Observer variability among colposcopists from the West Midlands region

Study protocol for a two-site clinical trial to validate a smartphone-based artificial intelligence classifier identifying cervical precancer and cancer in HPV-positive women in Cameroon

INTRODUCTION

Cervical cancer remains a major public health challenge in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) due to financial and logistical issues. WHO recommendation for cervical cancer screening in LMICs includes HPV testing as primary screening followed by visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA) and treatment. However, VIA is a subjective procedure dependent on the healthcare provider's experience. Its accuracy can be improved by computer-aided detection techniques. Our aim is to assess the performance of a smartphone-based Automated VIA Classifier (AVC) relying on Artificial Intelligence to discriminate precancerous and cancerous lesions from normal cervical tissue.

METHODS

The AVC study will be nested in an ongoing cervical cancer screening program called "3T-study" (for Test, Triage and Treat), including HPV self-sampling followed by VIA triage and treatment if needed. After application of acetic acid on the cervix, precancerous and cancerous cells whiten more rapidly than non-cancerous ones and their whiteness persists stronger overtime. The AVC relies on this key feature to determine whether the cervix is suspect for precancer or cancer. In order to train and validate the AVC, 6000 women aged 30 to 49 years meeting the inclusion criteria will be recruited on a voluntary basis, with an estimated 100 CIN2+, calculated using a confidence level of 95% and an estimated sensitivity of 90% +/-7% precision on either side. Diagnostic test performance of AVC test and two current standard tests (VIA and cytology) used routinely for triage will be evaluated and compared. Histopathological examination will serve as reference standard. Participants' and providers' acceptability of the technology will also be assessed. The study protocol was registered under ClinicalTrials.gov (number NCT04859530).

EXPECTED RESULTS

The study will determine whether AVC test can be an effective method for cervical cancer screening in LMICs.

Classification of high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia by p16ink4a , Ki-67, HPV E4 and FAM19A4/miR124-2 methylation status demonstrates considerable heterogeneity with potential consequences for management

High‐grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN2 and CIN3) represents a heterogeneous disease with varying cancer progression risks. Biomarkers indicative for a productive human papillomavirus (HPV) infection (HPV E4) and a transforming HPV infection (p16^ink4a, Ki‐67 and host‐cell DNA methylation) could provide guidance for clinical management in women with high‐grade CIN. This study evaluates the cumulative score of immunohistochemical expression of p16^ink4a (Scores 0‐3) and Ki‐67 (Scores 0‐3), referred to as the “immunoscore” (IS), in 262 CIN2 and 235 CIN3 lesions derived from five European cohorts in relation to immunohistochemical HPV E4 expression and FAM19A4/miR124‐2 methylation in the corresponding cervical scrape. The immunoscore classification resulted in 30 lesions within IS group 0‐2 (6.0%), 151 lesions within IS group 3‐4 (30.4%) and 316 lesions within IS group 5‐6 (63.6%). E4 expression decreased significantly from CIN2 to CIN3 (P < .001) and with increasing immunoscore group (P_trend < .001). Methylation positivity increased significantly from CIN2 to CIN3 (P < .001) and with increasing immunoscore group (P_trend < .001). E4 expression was present in 9.8% of CIN3 (23/235) and in 12.0% of IS group 5‐6 (38/316). Notably, in a minority (43/497, 8.7%) of high‐grade lesions, characteristics of both transforming HPV infection (DNA hypermethylation) and productive HPV infection (E4 expression) were found simultaneously. Next, we stratified all high‐grade CIN lesions, based on the presumed cancer progression risk of the biomarkers used, into biomarker profiles. These biomarker profiles, including immunoscore and methylation status, could help the clinician in the decision for immediate treatment or a “wait and see” policy to reduce overtreatment of high‐grade CIN lesions.

What's new?

Treating all high‐grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN2/3) with excisional therapy leads to overtreatment, as these lesions have varying cancer progression risks. Here, the authors evaluated expression patterns of p16^ink4a, Ki‐67 and the HPV E4 protein, and methylation of FAM19A4/miR124‐2 in high‐grade CIN. The biomarker expression patterns revealed the high degree of heterogeneity among CIN2/3 lesions. Biomarker profiles based on the presumed cancer progression risks were established and could guide clinicians in choosing whether to treat immediately or wait and see.

Using Dynamic Features for Automatic Cervical Precancer Detection

Cervical cancer remains a major public health concern in developing countries due to financial and human resource constraints. Visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA) of the cervix was widely promoted and routinely used as a low-cost primary screening test in low- and middle-income countries. It can be performed by a variety of health workers and the result is immediate. VIA provides a transient whitening effect which appears and disappears differently in precancerous and cancerous lesions, as compared to benign conditions. Colposcopes are often used during VIA to magnify the view of the cervix and allow clinicians to visually assess it. However, this assessment is generally subjective and unreliable even for experienced clinicians. Computer-aided techniques may improve the accuracy of VIA diagnosis and be an important determinant in the promotion of cervical cancer screening. This work proposes a smartphone-based solution that automatically detects cervical precancer from the dynamic features extracted from videos taken during VIA. The proposed solution achieves a sensitivity and specificity of 0.9 and 0.87 respectively, and could be a solution for screening in countries that suffer from the lack of expensive tools such as colposcopes and well-trained clinicians.

Clinical Applications of Telemedicine in Gynecology and Women's Health

Telemedicine and telehealth (TM/TH) are the 2 terms used interchangeably focusing on the delivery of health care services at a long distance using telecommunication technology. TM/TH has several gynecologic applications, including the well-woman visits, preventive care, preconception counseling, family planning including contraception and medical abortion, infertility workup, teleradiology, cervical cancer screening and colposcopy, mental health, and telesurgery. The goals of TM/TH are not only improving quality of health care in patients and building a virtual community of physicians but also increasing convenience, efficacy, and decreasing medical cost. In gynecology, TM/TH plays an important role, especially in well-woman care.

Evaluating diagnostic indicators of urogenital Schistosoma haematobium infection in young women: A cross sectional study in rural South Africa

BACKGROUND

Urine microscopy is the standard diagnostic method for urogenital S. haematobium infection. However, this may lead to under-diagnosis of urogenital schistosomiasis, as the disease may present itself with genital symptoms in the absence of ova in the urine. Currently there is no single reliable and affordable diagnostic method to diagnose the full spectrum of urogenital S. haematobium infection. In this study we explore the classic indicators in the diagnosis of urogenital S. haematobium infection, with focus on young women.

