Direct gene transfer into human epileptogenic hippocampal tissue with an adeno-associated virus vector: implications for a gene therapy approach to epilepsy

Epilepsy Benchmarks Area II: Prevent Epilepsy and Its Progression

Area II of the 2014 Epilepsy Research Benchmarks aims to establish goals for preventing the development and progression of epilepsy. In this review, we will highlight key advances in Area II since the last summary of research progress and opportunities was published in 2016. We also highlight areas of investigation that began to develop before 2016 and in which additional progress has been made more recently.

Use of Precision-Cut Lung Slices as an Ex Vivo Tool for Evaluating Viruses and Viral Vectors for Gene and Oncolytic Therapy

Organotypic slice cultures recapitulate many features of an intact organ, including cellular architecture, microenvironment, and polarity, making them an ideal tool for the ex vivo study of viruses and viral vectors. Here, we describe a procedure for generating precision-cut ovine and murine tissue slices from agarose-perfused normal and murine melanoma tumor-bearing lungs. Furthermore, we demonstrate that these precision-cut lung slices can be maintained up to 1 month and can be used for a range of applications, which include characterizing the tissue tropism of viruses that cannot be propagated in cell monolayers, evaluating the transducing properties of gene therapy vectors, and, finally, investigating the tumor specificity of oncolytic viruses. Our results suggest that ex vivo lung slices are an ideal platform for studying the tissue specificity and cancer cell selectivity of gene therapy vectors and oncolytic viruses prior to in vivo studies, providing justification for pre-clinical work.

A robust ex vivo experimental platform for molecular-genetic dissection of adult human neocortical cell types and circuits

The powerful suite of available genetic tools is driving tremendous progress in understanding mouse brain cell types and circuits. However, the degree of conservation in human remains largely unknown in large part due to the lack of such tools and healthy tissue preparations. To close this gap, we describe a robust and stable adult human neurosurgically-derived ex vivo acute and cultured neocortical brain slice system optimized for rapid molecular-genetic manipulation. Surprisingly, acute human brain slices exhibited exceptional viability, and neuronal intrinsic membrane properties could be assayed for at least three days. Maintaining adult human slices in culture under sterile conditions further enabled the application of viral tools to drive rapid expression of exogenous transgenes. Widespread neuron-specific labeling was achieved as early as two days post infection with HSV-1 vectors, with virally-transduced neurons exhibiting membrane properties largely comparable to uninfected neurons over this short timeframe. Finally, we demonstrate the suitability of this culture paradigm for optical manipulation and monitoring of neuronal activity using genetically encoded probes, opening a path for applying modern molecular-genetic tools to study human brain circuit function.

Efficient Early and Sustained Transduction of Human Fetal Mesencephalon Using Adeno-Associated Virus Type 2 Vectors

The success of transplantation of human fetal mesencephalic tissue into the putamen of patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) is still limited by the poor survival of the graft. In animal models of fetal transplantation for PD, antiapoptotic agents, such as growth factors or caspase inhibitors, or agents counteracting oxidative stress enhance the survival and reinnervation potential of the graft. Genetic modification of the transplant could allow a local and continuous delivery of these factors at physiologically relevant doses. The major challenge remains the development of strategies to achieve both early and sustained gene delivery in the absence of vector-mediated toxicity. We recently reported that E14 rat fetal mesencephalon could be efficiently tranduced by adeno-associated virus type 2 (AAV2) vectors and that gene expression was maintained until at least 3 months after transplantation in the adult rat striatum. Here we report that an AAV2 vector can mediate the expression of the EGFP reporter gene under the control of a CMV promoter in organotypic cultures of freshly explanted solid fragments of human fetal mesencephalic tissue as early as 3 days to at least 6 weeks postinfection. These results suggest that AAV2 vectors could be used to genetically modify the human fetal tissue prior to transplantation to Parkinson's patients to promote graft survival and integration.

