Gln27→Gluβ2-Adrenergic Receptor Polymorphism in Heart Failure Patients: Differential Clinical and Oxidative Response to Carvedilol

Heart Failure: Recent Advances and Breakthroughs

Heart failure (HF) is a common clinical condition encountered in various healthcare settings with a vast socioeconomic impact. Recent advancements in pharmacotherapy have led to the evolution of novel therapeutic agents with a decrease in hospitalization and mortality rates in HF with reduced left ventricular ejection fraction (HFrEF). Lately, the introduction of artificial intelligence (AI) to construct decision-making models for the early detection of HF has played a vital role in optimizing cardiovascular disease outcomes. In this review, we examine the newer therapies and evidence behind goal-directed medical therapy (GDMT) for managing HF. We also explore the application of AI and machine learning (ML) in HF, including early diagnosis and risk stratification for HFrEF.

Risk Stratification Towards Precision Medicine in Heart Failure - Current Progress and Future Perspectives

Clinical risk stratification is a key strategy used to identify low- and high-risk subjects to optimize the management, ranging from pharmacological treatment to palliative care, of patients with heart failure (HF). Using statistical modeling techniques, many HF risk prediction models that combine predictors to assess the risk of specific endpoints, including death or worsening HF, have been developed. However, most risk prediction models have not been well-integrated into the clinical setting because of their inadequacy and diverse predictive performance. To improve the performance of such models, several factors, including optimal sampling and biomarkers, need to be considered when deriving the models; however, given the large heterogeneity of HF, the currently advocated one-size-fits-all approach is not appropriate for every patient. Recent advances in techniques to analyze biological "omics" information could allow for the development of a personalized medicine platform, and there is growing awareness that an integrated approach based on the concept of system biology may be an excessively naïve view of the multiple contributors and complexity of an individual's HF phenotype. This review article describes the progress in risk stratification strategies and perspectives of emerging precision medicine in the field of HF management.

Pharmacogenetic factors affecting β-blocker metabolism and response

INTRODUCTION

β-blockers are among the most widely prescribed of all drugs, used for treatment of a large number of cardiovascular diseases. Herein we evaluate literature pertaining to pharmacogenetics of β-blocker therapy, provide insight into the robustness of the genetic associations, and determine the appropriateness for translating these genetic associations into clinical practice.

AREAS COVERED

A literature search was conducted using PubMed to collate evidence on associations between CYP2D6, ADRB1, ADRB2, and GRK5 genetic variation and drug-response outcomes in the presence of β-blocker exposure. Pharmacokinetic, pharmacodynamic, and clinical outcomes studies were included if genotype data and β-blocker exposure were documented.

EXPERT OPINION

Substantial data suggest that specific ADRB1 and GRK5 genotypes are associated with improved β-blocker efficacy and have potential for use to guide therapy decisions in the clinical setting. While the data do not justify ordering a CYP2D6 pharmacogenetic test, if CYP2D6 genotype is available in the electronic health record, there may be clinical utility for understanding dosing of β-blockers.

Pharmacogenomics of heart failure: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Heart failure (HF) and multiple HF-related phenotypes are heritable. Genes implicated in the HF pathophysiology would be expected to influence the response to treatment.

METHODS

We conducted a series of systematic literature searches on the pharmacogenetics of HF therapy to assess the current knowledge on this field.

RESULTS

Existing data related to HF pharmacogenomics are still limited. The ADRB1 gene is a likely candidate to predict response to β-blockers. Moreover, the cytochrome P450 2D6 coding gene (CYP2D6) clearly affects the pharmacokinetics of metoprolol, although the clinical impact of this association remains to be established.

CONCLUSION

Given the rising prevalence of HF and related costs, a more personalized use of HF drugs could have a remarkable benefit for patients, caregivers and healthcare systems.

