State-dependent learning and drug discriminative control of behaviour: an overview

Neurologizing the Psychology of Affects: How Appraisal-Based Constructivism and Basic Emotion Theory Can Coexist

Abundant neurobehavioral data, not discussed by Lisa Feldman Barrett (2006) , support the existence of a variety of core emotional operating systems in ancient subneocortical regions of the brain ( Panksepp, 1998a , 2005a ). Such brain systems are the primary-process ancestral birthrights of all mammals. There may be as many genetically and neurochemically coded subcortical affect systems in emotionally rich medial regions of the brain as there are “natural” emotional action systems in the brain. When emotional primes are aroused directly, as with local electrical or chemical stimulation, the affective changes sustain conditioned place preferences and place aversions, which are the premier secondary-process indices of affective states in animals. Humans are not immune to such brain manipulations; they typically exhibit strong emotional feelings. Human emotion researchers should not ignore these systems and simply look at the complex and highly variable culturally molded manifestations of emotions in humans if they wish to determine what kinds of “natural” emotional processes exist within all mammalian brain. Basic emotion science has generated workable epistemological strategies for under-standing the primal sources of human emotional feelings by detailed study of emotional circuits in our fellow animals.

Differentiation between low- and high-efficacy CB1 receptor agonists using a drug discrimination protocol for rats

RATIONALE

The "subjective high" from marijuana ingestion is likely due to Δ(9)-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) activating the central cannabinoid receptor type 1 (CB1R) of the endocannabinoid signaling system. THC is a weak partial agonist according to in vitro assays, yet THC mimics the behavioral effects induced by more efficacious cannabinergics. This distinction may be important for understanding similarities and differences in the dose-effect spectra produced by marijuana/THC and designer cannabimimetics ("synthetic marijuana").

OBJECTIVE

We evaluated if drug discrimination is able to functionally detect/differentiate between a full, high-efficacy CB1R agonist [(±)AM5983] and the low-efficacy agonist THC in vivo.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Rats were trained to discriminate between four different doses of AM5983 (0.10 to 0.56 mg/kg), and vehicle and dose generalization curves were determined for both ligands at all four training doses of AM5983. The high-efficacy WIN55,212-2 and the lower-efficacy (R)-(+)-methanandamide were examined at some AM5983 training conditions. Antagonism tests involved rimonabant and WIN55,212-2 and AM5983. The separate (S)- and (R)-isomers of (±)AM5983 were tested at one AM5983 training dose (0.30 mg/kg). The in vitro cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) assay examined AM5983 and the known CB1R agonist CP55,940.

RESULTS

Dose generalization ed50 values increased as a function of the training dose of AM5983, but more so for the partial agonists. The order of potency was (R)-isomer > (±)AM5983 > (S)-isomer and AM5983 > WIN55,212-2 ≥ THC > (R)-(+)-methanandamide. Surmountable antagonism of AM5983 and WIN55,212-2 occurred with rimonabant. The cAMP assay confirmed the cannabinergic nature of AM5983 and CP55,940.

CONCLUSIONS

Drug discrimination using different training doses of a high-efficacy, full CB1R agonist differentiated between low- and high-efficacy CB1R agonists.

Tolerance, sensitization and dependence to diazepam in Balb/c mice exposed to a novel open space anxiety test

Balb/c mice were exposed to an elevated platform that is extended on two opposite sides with lowered steep slopes. They were tested for 12min per session in 6 successive days. They received i.p. administration of either saline or one dose of diazepam (DZP 0.5, 1, 3mg/kg) in sessions 1-3, and saline in sessions 4 and 5. All groups of mice received a single dose of DZP (1mg/kg) in session 6. DZP produced inverted U-shaped dose-responses on the number of entries into different areas of the apparatus, with a peak in mean response at 1mg/kg whereas its effect on the duration of entries was mostly comparable between the 3 doses. It increased the number of crossings on the surface of the platform and facilitated entries onto the slopes. DZP-treated mice crossed frequently onto and spent longer time on the slopes in sessions 1-3 whereas saline-treated mice remained on the platform in sessions 1-6. Withdrawal of DZP in sessions 4-5 increased the latency of first entry and decreased the number and duration of entries onto the slopes which was reversed with the administration of 1mg/kg of DZP in the next session. This ON-OFF the drug may be due to the half-life of DZP which is very short in mice and rats ( approximately 0.88h). It also indicates that DZP-treated mice did not benefit from previous experience of entries onto the slopes which suggests a possible "state-dependent" effect. Administration of DZP after repeated exposures to the test did not facilitate entries onto the slopes but instead increased significantly the number of crossings on the surface of the platform; this increase was much higher than that observed in mice initially treated with DZP and exposed to the test. There is no evidence of habituation in saline-treated mice: the number of crossings on the platform was comparable between the first 5 sessions of the test. These results demonstrate that repeated exposures to the same anxiogenic environment resulted in avoidance responses developing tolerance and approach responses developing sensitization. They suggest that tolerance and sensitization are two opposite sides of the habituation process to the same stimulus and may account for the maintained state of anxiety.