METHODS

In a cross-sectional study of 1237 sexually active young women in rural South Africa, we assessed four diagnostic indicators of urogenital S. haematobium infection: microscopy of urine, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of cervicovaginal lavage (CVL), urogenital symptoms, and sandy patches detected clinically in combination with computerised image analysis of photocolposcopic images. We estimated the accuracy of these diagnostic indicators through the following analyses: 1) cross tabulation (assumed empirical gold standard) of the tests against the combined findings of sandy patches and/or computerized image analysis and 2) a latent class model of the four indicators without assuming any gold standard.

RESULTS

The empirical approach showed that urine microscopy had a sensitivity of 34.7% and specificity of 75.2% while the latent class analysis approach (LCA) suggested a sensitivity of 81.0% and specificity of 85.6%. The empirical approach and LCA showed that Schistosoma PCR in CVL had low sensitivity (14.1% and 52.4%, respectively) and high specificity (93.0% and 98.0, respectively). Using LCA, the presence of sandy patches showed a sensitivity of 81.6 and specificity of 42.4%. The empirical approach and LCA showed that urogenital symptoms had a high sensitivity (89.4% and 100.0%, respectively), whereas specificity was low (10.6% and 12.3%, respectively).

CONCLUSION

All the diagnostic indicators used in the study had limited accuracy. Using urine microscopy or Schistosoma PCR in CVL would only confirm a fraction of the sandy patches found by colposcopic examination.

[Self-evaluation of conization indications since the introduction of the French colposcopy and cervico-vaginal pathology quality charter in 2 colposcopy centers]

OBJECTIVES

Analyze the efficiency of the implementation of the colposcopy and cervico-vaginal pathology quality charter. The question was to determine whether the criteria of more than 70% of excisional conizations containing CIN2+ lesions (cervical intraepithelial neoplasia 2 or 3 or carcinoma in situ) had been reached and demonstrate a reduction of the conization rate is possible.

METHODS

An epidemiological descriptive, retrospective and multicenter study was performed in "Nord Franche-Comté Hospitals" (Belfort and Montbéliard, France) during the period from November 2013 to January 2015. Inclusion criteria were patients over 25 years undergoing cervical excisions for diagnostic and/or therapeutic purposes after Pap smear screening followed by colposcopically directed biopsies. The files were selected from a data collection and studied using the computerized patient record.

RESULTS

In total, 116 conizations were performed: 103 by four French Society of Colposcopy and Cervico-Vaginal Pathology (SFCPCV) members and 13 by four SFCPCV non-members. The overall result of the primary outcome showed 53% of CIN2+ lesions found in cervical conization specimens, which can be broken down to 55% for the group of SFCPCV members and to 38% for the group of SFCPCV non-members. The statistical analysis indicates a significant difference (P=0.02) in the percentage of CIN2+ lesions discovered on the surgical specimen for the group of SFCPCV members.

CONCLUSIONS

This self-evaluation shows that it is essential to be a SFCPCV member and to adhere to the charter. By complying with the charter and associating the new National Cancer Institute recommendations (December 2016), it is possible to reduce the conization rate and even to surpass the target of more than 70% of excisional conizations containing CIN2+ lesions.

Alternative Colposcopy Techniques: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

To assess the diagnostic value of alternative (digital) colposcopy techniques for detection of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 2 or worse in a colposcopy population.

DATA SOURCES

MEDLINE, EMBASE, ClinicalTrials.gov, and the Cochrane Library were searched from inception up to January 11, 2016, for studies that evaluated the diagnostic value of alternative (digital) colposcopy techniques.

METHODS OF STUDY SELECTION

Inclusion criteria were: 1) an alternative (digital) colposcopy technique was used in a colposcopy population; 2) a histologic outcome was reported, classified as CIN, differentiating between mild dysplasia or less (CIN 1 or less), and moderate dysplasia or worse (CIN 2 or greater); 3) the entire cervix was scanned at once or a per-woman analysis was performed; 4) no other topical application than acetic acid and Lugol's solution was used; 5) at least three eligible studies had to be available within a single technique; and 6) studies obtained research ethics approval. Language was restricted to English.

TABULATION, INTEGRATION, AND RESULTS

Two reviewers assessed the eligibility of the identified articles. Disagreements were resolved by a third reviewer. Thirteen studies met the inclusion criteria. We found six studies on fluorescence and reflectance spectroscopy, including 2,530 women, with a pooled sensitivity of 93% (95% confidence interval [CI] 89-95%) and specificity of 62% (95% CI 47-76%). Four studies on dynamic spectral imaging were found including 1,173 women with a pooled sensitivity of 69% (95% CI 48-85%) and specificity of 83% (95% CI 76-88%). We found three studies on optical coherence tomography including 693 women with a pooled sensitivity of 48% (95% CI 32-64%) and specificity of 77% (95% CI 52-91%). Previously published conventional colposcopy results showed a sensitivity of 61% (95% CI 58-63%) and a specificity of 85% (95% CI 83-86%).

CONCLUSION

Alternative (digital) colposcopy techniques may result in increased sensitivity and specificity, but no recommendation for introduction in clinical practice can be made yet.

Multimodal Hyperspectroscopic Imaging for Detection of High-Grade Cervical Intraepithelial Neoplasia

OBJECTIVE

Numerous new alternative digital colposcopy techniques have been developed, of which multimodal hyperspectroscopy (MHS) showed a high sensitivity in previous studies. The objective of this prospective single-center cohort study was to evaluate the clinical value of MHS for detecting high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia in a colposcopy referral population and colposcopy follow-up population, to assess whether MHS could be safely used to improve care for women at risk for high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 125 women from a colposcopy referral population and colposcopy follow-up population were evaluated with MHS and tested for the presence of high-risk human papillomavirus (HPV) with HPV-16/18 genotyping. Spectroscopic measurements of the cervix were taken and compared with an end point based on histology, high-risk HPV, and cytology. Evaluable data for analysis were collected from 102 of the subjects. Sensitivity, specificity, and predictive values were calculated for MHS and colposcopic impression based on conventional colposcopic examination.

RESULTS

From the total study population of the 102 patients, 47 were enrolled in the colposcopy referral group and 55 in the colposcopy follow-up group. The MHS yielded a sensitivity of 93.6% (95% CI = 78.6-99.2), with a corresponding specificity of 42.3% (95% CI = 30.6-54.6) in the group with a composite end point. No adverse effects occurred, and patient acceptability was high.

CONCLUSIONS

Multimodal hyperspectroscopy is a digital colposcopy technique that offers an easy, rapid, well-tolerated point-of-care assessment with a high sensitivity for the presence of high-grade cervical intraepithelial lesions, however, with a low specificity, resulting in limited clinical value.

Intra and Inter-Observer Variability of Transformation Zone Assessment in Colposcopy: A Qualitative and Quantitative Study

INTRODUCTION

Colposcopy is an important tool in the diagnosis of cervical precancer and early cancer. The assessment of women with abnormal cytology and selection of those who require further therapy or follow up depends on the colposcopic assessment of the Transformation Zone (TZ). Identification of the TZ is thus an important part of this examination. Intra and inter-observer variability is known to be relatively high in the colposcopic interpretation of abnormal features. However, there are hardly any studies on the observer variability in the assessment of the type of TZ.

