Allograft tolerance after total lymphoid irradiation (TLI)

Transplant Tolerance, Not Only Clonal Deletion

The quest to understand how allogeneic transplanted tissue is not rejected and how tolerance is induced led to fundamental concepts in immunology. First, we review the research that led to the Clonal Deletion theory in the late 1950s that has since dominated the field of immunology and transplantation. At that time many basic mechanisms of immune response were unknown, including the role of lymphocytes and T cells in rejection. These original observations are reassessed by considering T regulatory cells that are produced by thymus of neonates to prevent autoimmunity. Second, we review "operational tolerance" induced in adult rodents and larger animals such as pigs. This can occur spontaneously especially with liver allografts, but also can develop after short courses of a variety of rejection inhibiting therapies. Over time these animals develop alloantigen specific tolerance to the graft but retain the capacity to reject third-party grafts. These animals have a "split tolerance" as peripheral lymphocytes from these animals respond to donor alloantigen in graft versus host assays and in mixed lymphocyte cultures, indicating there is no clonal deletion. Investigation of this phenomenon excludes many mechanisms, including anti-donor antibody blocking rejection as well as anti-idiotypic responses mediated by antibody or T cells. This split tolerance is transferred to a second immune-depleted host by T cells that retain the capacity to effect rejection of third-party grafts by the same host. Third, we review research on alloantigen specific inhibitory T cells that led to the first identification of the CD4+CD25+T regulatory cell. The key role of T cell derived cytokines, other than IL-2, in promoting survival and expansion of antigen specific T regulatory cells that mediate transplant tolerance is reviewed. The precise methods for inducing and diagnosing operational tolerance remain to be defined, but antigen specific T regulatory cells are key mediators.

Establishment of Chimerism and Organ Transplant Tolerance in Laboratory Animals: Safety and Efficacy of Adaptation to Humans

The definition of immune tolerance to allogeneic tissue and organ transplants in laboratory animals and humans continues to be the acceptance of the donor graft, rejection of third-party grafts, and specific unresponsiveness of recipient immune cells to the donor alloantigens in the absence of immunosuppressive treatments. Actively acquired tolerance was achieved in mice more than 60 years ago by the establishment of mixed chimerism in neonatal mice. Once established, mixed chimerism was self-perpetuating and allowed for acceptance of tissue transplants in adults. Successful establishment of tolerance in humans has now been reported in several clinical trials based on the development of chimerism after combined transplantation of hematopoietic cells and an organ from the same donor. This review examines the mechanisms of organ graft acceptance after establishment of mixed chimerism (allo-tolerance) or complete chimerism (self-tolerance), and compares the development of graft versus host disease (GVHD) and graft versus tumor (GVT) activity in complete and mixed chimerism. GVHD, GVT activity, and complete chimerism are also discussed in the context of bone marrow transplantation to treat hematologic malignancies. The roles of transient versus persistent mixed chimerism in the induction and maintenance of tolerance and organ graft acceptance in animal models and clinical studies are compared. Key differences in the stability of mixed chimeras and tolerance induction in MHC matched and mismatched rodents, large laboratory animals, and humans are examined to provide insights into the safety and efficacy of translation of results of animal models to clinical trials.

Development of immunosuppressive myeloid cells to induce tolerance in solid organ and hematopoietic cell transplant recipients

Replacement of failed organs followed by safe withdrawal of immunosuppressive drugs has long been the goal of organ transplantation. We studied changes in the balance of T cells and myeloid cells in the blood of HLA-matched and -mismatched patients given living donor kidney transplants followed by total lymphoid irradiation, anti-thymocyte globulin conditioning, and donor hematopoietic cell transplant to induce mixed chimerism and immune tolerance. The clinical trials were based on a conditioning regimen used to establish mixed chimerism and tolerance in mice. In preclinical murine studies, there was a profound depletion of T cells and an increase in immunosuppressive polymorphonuclear (pmn) myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSCs) in the spleen and blood following transplant. Selective depletion of pmn MDSCs in mice abrogated mixed chimerism and tolerance. In our clinical trials, patients given an analogous tolerance conditioning regimen developed similar changes, including profound depletion of T cells and a marked increase in MDSCs in blood posttransplant. Posttransplant pmn MDSCs transiently increased expression of lectin-type oxidized LDL receptor-1, a marker of immunosuppression, and production of the T-cell inhibitor arginase-1. These posttransplant pmn MDSCs suppressed the activation, proliferation, and inflammatory cytokine secretion of autologous T-cell receptor microbead-stimulated pretransplant T cells when cocultured in vitro. In conclusion, we elucidated changes in receptors and function of immunosuppressive myeloid cells in patients enrolled in the tolerance protocol that were nearly identical to those of MDSCs required for tolerance in mice. These trials were registered at www.clinicaltrials.gov as #NCT00319657 and #NCT01165762.

Combined kidney and hematopoeitic cell transplantation to induce mixed chimerism and tolerance

Based on preclinical studies, combined kidney and hematopoietic cell transplantation was performed on fully HLA matched and haplotype matched patients at the Stanford University Medical Center. The object of the studies was to induce mixed chimerism, immune tolerance, and complete immunosuppressive drug withdrawal. Tolerance, persistent mixed chimerism, and complete withdrawal was achieved in the majority of fully matched patients. Persistent mixed chimerism and partial withdrawal has been achieved in the haplotype matched patients at present.

Induction of Tolerance Towards Solid Organ Allografts Using Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation in Large Animal Models

Background

The application of hematopoietic cell transplantation for induction of immune tolerance has been limited by toxicities associated with conditioning regimens and to graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Decades of animal studies have culminated into sufficient control of these two problems, making immune tolerance a viable alternative to life-long application of immunosuppressive drugs to prevent allograft rejection.