Rapid, specific and active site-catalyzed effect of tissue-plasminogen activator on hippocampus-dependent learning in mice

In the present study we trained tissue-plasminogen activator (tPA)-knockout (tPA -/-) and wild-type (tPA +/+) male mice in step-down inhibitory avoidance learning, a hippocampus-dependent task. tPA -/- displayed significantly shorter latencies to step down at 90 min, one, two and seven days after training indicating the learning deficit in these animals (P < 0.05 vs tPA +/+). The locomotor activity, the level of anxiety in an elevated-plus maze, as well as the pain threshold did not differ between the two strains of mice. The learning disability of tPA -/- was overcome by more intense training. The learning deficit was also partially restored by limited intrahippocampal delivery of tPA (infused for 2 h before training; P < 0.05 vs control), but not by the delivery of urokinase plasminogen activator, indicating the acute need for tPA in learning. The beneficial effect of tPA was abolished by co-infusion of its inhibitor tPA-STOP, indicating that the facilitatory effect of tPA on learning requires a proteolytic step. However, tPA activity in the hippocampus was not indispensable for effective memory retrieval in tPA-infused tPA -/- mice. Thus, rapid, specific and proteolytic action of tPA facilitates hippocampus-dependent learning, but not retrieval of previously acquired information.

Four-choice drug discrimination in pigeons

(+)Amphetamine was added as a training stimulus for pigeons previously trained to discriminate among pentobarbital, morphine and saline using a three-choice procedure. Pigeons quickly learned the four-choice drug discrimination. Generalization from the training drugs was similar to that established with simpler drug discriminations; pentobarbital generalized to chlordiazepoxide, morphine generalized to methadone, and (+)amphetamine generalized to cocaine and methamphetamine. Low doses of phencyclidine generalized to saline, while higher doses partially generalized to pentobarbital and (+)amphetamine. When dose-response curves were redetermined with a cumulative-dosing procedure, the same pattern of generalization occurred as under single-dose procedures. Dose-response curves were quantal under both the single-dose and the cumulative-dosing procedures. The four-choice procedure offers some important advantages for studying the discriminative stimulus effects of drugs that interact with multiple receptor subtypes and for studying drug mixtures.

The pharmacology of latent inhibition as an animal model of schizophrenia

The nature of the primary symptoms of schizophrenia and our lack of knowledge of its underlying cause both contribute to the difficulty of generating convincing animal models of schizophrenia. A more recent approach to investigating the biological basis of schizophrenia has been to use information processing models of the disease to link psychotic phenomena to their neural basis. Schizophrenics are impaired in a number of experimental cognitive tasks that support this approach, including sensory gating tasks and models of selective attention such as latent inhibition (LI). LI refers to a process in which noncontingent presentation of a stimulus attenuates its ability to enter into subsequent associations, and it has received much attention because it is widely considered to relate to the cognitive abnormalities that characterise acute schizophrenia. Several claims have been made for LI having face and construct validity for schizophrenia. In this review of the pharmacological studies carried out with LI we examine its claim to predictive validity and the role of methodological considerations in drug effects. The data reviewed demonstrate that facilitation of low levels of LI is strongly related to demonstrated antipsychotic activity in man and all major antipsychotic drugs, both typical and atypical, have been shown to potentiate LI using a variety of protocols. Very few compounds without antipsychotic activity are active in this model. In contrast, disruption of LI occurs with a wide range of drugs and the relationship with psychotomimetic potential is less clear. Although reversal of disrupted LI has also been used as a model for antipsychotic acticity, mostly using amphetamine-induced disruption, insufficient studies have been carried out to evaluate its claim to predictive validity. However, like facilitation, it is sensitive to both typical and atypical antipsychotic agents. The data we have reviewed here demonstrate that facilitation of LI and, perhaps to a lesser extent, reversal of disrupted LI fulfil the criteria for predictive validity.

