Quality of life in vitiligo patients after treatment with long-term narrowband ultraviolet B phototherapy

An Open-Label Non-Randomized Preliminary Noninferiority Study Comparing Home-Based Handheld Narrow-Band UVB Comb Device with Standard Hospital-Based Whole-Body Narrow-Band UVB Therapy in Localized Vitiligo

Background

Narrow-band ultraviolet B (NB-UVB) is the standard therapy for vitiligo.

Objective

The objective of this study is to compare the safety and clinical efficacy of a handheld NB-UVB comb device with the standard whole-body NB-UVB therapy in localized stable vitiligo.

Materials and Methods

Thirty-one vitiligo patients were allocated to either daily therapy with a home-based handheld comb device (group A, n = 17) or thrice-weekly hospital-based whole-body NB-UVB therapy (group B, n = 14) for 4 months, based on their preference. The primary and secondary outcomes were assessed at each follow-up, and appropriate statistical tools were used for analysis.

Results

Of the 31 patients enrolled, 26 patients (study groups A/B: 15/11) completed the study. Primary outcome: Median percentage repigmentation of the representative patch in groups A and B were 51.35% and 63.85%, respectively (P = 0.64). The median size reduction of the representative patch in both groups was statistically significant (P < 0.05). The mean difference between "per protocol analysis" and "intention to treat" showed noninferiority. Secondary outcomes: Both groups were comparable on Lund and Browder score, patient global assessment and investigator global assessment scores, adverse events, color match, and change in the quality of life. The comparison group had a significantly greater number of missed sessions (P = 0.02). The majority of patients had a "good" response in both groups.

Conclusion

Handheld NB-UVB comb device daily with a fixed dose of fluence was found to be noninferior with better compliance to standard whole-body NB-UVB therapy.

Quality of life measurement in vitiligo. Position statement of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology Task Force on Quality of Life and Patient Oriented Outcomes with external experts

Members of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology (EADV) Task Force on Quality of Life (QoL) and Patient Oriented Outcomes reviewed the instruments available for health-related (HR) QoL assessment in vitiligo and together with external vitiligo experts (including representatives of the EADV Vitiligo Task Force) have made practical recommendations concerning the assessment of QoL in vitiligo patients. The Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI) was the most frequently used HRQoL instrument, making comparison of results between different countries possible. Several vitiligo-specific instruments were identified. The vitiligo Impact Scale (VIS) is an extensively validated vitiligo-specific HRQoL instrument with proposed minimal important change and clinical interpretation for VIS-22 scores. VIS-22 was developed for use in India, where there are some specific cultural beliefs concerning vitiligo. The EADV Task Force on QoL and Patient Oriented Outcomes recommends use of the DLQI and the Children's Dermatology Life Quality Index (CDLQI) as dermatology-specific instruments in vitiligo. There is a strong need for a valid (including cross-cultural validation) vitiligo-specific instrument that can be either a new instrument or the improvement of existing instruments. This validation must include the proof of responsiveness.

The humanistic burden of vitiligo: a systematic literature review of quality-of-life outcomes

