Indirect recognition of MHC class I allopeptides accelerates lung allograft rejection in miniature swine

Update on Chronic Lung Allograft Dysfunction

Chronic lung allograft dysfunction (CLAD) encompasses a range of pathologies that cause a transplanted lung to not achieve or maintain normal function. CLAD manifests as airflow restriction and/or obstruction and is predominantly a result of chronic rejection. Three distinct phenotypes of chronic rejection are now recognized: bronchiolitis obliterans, neutrophilic reversible allograft dysfunction, and restrictive allograft syndrome. Recent investigations have revealed that each phenotype has a unique pathology and histopathological findings, suggesting that treatment regimens should be tailored to the underlying etiology. CLAD is poorly responsive to treatment once diagnosed, and therefore the prevention of the factors that predispose a patient to develop CLAD is critically important. Small and large animal models have contributed significantly to our understanding of CLAD and more studies are needed to develop treatment regimens that are effective in humans.

Augmentation of Transient Donor Cell Chimerism and Alloantigen-Specific Regulation of Lung Transplants in Miniature Swine

Donor alloantigen infusion induces T cell regulation and transplant tolerance in small animals. Here, we study donor splenocyte infusion in a large animal model of pulmonary transplantation. Major histocompatibility complex-mismatched single lung transplantation was performed in 28 minipigs followed by a 28-day course of methylprednisolone and tacrolimus. Some animals received a perioperative donor or third party splenocyte infusion, with or without low-dose irradiation (IRR) before surgery. Graft survival was significantly prolonged in animals receiving both donor splenocytes and IRR compared with controls with either donor splenocytes or IRR only. In animals with donor splenocytes and IRR, increased donor cell chimerism and CD4(+) CD25(high+) T cell frequencies were detected in peripheral blood associated with decreased interferon-γ production of leukocytes. Secondary third-party kidney transplants more than 2 years after pulmonary transplantation were acutely rejected despite maintained tolerance of the lung allografts. As a cellular control, additional animals received third-party splenocytes or donor splenocyte protein extracts. While animals treated with third-party splenocytes showed significant graft survival prolongation, the subcellular antigen infusion showed no such effect. In conclusion, minipigs conditioned with preoperative IRR and donor, or third-party, splenocyte infusions may develop long-term donor-specific pulmonary allograft survival in the presence of high levels of circulating regulatory T cells.

Allorecognition pathways in transplant rejection and tolerance

With the advent of cellular therapies, it has become clear that the success of future therapies in prolonging allograft survival will require an intimate understanding of the allorecognition pathways and effector mechanisms that are responsible for chronic rejection and late graft loss.Here, we consider current understanding of T-cell allorecognition pathways and discuss the most likely mechanisms by which these pathways collaborate with other effector mechanisms to cause allograft rejection. We also consider how this knowledge may inform development of future strategies to prevent allograft rejection.Although both direct and indirect pathway CD4 T cells appear active immediately after transplantation, it has emerged that indirect pathway CD4 T cells are likely to be the dominant alloreactive T-cell population late after transplantation. Their ability to provide help for generating long-lived alloantibody is likely one of the main mechanisms responsible for the progression of allograft vasculopathy and chronic rejection.Recent work has suggested that regulatory T cells may be an effective cellular therapy in transplantation. Given the above, adoptive therapy with CD4 regulatory T cells with indirect allospecificity is a rational first choice in attempting to attenuate the development and progression of chronic rejection; those with additional properties that enable inhibition of germinal center alloantibody responses hold particular appeal.

Tolerogenicity of donor major histocompatibility complex-matched skin grafts in previously tolerant Massachusetts general hospital miniature swine

BACKGROUND

Long-term tolerance of class I disparate renal allografts in miniature swine can be induced by a short course of cyclosporine and persists for 3 to 4 months after grafts are removed. Donor class I peptide immunization 6 weeks after graftectomy of tolerated kidneys leads to sensitization, but donor skin grafts do not. Here, we tested the hypothesis that skin grafts prevent rejection after simultaneous peptide administration and skin grafting.

METHODS

Miniature swine underwent bilateral nephrectomy and class I-mismatched renal transplantation with a 12-day course of cyclosporine A to induce long-term tolerance. Tolerated allografts were then replaced with recipient-matched kidneys, and animals were challenged with simultaneous donor-type skin grafts and peptide. Six weeks later, second donor-matched kidneys were transplanted without immunosuppression, and immune responses were characterized.