Hormones of the hypothalamo-pituitary-gonadal axis in drug discrimination learning

More than 30 years ago, T-maze studies with progesterone indicated that sex hormones have the potential to act as a discriminative stimulus in rats. Despite these early positive findings, the interest in discriminative stimulus properties of sex hormones remained low; few studies were dedicated to the investigation of discriminative stimulus properties of hypothalamo-pituitary-gonadal axis hormones (i.e., LHRH, LH/FSH, sex steroids). Nevertheless, the few studies that were published showed some interesting, and often sex-dependent results. Applying various methodologies (T-, or Y-maze, two-lever drug discrimination, taste aversion procedures), it was found that not only progesterone but also the two other principal sex steroids estradiol and testosterone can serve as discriminative stimuli in rodents. In addition to these gonadal hormones, the hypothalamic peptide LHRH (having a key role in the neuroendocrine regulation of steroid release from the gonads) appears to generate discriminative stimulus properties. Interestingly, recent (but preliminary) studies in postmenopausal women suggest that estradiol (and possibly progesterone) may also function as a discriminative stimulus in human subjects.

Abolition of long-term stability of new hippocampal place cell maps by NMDA receptor blockade

Hippocampal pyramidal cells are called place cells because each cell tends to fire only when the animal is in a particular part of the environment-the cell's firing field. Acute pharmacological blockade of N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) glutamate receptors was used to investigate how NMDA-based synaptic plasticity participates in the formation and maintenance of the firing fields. The results suggest that the formation and short-term stability of firing fields in a new environment involve plasticity that is independent of NMDA receptor activation. By contrast, the long-term stabilization of newly established firing fields required normal NMDA receptor function and, therefore, may be related to other NMDA-dependent processes such as long-term potentiation and spatial learning.

The discrimination and durability of an ethanol cue in young and mid-aged female mice

Young adult (6 months) and mid-aged (12 months) C57BL/6 mice both learned to discriminate ethanol (ETOH, 1.0 g/kg) although criterion performance occurred later for mid-aged mice. ETOH discrimination improved with increasing dose (0.25-1.0 g/kg) and the dose-response function was unaffected by age. The ETOH cue had declined by 40 min postinjection for young mice not unlike a previous report for young rats. In contrast, the ETOH cue remained discriminable at 40 min for mid-aged mice, an effect perhaps due to their slower rate of ETOH metabolism and accountable for the previously reported reduction in ethanol consumption by mid-aged mice. Retention tests and reacquisition training both indicated that the ETOH cue can be retained by both age groups for at least 60 days without discrimination training or food deprivation. The present study suggests that the ethanol discriminative cue in mid-aged mice does not differ from that in young adult mice in potency but is more long lasting, the latter perhaps being related to their reduced ethanol consumption. Of significance from a therapeutic perspective, is that the ETOH cue remained discriminable for 2 months in both age groups (i.e., approximately 1/12 of their total life span).

Empirical evidence that the state dependence and drug discrimination paradigms can generate different outcomes

The study compared the outcomes generated by the State Dependence and Drug Discrimination paradigms with ethanol in the rat. Food-deprived rats learned to complete a fixed-ratio 10 schedule of bar presses for food within 120 s while treated with 320- to 1250-mg/kg doses of ethanol. Subsequent tests of recall of this response with saline failed to generate any evidence that transfer was hampered following the drug-to-saline state change. In contrast, each of 14 rats learned to discriminate 1250 mg/kg ethanol from saline in a Drug Discrimination procedure that also required the animals to press one of two levers for food according to a fixed- ratio 10 schedule. The results offer the first empirical evidence to demonstrate directly that the State Dependence and Drug Discrimination paradigms can generate different outcomes in otherwise identical experimental conditions.

