The rapid elimination of allogeneic lymphocytes: relationship to established mechanisms of immunity and to lymphocyte traffic

Visualizing the Rapid and Dynamic Elimination of Allogeneic T Cells in Secondary Lymphoid Organs

Allogeneic organ transplants are rejected by the recipient immune system within several days or weeks. However, the rejection process of allogeneic T (allo-T) cells is poorly understood. In this study, using fluorescence-based monitoring and two-photon live imaging in mouse adoptive transfer system, we visualized the fate of allo-T cells in the in vivo environment and showed rapid elimination in secondary lymphoid organs (SLOs). Although i.v. transferred allo-T cells efficiently entered host SLOs, including lymph nodes and the spleen, ∼70% of the cells had disappeared within 24 h. At early time points, allo-T cells robustly migrated in the T cell area, whereas after 8 h, the numbers of arrested cells and cell fragments were dramatically elevated. Apoptotic breakdown of allo-T cells released a large amount of cell debris, which was efficiently phagocytosed and cleared by CD8⁺ dendritic cells. Rapid elimination of allo-T cells was also observed in nu/nu recipients. Depletion of NK cells abrogated allo-T cell reduction only in a specific combination of donor and recipient genetic backgrounds. In addition, F₁ hybrid transfer experiments showed that allo-T cell killing was independent of the missing-self signature typically recognized by NK cells. These suggest the presence of a unique and previously uncharacterized modality of allorecognition by the host immune system. Taken together, our findings reveal an extremely efficient and dynamic process of allogeneic lymphocyte elimination in SLOs, which could not be recapitulated in vitro and is distinct from the rejection of solid organ and bone marrow transplants.

Identification of MHC Class Ib Ligands for Stimulatory and Inhibitory Ly49 Receptors and Induction of Potent NK Cell Alloresponses in Rats

Early studies indicate that rats may have a repertoire of MHC class Ib-reactive Ly49 stimulatory receptors capable of mounting memory-like NK cell alloresponses. In this article, we provide molecular and functional evidence for this assumption. Pairs of Ly49 receptors with sequence similarities in the lectin-like domains, but with opposing signaling functions, showed specificity for ligands with class Ia-like structural features encoded from the first telomeric MHC class Ib gene cluster, RT1-CE, which is syntenic with the H2-D/H2-L/H2-Q cluster in mice. The activating Ly49s4 receptor and its inhibitory counterparts, Ly49i4 and Ly49i3, reacted with all allelic variants of RT1-U, whereas Ly49s5 and Ly49i5 were specific for RT1-E^u NK cell cytolytic responses were predictably activated and inhibited, and potent in vivo NK alloresponses were induced by repeated MHC class Ib alloimmunizations. Additional Ly49-class Ib interactions, including RT1-C^l with the Ly49s4/Ly49i4/Ly49i3 group of receptors, were characterized using overexpressed receptor/ligand pairs, in vitro functional assays, and limited mutational analyses. Obvious, as well as subtle, Ly49-class Ib interactions led to ligand-induced receptor calibration and NK subset expansions in vivo. Together, these studies suggest that in vivo NK alloresponses are controlled by pleomorphic Ly49-class Ib interactions, some of which may not be easily detectable in vitro.

The Role of Animal Models in the Study of Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation and GvHD: A Historical Overview

Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) is the only therapeutic option for many hematological malignancies, but its applicability is limited by life-threatening complications, such as graft-versus-host disease (GvHD). The last decades have seen great advances in the understanding of BMT and its related complications; in particular GvHD. Animal models are beneficial to study complex diseases, as they allow dissecting the contribution of single components in the development of the disease. Most of the current knowledge on the therapeutic mechanisms of BMT derives from studies in animal models. Parallel to BMT, the understanding of the pathophysiology of GvHD, as well as the development of new treatment regimens, has also been supported by studies in animal models. Pre-clinical experimentation is the basis for deep understanding and successful improvements of clinical applications. In this review, we retrace the history of BMT and GvHD by describing how the studies in animal models have paved the way to the many advances in the field. We also describe how animal models contributed to the understanding of GvHD pathophysiology and how they are fundamental for the discovery of new treatments.

The early days of NK cells: an example of how a phenomenon led to detection of a novel immune receptor system - lessons from a rat model

In this review, I summarize some of the early research on NK cell biology and function that led to the discovery of a totally new receptor system for polymorphic MHC class I molecules. That NK cells both could recognize and kill tumor cells but also normal hematopoietic cells through expression of MHC class I molecules found a unifying explanation in the “missing self” hypothesis. This initiated a whole new area of leukocyte receptor research. The common underlying mechanism was that NK cells expressed receptors that were inhibited by recognition of unmodified “self” MHC-I molecules. This could explain both the killing of tumor cells with poor expression of MHC-I molecules and hybrid resistance, i.e., that F1 hybrid mice sometimes could reject parental bone marrow cells. However, a contrasting phenomenon termed allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity in rats gave strong evidence that some of these receptors were activated rather than inhibited by recognition of polymorphic MHC-I. This was soon followed by molecular identification of both inhibitory and stimulatory Ly49 receptors in mice and rats and killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptors in humans that could be either inhibited or activated when recognizing their cognate MHC-I ligand. Since most of these receptors now have been molecularly characterized, their ligands and the intracellular pathways leading to activation or inhibition identified, we still lack a more complete understanding of how the repertoire of activating and inhibitory receptors is formed and how interactions between these receptors for MHC-I molecules on a single NK cell are integrated to generate a productive immune response. Although several NK receptor systems have been characterized that recognize MHC-I or MHC-like molecules, I here concentrate on the repertoires of NK receptors encoded by the natural killer cell gene complex and designed to recognize polymorphic MHC-I molecules in rodents, i.e., Ly49 (KLRA) receptors.

Partial NK cell tolerance induced by radioresistant host cells in rats transplanted with MHC-mismatched bone marrow

We have studied the effect of radioresistant host cells in inducing tolerance and adaptation of the MHC recognition repertoire of donor-derived NK cells in stem cell allotransplanted (allo-SCT) rats. Sub-lethally irradiated PVG.1AV1 rats (RT1(av1)) were transplanted with bone marrow from fully MHC-mismatched allotype-marked PVG.7B (RT1(c)) rats; MHC-identical PVG (RT1(c)) controls were transplanted in parallel. In the PVG.7B → PVG.1AV1 allogeneic chimeras, NK cells were donor derived and showed partial tolerance toward host cells. Allogeneic chimeras failed to efficiently reject PVG.1AV1 cells by an NK-mediated mechanism in vivo (allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity), and IL-2-cultured NK cells derived from these chimeras showed diminished cytolytic activity against PVG.1AV1 cells in vitro. There were corresponding changes in the phenotype and function of the highly alloreactive Ly49i2(+) NK cells, which are specifically inhibited by a donor MHC class I ligand, RT1-A1(c). The ligand-negative host MHC haplotype apparently induced expression of a second uncharacterized inhibitory MHC receptor responsible for the partial tolerance toward host-derived cells, along with a modest increase in Ly49i2 receptor levels. The host MHC haplotype did not induce a general hyporesponsiveness in Ly49i2(+) NK cells, which showed normal activation responses in a panel of MHC congenic strains. The data suggest that the MHC constitution of radiation-resistant host cells can have permanent, albeit not fully tolerogenic, effects on the development of a functional NK repertoire following allo-SCT.

