On the oscillatory potentials of the human electroretinogram in light and dark adaptation. 3. Thresholds and relation to stimulus intensity on adaptation to background light

Altered central vision and amacrine cells dysfunction as marker of hypodopaminergic activity in treated patients with schizophrenia

BACKGROUND

Retinal dysfunction is widely documented in schizophrenia using flash (fERG) and pattern electroretinograms (PERG), but the role of dopamine transmission has seldom been explored.

METHODS

We explored the role of dopamine transmission by evaluating the spatial location of retinal anomalies using multifocal ERG (mfERG) in photopic condition and the oscillatory potentials (OPs) extracted from fERG measured in scotopic condition in 29 patients with schizophrenia and 29 healthy controls.

RESULTS

With the mfERG, our main results revealed reduced amplitudes in the center of the retina: P1 (p < .005) and N2 amplitudes (p < .01) in the <2° region, N1 (p < .0005) and P1 amplitudes (p < .001) in the 2-5° region and P1 amplitude (p < .05) in the 5-10° region. For OPs, our results showed a decrease in the O1 (p < .005), O2 (p < .005), O3 (p < .05) and overall O1, O2, O3 index amplitudes (p < .005) in patients with schizophrenia.

CONCLUSIONS

Both the central location of retinal dysfunctions of the mfERG and OPs results could reflect a hypodopaminergic effect in patients with schizophrenia. In future studies, OPs should be considered as a measure to evaluate the hypodopaminergy in patients.

The response of the neuronal adaptive system to background illumination and readaptation to dark in the immature retina

PURPOSE

Developmental characteristics of the neuronal adaptive system of the retina, focusing on background light (BGL) adaptation and readaptation functions, were studied by measuring the oscillatory response (SOP) of the electroretinogram (ERG).

METHODS

Digitally filtered and conventional ERGs were simultaneously recorded. Rats aged 15 and 17 days were studied during exposure to BGLs of two mesopic intensities and during readaptation to dark.

RESULTS

Results were compared to adult rats. In 'low mesopic' BGL SOP instantly dropped significantly to about half of its dark-adapted (DA) value contrary to mature rats, in which the SOP significantly increased. In 'high mesopic' BGL SOP decreased to about 20% and 30% of DA values in immature and adult rats, respectively. The process of recovery of SOP in darkness lacked the transient enhancement immediately as BGL was turned off, characteristic of adult rats. There were no major age differences in adaptive behaviour of a-wave. In young rats, recovery of b-wave was relatively slower.

CONCLUSIONS

Properties of BGL adaptation and readaptation functions of the neuronal adaptive system in baby retina differed compared to the adult one by being less forceful and more restrained. Handling of mesopic illumination and recovery in the dark was immature. Development of these functions of the neuronal adaptive system progresses postnatally and lags behind that of the photoreceptor response and seems to be delayed also compared to that of the bipolar response.

Neuronal adaptation in the human retina: a study of the single oscillatory response in dark adaptation and mesopic background illumination

PURPOSE

The single oscillatory response in complete dark adaptation (DA) and the effect of mesopic illumination were studied in order to investigate the behaviour of the neuronal adaptation system as reflected in the oscillatory potentials (OPs) of the electroretinogram (ERG).

METHODS

The rapid oscillatory and slow components (a- and b-waves) of single ERGs were simultaneously recorded in nine healthy, young subjects in response to first flash after both DA of 45 mins and light adaptation to a steady background light (BGL) of low mesopic intensity.

RESULTS

Two low-amplitude oscillatory peaks were present in the single response to the first flash recorded in DA. There was no increase in the summed amplitudes of the OPs (SOP) when recorded in the single response to the first flash in mesopic BGL. However, the morphology of the oscillatory response altered. The first OP was reduced and a third oscillatory peak appeared.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that early, scotopically related OPs may indeed be activated in the single response to the first flash in DA (i.e. without using conditioning flashes). Secondly, on its own, adaptation to mesopic BGL does not seem to trigger enhancement of the overall oscillatory response. The altered single oscillatory response to the first flash apparent in the mesopic BGL comprises a third cone-associated OP and seems to reflect a reorganization of the retinal microcircuitry from a predominantly rod-activated system to one of mixed rod/cone neuronal activity in the inner part of the retina at the level at which individual OPs have their respective origins.