Drug discrimination training with low doses: maintenance of discriminative control

Procedures are reported that maintain control by the drug cue during and after drug discrimination training with lower doses that yield predominantly vehicle-appropriate choices. Twelve pigeons were trained to discriminate chlordiazepoxide (CDP) from saline using two-key (drug vs. vehicle) drug discrimination procedures. Intermixed within each block of 30 sessions were nine sessions of training with 8.0 mg/kg CDP, nine with one of seven lower training doses (4.0, 2.8, 2.0, 1.4, 1.0, 0.7, or 0.5 mg/kg CDP), and 12 with saline. The lower training dose was decreased across blocks. The three lowest training doses (1.0, 0.7, and 0.5 mg/kg CDP) yielded predominantly saline-appropriate choices but had no effect on discrimination of 8.0 mg/kg CDP or saline. Three doses (2.0, 1.4, and 1.0 mg/kg CDP) were retrained, and each yielded percentages of drug-appropriate choices nearly identical to those obtained during previous training. This drug discrimination procedure maintains control by the drug cue during and after training with vehicle-like doses of the training drug and may allow for repeated assessment of effects of low training doses.

Phenytoin and phenobarbital: a comparison of their state-dependent effects

Two commonly used antiepileptic drugs, phenytoin sodium and phenobarbital sodium, were investigated for state-dependency effects at different doses. Male Wistar strain rats trained to a criterion in an inhibitory avoidance task and a food-motivated T-maze task under varying drug and nondrug states were subjected to retention tests 24 and 48 h, respectively, following acquisition. The treatment instituted at the time of retrieval was either the same as, or different from, that used during training. The results indicated that phenytoin produced state-dependency effects at test doses of 20, 40, and 60 mg/kg in the avoidance task and at test dose of 20 mg/kg in the T-maze task experiments. These state-specific effects were comparable to those of phenobarbital sodium (5 and 10 mg/kg). The reinstitution of the drug state in an additional test session produced approximately equal and significant recovery of conditioned responses in the T-maze paradigm both in phenytoin and phenobarbital groups. These results demonstrate, for the first time, the ability of phenytoin to produce state-dependency effects in a pattern similar to that observed with a widely studied compound such as phenobarbital. Overall, the data provide no support for the view that the degree of discriminability of a drug is an indicator of potential state-dependency effects and is restricted only to the dosage high enough to produce noticeable intoxication.

Evidence for state-dependent retrieval in conditioned place aversion

State-dependent retrieval (SDR) in conditioned place aversion (CPA) was observed using Long-Evans male rats, with three different aversive drugs injected ip: lithium chloride (31.8 mg/kg), FG 7142 (10 mg/kg), and naloxone (5 mg/kg). Experiment 1 showed that state-dependent dissociation was complete with lithium chloride following two conditioning trials, but disappeared when the number of learning sessions was increased. Experiment 2 showed that following two conditioning trials, such complete state-dependent dissociations were also observed when FG 7142 or naloxone were used during conditioning. The results of this study showed that the expression of SDR is not monotonic in CPA paradigm but depends on the stage of learning. In addition, SDR can be observed following administration of a variety of drugs known to produce CPA, but differing in their neurochemical targets and the nature of the aversive effects they induce. Finally, these results are discussed with regard to what is known about SDR in other paradigms.

Interaction between benzodiazepine and GABA-A receptors in state-dependent learning

State-dependent learning (SDL) induced by benzodiazepine (BDZ) and GABA-A agonists was investigated in the step-through passive avoidance task in rats. Pre-training injection of diazepam or muscimol dose-dependently reduced step-through latency in the test session conducted 24 hr after the training. Injection of either drug before both the training and test sessions, however, failed to reduce the latency. The results show that passive avoidance failures induced by pre-training injections of diazepam and muscimol are due to SDL. In contrast to diazepam and muscimol, baclofen induced no SDL. Diazepam and muscimol were found to substitute for each other in producing SDL. The failure of learning performance in SDL (dissociation in SDL) induced by diazepam was blocked by flumazenil and picrotoxin but not by bicuculline injected before the training session, whereas dissociation in SDL induced by muscimol was blocked by flumazenil, bicuculline and picrotoxin. On the other hand, the success of learning performance in SDL (non-dissociation in SDL) induced by diazepam was blocked by flumazenil, bicuculline and picrotoxin injected before the test session, whereas non-dissociation in SDL induced by muscimol was blocked by bicuculline and picrotoxin but not by flumazenil. These results demonstrate that 1) BDZ and GABA-A agonists produce a common drug state, but, 2) roles of each receptor in SDL might be different, i.e., BDZ receptors for dissociation in SDL and GABA-A receptors for non-dissociation in SDL, and 3) chloride ion channels are essential for the induction of SDL by BDZ and GABA-A agonists.