Practical Pharmacogenomic Approaches to Heart Failure Therapeutics

OPINION STATEMENT

The major challenge in applying pharmacogenomics to everyday clinical practice in heart failure (HF) is based on (1) a lack of robust clinical evidence for the differential utilization of neurohormonal antagonists in the management of HF in different subgroups, (2) inconsistent results regarding appropriate subgroups that may potentially benefit from an alternative strategy based on pharmacogenomic analyses, and (3) a lack of clinical trials that focused on testing gene-guided treatment in HF. To date, all pharmacogenomic analyses in HF have been conducted as post hoc retrospective analyses of clinical trial data or of observational patient series studies. This is in direct contrast with the guideline-directed HF therapies that have demonstrated their safety and efficacy in the absence of pharmacogenomic guidance. Therefore, the future of clinical applications of pharmacogenomic testing will largely depend on our ability to incorporate gene-drug interactions into the prescribing process, requiring that preemptive and cost-effective testing be paired with decision-support tools in a value-based care approach.

Association of common polymorphisms in β1-adrenergic receptor with antihypertensive response to carvedilol

OBJECTIVES

Marked interpatient variability exists in the blood pressure response to carvedilol, a nonselective β-blocker. Here we evaluated the influence of 4 common polymorphisms in genes of the β-adrenergic receptor on the antihypertensive efficacy of carvedilol in patients in a double-blinded monotherapy study.

METHODS

Eighty-seven subjects with uncomplicated essential hypertensive (49% men; age = 52.2 ± 11.1 years) from Jilin province of China were enrolled in the study, and 5 of them discontinued the treatment due to adverse effects. Both systolic and diastolic blood pressures (DBPs) were measured before and after 7 days of treatment with carvedilol (10 mg/d). Genotypes of the β1-adrenergic receptor (ADRB1 Ser49Gly and Arg389Gly) and β2-adrenergic receptor (ADRB2 Gly16Arg and Glu27Gln) were determined by polymerase chain reaction with restriction fragment length polymorphism.

RESULTS

Patients homozygous for ADRB1 Arg389 had an approximately 4-fold greater reduction in DBPs than those homozygous for ADRB1 Gly389 (10.61 vs. 2.62 mm Hg, P = 0.013). The ADRB1 haplotype was also a significant predictor of response, as patients with the Gly49Arg389/Ser49Arg389 haplotype pair had a 5.7-fold greater reduction in DBPs than those homozygous for the Ser49Gly389 haplotype (16.11 vs. 2.83 mm Hg, P = 0.0055). An association was not found between ADRB2 polymorphism and carvedilol responsiveness in antihypertensive therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides the first evidence to support that ADRB1 polymorphisms play an important role in the DBPs response to carvedilol treatment in patients with essential hypertension.

Pharmacogenomics of heart failure

The combination of angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors and β-adrenergic receptor (βAR) blockers remains the essential component of heart failure (HF) pharmacotherapy. However, individual patient responses to these pharmacotherapies vary widely. The variability in response cannot be explained entirely by clinical characteristics, and genetic variation may play a role. The purpose of this chapter is to examine the current knowledge in the field of beta-blocker and ACE inhibitor pharmacogenetics in HF. β-blocker and ACE inhibitor pharmacogenetic studies performed in patients with HF were identified from the PubMed database from 1966 to July 2011. Thirty beta-blocker and 10 ACE inhibitor pharmacogenetic studies in patients with HF were identified.The ACE deletion variant was associated with greater survival benefit from ACE inhibitors and beta-blockers compared with the ACE insertion. Ser49 in the β1AR, the insertion in the α2CAR, and Gln41 in G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) kinase (GRK)-5 are associated with greater survival benefit from β-blockers, compared with Gly49, the deletion, and Leu41, respectively. However, many of these associations have not been validated. The HF pharmacogenetic literature is still in its very early stages, but there are promising candidate genetic variants that may identify which HF patients are most likely to benefit from beta-blockers and ACE inhibitors and patients that may require additional therapies.