Methods

Studies in mice have paved the way for the application of HCT with limited toxicity in large animal models. Resultant studies in the pig, dog, and ultimately the nonhuman primate have led to appropriate methods for achieving nonmyeloablative irradiation protocols, dose, and timing of post-grafting immunosuppressive drugs, monoclonal antibody therapy, and biologicals for costimulatory molecule blockade. The genetics field has been extensively evaluated in appreciation of the ultimate need to obtain organs from MHC-mismatched unrelated donors.

Results

Nonmyeloablative conditioning regimens have been shown to be successful in inducing immune tolerance across all three animal models. Postgrafting immunosuppression is also important in assuring sustained donor hematopoiesis for tolerance. Donor chimerism need not be permanent to establish stable engraftment of donor organs, thereby essentially eliminating the risk of GVHD. Using nonmyeloablative HCT with monoclonal antibody immunosuppression, the kidney has been successfully transplanted in MHC-mismatched nonhuman primates.

Conclusions

Nonmyeloablative HCT for the establishment of temporary mixed chimerism has led to the establishment of stable tolerance against solid organ allografts in large animal models. The kidney, considered a tolerogenic organ, has been successfully transplanted in the clinic. Other organs such as heart, lung, and vascularized composite allografts (face and hands), remain distant possibilities. Further study in large animal models will be required to improve tolerance against these organs before success can be attained in the clinic.

Galectin-9 in Combination With EX-527 Prolongs the Survival of Cardiac Allografts in Mice After Cardiac Transplantation

Galectin-9 (Gal-9), a member of the galectin family, has a variety of biologic activities. However, its role in allografts is not fully clarified yet. The relationship between interleukin-17 (IL-17) and Gal-9 and the role of Gal-9 in T(H)17-cell differentiation also remain unclear. We built a murine cardiac transplantation model, which we treated with Gal-9 and/or EX-527, a specific Sirtuin-1 inhibitor. Afterwards, flow-cytometric analysis and reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction were used to detect the number of T(H)17 cells and the expression of key factors involved in the differentiation of T(H)17 cells; in addition, the survival times of cardiac transplanted mice in different groups were recorded. The levels of circulating T(H)17 cells were found to increase in the peripheral blood of mice that exhibited acute rejection (AR) after heart transplantation, which was determined to be correlated with the rejection grade. Gal-9 or EX-527 can inhibit the activation and differentiation of T(H)17 cells and effectively suppress T(H)17-cell-mediated AR. These data provide new evidence for the potential regulatory effects of Gal-9 in alloimmune responses in a murine model of heart transplantation, and suggest the combined use of galectin-9 and EX-527 may be a powerful method to induce tolerance of fully mismatched murine cardiac allografts.

Stable mixed chimerism and tolerance to human organ transplants

Tolerance to combined kidney and hematopoietic cell transplant has been achieved in humans after establishment of mixed chimerism allowing for the withdrawal of immunosuppressive drugs. The seminal contributions of Ray Owen provided the scientific basis for the human protocol.

Use of hematopoietic cell transplants to achieve tolerance in patients with solid organ transplants

The goals of tolerance in patients with solid organ transplants are to eliminate the lifelong need for immunosuppressive (IS) drugs and to prevent graft loss due to rejection or drug toxicity. Tolerance with complete withdrawal of IS drugs has been achieved in recipients of HLA-matched and mismatched living donor kidney transplants in 3 medical centers using hematopoietic cell transplants to establish mixed or complete chimerism.

Translational studies in hematopoietic cell transplantation: treatment of hematologic malignancies as a stepping stone to tolerance induction

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) has most commonly been used to treat hematologic malignancies, where it is often the only potentially curative option available. The success of HCT has been limited by transplant-associated toxicities related to the conditioning regimens used and to the common immunologic consequence of donor T cell recognition of recipient alloantigens, graft-vs-host disease (GVHD). The frequency and severity of GVHD observed when extensive HLA barriers are transgressed has essentially precluded the routine use of extensively HLA-mismatched HCT. Allogeneic HCT also has potential as an approach to organ allograft tolerance induction, but this potential has not been previously realized because of the toxicity associated with traditional conditioning. In this paper we review two approaches to HCT involving reduced intensity conditioning regimens that have been associated with improvements in safety in patients with hematologic malignancies, even in the HLA-mismatched transplant setting. These strategies have been applied in the first successful pilot studies for the induction of organ allograft tolerance in humans. Thus, we summarize an example of vertical translational research between animal models and humans and horizontal translation between two separate goals that culminated in the use of HCT to achieve allograft tolerance in humans.

Differences in Bcl-2 expression by T-cell subsets alter their balance after in vivo irradiation to favor CD4+Bcl-2hi NKT cells

Although it is well known that in vivo radiation depletes immune cells via the Bcl-2 apoptotic pathway, a more nuanced analysis of the changes in the balance of immune-cell subsets is needed to understand the impact of radiation on immune function. We show the balance of T-cell subsets changes after increasing single doses of total body irradiation (TBI) or after fractionated irradiation of the lymphoid tissues (TLI) of mice due to differences in radioresistance and Bcl-2 expression of the NKT-cell and non-NKT subsets to favor CD4(+)Bcl-2(hi) NKT cells. Reduction of the Bcl-2(lo) mature T-cell subsets was at least 100-fold greater than that of the Bcl-2(hi) subsets. CD4(+) NKT cells upregulated Bcl-2 after TBI and TLI and developed a Th2 bias after TLI, whereas non-NKT cells failed to do so. Our previous studies showed TLI protects against graft versus host disease in wild-type, but not in NKT-cell-deficient mice. The present study shows that NKT cells have a protective function even after TBI, and these cells are tenfold more abundant after an equal dose of TLI. In conclusion, differential expression of Bcl-2 contributes to the changes in T-cell subsets and immune function after irradiation.