RESULTS

Animals treated only with peptide (n=2) rejected subsequent renal transplants in 3 to 5 days with strong in vitro antidonor responses. Of five recipients of skin-plus-peptide regimen, two accepted kidneys long term, one demonstrated a modestly prolonged survival (11 days), and two rejected rapidly (5-7 days). The two long-term acceptors maintained donor-specific hyporesponsiveness in vitro.

CONCLUSIONS

Sensitization by class I peptide in previously tolerant swine could be prevented by simultaneous class I skin grafts. These data suggest that skin grafts may actually augment rather than abrogate downregulation in some cases. A mechanistic hypothesis for this surprising result is that recognition of class I antigens through the direct rather than the indirect pathway of antigen presentation promotes tolerance by expanding regulatory T cells.

Translational research: animal models of obliterative bronchiolitis after lung transplantation

Obliterative bronchiolitis (OB) or chronic graft dysfunction remains the major limitation to long-term success of lung transplantation. Investigation using animal models is a critical component of research to understand the underlying pathological mechanisms and to develop novel preventive and therapeutic strategies for OB. Multiple animal models of OB exist, including orthotopic lung transplantation in rodents and large animals, orthotopic tracheal transplantation and heterotopic transplantation of a trachea in variable sites such as subcutaneous, intraomental and intrapulmonary sites. The most important issue for researchers is not specifically which model is the best but which is the most appropriate model to test their scientific hypothesis. For example, while orthotopic lung transplantation best mimics the overall surgical procedure, a question regarding fibrotic processes of OB may be better answered using heterotopic tracheal transplant models because of their reliable reproducibility of allograft obliterative airway fibrosis. Animal models should be continuously refined, modified and sometimes combined to fit the particular research purpose. We review the available animal models, their modifications and possible applications to assist researchers in choosing the appropriate model for their intended research.

The human alloreactive CD4+ T-cell repertoire is biased to a Th17 response and the frequency is inversely related to the number of HLA class II mismatches

Estimates of precursor frequency and assessment of functional characteristics of alloreactive CD4+ T cells are all biased by the need for long-term culture. In this study, direct visualization of human alloreactive CD4+ T cells on the single-cell level was achieved using cell surface expression of CD154 as a tool for identification. The average frequency of alloreactive CD154+CD4+ T cells among peripheral blood CD4+ T cells was 0.1%, with half of the cells displaying a naive phenotype. The proliferation capacity and expression of cytokines after allogeneic stimulation resided in these CD154+CD4+ T cells. The repertoire of alloreactive CD4+ T cells was biased to a Th17 response, and on average 24% of alloreactive CD154+CD4+ memory T cells produced interleukin-17 (IL-17) after polyclonal stimulation. Unexpectedly, mixed cell cultures from human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-identical donors also generated alloreactive CD154+CD4+ T cells and yielded the highest frequency compared with HLA-nonidentical combinations. Therefore, reactivity to minor histocompatibility antigens between HLA-identical subjects appears to be relatively common. Alloreactive HLA-identical T cells did not proliferate or express cytokines, but were driven to proliferation in the presence of exogenous IL-2.

Value of FOXP3 expression in peripheral blood as rejection marker after miniature swine lung transplantation

BACKGROUND

Outcome for highly immunogenic lung transplantation remains unsatisfactory despite the development of potent immunosuppressants. The poor outcome may be the result of a lack of minimally invasive methods to detect early rejection. There is emerging clinical evidence that, paradoxically, expression of forkhead box P3 (FOXP3, a specific marker for the regulatory T cells) is upregulated within rejecting grafts.

METHODS

Orthotopic lung transplantation was performed using miniature swine without immunosuppression. Rejection was monitored by chest radiography and open lung biopsy. Expressions levels of FOXP3, perforin, Fas-L and IP-10 mRNA were quantified in the peripheral blood. In addition, rescue immunosuppressive therapy (steroid plus tacrolimus) was administered on post-operative day (POD) 4 or 6.

RESULTS

Early rejection was detected by open lung biopsy, but misdiagnosed by chest radiography on POD 4. Expression of FOXP3 in the peripheral blood reached its highest value as early as POD 4, followed by a decline. Such an increase of FOXP3 was not observed in recipients given high-dose tacrolimus. Neither perforin, Fas-L or IP-10 in the peripheral blood exhibited significant fluctuations in the early phase of rejection. Rescue immunosuppressive therapy from POD 4, when peak FOXP3 was seen, prolonged graft survival (27.2 days, versus 9.1 days without immunosuppression, p < 0.001), in contrast to POD 6, when rejection was suspected by chest radiography (11.5 days, p = not statistically significant [NS]).