Dopaminergic modulation and rod contribution in the generation of oscillatory potentials in the tiger salamander retina

The roles of rod and cone input and of dopamine in the generation of oscillatory potentials were studied in tiger salamander retina. Under scotopic conditions, oscillations were elicited with a green, but not a red stimulus. With mesopic background illumination, both stimuli caused oscillations. Addition of quinpirole to a mesopic retina eliminated oscillations while SKF-38393 had no effect. Similarly, addition of sulpiride to a light-adapted retina elicited oscillatory activity, but SCH 22390 had no effect. These results suggest that oscillatory potentials are elicited through activation of the rod pathway and are modulated by dopamine through D2-receptors.

Background light adaptation of the retinal neuronal adaptive system. I. Effect of background light intensity

The behaviour of the neuronal adaptive retinal mechanisms to environmental light exposures was studied by measuring the oscillatory potentials (OPs) of the electroretinogram. Dark adapted rats were exposed to four levels of background light (BG), starting at a 'low scotopic' level of 1.43x 10(6) cd/m2, increased by steps of two log units, through 'high scotopic' -, 'low mesopic' - and finally the 'high mesopic' BG of 1.43x 10(0) cd/m2. The summed oscillatory response significantly increased as the BG intensity was raised, except at the 'high mesopic' level. The amplitudes of the a- and b-waves reduced as the BG light increased above the 'high scotopic' level. Each OP responded individually to the different BGs. O1 and O2, significantly enhanced at the 'low scotopic' BG. The amplitudes of the three later OPs increased significantly at the 'low mesopic' BG. The adaptational behaviour of the retinal oscillatory response to BG illumination was different to that of the a- and b- waves. The results indicate that the adaptational neuronal system, as reflected by the OPs, seems to be relatively robust and is separate from the slower photochemical adaptive process in the distal retina. The tentative corollary suggests the oscillatory system to play a vision-preserving role, possibly as an alert against undue depletion of the slowly regenerating visual pigment. The enhancement of the oscillatory response at the 'mesopic' illumination levels indicate both scotopic and photopic processes to contribute to neuronal adaptive activity of the retina.

The electroretinogram recorded at the onset of dark-adaptation: understanding the origin of the scotopic oscillatory potentials

The purpose of this study was to examine the origin of the oscillatory potentials (OPs) recorded at the onset of dark-adaptation. Our results show that following pre-exposure of the retina to progressively brighter photopic backgrounds there is a complete abolition of OP4 and approximately 50% of OP3, while OP2 is not affected in responses evoked to dim flashes of white light and recorded at the onset of dark-adaptation. These results bring further support to the claim that the short latency OP2 is cone-mediated while the OP3 and OP4 would have a significant rod contribution. However, a more complex picture of OP genesis arises when flicker and response to brighter white light flashes, also obtained within the first minute of dark-adaptation are considered. The latter would suggest that our understanding of the origin of the OPs cannot be exclusively based on which of the two class of photoreceptors is preferentially stimulated at the time the response is recorded.

Oscillatory potentials of the electroretinogram in hypertensive patients with different antihypertensive treatment

Oscillatory potentials of the electroretinogram are useful to confirm the diagnosis of essential hypertension. Thirty-five hypertensive patients underwent primary antihypertensive therapy with four different treatments. Oscillatory potentials were recorded before the treatment and after 12 months. The oscillatory response increased in a statistically significant manner in the angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor group. This is probably caused by the vasodilatation mechanism, which increases the retinal blood flow.

