Platelet responses to agonists in a cohort of highly characterised platelet donors are consistent over time

Factors that modulate platelet reactivity as measured by 5 assay platforms in 3429 individuals

Background

Assessment of platelet function is key in diagnosing bleeding disorders and evaluating antiplatelet drug efficacy. However, there is a prevailing "one-size-fits-all" approach in the interpretation of measures of platelet reactivity, with arbitrary cutoffs often derived from healthy volunteer responses.

Objectives

Our aim was to compare well-used platelet reactivity assays.

Methods

Blood and platelet-rich plasma obtained from the Framingham Heart Study (N = 3429) were assayed using a range of agonists in 5 platelet assays: light transmission aggregometry, Optimul aggregometry, Multiplate impedance aggregometry (Roche Diagnostics), Total Thrombus-Formation Analysis System, and flow cytometry. Using linear mixed-effect models, we determined the contribution of preanalytical and technical factors that modulated platelet reactivity traits.

Results

A strong intra-assay correlation of platelet traits was seen in all assays, particularly Multiplate velocity (r = 0.740; ristocetin vs arachidonic acid). In contrast, only moderate interassay correlations were observed (r = 0.375; adenosine diphosphate Optimul Emax vs light transmission aggregometry large area under the curve). As expected, antiplatelet drugs strongly reduced platelet responses, with aspirin use primarily targeting arachidonic acid-induced aggregation, and explained substantial variance (β = -1.735; P = 4.59 × 10-780; variance proportion = 46.2%) and P2Y12 antagonists blocking adenosine diphosphate responses (β = -1.612; P = 6.75 × 10-27; variance proportion = 2.1%). Notably, female sex and older age were associated with enhanced platelet reactivity. Fasting status and deviations from standard venipuncture practices did not alter platelet reactivity significantly. Finally, the agonist batch, phlebotomist, and assay technician (more so for assays that require additional sample manipulation) had a moderate to large effect on measured platelet reactivity.

Conclusion

Caution must be exercised when extrapolating findings between assays, and the use of standard ranges must be medication-specific and sex-specific at a minimum. Researchers should also consider preanalytical and technical variables when designing experiments and interpreting platelet reactivity measures.

Heterogeneity of platelets and their responses

There has been increasing recognition of heterogeneity in blood platelets and their responses, particularly in recent years, where next-generation technologies and advanced bioinformatic tools that interrogate "big data" have enabled large-scale studies of RNA and protein expression across a growing list of disease states. However, pioneering platelet biologists and clinicians were already hypothesizing upon and investigating heterogeneity in platelet (and megakaryocyte) activity and platelet metabolism and aggregation over half a century ago. Building on their foundational hypotheses, in particular Professor Marian A. Packham's pioneering work and a State of the Art lecture in her memoriam at the 2023 International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis Congress by Anandi Krishnan, this review outlines the key features that contribute to the heterogeneity of platelets between and within individuals. Starting with important epidemiologic factors, we move stepwise through successively smaller scales down to heterogeneity revealed by single-cell technologies in health and disease. We hope that this overview will urge future scientific and clinical studies to recognize and account for heterogeneity of platelets and aim to apply methods that capture that heterogeneity. Finally, we summarize other exciting new data presented on this topic at the 2023 International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis Congress.

G protein-coupled receptor kinase 5 regulates thrombin signaling in platelets via PAR-1

The interindividual variation in the functional response of platelets to activation by agonists is heritable. Genome-wide association studies (GWASs) of quantitative measures of platelet function have identified fewer than 20 distinctly associated variants, some with unknown mechanisms. Here, we report GWASs of pathway-specific functional responses to agonism by adenosine 5'-diphosphate, a glycoprotein VI-specific collagen mimetic, and thrombin receptor-agonist peptides, each specific to 1 of the G protein-coupled receptors PAR-1 and PAR-4, in subsets of 1562 individuals. We identified an association (P = 2.75 × 10-40) between a common intronic variant, rs10886430, in the G protein-coupled receptor kinase 5 gene (GRK5) and the sensitivity of platelets to activate through PAR-1. The variant resides in a megakaryocyte-specific enhancer that is bound by the transcription factors GATA1 and MEIS1. The minor allele (G) is associated with fewer GRK5 transcripts in platelets and the greater sensitivity of platelets to activate through PAR-1. We show that thrombin-mediated activation of human platelets causes binding of GRK5 to PAR-1 and that deletion of the mouse homolog Grk5 enhances thrombin-induced platelet activation sensitivity and increases platelet accumulation at the site of vascular injury. This corroborates evidence that the human G allele of rs10886430 is associated with a greater risk for cardiovascular disease. In summary, by combining the results of pathway-specific GWASs and expression quantitative trait locus studies in humans with the results from platelet function studies in Grk5-/- mice, we obtain evidence that GRK5 regulates the human platelet response to thrombin via the PAR-1 pathway.