AIM

The present study was conducted with the aim to compare the intra and inter-observer variability of the TZ type classification and the Squamo-Columnar Junction (SCJ) visibility and to quantitatively measure the intra and inter-observer correlations of tracing of the TZ contours.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Colposcopy images were obtained for a total of 170 cases. They were reviewed by three colposcopists independently. The colposcopists classified the TZ type and also marked the SCJ contours on the images. Each observer independently reviewed the cases on two different instances (few weeks apart) and the result was compiled for intra-observer variation. The intra and inter observer variability on the TZ type was compared using Cohen's Kappa. This was followed by a quantitative measurement of TZ observation variability using Hausdorff distance.

RESULTS

The inter-observer agreement for the TZ type classification was moderate (Kappa= 0.53 to 0.66). The Intra-observer agreement was moderate to strong (0.60 to 0.86).

CONCLUSION

Colposcopic in vivo examination increases the variability in the identification of the TZ when compared to the analysis of recorded images. The disagreement in the TZ type was mostly in categories Type 2 vs Type 3 followed by Type 1 vs Type 2. A computerized quantification method can be used for quality control and training purpose in colposcopy.

An online quality assurance program for colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening setting in Italy: results on colposcopic impression

OBJECTIVE

To report the results of an Internet-based colposcopy quality assurance program from a population-based cervical screening service in a large region of northern Italy.

METHODS

In 2010 to 2011, a Web application was made accessible on the Web site of the regional administration. Fifty-nine colposcopists of the registered 65 participated. They logged-in, viewed a posted set of 50 high-quality digital colpophotographs selected by an expert committee, and rated them for colposcopic impression using a 4-tier classification (Negative; abnormal, grade 1 [G1]; abnormal, grade 2 [G2]; suspected invasive cancer [Cancer]) derived from the International Federation for Cervical Pathology and Colposcopy 2002 classification. kappa (κ) coefficients for intercolposcopist agreement and colposcopist-committee agreement were calculated.

RESULTS

Colposcopist-committee agreement was greater than intercolposcopist agreement (overall κ 0.69 vs 0.60, p<.001). The κ values for colposcopist-committee agreement were 0.83 on Negative, 0.53 on G1, 0.66 on G2, and 0.80 on Cancer (all p values for pairwise comparisons<.001, except for Negative vs Cancer [p=.078]). There was no systematic tendency for colposcopists to underestimate or overestimate the colposcopic findings (2-tailed sign test, p=.13). Overall colposcopist-committee agreement was greater among patients 35 years or older (p<.001) and for colposcopists with previous quality assurance experiences (p<.01). Only 0.2% of Negative impressions were formulated for a cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 2 or worse. As a parallel finding, the impression of Cancer predicted cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 2 or less in 0.5% of cases. The histologic substrates of G1 were dispersed over a large spectrum.

CONCLUSIONS

The reproducibility of colposcopic impression, when classified by trained colposcopists examining high-quality images, is higher than is generally thought.

High-resolution anoscopy: clinical features of anal intraepithelial neoplasia in HIV-positive men

BACKGROUND

High-resolution anoscopy is increasingly advocated to screen HIV+ men who have sex with men for anal cancer and its precursor lesions, anal intraepithelial neoplasia. A systematic comparison between clinical features and the histopathology of suspect lesions is lacking.

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to analyze interobserver agreement in classifying features of intra-anal lesions suspect for anal intraepithelial neoplasia and to compare these features with their histopathological outcome.

DESIGN

This study is a cross-sectional survey regarding high-resolution anoscopy with images and biopsies of suspect lesions. Two dermatologists experienced in high-resolution anoscopy, blinded for histopathological outcome, independently classified the lesions on clinical features.

SETTING

This investigation was conducted at the Dermatology outpatient clinic of the Academic Medical Center in Amsterdam, The Netherlands.

PATIENTS

Included in the study were 163 HIV+ men who have sex with men, older than 18 years, with no history of anal cancer.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcomes measured were the κ-coefficient for interobserver agreement and the proportions of anal intraepithelial neoplasia per clinical feature.

RESULTS

Three hundred four biopsies were taken from 163 patients. One hundred sixty-eight biopsies (55%) showed anal intraepithelial neoplasia, and 67/304 (22%) showed high-grade anal intraepithelial neoplasia. The κ-coefficient was 0.65 for condylomatous lesions, 0.14 for surface configuration, 0.54 for punctation, 0.08 for mosaicism, and 0.43 for atypical vessels. Condylomatous lesions showed high-grade anal intraepithelial neoplasia in 18% (95% CI, 11%-27%). In lesions with flat leukoplakia, punctation, and atypical vessels, high-grade anal intraepithelial neoplasia was seen in 25%, 30%, and 23%. In lesions with the combination punctation/atypical vessels and punctation/flat leukoplakia/atypical vessels, high-grade anal intraepithelial neoplasia was found in 38% and 40%.

LIMITATIONS

We did not take biopsies of healthy-looking mucosa. Furthermore, the real-time description of features during high-resolution anoscopy, instead of the use of images, would improve the recognition of subtle mucosal abnormalities.

CONCLUSIONS

A moderate to substantial interobserver agreement was demonstrated in recognizing condylomas, punctation, and atypical vessels. Furthermore, high-grade anal intraepithelial neoplasia is present in a high proportion of intra-anal condylomata. A combination of punctation, flat leukoplakia, and atypical vessels is the best predictor for high-grade anal intraepithelial neoplasia.

Rationale and development of an on-line quality assurance programme for colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening setting in Italy

Background

Colposcopy, the key step in the management of women with abnormal Pap smear results, is a visual technique prone to observer variation, which implies the need for prolonged apprenticeship, continuous training, and quality assurance (QA) measures. Colposcopy QA programmes vary in level of responsibility of organizing subjects, geographic coverage, scope, model, and type of actions. The programmes addressing the clinical standards of colposcopy (quality of examination and appropriateness of clinical decisions) are more limited in space and less sustainable over time than those focused on the provision of the service (resources, accessibility, etc.). This article reports on the protocol of a QA programme targeting the clinical quality of colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening service in an administrative region of northern Italy.