Clinical experience with mixed chimerism to induce transplantation tolerance

Lymphohematopoietic chimerism was first shown to be associated with donor-specific allograft tolerance more than 60 years ago. However, early clinical experience with bone marrow transplantation soon revealed that conventional, myeloablative approaches were far too toxic and the risk of graft-versus-host disease too great to justify using this technology for the purpose of organ allograft tolerance induction in the absence of malignant disease. In this review, we discuss a step-wise approach that has been applied by several centers to establish less toxic approaches to using hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) for tolerance induction. These steps include (i) feasibility and efficacy data for tolerance induction in large animal models; (ii) safety data in clinical trials for patients with hematologic malignancies; and (iii) pilot trials of combined HCT and kidney transplantation for tolerance induction. Thus far, only one published trial conducted at the Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston has achieved long-term acceptance of human leukocyte antigen-mismatched kidney allografts without chronic immunosuppressive therapy. Alternative protocols have been successful in large animals, but long-term organ allograft tolerance has not been reported in patients. Thus, proof-of-principle that nonmyeloablative induction of mixed chimerism can be used intentionally to induce organ allograft tolerance has now been achieved. Directions for further research to make this approach applicable for a broader patient population are discussed.

Induction immunosuppression

Induction immunosuppression is intense, prophylactic therapy used at the time of transplantation based on the empiric observation that more powerful immunosuppression is required to prevent acute rejection early. In the past decade, there has been a growing trend towards the use of specialized agents such as antibody therapies for induction. In general, these agents have been shown to reduce the rate of acute rejection. However, their use has not been clearly shown to improve long-term transplant outcomes. This overview will review the biological basis for induction immunosuppression and the mechanisms of action of those specialized induction agents currently in clinical use. Clinical trials investigating induction regimens will be evaluated, and an individualized approach to the use of induction immunosuppressants will be presented.

Approaches to transplantation tolerance in humans

Although transplantation tolerance to organ allografts has been achieved using a wide variety of immunologic interventions in laboratory animals, few tolerance induction protocols with complete immunosuppressive drug withdrawal have been tested in humans. Preclinical and clinical studies of the use of total lymphoid irradiation for the induction of chimeric and nonchimeric tolerance are summarized here.

Suppression of graft-versus-host disease by naturally occurring regulatory T cells

Studies of graft-versus-host disease after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation have shown that there are subsets of freshly isolated donor T cells that induce the disease and subsets that suppress the disease. The balance of subsets in the graft determines disease severity. The authors' work on the nature of the regulatory-suppressor T cells and their mechanisms of action is summarized in this article.

Heterologous immunity: an overlooked barrier to tolerance

In less than 50 years the field of organ transplantation has transitioned from an experimental concept to clinical commonplace. Notwithstanding the dramatic improvements in patient and allograft outcomes, chronic rejection and the complications from life-long immunosuppressive therapy remain significant problems. The induction of transplantation tolerance, indefinite allograft acceptance independent of chronic immunosuppressive therapy, remains the ultimate objective in transplantation. Many strategies have achieved tolerance to transplanted tissue in rodents; however, few, if any, have shown equal efficacy when tested in non-human primate transplant models or human patients. A critical distinction between specific pathogen-free mice and primates or human patients is the exposure of the latter to environmental pathogens and the resultant-acquired immune history. Recent data has shown that virally induced, alloreactive immune responses can provide a potent barrier to tolerance. In this review, we discuss one of the most robust methods for tolerance, the induction of hematopoietic chimerism as well as the influence of viral infections on the alloimmune response.

H2-mismatched transplantation with repetitive cell infusions and CD40 ligand antibody infusions without myeloablation

Graft rejection and graft-versus-host disease are major problems in mismatched marrow transplants along with toxicity from standard myeloablative host treatments. We have established a tolerization model, using 1 Gy irradiation, which reduces stem cell capacity to < 10% of control while causing minimal myelosuppression, donor antigen pre-exposure (spleen cells), CD40-ligand antibody blockade and high levels of marrow (40 x 106 cells), which allows for stable long-term multilineage engraftment in H2-mismatched murine marrow transplants. We now show that the establishment of 'microchimaerism' (0.5-3.8%) sets the stage for macrochimaerism, with subsequent marrow infusions in H2-mismatched mice with CD40-ligand blockade only. Neither irradiation nor spleen cell exposure were necessary. When 40 x 106 bone marrow cells were infused on weeks 0, 12, 14 and 16, blood engraftment was about seven times the single 40 x 106 control. When marrow cells were given on weeks 0, 3, 4, 5 and 6, engraftment at 24 weeks post transplant was 17.9 +/- 1.2%, compared with 2.7 +/- 0.8% for the single 40 x 106 control (P = 0.009). We have shown stable, long-term multilineage chimaerism and established that the schedule of marrow administration, not the total cell dose, is critical for tolerization. This approach indicates that microchimaerism can tolerize for subsequent marrow infusions and produce macrochimaerism. This strategy could be applied in clinical human transplants.