The activating rat Ly49s5 receptor responds to increased levels of MHC class Ib molecules on Listeria monocytogenes-infected enteric epithelial cells

We have investigated whether rat Ly49 receptors can monitor Listeria-infected intestinal epithelial cells through altered expression of MHC class I molecules. The rat colon carcinoma epithelial cell line CC531 infected with Listeria expressed higher levels of both classical and nonclassical MHC-I molecules. Reporter cells expressing the activating Ly49s5 receptor displayed increased stimulatory responses when incubated with Listeria-infected CC531 cells in vitro, which could be blocked with mAb 8G10 specific for nonclassical MHC-I molecules of the RT1(u) haplotype, but not with mAb OX18 reacting with classical MHC-I molecules in this haplotype. Similar responses were observed against IFN-γ-treated cells that also upregulated their expression of MHC-I molecules. Thus, the Ly49s5 receptor can respond to increased levels of nonclassical MHC-I molecules induced on target cells by either bacterial infection or cytokine stimulation. We furthermore found that splenic NK and NKT cells produced IFN-γ in response to Listeria-infected CC531 cells, and that this was not limited to Ly49-expressing cells, since similar levels of IFN-γ production were observed in Ly49(+) and Ly49(-) NK cell subsets. Therefore, NK cells may recognize Listeria-infected cells through both MHC-I-dependent and -independent innate immune receptor systems.

Strain-dependent expression of four structurally related rat Ly49 receptors; correlation with NK gene complex haplotype and NK alloreactivity

Natural killer (NK) cells from certain rat strains promptly kill MHC allogeneic lymphocytes in vivo, a rejection phenomenon termed allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity (ALC). ALC can be reproduced in vitro, and is preferentially mediated by a subset of NK cells expressing the Ly49 stimulatory receptor 3 (Ly49s3) in PVG strain rats. Functional studies have suggested that Ly49s3 triggers NK cell alloreactivity, but its importance relative to other Ly49 receptors has not been investigated. In this study, we have characterized three rat Ly49 receptors with close sequence similarity to Ly49s3 in the extracellular region, i.e., Ly49s4, Ly49 inhibitory receptor 3 (Ly49i3), and Ly49i4. Similar to Ly49s3, Ly49s4 mediated cellular activation while Ly49i4 inhibited NK cytolytic function. Ly49s4, -i3, and -i4 all reacted with a previously described anti-Ly49s3 monoclonal antibody (mAb) (DAR13), but not a novel mAb (STOK6), which was shown to be specific for Ly49s3. Expression of these Ly49 receptors varied markedly between inbred strains, in patterns related to their NK gene complex (NKC) haplotype, and ability to mediate ALC. Three major groups of NKC haplotypes could be discerned by restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis. Ly49s3 was present in strains from one of the groups, which corresponded with the "high" ALC responders. Ly49s3 surface expression was also markedly reduced in the presence of its putative MHC class Ib ligand(s) in MHC congenic strains. These data support the notion that Ly49s3 functions as a triggering MHC receptor both in vitro and in vivo. MHC ligands for the other three Ly49 receptors remain to be determined.

Two structurally related rat Ly49 receptors with opposing functions (Ly49 stimulatory receptor 5 and Ly49 inhibitory receptor 5) recognize nonclassical MHC class Ib-encoded target ligands

The Ly49 family of lectin-like receptors in rodents includes both stimulatory and inhibitory members. Although NK alloreactivity in mice is regulated primarily by inhibitory Ly49 receptors, in rats activating Ly49 receptors are equally important. Previous studies have suggested that activating rat Ly49 receptors are triggered by polymorphic ligands encoded within the nonclassical class Ib region of the rat MHC, RT1-CE/N/M, while inhibitory Ly49 receptors bind to widely expressed classical class Ia molecules encoded from the RT1-A region. To further investigate rat Ly49-mediated regulation of NK alloreactivity, we report in this study the identification and characterization of two novel paired Ly49 receptors that we have termed Ly49 inhibitory receptor 5 (Ly49i5) and Ly49 stimulatory receptor 5 (Ly49s5). Using a new mAb (mAb Fly5), we showed that Ly49i5 is an inhibitory receptor that recognizes ligands encoded within the class Ib region of the u and l haplotypes, while the structurally related Ly49s5 is an activating receptor that recognizes class Ib ligands of the u haplotype. Ly49s5 is functionally expressed in the high NK-alloresponder PVG strain, but not in the low alloresponder BN strain, in which it is a pseudogene. Ly49s5 is hence not responsible for the striking anti-u NK alloresponse previously described in BN rats (haplotype n), which results from repeated alloimmunizations with u haplotype cells. The present studies support the notion of a complex regulation of rat NK alloreactivity by activating and inhibitory Ly49 members, which may be highly homologous in the extracellular region and bind similar class Ib-encoded target ligands.

The genes and gene organization of the Ly49 region of the rat natural killer cell gene complex

We here report the cDNA sequences of 11 new rat Ly49 genes with full and three with incomplete open reading frames. Although obtained from different inbred rat strains, these as well as six previously published cDNA represent non-allelic genes matching different loci in the Brown Norway (BN) rat genome, which is predicted to contain 34 Ly49 loci distributed over the distal part of the NK cell gene complex. Some of the cloned genes appear to be mutated to non-function in the BN genome, which harbors additional genes with full open reading frames, suggesting at least 26 non-allelic functional Ly49 genes in the rat. Of the encoded receptors, 13 are predicted to be inhibitory, eight to be activating, whereas five may be both ('bifunctional'). Phylogenetic analysis bears evidence of a highly dynamic genetic region, in which only the most distally localized Ly49 gene has a clear-cut mouse ortholog. In phylograms, the majority of the genes cluster into three subgroups with the genes mapping together, defining three chromosomal regions that seem to have undergone recent expansions. When comparing the lectin-like domains, the receptors form smaller subgroups, most containing at least one inhibitory and one activating or 'bifunctional' receptor, where close sequence similarities suggest recent homogenization events.

Ly-49s3 is a promiscuous activating rat NK cell receptor for nonclassical MHC class I-encoded target ligands

Previous studies of the rapid rejection of MHC-disparate lymphocytes in rats, named allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity, have indicated that rat NK cells express activating receptors for nonclassical MHC class I allodeterminants from the RT1-C/E/M region. Using an expression cloning system that identifies activating receptors associated with the transmembrane adapter molecule DAP12, we have cloned a novel rat Ly-49 receptor that we have termed Ly-49 stimulatory receptor 3 (Ly-49s3). A newly generated anti-Ly-49s3 Ab, mAb DAR13, identified subpopulations of resting and IL-2-activated NK cells, but not T or B lymphocytes. Depletion of Ly-49s3-expressing NK cells drastically reduced alloreactivity in vitro, indicating that this subpopulation is responsible for a major part of the observed NK alloreactivity. DAR13-mediated blockade of Ly-49s3 inhibited killing of MHC-congenic target cells from the av1, n, lv1, and c haplotypes, but not from the u or b haplotypes. A putative ligand was mapped to the nonclassical MHC class I region (RT1-C/E/M) using intra-MHC recombinant strains. Relative numbers of Ly-49s3(+) NK cells were reduced, and surface levels of Ly-49s3 were lower, in MHC congenic strains expressing the putative Ly-49s3 ligand(s). In conclusion, we have identified a novel Ly-49 receptor that triggers rat NK cell-mediated responses.