CONCLUSIONS

In a miniature swine lung transplantation model, the FOXP3 mRNA level in the peripheral blood was upregulated at an early phase of rejection. The clinical implication of this finding remains to be elucidated.

Repetitive gastric aspiration leads to augmented indirect allorecognition after lung transplantation in miniature swine

INTRODUCTION

Lung transplant recipients with documented gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) are at increased risk for graft dysfunction. Here, we present the first large-animal model of gastric aspiration after allogeneic lung transplantation and some preliminary data demonstrating the effect of chronic aspiration on the direct and indirect pathways of allorecognition.

METHODS

Left orthotopic lung transplants (n=3) were performed in miniature swine across a major histocompatibility complex class I disparity, followed by 12 days of high-dose cyclosporine A. At the time of transplantation, a transtracheal catheter was placed at the carina, above the bronchial anastomosis. A gastrostomy tube was placed for daily aspiration of gastric contents. Subsequently, graft lungs were instilled with gastric aspirate daily (3 mL/hrX8 hr/day) for 50 days. Recipients were followed up with daily complete blood count, scheduled chest radiographs, and biopsies. In vitro studies, including cell-mediated lympholysis, mixed lymphocyte reactions, and peptide proliferation assays, were performed. Results from these three recipients were compared with those of historical controls (n=6) who were treated identically, except for the tracheal cannulation and simulated gastric aspiration.

RESULTS

Two of the experimental animals were euthanized with nonviable lungs soon after the postoperative day 50 biopsy. In both cases the native lung was normal. The third animal survived over 180 days without the evidence of chronic rejection. After immunosuppressive treatment, all animals demonstrated donor-specific hyporesponsiveness by assays of direct alloresponse (cell-mediated lympholysis, mixed lymphocyte reaction). A significant response to synthetic donor-derived class I peptide, however, was seen in all animals. A more pronounced and diffuse response was seen in the animals rejecting their grafts. The historical controls showed medium-term graft survival with evidence of chronic rejection in the majority of animals, as previously reported.

CONCLUSION

In a model of GERD after lung transplantation, a spectrum of clinical outcomes was observed. The in vitro data suggest that acid reflux enhances the indirect alloresponse to processed donor class I antigen, giving mechanistic insight into the manner in which GERD may be deleterious to the transplanted lung.

Immunosuppression for lung transplantation

As a result of advances in surgical techniques, immunosuppressive therapy, and postoperative management, lung transplantation has become an established therapeutic option for individuals with a variety of end-stage lung diseases. The current 1-year actuarial survival rate following lung transplantation is approaching 80%. However, the 5- year actuarial survival rate has remained virtually unchanged at approximately 50% over the last 15 years due to the processes of acute and chronic lung allograft rejection (1). Clinicians still rely on a vast array of immunosuppressive agents to suppress the process of graft rejection, but find themselves limited by an inescapable therapeutic paradox. Insufficient immunosuppression results in graft loss due to rejection, while excess immunosuppression results in increased morbidity and mortality from opportunistic infections and malignancies. Indeed, graft rejection, infection, and malignancy are the three principal causes of mortality for the lung transplant recipient. One should also keep in mind that graft loss in a lung transplant recipient is usually a fatal event, since there is no practical means of long-term mechanical support, and since the prospects of re-transplantation are low, given the shortage of acceptable donor grafts. This chapter reviews the current state of immunosuppressive therapy for lung transplantation and suggests alternative paradigms for the management of future lung transplant recipients.

Operational tolerance to class I disparate lungs can be induced despite pretransplant immunization with class I allopeptides

BACKGROUND

Using a class I-disparate swine lung transplant model, we examined whether an intensive course of tacrolimus could induce operational tolerance and whether preoperative allopeptide immunization would prevent the development of tolerance.

METHODS

Left lung grafts were performed using class I-disparate (class II-matched) donors. Recipients were treated with 12 days of postoperative tacrolimus. Three recipients were immunized prior to transplantation with class I allopeptides. Three other recipients were not immunized.

RESULTS

The nonimmunized recipients maintained their grafts long term (>497, >451, and >432 days), without developing chronic rejection. The immunized swine also maintained their grafts long term (>417, >402, >401 days), despite developing a variety of in vitro and in vivo responses to the immunizing peptides, as well as having strong mixed lymphocyte reactions to donor cells prior to transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

Using only a brief course of tacrolimus, we have been able to induce a state of operational tolerance in a class I-disparate preclinical lung transplant model. Moreover, preoperative alloimmunization did not block tolerance induction or induce chronic rejection. These data show that it is possible to create a state of operational tolerance to lung allografts even in the presence of donor-sensitized cells.

