Localization of visually evoked cortical activity in humans

Is human face recognition lateralized to the right hemisphere due to neural competition with left-lateralized visual word recognition? A critical review

The right hemispheric lateralization of face recognition, which is well documented and appears to be specific to the human species, remains a scientific mystery. According to a long-standing view, the evolution of language, which is typically substantiated in the left hemisphere, competes with the cortical space in that hemisphere available for visuospatial processes, including face recognition. Over the last decade, a specific hypothesis derived from this view according to which neural competition in the left ventral occipito-temporal cortex with selective representations of letter strings causes right hemispheric lateralization of face recognition, has generated considerable interest and research in the scientific community. Here, a systematic review of studies performed in various populations (infants, children, literate and illiterate adults, left-handed adults) and methodologies (behavior, lesion studies, (intra)electroencephalography, neuroimaging) offers little if any support for this reading lateralized neural competition hypothesis. Specifically, right-lateralized face-selective neural activity already emerges at a few months of age, well before reading acquisition. Moreover, consistent evidence of face recognition performance and its right hemispheric lateralization being modulated by literacy level during development or at adulthood is lacking. Given the absence of solid alternative hypotheses and the key role of neural competition in the sensory-motor cortices for selectivity of representations, learning, and plasticity, a revised language-related neural competition hypothesis for the right hemispheric lateralization of face recognition should be further explored in future research, albeit with substantial conceptual clarification and advances in methodological rigor.

The inferior occipital gyrus is a major cortical source of the face-evoked N170: Evidence from simultaneous scalp and intracerebral human recordings

The sudden onset of a face image leads to a prominent face-selective response in human scalp electroencephalographic (EEG) recordings, peaking 170 ms after stimulus onset at occipito-temporal (OT) scalp sites: the N170 (or M170 in magnetoencephalography). According to a widely held view, the main cortical source of the N170 lies in the fusiform gyrus (FG), whereas the posteriorly located inferior occipital gyrus (IOG) would rather generate earlier face-selective responses. Here, we report neural responses to upright and inverted faces recorded in a unique patient using multicontact intracerebral electrodes implanted in the right IOG and in the OT sulcus above the right lateral FG (LFG). Simultaneous EEG recordings on the scalp identified the N170 over the right OT scalp region. The latency and amplitude of this scalp N170 were correlated at the single-trial level with the N170 recorded in the lateral IOG, close to the scalp lateral occipital surface. In addition, a positive component maximal around the latency of the N170 (a P170) was prominent above the internal LFG, whereas this region typically generates an N170 (or "N200") over its external/ventral surface. This suggests that electrophysiological responses in the LFG manifest as an equivalent dipole oriented mostly along the vertical axis with likely minimal projection to the lateral OT scalp region. Altogether, these observations provide evidence that the IOG is a major cortical generator of the face-selective scalp N170, qualifying the potential contribution of the FG and questioning a strict serial spatiotemporal organization of the human cortical face network.

Generator localization by current source density (CSD): implications of volume conduction and field closure at intracranial and scalp resolutions

The topographic ambiguity and reference-dependency that has plagued EEG/ERP research throughout its history are largely attributable to volume conduction, which may be concisely described by a vector form of Ohm's Law. This biophysical relationship is common to popular algorithms that infer neuronal generators via inverse solutions. It may be further simplified as Poisson's source equation, which identifies underlying current generators from estimates of the second spatial derivative of the field potential (Laplacian transformation). Intracranial current source density (CSD) studies have dissected the "cortical dipole" into intracortical sources and sinks, corresponding to physiologically-meaningful patterns of neuronal activity at a sublaminar resolution, much of which is locally cancelled (i.e., closed field). By virtue of the macroscopic scale of the scalp-recorded EEG, a surface Laplacian reflects the radial projections of these underlying currents, representing a unique, unambiguous measure of neuronal activity at scalp. Although the surface Laplacian requires minimal assumptions compared to complex, model-sensitive inverses, the resulting waveform topographies faithfully summarize and simplify essential constraints that must be placed on putative generators of a scalp potential topography, even if they arise from deep or partially-closed fields. CSD methods thereby provide a global empirical and biophysical context for generator localization, spanning scales from intracortical to scalp recordings.

Repeatability of short-duration transient visual evoked potentials in normal subjects

To evaluate the within-session and inter-session repeatability of a new, short-duration transient visual evoked potential (SD-tVEP) device on normal individuals, we tested 30 normal subjects (20/20 visual acuity, normal 24-2 SITA Standard VF) with SD-tVEP. Ten of these subjects had their tests repeated within 1–2 months from the initial visit. Synchronized single-channel EEG was recorded using a modified Diopsys Enfant™ System (Diopsys, Inc., Pine Brook, New Jersey, USA). A checkerboard stimulus was modulated at two reversals per second. Two different contrasts of checkerboard reversal patterns were used: 85% Michelson contrast with a mean luminance of 66.25 cd/m² and 10% Michelson contrast with a mean luminance of 112 cd/m². Each test lasted 20 s. Both eyes, independently and together, were tested 10 times (5 times at each contrast level). The following information was identified from the filtered N75-P100-N135 complex: N75 amplitude, N75 latency, P100 amplitude, P100 latency, and Delta Amplitude (N75-P100). The median values for each eye’s five SD-tVEP parameters were calculated and grouped into two data sets based on contrast level. Mean age was 27.3 ± 5.2 years. For OD only, the median (95% confidence intervals) of Delta Amplitude (N75-P100) amplitudes at 10% and 85% contrast were 4.6 uV (4.1–5.9) and 7.1 uV (5.15–9.31). The median P100 latencies were 115.2 ms (112.0–117.7) and 104.0 ms (99.9–106.0). There was little within-session variability for any of these parameters. Intraclass correlation coefficients ranged between 0.64 and 0.98, and within subject coefficients of variation were 3–5% (P100 latency) and 15–30% (Delta Amplitude (N75-P100) amplitude). Bland–Altman plots showed good agreement between the first and fifth test sessions (85% contrast Delta Amplitude (N75-P100) delta amplitude, mean difference, 0.48 mV, 95% CI, −0.18–1.12; 85% contrast P100 latency delay, −0.82 ms, 95% CI, −3.12–1.46; 10% contrast Delta Amplitude (N75-P100) amplitude, 0.58 mV, 95% CI, −0.27–1.45; 10% contrast P100 latency delay, −2.05 mV, 95% CI, −5.12–1.01). The inter-eye correlation and agreement were significant for both SD-tVEP amplitude and P100 latency measurements. For the subset of eyes in which the inter-session repeatability was tested, the intraclass correlation coefficients ranged between 0.71 and 0.86 with good agreement shown on Bland–Altman plots. Short-duration transient VEP technology showed good within-session, inter-session repeatability, and good inter-eye correlation and agreement.