Tolerance, mixed chimerism and protection against graft-versus-host disease after total lymphoid irradiation

Total lymphoid irradiation (TLI), originally developed as a non-myeloablative treatment for Hodgkin's disease, has been adapted for the induction of immune tolerance to organ allografts in rodents, dogs and non-human primates. Moreover, pretransplantation TLI has been used in prospective studies to demonstrate the feasibility of the induction of tolerance to cadaveric kidney allografts in humans. Two types of tolerance, chimeric and non-chimeric, develop after TLI treatment of hosts depending on whether donor bone marrow cells are transplanted along with the organ allograft. An advantageous feature of TLI for combined marrow and organ transplantation is the protection against graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) and facilitation of chimerism afforded by the predominance of CD4+ NK1.1(+) -like T cells in the irradiated host lymphoid tissues. Recently, a completely post-transplantation TLI regimen has been developed resulting in stable mixed chimerism and tolerance that is enhanced by a brief course of cyclosporine. The post-transplantation protocol is suitable for clinical cadaveric kidney transplantation. This review summarizes the evolution of TLI protocols for eventual application to human clinical transplantation and discusses the mechanisms involved in the induction of mixed chimerism and protection from GVHD.

Clonal deletion and clonal anergy in allogeneic bone marrow chimeras prepared with TBI or TLI

The evolution of Vbeta6-expressing C3H (H2k, Thy 1.2, Mls a-) lymphocytes was investigated in C3H recipients mice pretreated with total body irradiation (TBI) or total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) and infusion of AKR (H2k, Thy 1.1, Mls a+) cells. After TBI (9.5 Gy) all Vbeta6+ Thy 1.2 (C3H) cells, which are capable of reacting against the Mls a antigen that like expressed by AKR mice, were deleted in the thymus and the periphery in stable bone marrow (BM) chimeras obtained by infusion of 5 x 10(6) T-cell-depleted (TCD) AKR BM cells. When, in the opposite combination, 30 x 10(6) C3H spleen cells were infused into TBI-treated AKR cells, all animals developed graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) with no clonal deletion and in contrast, showed an increase in Vbeta6+ C3H cells. After injection of 30 x 10(6) AKR BM cells into TLI-treated C3H mice no C3H cells were detected in the thymus and only a small percentage in the periphery. Within these C3H cells Vbeta6+ cells were only partially deleted and anergized as they did not respond in vitro after stimulation with Mls a+ AKR cells or anti-Vbeta6 mAb. Cells suppressing anti-Mls a-reacting C3H cells were not found. After injection of 15 x 10(6) AKR cells more C3H cells were found in the thymus, but only a minority of Vbeta6+ cells persisted in the periphery of these animals. In conclusion in TBI-prepared chimeras only clonal deletion occurred, whereas in TLI-prepared chimeras both clonal deletion and anergy occurred in maintaining tolerance.

Transforming growth factor-beta inhibits lymphokine activated killer cytotoxicity of bone marrow cells: implications for the graft-versus-leukemia effect in irradiation allogeneic bone marrow chimeras

BACKGROUND

We have previously shown that allogeneic bone marrow (BM) chimeras preconditioned with total lymphoid irradiation and low-dose total body irradiation (TLI/TBI) develop a stronger graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) effect than chimeras preconditioned with high-dose total body irradiation only (TBI). Here, we report on the possible role of cytokines in the mechanism underlying this GVL effect.

METHODS

Splenic mRNA levels of the cytokines interleukin (IL)-1, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-7, IL-10, IL-12, IL-15, interferon-gamma, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, and transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta), and of inducible nitric oxide synthetase were determined by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction in TLI/TBI- or TBI-conditioned C3H/AKR BM chimeras challenged with AKR-type BW5147.3 leukemia cells. Ex vivo TGF-beta protein production by splenocytes was determined using ELISA. The possibility that cytokines influence the GVL effect by modulating the activity of IL-2-activated lymphocytes (LAK cells) was investigated by in vitro assays on donor-type BM cells.

RESULTS

Of all cytokine mRNA levels studied, those of TGF-beta and IL-7 were different between groups; both were significantly more elevated in TBI- than in TLI/ TBI-conditioned or normal mice. Differences were apparent after conditioning and were not influenced by additionally injected BM or leukemia cells. Cultured splenocytes of TBI-conditioned animals produced significantly more TGF-beta protein than those of TLI/TBI-conditioned ones or normal controls. r-TGF-beta but not r-IL-7 suppressed in vitro LAK activity of donor-type BM cells against BW5147.3 cells in a dose-dependent way.

CONCLUSIONS

High-dose TBI-induced, host-derived splenic TGF-beta may inhibit generation of LAK cells from subsequently transplanted donor BM cells, suppressing their capacity to generate cytotoxicity upon injection of leukemia cells. The cytokine profile, induced by irradiation in host hematopoietic organs, can significantly modify posttransplant immunological processes such as the GVL effect and graft-versus-host disease (GVHD).

The molecular and cellular biologic basis for the radiation treatment of benign proliferative diseases

Since its discovery, radiation has been used to treat numerous ailments, including many benign conditions. The most susceptible disorders have included keloids, heterotopic bone formation, and, most recently, vascular restenosis. These disorders are proliferative in nature and fall under the category of excessive wound healing or scar formation after trauma. In addition, radiation has been used for its immunosuppressive quality, eg, in organ transplantation to suppress graft rejection and in the treatment of autoimmune diseases. In this article, we have chosen keloids as an archetype for radiation use with benign conditions; the radiation inhibition of vascular restenosis will be used as a prototype to explore a paradigm for the molecular and cellular basis of radiation treatment for selected benign disorders. Vascular restenosis is currently one of the new frontiers of radiation therapy and offers opportunities to explore the role of inflammatory or immune cell responses in benign conditions that lead to excessive fibrogenesis and require treatment. The pathophysiology of surgical wound healing has not been avidly studied in the radiobiologic laboratory setting. However, the paradigm we propose for the effectiveness of radiation treatment for benign conditions is based on the model offered by Clark. He describes three phases of molecular and cellular events in which an inflammatory phase precedes the fibrogenic phase, occurs within hours of injury, and continues for weeks. We postulate that the radiosensitive targets within the vascular milieu are the monocyte/macrophages that would otherwise act as the trigger for the induced cytokine cascade, leading to the myofibroblast being recruited from a quiescent to a proliferative phase, resulting in fibrogenesis.