NK cells, MHC class I molecules and the missing self

This article is based on a lecture presented at the Novartis Prize ceremony at the International Congress of Immunology in July 2001. It gives a personal and historical perspective on the research performed by the author and his colleagues during the development and pursuit of the model of 'missing-self recognition' for natural killer (NK) cells. This model is based on the idea that one important function of NK cells is to detect and eliminate cells because they fail to express normal self markers. Further mechanistic models predicted the existence of inhibitory major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I specific receptors, later identified by the fellow Novartis laureates contributing in this issue. The article covers the first decade (1980-1990) of research on this concept. It discusses factors contributing to the formulation of a hypothesis, the use of predictions and experimental test models, the importance of international collaborations and reagent exchange, and several other aspects that allowed the progression of this research project. Finally, the perspective of today's knowledge is used to discuss some surprising findings where the missing-self hypothesis made the wrong predictions, or at least failed to make the correct ones.

The effect of in vivo depletion of NKR-P1+ or CD8+ lymphocytes on the acute rejection of allogeneic lymphocytes (ALC) in the rat

We have depleted lymphocyte subsets in PVG and AO rats with MoAbs 3.2.3 (against NKR-P1 on NK and NK/T cells) and OX-8 (against CD8 on CTL and NK cells), and examined the effect on the killing of YAC-1 target cells in vitro and the effect on the acute rejection of small allogeneic lymphocytes in vivo (allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity, ALC). While 3.2.3 treatment led to only a partial depletion of 3.2.3-positive cells in PVG rats, this treatment drastically reduced the number of NKR-P1+ cells in AO rats, abolished splenic NK activity against the NK-sensitive tumour target YAC-1, and markedly diminished the ALC response. Rats treated with OX-8 for 1 day showed a similar loss of NK cell function in vivo and in vitro. However, in rats treated with OX-8 for 3 days a 3.2.3+ and OX-8- population consisting of NK cells appeared, restoring ALC. The results demonstrate that NK cell responses can be greatly diminished after in vivo treatment with these MoAbs. Furthermore, they demonstrate that ALC is not necessarily linked to expression of the CD8 molecule.

Specific immunosuppression by postoperative infusion of allogeneic spleen cells: requirement of donor major histocompatibility complex expression and graft-versus-host reactivity

BACKGROUND

Donor leukocytes may exert positive immunoregulatory effects on allograft acceptance. Most recent studies have focused on pretreatment protocols. In this study, the effect of postoperative infusion of donor leukocytes on graft survival and the phenotypic and functional requirements for infused cells were investigated in fully major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-mismatched rat heart transplant models.

METHODS

LEW (RT1l) heart grafts were implanted heterotopically into abdomens of LEW.1W (RT1u), and different types of cells were infused postoperatively. Immunohistochemistry was used to evaluate histopathological changes of grafts.

RESULTS

In the absence of any immunosuppressive agents, a single dose of viable donor spleen cells (SC), but not bone marrow cells, was able to prolong heart allograft survival to about 21 days, while they were rejected promptly at day 7 in controls. Infusion of T cell-depleted donor SC, irradiated donor SC or third-party (BN) SC showed no effect on graft survival. Compared with resting cells, neither in vitro nor in vivo prestimulation of infused donor SC improved graft survival. Clinical signs of graft-versus-host reaction were not observed in all above groups. Histology showed remarkable reduction in the severity of graft infiltrate and interleukin-2 receptor-positive cells in grafts of cell-treated animals. Postoperative infusion of SC of F1 generation between different strain combinations showed two requirements for infused cells to be effective: (1) expression of donor-type MHC antigens and (2) strong alloreactivity against the host MHC antigens.

CONCLUSION

Postoperative infusion of viable donor SC can lead to allospecific down-regulation of alloreactivity by a graft-versus-host-associated effect.

The role of natural killer cell mediated caspases activation in a graft-versus-host disease model of semiallogeneic small bowel transplantation

In the clinical setting of solid organ transplantation the event of graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) is rare and not easily predictable. Even intestinal and multivisceral transplants harbour a huge amount of immunocompetent cells and they do not exert a significantly higher risk to trigger serious GvH reactions. A series of our own experimental studies has been conducted to delineate the role of the host's innate immune system in the context of GvHD following parental to F1 hybrid semiallogeneic small bowel transplantation (SBTx). These results clearly demonstrated the immunological significance of the recipient's status of natural killer (NK) cell activity to counteract donor-derived lymphocytes and related cytotoxicity. NK cells and macrophages are both endowed with Ca2+-dependent receptors of the C-type lectin family which interact with a diversity of high-affinity oligosaccharide ligands expressed on potential target cells. One of these proteins of the C-type lectin family, termed NKR-P1, has been cloned and sequenced. Activation of NKR-P1 stimulates activation-induced cell death (AICD) of bound target cells. As intracellular mediators of apoptotic cell death a new family of cysteine proteases, the caspases, have been defined. These proteases appear to be involved in the initiation of apoptosis in response to a number of stimuli. This study was conducted to investigate the impact on the activity level of host NK cells and on target cell lysis of donor-derived lymphocytes after heterotopic semiallogeneic (parental [DA;RT1.aaav1] to F1 [DA x LEW;RT1.(1)]) small bowel transplantation using a rat model. The host's NK activity was either specifically activated (by use of polyinosinic:polycytodilic acid [poly-I:C]) or suppressed (by depletion of host NK cells after intraperitoneal administration of the NKR-P1 monoclonal antibody 3.2.3). The impact of NK-activity on the incidence of GvHD and the recipients' survival was correlated with the frequency of apoptotic cell death and related expression of caspases 1 (ICE) and 3 (CPP-32) from donor and recipient small bowel tissues. Our results confirm that depletion of NK cells in F1 host rats prior to parental small bowel transplantation significantly decreased the mean survival to 11.4 days versus 16.2 days of nondepleted F1 rats (p < 0.01). Conversely, activation of host NK activity with poly-I:C abrogated GvHD in all 12 recipient rats and led to long-term survival in seven of 12 animals. Long-term survival was associated with a substantially higher frequency of apoptotic cell death in donor and recipient small bowel and mesenteric lymph nodes. On day 10 after transplantation, Northern blot analysis of these tissues revealed profound upregulation of mRNA-specific gene expression for caspase 1 and 3 as potential mediators of programmed cell death of activated lymphocytes. Our findings emphasize the importance of NK cell associated innate immunity in the context of GvHD after semiallogeneic small bowel transplantation. Killing of alloreactive donor-derived lymphocytes was mediated by the NKR-P1 protein on NK cells and could be suppressed after pretreatment of F1 hosts with anti-NKR-P1 mAb 3.2.3. Moreover, NK cell-mediated apoptosis induced upregulation of caspases 1 and 3, thus elucidating the involvement of this protein in the context of caspase-mediated target cell killing.