Adeno-associated viral vector-mediated preprosomatostatin expression suppresses induced seizures in kindled rats

Somatostatin is expressed widely in the hippocampus and notably in hilar GABAergic neurons that are vulnerable to seizure neuropathology in chronic temporal lobe epilepsy. We previously demonstrated that sustained bilateral preprosomatostatin (preproSST) expression in the hippocampus prevents the development of generalized seizures in the amygdala kindling model of temporal lobe epilepsy. Here we tested whether sustained preproSST expression is anticonvulsant in rats already kindled to high-grade seizures. Rats were kindled until they exhibited 3 consecutive Racine Grade 5 seizures before adeno-associated virus serotype 5 (AAV5) vector driving either eGFP (AAV5-CBa-eGFP) or preproSST and eGFP (AAV5-CBa-preproSST-eGFP) expression was injected bilaterally into the hippocampal dentate gyrus and CA1 region. Retested 3 weeks later, rats that received control vector (AAV5-CBa-eGFP) continued to exhibit high-grade seizures whereas 6/13 rats that received preproSST vector (AAV5-CBa-preproSST-eGFP) were seizure-free. Of these rats, 5/6 remained seizure-free after repeated stimulation sessions and when the stimulation current was increased. These results suggest that vector-mediated expression of preproSST may be a viable therapeutic strategy for temporal lobe epilepsy.

Therapeutic epilepsy research: from pharmacological rationale to focal adenosine augmentation

Epilepsy is a common seizure disorder affecting approximately 70 million people worldwide. Current pharmacotherapy is neuron-centered, frequently accompanied by intolerable side effects, and fails to be effective in about one third of patients. Therefore, new therapeutic concepts are needed. Recent research suggests an astrocytic basis of epilepsy, presenting the possibility of novel therapeutic targets. In particular, dysfunction of the astrocyte-controlled, endogenous, adenosine-based seizure control system of the brain is implicated in seizure generation. Thus, astrogliosis - a pathological hallmark of the epileptic brain - is associated with upregulation of the adenosine-removing enzyme adenosine kinase (ADK), resulting in focal adenosine deficiency. Both astrogliotic upregulation of ADK in epilepsy and transgenic overexpression of ADK are associated with seizures, and inhibition of ADK prevents seizures in a mouse model of pharmacoresistant epilepsy. These findings link adenosine deficiency with seizures and predict that adenosine augmentation therapies (AATs) will likely be effective in preventing seizures. Given the wide-spread systemic and central side effects of systemically administered AATs, focal AATs (i.e., limited to the astrogliotic lesion) are a necessity. This Commentary will discuss the pharmacological rationale for the development of focal AATs. Additionally, several AAT strategies will be discussed: (1) adenosine released from silk-based brain implants; (2) adenosine released from locally implanted encapsulated cells; (3) adenosine released from stem cell-derived brain implants; and (4) adenosine augmenting gene therapies. Finally, new developments and therapeutic challenges in using focal AATs for epilepsy therapy will critically be evaluated.

Treatment of Lennox-Gastaut syndrome: overview and recent findings

Lennox-Gastaut syndrome (LGS) is a rare, age-related syndrome, characterized by multiple seizure types, a specific electro-encephalographic pattern, and mental regression. However, published data on the etiology, evolution, and therapeutic approach of LGS are contradictory, partly because the precise definition of LGS used in the literature varies. In the most recent classification, LGS belongs to the epileptic encephalopathies and is highly refractory to all antiepileptic drugs. Numerous treatments, medical and non-medical, have been proposed and results mostly from open studies or case series have been published. Sometimes, patients with LGS are included in a more global group of patients with refractory epilepsy. Only 6 randomized double-blind controlled trials of medical treatments, which included patients with LGS, have been published. Overall, treatment is rarely effective and the final prognosis remains poor in spite of new therapeutic strategies. Co-morbidities need specific treatment. This paper summarizes the definition, diagnosis and therapeutic approach to LGS, including not only recognized antiepileptic drugs, but also "off label" medications, immune therapy, diet, surgery and some perspectives for the future.

