Imaging photoplethysmography for clinical assessment of cutaneous microcirculation at two different depths

Understanding the physiological transmission mechanisms of photoplethysmography signals: a comprehensive review

Objective. The widespread adoption of Photoplethysmography (PPG) as a non-invasive method for detecting blood volume variations and deriving vital physiological parameters reflecting health status has surged, primarily due to its accessibility, cost-effectiveness, and non-intrusive nature. This has led to extensive research around this technique in both daily life and clinical applications. Interestingly, despite the existence of contradictory explanations of the underlying mechanism of PPG signals across various applications, a systematic investigation into this crucial matter has not been conducted thus far. This gap in understanding hinders the full exploitation of PPG technology and undermines its accuracy and reliability in numerous applications.Approach. Building upon a comprehensive review of the fundamental principles and technological advancements in PPG, this paper initially attributes the origin of PPG signals to a combination of physical and physiological transmission processes. Furthermore, three distinct models outlining the concerned physiological transmission processes are synthesized, with each model undergoing critical examination based on theoretical underpinnings, empirical evidence, and constraints.Significance. The ultimate objective is to form a fundamental framework for a better understanding of physiological transmission processes in PPG signal generation and to facilitate the development of more reliable technologies for detecting physiological signals.

Deep learning and remote photoplethysmography powered advancements in contactless physiological measurement

In recent decades, there has been ongoing development in the application of computer vision (CV) in the medical field. As conventional contact-based physiological measurement techniques often restrict a patient's mobility in the clinical environment, the ability to achieve continuous, comfortable and convenient monitoring is thus a topic of interest to researchers. One type of CV application is remote imaging photoplethysmography (rPPG), which can predict vital signs using a video or image. While contactless physiological measurement techniques have an excellent application prospect, the lack of uniformity or standardization of contactless vital monitoring methods limits their application in remote healthcare/telehealth settings. Several methods have been developed to improve this limitation and solve the heterogeneity of video signals caused by movement, lighting, and equipment. The fundamental algorithms include traditional algorithms with optimization and developing deep learning (DL) algorithms. This article aims to provide an in-depth review of current Artificial Intelligence (AI) methods using CV and DL in contactless physiological measurement and a comprehensive summary of the latest development of contactless measurement techniques for skin perfusion, respiratory rate, blood oxygen saturation, heart rate, heart rate variability, and blood pressure.

Contactless photoplethysmography for assessment of small fiber neuropathy

Chronic pain is a prevalent condition affecting approximately one-fifth of the global population, with significant impacts on quality of life and work productivity. Small fiber neuropathies are a common cause of chronic pain, and current diagnostic methods rely on subjective self-assessment or invasive skin biopsies, highlighting the need for objective noninvasive assessment methods. The study aims to develop a modular prototype of a contactless photoplethysmography system with three spectral bands (420, 540, and 800 nm) and evaluate its potential for assessing peripheral neuropathy patients via a skin topical heating test and spectral analyses of cutaneous flowmotions. The foot topical skin heating test was conducted on thirty volunteers, including fifteen healthy subjects and fifteen neuropathic patients. Four cutaneous nerve fiber characterizing parameters were evaluated at different wavelengths, including vasomotor response trend, flare area, flare intensity index, and the spectral power of cutaneous flowmotions. The results show that neuropathic patients had significantly lower vasomotor response (50%), flare area (63%), flare intensity index (19%), and neurogenic component (54%) of cutaneous flowmotions compared to the control group, independent of photoplethysmography spectral band. An absolute value of perfusion was 20%-30% higher in the 420 nm band. Imaging photoplethysmography shows potential as a cost-effective alternative for objective and non-invasive assessment of neuropathic patients, but further research is needed to enhance photoplethysmography signal quality and establish diagnostic criteria.

Optimal digital filter selection for remote photoplethysmography (rPPG) signal conditioning

Remote photoplethysmography (rPPG) using camera-based imaging has shown excellent potential recently in vital signs monitoring due to its contactless nature. However, the optimum filter selection for pre-processing rPPG data in signal conditioning is still not straightforward. The best algorithm selection improves the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and therefore improves the accuracy of the recognition and classification of vital signs. We recorded more than 300 temporal rPPG signals where the noise was not motion-induced. Then, we investigated the best digital filter in pre-processing temporal rPPG data and compared the performances of 10 filters with 10 orders each (i.e., a total of 100 filters). The performances are assessed using a signal quality metric on three levels. The quality of the raw signals was classified under three categories; Q1 being the best and Q3 being the worst. The results are presented in SNR scores, which show that the Chebyshev II orders of 2nd, 4th, and 6th perform the best for denoising rPPG signals.

