cell epitopes-antibodies, and T-cell epitopes-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) of class I and II complexes. This paper discusses the peptide ligand conformation consequences of these findings particularly in view of the identification of the PII conformation (left-handed extended polyproline II) in free solution.

The conformational equilibria of a renin inhibitor peptide in solution

The conformational equilibrium of a decapeptide renin inhibitor (Renin Inhibitory Peptide (RIP), NH-P-H-P-F-H-F-F-V-Y-K-CO2H) in water, methanol and trifluoroethanol has been investigated. The value of a combined spectroscopic approach was apparent, with the need to define conformational states that were mixtures of conformational forms. Similarities between this study and that of the Melanin Concentrating Hormone (MCH) core peptide (5-14) are notable [1]. In water, two beta-turn conformations and an extended form were found to be in equilibrium, with cis/trans isomerism at Pro-3. Extended conformations associated with the P(II) helix and irregular forms were more favoured in aqueous environments. In MeOH and TFE, two beta-turn conformations associated with overlapping sequences and cis/trans isomerism at Pro-3 amide bond were seen to be in equilibrium. 2D ROESY and chemical-exchange cross-peaks were detected by 1H NMR and used to build up detailed models of the interconverting beta-turn conformations of RIP.

Correlations between biological activities and conformational properties for human, salmon, eel, porcine calcitonins and Elcatonin elucidated by CD spectroscopy

Calcitonin (CT) inhibits osteoclastic bone resorption and induces calcium uptake from body fluids. A comparative study of the conformational behaviours of therapeutic calcitonins [salmon (s), eel (e), a synthetic eel calcitonin analogue (Elcatonin), porcine (p) and human (h) calcitonins] as a function of solvent polarity and temperature have been performed by circular dichroism spectroscopy. Elements of secondary structure were lacking in H2O but could be observed in 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol and sodium dodecyl sulphate. In particular, similar amounts of alpha-helical content (four alpha-helical turns) were estimated in trifluoroethanol despite the considerable differences in amino acid sequences. The relative ability to form an alpha helix, assessed by trifluoroethanol/H2O titration, was found to be Elcatonin > sCT > pCT > eCT > hCT. In Elcatonin, sCT, pCT and eCT the four alpha-helical turns were promoted almost completely in a single step, between 0 and 35% trifluoroethanol, unlike hCT where helical structure formation has been reported to involve two steps over the whole trifluoroethanol/H2O range [Arvinte, T. & Drake, A. F. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 6408-6414]. In SDS, which mimics the membrane environment, conformational differences (3-4 helical turns in Elcatonin, sCT, eCT versus one helical turn in pCT, hCT) were observed and correlate well with biological activity (Elcatonin = sCT = eCT > pCT = hCT). Low-temperature studies in a cryogenic solvent mixture showed the formation of high alpha-helix content (similar to that in trifluoroethanol) in Elcatonin, sCT, eCT and pCT, whilst a left-handed extended helix (3(1) helix) was formed in hCT. This is consistent with the hypothesis of 'linear' and 'helical' calcitonin receptors [Nakanuta, H., Orlowski, R. C. & Epand, R. M. (1990) Endocrinology 127, 163-169].

A partially folded state of hen egg white lysozyme in trifluoroethanol: structural characterization and implications for protein folding

The effect of 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) on the solution conformation of hen egg white lysozyme has been investigated using circular dichroism (CD) and 1H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Addition of TFE to lysozyme at pH 2.0, 27 degrees C, up to a concentration of 15% (v/v) induces only slight changes in the NMR spectrum. However, above this concentration a cooperative transition to a new but partially structured state of the protein is observed. This state shows no structural cooperativity against further denaturation and is characterized by an ellipticity in the far-UV CD greater than that of the native protein. Near-UV CD intensity is dramatically reduced compared with that of the native state, and 1H NMR studies indicate that side-chain interactions are substantially averaged in this denatured state. Solvent proton/deuterium exchange rates for 66 amide hydrogens were measured site-specifically by a combination of amide trapping experiments and 2D 1H NMR. Significant protection from exchange occurs for about 25 backbone amides, the majority of which are located in regions of the protein that are helical in the native enzyme. By contrast, amides located in a second region of the native protein which contains a beta-sheet and one 3(10)-helix as well as a long loop show little protection. This pattern of protection resembles that found in the stable molten globule state of alpha-lactalbumin and in an early kinetic intermediate detected in the refolding of hen lysozyme.