Qβ Bacteriophage Photoinactivated by Methylene Blue Plus Light Involves Inactivation of Its Genomic RNA

Photodynamic inactivation of mammalian viruses and bacteriophages

Photodynamic inactivation (PDI) has been used to inactivate microorganisms through the use of photosensitizers. The inactivation of mammalian viruses and bacteriophages by photosensitization has been applied with success since the first decades of the last century. Due to the fact that mammalian viruses are known to pose a threat to public health and that bacteriophages are frequently used as models of mammalian viruses, it is important to know and understand the mechanisms and photodynamic procedures involved in their photoinactivation. The aim of this review is to (i) summarize the main approaches developed until now for the photodynamic inactivation of bacteriophages and mammalian viruses and, (ii) discuss and compare the present state of the art of mammalian viruses PDI with phage photoinactivation, with special focus on the most relevant mechanisms, molecular targets and factors affecting the viral inactivation process.

Methylene blue-mediated photodynamic inactivation as a novel disinfectant of enterovirus 71

OBJECTIVES

We tested whether methylene blue, an inexpensive and safe photosensitizer, is feasible for photodynamic inactivation of enterovirus 71 (EV71) in the environment.

METHODS

By escalating light doses and photosensitizer concentrations, photoinactivation of EV71 and other enteroviruses was examined in vitro. Viral transmission in the environment was simulated with a neonatal mouse model in vivo. Possible mechanisms were analysed with alterations of viral DNA and proteins after treatments.

RESULTS

Photodynamic inactivation of EV71 in suspensions occurred in a dose-dependent manner. The optimal condition for photoinactivating EV71 required a light dose of 200 J/cm(2) in the presence of methylene blue. This photodynamic condition was also able to inactivate other enteroviruses, including poliovirus 1 and coxsackieviruses A2, A3, A16 and B3. In an imitation environment, EV71 spread on a solid surface was inactivated by methylene blue-mediated photodynamic inactivation and prevented EV71 transmission to mice. Western blot and RT-PCR analysis indicated that both the viral proteins and the genome were disrupted after photodynamic inactivation.

CONCLUSIONS

Methylene blue-mediated photodynamic inactivation may provide a novel way to eliminate environmentally contaminated sources of EV71 to prevent infection.

Serendipitous findings while researching oxygen free radicals

This review is based on the honor of receiving the Discovery Award from the Society of Free Radical Biology and Medicine. The review is reflective and presents our thinking that led to experiments that yielded novel observations. Critical questioning of our understanding of oxygen free radicals in biomedical problems led us to use and develop more direct and extremely sensitive methods. This included nitrone free radical spin trapping and HPLC-electrochemical detection. This technology led to the pioneering use of salicylate to trap hydroxyl free radicals and show increased flux in ischemia/reperfused brain regions and also to first sensitively detect 8-hydroxyl-2-deoxyguanosine in oxidatively damaged DNA and help assess its role in cancer development. We demonstrated that methylene blue (MB) photoinduces formation of 8-hydroxyguanine in DNA and RNA and discovered that MB sensitively photoinactivates RNA viruses, including HIV and the West Nile virus. Studies in experimental stroke led us serendipitously to discover that alpha-phenyl-tert-butylnitrone (PBN) was neuroprotective if given after the stroke. This led to extensive commercial development of NXY-059, a PBN derivative, for the treatment of stroke. More recently we discovered that PBN nitrones have potent anti-cancer activity and are active in preventing hearing loss caused by acute acoustical trauma.

Methylene blue photoinactivation of RNA viruses

We present a review of the current status of the use of methylene blue (MB) photoinactivation of viruses starting with the first early observations up to its current use to inactivate HIV-1 in blood products. Basic mechanism of action studies conducted with model bacteriophages indicate that MB-photomediated viral RNA-protein crosslinkage is a primary lesion and that oxygen, specifically singlet oxygen, is very important also. Basic studies on the mechanism of action with HIV are lacking; however, we do show new data illustrating that viral reverse transcriptase inactivation per se cannot account for MB-mediated photoinactivation. We also show data illustrating that MB photomediates the inactivation of West Nile Virus, a flavivirus, which poses a significant new threat to the continental US. MB photoinactivation of viruses show significant promise because the technology not only offers significant potency but the history of safe MB use in human therapy makes it attractive also.

Photosensitized inactivation of T7 phage as surrogate of non-enveloped DNA viruses: efficiency and mechanism of action

We investigated the efficiency and the mechanism of action of a tetraphenyl porphyrin derivative in its photoreaction with T7 phage as surrogate of non-enveloped DNA viruses. TPFP was able to sensitize the photoinactivation of T7 phage in spite of the lack of its binding to the nucleoprotein complex. The efficiency of TPFP photosensitization was limited by the aggregation and by the photobleaching of porphyrin molecules. Addition of sodium azide or 1,3-dimethyl-2-thiourea (DMTU) to the reaction mixture moderated T7 inactivation, however, neither of them inhibited T7 inactivation completely. This result suggests that both Type I and Type II reaction play a role in the virus inactivation. Optical melting studies revealed structural changes in the protein part but not in the DNA of the photochemically treated nucleoprotein complex. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) also failed to demonstrate any DNA damage. Circular dichroism (CD) spectra of photosensitized nucleoprotein complex indicated changes in the secondary structure of both the DNA and proteins. We suggest that damages in the protein capsid and/or loosening of protein-DNA interaction can be responsible for the photodynamic inactivation of T7 phage. The alterations in DNA secondary structure might be the result of photochemical damage in phage capsid proteins.

Photoinduced inactivation of T7 phage sensitized by symmetrically and asymmetrically substituted tetraphenyl porphyrin: comparison of efficiency and mechanism of action

We investigated the efficiency and the mechanism of action of two--one symmetrically and one asymmetrically substituted--glycoconjugated tetraphenyl porphyrins in their photoreaction with T7 phage as a model of nucleoprotein (NP) complexes. A correlation was found between the dark inactivation of T7 and the binding of porphyrins determined by fluorescence spectroscopy. Both types of porphyrin sensitized the photoinactivation of T7, but the slopes of inactivation kinetics were markedly different. There was no correlation between the dark binding and the photosensitizing efficacy of the two derivatives. Inactivation was moderated by 1,3-diphenylisobenzofuran and 1,3-dimethyl-2-thiourea; however, neither of them inhibited T7 inactivation completely. This result suggests that both Type-I and Type-II reactions play a role in the virus inactivation. Optical melting studies revealed structural changes in the protein part but not in the DNA of the photochemically treated NP complex. Polymerase chain reaction analysis of a 555 bp segment of gene 1 and a 3826 bp segment of genes 3 and 4 failed to demonstrate any DNA damage.