The topography of the scalp-recorded visual N700

OBJECTIVE

To describe the topography of the N700 component of the scalp-recorded visual event-related potential (ERP) and to provide fundamental knowledge of the conditions under which it occurs.

METHODS

We examined the time-course of visual ERP in response to the short (100ms) and prolonged (7s) presentation of simple salient visual stimuli separated by long interstimulus intervals employing high-resolution 64-channel DC-EEG. Current source density (CSD) mapping and spatio-temporal dipole source analysis were performed.

RESULTS

CSD analysis revealed highly significant bilateral current sinks over occipito-temporal areas from about 450ms up to 1s after stimulus offset (visual N700). CSD topography and dipole source analysis suggested late prolonged activation of extrastriate visual areas which did not depend merely upon a stimulus offset response, afterimages or blinking, as confirmed by control conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings provide basic knowledge about the time-course of sensory activation. We found that passive watching of rare salient short stimuli automatically evoked sustained activity in the extrastriate visual cortex up to 1s after stimulus offset.

SIGNIFICANCE

Visual N700 provides a promising tool for important insights into the cortical mechanisms of stimulus post-processing. Its role in associative learning of temporally non-overlapping stimuli (automatic ultra-short-term sensory memory) should be explored.

Predicting potential acuities in amblyopes

PURPOSE

Amblyopic patients, or their parents, often want to know the potential for success before committing to treatment. Recent reports have indicated that the pattern visual evoked potential (pVEP) can be used as a predictor of the success of amblyopia therapy. Unfortunately, these studies did not determine if acuity estimates from pVEPs could accurately predict the acuity post-treatment. Furthermore, pVEPs are not always practical to obtain because of the time necessary to acquire the data. Sweep VEPs (sVEP) offer the advantage of rapidly estimating visual acuity in amblyopic patients. In this retrospective study, the relationship between sVEP acuities measured pre-amblyopic therapy and Snellen acuities measured post-amblyopic therapy was determined.

METHODS

Seventeen patients with amblyopia were studied. Monocular sVEP and Snellen acuities were determined pre-amblyopic therapy and Snellen acuities were determined post-amblyopic therapy. An Enfant 4010 computer system was used to produce the stimuli, record the VEPs, and extrapolate the acuity. The stimuli were horizontally oriented, sine wave gratings (11 spatial frequencies from 2 to 24 cpd) with a contrast of 80%, counterphased at 7.5 Hz. Standard VEP recording techniques were employed. Therapy consisted of the full refractive correction and occlusion combined with active vision therapy.

RESULTS

The patients demonstrated a significant improvement in pre- to post-amblyopic therapy Snellen acuities (P < 0.00001). The intraclass correlation coefficient (r (i)) between the pre-therapy sVEP acuities and the post-therapy Snellen acuities was 0.73. A paired t-test did not find a significant difference between the two sets of data (P = 0.94). For the amblyopes in this study, the average difference (+/-SD) in the sVEP acuity estimate and the final Snellen visual acuity was +0.002 +/- 0.123 logMAR acuity lines.

CONCLUSION

The results indicate that pre-amblyopic therapy sVEP acuity can be a good predictor of post-amblyopic therapy Snellen acuity.

Human cortical responses to contrast modulations of visual noise

We studied visual evoked potentials (VEPs) elicited by second-order contrast modulations of binary dynamic noise and first-order luminance modulations. Using a 3-point Laplacian operator centred on Oz, we found that contrast modulations of both low and higher spatial frequencies elicited a negative component whose latency was about 200 ms. The latency of this component was significantly longer than that of the early Laplacian components to first-order luminance modulations. These findings could be due to slower first-stage linear filters and additional processing stages of the second-order pathway. The topographical analysis of scalp recorded VEPs to central and half-field stimulation has suggested that the responses to second-order patterns are likely to be generated by neuronal structures within the primary visual cortex which may have inputs from extrastriate neurons via feedback connections.

Spatial enhancement of EEG traces by surface Laplacian estimation: comparison between local and global methods

OBJECTIVE

Surface Laplacian estimation enhances EEG spatial resolution. In this paper, we compare, on empirical grounds, two computationally different estimations of the surface Laplacian.

METHODS

Surface Laplacian was estimated from the same monopolar data set with both Hjorth's method [local; Electroenceph Clin Neurophysiol 39 (1975) 526] as modified by MacKay [Electroenceph Clin Neurophysiol 56 (1983) 696] and with spherical spline interpolation [global; Electroenceph Clin Neurophysiol 72 (1989) 184].

RESULTS

The grand averages computed with the two methods proved to be very similar but differed markedly from the monopolar ones. The two different computations were highly correlated, presented low relative errors and allowed to evidence comparable experimental effects.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that Hjorth's method and spherical spline interpolation convey similar topographic and chronometric informations.

SIGNIFICANCE

We provide empirical evidence that local and global methods of surface Laplacian estimation are equivalent to improve the spatial resolution of EEG traces. Global methods allow to explore the scalp topography and local methods allow to spare time in electrode setting that can be useful for studies on special populations (i.e. children, aged subjects) and for clinical purposes.