Adeno-associated virus-mediated expression and constitutive secretion of NPY or NPY13-36 suppresses seizure activity in vivo

Neuropeptide Y (NPY) is a 36-amino-acid peptide that attenuates seizure activity following direct infusion or adeno-associated virus (AAV)-mediated expression in the central nervous system. However, NPY activates all NPY receptor subtypes, potentially causing unwanted side effects. NPY13-36 is a C-terminal peptide fragment of NPY that primarily activates the NPY Y2 receptor, thought to mediate the antiseizure activity. Therefore, we investigated if recombinant adeno-associated virus-mediated expression and constitutive secretion of NPY or NPY13-36 could alter limbic seizure sensitivity. Rats received bilateral piriform cortex infusions of AAV vectors that express and constitutively secrete full-length NPY (AAV-FIB-NPY) or NPY13-36 (AAV-FIB-NPY13-36). Control rats received no infusion, as we have previously shown that vectors expressing and secreting reporter genes like GFP (AAV-FIB-EGFP), as well as vectors expressing peptides that lack secretion sequences (AAV-GAL) have no effect on seizures. One week later, all animals received kainic acid (10 mg kg(-1), intraperitoneally), and the latencies to wet dog shakes and limbic seizure behaviors were determined. Although both control and vector-treated rats developed wet dog shake behaviors with similar latencies, the latencies to class III and class IV limbic seizures were significantly prolonged in both NPY- and NPY13-36-treated groups. Thus, AAV-mediated expression and constitutive secretion of NPY and NPY13-36 is effective in attenuating limbic seizures, and provides a platform for delivering therapeutic peptide fragments with increased receptor selectivity.

Gene therapy in epilepsy: the focus on NPY

Gene therapy represents an innovative and promising alternative for the treatment of epileptic patients who are resistant to conventional antiepileptic drugs. Among the various approaches for the application of gene therapy in the treatment of CNS disorders, recombinant viral vectors have been most widely used so far. Several gene targets could be used to correct the compromized balance between inhibitory and excitatory transmission in epilepsy. Transduction of neuropeptide genes such as galanin and neuropeptide Y (NPY) in specific brain areas in experimental models of seizures resulted in significant anticonvulsant effects. In particular, the long-lasting NPY over-expression obtained in the rat hippocampus using intracerebral application of recombinant adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors reduced the generalization of seizures from their site of onset, delayed acquisition of fully kindled seizures and afforded neuroprotection. These results establish a proof-of-principle for the applicability of AAV-NPY vectors for the inhibition of seizures in epilepsy. Additional investigations are required to demonstrate a therapeutic role of gene therapy in chronic models of seizures and to address in more detail safety concerns and possible side-effects.

Enhanced gene transfer efficiency in the murine striatum and an orthotopic glioblastoma tumor model, using AAV-7- and AAV-8-pseudotyped vectors

In this study, recombinant AAV vectors pseudotyped with viral capsids derived from AAV serotypes 7 and 8 were evaluated for gene transfer in the murine striatum relative to vectors pseudotyped with AAV serotypes 2, 5, and 6. In comparison with rAAV serotype 2, pseudotyped vectors derived from AAV-7 and AAV-8 have increased transduction efficiency in the murine CNS, with the rank order rAAV-7 > rAAV-8 > rAAV-5 > rAAV-2 = rAAV-6, with all vectors demonstrating a marked tropism for neuronal transduction. Pseudotyped rAAV vector gene transfer in the brain after preimplantation of a murine 4C8 glioblastoma tumor was also evaluated. Efficiency of gene transfer to the orthotopic tumor was increased when using AAV-6, -7, and -8 capsid proteins in comparison with serotype 2, with the order rAAV-8 = rAAV-7 > rAAV-6 > rAAV-2 > rAAV-5. The increased gene transfer efficiency of rAAV vectors pseudotyped with the rAAV-8 capsid also provided enhanced therapeutic efficacy in a mouse model of glioblastoma multiforme, using vectors encoding an inhibitor of the vascular endothelial growth factor pathway. These studies demonstrate that rAAV vectors pseudotyped with capsids derived from AAV serotypes 7 and 8 provide enhanced gene transfer in the murine CNS and may offer increased therapeutic efficacy in the treatment of neurological disease.