Methods/design

After a situation analysis of local colposcopy audit practices and previous QA initiatives, a permanent web-based QA programme was developed. The design places more emphasis on providing education and feedback to participants than on testing them. The technical core is a log-in web application accessible on the website of the regional Administration. The primary objectives are to provide (1) a practical opportunity for retraining of screening colposcopists, and (2) a platform for them to interact with colposcopists from other settings and regions through exchange and discussion of digital colposcopic images. The retraining function is based on repeated QA sessions in which the registered colposcopists log-in, classify a posted set of colpophotographs, and receive on line a set of personal feedback data. Each session ends with a plenary seminar featuring the presentation of overall results and an interactive review of the test set of colpophotographs. This is meant to be a forum for an open exchange of views that may lead to more knowledge and more diagnostic homogeneity. The protocol includes the criteria for selection of colpophotographs and the rationale for colposcopic gold standards.

Discussion

This programme is an ongoing initiative open to further developments, in particular in the area of basic training. It uses the infrastructure of the internet to give a novel solution to technical problems affecting colposcopy QA in population-based screening services.

Adjunctive colposcopy technologies for examination of the uterine cervix--DySIS, LuViva Advanced Cervical Scan and Niris Imaging System: a systematic review and economic evaluation

BACKGROUND

Women in England (aged 25-64 years) are invited for cervical screening every 3-5 years to assess for cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) or cancer. CIN is a term describing abnormal changes in the cells of the cervix, ranging from CIN1 to CIN3, which is precancerous. Colposcopy is used to visualise the cervix. Three adjunctive colposcopy technologies for examination of the cervix have been included in this assessment: Dynamic Spectral Imaging System (DySIS), the LuViva Advanced Cervical Scan and the Niris Imaging System.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of adjunctive colposcopy technologies for examination of the uterine cervix for patients referred for colposcopy through the NHS Cervical Screening Programme.

DATA SOURCES

Sixteen electronic databases [Allied and Complementary Medicine Database (AMED), BIOSIS Previews, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (CDSR), Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects (DARE), EMBASE, Health Management Information Consortium (HMIC), Health Technology Assessment (HTA) database; Inspec, Inside Conferences, MEDLINE, NHS Economic Evaluation Database (NHS EED), PASCAL, Science Citation Index Expanded (SCIE) and Science Citation Index (SCI) - Conference Proceedings], and two clinical trial registries [ClinicalTrials.gov and Current Controlled Trials (CCT)] were searched to September-October 2011.

REVIEW METHODS

Studies comparing DySIS, LuViva or Niris with conventional colposcopy were sought; a narrative synthesis was undertaken. A decision-analytic model was developed, which measured outcomes in terms of quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) and costs were evaluated from the perspective of the NHS and Personal Social Services with a time horizon of 50 years.

RESULTS

Six studies were included: two studies of DySIS, one study of LuViva and three studies of Niris. The DySIS studies were well reported and had a low risk of bias; they found higher sensitivity with DySIS (both the DySISmap alone and in combination with colposcopy) than colposcopy alone for identifying CIN2+ disease, although specificity was lower with DySIS. The studies of LuViva and Niris were poorly reported and had limitations, which indicated that their results were subject to a high risk of bias; the results of these studies cannot be considered reliable. The base-case cost-effectiveness analysis suggests that both DySIS treatment options are less costly and more effective than colposcopy alone in the overall weighted population; these results were robust to the ranges tested in the sensitivity analysis. DySISmap alone was more costly and more effective in several of the referral groups but the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was never higher than £1687 per QALY. DySIS plus colposcopy was less costly and more effective in all reasons for referral. Only indicative analyses were carried out on Niris and LuViva and no conclusions could be made on their cost-effectiveness.

LIMITATIONS

The assessment is limited by the available evidence on the new technologies, natural history of the disease area and current treatment patterns.

CONCLUSIONS

DySIS, particularly in combination with colposcopy, has higher sensitivity than colposcopy alone. There is no reliable evidence on the clinical effectiveness of LuViva and Niris. DySIS plus colposcopy appears to be less costly and more effective than both the DySISmap alone and colposcopy alone; these results were robust to the sensitivity analyses undertaken. Given the lack of reliable evidence on LuViva and Niris, no conclusions on their potential cost-effectiveness can be drawn. There is some uncertainty about how generalisable these findings will be to the population of women referred for colposcopy in the future, owing to the introduction of the human papillomavirus (HPV) triage test and uptake of the HPV vaccine.

Accuracy of detection of high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia using electrical impedance spectroscopy with colposcopy

Objective

To determine if electrical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) improves the diagnostic accuracy of colposcopy when used as an adjunct.

Design

Prospective, comparative, multi-centre clinical study.

Setting

Three colposcopy clinics: two in England and one in Ireland.

Population

Women referred with abnormal cytology.

Methods

In phase 1, EIS was assessed against colposcopic impression and histopathology of the biopsies taken. In phase 2, a probability index and cut-off value for the detection of high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (HG–CIN, i.e. grade CIN2+) was derived to indicate sites for biopsy. EIS data collection and analyses were performed in real time and blinded to the clinician. The phase-2 data were analysed using different cut-off values to assess performance of EIS as an adjunct.

Main outcome measure

Histologically confirmed HG–CIN (CIN2+).

Results

A total of 474 women were recruited: 214 were eligible for analysis in phase 1, and 215 were eligible in phase 2. The average age was 33.2 years (median age 30.3 years, range 20–64 years) and 48.5% (208/429) had high-grade cytology. Using the cut-off from phase 1 the accuracy of colposcopic impression to detect HG–CIN when using EIS as an adjunct at the time of examination improved the positive predictive value (PPV) from 78.1% (95% CI 67.5–86.4) to 91.5%. Specificity was also increased from 83.5% (95% CI 75.2–89.9) to 95.4%, but sensitivity was significantly reduced from 73.6% (95% CI 63.0–82.5) to 62.1%, and the negative predictive value (NPV) was unchanged. The positive likelihood ratio for colposcopic impression alone was 4.46. This increased to 13.5 when EIS was used as an adjunct. The overall accuracy of colposcopy when used with EIS as an adjunct was assessed by varying the cut-off applied to a combined test index. Using a cut-off set to give the same sensitivity as colposcopy in phase 2, EIS increased the PPV to detect HG–CIN from 53.5% (95% CI 45.0–61.8) to 67%, and specificity increased from 38.5% (95% CI 29.4–48.3) to 65.1%. NPV was not significantly increased. Alternatively, applying a cut-off to give the same specificity as colposcopy alone increased EIS sensitivity from 88.5% (95% CI 79.9–94.4) to 96.6%, and NPV from 80.8% (95% CI 67.5–90.4) to 93.3%. PPV was not significantly increased. The receiver operator characteristic (ROC) to detect HG–CIN had an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.887 (95% CI 0.840–0.934).

Conclusions

EIS used as an adjunct to colposcopy improves colposcopic performance. The addition of EIS could lead to more appropriate patient management with lower intervention rates.