Multisensory convergence at human temporo-parietal junction - epicortical recording of evoked responses

OBJECTIVE

Previous lesion studies in patients and functional imaging studies in normal subjects have led to the notion that the temporo-parietal junction (TPJ) has an integrative function for multisensory inputs. However, its electrophysiological properties such as response latencies and distributions of responses to various stimulus modalities in humans have not been fully investigated. The aim of the study is to clarify this issue.

METHODS

We recorded evoked potentials to different kinds of sensory stimuli including somatosensory, auditory and visual modalities in 6 patients with intractable partial epilepsy, who underwent chronic implantation of subdural electrodes in TPJ for presurgical evaluation.

RESULTS

In 5 out of 6 subjects, at least one electrode located in TPJ for each subject showed a maximum somatosensory evoked response commonly to electric, passive joint motion and pain stimuli. These electrodes showed the maximum responses also to tone stimuli in all of 4 subjects studied, and to visual motion stimuli in 3 out of 5 subjects studied. The polarity was consistent regardless of the stimulus modality within each individual subject, although the anatomical location, polarity and latency varied among subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

A small area in TPJ for each individual subject receives sensory information of multiple modalities possibly coming from different receptive sites, although the electrophysiological properties of the responses may vary among subjects.

SIGNIFICANCE

We confirmed the convergence of somatosensory, auditory and visual evoked responses at human TPJ.

Electrical activity in visual cortex associated with combined auditory and visual stimulation in temporal sequences known to be associated with a visual illusion

When a subject views a visual stimulus paired with a brief click, a second click occurring approximately 80 ms later produces the hallucination of a second visual stimulus. We have used combinations of visual and sound stimuli to evoke cortical activity and have recorded the associated event-related potentials. We have recorded EPs in a conventional manner, and have calculated from multichannel recordings the Laplacian derivations to determine if the currents were generated in primary visual cortex. Clicks alone do not cause significant activity in V1, but if paired with pattern stimulation, modify the evoked potential. The timing of this extra activity almost certainly excludes "feed back" activation from higher centres, and can most simply be explained if sound-activated thalamo-cortical input can rapidly produce extra activity in 'primed' visual cortex. This finding has general implications for cortical function, for the generation of the hallucination and for 'blindsight'.

Topographical analysis of the onset VEP in the detection of paracentral visual field defects

Transient visual evoked potentials (VEP) were recorded simultaneously from 16 electrodes evenly placed over posterior scalp locations covering the occipital, posterior parietal and temporal areas. Interhemispheric amplitude difference of the N70 deflection was established across 6 homologous lateral electrode pairs in 15 normal controls and 32 patients with chiasmatic or retrochiasmatic cerebral lesions. Twenty-three of these had known homonymous or bitemporal field defects while 9 had normal fields on routine perimetry. Significant interhemispheric asymmetry of any single electrode pair occurred in 55% of the 32 patients with known pathology, while the cumulative yield of all electrode pairs was over 80 percent. The diagnostic yield of individual electrode pairs was significantly different: the electrode pair placed over the temporo-parietal junction detected the highest number of abnormalities. The cumulative abnormality taken over all lateral electrode pairs could be described with a curve well fitted with a probability summation function. It is inferred that the contribution of several independent generator sources is reflected in the N70 of the pattern onset VEP. The results suggest that multichannel recording of the interhemispheric amplitude distribution of the N70 of the onset VEP is useful for the evaluation of paracentral visual field defects.

Generators of visual evoked potentials investigated by dipole tracing in the human occipital cortex

Current source generators (dipoles) of the human visual evoked potentials to pattern-onset stimuli were investigated with the dipole tracing method, using a realistic four-layer head model of scalp-skull-fluid-brain, which can equate the surface potential distributions on a scalp to one or two corresponding equivalent dipoles. Three healthy adult human subjects were used, and 29 electrodes were set on a scalp of each subject. Visual stimulus of a checkerboard pattern was presented for 250 ms in each of eight different visual fields (central and peripheral parts of each of four quadrant fields). The visual evoked potentials consisting of initial positive-late negative waves (CI and CII components designated by Jeffreys and Axford) were recorded mainly on the occipital region contralateral to stimulated visual fields. The initial positive wave (CI) of visual evoked potentials were divided into two components: early component of the CI (e-CI--an early small positive deflection with approximate peak latency of 70-90 ms) and late component of the CI (l-CI--a late large positive deflection with approximate peak latency of 100-120 ms). The dipole with a fit exceeding 98% dipolarity with our model at the shortest latencies was defined as an "earliest dipole" of the evoked potentials, produced by the primary responses in the occipital cortex to an afferent volley from the lateral geniculate body. These earliest dipoles, for eight different visual field stimulations, were estimated at the approximate peak of the e-CI. Estimated dipoles were superimposed on a three-dimensional magnetic resonance image of each subject's brain. Earliest dipoles for right upper and right lower quadrant-field stimulations were located at the left calcarine cortices below and above the calcarine fissure, respectively; earliest dipoles for left upper and left lower quadrant-field stimulations were located at the right calcarine cortices below and above the calcarine fissure, respectively. Furthermore, earliest dipoles for central and peripheral quadrant-field stimulations were located posteriorly and anteriorly in the calcarine cortex, respectively. The results from these non-invasive analyses of visual evoked potentials indicated topographic localization of the dipoles around the calcarine fissure based on the loci of the visual fields. This was comparable to the retinotopy of the human occipital lobe based on clinicopathological studies.