Recombinant adeno-associated viral vectors in the nervous system

Recombinant adeno-associated virus 2 (rAAV2) has been extensively used as a gene delivery vector for the nervous system. It targets primarily neurons in the nervous system and results in sustained long-term expression of transgenes. New rAAV serotypes have been characterized and demonstrated to have improved transduction efficiencies in various regions of the brain and spinal cord. This review discusses some properties of rAAV that have been studied in the nervous system such as cell tropism, duration of transgene expression, and distribution of viral transduction, as well as immunity and regulation of transgene expression issues, all of which are important for optimization of the use of rAAV in the nervous system.

Adeno-associated virus-mediated aspartoacylase gene transfer to the brain of knockout mouse for canavan disease

Canavan disease (CD) is an autosomal recessive leukodystrophy caused by deficiency of aspartoacylase (ASPA). Deficiency of ASPA leads to elevation of N-acetyl-L-aspartic acid (NAA) in the brain and urine. To explore the feasibility of gene transfer to replace ASPA in CD, we generated a knockout mouse and constructed an AAV vector that encodes human ASPA cDNA (hASPA) followed by green fluorescent protein (GFP) after an intraribosomal entry site. We injected CD mice with rAAV-hASPA-GFP in the striatum and thalamus or injected rAAV-GFP identically into control animals. Three to five months after the injection, we determined the presence of ASPA in the CD mouse brain by ASPA activity assay, GFP expression, and Western blot analysis. While rAAV-GFP-injected animals displayed undetectable levels of ASPA, all detection methods revealed significant ASPA levels in rAAV-hASPA-GFP-injected CD mice. We evaluated the functional effects of rAAV-hASPA-GFP-mediated ASPA expression by standard histological methods, magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) for in vivo NAA levels, and magnetic resonance imaging of CD mice. rAAV-hASPA-injected animals displayed a remarkable lack of spongiform degeneration in the thalamus. However, pathology in sites unrelated to the injected areas showed no improvement in histopathology. The improvement in thalamic neuropathology was also detectable via in vivo MRI. MRS revealed that in vivo NAA levels were also reduced. These data indicate that rAAV-mediated ASPA delivery may be an interesting avenue for the treatment of CD.

Clinical protocol. Gene therapy of Canavan disease: AAV-2 vector for neurosurgical delivery of aspartoacylase gene (ASPA) to the human brain

This clinical protocol describes virus-based gene transfer for Canavan disease, a childhood leukodystrophy. Canavan disease, also known as Van Bogaert-Bertrand disease, is a monogeneic, autosomal recessive disease in which the gene coding for the enzyme aspartoacylase (ASPA) is defective. The lack of functional enzyme leads to an increase in the central nervous system of the substrate molecule, N-acetyl-aspartate (NAA), which impairs normal myelination and results in spongiform degeneration of the brain. No effective treatment currently exists; however, virus-based gene transfer has the potential to arrest or reverse the course of this otherwise fatal condition. This procedure involves neurosurgical administration of approximately 900 billion genomic particles (approximately 10 billion infectious particles) of recombinant adeno-associated virus (AAV) containing the aspartoacylase gene (ASPA) directly to affected regions of the brain in each of 21 patients with Canavan disease. Pre- and post-delivery assessments include a battery of noninvasive biochemical, radiological, and neurological tests. This gene transfer study represents the first clinical use of AAV in the human brain and the first instance of viral gene transfer for a neurodegenerative disease.

Viral-based gene transfer to the mammalian CNS for functional genomic studies

A fundamental problem in neuroscience has been the creation of suitable in vivo model systems to study basic neurological phenomena and pathology of the central nervous system (CNS). Somatic cell genetic engineering with viral vectors provides a versatile tool to model normal brain physiology and a variety of neurological diseases.

Gene therapy for acute diseases

The use of gene transfer systems to study cell function makes it apparent that overexpression of a transgene can restore or improve the function of a protein and positively influence cell function in a predetermined manner for purposes of counterbalancing cellular pathophysiology. The ability of some gene transfer vehicles to produce transgene product within hours of delivery positions gene transfer as a unique pharmaceutical administration system that can quickly affect production of biologic response modifiers in a highly compartmentalized fashion. This approach can be expected to overcome many of the adverse effects and high costs of systemic delivery of recombinant pharmaceuticals. This review highlights recent advances toward development of gene therapies for acute illnesses with particular emphasis on preclinical models of disease. In this context, a growing body of data suggests that gene therapies for polygenic and non-genetic diseases such as asthma, cardiogenic and non-cardiogenic pulmonary edema, stroke, subarachnoid hemorrhage, seizures, acute myocardial infarction, endovascular thrombosis, and infections may someday be options for the treatment of patients.