Donor blood monocytes but not T or B cells facilitate long-term allograft survival after total lymphoid irradiation

BACKGROUND

Previous studies showed that a combination of posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation (TLI), rabbit antithymocyte globulin (ATG), and a single donor blood transfusion induced tolerance to ACI heart allografts in Lewis rats. All three modalities were required to achieve tolerance. The objective of the current study was to determine the subset(s) of cells in the donor blood that facilitated long-term allograft survival.

METHODS

Lewis hosts received TLI, ATG, and donor cell infusion after heart transplantation. Graft survival, mixed leukocyte reaction (MLR), and intragraft cytokine mRNA were studied.

RESULTS

The intravenous injection of 25 x 10(6) ACI peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) significantly prolonged graft survival as compared with that of Lewis hosts given TLI and ATG alone. Injection of highly enriched blood T cells or splenic B cells adjusted for the number contained in 25 x 10(6) PBMC failed to induce significant graft prolongation. Unexpectedly, depletion of monocytes (CD11b+ cells) from PBMC resulted in the loss of graft prolongation activity. Enriched populations of monocytes obtained by plastic adherence were more efficient in prolonging graft survival than PBMC on a per cell basis. Hosts with long-term grafts (>100-day survival) showed evidence of immune deviation, because the MLR to ACI stimulator cells was vigorous, but secretion of interferon-gamma in the MLR was markedly reduced. In situ hybridization studies of long-term grafts showed markedly reduced levels of interferon-gamma mRNA as compared with rejecting grafts.

CONCLUSION

Infusion of donor monocytes facilitated graft prolongation via immune deviation.

The effect of total lymphoid irradiation and low-dose steroids on T lymphocyte populations in multiple sclerosis: correlation with clinical and MRI status

We have monitored the cell surface phenotypic changes occurring in T, B and NK cells of chronic progressive multiple sclerosis (MS) patients after total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) plus low-dose prednisone (TLI-LDP) therapy in comparison to sham TLI-LDP. TLI-LDP resulted in a marked reduction in the relative and absolute number of total CD3+ T cells, CD4+ helper T cells, CD4+ CD45RA+ naive T cells and CD19+ B cells for at least 1 year after treatment. No change occurred in the percent CD8+ T cells although the number of these cells declined after radiotherapy. The CD4/CD8 T cell ratio was also decreased. The relative percent of CD16+ NK cells increased steadily after TLI-LDP while the number of NK cells transiently declined but returned to baseline values 1 year later. An increase in the percent of CD2+ CD3- cells and a decrease in their number after therapy was also observed. In contrast, no significant changes in the number of T, B or NK cells were seen in the MS patients receiving sham TLI-LDP. These results provide further evidence that radiotherapy causes a reduction of immunocompetent T and B cells and that a population of possibly NK cells and/or immature T cells appears to be repopulating the circulation after TLI. In addition, a correlation was observed between alterations in lymphocyte populations and the presence or absence of contrast enhancing or new T2 lesions on brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the TLI-LDP treated MS patients. Patients devoid of contrast enhancing or new T2 lesions had a decreased percentage of CD3+ and CD4+ T cells prior to therapy and at six months following TLI-LDP compared to patients with such lesions. An association was also observed between stability in disease activity as determined on the Expanded Disability Status Scale and relative values of CD3 T cells.

Acquired transplant tolerance

Increasing the acceptance rate of organs is the central goal of transplantation research. Long-term survival of vascularized organs without chronic immunosuppressive therapy has been achieved in experimental animals. In humans, the possibility of achieving immunological tolerance and a drug-free state has been reported occasionally in patients who after withdrawal of immunosuppressants because of major toxicity still carry a functioning graft. It has been proposed that organ transplant implies a migratory flux of donor 'passenger' leukocytes out of the graft into the recipient tissue or organs, to establish a persistent condition of 'microchimerism'. Although there is evidence that the same migratory mechanisms apply to all organ grafts, migration of 'passenger' leukocytes is less in kidney and heart than in liver. To enhance the acceptance of organs less tolerogenic than liver, perioperative infusion of donor bone marrow has been attempted to increase the donor 'passenger' leukocyte load. It has been suggested that the established microchimerism is not only associated with long-term acceptance of the graft, but it also plays an active role in induction and maintenance of donor-specific unresponsiveness. However, the intimate mechanism(s) responsible for prolonged graft survival in this setting remain speculative. Experimental evidence is also available that the thymus plays a major role in the development of self-tolerance and is critical in the induction of acquired tolerance to exogenous antigens. It has been reported that after intrathymic injection of donor cells clonal deletion of maturing thymocytes occurs and is the major mechanism in the induction of donor-specific tolerance, since peripheral T-cell component would be devoid of alloreactive population. Studies are warranted in the near future to explore whether the thymus technique can be employed to prolong survival or induce tolerance to allograft in humans. An interesting novel strategy for transplant tolerance is also the oral administration of alloantigens, which has been recently applied to the cardiac transplant model in rat. All these approaches will have a major impact in the near future on transplant medicine, opening new perspectives to obtain indefinite graft survival.