Shifts of visual spatial attention modulate a steady-state visual evoked potential

Although the effects of static allocations of visual spatial attention have been investigated using event-related potentials, most studies of shifts in visual spatial attention have been limited to behavioural measures. This study applied electroencephalographic measures to shifts in visual spatial attention in an effort to elucidate the time courses of such shifts. Using a custom-developed steady-state evoked potential analysis system, we analysed amplitude changes in EEG responses to rapid, periodic visual stimulation during a behavioural task that required rapid, repetitive shifts in visual spatial attention. Both stimulus-evoked oscillations (that is, those signals whose phases matched the phase of the steady-state stimulus) and ongoing, background (non-phase-locked) oscillations were measured. This analysis revealed a transient increase in phase-locked amplitude, in the interval 0-300-ms post-stimulus, contralateral to the visual hemifield in which an attended target appeared. The magnitude of this increase varied with the length of the interval since the previous shift. In addition, by about 600-ms post-stimulus, phase-locked amplitude increased in the hemisphere contralateral to the newly-attended visual hemifield and decreased in the ipsilateral hemisphere. In the case of long inter-target intervals, phase-locked amplitude increased in the right hemisphere regardless of the laterality of the target. Non-phase-locked amplitude exhibited a complementary pattern of modulation: it decreased contralaterally to the newly-attended visual hemifield and increased ipsilaterally. These components may be electrophysiological concomitants of both transient and long-lasting alterations in neural function that implement shifts in visual spatial attention. In particular, we suggest that they may reflect orienting to a target stimulus, and reorienting to a cued location.

Dipole-modeling of the visual evoked P300

We collected visual event-related potentials (ERPs) from 6 normal subjects using an "oddball" paradigm. Subjects were required to count the occurrences of matching shapes presented in the left and right visual field. Shapes matched on 20% of trials. ERPs were recorded from 20 or 43 electrodes distributed over the scalp. A multiple spatio-temporal equivalent dipole (ED) model was used to fit the early sensory and P300 component. A latency window to analyze the P300 was determined using the global field power statistic. The spatial topography of the P300 over this window was characterized by a midline positivity that decreased in amplitude with spatial distance from the peak. After sensory components were fit, the source of P300 could be accounted for by 1 or 2 EDs, which were usually located near medial temporal areas. This result is at odds with evidence from depth recordings during the oddball paradigm, showing that multiple regions of the brain are active during this interval.

A new procedure for the registration of the visual-evoked cortical potential by multichannel recording of the gradient distribution

A new bipolar multichannel visual-evoked cortical potential (VECP) procedure is presented, which can supply objective information on visual field losses. The electrical potential is recorded from 11 electrodes applied to the back of the head in the form of an equidistant rectangular grid. Each neighbouring pair of electrodes feeds one of 14 bipolar channels. The adjacent horizontal and vertical channels are used to calculate an approximation to the direction and amplitude of the electrical field gradients. The gradient distribution is represented by a map of arrows (gradient map) for every instant of the sweep, so that the whole sweep can be plotted as a time series of gradient maps. The maps are easy to scale and are well suited for visual evaluation. Twenty normal subjects were stimulated using checkerboard reversal, partial field patterns to simulate visual field defects. The stimulated area varied between full-, half- and quarter-field, and the particular area stimulated could be clearly seen in the resulting gradient maps. Additionally, we developed a computerized classification procedure that detected 86% of the disturbed visual fields from the gradient recordings.

Programming the duration of a motor sequence: role of the primary and supplementary motor areas in man

Event-related potentials were recorded in a reaction time (RT) paradigm, where the duration of a learned interval (either 0.7 s or 2.5 s) delimited by two brief button-presses was to be accurately controlled. A preparatory signal (PS) either did not give or gave prior information concerning the duration of the following response (neutral condition or primed conditions, respectively). In the latter case, the information was either validated (valid condition) or invalidated (invalid condition) by the response signal (RS). When duration was not known in advance (invalid and neutral conditions), RTs were longer before a response of short than long duration. This difference was not found under the valid condition. During the preparatory period (PP), the amplitude of the contingent negative variation (CNV) was larger when the duration was primed than when it was not. A larger CNV appeared when the PS primed a short rather than a long duration. This effect occurred in the early part of the PP over the supplementary motor area (SMA) and in its latest part over the primary motor area (MI). The RT and the electrophysiological pattern were interpreted as revealing the occurrence of programming operations regarding the temporal dimension of the response. The time course of the CNV over the SMA and MI suggested that these two areas were hierarchically organized. Between the RS and the onset of the response, differences probably related to programming effects were still found over MI: the activities were larger under the valid than under the neutral condition. However, no sign of deprogramming (expected in the invalid condition) was observed: similar amplitudes were found under the neutral and invalid conditions. Deprogramming operations seemed to be postponed during response execution where the invalid condition evoked larger activities than the two other conditions over the SMA. Finally, MI but not the SMA yielded a Bereitschaftpotential before the second press ending the response (i.e., during response execution). These results suggest that the duration of a motor response can be a part of the motor program and that the SMA plays a major role in programming processes but not in response execution, contrary to MI.

Continuous current source inversion of evoked potential fields in a spherical model head

This study explores the efficacy of a physiological constraint on cortical current generators in promoting a robust solution for the inverse problem in evoked potentials. It is proposed that the current sources responsible for the evoked potential be modeled as a set of dipoles oriented orthogonal to the surface of the cortex. Rather than using a minimum norm approach, the solution space is searched for a vector that minimizes the error of the predicted evoked potential scalp field.

The lateralized readiness potential preceding brief isometric force pulses of different peak force and rate of force production

Previous studies have reported that the lateralization of the readiness potential is unaffected by force amplitude of brief unimanual responses. However, because those studies did not specify rate of force production, response force probably was mainly controlled by force unit duration rather than by recruitment of force units, which may explain this negative finding. To enforce recruitment control, we factorially combined peak force (10% or 50% of maximal voluntary finger force) and time to peak force (100 or 200 ms). A precue provided advance information about the responding index finger (left vs. right). After 1 s, the imperative stimulus followed, requiring a brisk isometric flexion of the specified index finger. Symmetric effects, maximal at the vertex, of both force and rate of force production were observed 200-100 ms before the imperative stimulus in stimulus-synchronized averages and 200-100 ms before response onset in response-synchronized averages. However, neither force nor rate of force production affected the lateralized readiness potential. We conclude that this measure does not reflect movement parameters but appears to indicate an abstract preparation of lateralized response channels.