Despite historical mischaracterization as a cosmetic condition, patients with the autoimmune disorder vitiligo experience substantial quality-of-life (QoL) burden. This systematic literature review of peer-reviewed observational and interventional studies describes comprehensive evidence for humanistic burden in patients with vitiligo. PubMed, EMBASE, Scopus and the Cochrane databases were searched through February 10, 2021, to qualitatively assess QoL in vitiligo. Two independent reviewers assessed articles for inclusion and extracted data for qualitative synthesis. A total of 130 included studies were published between 1996 and 2021. Geographical regions with the most studies were Europe (32.3%) and the Middle East (26.9%). Dermatology-specific instruments, including the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI; 80 studies) and its variants for children (CDLQI; 10 studies) and families (FDLQI; 4 studies), as well as Skindex instruments (Skindex-29, 15 studies; Skindex-16, 4 studies), were most commonly used to measure humanistic burden. Vitiligo-specific instruments, including the Vitiligo-specific QoL (VitiQoL; 11 studies) instrument and 22-item Vitiligo Impact Scale (VIS-22; 4 studies), were administered in fewer studies. Among studies that reported total scores for the overall population, a majority revealed moderate or worse effects of vitiligo on patient QoL (DLQI, 35/54 studies; Skindex, 8/8 studies; VitiQoL, 6/6 studies; VIS-22, 3/3 studies). Vitiligo also had a significant impact on the QoL of families and caregivers; 4/4 studies reporting FDLQI scores indicated moderate or worse effects on QoL. In general, treatment significantly (P < 0.05) improved QoL, but there were no trends for types or duration of treatment. Among studies that reported factors significantly (P ≤ 0.05) associated with reduced QoL, female sex and visible lesions and/or lesions in sensitive areas were most common. In summary, vitiligo has clinically meaningful effects on the QoL of patients, highlighting that greater attention should be dedicated to QoL decrement awareness and improvement in patients with vitiligo.

Psychosocial Effects of Vitiligo: A Systematic Literature Review

Background

Patients with vitiligo experience reduced quality of life.

Objective

To comprehensively describe the available evidence for psychosocial burden in vitiligo.

Methods

A systematic review of observational studies and clinical trials identified using PubMed, EMBASE, Scopus, and the Cochrane databases was performed through 1 March, 2021, to assess psychosocial comorbidities in vitiligo. Two independent reviewers performed an assessment of articles and extracted data for qualitative synthesis.

Results

Included studies (N = 168) were published between 1979 and 1 March, 2021; 72.6% were published since 2010. Disorders including or related to depression (41 studies, 0.1–62.3%) and anxiety (20 studies, 1.9–67.9%) were the most commonly reported. The most prevalent psychosocial comorbidities were feelings of stigmatization (eight studies, 17.3–100%), adjustment disorders (12 studies, 4–93.9%), sleep disturbance (seven studies, 4.6–89.0%), relationship difficulties including sexual dysfunction (ten studies, 2.0–81.8%), and avoidance or restriction behavior (12.5–76%). The prevalence of most psychosocial comorbidities was significantly higher vs healthy individuals. Factors associated with a significantly higher burden included female sex, visible or genital lesions, age < 30 years (particularly adolescents), and greater body surface area involvement, among others. The most commonly reported patient coping strategy was lesion concealment.

Limitations

Available studies were heterogeneous and often had limited details; additionally, publication bias is possible.

Conclusions

The results of this systematic review show that vitiligo greatly affects psychosocial well-being. The extent of psychosocial comorbidities supports the use of multidisciplinary treatment strategies and education to address the vitiligo-associated burden of disease.

Protocol Registration

PROSPERO (CRD42020162223).

Graphic Abstract

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s40257-021-00631-6.

Questionnaire Modifications and Alternative Scoring Methods of the Dermatology Life Quality Index: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVES

Dermatology Life Quality index (DLQI) is the most widely used health-related quality of life questionnaire in dermatology. Little is known about existing questionnaire or scoring modifications of the DLQI. We aimed to systematically review, identify, and categorize all modified questionnaire versions and scoring methods of the DLQI.

METHODS

We performed a systematic literature search in PubMed, Web of Science, CINAHL, and PsychINFO. Methodologic quality and evidence of psychometric properties were assessed using the Consensus-Based Standards for the Selection of Health Measurement Instruments (COSMIN) and Terwee checklists.

RESULTS

The included 81 articles reported on 77 studies using 59 DLQI modifications. Modifications were used for a combined sample of 25 509 patients with 47 different diagnoses and symptoms from 28 countries. The most frequently studied diseases were psoriasis, hirsutism, acne, alopecia, and bromhidrosis. The modifications were categorized into the following nonmutually exclusive groups: bolt-ons or bolt-offs (48%), disease, symptom, and body part specifications (42%), changes in existing items (34%), scoring modifications (27%), recall period changes (19%), response scale modifications (15%), and illustrations (3%). The evidence concerning the quality of measurement properties was heterogeneous: 4 of 13 studies were rated positive on internal consistency, 1 of 3 on reliability, 3 of 5 on content validity, 9 of 22 on construct validity, 6 of 6 on criterion validity, and 1 of 1 on responsiveness.