Will killing the last HIV1 particle cure AIDS patients? Doesn't CMV activation and/or a graft-versus-host component of the disease, also have to be considered? I. First of two parts

Before the discovery of HIV1 and HIV2, I proposed as the mechanism of HIV1-AIDS complex, a graft versus host reaction (GvH) induced by transfusion or seringe or sexual act blood transferred lymphocytes: this was based on the clinical, pathological and biological, and especially immunological similarities. I have treated ten HIV1-AIDS complex patients in the last phase with five virostatics, distributed in three week sequence combinations of 3 or 4, each differing from the preceeding and following ones. After follow-up between one and three and a half years, the results can be summarized as such: when the viral loads fall below the detectable level, the CD8+ CD57+ suppressor T-cell and CD8+ CD57- cytotoxic T-cell numbers tend towards normal levels (approximately 200/mL), but the CD4 counts go up to a maximum of only 394, far from the normal level (800). Moreover, none of these subsets present a significant coefficient of correlation with the HIV1 load, which indicates that these immunologic markers and the viral one provide different information. I suggest the hypothesis according to which HIV1-AIDS complex comprises other components than HIV1 infection, such as a) the evoked GvH, which would occur early enough and might explain this CD4 incomplete restoration by virostatics, and b) cytomegalovirus (CMV) activation which occurs later. The second part of this editorial review will be published in a part II of the "Dossier" on AIDS. It will be devoted to the discussion of GvH and CMV infection systematic treatments.

Total lymphoid irradiation: a novel and successful therapy for resistant cardiac allograft rejection

Total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) is a novel type of adjuvant immunosuppression for patients who undergo cardiac transplantation and have refractory allograft rejection during standard immunosuppressive therapy. TLI consists of 6 to 10 fractions of 80 cGy (1 cGy = 1 rad) of irradiation to lymphatic tissues with use of the standard mantle and inverted Y fields. We have used TLI in six patients with biopsy-proven rejection that was refractory to standard treatments, including cyclosporine, azathioprine, antilymphocyte antibodies, and corticosteroids. In five patients, recalcitrant rejection was resolved after completion of TLI, and resolution persisted during long-term follow-up (17 to 30 months; mean, 22.2 months). In each patient, a substantial increase in the CD8 (suppressor T-lymphocyte) subset and elimination of B lymphocytes were demonstrated, findings that also persisted. Side effects were mild and primarily limited to transient leukopenia. In four patients, a readily treated cytomegalovirus reactivation was noted during TLI; thus, a causal relationship was suggested. In recipients of cardiac allografts who have refractory rejection, TLI provides long-lasting amelioration of the rejection profile. This result may be attributable to a relative enhancement of the suppressor T-cell subset and elimination of the B-lymphocyte line. Side effects are minimal, but monitoring for cytomegalovirus activation or reactivation is recommended.

Causes and mechanism of autoimmune disease: cyclosporin A as a probe for the investigation

Organ-specific autoimmune disease can be elicited in rodents by manipulating the thymus/T cells. For example, elimination of a particular T-cell subset causes organ-specific autoimmune diseases, such as thyroiditis and gastritis, in otherwise normal mice. Environmental agents can cause similar autoimmune diseases by affecting the thymus/T cells. Cyclosporin A (CsA), a potent immunosuppressive drug, is an example. When a particular strain of newborn mice are daily administered with CsA for a limited period, they spontaneously develop organ-specific autoimmune disease, such as gastritis with anti-parietal cell autoantibodies, later in life. CsA abrogates the production of CD4+T cells and CD8+T cells in the thymus. Consequently, these T cells are substantially depleted from the peripheral lymphoid organs, especially when the drug is administered from the day of birth. The autoimmune disease is prevented when CsA-treated newborn mice are inoculated with splenic T cells from normal syngeneic adult mice. On the other hand, removal of the thymus immediately after neonatal CsA treatment produces autoimmune disease with a higher incidence and in a wider spectrum of organs, i.e., thyroiditis, sialoadenitis of the salivary gland, gastritis, insulitis of the endocrine pancreas, adrenalitis, oophoritis, or orchitis. Each autoimmune disease is accompanied by the development of circulating autoantibodies specific for the corresponding organ-specific antigens. These findings taken together indicate that CsA causes autoimmune disease not by affecting the target self-antigens, but by interfering with a thymus/T cell-dependent control mechanism on the production/expansion of pathogenic self-reactive T cells. Various other environmental insults (such as ionizing radiation or virus) can also cause similar autoimmune diseases, presumably by a similar mechanism.

Thymic irradiation inhibits the rapid recovery of TH1 but not TH2-like functions of CD4+ T cells after total lymphoid irradiation

Four to six weeks after total lymphoid irradiation (TLI), there is a selective deficit in the CD4+ T cells which secrete IL-2, proliferate in the MLR, and induce GVHD (Th1-like functions). A similar deficit in CD4+ T cells which secrete IL-4 and help antibody responses (Th2-like functions) is not observed. In the present study, shielding of the thymus with lead during TLI increased the Th1-like functions of CD4+ cells. Mice without thymus shields showed a marked selective reduction in the medullary stromal cells identified with the monoclonal antibody, MD1, and the severe reduction was prevented with thymus shields. Thus, shielding the thymus prevents the depletion of thymic medullary stromal cells and allows for a rapid recovery of Th1-like functions in the mouse spleen after TLI. Th2-like functions recover rapidly after TLI whether or not the thymus is irradiated.