A dry electrode for EEG recording

This paper describes the design, fabrication and testing of a prototype dry surface electrode for EEG signal recording. The new dry electrode has the advantages of no need for skin preparation or conductive paste, potential for reduced sensitivity to motion artifacts and an enhanced signal-to-noise ratio. The electrode's sensing element is a 3 mm stainless steel disk which has a 2000 A (200 nm) thick nitride coating deposited onto one side. The back side of the disk is attached to an impedance converting amplifier. The prototype electrode was mounted on a copper plate attached to the scalp by a Velcro strap. The performance of this prototype dry electrode was compared to commercially available wet electrodes in 3 areas of electroencephalogram (EEG) recording: (1) spontaneous EEG, (2) sensory evoked potentials, and (3) cognitive evoked potentials. In addition to the raw EEG, the power spectra of the signals from both types of electrodes were also recorded. The results suggest that the dry electrode performs comparably to conventional electrodes for all types of EEG signal analysis. This new electrode may be useful for the production of high resolution surface maps of brain activity where a large number of electrodes or prolonged recording times are required.

The topography of visual evoked response properties across the visual field

Visual evoked potentials (VEPs) to luminance and pattern reversal stimulation were derived for a large number of small areas throughout the central visual field. In one study, the field was tested with a stimulus array consisting of 64 equal-area patches. Local response components were extracted by independent m-sequence modulation of the patches. Field topographies were compared between and within subjects using different electrode placements. The subject-dependent local variability observed in response characteristics is attributed to contributions from two or more cortical representations of the visual field and to inter-subject variations in gross cortical anatomy. The second study used luminance modulation of 56 patches across a 15 degrees field, scaled to activate approximately equal cortical areas in area V1. This produced many robust signals at all eccentricities. Bipolar and double differential ("1-dimensional Laplacian") signals were compared. The double differencing reduced contributions from distant or distributed sources, enhancing nearby current source activity, and greatly improved S/N for many stimulus locations. The high-resolution visual field maps demonstrated that clinical field testing using the VEP is not feasible because of effects of cortical convolutions on responses. However, the vast improvement in data quality and quantity make it a useful tool for VEP source localization and identification.

Functional brain imaging: dipole localization and Laplacian methods

The performance of two methods, used to localize brain activity from evoked potential fields measured on the scalp, was assessed in a tank model of the human head. This physical model contained a human skull encased in a polymer simulating the resistivity and geometry of brain and scalp. The dipole localization method mislocalized the positions of known dipole sources by several centimeters. The mislocalization was systematic. The dipoles were localized too deeply in the head. The Laplacian method yielded a field resembling the brain surface field (epicortical potential field) provided that the iso-potential contours of the scalp field closed within the measurement range. Clipping resulted in a serious mislocalization of the position of the peak of the epicortical potential field.

Pattern visual evoked potentials recorded from human occipital cortex with chronic subdural electrodes

Pattern evoked potentials to full- and partial-field stimulation were recorded simultaneously from scalp electrodes and from subdural electrodes located over the temporal and occipital cortex, including electrodes placed over or close to the lower lip of the calcarine fissure. High-amplitude pattern evoked potentials were recorded exclusively from electrodes localized in the vicinity of the calcarine fissure and showed a positive-negative deflection in phase with surface recordings, followed by a second negative peak phase reversed with respect to the major surface positive peak ("P100"). The findings suggest that the initial component is an expression of the afferent volley and that the second component (equivalent of the surface "P100") is most probably generated as a dipole strictly localized to the visual cortex in close proximity of the calcarine fissure (area 17 and/or area 18).

Identification of the hemisphere activated by hemifield visual stimulation using a single equivalent dipole model

Topographic amplitude distribution of the hemifield pattern visual evoked potential (PVEP) shows substantial intersubject variability. Many subjects have larger P100 amplitudes paradoxically over the hemisphere ipsilateral to the stimulated field, whereas others show larger responses over the stimulated hemisphere. The present study was designed to determine whether a single equivalent dipole model could correctly identify the field of stimulation, and therefore the hemisphere activated, under conditions in which the surface distribution is variable. Under conditions used in the present study, visual examination of the surface amplitude distribution of the P100 peak could not be reliably used to identify the hemifield that was stimulated. Of 28 hemifield PVEPs, obtained from 14 normal subjects, only 13 showed higher amplitude ipsilateral to the field of stimulation. Thus, neither examination of EP wave forms nor topographic maps provided an accurate means for determination of which hemifield was stimulated or which hemisphere was activated. The single equivalent dipole model correctly identified the stimulated hemisphere for 25/28 hemifield PVEPs. Orientation of the equivalent dipole accounted for much of the variability in surface amplitude distribution, with tangential orientations obtained in subjects with ipsilaterally predominant P100 surface topography. Although the dipole model improved identification of the stimulated hemisphere, dipoles were located anterior or inferior to the occipital lobe in some subjects. Results suggest that dipole modeling can provide useful information regarding the source of surface recorded potentials.

Estimating regional brain activity from evoked potential fields on the scalp

Potential fields on the surface of the brain were estimated from discretely sampled scalp fields in human subjects. Relatively simple methods of linear algebra were combined with detailed anatomical information from magnetic resonance imaging. The method was verified using a tank model of the human head that encased a fully hydrated human skull in a polymer matrix of controlled resistivity matching that of human brain and scalp. Brain surface fields evoked by checkerboard contrast reversal, spread less than their scalp field counterparts, and provided information helpful in localizing brain activity.