Gene Transfer into Neurons from Hippocampal Slices: Comparison of Recombinant Semliki Forest Virus, Adenovirus, Adeno-Associated Virus, Lentivirus, and Measles Virus

Viral vectors are useful for transferring genes into neurons. Here, we characterized recombinant Semliki Forest virus (SFV), adenovirus type 5 (Ad5), adeno-associated virus type 2 (AAV), lentivirus, and measles virus (MV) by their expression of green fluorescent protein (GFP) in rat hippocampal slice cultures. SFV infected more neurons (>90% of all GFP-positive cells) than AAV, lentivirus, and MV (71, 69, and 62%, respectively), whereas no infected neurons were identified with Ad5. AAV-mediated GFP expression was neuron-specific when the platelet-derived growth factor beta-chain promoter rather than cytomegalovirus promoter was used. Transgene expression occurred rapidly but transiently for SFV, increased slowly but remained stable with AAV and lentivirus, and was fast with MV. Resting membrane potential and conductance, action potentials, firing accommodation, and H-current appeared normal in infected CA1 pyramidal cells. Thus, SFV is useful for short-term and AAV and lentivirus for long-term transduction of hippocampal slices, while MV constitutes a novel vector.

Adenovirus-mediated transfer and expression of beta-gal in injured hippocampus after traumatic brain injury in mice

In models of focal cerebral ischemia, adenoviral gene transfer is often attenuated or delayed versus naive. After controlled cortical impact (CCI)-induced traumatic brain injury in mice, CA1 and CA3 hippocampus exhibit delayed neuronal death by 3 days, with subsequent near complete loss of hippocampus by 21 days. We hypothesized that adenoviral-mediated expression of the reporter gene beta-Galactosidase (beta-Gal) in hippocampus would be attenuated after CCI in mice. C57BL6 mice (n = 16) were subjected to either CCI to left parietal cortex or sham (burr hole). Adenovirus carrying the beta-Gal gene (AdlacZ; 1 x 10(9) plaque-forming units [pfu]/mL) was then injected into left dorsal hippocampus. At 24 or 72 h, beta-Gal expression was quantified (mU/mg protein). Separate mice (n = 10) were used to study beta-Gal spatial distribution in brain sections. Beta-Gal expression in left hippocampus was similar in shams at 24 h (48.4 +/- 4.1) versus 72 h (68.8 +/- 8.8, not significant). CCI did not reduce beta-Gal expression in left hippocampus (68.8 +/- 8.8 versus 88.1 +/- 7.0 at 72 h, sham versus CCI, not significant). In contrast, CCI reduced beta-Gal expression in right (contralateral) hippocampus versus sham (p < 0.05 at both 24 and 72 h). Beta-Gal was seen in many cell types in ipsilateral hippocampus, including CA3 neurons. Despite eventual loss of ipsilateral hippocampus, adenovirus-mediated gene transfer was surprisingly robust early after CCI providing an opportunity to test novel genes targeting delayed hippocampal neuronal death.

Adeno-associated virus-based vectors in gene therapy

Adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors were shown capable of high efficiency transduction of both dividing and nondividing cells and tissues. AAV-mediated transduction leads to stable, long-term transgene expression in the absence of apparent immune response. These properties and the broad host range of AAV vectors indicate that they constitute a powerful tool for gene therapy purposes. An additional potential benefit of AAV vectors is their ability to integrate site-specifically in the presence of Rep proteins which can be expressed transiently, thus limiting their suspected adverse effects. The major restrictions of AAV as vectors are their limited genetic capacity and strict packaging size constraint of less than 5 kb. Another difficulty is the labor-intensive and expensive procedure for the production and packaging of recombinant AAV vectors. The major benefits and drawbacks of AAV vectors and advances made in the past 3 years are discussed.

