The highly conserved tRNAHis guanylyltransferase Thg1p interacts with the origin recognition complex and is required for the G2/M phase transition in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Genetic Interactions and Molecular Evolution of the Duplicated Genes ICARUS2 and ICARUS1 Help Arabidopsis Plants Adapt to Different Ambient Temperatures

Understanding how plants adapt to ambient temperatures has become a major challenge prompted by global climate change. This has led to the identification of several genes regulating the thermal plasticity of plant growth and flowering time. However, the mechanisms accounting for the natural variation and evolution of such developmental plasticity remain mostly unknown. In this study, we determined that natural variation at ICARUS2 (ICA2), which interacts genetically with its homolog ICA1, alters growth and flowering time plasticity in relation to temperature in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana). Transgenic analyses demonstrated multiple functional effects for ICA2 and supported the notion that structural polymorphisms in ICA2 likely underlie its natural variation. Two major ICA2 haplogroups carrying distinct functionally active alleles showed high frequency, strong geographic structure, and significant associations with climatic variables related to annual and daily fluctuations in temperature. Genome analyses across the plant phylogeny indicated that the prevalent plant ICA genes encoding two tRNAHis guanylyl transferase 1 units evolved ∼120 million years ago during the early divergence of mono- and dicotyledonous clades. In addition, ICA1/ICA2 duplication occurred specifically in the Camelineae tribe (Brassicaceae). Thus, ICA2 appears to be ubiquitous across plant evolution and likely contributes to climate adaptation through modifications of thermal developmental plasticity in Arabidopsis.

The Role of 3' to 5' Reverse RNA Polymerization in tRNA Fidelity and Repair

The tRNA^His guanylyltransferase (Thg1) superfamily includes enzymes that are found in all three domains of life that all share the common ability to catalyze the 3′ to 5′ synthesis of nucleic acids. This catalytic activity, which is the reverse of all other known DNA and RNA polymerases, makes this enzyme family a subject of biological and mechanistic interest. Previous biochemical, structural, and genetic investigations of multiple members of this family have revealed that Thg1 enzymes use the 3′ to 5′ chemistry for multiple reactions in biology. Here, we describe the current state of knowledge regarding the catalytic features and biological functions that have been so far associated with Thg1 and its homologs. Progress toward the exciting possibility of utilizing this unusual protein activity for applications in biotechnology is also discussed.

Molecular mechanism of substrate recognition and specificity of tRNAHis guanylyltransferase during nucleotide addition in the 3'-5' direction

The tRNA^His guanylyltransferase (Thg1) transfers a guanosine triphosphate (GTP) in the 3'-5' direction onto the 5'-terminal of tRNA^His, opposite adenosine at position 73 (A₇₃). The guanosine at the -1 position (G_-1) serves as an identity element for histidyl-tRNA synthetase. To investigate the mechanism of recognition for the insertion of GTP opposite A₇₃, first we constructed a two-stranded tRNA^His molecule composed of a primer and a template strand through division at the D-loop. Next, we evaluated the structural requirements of the incoming GTP from the incorporation efficiencies of GTP analogs into the two-piece tRNA^His Nitrogen at position 7 and the 6-keto oxygen of the guanine base were important for G_-1 addition; however, interestingly, the 2-amino group was found not to be essential from the highest incorporation efficiency of inosine triphosphate. Furthermore, substitution of the conserved A₇₃ in tRNA^His revealed that the G_-1 addition reaction was more efficient onto the template containing the opposite A₇₃ than onto the template with cytidine (C₇₃) or other bases forming canonical Watson-Crick base-pairing. Some interaction might occur between incoming GTP and A₇₃, which plays a role in the prevention of continuous templated 3'-5' polymerization. This study provides important insights into the mechanism of accurate tRNA^His maturation.