Category-related components in visual evoked potentials: photographs of faces, persons, flowers and tools as stimuli

One hundred and sixty black-and-white photographs of faces, persons, tools and flowers constituted the four stimulus categories in the first experimental paradigm. In the second paradigm, 160 black-and-white photographs of persons in a neutral (side view), fighting, greeting and "depressed" postures were used. The same nine female and nine male students volunteered as subjects in both paradigms. EEG responses were recorded through the electrodes F3, F4, Cz, Oz, T5 and T6 and referenced to "linked" mastoid electrodes. Individually averaged EPs and grand averages of the EPs for all 18 subjects were computed as well as bipolar responses for selected pairs of electrodes. Category-related components in the evoked potentials (EPs) were found mainly in the recordings through the midline and the frontal electrodes. These category-specific differences were more prominent, however, in the bipolar recordings between these electrodes and the respective ipsilateral electrodes (T5 or T6) than in the monopolar recordings. Monopolar and bipolar EPs could be divided into those evoked by person stimuli and by non-person stimuli. Category-related differences were demonstrated by computing EP-difference curves related to pairs of stimulus categories. In addition to the statistical analysis of peak amplitudes and peak latencies of the individual curves, a "running" Wilcoxon test was applied and cross-correlation functions between the EPs evoked by different stimulus categories were computed. The "face-related" components of the EPs described in earlier studies could be confirmed. They were prominent in the waves peaking between 130 and 150 ms and between 200 and 230 ms and were stronger when faces rather than full-figure "neutral persons" were used as stimuli. No significant hemispheric differences could be found between any of the EPs. In the second paradigm, EEG responses evoked by person stimuli in a neutral, fighting, greeting or depressed posture exhibited only slight differences, if at all. The "person-responsive" components in the EPs evoked by the photographs of a neutral standing person (side view) were smaller between 120 and 200 ms than in the other three categories in which "expressive" persons were the stimuli.

An analysis of the VEP to luminance modulation and of its nonlinearity

Identification of the VEP luminance modulation system was carried out using a relatively long pseudorandom binary m-sequence stimulus. The complete first order cross-correlation function provides a "fingerprint" of the nonlinearity in the time domain. Volterra kernel slices up to third order are recognized in the complete first order cross-correlation function. They all lie close to the major diagonal. Higher order kernel slices are not measurable. A cascade block model (sandwich model) analysis shows the nonlinearity to be an asymmetric rectification. Luminance increase causes a stronger response than does luminance decrease. The pre-filter gain function is low-pass. The post-filter gain function is band-pass tuned near 10 Hz. Coherency spectra are used to examine the channel structure of the system. Two channels operating near 8 and 15 Hz are easily identified. Another broad channel (or possibly multiple channels) is present above 30 Hz. In many subjects, the pseudorandom stimuli allow a complete system identification to be carried out in less than 82 sec.

Topography of the evoked potential to spatial localization cues

Visual tasks that are perceptually diverse might be expected to elicit unique evoked-potential waveforms that exhibit differing topographic maps. To investigate this possibility, multichannel visual-evoked potentials (VEPs) were recorded in response to several dot spatial localization stimuli that are physically similar yet produce different percepts (vernier offsets, steroscopic disparity, bisection, orientation, and relative displacement) to determine if the unique percepts arising from these stimuli reflect the activation of different cortical neural populations. The resulting evoked potentials were all similar in waveform, although the stereoscopic VEPs were relatively delayed. Topographic maps of the evoked-potential activity to each stimulus revealed a late major component with two independent foci: one 7 or more centimeters above the inion lateral to the midline, and the other at least 6 cm lateral to OZ. The scalp localization of both peaks was independent of both the position of the stimulus in the visual field and the particular stimulus cue presented. An asymmetric response to pattern appearance vs. disappearance indicated strong pattern specificity for each stimulus type except unreferenced motion. The timing of the VEP responses and relative insensitivity to retinal locus of stimulation suggest the involvement of higher cortical areas. The two map foci might be interpreted as activation of inferotemporal and parietal cortices whose roles are thought to be visual object interpretation and spatial attention and localization, respectively.

Estimates of visually evoked cortical currents

We have measured magnetic fields evoked by the onset of checkerboard-like sectorial patterns presented at 16 locations near the center of the visual field. Small stimuli (less than 2 degrees), which, nevertheless, gave sufficiently strong responses to enable source localization, were used to limit cortical activation to a small area, thus simplifying the analysis of the magnetic field data. We focused on optimizing the experimental design: cortical sources could be located from measurements at just one position of our 24-channel magnetometer and with as few as 15-20 repetitions of the stimulus. Minimum-norm-estimate maps calculated from even a single response showed reproducible features of the current distribution, which was, 80-100 msec after the pattern onset, retinotopically organized in the occipital lobe. Since magnetoencephalography can reveal cortical locations with a precision of 2-3 mm, our procedure appears promising for further studies of cortical retinotopy and visual field defects.

The laplacian analysis of the pattern onset response in man

The pattern onset VEP described by means of principal component analysis was shown to be composed of at least two overlapping time components, of which one has a striate and the other an extrastriate origin. This analysis was based on a multi (24)-electrode registration. We looked for a technique that can distinguish, with a limited number of electrodes, between the striate and extrastriate components and can be applied in the clinic. The calculation of a 5-point 'Laplacian' operator over the striate area enhances the contribution of the striate source relative to the contribution of the extrastriate source that lies outside the area of the operator, and vice versa. We applied two 5-point operators, one centered on Oz and the other 6 cm left of Oz. This montage allowed for the selective recording of the striate and extrastriate activities separately. This was proved by means of an adaptation paradigm that selectively reduced the striate contribution. Application of the laplacian operator for clinical practice is exemplified by means of the VEPs of a patient suspected of psychogenic hemianopsia.