Objective perspective in colposcopy

Colposcopy is a widely used diagnostic procedure, primarily in the assessment of women with abnormal cervical cytology. It is used by appropriately trained individuals using techniques that allow a full assessment of the abnormality and plan for further investigation or treatment. Certain key features are specifically looked for, and a colposcopic impression formed. Using a systematic approach to the colposcopic assessment can improve the diagnostic accuracy. In this chapter, we review various factors and meta-analyses in relation to the diagnostic performance of colposcopy. Newer technologies are being developed that will assist the clinician in assessing the colposcopic changes. Quality assurance of the training and practise of colposcopy is important to maintain appropriate management for women with cytological abnormalities.

Effectiveness of asynchronous tele-endoscopy

BACKGROUND

Asynchronous tele-endoscopy can improve access and quality of patient care. This is the first published evaluation of the diagnostic accuracy of highly compressed digital video in GI endoscopy.

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether asynchronous tele-endoscopy using highly compressed video can accurately document and diagnose lesions in the upper GI tract.

DESIGN

Local endoscopists performed 50 elective upper GI endoscopies. A high-quality DV compressed video (25 megabits per second [Mbps], 720 x 480 pixels) and highly compressed MPEG-1 video (2.0 Mbps, 352 x 240 pixels) were simultaneously captured. Five endoscopists asynchronously reviewed 20 compressed digital videos (100 case reviews) for endoscopic diagnoses. In addition, demonstration technique and image quality were rated on a Likert scale. Concordance between local and asynchronous endoscopists for major and minor endoscopic findings was evaluated. An independent panel classified discrepancies as caused by image quality, endoscopic technique, or interobserver variability through comparison of the 2 forms of digital video.

RESULTS

Although asynchronous endoscopists rated the image quality of highly compressed video as diagnostic in 85% of cases, only 18% of studies yielded the same clinical diagnoses. There was high discordance for both major (kappa = 0.38, 95% CI, 0.19-0.57) and minor findings (kappa = -0.29, 95% CI, -0.43 to -0.15). Interobserver reporting was responsible for 90% of variability in contrast to only 4.9% for poor image quality.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings suggest that the diagnostic accuracy of low-bandwidth, low-resolution, highly compressed video is well tolerated and comparable to the current standard. Interobserver reporting variability accounted for most of the poor correlation. Improved synoptic documentation is required for effective communication among endoscopists.

Cytological surveillance compared with immediate referral for colposcopy in management of women with low grade cervical abnormalities: multicentre randomised controlled trial

OBJECTIVES

To examine the effectiveness of cytological surveillance in primary care compared with immediate referral for colposcopic examination in women with low grade abnormal results on cervical cytology tests.

DESIGN

Multicentre individually randomised controlled trial.

SETTING

NHS cervical screening programmes in Grampian, Tayside, and Nottingham.

PARTICIPANTS

4439 women, aged 20-59, with a cytology result showing borderline nuclear abnormalities or mild dyskaryosis, October 1999-October 2002.

INTERVENTIONS

Cytological screening every six months in primary care (n=2223) or referral for colposcopy and related interventions (n=2216). All women were followed for three years, concluding with an exit appointment at which colposcopic examination was undertaken. Colposcopists assessing outcome at this appointment were blinded to randomisation.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Primary end point: cumulative incidence of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade II or more severe disease. Other end points: cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade III or worse, clinically significant anxiety and depression, other self reported after effects, and rates of non-attendance. Analysis was by intention to treat; all those randomised were included.

RESULTS

The cumulative incidence of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade II or worse was 79 per 1000 person years in the colposcopy arm and 58 per 1000 person years in the cytological surveillance arm (relative risk 1.37, 95% confidence interval 1.19 to 1.57). This difference was less marked for cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade III or more severe disease, but the incidence was still higher in the colposcopy arm (relative risk 1.26, 1.04 to 1.53). Among women randomised to immediate colposcopy, 79% (74.9% to 82.5%) of cases of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade II or worse were diagnosed at the time of the immediate colposcopy, while among women randomised to cytological surveillance, 77% (72.1% to 81.2%) of cases were detected by surveillance cytology and related interventions. Similar proportions of women were anxious or depressed in the two arms. A higher proportion of women in the colposcopy arm reported after effects, and these were of longer duration and more severe. Non-attendance was low in both arms.

CONCLUSION

The more marked difference between the arms in the occurrence of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade II or worse than in the occurrence of grade III or worse can probably be accounted for by the spontaneous regression of some cases of grade II neoplasia. Compared with cytological surveillance, a policy of immediate colposcopy detects more cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade II or worse, and some more grade III or worse, but might lead to overtreatment. Such a policy is associated with a higher rate of reported after effects, which are more severe and of longer duration than those associated with cytological surveillance.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

ISRCTN 34841617.

Biopsy and selective recall compared with immediate large loop excision in management of women with low grade abnormal cervical cytology referred for colposcopy: multicentre randomised controlled trial

OBJECTIVES

To compare the effectiveness of punch biopsy and selective recall for treatment versus a policy of immediate treatment by large loop excision in the management of women with low grade abnormal cervical cytology referred for colposcopy.

DESIGN

Multicentre individually randomised controlled trial, nested within the NHS cervical screening programmes.

SETTING

Grampian, Tayside, and Nottingham.

PARTICIPANTS

1983 women, aged 20-59, with cytology showing borderline nuclear abnormalities or mild dyskaryosis, October 1999-October 2002.

INTERVENTIONS

Immediate large loop excision or up to four targeted punch biopsies taken immediately with recall for treatment (by large loop excision) if these showed cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade II or III or worse. Participants were followed for three years, concluding with an exit colposcopy.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Clinical end points: cumulative incidence of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade II or worse and grade III or worse at three years. Clinically significant anxiety and depression and self reported after effects assessed six weeks after colposcopy, biopsies, or large loop excision.

RESULTS

879 women (44%) had a normal transformation zone at colposcopy and had no further procedures at that time. Colposcopists were less likely to classify the transformation zone as abnormal when the allocation was large loop excision (603 (60%) in the biopsy and selective recall group; 501 (51%) in the immediate large loop excision group). Of women randomised to biopsy and recall, 157 (16%) required a second clinic visit for treatment. Specimens from almost 60% (n=296) of women who underwent immediate large loop excision showed no cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (31%; n=156) or showed cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade I (28%; n=140). The percentages of women diagnosed with grade II or worse up to and including the exit examination were 22% (n=216) in the biopsy and recall arm and 23% (n=228) in the immediate large loop excision arm. There was no significant difference between the arms in cumulative incidence of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade II or worse (adjusted relative for risk large loop excision v biopsy 1.04, 95% confidence interval 0.86 to 1.25) or grade III or worse (1.03, 0.79 to 1.34). A greater proportion of disease was detected at initial investigation and less during follow-up and at exit in the immediate large loop excision arm, but time of detection did not differ significantly between arms. Levels of anxiety and depression and reported pain did not differ between arms. Higher proportions of women randomised to large loop excision reported moderate or more severe bleeding and discharge.