[Possibilities of tissue perfusion assessment in abdominal surgery: integration into the intraoperative system of safety control points]

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the possibility of integrating tissue perfusion assessment techniques (ICG perfusion and imaging photoplethysmography - iPPG) into the system of intraoperative control points of laparoscopic interventions with a reconstructive component.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Quantitative assessment of ICG fluorescence and iPPG were used during 8 laparoscopically assisted interventions: gastrectomy for gastric cancer (total - 2 and distal - 1) and colorectal resections (left-sided colorectal resections - 4 and right hemicolectomy - 1).

RESULTS

Four stages are presented for the assessment of tissue perfusion: initial assessment, before intestine transection, before anastomosis formation, and evaluation of anastomosis. From the point of view of the significance of clinical decision-making, the «before intestine transection» stage is of great importance, due to the ease of transferring the resection level to the optimal tissue perfusion zone.

CONCLUSION

Integration of tissue perfusion assessment techniques into the system of intraoperative checkpoints is possible and promising.

Photoplethysmographic Imaging of Hemodynamics and Two-Dimensional Oximetry

The review of recent papers devoted to actively developing methods of photoplethysmographic imaging (the PPGI) of blood volume pulsations in vessels and non-contact two-dimensional oximetry on the surface of a human body has been carried out. The physical fundamentals and technical aspects of the PPGI and oximetry have been considered. The manifold of the physiological parameters available for the analysis by the PPGI method has been shown. The prospects of the PPGI technology have been discussed. The possibilities of non-contact determination of blood oxygen saturation SpO2 (pulse saturation O2) have been described. The relevance of remote determination of the level of oxygenation in connection with the spread of a new coronavirus infection SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) has been emphasized. Most of the works under consideration cover the period 2010-2021.

Photoplethysmographic imaging and analysis of pulsatile pressure wave in palmar artery at 10 wavelengths

SIGNIFICANCE

As a noncontact method, imaging photoplethysmography (iPPG) may provide a powerful tool to measure pulsatile pressure wave (PPW) in superficial arteries and extract biomarkers for monitoring of artery wall stiffness.

AIM

We intend to develop a approach for extraction of the very weak cardiac component from iPPG data by identifying locations of strong PPW signals with optimized illumination wavelength and determining pulse wave velocity (PWV).

APPROACH

Monochromatic in vivo iPPG datasets have been acquired from left hands to investigate various algorithms for retrieval of PPW signals, distribution maps and waveforms, and their dependence on arterial location and wavelength.

RESULTS

A robust algorithm of pixelated independent component analysis (pICA) has been developed and combined with spatiotemporal filtering to retrieve PPW signals. Spatial distributions of PPW signals have been mapped in 10 wavelength bands from 445 to 940 nm and waveforms were analyzed at multiple locations near the palmar artery tree. At the wavelength of 850 nm selected for timing analysis, we determined PWV values from 12 healthy volunteers in a range of 0.5 to 5.8 m/s across the hand region from wrist to midpalm and fingertip.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate the potentials of the iPPG method based on pICA algorithm for translation into a monitoring tool to characterize wall stiffness of superficial artery by rapid and noncontact measurement of PWV and other biomarkers within 10 s.

Intraoperative visualization and quantitative assessment of tissue perfusion by imaging photoplethysmography: comparison with ICG fluorescence angiography

Intraoperative monitoring of tissue perfusion is of great importance for optimizing surgery and reducing postoperative complications. To date, there is no standard procedure for assessing blood circulation in routine clinical practice. Over the past decade, indocyanine green (ICG) fluorescence angiography is most commonly used for intraoperative perfusion evaluation. Imaging photoplethysmography (iPPG) potentially enables contactless assessment of the blood supply to organs. However, no strong evidence of this potential has been provided so far. Here we report results of a comparative assessment of tissue perfusion obtained using custom-made iPPG and commercial ICG-fluorescence systems during eight different gastrointestinal surgeries. Both systems allow mapping the blood-supply distribution over organs. It was demonstrated for the first time that the quantitative assessment of blood perfusion by iPPG is in good agreement with that obtained by ICG-fluorescence imaging in all surgical cases under study. iPPG can become an objective quantitative monitoring system for tissue perfusion in the operating room due to its simplicity, low cost and no need for any agent injections.