Mechanisms of immune injury in rheumatoid arthritis: evidence for the involvement of T cells and heat-shock protein

Evidence for the involvement of T cells, especially CD4+ T cells, in the pathogenesis of RA is substantial and includes 1) the correlation between prolonged CD4+ T-cell depletion and improvement in joint disease in the absence of observable changes in the levels of autoantibodies (rheumatoid factors) in the blood and joints, 2) the infiltration of the inflamed synovial tissues with T cells and, 3) the increased susceptibility of individuals to RA with certain HLA-DR haplotypes. The most direct evidence for the involvement of CD4+ T cells is provided by recent studies which demonstrate rapid improvement in the joint disease manifestations of RA following the infusion of anti-CD4 monoclonal antibodies (Herzog et al. 1989, Walker et al. 1989). It is unlikely that T cells alone are responsible for the joint injury in RA. Autoantibodies (rheumatoid factors) in the joint which contribute to the release of complement breakdown products, and to the secretion of cytokines such as IL-1 by macrophages must also play an important role. Indeed, depletion of CD4+ cells after TLI or therapy with monoclonal antibody reduces, but does not eliminate, joint disease activity. The residual joint disease activity is probably influenced by the continued contribution of autoantibodies to joint injury. Production of these autoantibodies may not be dependent on help from CD4+ cells, since little change is observed in autoantibody levels after CD4+ cell depletion. The mechanisms by which T cells mediate to the joint disease in RA are not clear. Little or no direct evidence of cytotoxic effects of T cells on autologous joint cells has been reported. Considerable evidence suggests that at least some T-cell cytokines (i.e., TNF alpha, IL-6) can contribute to the proliferation of synovial lining cells which results in the marked build-up of inflammatory tissue (pannus) in the joints of patients with RA (Firestein et al. 1990). In addition, T cells may recruit other joint cells, such as macrophages, to secrete cytokines (i.e., IL-1) which both contribute to synovial cell proliferation, and cartilage and bone degeneration. The marked reduction in the spontaneous secretion of IL-1 by synovial biopsies, and improvement in disease activity after TLI support this notion. Interestingly, the CD4+ T-cell lymphokines, IL-2 and IFN-gamma, were not spontaneously secreted in detectable quantities by synovial biopsies. This suggests that the pattern of lymphokines secreted by T cells in the joint in RA are not typical of that in delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The use of parabiosis for investigating the mechanism of transplantation tolerance in bone marrow chimeras induced by total lymphoid irradiation

The mechanism of transplantation tolerance in total lymphoid irradiation (TLI)-induced semiallogeneic bone marrow chimeras without clinical evidence of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) was investigated using the technique of surgical parabiosis. When held in parabiosis with normal BALB/c mice, BALB/c---- (BALB/c x C57BL/6)F1 (BALB----F1) chimeras survived 7-9 days, significantly (P less than 0.001) shorter than the 12-19 day survival of normal F1 hybrids kept in parabiosis with normal BALB, and in contrast to indefinite (greater than 200 days) survival of syngeneic BALB parabiotic partners. When C57 skin grafts were placed on BALB mice held in parabiosis with BALB----F1 chimeras, C57 skin grafts survived 50-60 days, in contrast to 10-14 days in normal BALB recipients (P less than 0.001). Lethal GVHD, induced in sublethally irradiated F1 recipients by 10(7) BALB spleen cells, could not be delayed or prevented by cotransfer of 10(7) to 30 x 10(7) tolerant BALB spleen cells obtained from stable BALB----F1 chimeras. GVHD reactivity of BALB spleen cells isolated from BALB----F1 chimeras tolerant of C57 could not be recovered by depletion of Lyt2 cytotoxic suppressor cells. Taken together, in the absence of suppressive capacity by suppressor cells, these data support functional clonal deletion as the primary mechanism responsible for the maintenance of unresponsiveness to host alloantigens in TLI-induced semiallogeneic chimeras, since no protection against induction of GVHD could be documented in vivo.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Induction of non-specific suppressor cells in normal Lewis rats by a novel azaspirane SK&F 105685

SK&F 105685 (N,N-Dimethyl-8,8-dipropyl-2-azaspiro[4,5]decane-2- propanamine dihydrochloride) is a novel azaspirane which has therapeutic activity in rat models of autoimmune disease. In this study, we have demonstrated that SK&F 105685 is a potent inducer of non-specific suppressor cells (SC). Oral administration of 15-30 mg/kg/day results in the generation of SC in the spleen, lymph nodes and bone marrow, but not the thymus of Lewis rats. Splenic SC suppress Con-A-induced proliferation in co-culture assays at effector-responder ratios of 1:1 to 1:64. SC are radiation resistant (2000 R), non-T, non-B cells, partially adherent to plastic surfaces and are enriched in a 1.07 g/ml fraction of a Percoll density gradient. Their activity is increased, rather than ablated, by indomethacin. No definitive changes in Ig+, OX-19+, OX-8+, W3/25+ or asialo GM1+ cells could be detected in the spleens of treated rats compared to control untreated animals. Elevated levels of both radiation-sensitive and radiation-resistant suppressor cells were found in the bone marrow of treated rats in addition to the radiosensitive SC normally present in this tissue.