CONCLUSION

An exceptionally large number of DLQI modifications have been used that may indicate an unmet need for adequate health-related quality of life instruments in dermatology. The psychometric overview of most questionnaire modifications is currently incomplete, and additional efforts are needed for proper validation.

Effect of combination NSAID and NBUVB treatment in non-photoadapters-A pilot study

BACKGROUND

Vitiligo is a disorder of dyspigmentation that can impact quality of life. While narrow-band ultraviolet B (NBUVB) is an effective treatment for vitiligo, a subset of patients are unable to respond to phototherapy as they cannot photoadapt. However, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) have been shown to increase the minimal erythema dose.

PURPOSE

To determine whether ibuprofen allows non-photoadapters to respond to therapeutic doses of NBUVB and maintain photoadaptation.

METHOD

Four patients unable to tolerate NBUVB or excimer past a dose of 1000 mJ/cm² were enrolled in the study and given ibuprofen 400 mg prior to phototherapy, which was performed 2-3 times a week. Patients were followed up to 72 treatments to demonstrate photoadaptation and maintenance of response to phototherapy. Patients were clinically monitored by serial photographs approximately every 12 treatments. Response to phototherapy was monitored by tracking the dose of NBUVB received at each session. Maintenance of response was monitored for six treatments after discontinuing the ibuprofen. Percent change in pigmentation was also recorded.

RESULTS

Three out of four subjects enrolled in the study were able to increase their doses of phototherapy to a therapeutic range, and subjects continued to photoadapt for six treatments after discontinuing ibuprofen. Two subjects achieved repigmentation during their course of phototherapy.

CONCLUSION

Ibuprofen may be a safe alternative to corticosteroids for select patients with vitiligo that are unable to photoadapt. It appears that the ability to photoadapt continues once ibuprofen is discontinued, negating the need for chronic use. Enabling photoadaptation allows patients to achieve therapeutic doses of NBUVB phototherapy, leading to repigmentation and improved outcomes.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

The trial was registered through Henry Ford Hospital IRB-No. 9744.

Review of narrowband ultraviolet B radiation in vitiligo

Vitiligo is a common, acquired pigmentary disorder of unknown etiology with great impact on patient’s appearance and quality of life. It presents a therapeutic challenge to many dermatologists. Photochemotherapy using psoralen and ultraviolet A (UVA) therapy, topical and oral immunosuppresants, as well as cosmetic camouflage are also commonly employed with varying clinical efficacy. Phototherapy is a popular treatment option, which includes both of the generalized ultraviolet B (UVB) therapies, broadband UVB and narrowband UVB (NB-UVB). It has been used favorably, both alone as well as in combination with other agents like topical calcineurin inhibitors, vitamin-D analogs. Combination therapies are useful and may provide quicker regimentation and treat vitiligo with an additive mechanism of action than UVB phototherapy. Advances in technology may lead to the continuing use of UVB phototherapy as a treatment for vitiligo through the development of sophisticated devices and delivery systems as well as innovative application methods. These will provide increased therapeutic options for all vitiligo patients, particularly those with refractory disease. In this article, I have reviewed the available data pertaining to efficacy and safety issues for NB-UVB as monotherapy, its comparison with psoralen plus UVA and other modes of phototherapy, combination regimens that have been tried and future prospects of NB-UVB in vitiligo.

Correlation of clinical efficacy and psychosocial impact on vitiligo patients by excimer laser treatment

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Vitiligo is a difficult disease to treat. Recently, a 308-nm excimer laser has been shown to be effective in treating vitiligo. In addition, the patients with vitiligo have impairment in their quality of life. The aim of the study was to investigate the clinical efficacy, safety, and psychosocial impact after treating vitiligo with the 308-nm excimer laser.