Camera-based assessment of cutaneous perfusion strength in a clinical setting

Objective. After skin flap transplants, perfusion strength monitoring is essential for the early detection of tissue perfusion disorders and thus to ensure the survival of skin flaps. Camera-based photoplethysmography (cbPPG) is a non-contact measurement method, using video cameras and ambient light, which provides spatially resolved information about tissue perfusion. It has not been researched yet whether the measurement depth of cbPPG, which is limited by the penetration depth of ambient light, is sufficient to reach pulsatile vessels and thus to measure the perfusion strength in regions that are relevant for skin flap transplants.Approach. We applied constant negative pressure (compared to ambient pressure) to the anterior thighs of 40 healthy subjects. Seven measurements (two before and five up to 90 minutes after the intervention) were acquired using an RGB video camera and photospectrometry simultaneously. We investigated the performance of different algorithmic approaches for perfusion strength assessment, including the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), its logarithmic components logS and logN, amplitude maps, and the amplitude height of alternating and direct signal components.Main results. We found strong correlations of up tor=0.694 (p<0.001) between photospectrometric measurements and all cbPPG parameters except SNR when using the green color channel. The transfer of cbPPG signals to POS, CHROM, and O3C did not lead to systematic improvements. However, for direct signal components, the transformation to O3C led to correlations of up tor=0.744 (p<0.001) with photospectrometric measurements.Significance. Our results indicate that a camera-based perfusion strength assessment in tissue with deep-seated pulsatile vessels is possible.

Optical incoherent technique for noninvasive assessment of blood flow in tissues: Theoretical model and experimental study

Laser noninvasive methods for assessment of a tissue blood flow (BF), for example, the Laser Doppler Flowmetry (LDF), are well-known today. However, in such methods, low-frequency fluctuations (LFFs) in the registered optical signal caused by blood volume changes inside a tissue have not been studied in details until now. The aim of this study is to investigate the LFFs formation and to justify the LFFs-based diagnostic technique for cutaneous BF assessment. LFFs are theoretically described and experimentally shown in the input LDF signal inside the frequency range 0 to 10 Hz. They are substantiated as the basis of the new diagnostic method, in which BF is defined as the magnitude of blood volume changes in a tissue per unit time. The hand-made prototype of the promising diagnostic tool with light emitted diodes is used to validate the technique in experiments in vivo on 16 healthy volunteers in comparison with the LDF method. Experimental results show a good similarity of the recorded BF for both coherent and incoherent method. The proposed technique makes it possible the creation of inexpensive diagnostic equipment for assessment of cutaneous BF without using lasers and coherent light, completely and functionally comparable to LDF devices.

Spatiotemporal monitoring of changes in oxy/deoxy-hemoglobin concentration and blood pulsation on human skin using smartphone-enabled remote multispectral photoplethysmography

We propose a smartphone-enabled remote multispectral photoplethysmography (SP-rmPPG) system and method to realize spatiotemporal monitoring of perfusion changes and pulsations of the oxyhemoglobin (HbO2) and deoxyhemoglobin (Hb) information of the effective blood volume within light interrogated skin tissue beds. The system is implemented on an unmodified smartphone utilizing its built-in camera and flashlight to acquire videos of the skin reflectance. The SP-rmPPG method converts the RGB video into multispectral cubes, upon which to decouple the dynamic changes in HbO2 and Hb information using a modified Beer-Lambert law and the selective wavelength bands of 500 nm and 650 nm. Blood pulsation amplitudes are then obtained by applying a window-based lock-in amplification on the derived spatiotemporal changes in HbO2 or Hb signals. To demonstrate the feasibility of proposed method, we conduct two experiments on the skin tissue beds that are conditioned by occlusive maneuver of supplying arteries: one using the popular blood cuff pressure maneuver on the upper arm, and another artificially inducing a transient ischemic condition on the facial skin tissue beds by finger pressing on the supplying external carotid artery. The cuff experiment shows that the measured dynamic information of HbO2 and Hb in the downstream agrees well with the parallel measurements of oxygenation saturation given by the standard pulse oximeter. We also observe the expected imbalance of spatiotemporal changes in the HbO2 and Hb between the right and left cheeks when the transient ischemic condition is induced in the one side of facial skin tissue beds. The results from the two experiments sufficiently demonstrate the feasibility of the proposed method to monitor the spatiotemporal changes in the skin hemodynamics, including blood oxygenation and pulsation amplitudes. Considering the ever-growing accessibility and affordability of the smartphone to the general public, the proposed strategy promises the early screening of vascular diseases and improving general public health particularly in rural areas with low resource settings.