Is blockade of conditioned flavor aversions by chlorpheniramine the result of state dependency?

Conditioned flavor aversions induced by pairing flavored fluids with ionizing irradiation, lithium chloride, estrogen, or centrifugal rotation have been blocked by prior administration of chlorpheniramine. The blockade may be due to state dependency. This possibility was evaluated in the present experiment, which assigned female Long-Evans rats to a factorial combination of chlorpheniramine (20 mg/kg) vs saline during training, centrifugal rotation (150 rpm for 15 min) vs none as an UCS, and chlorpheniramine vs saline in testing. Rats conditioned with saline and rotation showed strong aversions when tested with either same or chlorpheniramine. Rats conditioned with chlorpheniramine and rotation showed no change during conditioning; when tested with saline they showed no aversion, and when tested with chlorpheniramine they showed no change from conditioning. Rats conditioned with either chlorpheniramine or saline and no rotation showed high fluid intake when tested with saline and reduced fluid intake when tested with chlorpheniramine. The results were interpreted as offering little support for state dependency.

Is anisomycin-induced amnesia for a passive avoidance task in chicks the result of state-dependent learning?

Many studies suggest that protein synthesis is required for formation of long-term memory. To test whether the protein synthesis inhibitor anisomycin (ANI) actually inhibits long-term memory formation or whether apparent amnesia could be attributed to state-dependency, chicks were both trained and tested under the influence of anisomycin (ANI). Two-day-old cockerels were trained in a 1-trial passive avoidance task. Intracerebral injections (10 microliters per hemisphere) of either saline (SAL) or 11.0 mM ANI were made into the medial hyperstriatum ventrale 5 min pretraining and 5 min pretest. The ANI inhibited cerebral protein synthesis by 70-80%, a level necessary to cause amnesia. Chicks that pecked a small bead dipped in methylanthranilate (MeA) and were injected with SAL both pretraining and pretest avoided pecking at test, showing memory for the bitter substance; chicks given ANI pretraining and SAL pretest pecked at the bead during test, which suggests amnesia. However, those given ANI both pretraining and pretest showed marked avoidance at test. Chicks trained to peck at a small bead dipped in water and given injections of either SAL or ANI pretraining and SAL pretest pecked readily at test. However, water-trained chicks given ANI pretest, regardless of pretraining injection, showed significantly higher avoidance at test. We conclude that peck aversion in the ANI-MeA-ANI group was not due to state-dependency but to generalized avoidance induced by pretest ANI.

Concentrations of ethanol in rebreathed air of rats: correlation with the discriminative stimulus effects of ethanol

We modified the method of Pohorecky and Brick (14) for determination of ethanol (ETOH) concentrations in rebreathed air of rats. Rats were injected with different doses (1-2 g/kg) of ETOH and both arterial blood and rebreathed air samples were collected at various time intervals (15-120 min) after administration. We found a very good correlation (r = .96) between ETOH concentrations in arterial blood and in rebreathed air; the blood/breath conversion factor (+/- SEM) was 3241 +/- 55. In the second part of the study, rats were trained to discriminate between IP administered ETOH (1.2 g/kg) and the saline vehicle (12 ml/kg). Training occurred 15 min after administrations. Once trained to reliably differentiate between ETOH/saline training sessions, different doses (0.6, 0.9 and 1.2 g/kg) of ETOH were examined at various time intervals (1, 7.5, 15, 30, 60, 120 and 240 min) after administrations on certain test days. The results indicated a good correlation (r = .65) between the discriminative stimulus effects of ETOH and the concentrations measured in rebreathed air. The behavioral effects as well as the concentrations of ETOH in rebreathed air have a fast onset. The peak occurred 7.5 min after injection, and both the stimulus effects and concentrations of ETOH were time- and dose-dependent.