Neonatal Sepsis and Hemostasis

Neonatal sepsis is considered critical for a significant increase in neonatal morbidity and mortality among hospitalized neonates. Neonatal sepsis, in most cases, coexists with coagulopathy, which can prove to be life-threatening. Complex molecular and cellular systems are involved in the cross-talk between inflammation and hemostasis during sepsis. Disturbances in the regulating systems of the vascular endothelium, and platelet–endothelial and platelet–neutrophil interactions play a pivotal role in both inflammation and coagulation. This complex process is poorly understood in neonates. In addition to the developmental maturation of hemostasis and the immune response in neonatal sepsis, a cellular model of hemostasis during sepsis should be taken into account. This review focused on the molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying inflammation and hemostasis during neonatal sepsis, taking the developmental immune response and developmental hemostasis into account in order to provide future diagnostic approaches to be applied in everyday clinical settings. Regarding the diagnostic modalities, we briefly provide the limitations of the currently used conventional coagulation assays, focusing on viscoelastic tests and platelet flow cytometry.

Multiparameter phenotyping of platelet reactivity for stratification of human cohorts

Accurate and comprehensive assessment of platelet function across cohorts of donors may be key to understanding the risk of thrombotic events associated with cardiovascular disease, and, hence, to help personalize the application of antiplatelet drugs. However, platelet function tests can be difficult to perform and analyze; they also can be unreliable or uninformative and poorly standardized across studies. The Platelet Phenomic Analysis (PPAnalysis) assay and associated open-source software platform were developed in response to these challenges. PPAnalysis utilizes preprepared freeze-dried microtiter plates to provide a detailed characterization of platelet function. The automated analysis of the high-dimensional data enables the identification of subpopulations of donors with distinct platelet function phenotypes. Using this approach, we identified that the sensitivity of a donor's platelets to an agonist and their capacity to generate a functional response are distinct independent metrics of platelet reactivity. Hierarchical clustering of these metrics identified 6 subgroups with distinct platelet phenotypes within healthy cohorts, indicating that platelet reactivity does not fit into the traditional simple categories of "high" and "low" responders. These platelet phenotypes were found to exist in 2 independent cohorts of healthy donors and were stable on recall. PPAnalysis is a powerful tool for stratification of cohorts on the basis of platelet reactivity that will enable investigation of the causes and consequences of differences in platelet function and drive progress toward precision medicine.

Current challenges in platelet transfusion

The supply of platelets for transfusion is a logistical challenge due to the physiology of platelets and current measures of transfusion performance dictating storage at 22°C and a short product shelf-life (<7 days). Demand for platelets has increased in recent years and changes in the demographics of the population may enhance this further. Many studies have been conducted to understand what the optimal dose and trigger for transfusion should be, mainly in hematology patients who are the largest cohort that receive platelets, mostly to prevent bleeding. Emerging data suggests that for bleeding patients, where immediate hemostasis is a key consideration, the current standard product may not be optimal. Alternative platelet preparation methods/storage options that may improve the hemostatic properties of platelets are under active development. In parallel with research into alternative platelet products that might enhance hemostasis, better measures for assessing bleeding risk and platelet efficacy are needed.