DESIGN AND SETTINGS

A prospective clinical trial conducted at dermatology clinics of hospitals affiliated with Qassim University, Saudi Arabia, from May 2012 to February 2013.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Forty-eight patients with 105 vitiliginous patches were treated using a 308-nm excimer laser. The treatment was performed twice per week for a maximum of 48 treatments or 100% repigmentation of lesions whichever was achieved first. The assessment of the clinical response and recording of side effects were performed biweekly.

RESULTS

Out of 105 lesions in these patients, 63 lesions (60.0%) achieved over 75% repigmentation by laser treatment, 12 lesions (11.4%) showed 51% to 75% repigmentation, 9 lesions (8.6%) showed 26% to 50% repigmentation, and another 9 lesions (8.6%) showed 1% to 25% repigmentation, while 12 lesions (11.4%) showed no repigmentation. The average (+/-standard deviation [SD]) number of sessions needed to achieve repigmentation was 16.8 (8.0), whereas the average (+/-SD) number of sessions needed to realize Grade IV repigmentation was 20.2 (15). The type of repigmentation varied between lesions. Diffuse repigmentation was the most common pattern and occurred in 34 lesions (36.6%). Facial lesions responded better than lesions located elsewhere. Skin type did not play a statistically significant role (P=.07) in the lesions response to treatment. All side effects were mild and disappeared shortly after end of treatment sessions.

CONCLUSION

The clinical data indicate that the treatment of vitiligo using the 308-nm excimer laser is effective and safe and improves psychosocial quality of life. Lesion location, duration of disease, and treatment duration are factors affecting the clinical and psychological outcome.

Vitiligo treatment options: An evolving scenario

Sequential displays of several treatment options for vitiligo have been scanned from the literature, and are presented here. A few of the medical modalities have been resigned to history, whereas others have become customary in clinical practice. There has also been a recent surge of interest in the surgical treatment of this disease. Accordingly, this has been appraised and summarized. Special attention has been given to prevalent medical modalities so that they may be effectively utilized by those currently in practice.

Treatment of vitiligo with narrow-band ultraviolet B: advantages and disadvantages

BACKGROUND

Narrow-band ultraviolet B (NB-UVB) therapy for vitiligo is increasingly used in patients who are unresponsive to other forms of therapy.

OBJECTIVE

This study measures levels of patient and physician satisfaction and the associated advantages and disadvantages of NB-UVB.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review was conducted of the first 50 patients with vitiligo treated at the Photoderm Clinic in Ottawa, Ontario. Data were obtained from digital photographs and patient charts (n = 50).

RESULTS

Percent repigmentation of the face and body was very good compared with the hands and feet (poor = 0-or< 33%; good = 33-or< 66%; very good = >or= 66%). The physician and patients were satisfied with results achieved with NB-UVB therapy (very good [VG]: medical doctor [MD] 49% [95% CI 35-63], patient [Pt] 51% [95% CI 37-65]; good [G]: MD 24% [95% CI 12-36], Pt 22% [95% CI 10-34]).

CONCLUSION

NB-UVB therapy is an effective treatment for vitiligo (ie, VG, repigmentation >or= 66%) that leads to high levels of patient and physician treatment-related satisfaction. Although there are disadvantages to NB-UVB therapy, the advantages outweigh the drawbacks. An objective evaluation such as the Vitiligo Area Scoring Index (VASI) is necessary to validate these findings. Additional limitations include those inherent in retrospective study design.

The Dermatology Life Quality Index 1994-2007: a comprehensive review of validation data and clinical results

BACKGROUND

The Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI) is one of the most widely used dermatology-specific quality of life instruments. Over the last 5 years there has been great interest in its use.

OBJECTIVES

To collect and present all information regarding the technical properties and the clinical use of the DLQI from the date it was published to the end of 2007 for use as a single source of reference.