A novel approach to drug development in heart failure: towards personalized medicine

Evidence-based treatment has succeeded in improving clinical outcomes in heart failure. Nevertheless, morbidity, mortality, and the economic burden associated with the syndrome remain unsatisfactorily high. Most landmark heart failure studies included broad study populations, and thus current recommendations dictate standardized, universal therapy. While most patients included in recent trials benefit from this background treatment, exceeding this already significant gain has proven to be a challenge. The early identification of responders and nonresponders to treatment could result in improved therapeutic effectiveness, while reduction of unnecessary exposure may limit harmful and unpleasant side effects. In this review, we examine the potential value of currently available information on differential responses to heart failure therapy-a first step toward personalized medicine in the management of heart failure.

Pharmacogenomics and cardiovascular disease

Variability in drug responsiveness is a sine qua non of modern therapeutics, and the contribution of genomic variation is increasingly recognized. Investigating the genomic basis for variable responses to cardiovascular therapies has been a model for pharmacogenomics in general and has established critical pathways and specific loci modulating therapeutic responses to commonly used drugs such as clopidogrel, warfarin, and statins. In addition, genomic approaches have defined mechanisms and genetic variants underlying important toxicities with these and other drugs. These findings have not only resulted in changes to the product labels but also have led to development of initial clinical guidelines that consider how to facilitate incorporating genetic information to the bedside. This review summarizes the state of knowledge in cardiovascular pharmacogenomics and considers how variants described to date might be deployed in clinical decision making.

Effect of race on left ventricular ejection fraction decline after initial improvement with beta blockers in patients with non-ischemic cardiomyopathy: a retrospective analysis

Background

Although beta blockers (BBs) are established therapy in heart failure, some patients whose left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) initially increases on BB therapy experience a subsequent LVEF decline. This study aimed to evaluate the proportion of patients with non-ischemic cardiomyopathy (NICM) whose LVEF declines while on BB therapy and determine important predictors of LVEF decline.

Methods

A retrospective analysis of 238 patients receiving a BB (carvedilol, metoprolol succinate, or tartrate), with an ejection fraction of ≤40 % and NICM, whose LVEF initially rose ≥5 % after 1 year of BB therapy, was conducted. Post-response LVEF decline ≥5 % to a final LVEF of ≤35 % was evaluated within 4 years of BB initiation.

Results

In our study, we had 52 Caucasians (22 %), 78 Hispanics (33 %), and 108 African Americans (45 %). Overall, 32 patients (13.44 %) had post-response LVEF decline. The nadir LVEF of patients with post-response LVEF decline was 25 % (interquartile range 20–27). Compared with others, Hispanics had lower nadir LVEF (22 %, p < 0.001). Important predictors of LVEF decline were Hispanic race (odds ratio (OR) 6.094, p < 0.001), New York Heart Association (NYHA) class (OR 2.287, p < 0.05), baseline LVEF (OR 1.075, p < 0.05), and age (OR 0.933, p < 0.001).

Conclusion

A significant proportion (13.44 %) of NICM patients with LVEF increase over 1 year of BB therapy experienced subsequent LVEF decline. Race, NYHA class, baseline LVEF, and age are important predictors of this decline.

Genetic prediction of heart failure incidence, prognosis and beta-blocker response

Heart failure (HF) is a widespread syndrome due to left ventricular dysfunction with high mortality, morbidity and health-care costs. Beta-blockers, together with diuretics and ACE-inhibitors or angiotensin receptor blockers, are a cornerstone of HF therapy, as they reduce mortality and morbidity. Nevertheless, their efficacy varies among patients, and genetics is likely to be one of the modifying factors. In this article, literature on the role of candidate genes on the development of HF, its prognosis and pharmacogenomics of β-blockers in patients with HF is reviewed. The available findings do not support, at the present time, a role for genetic tests in the treatment of HF. More large-scale genome-wide studies with adequate methodology and statistical analysis are required before considering genetic tailoring of HF therapy in patients with systolic HF.