Remote Photoplethysmography for Evaluation of Cutaneous Sensory Nerve Fiber Function

About 2% of the world’s population suffers from small nerve fiber dysfunction, neuropathy, which can result in severe pain. This condition is caused by damage to the small nerve fibers and its assessment is challenging, due to the lack of simple and objective diagnostic techniques. The present study aimed to develop a contactless photoplethysmography system using simple instrumentation, for objective and non-invasive assessment of small cutaneous sensory nerve fiber function. The approach is based on the use of contactless photoplethysmography for the characterization of skin flowmotions and topical heating evoked vasomotor responses. The feasibility of the technique was evaluated on volunteers (n = 14) using skin topical anesthesia, which is able to produce temporary alterations of cutaneous nerve fibers function. In the treated skin region in comparison to intact skin: neurogenic and endothelial component of flowmotions decreased by ~61% and 41%, the local heating evoked flare area decreased by ~44%, vasomotor response trend peak and nadir were substantially reduced. The results indicate for the potential of the remote photoplethysmography in the assessment of the cutaneous nerve fiber function. It is believed that in the future this technique could be used in the clinics as an affordable alternative to laser Doppler imaging technique.

Association of remote imaging photoplethysmography and cutaneous perfusion in volunteers

Remote imaging photoplethysmography (iPPG) senses the cardiac pulse in outer skin layers and is responsive to mean arterial pressure and pulse pressure in critically ill patients. Whether iPPG is sufficiently sensitive to monitor cutaneous perfusion is not known. This study aimed at determining the response of iPPG to changes in cutaneous perfusion measured by  Laser speckle imaging (LSI). Thirty-seven volunteers were engaged in a cognitive test known to evoke autonomic nervous activity and a Heat test. Simultaneous measurements of iPPG and LSI were taken at baseline and during cutaneous perfusion challenges. A perfusion index (PI) was calculated to assess iPPG signal strength. The response of iPPG to the challenges and its relation to LSI were determined. PI of iPPG significantly increased in response to autonomic nervous stimuli and to the Heat test by 5.8% (p = 0.005) and 11.1% (p < 0.001), respectively. PI was associated with LSI measures of cutaneous perfusion throughout experiments (p < 0.001). iPPG responses to study task correlated with those of LSI (r = 0.62, p < 0.001) and were comparable among subjects. iPPG is sensitive to autonomic nervous activity in volunteers and is closely associated with cutaneous perfusion.

Remote Photoplethysmographic Assessment of the Peripheral Circulation in Critical Care Patients Recovering From Cardiac Surgery

PURPOSE

Camera-based photoplethysmography (cbPPG) remotely detects the volume pulse of cardiac ejection in the peripheral circulation. The cbPPG signal is sourced from the cutaneous microcirculation, yields a 2-dimensional intensity map, and is therefore an interesting monitoring technique. In this study, we investigated whether cbPPG is in general sufficiently sensitive to discern hemodynamic conditions.

METHODS

cbPPG recordings of 70 patients recovering from cardiac surgery were analyzed. Photoplethysmograms were processed offline and the optical pulse power (OPP) of cardiac ejection was calculated. Hemodynamic data, image intensity, and patient movements were recorded synchronously. The effects of hemodynamic parameters and measurement conditions on the patient's individual OPP variability and their actual OPP values were calculated in mixed-effects regression models.