Aspartoacylase gene transfer to the mammalian central nervous system with therapeutic implications for Canavan disease

With the ultimate goal of developing safe and effective in vivo gene therapy for the treatment of Canavan disease and other neurological disorders, we developed a non-viral lipid-entrapped, polycation-condensed delivery system (LPD) for central nervous system gene transfer, in conjunction with adeno-associated virus (AAV)-based plasmids containing recombinant aspartoacylase (ASPA). The gene delivery system was tested in healthy rodents and primates, before proceeding to preliminary studies in 2 children with Canavan disease. Toxicity and expression testing was first carried out in human 293 cells, which demonstrated effective transduction of cells and high levels of functional ASPA activity. We performed in vivo toxicity and expression testing of LPD/pAAVaspa and LPD/pAAVlac in rodents, which demonstrated widespread gene expression for more than 10 months after intraventricular delivery, and local expression in deep brain nuclei and white matter tracts for more than 6 months after intraparenchymal injections, with no significant adverse effects. We also performed intraventricular delivery of LPD/pAAVaspa to 2 cynomologous monkeys, with 2 additional monkeys receiving LPD and saline controls. None of the monkeys demonstrated significant adverse effects, and at 1 month the 2 LPD/pAAVaspa monkeys were positive for human ASPA transcript by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction of brain tissue punches. Finally, we performed the first in vivo gene transfer study for a human neurodegenerative disease in 2 children with Canavan disease to assess the in vivo toxicity and efficacy of ASPA gene delivery. Our results suggest that LPD/pAAVaspa is well tolerated in human subjects and is associated with biochemical, radiological, and clinical changes.

Introduction to gene therapy in neurological surgery

Gene therapy is an exciting new discipline in which neurosurgery and neurosurgeons can have a direct impact on both patient care and emerging scientific developments. Unlike other organs, the brain is unique in that it has a blood–brain barrier, often preventing efficient systemic gene delivery to the area of interest. Therefore, not only is gene delivery required, but it will often need to be accomplished in a local and specific manner. Although brain neoplasms have been the most commonly studied application of genetic therapeutics in neurological surgery, there are many other potential applications of this technology to neurosurgical disorders, including spinal instability, neurodegenerative disease, neurogenetic diseases, central nervous system (CNS) injury, aneurysms, trauma, stroke, and epilepsy. As the field of gene therapy for the CNS develops from the preclinical setting to clinical trials to mainstream therapy, the need for safe and specific gene delivery will be increasingly apparent. Neurosurgeons are in an enviable position as there is nobody more qualified to address the issue of how a gene can be delivered to the central nervous system. Not only do we have the training to operate on the nervous system and its coverings, but we have the ability to recognize and take care of complications that may arise from these procedures. However, the neurosurgeon's role in gene therapy for the brain and spine should not be confined to gene delivery only. Instead, we also need to understand and have a role in deciding what genes could have therapeutic utility in our patients. Herein lies our challenge in gene therapy: how can we as neurosurgeons interface with our basic science colleagues to address rapidly all of the problems that are blocking the advancement of nucleic acid therapeutics into the clinical setting.

Restorative gene therapy approaches to Parkinson's disease

Perhaps one of the most exciting developments in brain research of the past decade is the advent of genetic intervention in human neurologic disease. Although there are a variety of gene transfer approaches, none of which has been perfected, gene therapy is now science fact and no longer science fiction. As technology progresses, some vectors will prove more effective for certain disease categories than others; it is too early to predict definitively which vector would be most effective for therapy in Parkinson's disease and other movement disorders. Nonetheless, it is likely that within the next year or two a gene therapy trial will be instituted in human patients with Parkinson's disease. The potential for an impact on the symptoms and progression of this disease is significant. Clinicians may be on the threshold of a new era of intervention for Parkinson's disease and other neurologic diseases, based on bypassing traditional but less selective drug-extracellular receptor interactions and instead focusing on genetic modulation of specific intracellular processes. The continuing development of small incremental changes of new dopamine agonists and pharmacologic agents will likely pale in comparison to the specificity of intracellular genetic manipulation.