A case for pharmacogenomics in management of cardiac arrhythmias

Disorders of the cardiac rhythm are quite prevalent in clinical practice. Though the variability in drug response between individuals has been extensively studied, this information has not been widely used in clinical practice. Rapid advances in the field of pharmacogenomics have provided us with crucial insights on inter-individual genetic variability and its impact on drug metabolism and action. Technologies for faster and cheaper genetic testing and even personal genome sequencing would enable clinicians to optimize prescription based on the genetic makeup of the individual, which would open up new avenues in the area of personalized medicine. We have systematically looked at literature evidence on pharmacogenomics markers for anti-arrhythmic agents from the OpenPGx consortium collection and reason the applicability of genetics in the management of arrhythmia. We also discuss potential issues that need to be resolved before personalized pharmacogenomics becomes a reality in regular clinical practice.

Pharmacogenetics in chronic heart failure: new developments and current challenges

The individual patient responses to chronic heart failure (HF) pharmacotherapies are highly variable. This variability cannot be entirely explained by clinical characteristics, and genetic variation may play a role. Therefore, this review will summarize the background pharmacogenetic literature for major HF pharmacotherapy classes (ie, β-blockers, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, digoxin, and loop diuretics), evaluate recent advances in the HF pharmacogenetic literature in the context of previous findings, and discuss the challenges and conclusions for HF pharmacogenetic data and its clinical application.

Genetic tailoring of pharmacotherapy in heart failure: optimize the old, while we wait for something new

BACKGROUND

The combination of angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors and beta-adrenergic receptor blockers remains the essential component of heart failure (HF) pharmacotherapy. However, individual patient responses to these pharmacotherapies vary widely. The variability in response cannot be explained entirely by clinical characteristics, and genetic variation may play a role. The purpose of this review is to examine our current state of understanding of beta-blocker and ACE inhibitor pharmacogenetics in HF.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Beta-blocker and ACE inhibitor pharmacogenetic studies performed in patients with HF were identified from the Pubmed database from 1966 to July 2011. Thirty beta-blocker and 10 ACE inhibitor pharmacogenetic studies in patients with HF were identified. The ACE deletion variant was associated with greater survival benefit from ACE inhibitors and beta-blockers compared with the ACE insertion. Ser49 in the beta-1 adrenergic receptor, the insertion in the alpha-2C adrenergic receptor, and Gln41 in G-protein-coupled receptor kinase 5 are associated with greater survival benefit from beta-blockers, compared with Gly49, the deletion, and Leu41, respectively. However, many of these associations have not been validated.

CONCLUSIONS

The HF pharmacogenetic literature is still in its very early stages, but there are promising candidate genetic variants that may identify which HF patients are most likely to benefit from beta-blockers and ACE inhibitors and patients that may require additional therapies.

Heart failure pharmacogenetics: past, present, and future

Heart failure is an increasingly common disease associated with significant morbidity and mortality in the aging population. Recent advances in heart failure pharmacotherapy have established several agents as beneficial to disease progression and outcomes. However, current consensus guideline-recommended pharmacotherapy may not represent an optimal treatment strategy in all heart failure patients. Specifically, individuals with genetic variation in regions central to mediation of beneficial response to standard heart failure agents may not receive optimal benefit from these drugs. Additionally, targeted approaches in phase 3 clinical trials that select patients for inclusion based on the genotype most likely to respond might advance the currently stalled drug development pipeline in heart failure. This article reviews the literature in heart failure pharmacogenetics to date, opportunities for discovery in recent and upcoming clinical trials, as well as future directions in this field.

A systematic review on pharmacogenetics in cardiovascular disease: is it ready for clinical application?

Pharmacogenetics is the search for heritable genetic polymorphisms that influence responses to drug therapy. The most important application of pharmacogenetics is to guide choosing agents with the greatest potential of efficacy and smallest risk of adverse drug reactions. Many studies focusing on drug-gene interactions have been published in recent years, some of which led to adaptation of FDA recommendations, indicating that we are on the verge of the clinical application of genetic information in drug therapy. This systematic review provides a comprehensive overview of the current knowledge on pharmacogenetics of all major drug classes currently used in the treatment of cardiovascular diseases.