The application of Laplacian analysis in the recording of half-field pattern-onset evoked potentials

The Laplacian operator in electroencephalographic measurements consists of a mathematical combination of the responses from a number of electrodes (e.g., five in a crosswise montage). It enhances activity from sources lying underneath the area covered, relative to activity from outside this area. Thus, by appropriate positioning, the contributions of extrastriate and striate sources can be recorded selectively. To quantify the contribution of each hemisphere to half-field onset evoked potentials, the responses in two Laplacian operators, one over each hemisphere, were analyzed and compared to monopolar derivations and a bipolar derivation between the two hemispheres. Both the Laplacian and bipolar analyses were helpful in interpretation of the responses.

Visual evoked potential estimation of visual activity with a Laplacian derivation

Visual acuity was estimated with visual evoked potentials in 13 healthy subjects. A Laplacian derivation of 5 electrodes was used to improve the signal-to-noise ratio and to enhance striate cortical activity selectively. In 6 subjects, the Laplacian derivation gave a more reliable estimation of visual acuity than did a single midline derivation. In the other 7 subjects, the quality of both estimations was comparable.

Occipital lobe morphology in normal individuals assessed by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)

The topography of visual evoked potentials (VEP) is dependent on occipital lobe morphology. Using magnetic resonance imaging we examine the sulcal pattern (the calcarine and parieto-occipital sulci), and assess the size of the cuneus and the asymmetry of the occipital lobes, computed separately for its ventral and dorsal segments. No differences were found for either the cuneus or the sulci pattern. In contrast, hemispheric asymmetry values appeared to be substantial. The predominance of the left occipital area was seen distinctly in the ventro-caudal portion of the occipital lobe. It was frequently reversed in the dorsal aspect of the lobe, notably in more rostral cuts. Such complexities may lead to ambiguities in interpreting VEP asymmetries.

Realistic modeling of VEP topography

A finite element model of the human head was constructed from digitized contours of a cadaver head cut at 1 cm intervals parallel to the cantho-meatal plane. The boundary element method was used to calculate the potential fields produced by dipoles in the cortex at various locations and orientations. Field profiles and their Fourier transforms established the Nyquist Sampling interval necessary to faithfully reconstruct scalp fields from discrete measurements. The interval varies from approx. 1 cm for sources near the occipital pole to 2 cm for sources near the Rolandic fissure. The resolution of the VEP was also estimated. For signal-to-noise ratios ranging from 4 to 10, source displacements ranging from approx. 1.4 to 0.4 cm in the cortex can be resolved.

Localization of visually evoked cortical activity using magnetic resonance imaging and computerized tomography

Evoked scalp potentials, computerized tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging were used together to localize cortical activity evoked by visual stimuli in humans. The temporal resolution of evoked potential measurements is sufficient to track the flow of cortical activity which evolves in epochs of a few tens of msec. Spatial localization was enhanced by deconvolving scalp potential fields with a Laplacian operator. Markers glue to the scalp served to unify the three geometric reference frames into a single computer graphics database.

A face-responsive potential recorded from the human scalp

Evoked potentials were recorded to the separate tachistoscopic presentation of a variety of faces and other simple and complex visual stimuli. A positive potential of 150-200 ms peak latency which responds preferentially, but not exclusively, to faces was identified in 8 out of 9 subjects. This potential, best recorded from midline central and parietal electrodes, was evoked by all face stimuli, including photographs, outline drawings, and fragmentary figures. Changes in stimulus size and other parameters which do not affect the clarity of the face, generally had little effect on the peak amplitude. Stimulus changes such as face inversion, reversing the contrast polarity of photographic images, and selectively removing particular facial features, produced a marked increase in latency but often only slight attenuation of this peak. These response properties correspond well with those reported for face-related single cells in the temporal cortex of the rhesus monkey. The scalp distribution of this face-responsive peak also appears consistent with bilateral sources in the temporal cortex.

Electric brain potentials evoked by pictures of faces and non-faces: a search for "face-specific" EEG-potentials

In three different experimental series, electroencephalographic responses evoked by changes in pictorial patterns were recorded in 29 adult human subjects (19 females, 10 males). Quantitative data evaluation for the evoked responses from electrodes T5, T6, Cz, Pz (10-20 system) was performed. The stimuli were projected to a 4 x 6 degree binocularly viewed field. The patterns changed within 6 ms every 2.5-4.5 s according to a random program. Paradigm (1): Identical line drawings of a face, a tree and a chair were used, either black on white (P-stimuli) or white on black (N-stimuli); in each set altogether 160 slides appeared in semi-random order. At Cz and Pz a prototypical EEG-response evoked by face stimuli was found exhibiting 3 prominent peaks, very similar for P-stimuli and N-stimuli. A P150 maximum was especially pronounced in the responses to face stimuli but absent in the evoked potentials aroused by chair or tree stimuli. The difference curves (face-chair, face-tree, chair-tree) supported the hypothesis of "face-responsive" components in these responses. Paradigm (2): 4 x 6 degree slides (black and white photographs) of 54 different human faces, 53 different vases and 53 different pairs of shoes were projected as in paradigm (1), but instruction to the subjects on a supposed post-test memory task raised their attention during the recordings. "Face-responsive" components (an early N 140-160, P 210-240, N 300) were more marked in female than in male subjects, and again most pronounced at electrode Cz. Paradigm (3): When a recognition task was included in paradigm (2)--9 out of 192 items were memorized 20 minutes before the recording session--essentially the same evoked potentials were obtained as in (2), but an additional late positive wave (450-600 ms) appeared in the responses to all stimuli. We assume that the "face-specific" components--a designation which is used cautiously considering the limited number of non-face stimuli--do not originate in the temporo-occipital cortical face region, but in limbic structures (amygdala, hippocampus) deep in the temporal lobe or in the gyrus cinguli. In the present study no significant hemispheric differences (T5, T6) in the evoked responses were found (all stimulus categories), but such differences are known to appear with highly schematic face stimuli.