Current Understanding of the Relationship between Blood Donor Variability and Blood Component Quality

While differences among donors has long challenged meeting quality standards for the production of blood components for transfusion, only recently has the molecular basis for many of these differences become understood. This review article will examine our current understanding of the molecular differences that impact the quality of red blood cells (RBC), platelets, and plasma components. Factors affecting RBC quality include cytoskeletal elements and membrane proteins associated with the oxidative response as well as known enzyme polymorphisms and hemoglobin variants. Donor age and health status may also be important. Platelet quality is impacted by variables that are less well understood, but that include platelet storage sensitive metabolic parameters, responsiveness to agonists accumulating in storage containers and factors affecting the maintenance of pH. An increased understanding of these variables can be used to improve the quality of blood components for transfusion by using donor management algorithms based on a donors individual molecular and genetic profile.

Flow cytometry for near-patient testing in premature neonates reveals variation in platelet function: a novel approach to guide platelet transfusion

BACKGROUND

Neonatal haemorrhaging is often co-observed with thrombocytopenia; however, no evidence of a causal relationship with low platelet count has been reported. Regardless, the administration of a platelet transfusion is often based upon this parameter. Accurate measurement of platelet function in small volumes of adult blood samples by flow cytometry is well established and we propose that the use of the same technology could provide complementary information to guide the administration of platelet transfusions in premature neonates.

METHODS

In 28 neonates born at 27-41 weeks gestation, platelet function after stimulation agonists was measured using fibrinogen binding and P-selectin expression (a marker of degranulation).

RESULTS

Platelets of neonates with gestation of ≤36 weeks (n = 20) showed reduced fibrinogen binding and degranulation with ADP, and reduced degranulation with CRP-XL. Degranulation Scores of 7837 ± 5548, 22,408 ± 5301 and 53,131 ± 12,102 (mean ± SEM) identified significant differences between three groups: <29, 29-36 and >36 weeks gestation). Fibrinogen binding and degranulation responses to ADP were significantly reduced in suspected septic neonates (n = 6) and the Fibrinogen Binding scores clearly separated the septic and healthy group (88.2 ± 10.3 vs 38.6 ± 12.2, P = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Flow cytometric measurement of platelet function identified clinically different neonatal groups and may eventually contribute to assessment of neonates requiring platelet transfusion.

High-throughput elucidation of thrombus formation reveals sources of platelet function variability

In combination with microspotting, whole-blood microfluidics can provide high-throughput information on multiple platelet functions in thrombus formation. Based on assessment of the inter- and intra-subject variability in parameters of microspot-based thrombus formation, we aimed to determine the platelet factors contributing to this variation. Blood samples from 94 genotyped healthy subjects were analyzed for conventional platelet phenotyping: i.e. hematologic parameters, platelet glycoprotein (GP) expression levels and activation markers (24 parameters). Furthermore, platelets were activated by ADP, CRP-XL or TRAP. Parallel samples were investigated for whole-blood thrombus formation (6 microspots, providing 48 parameters of adhesion, aggregation and activation). Microspots triggered platelet activation through GP Ib-V-IX, GPVI, CLEC-2 and integrins. For most thrombus parameters, inter-subject variation was 2-4 times higher than the intra-subject variation. Principal component analyses indicated coherence between the majority of parameters for the GPVI-dependent microspots, partly linked to hematologic parameters, and glycoprotein expression levels. Prediction models identified parameters per microspot that were linked to variation in agonist-induced α_IIbβ₃ activation and secretion. Common sequence variation of GP6 and FCER1G, associated with GPVI-induced α_IIbβ₃ activation and secretion, affected parameters of GPVI-and CLEC-2-dependent thrombus formation. Subsequent analysis of blood samples from patients with Glanzmann thrombasthenia or storage pool disease revealed thrombus signatures of aggregation-dependent parameters that were subject-dependent, but not linked to GPVI activity. Taken together, this high-throughput elucidation of thrombus formation revealed patterns of inter-subject differences in platelet function, which were partly related to GPVI-induced activation and common genetic variance linked to GPVI, but also included a distinct platelet aggregation component.