Rat-to-mouse small bowel xenotransplantation: a novel model for studying acute vascular and hyperacute xenograft rejection and xenogenic cell migration

The present study was undertaken to establish a rat-to-mouse vascularized small bowel xenotransplantation model to study acute vascular and hyperacute xenograft rejection, and xenogenic cell migration. Lewis rat small bowel grafts were transplanted heterotopically to group 1, Balb/c mice, and group 2, Balb/c mice pre-sensitized with a donor spleen cell injection. The grafts were examined by serial pathology and flow cytometry. In group 1, acute vascular rejection was present by the 5th post-operative day (POD). Immunohistology showed a strong endothelial deposition of IgG, IgM and C3, associated with a minimal lymphocytic infiltrate. There was a vigorous cell migration from the recipient to the graft, in which recipient origin cells comprised 80.1+/-6.9% of the graft mesenteric lymph node by POD 3. However, there was almost no cell migration from the graft to the recipient. The intestinal xenografts in the group 2 showed massive hemorrhage, fibrin deposition, vascular congestion and thrombosis 60 min after transplantation. IgG and C3 were present on the endothelium as early as 1 min after reperfusion. The vigorous humorally-mediated vascular damage and rapid elimination of donor cells seen with intestinal xenograft rejection are distinct from the usual picture of allograft rejection. Hyperacute rejection can be induced by recipient pre-sensitization with donor spleen cells. The potential advantages of studying xenotransplantation in this model include: (1) the wide range of immunologic reagents available for mice; (2) the opportunity to study the progression of vascular damage easily by performing serial biopsies in the same animal; and (3) the opportunity to study, in vivo, two-way cellular response by examining cell trafficking in the mesenteric lymph nodes.

Role of classical (RT1.A) and nonclassical (RT1.C) MHC class I regions in natural killer cell-mediated bone marrow allograft rejection in rats

BACKGROUND

We have studied the role of the different MHC (RT1) subregions in acute natural killer (NK) cell-mediated bone marrow allograft rejection in lethally irradiated, bone marrow cell (BMC) reconstituted rats.

METHODS

We employed a series of MHC congenic and intra-MHC recombinant rat strains so that effects of mismatches in defined RT1 subregions could be studied systematically. BMC allograft survival was measured as 125IUdR uptake in the spleen between day 5 and day 7 after irradiation and BMC reconstitution.

RESULTS

We found that in certain RT1 haplotype combinations, nonclassical RT1.C disparities by themselves could determine graft rejection (i.e., in the u/av1 recombinant haplotypes), whereas in another combination (between the av1 and c haplotypes) a mismatch for an isolated classical RT1.A region was decisive for engraftment. Thus, PVG.R1 BMC failed to proliferate in PVG rats, differing in the RT1.A region only, whereas in PVG.1U rats rejection could be determined by isolated differences in the RT1.C region (LEW.1WR1). Also, RT1 homozygous rats (RT1.U) rejected semi-allogeneic F1 hybrid BMC. The acute rejection of BMC was mediated by NK cells, as athymic nude rats, lacking alloreactive T cells but with normal alloreactive NK cells, showed the same patterns of rejection as did normal rats. Nude rats also rejected allogeneic lymphocytes, a previously documented NK-mediated phenomenon, with identical requirements of MHC disparity.

CONCLUSIONS

This investigation shows that rat effector NK cells are radioresistant, independent of the thymus, and capable of recognizing and rejecting MHC mismatched transplanted BMC on the basis of mismatches in both classical and nonclassical class I regions in vivo. The studies underline the importance also of NK cells in determining BMC allograft survival.

Identification of an Inhibitory MHC Receptor on Alloreactive Rat Natural Killer Cells

Studies of allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity have shown that the rat NK allorecognition repertoire is controlled by genetic elements in both the MHC (RT1) and the NK gene complex (NKC). DA rats, possessing NK cells that are unable to lyse allogeneic lymphoblasts, were immunized with alloreactive NK cells from MHC-matched PVG.1AV1 rats, and two mAb, STOK1 and STOK2, were generated. STOK1 and STOK2 stained identical subsets of NKR-P1+ T and NK cells from certain strains of rats. Relative numbers varied markedly in a panel of MHC congenic strains, however, implicating a role for self MHC genes in their development. Both STOK1 and STOK2 immunoprecipitated a 110-kDa disulfide-linked homodimeric molecule, with extensive N-linked glycosylations, encoded by a gene that mapped to the NKC. NK cells expressing this glycoprotein displayed an increased ability to lyse allogeneic lymphoblasts, while syngeneic targets were spared. However, blockade of the STOK2 Ag with F(ab′)2 of STOK2 permitted the NK lysis of syngeneic targets, but did not affect NK allorecognition. These results indicate that mAb STOK1 and STOK2 identify an NKC-encoded MHC receptor in the rat that acts as a negative regulator of cytotoxicity.

Host MHC class I gene control of NK-cell specificity in the mouse

The missing self model predicts that NK cells adapt somatically to the type as well as levels of MHC class I products expressed by their host. Transgenic and gene knock-out mice have provided conclusive evidence that MHC class I genes control specificity and tolerance of NK cells. The article describes this control and discusses the possible mechanisms behind it, starting from a genetic model to study how natural resistance to tumors is influenced by MHC class I expression in the host as well as in the target cells. Data on host gene regulation of NK-cell functional specificity as well as Ly49 receptor expression are reviewed, leading up to the central question: how does the system develop and maintain "useful" NK cells, while avoiding "harmful" and "useless" ones? The available data can be fitted within each of two mutually none-exclusive models: cellular adaptation and clonal selection. Recent studies supporting cellular adaptation bring the focus on different possibilities within this general mechanism, such as anergy, receptor calibration and, most importantly, whether the specificity of each NK cell is permanently fixed or subject to continuous regulation.

Positive and negative MHC class I recognition by rat NK cells

The prompt rejection of transplanted allogeneic lymphocytes by rat NK cells in non-sensitized recipients (allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity or ALC) is determined by MHC genes as well as by genes located in the NK complex. The same genetic control is found when NK alloreactivity is measured by an in vitro assay, and we have employed this assay to delineate the specificity of NK cells for the MHC. The MHC of the rat, RT1, contains class I genes situated on either side of the class II/class III region. The majority of these class I genes are located in the RT1.C region and expressed class I products usually behave as non-classical (class Ib) molecules. They do not serve as restriction elements for the vast majority of conventional alpha/beta T-cells, in contrast to those class I molecules encoded by one or more loci in the classical (class Ia) region, RT1.A. However, NK cells appear to recognize the products of either class I region. Immunogenetic studies suggest that NK cells are inhibited by RT1. A molecules, whereas RT1.C region molecules may have a dual role in regulating NK cytolytic activity, i.e. they either inhibit or activate natural killing. Based on these premises, a model is proposed in which identification of a target as self or non-self depends on different receptors for class I in single NK cells, interpreting coincident positive and negative signals from the various target class I molecules. The putative role of peptides presented by class I, the biological implications, and the evolution of the NK receptors and their ligands are discussed.