RESULTS

Mean arterial pressure (MAP), pulse pressure (PP), heart rate (HR), and central venous pressure (CVP) significantly explained the individual OPP variability. PP had the highest explanatory power (19.9%). Averaged OPP significantly increased with PP and MAP (P < 0.001, respectively) and decreased with higher HR (P = 0.024). CVP had a 2-directional, nonsignificant effect on averaged OPP. Image intensity and patient movements did significantly affect OPP. After adjustment for hemodynamic covariables and measurement conditions, the effect of PP and HR remained unchanged, whereas that of MAP vanished.

CONCLUSION

cbPPG is sensitive to hemodynamic parameters in critical care patients. It is a potential application for monitoring the peripheral circulation. Its value in a clinical setting has to be determined.

Identification and Tracking of Physiological Parameters from Skin using Video Photoplethysmography

In recent years, there has been a growing interest in video Photoplethysmography (vPPG), a technique able to estimate cardiovascular parameters from video recordings of the skin. Despite the growing interest in vPPG technology, there are still problems in extracting the correct waveform of blood volume pulse, mainly due to real world artifacts, such as changes in light condition and movement artifacts. Another important issue is the correct definition of skin against background. Therefore, we propose an algorithm of skin detection that is able to recognize skin pixels solid to variations of luminosity. We recorded the signals of interest during an experimental protocol designed to provide thermal stimulation and observe the resulting Autonomic Nervous System changes. Experimental data were gathered from 10 young healthy subjects (age: 21±2 years). Video recordings are processed using a band-pass filter and then an automatic algorithm of peak detection is applied to detect the pulse wave peaks, then used to estimate heart rate variability (HRV). The efficiency and stability of the algorithm are compared against finger-PPG waveforms. Preliminary results show an overall statistical agreement between time and frequency domain indexes. However, further efforts are required to improve the estimation of frequency components, particularly during rest.

PulseCam: a camera-based, motion-robust and highly sensitive blood perfusion imaging modality

Blood carries oxygen and nutrients to the trillions of cells in our body to sustain vital life processes. Lack of blood perfusion can cause irreversible cell damage. Therefore, blood perfusion measurement has widespread clinical applications. In this paper, we develop PulseCam - a new camera-based, motion-robust, and highly sensitive blood perfusion imaging modality with 1 mm spatial resolution and 1 frame-per-second temporal resolution. Existing camera-only blood perfusion imaging modality suffers from two core challenges: (i) motion artifact, and (ii) small signal recovery in the presence of large surface reflection and measurement noise. PulseCam addresses these challenges by robustly combining the video recording from the camera with a pulse waveform measured using a conventional pulse oximeter to obtain reliable blood perfusion maps in the presence of motion artifacts and outliers in the video recordings. For video stabilization, we adopt a novel brightness-invariant optical flow algorithm that helps us reduce error in blood perfusion estimate below 10% in different motion scenarios compared to 20-30% error when using current approaches. PulseCam can detect subtle changes in blood perfusion below the skin with at least two times better sensitivity, three times better response time, and is significantly cheaper compared to infrared thermography. PulseCam can also detect venous or partial blood flow occlusion that is difficult to identify using existing modalities such as the perfusion index measured using a pulse oximeter. With the help of a pilot clinical study, we also demonstrate that PulseCam is robust and reliable in an operationally challenging surgery room setting. We anticipate that PulseCam will be used both at the bedside as well as a point-of-care blood perfusion imaging device to visualize and analyze blood perfusion in an easy-to-use and cost-effective manner.

An open-source remote heart rate imaging method with practical apparatus and algorithms

Recent developments in computer science and digital image processing have enabled the extraction of an individual’s heart pulsations from pixel changes in recorded video images of human skin surfaces. This method is termed remote photoplethysmography (rPPG) and can be achieved with consumer-level cameras (e.g., a webcam or mobile camera). The goal of the present publication is two-fold. First, we aim to organize future rPPG software developments in a tractable and nontechnical manner, such that the public gains access to a basic open-source rPPG code, comes to understand its utility, and can follow its most recent progressions. The second goal is to investigate rPPG’s accuracy in detecting heart rates from the skin surfaces of several body parts after physical exercise and under ambient lighting conditions with a consumer-level camera. We report that rPPG is highly accurate when the camera is aimed at facial skin tissue, but that the heart rate recordings from wrist regions are less reliable, and recordings from the calves are unreliable. Facial rPPG remained accurate despite the high heart rates after exercise. The proposed research procedures and the experimental findings provide guidelines for future studies on rPPG.