Platelet proteomics: from discovery to diagnosis

INTRODUCTION

Platelets are the smallest cells within the circulating blood with key roles in physiological hemostasis and pathological thrombosis regulated by the onset of activating/inhibiting processes via receptor responses and signaling cascades. Areas covered: Proteomics as well as genomic approaches have been fundamental in identifying and quantifying potential targets for future diagnostic strategies in the prevention of bleeding and thrombosis, and uncovering the complexity of platelet functions in health and disease. In this article, we provide a critical overview on current functional tests used in diagnostics and the future perspectives for platelet proteomics in clinical applications. Expert commentary: Proteomics represents a valuable tool for the identification of patients with diverse platelet associated defects. In-depth validation of identified biomarkers, e.g. receptors, signaling proteins, post-translational modifications, in large cohorts is decisive for translation into routine clinical diagnostics.

ADP Platelet Hyperreactivity Predicts Cardiovascular Disease in the FHS (Framingham Heart Study)

BACKGROUND

Platelet function is associated with adverse events in patients with cardiovascular disease (CVD).

METHODS AND RESULTS

We examined associations of baseline platelet function with incident CVD events in the community-based FHS (Framingham Heart Study). Participants free of prevalent CVD and without recent aspirin treatment with available data in the Framingham Offspring cohort (1991-1995) and Omni cohort (1994-1998) were included. Platelet function was measured with light transmission aggregometry using collagen (1.9 μg/mL), ADP (0.05-15 μmol/L), and epinephrine (0.01-15 μmol/L). We used proportional hazards models to analyze incident outcomes (myocardial infarction/stroke, CVD, and CVD mortality) with respect to platelet measures. The study sample included 2831 participants (average age, 54.3 years; 57% women). During follow-up (median, 20.4 years), we observed 191 composite incident myocardial infarction or stroke events, 432 incident CVD cases, and 117 CVD deaths. Hyperreactivity to ADP and platelet aggregation at ADP concentration of 1.0 μmol/L were significantly associated with incident myocardial infarction/stroke in a multivariable model (hazard ratio, 1.68 [95% confidence interval, 1.13-2.50] [P=0.011] for hyperreactivity across ADP doses; and hazard ratio, 1.16 [95% confidence interval, 1.02-1.33] [P=0.029] for highest quartile of ADP response at 1.0 μmol/L versus others). No association was observed for collagen lag time or any epinephrine measures with incident myocardial infarction or stroke.

CONCLUSIONS

Intrinsic hyperreactivity to low-dose ADP in our community-based sample, who were free of CVD and any antiplatelet therapy, is associated with future arterial thrombosis during a 20-year follow-up. These findings reinforce ADP activation inhibition as a critical treatment paradigm and encourage further study of ADP inhibitor-refractive populations.

The effect of variation in donor platelet function on transfusion outcome: a semirandomized controlled trial

The effect of variation in platelet function in platelet donors on patient outcome following platelet transfusion is unknown. This trial assessed the hypothesis that platelets collected from donors with highly responsive platelets to agonists in vitro assessed by flow cytometry (high-responder donors) are cleared more quickly from the circulation than those from low-responder donors, resulting in lower platelet count increments following transfusion. This parallel group, semirandomized double-blinded trial was conducted in a single center in the United Kingdom. Eligible patients were those 16 or older with thrombocytopenia secondary to bone marrow failure, requiring prophylactic platelet transfusion. Patients were randomly assigned to receive a platelet donation from a high- or low-responder donor when both were available, or when only 1 type of platelet was available, patients received that. Participants, investigators, and those assessing outcomes were masked to group assignment. The primary end point was the platelet count increment 10 to 90 minutes following transfusion. Analysis was by intention to treat. Fifty-one patients were assigned to receive platelets from low-responder donors, and 49 from high-responder donors (47 of which were randomized and 53 nonrandomized). There was no significant difference in platelet count increment 10 to 90 minutes following transfusion in patients receiving platelets from high-responder (mean, 21.0 × 10⁹/L; 95% confidence interval [CI], 4.9-37.2) or low-responder (mean, 23.3 × 10⁹/L; 95% CI, 7.8-38.9) donors (mean difference, 2.3; 95% CI, -1.1 to 5.7; P = .18). These results support the current policy of not selecting platelet donors on the basis of platelet function for prophylactic platelet transfusion.