Neonatally tolerant rats actively eliminate donor-specific lymphocytes despite persistent chimerism

Rats from the allotype-marked PVG-RT7b and PVG-RT1u-RT7b strains were injected at birth with semi-allogenic F1 bone marrow (BM) cells from athymic nude rats (PVG-rnu/rnu x PVG-RT1u-rnu/rnu) to induce neonatal tolerance. As adults, 97% of the animals accepted donor-specific allogeneic skin grafts and a majority (65%) of rats were chimeric, expressing the major histocompatibility complex class I and allotype marker of the donor strain. Similar results were obtained when PVG-RT1u-RT7b rats were injected at birth with fully allogeneic PVG-rnu/rnu nude BM cells: as adults, 94% accepted donor-specific skin allografts and 76% of recipients were chimeric. Donor derived CD4 T cells, CD8 T cells and B cells were found in low numbers (less than 2%) in peripheral blood of rats made tolerant by F1 BM cells. A large proportion of T cells bore the phenotype of recent thymic emigrants, suggesting that they were newly produced. All the evidence was consistent with clonal deletion tolerance, induced centrally within the thymus. The thymus was chimeric and thymocytes failed to respond in vitro to alloantigens of the donor-specific haplotype; donor-specific skin allografts survived indefinitely on athymic nude recipients reconstituted with CD4+CD8- thymocytes or peripheral CD4 T cells from tolerant animals. The chimeric state was interesting, since the PVG and PVG-RT1u rat strains contain a natural killer (NK) cell system that rapidly eliminates (within 24 h) intravenously injected allogeneic or semi-allogeneic lymphocytes--a phenomenon known as allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity or ALC. When neonatal tolerant rats were tested, the ALC index (a measure of cell killing) was unchanged in nonchimeric tolerant rats and significantly altered (reduced killing), but not abolished in chimeric animals. Hence, the injection of allogeneic BM cells which induced specific tolerance in the T cell population failed to tolerize the NK cell system, allowing the constant killing of newly produced donor-derived lymphocytes and putting at risk the very survival of the allogenic BM cells. This has interesting implications for clinical transplantation.

Alloreactive natural killer cells in the rat: complex genetics of major histocompatibility complex control

A major role for the nonclassical major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I region, i.e. RT1.C, in controlling rat natural killer (NK) cell alloreactivity has recently been established, and several findings suggested the existence of NK-triggering alloantigens coded for by this region. Here, we have extended our studies on the MHC control of NK cell cytotoxicity against concanavalin A-activated T cell blasts by comparing semi-syngeneic and fully allogeneic combinations, and we show the following: (a) The self MHC exerted a strong influence on the NK allorecognition repertoire. (b) When anti-F1 hybrid cytolytic activities of parental strain NK cells were measured, both recessively and non-recessively inherited susceptibility patterns emerged. (c) In most combinations parental strain cells were lysed by F1 hybrid NK cells, thus resembling the hybrid resistance phenomenon described in mice. The cytotoxicity was lower in strain combinations where NK susceptibility was inherited non-recessively, i.e. when parent anti-F1 reactivity was detected, than in recessive combinations. (d) LEW.1LM1 (RT1lm1) target cells, with a deletion in the RT1.C region that includes expressed class I genes, were more sensitive to lysis by MHC matched NK cells (PVG.1L(LEW), RT1l) than were parental LEW (RT1l) cells. The effect of the deletion was the opposite when MHC allogeneic (RT1c, RT1u) as well as semi-syngeneic (RT1l/c) NK cells were employed, i.e. sensitivity was decreased. We conclude that certain MHC-encoded antigens, depending on the haplotype combination of effector and target cells, may either trigger or inhibit rat NK cell cytotoxicity. Furthermore, the potential role of peptides bound to MHC class I molecules recognized by NK cells is discussed.

Recruitment of alloreactive natural killer cells to the rat peritoneum by a transfected cell line secreting rat recombinant interleukin-2

In order to obtain large numbers of natural killer (NK) cells from single rats for functional studies, we have devised a method for the generation of IL-2-activated NK cells in vivo. Rats were implanted intraperitoneally with cell-impermeable diffusion chambers (DC) containing cultures of transfected Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells secreting rat recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2). This resulted in a dramatic increase in the peritoneal exudate cell (PEC) number with a peak (300-1000 x 10(6)) 1 week after implantation. The majority were mononuclear cells of which a large proportion were CD3-NKR-P1+ NK cells, but with substantial numbers of macrophages (M phi) and CD3+8+NKR-P1+ T cells also. The NK activity against standard tumor target cells was high among PEC from six different inbred rat strains tested. However, the NK cell-mediated reactivity against concanavalin A (ConA)-activated T cell blasts from a panel of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) congenic strains differed widely. PEC from some strains (PVG, LOU/C, and AO) efficiently lysed all the MHC-disparate lymphoblasts. In other strains (BN and LEW) more restricted allorecognition repertoires were observed, whereas PEC from one strain (DA) were unresponsive. The secretion of rat rIL-2 intraperitoneally did not lead to a significant increase in the IL-2 level in the blood or in the total number or activity of NK cells in blood and spleen. The present method represents a most potent technique for generating large numbers of functional rat NK cells and shows the high efficiency with which IL-2 can induce NK cell recruitment in vivo.

Control of rat natural killer cell-mediated allorecognition by a major histocompatibility complex region encoding nonclassical class I antigens

The ability of natural killer (NK) cells to eliminate normal allogeneic hemic cells is well established in several species including mice, rats, and humans. The controlling elements for NK susceptibility in these species map to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), but in contrast to findings in mice and humans, the mode of inheritance is not always recessive in rats. This finding is not easily explained by the missing self and hemopoietic histocompatibility (Hh) models for NK recognition, and has led to the idea that certain alloantigens may trigger NK cell reactivity. In our in vitro system for assessing rat NK alloreactivity, we have employed target and inhibitor cells from a large panel of MHC congenic, intra-MHC recombinant and MHC mutant rat strains, as well as appropriate F1 hybrids between them, and we show the following: (a) The nonclassical class I (RT1.C) region was most important in determining the susceptibility of target cells to alloreactive NK cells in vitro. Lymphocyte susceptibility to lysis in vivo also mapped to the C region, which supports the concept that the in vivo and in vitro alloreactivity assays reflect the same recognition process. (b) Four different RT1-controlled NK allospecificities (represented by the u, l, a, and n haplotypes) could be discerned when we used polyclonal NK cells from the PVG (RT1c) strain as effector cells. Three of the target specificities recognized were controlled mainly by the RT1.C region. (c) The expression of RT1.C region-controlled parental strain NK allodeterminants could be demonstrated in F1 hybrids heterozygous for the C region alone and were therefore inherited nonrecessively. (d) Loss of an RT1.C region-controlled NK allospecificity could be shown with the MHC mutant LEW.1LM1 rat strain characterized by a genomic deletion of about 100 kb of the C region. Taken together, these observations have demonstrated a major importance of the nonclassical class I region, i.e., RT1.C, in controlling rat NK allorecognition, and have thereby assigned a hitherto undescribed immunological property to this region. Furthermore, some of the present data are consistent with the existence of polymorphic NK-triggering alloantigens that are coded for by the RT1.C region.

Allorecognition by NK cells: nonself or no self?

The issue of antigen recognition by NK cells is complex, fascinating and, as yet, unresolved. This article reviews recent research on the repertoire of human NK cell clones for the recognition of different allogeneic cells, and summarizes the studies, most of which have been performed in mice, that implicate the MHC in NK cell recognition. It goes on to provide a common conceptual framework within which these different systems may be understood.