Oscillatory potentials in the retina: what do they reveal

This chapter is an overview of current knowledge on the oscillatory potentials (OPs) of the retina. The first section describes the characteristics of the OPs. The basic, adaptational, pharmacological and developmental characteristics of the OPs are different from the a- and b-waves, the major components of the electroretinogram (ERG). The OPs are most easily recorded in mesopic adaptational conditions and reflect rapid changes of adaptation. They represent photopic and scotopic processes, probably an interaction between cone and rod activity in the retina. The OPs are sensitive to disruption of inhibitory (dopamine, GABA-, and glycine-mediated) neuronal pathways and are not selectively affected by excitatory amino acids. The earlier OPs are associated with the on-components and the late OPs with the off-components in response to a brief stimulus of light. The postnatal appearance of the first oscillatory activity is preceded by the a- and b-waves. The earlier OPs appear postnatally prior to, and mature differently from, the later ones. The second section deals with present views on the origin of the OPs. These views are developed from experimental studies with the vertebrate retina including the primate retina and clinical studies. Findings favor the conclusion that the OPs reflect neuronal synaptic activity in inhibitory feedback pathways initiated by the amacrines in the inner retina. The bipolar (or the interplexiform) cells are the probable generators of the OPs. Dopaminergic neurons, probably amacrines (or interplexiform cells), are involved in the generation of the OPs. The earlier OPs are generated in neurons related to the on-pathway of the retina and the later ones to the off-channel system. Peptidergic neurons may be indirectly involved as modulators. The individual OPs seem to represent the activation of several retinal generators. The earlier OPs are more dependent on an intact rod function and the later ones on an intact cone system. Thus, the OPs are good indicators of neuronal adaptive mechanisms in the retina and are probably the only post-synaptic neuronal components that can be recorded in the ERG except when structured stimuli are used. The last section describes the usefulness of the oscillatory response as an instrument to study the postnatal development of neuronal adaptation of the retina. In this section clinical examples of of the sensitivity of the OPs for revealing early disturbance in neuronal function in different retinal diseases such as pediatric, vascular and degenerative retinopathies are also given.

Evidence for an intensity-coding oscillatory potential in the human electroretinogram

Electroretinograms (ERGs) were obtained from normal subjects to various combinations of stimulus and background intensities to examine if, as shown in rabbits, one of the oscillatory potentials (OP2) could be identified as reflecting the absolute intensity of the stimulus (i.e. the intensity irrespective of the state of retinal adaptation). The results presented clearly demonstrate that the peak time and the amplitude of OP2 are highly correlated with the absolute intensity of the stimulus. Linear regression analysis (for light- and dark-adapted data combined) yields a correlation coefficient of r = 0.98 for the peak time of OP2 and r = 0.88 for the amplitude of OP2. The latter equations were obtained from ERGs where the brightest flashes were delivered in light-adaptation and the dimmest in dark-adaptation. This is the first demonstration of a high correlation between the intensity of the stimulus and the amplitude and peak time of a human ERG component which is shown to be linear irrespective of the state of retinal adaptation.

Effects of light adaptation on the response characteristics of human oscillatory potentials

We have examined the response characteristics of the oscillatory potentials (OPs) of the human electroretinogram (ERG) obtained to ganzfeld flash stimuli presented against adapting fields. First, we determined the extent to which the OPs obtained to high luminance flashes change during the course of light adaptation to a cone-isolating adapting field. Regardless of the number of OP wavelets, the last OP wavelet increased in amplitude and decreased in implicit time to a greater extent than did the earlier wavelet(s). In addition, we examined the role of both flash and adapting field luminance in determining the wave form of the OPs. For each adapting field luminance that was tested, the number of OP wavelets increased as flash luminance increased, primarily resulting from the splitting of the last OP into 2 distinct wavelets. While the number of OP wavelets generally decreased as adapting field luminance increased, the amplitude of the last OP became larger. These functional distinctions between the last and the earlier wavelets are consistent with their representing the activity of different retinal generators.