CONCLUSION

A policy of targeted punch biopsies with subsequent treatment for cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade II or III and cytological surveillance for grade I or less provides the best balance between benefits and harms for the management of women with low grade abnormal cytology referred for colposcopy. Immediate large loop excision results in overtreatment and more after effects and should not be recommended.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

ISRCTN 34841617.

The diagnostic accuracy of colposcopy in previously treated cervical intraepithelial neoplasia

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether colposcopy is reliable in diagnosing cervical intraepithelial neoplasia in women who have undergone a previous cervical excision biopsy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A prospective study of women attending the colposcopy clinic at the University Hospital of North Staffordshire was performed between January 1998 and December 1999.

RESULTS

A clear histological diagnosis of the grade of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia was available for 469 in the treatment-naive group and 58 in the treatment group. kappa coefficients comparing the colposcopic impression (negative, low-grade, high-grade, or invasion) with histological diagnosis showed that there was no difference between the treatment-naive group, weighted kappa=0.46, and the previous treatment group, weighted kappa=0.47. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value of colposcopy for any cervical disease in the treatment-naive women were 93.9%, 51.9%, 96.7%, and 34.1%, respectively, compared with 77.6%, 66.7%, 86.4%, and 35.3% in previously treated women. The sensitivity of colposcopy fell when it was used to differentiate normal and low-grade disease from high-grade disease and invasion: 82.4%, 55.9%, 82.6%, and 49.6% for treatment-naive women, compared with 61.5%, 84.2%, 60.0% and 51.6%, respectively, for the previous treatment group.

CONCLUSIONS

Previous treatment to the cervix does not seem to impair the ability of colposcopy to differentiate normal cervix from all grades of cervical abnormality in women where the squamocolumnar junction is visible. However, there is a suggestion that the sensitivity of colposcopy to differentiate negative/low-grade disease from high-grade disease/invasion is lower in previously treated women.

Digital colposcopy: ready for use? An overview of literature

The aims of this review were to summarise the various methods of digital colposcopy and to provide an overview of their efficacy. We conducted a literature search and focused on papers that described a technique for colposcopy, other than conventional colposcopy, and compared this with conventional colposcopy and/or histology and included digitalisation of the process. All papers have been classified in one of the following categories: digital imaging and telecolposcopy, spectroscopy, computerised colposcopy, optical coherence tomography and confocal microcolposcopy. Among the most promising developments is spectroscopy, allowing a more or less automated analysis and interpretation of the colposcopic image.

Interobserver agreement in the evaluation of digitized cervical images

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the agreement among multiple expert colposcopists evaluating high-resolution digitized cervigrams taken from patients with a variety of human papillomavirus (HPV) infection states and previous cervigram interpretations.

METHODS

Twenty expert colposcopists evaluated 939 digitized images of the uterine cervix obtained after the application of 5% acetic acid during the ASCUS-LSIL Triage Study. Twenty images selected to represent a broad range were graded by all the colposcopists. The remaining 919 pictures were distributed by stratified random sampling, such that each image was evaluated by two colposcopists, and each expert evaluated 112 images with similar distributions of cervigram diagnoses and HPV DNA test results. We evaluated interrater agreement among the pairs of colposcopists and confirmed the conclusions using the 20 images they all graded.

RESULTS

Pairs of colposcopists agreed on the diagnosis for only 56.8% of images. Similar agreement was seen regarding number of visible lesions (of low-grade or greater). This variability in ratings remained when the images were stratified by final histologic diagnosis or HPV status. The results were confirmed by the presence of large variability in ratings (ranging in some cases from normal to cancer) for the 20 images graded by all colposcopists.

CONCLUSION

Colposcopic diagnosis using static images is poorly reproducible and might reflect similar problems in clinical practice. Researchers should question the use of colposcopic images as a reference standard for teaching and evaluating the presence or severity of disease.

A Prospective Study to Evaluate the Correlation Between Reid Colposcopic Index Impression and Biopsy Histology

OBJECTIVE

To determine the strength of correlation between colposcopic impression using Reid index and biopsy histology.

METHODS

In a colposcopy referral clinic in Tehran University, Iran. Colposcopy was carried out using Reid colposcopic index (RCI) scoring system and directed biopsy on 344 women between March 2004 and October 2005 by fellows supervised by a board-certified gynecologic oncologist. Results were retrospectively compared with a previous study carried out on 353 women by the same physicians. In this previous study, the colposcopy findings did not use RCI index; the significance of association between these 2 studies was assessed by chi(2) and kappa statistics.

RESULT

The association between colposcopic impression and biopsy histology was highly significant (p < .001), both in RCI colposcopy group and general colposcopy group. However, the strength of the correlation between colposcopy impression and biopsy histology in RCI colposcopy group was more than the general colposcopy group (0.74 vs 0.45). The positive predictive value of any colposcopic abnormality for any histologic abnormalities in the RCI group was 92%. The negative predictive value of a benign colposcopic impression was 70.5%. The sensitivity was 74%, and the specificity was 90.7%.

CONCLUSIONS

The good correlation between colposcopic impression and histological diagnosis by using Reid index in colposcopy would produce higher agreement and strength of the correlation. Therefore, the Reid index can be used as a reproducible technique which is easy to learn in colposcopic clinic.

Achieving quality assurance standards in colposcopy practice: A teaching hospital experience

OBJECTIVE

To assess the performance of the colposcopy service of the teaching hospitals of Cardiff and Vale Trust, University of Wales, Cardiff, South Wales, UK by determining if patients attending colposcopy clinic had been managed in accordance with the local departmental, regional and national (National Health Service Cervical Screening Programme) guidelines with the ultimate purpose of identifying areas for improvement in patients' care.

METHODS

We retrospectively analysed the case notes of 426 women who attended the colposcopy clinic over a three-month period in 2005.

RESULTS

This study has shown that five of the national standards have been achieved. These relate to availability of cytology report at the time of colposcopic assessment, recording of colposcopist's impression as to the nature of the cervical lesion, suitability of biopsy samples for histological analysis, primary haemorrhage as a complication of large loop excision of transformation zone treatment and inpatient admission following this treatment. However, other five unmet standards relate to recording of visibility of squamocolumnar junction, predictability of high-grade lesion, taking a biopsy from a high-grade lesion as suggested by smear, recording consent of treatment, and number of treatments performed as an outpatient.

CONCLUSION

Our findings should lead to changes in the structure and functioning of the colposcopy clinic that would improve the detection of significant disease and the timeliness of diagnosis and the speed with which results are communicated.