Comparison of CNS homing pattern among murine TH cell lines responsive to myelin basic protein

A myelin basic protein (MBP)-reactive TH cell line capable of inducing experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE), and a MBP-reactive TH cell clone that does not cause EAE were labeled with a fluorescent vital dye, and transferred into naive syngeneic SJL/J mice. Animals were killed before the appearance of symptoms (3 and 4 days post-injection). Sections obtained from the spleen, spinal cord and brain of both groups of animals were examined by fluorescence microscopy to localize labeled TH cells. At all time points examined, the spleens of both groups contained innumerable labeled cells. The spinal cords and brains of animals that had received EAE-causing cells had a basal level of 20 labeled cells/cm2 at 3 days; this number increased rapidly to 150 cells/cm2 in the spinal cord at 4 days. Perivascular infiltrates and small foci of astrogliosis were already apparent in this group 3 days after injection. The spinal cords and brains of animals that had received the non-EAE-causing TH cells contained 50 labeled cells/cm2 at 3 days. The density of these transferred cells, as compared to that of the EAE-causing cells, suggested that they have an unaltered CNS-homing capability. However, by 4 days, the number of non-EAE-causing labeled cells had returned to near basal level. Our findings suggest that discrimination between disease and non-disease causing MBP-responsive TH cells occurs within the first 3 days following transfer, requires the presence in the CNS of a limited number of TH cells, and depends on yet unidentified TH cell factor(s).

Glomerulopathy Induced by Graft-Versus-Host Reaction in the Rat. Requirement of Donor CD4+ T Lymphocytes and MHC Class II Incompatibility at the Lymphoid Compartment

Graft-versus-host reactions (GVHR) can be associated with several autoimmune phenomena involving the kidney as a target organ. By transferring lymphocytes of AO rats into complete Freund's adjuvant-pretreated (AO x BN)F1 hybrids, a dose-dependent GVHR with glomerulopathy was experimentally induced. IgM, IgG1, and IgG2a were deposited in the mesangial area and along the glomerular basement membrane. Eluted immunoglobulins from diseased kidneys bound to normal basement membranes and especially to laminin. Anti-laminin reactivity was also present in sera from F1 recipients with GVHR. Parental CD4+ T lymphocytes were required and sufficient to induce GVHR and glomerulopathy in sublethally irradiated F1 hybrids. Using various F1 hybrids, MHC class II incompatibility was shown to be required for the induction of GVHR-associated glomerulopathy. Across MHC class I incompatibility, GVHR without glomerulopathy could be induced, provided that both CD4+ and CD8+ donor T lymphocytes were administered. Finally, MHC incompatibility between donor T lymphocytes and the recipient non-lymphoid compartment was found to be sufficient for the induction of GVHR, but not for GVHR-associated glomerulopathy. The results indicate that alloreactive donor CD4+ T lymphocytes have to interact directly with MHC class II alloantigen bearing host B lymphocytes in order to stimulate the latter to produce (auto-)antibodies. GVHR-induced glomerulopathy shares several immunopathological features with HgCl2-induced autoimmune glomerulopathy in the rat.

Allospecific recognition of hemic cells in vitro by natural killer cells from athymic rats: evidence that allodeterminants coded for by single major histocompatibility complex haplotypes are recognized

We have previously shown that large granular lymphocyte (LGL)-enriched cell populations have the capacity to spontaneously recognize and kill allogeneic small lymphocytes and bone marrow cells (BMC) in vitro in certain strain combinations of rats. Here, we have studied the alloreactivity of natural killer (NK) cells from PVG nude (RT1c) rats against a panel of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) incompatible hemic cells. Both lymphocytes and BMC from the AO (RT1u), DA (RT1a), BN (RT1n) as well as the MHC-congenic PVG-RT1u (RT1u) rat strains were efficiently killed in vitro, whereas cells from syngeneic PVG rats were spared. The structures recognized on lymphocytes and BMC were probably similar since the two cell populations inhibited each other in cross-competition experiments. A number of features aligned the alloreactive effector cells with NK cells and not T cells. (a) Only about 5% of the effector cells from nude spleens expressed the T cell antigens CD3, CD5 or T cell receptor (TcR) alpha/beta whereas greater than 50% of the cells expressed markers present on NK cells (CD2, CD8, OX52 and the rat NK cell-specific marker NKR-P1 recognized by the monoclonal antibody 3.2.3). (b) The alloreactive cells were granular since pretreatment of nude spleen cells with the lysosomotropic agent L-leucine methyl ester which eliminated LGL, simultaneously abolished the cytolysis of both allogeneic lymphocytes and YAC-1 tumor cells. (c) Nude spleen cells stimulated with human recombinant interleukin 2 for 1 week in vitro generated large granular proliferating cells which were CD3-, CD5-, TcR alpha/beta-, but greater than 95% 3.2.3+. These cells efficiently killed allogeneic hemic cells from the same rat strains as did freshly isolated effector cells. (d) The cytolysis of allogeneic hemic cells could effectively be inhibited with unlabelled NK-sensitive (YAC-1 and K-562), but not NK-resistant (Roser leukemia) tumor cells. Cross-competition studies showed that PVG nude NK cells discriminated between AO, BN and DA BMC, suggesting that different alloantigens were positively recognized by subsets of NK cells. The mode of inheritance of the allodeterminant specifically recognized on AO BMC was investigated in crosses and backcrosses between AO and BN or DA rats. A gene dosage effect was observed in that this determinant was expressed at a slightly reduced level in F1 hybrids.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Migration of 99mTc-labelled syngeneic lymphocytes in the rat. Biological and theoretical models predict radiation damage and poor scintigraphic detectability

The possibility of obtaining useful scintigrams of secondary lymphoid organs after infusion of syngeneic lymphocytes labelled with technetium-99m (99mTc) was explored in a rat model. Thoracic duct lymphocyte (TDL) accumulation in various organs was measured with both 99mTc and 51Cr labelled cells, the latter processed with a method that has been shown not to damage lymphocytes. 99mTc labelled TDL did not localize properly in the lymph nodes and spleen. We could not visualize lymph nodes in scintigrams, neither could we demonstrate any difference between normal and hyperplastic spleens. Our conclusion is that radiation from the 99mTc label readily influences lymphocyte migration so that useful scintigraphy in rats and other small experimental animals becomes impossible. This was supported by results from culture experiments with 99mTc labelled, radiosensitive mouse haemopoietic progenitor cells. Theoretical considerations, including the calculations of lymphocyte self-irradiation and signal/noise ratios during scintigraphy of rat tissues, supported our conclusion that scintigraphy in small animals, to disclose the physiological migration of lymphocytes, may be impossible with the present sensitivity of gamma cameras.

Fidelity of the repertoire in T cell reconstituted athymic nude rats. Preservation of a deficit in alloresponsiveness over one year

A single intravenous injection of a relatively small number of T cells contained in the population of rat thoracic duct lymphocytes (TDL) is sufficient to restore to normal the peripheral T cell pool of athymic PVG.rnu/rnu nude rats. The donor T cells expand greater than 10-15-fold, self-renew, and restore immunocompetency to nude recipients permanently (greater than 2 yr). We asked whether the T cell repertoire was affected by the expansion and self-renewal process. Nude recipients were injected with syngeneic PVG TDL that had been allospecifically depleted (negatively selected) by consecutive passage from blood to thoracic duct lymph through two irradiated (DAxPVG)F1 intermediate rats. Negatively selected TDL were tested before transfer by the P----F1 popliteal LN GVH assay and showed a greater than 90% depletion of specific reactivity to DA alloantigens. Surviving cells or their progeny were recovered from LN or TDL of nude recipients 8 and 12 mo after transfer. The deficit in GVH reactivity to the DA haplotype persisted, but normal GVH activity was demonstrated against a third party (AOxPVG)F1 alloantigen. The "hole" in the repertoire could not be attributed to tolerance induced by the co-transfer of contaminating irradiated F1 TDL. PVG TDL passaged consecutively through (AOxPVG)F1 and (DAxPVG)F1 intermediates and devoid of (AOxPVG)F1 cells remained specifically depleted to both AO and DA haplotypes when recovered from nude recipients 4 and 13 mo later, but displayed GVH activity to a third-party (BNxPVG)F1 alloantigen. Thus the exact specificity of the T cell repertoire of the original inoculum was faithfully maintained in nude recipients throughout the initial phase of rapid expansion and the continued self-renewal of the mature peripheral T cell pool.