Deficits in T helper cells after total lymphoid irradiation (TLI): reduced IL-2 secretion and normal IL-2 receptor expression in the mixed leukocyte reaction (MLR)

Spleen cells from BALB/c mice treated with total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) and from normal, unirradiated mice were compared in the mixed leukocyte reaction (MLR). Although the percentage of CD4+ cells in the spleen was close to normal, 4 to 6 weeks after TLI, the MLR of unfractionated spleen cells from irradiated mice was more than 10-fold lower than controls. A similar reduction was observed when purified CD4+ cells were used as responders in the MLR. Secretion of IL-2 by cells from irradiated mice was also about 10-fold lower than controls. However, the percentage of CD4+ and CD8+ cells which expressed IL-2 surface receptors during the MLR was similar using spleen cells from irradiated and control mice. Addition of an exogenous source of IL-2 restored the proliferative capacity of the irradiated cells and suggests that the lack of IL-2 secretion is the likely explanation of the marked deficit in the MLR of CD4+ spleen cells after TLI.

Evidence for mouse Th1- and Th2-like helper T cells in vivo. Selective reduction of Th1-like cells after total lymphoid irradiation

Purified CD4+ BALB/c spleen T cells obtained 4-6 wk after total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) helped normal syngeneic B cells to produce a vigorous antibody response to TNP keyhole limpet hemocyanin in adoptive cell transfer experiments. However, the same cells failed to transfer delayed-type hypersensitivity to the adoptive hosts as measured by a foot pad swelling assay. In addition, purified CD4+ cells from TLI-treated mice were unable to induce graft vs. host disease in lethally irradiated allogeneic C57BL/Ka recipient mice. In response to mitogen stimulation, unfractionated spleen cells obtained from TLI mice secreted normal levels of IL-4 and IL-5, but markedly reduced levels of IL-2 and INF-gamma. A total of 229 CD4+ clones from spleen cells of both normal and TLI-treated mice were established, and the cytokine secretion pattern from each clone was analyzed. The results demonstrate that the ratio of Th1- and Th2-like clones in the spleens of normal BALB/c mice is 1:0.6, whereas the ratio in TLI mice is approximately 1:7. These results suggest that Th2-like cells recover rapidly (at approximately 4-6 wk) after TLI treatment and account for the early return of antibody helper activity and secretion of IL-4 and IL-5, but Th1-like cells recover more slowly (in approximately 3 mo) after irradiation, and this accounts for the deficit in cell-mediated immunity and the reduced amount of IL-2 and IFN-gamma secretion.

Inhibition of animal models of autoimmune disease and the induction of non-specific suppressor cells by SK&F 105685 and related azaspiranes

SK&F 105685 (N,N-dimethyl-8,8-dipropyl-2-azaspiro[4.5]decane-2-propanamine+ ++ dihydrochloride), administered orally to adjuvant arthritic (AA) rats inhibited immune-mediated hindpaw inflammation with an ED50 of 20 mg/kg/day. Both prophylactic and therapeutic administration were effective in this model. In addition, SK&F 105685 inhibited skin wheal responses to purified protein derivative (PPD) of tuberculin in AA rats and the development of hindleg paralysis associated with experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE). Spleens of normal rats treated with SK&F 105685 were found to contain a population(s) of suppressor cells (SC) which inhibited the response of normal cells to Concanavalin A (Con A) in co-culture assays. The association between SC induction and anti-arthritic activity was determined by evaluating a series of chemically related azaspiranes in the AA rat model and for SC induction in normal rats. A statistically significant correlation was demonstrated (r = 0.79, P less than 0.001), indicating that SC induction may be responsible for the therapeutic activity of these compounds.

Treatment of murine lupus nephritis with cyclophosphamide or total lymphoid irradiation

Untreated 9 to 11 month-old, female NZB/W F1 mice all died within six weeks (wks) after the occurrence of nephrotic range proteinuria (greater than or equal to 3 g/liter). Significant prolonged survival could be obtained in similar groups of animals either by weekly i.v. pulses of cyclophosphamide (CY, 25 mg/kg, 40% survival 20 wks after start of treatment) or by administering total lymphoid irradiation (TLI, 17 daily fractions of 2 Gy, 70% survival at 20 wks). All surviving animals in both groups showed remission of the nephrotic range proteinuria. In all treated mice, light microscopy examination of the kidneys revealed a decrease of inflammation and a stabilization of proliferation and sclerosis, yet immunofluorescence for IgM, IgG and C3 was not significantly altered. The better survival of the TLI- as compared to the CY-treated mice (P less than 0.001) was due to a lower incidence of lymphomas or viral infections. IgG anti-DNA auto-antibodies were significantly lowered by CY but not by TLI treatment. It is concluded that CY pulse therapy and TLI are both efficient treatment modalities for high grade lupus like NZB/W disease. In this model TLI is safer than CY when used in a dose regimen of 25 mg/kg/wk and interferes with the course of the disease without lowering the IgG anti-DNA antibodies.

Renal cadaveric transplantation in diabetics using total lymphoid irradiation or cyclosporin A. A controlled randomized study. Leuven Collaborative Transplantation Group

A total of 20 renal transplant patients with end-stage diabetic nephropathy entered a randomized controlled trial comparing preoperative, fractionated total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) (radiation dose, 20-30 Gy) with postoperative cyclosporin A (CsA). Both groups received postoperative low-dose methylprednisolone maintenance therapy. The 3-year patient and graft survival was similar for both groups (100% and 71% in the TLI and 75% and 75% in the CsA group, respectively). Rejection crises occurred significantly more frequently (P less than 0.01) in the TLI-treated recipients. The incidence of infectious or diabetic complications was not significantly different in both groups. It is concluded that TLI and CsA are both effective treatment modalities for cadaveric renal transplantation in diabetics; CsA, however, is superior in preventing rejection crises.