Cardiovascular assessment by imaging photoplethysmography - a review

Over the last few years, the contactless acquisition of cardiovascular parameters using cameras has gained immense attention. The technique provides an optical means to acquire cardiovascular information in a very convenient way. This review provides an overview on the technique's background and current realizations. Besides giving detailed information on the most widespread application of the technique, namely the contactless acquisition of heart rate, we outline further concepts and we critically discuss the current state.

A Model for Waveform Dissimilarities in Dual-Depth Reflectance-PPG

The pressure wave is attenuated as it travels through the vascular bed of tissue. Consequently, reflectance photoplethysmography (PPG) waveforms probed using dual-penetrating wavelengths, such as green (G) and red R; the deepest) are dissimilar. To unravel the dual-depth aspect of PPG, we modeled the wavelength-dependency of the shape of reflection-PPG signals in G (520-580 nm) and R (625-720nm). Skin compression perturbs the relative contributions of the dermal and subdermal blood volume variations sources (BVVs) to PPG and was used to verify our model. We acquired reflectance-PPG in G and R on the finger of nine subjects (ages, 26-32 yrs). Two parameters were used for describing dual-depth dissimilarities: the phase shift, $\phi $, between the first harmonics of the subdermal and dermal BVVs, and the observed phase shift (PS) between PPG signals in G and R. The average $\phi $ was 37.6, CI 95% [22.0, 53.2] degrees. At uncompressed skin, this corresponds to an average PS of 12.5, [7.8, 17.2] degrees. Our results suggest that phase parameters may enable microvascular characterization and diagnosis.

The value of polarization in camera-based photoplethysmography

Camera-based photoplethysmography (cbPPG) is a novel measuring technique that permits the remote acquisition of cardiovascular signals using video cameras. Research still lacks in fundamental studies to reach a deeper technical and physiological understanding. This work analyzes the employment of polarization filtration to (i) assess the gain for the signal quality and (ii) draw conclusions about the cbPPG signal's origin. We evaluated various forehead regions of 18 recordings with different color and filter settings. Our results prove that for an optimal illumination, the perpendicular filter setting provides a significant benefit. The outcome supports the theory that signals arise from blood volume changes. For lateral illumination, ballistocardiographic effects dominate the signal as polarization's impact vanishes.

Multispectral, Fluorescent and Photoplethysmographic Imaging for Remote Skin Assessment

Optical tissue imaging has several advantages over the routine clinical imaging methods, including non-invasiveness (it does not change the structure of tissues), remote operation (it avoids infections) and the ability to quantify the tissue condition by means of specific image parameters. Dermatologists and other skin experts need compact (preferably pocket-size), self-sustaining and easy-to-use imaging devices. The operational principles and designs of ten portable in-vivo skin imaging prototypes developed at the Biophotonics Laboratory of Institute of Atomic Physics and Spectroscopy, University of Latvia during the recent five years are presented in this paper. Four groups of imaging devices are considered. Multi-spectral imagers offer possibilities for distant mapping of specific skin parameters, thus facilitating better diagnostics of skin malformations. Autofluorescence intensity and photobleaching rate imagers show a promising potential for skin tumor identification and margin delineation. Photoplethysmography video-imagers ensure remote detection of cutaneous blood pulsations and can provide real-time information on cardiovascular parameters and anesthesia efficiency. Multimodal skin imagers perform several of the abovementioned functions by taking a number of spectral and video images with the same image sensor. Design details of the developed prototypes and results of clinical tests illustrating their functionality are presented and discussed.

Skin inhomogeneity as a source of error in remote PPG-imaging

Remote photoplethysmography (rPPG) imaging is an optical technique to remotely assess the local cutaneous microcirculation. Despite its potential for enabling health-related applications, the current understanding of the outcome images/maps remains incomplete. In this paper, we present a model and supporting experiments confirming the contribution of skin inhomogeneity to the morphology of PPG waveforms. Since rPPG imagers rely on the complex inner-product operator and may combine multiple wavelengths, the derived phase measurements reflect morphological heterogeneity of PPG signals to a larger extent than propagation-related phase differences. The influence of light penetration depth on PPG was observed and modeled on the green and red wavelengths at the hand region. We further show how our work contributes to understanding reproducibility issues in recent papers on pulse wave velocity (PWV) estimation.