Ethanol and Ro 15-4513: behaviour maintained by operant procedures (DRL-72s and PTZ-drug discrimination) in rats

The proposed amethystic imidazobenzodiazepine Ro 15-4513 and ethanol (ETOH) were examined in rats using two operant procedures, differential reinforcement of low rates of responding (DRL), and drug discrimination learning (DDL). In the first bar-pressing responses occurring 72 s or longer after the last reinforcement were rewarded; responses occurring earlier reset the time schedule. In the latter, animals were trained to discriminate between the effects of the analeptic pentylenetetrazole (PTZ) and the non-drug condition; the schedule of reinforcement was FR-10. Water was the reinforcer. A dose of 1000 mg/kg ETOH decreased the rate of bar pressing in the DRL experiment; doses of 300 and 560 mg/kg ETOH did not. The decrease was not attenuated by Ro 15-4513. No significant deviations from baseline responding occurred with Ro 15-4513 (1, 3 10 mg/kg). The number of reinforcements increased significantly after ETOH (1000 mg/kg), but not after Ro 15-4513. Combinations of the two agents produced increases in the number of reinforcements. Changes in DRL behaviour induced by diazepam (1 and 10 mg/kg) were normalized by 3 mg/kg Ro 15-4513. In DDL, Ro 15-4513 (10 mg/kg) substituted for PTZ; ETOH did not. Diazepam and Ro 15-1788 attenuated the response generalization from Ro 15-4513 to PTZ; ETOH did not. There was a dose-related increase in the time to complete the DDL tests after ETOH treatment; addition of Ro 15-4513 increased the time further. In conclusion, antagonism between Ro 15-4513 and ETOH did not occur in the present studies; data are furthermore consistent with the view that Ro 15-4513 acts as a partial inverse benzodiazepine agonist.

Effects of ethanol on mature offspring of mice given ethanol during pregnancy

Male offspring of mice maintained on isocaloric liquid diets containing either 20% ethanol or sucrose derived calories during pregnancy were tested on their ability to discriminate different ethanol doses as adults. They were trained to lever-press for a food reward on each of two levers in an operant chamber, and were then maintained on an FR20 reinforcement schedule. After response rates stabilized, ethanol discrimination training was initiated by reinforcing only responses made on the drug appropriate-lever after i.p. injections of ethanol (1.0 g/kg) or water. After learning to discriminate the 1.0 g dose, the animals' ability to discriminate doses of 0.25, 0.50, 0.75, 1.0, and 1.5 g/kg was assessed by determining the percentage of responses made on the drug lever during a 2-min test period. Compared to sucrose controls, mice exposed to alcohol in utero learned the lever response more slowly and were less responsive to injected ethanol as evidenced by a reduced effect of the drug on response rates and by a reduction in their ability to discriminate the presence of injected ethanol. The results indicate that prenatal ethanol exposure can have long term consequences which reduce the effects of ethanol in fully mature animals.

Cueing effects of anxiolytic benzodiazepines (DZP and Ro 11-3128): stereospecificity and antagonism by the convulsant benzodiazepine Ro 5-3663

Two groups of gerbils were trained in a T-maze to discriminate between the vehicle condition (4 ml/kg) and either of the benzodiazepine (BDZ) agonists diazepam (DZP) and Ro 11-3128; administration (5.6 mg/kg) was IP 5 min prior to training onset. Once trained, novel doses and drugs were assessed in test sessions interposed between the regular training days. A dose-related generalization effect occurred with both compounds (range 0.1-5.6 mg/kg), the effect being similar at both the 5 and 15 min test intervals; the two intervals were evaluated after a single injection. The lack of generalization of Ro 11-3624 (range 5.6-56 mg/kg) indicates a stereoisomeric separation of BDZ agonist activity. Ro 5-4864 (range 17.5-56 mg/kg), an agent chemically/structurally related to DZP, did not produce DZP responding at either of the two test inverals; clear-cut convulsant activity occurred at the 15 min interval. The convulsant BDZ compound Ro 5-3663 (3 and 10 mg/kg) antagonized the DZP stimulus irrespective of whether Ro 5-3663 was given either prior to, simultaneously with, or shortly after the DZP injection.