Cellular requirements for renal allograft rejection in the athymic nude rat

This study has examined the ability of adoptively transferred CD4+ and CD8+ T cells to mediate rejection of a fully allogeneic DA renal graft in the PVG nude rat. Transfer, at the time of transplantation, of naive CD4+ T cells caused rapid graft rejection and primed CD4+ cells were several times more potent. In contrast, naive or specifically sensitized CD8+ cells were entirely ineffective at mediating renal allograft rejection. Whereas nonrejecting grafts showed only a mild cellular infiltrate, rejecting grafts in CD4+ reconstituted animals showed a substantial infiltrate and many of the infiltrating cells had a phenotype (MRC OX8+, MRC OX19-), consistent with NK cells. Experiments using a mAb (HIS 41) against an allotypic determinant of the leukocyte common antigen confirmed that the majority (greater than 80%) of the cellular infiltrate in rejecting grafts derived from the host rather than from the CD4+ inoculum. Infiltrating mononuclear cells, obtained from rejecting allografts 7 d after transplantation in CD4+-injected PVG nude hosts, showed high levels of in vitro cytotoxicity against not only kidney donor strain Con A blasts but also third-party allogeneic Con A blasts, as well as against both NK and LAK susceptible targets. When splenocytes from nontransplanted nude PVG rats were tested in vitro they also demonstrated high levels of lytic activity against both NK and LAK susceptible targets as well as allogeneic Con A blasts, which were not susceptible to lysis by spleen cells from euthymic rats. These findings suggest that injected CD4+ cells may cause renal allograft rejection by the recruitment of extrathymically derived, widely alloreactive cells into the kidney in this model of graft rejection.

Anti-Ia monoclonal antibody (10-2.16) inhibits lymphocyte-high endothelial venule (HEV) interaction

Lymphocyte egress from the vascular compartment into the lymph node (LN) parenchyma occurs at the postcapillary venules, termed high endothelial venules (HEVs). Lymphocyte adhesion and migration through the HEVs is a receptor-mediated, energy-dependent, process. The aim of this study was to investigate the role of MHC Class II antigen expression on lymphocyte-HEV interaction in normal (CBA) and autoimmune (MRL/l) mice. Using the HEV binding assay, lymphocyte adhesion to LN sections pretreated with monoclonal antibody (MAb; 10-2.16) was decreased compared to diluent (mean of the differences +/- standard deviation; xd +/- SD: 0.749 +/- 0.22, P less than 0.0075)- and myeloma immunoglobulin-pretreated controls (xd = 0.462 +/- 0.13, P less than 0.005). Similar inhibition of binding was found in MRL/l LN sections pretreated with MAb 10-2.16. Binding inhibition was concentration dependent, but total inhibition was never achieved. Several other anti-Ia MAb's were used, but failed to inhibit lymphocyte attachment. Lymphocyte binding to control sections treated with MAb's against MHC Class I antigen, plasminogen activator (PAM-3), anti-thrombin III (AT-IIIm), and MECA-325 antigen was not significantly different from diluent controls. LN cell suspensions pretreated with MAb 10-2.16 bound normally to LN sections. By contrast, MAb to lymphocyte homing receptor (MEL-14) inhibited lymphocyte adhesion. The role of Class II antigens in lymphocyte-HEV interactions is discussed.

Specific inhibition of natural killer (NK) activity against different alloantigens

Allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity (ALC), i.e., rapid rejection of i.v. injected allogeneic lymphocytes in unprimed hosts, is an example of NK activity. Apparently anomalous rejection patterns, such as acceptance of F1 hybrid cells by parental hosts and rejection of parental cells by F1 hybrid hosts in many strain combinations, would fit the hypothesis that the effector cells in ALC recognize the absence of certain self-molecules (passwords) rather than the presence of nonself determinants. However, cold target inhibition studies showed that ALC displays allospecificity: when a mixture of radiolabeled AO and DA cells were injected i.v. into euthymic or athymic PVG rats, adding a surplus of cold DA cells reduced killing only of labeled DA cells and vice versa. Furthermore, semiallogeneic cold target cells were ineffective in inhibiting elimination of fully allogeneic cells, which supports the argument against a modification of the hypothesis that self-determinants inhibit a postbinding stage of lysis. Finally, (DA x AO)F1 cells injected into (DA x PVG)F1 hosts were rapidly rejected, despite the fact that donor and host shared expressed DA determinants. In sum, our results show that a hypothesis based on inhibition of killing by self-determinants can only be sustained with extensive modifications, and favor the alternative mechanism that the effector cells positively recognize the presence of allospecific determinants on the target cell surface.

Analysis of the genetic control of lymphocyte positioning

A possible role for the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) in the localization of lymphocytes in different lymphoid organs was investigated using inbred mouse strains. Lymphocytes labelled with the intracellular fluorochrome Hoechst 33342 (H33342) were transfused intravenously (IV) into unimmunized mice and the distribution of these labelled lymphocytes examined. In some combinations (e.g. C57BL/6----CBA) 2 h after injection allogeneic lymphocytes accumulated in the region between the marginal zones and outer aspects of the white pulp of the spleen. In contrast, in syngeneic controls (e.g. CBA----CBA) the lymphocytes migrated normally into the while pulp. Similar results were obtained in Peyer's patches. Mapping studies in the spleen indicated that the failure to migrate normally is predominantly controlled by the MHC complex, although some non-MHC genes may play a role. In the case of the MHC the most definitive combination was BALB/c-H-2dm2 (H-2L deletion mutant) lymphocytes transfused into BALB/c recipients, the mutant lymphocytes failing to migrate normally and, therefore, implicating the H-2L region in the phenomenon. No differences in the viability of labelled lymphocytes at 6 and 24 h after injection into either syngeneic or allogeneic recipients suggests that the inability of cells to passage through lymphoid organs may represent inappropriate receptors rather than elimination of the allogeneic lymphocytes by natural killer cells (NK) as previously proposed.