The influence of adaptation on the oscillatory potentials of the human electroretinogram

The influence of adaptation on the oscillatory potentials of the human electroretinogram was studied in the domains of frequency and time. The amplitude of OP1 to OP4, the summed amplitude of OP1 to OP4, as well as the area, decreased from dark adaptation to light adaptation. With increasing intensities of background illumination, they increased slightly and appeared to decrease with the strongest background illumination. The implicit time of oscillatory potentials 3 and 4 increased with stronger background illumination and decreased with the strongest background illumination. The results of the dominant frequency and the total power of the OPs correspond to the results in the time domain. The dominant power decreased from dark adaptation into light adaptation and did not show any systematic changes with increasing intensity of background illumination.

Oscillatory potentials in early diabetic retinopathy

To study the oscillatory potentials in early diabetic retinopathy the authors developed a new power measurement based on the fast Fourier transform. Three groups totalling 46 patients were examined, varying from nonvisible to preproliferative diabetic retinopathy. The oscillatory potentials expressed in microwatts were measured under scotopic and photopic conditions. The data of the three groups are compared with those of a group of 22 normal individuals. The oscillatory potential power measurement appears to be a reliable method in detecting diabetic retinopathy at an early stage.

Measuring oscillatory potentials: Fourier analysis

Studying the oscillatory potentials in diabetic retinopathy, the authors experienced several problems interpreting results of digital filtering. The main problem was the separation of the first potential from the a-wave, since their frequencies are within the same range. To improve the procedure of measuring implicit times and of calculating amplitudes, the filtering was started with a finite impulse response filter and followed by a fast Fourier transform. The power of the oscillatory potential was calculated by determining the dominant frequency in the Fourier transformed response and expressed in microwatts. A group of normal subjects was compared with a group of early diabetic retinopathy patients. It appears that even in pathological circumstances a quantitative expression of the oscillatory potential is possible.

Basic research and clinical aspects of the oscillatory potentials of the electroretinogram

This paper reviews current knowledge concerning the oscillatory potentials (OPs) of the electroretinogram (ERG). The first section describes the basic characteristics of the OPs primarily studied in healthy subjects. The behavior of the OPs is different from the a- and b-waves, indicating separate mechanisms for generation of the OPs compared with the major components of the ERG. The second section deals with the present view of the origin of the OPs collected from experimental studies of the vertebrate retina, including the primate. Findings favor the conclusion that the bipolar (or interplexiform) cells are the probable generators of the OPs. The third section gives clinical examples of the sensitivity of OPs to early disturbances of retinal function in different eye diseases.

Oscillatory potentials. History, techniques and potential use in the evaluation of disturbances of retinal circulation

The oscillatory potentials seem to reflect severe disturbances in the retinal (and perhaps choroidal) circulation. In some cases of diabetic retinopathy with severe microangiopathy, the oscillatory potentials may be selectively reduced or extinguished while the amplitude of the a- and b-waves of the ERG remains normal. A correlation appears to exist between severely reduced oscillatory potentials and a circulatory deficiency in the retina. This selective reduction of the oscillatory potentials during advancing retinopathy is considered to be indirect evidence that they are generated independently from the mechanism producing the primary components (the a- and b-waves). The usefulness of the oscillatory potentials in the prognosis of retinal disease, particularly in diabetic retinopathy, is reviewed. The historical background, the techniques and instrumentation necessary to produce and record them, the experimental data available on the site of their origin, the clinical significance to date and the experimental efforts in our laboratory are summarized.

Stimulus alternation and fast retinal potentials: photopic anc scotopic contributions

Human retinal oscillatory potentials in response to an alternating checker-board pattern stimulus were studied in two subjects over an intensity range of 7.5 log units. Under scotopic conditions, two wavelets (S1 and S2) could be recorded. At an intensity of 1.9 photopic log Td four high frequency oscillations (O1--O4) were noticed and a discontinuity was observed in the corresponding luminance curve of the b-wave together with a sudden decrease in the magnitude of the standard deviation of the amplitude measures. The oscillations were noticed only on the ascending slope of the b-wave. With increasing stimulus intensity, their latency decreased at a slower rate than that of the b-wave and their number decreased. Each wavelet had an amplitude maximum at a certain stimulus intensity level. It was suggested that O1--O4 were generated by the activation of the photopic system and that S1 and S2 were of scotopic origin.