Quantitative VEP analysis in children with cortical visual impairment

Children with cortical visual impairment (CVI) usually have a typical clinical presentation. However, in some cases, it may be useful to have confirmatory evidence based on objective electrophysiologic information. To achieve this, we examined some mathematically derived parameters constructed from 20 channel visual evoked potential (VEP). A group of 30 children diagnosed with CVI by clinical and CT findings was compared to a normal control group of 52 children. Each recorded VEP was mathematically transformed using Hjorth's source derivation, to reduce reference contamination and enhance local features. The area under the response curve, computed for each channel within a fixed time window, was used as a measure of the response activity at that channel. These areas were then used to construct several parameters ("R values") describing ratios of activities between different recording electrode areas. Some of these ratios provided good separation between patient and control groups, especially for children older than 5 years of age; in particular CVI patients were found to have a low occipital-to-parietal activity ratio. This finding, together with the observed age independence of the R values in the normal population, their ease of computation and possible physiological interpretability, suggest that R values could be used as confirmatory diagnostic measures.

Computed radial-current topography of the brain: patterns associated with the normal and abnormal EEG

We describe a method for producing estimates of radial-current topography underlying the background EEG. This method is based on the application of the laplacian operator to potentials measured on the scalp using a 31-electrode recording array. The laplacian is applied analytically to a potential surface obtained by bicubic-spline interpolation of the measurements at the electrode sites. The results obtained when the method was applied to the alpha rhythm recorded from a normal volunteer and to the slow wave activity recorded from a neurologic patient are presented. The alpha rhythm is associated with areas of strong radial-current activity in the occipital regions (although dominantly right); for the slow rhythm the activity appears in the medial-frontal region. The radial-current topography for the alpha rhythm suggests rotating dipole generators in the occipital lobes whereas it is suggestive of a radially oriented dipole in the case of the delta activity. Discussion is focused upon the apparent advantages of radial-current topography for localizing brain electrical activity, upon the strengths and weaknesses of the method, and upon the observation that the topography of radial current activity obtained would have been difficult to predict from a visual examination of raw EEG traces alone.

Hemi-field pattern visual evoked potentials: a comparison of display and analysis techniques

Three methods for analyzing the spatial organization of visual evoked potentials were compared. Pattern reversal visual evoked potentials were obtained from a single subject under three viewing conditions: stimulation of the left, right, and both visual fields. The scalp distribution of the VEP to 1 deg checks was displayed using three recording and analysis techniques: a conventional horizontal occipital array of electrodes, topographic mapping, and 3-dimensional evoked potentials. All three techniques revealed "paradoxical" lateralization of P100. The relative merits of each technique are discussed.

Current source density estimation and interpolation based on the spherical harmonic Fourier expansion

A method for the spatial analysis of EEG and EP data, based on the spherical harmonic Fourier expansion (SHE) of scalp potential measurements, is described. This model provides efficient and accurate formulas for: (1) the computation of the surface Laplacian and (2) the interpolation of electrical potentials, current source densities, test statistics and other derived variables. Physiologically based simulation experiments show that the SHE method gives better estimates of the surface Laplacian than the commonly used finite difference method. Cross-validation studies for the objective comparison of different interpolation methods demonstrate the superiority of the SHE over the commonly used methods based on the weighted (inverse distance) average of the nearest three and four neighbor values.

Scalp current density fields: concept and properties

The physical meaning of scalp current density (SCD) is presented and its properties are described using simulations of brain generators by dipolar models inside an inhomogeneous sphere. Its properties are compared with those of potentials and magnetic fields.

Spatial dissociation of early and late colour evoked components

Evoked potentials to the primary colours red, green, yellow and blue were recorded and compared with those evoked by white. The unpatterned 10 degrees X13 degrees stimuli were generated with the aid of a colour monitor. Activity was depicted with 5 electrodes, the central electrode 5 cm above the inion and two on each side 5 and 10 cm apart from the central electrode. With equally bright colour stimuli a previously described early negative colour-dominated component N87 was localized in all subjects at the central occipital electrode while the following positivity P100 was clearly more lateralized to the peripheral electrodes. With half-field stimulation N87 showed a similar--paradoxical--lateralization to the ipsilateral electrodes as has been demonstrated for pattern reversal. The existence and localization of N87 could be confirmed also for blue colours, its amplitude independent of the blue luminance, its latency decreasing for definite additional brightness increments and decrements. The N87 to blue was of the same latency as the N87 components to other colours. N87 is mainly generated foveally and parafoveally, its amplitude saturates with stimuli larger than 6-8 degrees in diameter.

Properties of the evoked potential generators: current source-density analysis of visually evoked potentials in the cat cortex

The depth profiles of visually evoked field potentials were recorded in areas 17 and 18 of the cat visual cortex. For comparison, potential profiles evoked by electrical stimulation of the primary afferents and of the nonspecific reticular system were also recorded. From these profiles the current source-density (CSD) distributions were calculated using the one-dimensional CSD method. CSD distributions evoked by the different types of stimuli differ in their amplitudes and time courses by approximately one and two orders of magnitude. Qualitatively, however, they are very similar. Thus, the CSDs can be interpreted as reflecting the same basic pattern of excitatory synaptic activations. This pattern consists of early activation components in the input layers, followed by excitatory synaptic activations in layer III, then in layer II, and in layer V. The basic pattern of cortical activation was found to be modulated by specific features of the visual stimuli. Modulations reflecting contour-versus contrast-contents as well as those reflecting characteristic features of moving patterns have been identified. Most of the CSD components of the cortical activation sequence were obtained from regions extending well beyond the cellular receptive fields in visual cortex. Thus, they reflect nonretinotopic activities. Parameters other than specific features of the visual stimuli have profound influence on cortical CSDs. Nonspecific parameters which have been considered are the general state of cortical excitability, the temporal interactions of successive activities (which are predominantly facilitatory), and the lateral interactions of simultaneous activations from different regions of the visual field (predominantly inhibitory).