Maintenance of airway epithelium in acutely rejected orthotopic vascularized mouse lung transplants

Lung transplantation remains the only therapeutic option for many patients suffering from end-stage pulmonary disease. Long-term success after lung transplantation is severely limited by the development of bronchiolitis obliterans. The murine heterotopic tracheal transplantation model has been widely used for studies investigating pathogenesis of obliterative airway disease and immunosuppressive strategies to prevent its development. Despite its utility, this model employs proximal airway that lacks airflow and is not vascularized. We have developed a novel model of orthotopic vascularized lung transplantation in the mouse, which leads to severe vascular rejection in allogeneic strain combinations. Here we characterize differences in the fate of airway epithelial cells in nonimmunosuppressed heterotopic tracheal and vascularized lung allograft models over 28 days. Up-regulation of growth factors that are thought to be critical for the development of airway fibrosis and interstitial collagen deposition were similar in both models. However, while loss of airway epithelial cells occurred in the tracheal model, airway epithelium remained intact and fully differentiated in lung allografts, despite profound vascular rejection. Moreover, we demonstrate expression of the anti-apoptotic protein Bcl-2 in airway epithelial cells of acutely rejected lung allografts. These findings suggest that in addition to alloimmune responses, other stimuli may be required for the destruction of airway epithelial cells. Thus, the model of vascularized mouse lung transplantation may provide a new and more physiologic experimental tool to study the interaction between immune and nonimmune mechanisms affecting airway pathology in lung allografts.

A mouse model of orthotopic vascularized aerated lung transplantation

Outcomes after lung transplantation are markedly inferior to those after other solid organ transplants. A better understanding of cellular and molecular mechanisms contributing to lung graft injury will be critical to improve outcomes. Advances in this field have been hampered by the lack of a mouse model of lung transplantation. Here, we report a mouse model of vascularized aerated single lung transplantation utilizing cuff techniques. We show that syngeneic grafts have normal histological appearance with minimal infiltration of T lymphocytes. Allogeneic grafts show acute cellular rejection with infiltration of T lymphocytes and recipient-type antigen presenting cells. Our data show that we have developed a physiological model of lung transplantation in the mouse, which provides ample opportunity for the study of nonimmune and immune mechanisms that contribute to lung allograft injury.

The role of indirect recognition of MHC class I and II allopeptides in a fully mismatched miniature swine model of lung transplantation

Considerable evidence suggests that indirect recognition of MHC allopeptides plays an important role in solid-organ rejection. Here, we examine whether immunization with class I or class II allopeptides accelerates rejection in a fully MHC-mismatched lung transplant model in miniature swine.

METHODS

Recipients were immunized with either donor-derived class I or class II peptides. Sensitization to the peptides was confirmed by DTH testing and in vitro proliferation assays. Nonimmunized control (n = 6), class I peptide-immunized (n = 3), and class II peptide-immunized (n = 3) swine were transplanted with fully mismatched lungs using only a 12-day course of tacrolimus.

RESULTS

One control animal rejected its graft on postoperative day 103, while the others maintained their grafts for over 1 year. In the class I peptide-immunized group, two recipients rejected their grafts (days 14 and 52). The third animal has not rejected the graft (day 120, experiment is ongoing). In contrast, in the class II-peptide immunized group, only one animal rejected its graft on day 52, while the others maintained their grafts over 1 year. Both anti-donor IgM and IgG antibodies were detectable in all acute rejectors, although no alloantibody was detectable in long-term acceptors. Regardless of the fate of the graft, all animals have maintained their proliferative responses to the peptides. However, only acceptors maintained donor-specific hyporesponsiveness in cell-mediated lymphocytotoxity and mixed lymphocyte reaction assays.

CONCLUSIONS

Pretransplant sensitization of lung allograft recipients to donor allopeptides accelerates graft rejection. This appears particularly true for class I-derived allopeptides, suggesting that class II molecules may be less antigenic when presented indirectly.

Lung Transplantation: Current Status and Challenges

The lung is an anatomically complex vital organ whose normal physiology depends on actively regulated ventilation and perfusion, and maintenance of a delicate blood-air barrier over a huge surface area in direct contact with a potentially hostile environment. Despite significant progress over the past 25 years, both short- and long-term outcomes remain significantly inferior for lung recipients relative to other "solid" organs. This review summarizes the current status of lung transplantation so as to frame the principle challenges currently facing end-stage lung-failure patients and the practitioners who care for them.