METHODS

A detailed literature search was conducted using electronic reference databases and the DLQI library in the Department of Dermatology, Cardiff University. All publications mentioning any aspect of the DLQI, from the time of its development to the end of 2007, were identified and the data concerning the DLQI in terms of its psychometric analysis, and use in clinical trials, epidemiological studies and health services research, were extracted and tabulated with all the relevant references.

RESULTS

In total, 272 full articles which have included the DLQI were reviewed. Studies described in these articles were divided into five main categories: psychometric studies, descriptive/epidemiological studies, drug (topical and systemic) trials, clinical practice research, and therapeutic interventions. The DLQI has been used in 33 different skin conditions in 32 countries and is available in 55 languages. Psychometric aspects of the DLQI such as validity, reliability, responsiveness to change, factor structure, and minimal important difference were described in 115 studies. The DLQI has been used in 33 studies assessing the effectiveness of 14 different types of therapeutic interventions and in 37 studies evaluating nine types of clinical practice research. Sixty studies have used it alone or in parallel with other instruments as an outcome measure in clinical trials of 18 systemic drugs while 22 studies have used it in 14 different topical drug trials. The DLQI has also been used in 27 multinational studies.

CONCLUSIONS

During the last 14 years there has been a gradual increase in the international use of the DLQI. The brevity and simplicity of use of the DLQI has resulted in its popularity both in clinical practice and in research. However, there are various issues in particular regarding its unidimensionality, differential item functioning, and minimal clinically important difference, which require further research. This article should facilitate the work of potential users of the DLQI by providing a readily available source of references for different aspects of the DLQI.

Stigmatization experience, coping and sense of coherence in vitiligo patients

OBJECTIVE

This study examines the extent of stigmatization experienced by vitiligo patients considering the visibility of the lesions.

METHODS

363 vitiligo patients were assessed using the Experience with Skin Complaints (QES), Adjustment to Chronic Skin Disorders (ASC), and Sense of Coherence (SOC) questionnaires. Out of the total patients group two representative samples with 52 patients each were identified comparable for age, gender, and the duration of the skin disease, the first with visible and the second with invisible lesions.

RESULTS

Data indicate a significant negative correlation between the QES dimensions, except for 'Composure', and between coping scales with sense of coherence withstanding. The 'visible lesions' group scored higher compared to the 'invisible lesions' group on the two QES scales 'Self-Esteem' and 'Refusal', i.e., patients with visible lesions experienced a higher level of stigmatization.

CONCLUSION

This study provides new information which supports the notion that the stigmatization experience of vitiligo patients is psychologically relevant.

Quality of life with vitiligo: Comparison of male and female muslim patients in Iran

BACKGROUND

Vitiligo is a chronic pigmentary disorder of the skin that, although not life threatening, may considerably influence the psychological well-being of patients. It has been suggested that vitiligo patients suffer from low self-esteem, poor body image, and poor quality of life (QOL).

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to explore and compare QOL in male and female patients with vitiligo in Iran.

METHODS

To obtain the patients' self-assessment of QOL, we used a 17-item multiple-choice questionnaire based on the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI). All statistics used 2-way analysis of variance comparisons with an (alpha-risk of 5%. DLQI scores were assessed using nonparametric comparisons, and qualitative variables were compared with xi(2) testing. Categorical regression analyses were also used as an exploratory aim.

RESULTS

A total of 77 Muslim patients with vitiligo (53 females, 24 males; mean age, 29.3 years) were included in this survey. The mean (SD) DLQI score of 42.9 (11.4) for females was lower than that of 51.6 (8.8) for males (P = 0.002). Female patients experienced significantly more impairment of general and psychological health (P < 0.003), social relationships (P < 0.02), and sexual activity (P < 0.001) than did male patients.

CONCLUSIONS

This study indicates the specific areas of patients' lives that are most affected by vitiligo. Gender and location of disease independently affect QOL in Muslim patients in Iran. Women with vitiligo experience greater QOL impairment than their male counterparts.