Inhibition of pluripotent hematopoietic stem cells of bone marrow by large granular lymphocytes

Previous studies suggested that natural killer (NK) cells are involved in the regulation of the growth and differentiation of pluripotent hematopoietic stem cells. To establish whether the effector cells responsible for the in vivo resistance to bone marrow (BM) transplants and the in vitro inhibition of colony-forming units (CFU) may represent identical or overlapping populations, we used a rat system for syngeneic BM transplantation, with and without the transfer of large numbers of peripheral blood large granular lymphocytes (LGLs). BM reconstitution was measured by the in vivo formation of syngeneic CFU in the spleen (CFU-s). Because of the very low frequency of CFU-s in normal rat BM, we fractionated BM cells in Percoll density gradients, which provided a 2- to 5-fold enrichment in CFU-s in the lower-density fractions. Although these fractions contained less than 10% of the total cells, they contained greater than 75% of the CFU-s and allowed for the transfer of significantly fewer donor cells. At the time of BM transplantation, radiation-resistant asialoganglioside GM1-positive LGLs, with high NK activity, accounted for a significant percentage of the lymphoid cells in the irradiated recipient. The in vivo regulatory role of these cells on engraftment was demonstrated by their depletion (by i.v. injection of small amounts of anti-asialo-GM1 antiserum before BM transplantation), which resulted in a significant increase in the number of CFU-s. Conversely, a 50% inhibition in CFU-s was found when CFU-s-enriched BM fractions were preincubated in vitro with LGLs. Additional experiments, involving selective in vivo depletion of NK cells followed by LGL repopulation, directly demonstrated the involvement of LGLs in the regulation and growth of syngeneic pluripotent hematopoietic stem cells. Our results further support the hypothesis that LGLs are involved directly or via humoral factors in the homeostasis and regulation of hematopoietic stem cell growth and differentiation.

The influence of oxazolone on the recirculation capacity of B and T cells

Stimulation of lymph nodes with the contact allergen oxazolone had a profound effect on the recirculation capacity of IgD+ B cells and to a lesser extent of T cells when tested in an allotypic transfer system. The effect was most prominent on day 4 after stimulation and was not found with any other antigen that was tested. The impaired recirculation was correlated with a reduction of the adherence capacity of this cell population to HEV in vitro. However, the cells expressed normal levels of the MEL-14 antigen on their surface, as determined by dual-fluorescence FACS analysis. Similar effects were observed when lymphocytes were haptenized with the allergen for a short period in vitro. The treatment had no effect on the viability of the cell population nor on its capacity to react with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and concanavalin A (Con A). When the cells were cultured for 24 h in the absence of oxazolone after either in vivo or in vitro treatment, a normal recirculation capacity was observed, indicating that the effects were reversible. The possible implications of this finding are discussed.

The host component of the popliteal lymph node graft-versus-host reaction. Selective representation of lymphocyte subsets and the requirement for alloantigenic incompatibility between donor cells and activated host B cells

We have examined the cellular changes taking place in rat popliteal lymph nodes undergoing a graft-versus-host (GvH) reaction. Examination of immunoperoxidase-stained lymph node sections, using a panel of mouse monoclonal antibodies directed against different rat lymphoid cell subsets, revealed a disorganization of the lymph node architecture with disappearance of the follicles, and an intermingling of T and B cells, so that no distinct T- and B-cell areas were visible any more. Since the GvH nodes showed a preferential accumulation of host B cells over host T cells (particularly over the W 3/25+ T helper cell subset), we also investigated the requirements for host B cell activation. The popliteal lymph node GvH reaction was induced in (PVG X DA)F1 rats by the injection of PVG cells into one foot and by DA cells into the other foot, and then immunoglobulin kappa allotype marked PVG B cells from athymic donors were injected intravenously. The allotype marked B cells proliferated vigorously in response to the DA T cells, but much less in response to the PVG T cells. These results indicate that the massive B-cell activation taking place in GvH reactions may require an alloantigen incompatibility between donor T cells and host B cells, and argue against non-specific mitogenic induction of the B cells.

The roles of interdigitating cells and natural killer cells in the rapid rejection of allogeneic lymphocytes

The fate of radiolabeled allogeneic thoracic duct lymphocytes injected into congenitally athymic, nude rats was followed by autoradiography and electron microscopy. The allogeneic cells entered the host lymphoid organs at a normal rate, but once inside the lymphoid tissue they were rapidly phagocytozed by interdigitating cells (IDC) situated in the lymph node paracortex and the splenic periarteriolar lymphoid sheaths. Neither host nor donor T cells were required to initiate phagocytosis, as purified donor B cells were also avidly ingested by the athymic host IDC. Compared with fully allogeneic cells phagocytosis of semiallogeneic donor cells was much less efficient. When natural killer cell activity was blocked by preinjecting the recipients with antibodies against natural killer cells (anti-asialo GM1 or MRC OX-8) phagocytosis of the allogeneic cells was strongly reduced. As IDC did not bind these antibodies, the finding indicates that natural killer cells were needed to discriminate between own and foreign lymphocytes and to kill the allogeneic cells, which were then ingested by surrounding IDC. This was further supported by the observation that dendritic, constitutively Ia+ cells from peripheral lymph, phenotypically identical to IDC, did not lyse or phagocytoze allogeneic lymphocytes in vitro.

Selective rejection of H-2-deficient lymphoma variants suggests alternative immune defence strategy

Metazoan organisms may discriminate between self and non-self not only by the presence of foreign antigens but also by the absence of normal self markers. Mammalian adaptive immune responses use the first strategy, with the additional requirement that foreign antigens are recognized in the context of self-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) products at the cell surface. Aberrant cells which fail to express MHC products adequately can therefore avoid detection. A more primitive but complementary defence system, eliminating such cells on the basis of absent self-markers, is suggested by a re-interpretation of phenomena associated with metastasis and natural resistance. We now show that murine lymphoma cells selected for loss of H-2 expression are less malignant after low-dose inoculation in syngeneic hosts than are wild-type cells, and that the rejection of such cells is non-adaptive. On the basis of our data, we suggest that natural killer cells are effector cells in a defence system geared to detect the deleted or reduced expression of self-MHC.

Host resistance directed selectively against H-2-deficient lymphoma variants. Analysis of the mechanism

Three independent variants with a profound reduction of cell surface H-2 have been selected from the C57BL/6 mouse-derived RBL-5 and EL-4 T lymphomas. After subcutaneous inoculation of low cell doses in syngeneic mice, the H-2- variants failed to grow out, whereas the H-2+ control lines showed progressive growth. No difference in growth rate or cloning efficiency was detectable in tissue culture. The in vivo difference in tumor outgrowth was analyzed in detail for one of the H-2-low lines. The outgrowth difference remained after the H-2-low variant and the control line had been injected subcutaneously in opposite flanks of the same mouse, and it was not dependent upon activity of mature T cells, since the same result was seen in athymic nude mice. The difference was partially sensitive to irradiation of the hosts. When mice were pretreated with anti-asialo GM1 antiserum, known to depress natural killer (NK) cell activity, the difference in outgrowth was abolished, and both the control line and the H-2- variant showed progressive growth in vivo. Experiments comparing the distribution and survival of isotope-prelabeled variant and wild type cells indicated that a rapid elimination of the former took place within 24 h after intravenous injection. These differences in tumor elimination were not seen in mice treated with anti-asialo GM1 antiserum. We conclude that the reduced tumorigenicity of sublines with impaired H-2 expression is largely, if not exclusively due to rapid elimination by NK cells. These findings may reflect an inverse, indirect relation between factors controlling H-2 expression and NK sensitivity. Another possible explanation is that major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-encoded gene products are directly involved in a regulatory signal in the NK cell system. According to this interpretation, immunological selectivity in the NK cell system would be achieved by the failure to recognize self-MHC, irrespective of the presence of foreign antigens, i.e. by detection of no-self rather than of nonself. This may also explain previous observations on H-2-linked hybrid resistance against lymphoid grafts and changes in H-2 phenotypes associated with tumor progression.