Colposcopic accuracy of obstetrics and gynecology residents

OBJECTIVE

The objective of our study was to determine the accuracy of gynecology residents' colposcopic impressions.

METHODS

A retrospective review of colposcopic examinations was performed. Colposcopic impressions were compared to cervical biopsy and the results stratified by level of residency training. kappa Statistics were calculated to determine the strength of correlation between impression and biopsy results.

RESULTS

Agreement within one-step between cervical histology and the colposcopic impression was found in 351 (77%) of the subjects. Histology impression agreement occurred in 92% of the nurse practitioner procedures, 77% of the second year resident (R2) cases, 75% of R3 colposcopies and 73% of the R4 procedures. The association between cervical biopsy and impression was highly significant (P<0.0001). However, the strength of the correlation was only slight (kappa=0.197). The kappa value was highest for the nurse practitioners (0.376, fair correlation) and lowest for the R3 residents (0.110, slight correlation). The positive predictive value for the association of any colposcopically detected abnormality with any histologic abnormality was 64.1%. The overall PPV was highest for the nurse practitioners (79.3%) and lowest for the R2 residents (58.7%).

CONCLUSIONS

While the colposcopic impressions of gynecology residents were accurate, there was little difference in the accuracy of colposcopic assessment based upon the level of resident training.

Colposcopically obtained images of vulvar, vaginal, and cervical epithelium for assessment of safety of intravaginal agents among normal adolescent females: comparison with in vivo exam and interobserver agreement

OBJECTIVES

This study was designed to assess identification of epithelial abnormalities of both in vivo examination as compared with colposcopically obtained images and interobserver assessment of the same images of the lower genital tract in healthy women.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ninety women between the ages of 14 and 21 years were recruited for a phase II trial of a vaginal Lactobacillus crispatus capsule. All women underwent a baseline and 1-week colposcopic examination. Multiple genital tract areas were evaluated for abnormalities and photographed. The original examiner and two experienced colposcopists reevaluated all images masked to previous interpretations. Agreement was evaluated using kappa statistics.

RESULTS

The representative kappa statistics for direct observation vs photographic interpretation for the vulva, vagina, and cervix are: 37%, -2%, and -4%, respectively. The kappa statistics comparing the three observers ranged from 1% to 39%. CONCLUSIONS.: There is poor agreement between in vivo exams and photographic interpretation, and interobserver assessments of lower genital tract photographs.

Interobserver agreement on interpreting hand drawings of colposcopy in women with borderline cytology to predict high-grade lesions

OBJECTIVE

To assess the interobserver agreement on interpreting hand drawings as a colposcopic image recording technique in women with borderline cytology and to assess the correlation between colposcopic impression and histological outcome.

METHODS

We used colposcopic documentation and histology from a cohort study of women with borderline dyskaryosis. Four gynecologists and four residents scored the same 30 colposcopic documentation forms.

RESULTS

There is a good interobserver agreement on classifying colposcopic hand drawings as high-grade lesions (average kappa 0.58). The interobserver agreement on interpreting colposcopic image was higher for the more highly experienced gynecologists than for the residents. The agreement between colposcopic impression and histological outcome is poor (kappa 0.17) among the observers.

CONCLUSIONS

Hand drawings are a reliable recording technique of interpreting colposcopic impression documented as high-grade lesion. However, the correlation between colposcopic impression and histological outcome is still poor in women with minor cytological abnormalities.

Digital tools for collecting data from cervigrams for research and training in colposcopy

Colposcopy is a critical part of gynecologic practice but has documented deficiencies, including lack of correlation between the colposcopic appearance and the severity of underlying neoplasia, limited reproducibility, and difficulty in the optimal placement of colposcopically directed biopsies. In a collaborative effort to improve colposcopy, we are analyzing digitized cervigram images from National Cancer Institute-funded studies. Specifically, the National Cancer Institute has collected close to 100,000 cervigrams, digitized to create a database of images of the uterine cervix for research, training, and education. In addition to the cervigram images, this database contains clinical, cytologic, and molecular information at multiple examinations of 15,000 women, with password and ID labeling strategies to protect patient privacy. The National Library of Medicine has designed two web-accessible software tools. The Boundary Marking Tool allows experts on colposcopy to perform an evaluation of the pictures and to mark boundary regions of normal and abnormal regions of the uterine cervix; these evaluations are collected and saved in the database. The Multimedia Database Tool enables retrieval of test and image biomedical data according to specific queries, for example, all women with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia 3 whose cytologic results are atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance. The resource soon will be available as an open resource, via a teaching tool coordinated by a database manager, which will permit a variety of applications for teaching and research. In this article, we describe the perceived need for the resource and its components.

Recent innovations in colposcopy practice

Colposcopic practice continues to evolve. As its need has expanded, so has the role of training, audit and continuing medical education. The recently published National Health Service Cervical Screening Programme clinical guidelines document covers almost every aspect of clinical practice in an evidence-based directory. Excision of the transformation zone (TZ) may be a very minor or major entity. The recent TZ classification system of the International Federation of Cervical Pathology and Colposcopy attempts to clarify and standardize nomenclature so that therapy can be realistically compared. The role of human papillomavirus (HPV) in clinical practice continues to be controversial and has not yet found a place in the UK. For the evaluation of borderline nuclear abnormal smear and for post-treatment surveillance, HPV is clinically useful and efficient. Other biological tumour markers are likely to become clinically useful as their predictive profiles emerge.

The performance of a new scoring system for colposcopy in detecting high-grade dysplasia in the uterine cervix

OBJECTIVE

To construct a simple scoring system for colposcopic examination that can facilitate education of colposcopists and increase the accuracy of evaluation.

DESIGN

Prospective clinical study.

SETTING AND POPULATION

Two hundred ninety-seven examinations of women referred for colposcopy in western Sweden.

METHODS

Five variables were scored: acetowhiteness, margins and surface, vessels, lesion size, and iodine staining. Each variable could be assigned one of three ordered values. Multiple logistic regression was used in order to assess the ability of each single score to predict high-grade lesions (HGL) in histology (cone or biopsy).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Histopathology.

RESULTS

All five variables independently predicted for HGL. The analysis resulted in an 'ideal' weighted scoring system, which showed good sensitivity and specificity. Rounding off of each weight gave a more useful and simpler scoring system with values of 0, 1, or 2 without any significant change in performance. The possible total score was then 0-10. A score of > or =5 points identified all HGL and > or =8 points had a specificity of 90%.

CONCLUSIONS

The scoring system safely identified a group of patients with low-grade lesions or normal findings, thus allowing 17% to be followed only by colposcopy or cytology. Furthermore, it could select women for see-and-treat with only 10% of cases having less than HGL. With this strategy, only approximately 50% of the cases would have needed biopsy in the evaluation.

Interobserver Agreement for Colposcopy Quality Control Using Digitized Colposcopic Images During the ALTS Trial

OBJECTIVE

To estimate interobserver agreement among colposcopy quality control reviewers viewing digitized cervical images during the Atypical Squamous Cells of Undetermined Significance/Low-Grade Squamous Intraepithelial Lesion Triage Study (ALTS).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Three colposcopy quality control reviewers independently examined modem-transferred digitized colposcopic images from subjects examined at four clinical centers. Reviewers indicated colposcopic impression, Reid colposcopic index scores, lesion size, and the technical quality of the image. Rates of agreement were evaluated using the kappa statistic and McNemar and Bowker tests of symmetry.

RESULTS

Regarding colposcopic impressions, the average weighted kappa for pairs of initial reviewers was 0.36 (95% confidence interval, 0.33-0.39). kappa scores with respect to Reid colposcopic index, cervical image quality, and lesion size ranged from 0.23 to 0.28, 0.18 to 0.27, and 0.33 to 0.42, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Fair rates of agreement and poor to fair kappa scores among ALTS colposcopy quality control reviewers were noted for colposcopic impression, Reid colposcopic index scores, image quality, and lesion size. Great latitude exists in the interpretation of digitized cervical images. Poor image quality partially may explain these suboptimal results.

Strength of correlations between colposcopic impression and biopsy histology

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to determine the strength of the correlation between colposcopic impression and biopsy histology.

METHODS

In an urban referral clinic, colposcopy and directed biopsy were performed between July 1, 1996, and December 31, 1999, by residents supervised by board-certified attending obstetrician-gynecologists. Impression and biopsy were graded as benign, suggesting condyloma or koilocytosis, cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) grades 1-3, or cancer. The significance of association was assessed by chi(2) testing and the strength by kappa statistics.

RESULTS

Colposcopies were performed on 2825 women, with colposcopic impression and biopsy grade known for 2112. Exact agreement was found in only 893 (37%) women, but results agreed within one grade in 1203 (75%). The association between impression and histology was significant (P < 0.001), but the strength of the correlation was poor (0.20). The positive predictive value of any colposcopic abnormality for any histologic abnormality was 80%. The negative predictive value of a benign colposcopic impression was 68%. The sensitivity of colposcopy with a threshold of any lesion detected was 89%, and the specificity was 52%. The sensitivity for CIN 2/3 was 56%.

CONCLUSION

Colposcopy is imprecise, although useful in estimating lesion grade. Management decisions require biopsy.

Prospective Evaluation of Colposcopic Features in Predicting Cervical Intraepithelial Neoplasia: Degree of Acetowhite Change Most Important

OBJECTIVE.: To prospectively evaluate the contribution of three colposcopic features-degree of acetowhite change, blood vessel pattern, and lesion margin-to the diagnosis of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. MATERIALS AND METHODS.: A total of 301 women, who participated in two randomized controlled trials and a cross-sectional study of human papillomavirus testing and who were referred to a regional colposcopy center, were studied. Women were examined by colposcopists, who prospectively scored all abnormal transformation zones using three features. The site with the highest score (the most abnormal site) was biopsied and histology reviewed by two pathologists. RESULTS.: In multivariate analysis, degree of acetowhite change was the only feature significantly associated with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. CONCLUSIONS.: Grading lesion severity using degree of acetowhite change alone gave comparable results to grading using the three combined features.

Management of women with cervical cancer precursor lesions

An understanding of the natural history of HPV-induced precancer and cancer, and of the immune response to HPV and to these lesions, has significantly changed the management of lower genital tract neoplasia. New management guidelines incorporate this understanding, providing a more rational approach to diagnosis and treatment. Understanding that low-grade HPV-induced lesions are not true cervical cancer precursor has fostered expectant management of women with these lesions; however, management approaches are still hampered by the inability to better predict who is at risk for high-grade intraepithelial neoplasia and cancer and who is not; this is particularly problematic in the expectant management of CIN 1. In addition, the decision whether or not to treat these low-grade lesions may depend on a number of complex factors that take into account the woman's preferences and reliability for follow-up, as well as a host of issues related to costs and the reliability of the original diagnosis and the tests used for follow-up. Management options for high-grade cervical cancer precursor lesions are much more definitive, because the option of expectant management is given except in pregnancy and for adolescents with CIN 2. New markers that better predict which women with high-risk HPV are at highest risk for subsequent development of a true cervical cancer precursor lesion appear to be on the horizon and may make the management of low-grade lesions as clear as present guide lines for their high-grade cousins. Until that time, understanding all the issues involved in expectant and in active management of cervical HPV-induced lesions will help provide women with the best care possible.

Needle excision of the transformation zone: A new method for treatment of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia

OBJECTIVE

This study was undertaken to evaluate a new needle electrode for conization of the cervix that was developed in my department.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a prospective study of 58 unselected women with histologically verified cervical intraepithelial neoplasia who underwent conization with the diathermy needle. The operations were performed with local anesthesia as outpatient procedures. Follow-up time was 5 years.

RESULTS

All cones were removed in one piece and were of high histologic quality. Mean (+/-SD) operating time, including anesthesia, was 7.9 +/- 2.7 minutes. Mean depth of thermal damage was 0.29 +/- 0.21 mm, and mean blood loss was 12.5 +/- 9.4 mL. No late complications have been noted, and 94.8% of patients have required no further treatment.

CONCLUSION

Needle excision of the transformation zone is a simple and effective outpatient procedure that yields a one-piece cone specimen of high quality and carries a success rate of 94.8%.

Observer variation in cytologic grading for cervical dysplasia of Papanicolaou smears with the PAPNET testing system

BACKGROUND

To assess the interobserver and intraobserver variation of Papanicolaou (Pap) smear screening with the computer-assisted (neural network based) PAPNET Testing System in diagnosing cervical smear abnormalities, results of agreement were compared with the interobserver and intraobserver variation of conventional smear analysis.

METHODS

Cervical smears obtained from women in 1996 were reevaluated both by conventional light microscopy and with use of the PAPNET Testing System by the same four investigators, and results were compared with the original screening diagnoses obtained by both methods.

RESULTS

The interobserver results for epithelial abnormalities (the degree of agreement between the cytologists), characterized by weighted kappa statistics, were 0.71 (95% CI: 0. 68-0.73) for PAPNET screening and 0.69 (95% CI: 0.66-0.72) for conventional screening. No significant differences were found among the individual results obtained by the four cytotechnologists (intraobserver variation) with conventional screening versus PAPNET reviewing.

CONCLUSIONS

Pap smear grading with the PAPNET Testing System has interobserver and intraobserver variation similar to that of conventional screening of Pap smears in routine use. Cancer (Cancer Cytopathol)