Crystal structure of tRNAHis guanylyltransferase from Saccharomyces cerevisiae

tRNA maturation involves several steps, including processing, splicing, CCA addition, and posttranscriptional modifications. tRNA^His guanylyltransferase (Thg1) is the only enzyme known to catalyze templated nucleotide addition in the 3'-5' direction, unlike other DNA and RNA polymerases. For a better understanding of its unique catalytic mechanism at the molecular level, we determined the crystal structure of GTP-bound Thg1 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae at the maximum resolution of 3.0 Å. The structure revealed the enzyme to have a tetrameric conformation that is well conserved among different species, and the GTP molecule was clearly bound at the active site, coordinating with two magnesium ions. In addition, two flexible protomers at the potential binding site (PBS) for tRNA^His were observed. We suggest that the PBS of the tetramer could also be one of the sites for interaction with partner proteins.

Identification of distinct biological functions for four 3'-5' RNA polymerases

The superfamily of 3'-5' polymerases synthesize RNA in the opposite direction to all other DNA/RNA polymerases, and its members include eukaryotic tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (Thg1), as well as Thg1-like proteins (TLPs) of unknown function that are broadly distributed, with family members in all three domains of life. Dictyostelium discoideum encodes one Thg1 and three TLPs (DdiTLP2, DdiTLP3 and DdiTLP4). Here, we demonstrate that depletion of each of the genes results in a significant growth defect, and that each protein catalyzes a unique biological reaction, taking advantage of specialized biochemical properties. DdiTLP2 catalyzes a mitochondria-specific tRNA(His) maturation reaction, which is distinct from the tRNA(His) maturation reaction typically catalyzed by Thg1 enzymes on cytosolic tRNA. DdiTLP3 catalyzes tRNA repair during mitochondrial tRNA 5'-editing in vivo and in vitro, establishing template-dependent 3'-5' polymerase activity of TLPs as a bona fide biological activity for the first time since its unexpected discovery more than a decade ago. DdiTLP4 is cytosolic and, surprisingly, catalyzes robust 3'-5' polymerase activity on non-tRNA substrates, strongly implying further roles for TLP 3'-5' polymerases in eukaryotes.

Template-dependent nucleotide addition in the reverse (3'-5') direction by Thg1-like protein

Thg1-like protein (TLP) catalyzes the addition of a nucleotide to the 5'-end of truncated transfer RNA (tRNA) species in a Watson-Crick template-dependent manner. The reaction proceeds in two steps: the activation of the 5'-end by adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP)/guanosine 5'-triphosphate (GTP), followed by nucleotide addition. Structural analyses of the TLP and its reaction intermediates have revealed the atomic detail of the template-dependent elongation reaction in the 3'-5' direction. The enzyme creates two substrate binding sites for the first- and second-step reactions in the vicinity of one reaction center consisting of two Mg(2+) ions, and the two reactions are executed at the same reaction center in a stepwise fashion. When the incoming nucleotide is bound to the second binding site with Watson-Crick hydrogen bonds, the 3'-OH of the incoming nucleotide and the 5'-triphosphate of the tRNA are moved to the reaction center where the first reaction has occurred. That the 3'-5' elongation enzyme performs this elaborate two-step reaction in one catalytic center suggests that these two reactions have been inseparable throughout the process of protein evolution. Although TLP and Thg1 have similar tetrameric organization, the tRNA binding mode of TLP is different from that of Thg1, a tRNA(His)-specific G-1 addition enzyme. Each tRNA(His) binds to three of the four Thg1 tetramer subunits, whereas in TLP, tRNA only binds to a dimer interface and the elongation reaction is terminated by measuring the accepter stem length through the flexible β-hairpin. Furthermore, mutational analyses show that tRNA(His) is bound to TLP in a similar manner as Thg1, thus indicating that TLP has a dual binding mode.

Natural Variation Identifies ICARUS1, a Universal Gene Required for Cell Proliferation and Growth at High Temperatures in Arabidopsis thaliana

Plants are highly sensitive to environmental changes and even small variations in ambient temperature have severe consequences on their growth and development. Temperature affects multiple aspects of plant development, but the processes and mechanisms underlying thermo-sensitive growth responses are mostly unknown. Here we exploit natural variation in Arabidopsis thaliana to identify and characterize novel components and processes mediating thermo-sensitive growth responses in plants. Phenotypic screening of wild accessions identified several strains displaying pleiotropic growth defects, at cellular and organism levels, specifically at high ambient temperatures. Positional cloning and characterization of the underlying gene revealed that ICARUS1 (ICA1), which encodes a protein of the tRNA^His guanylyl transferase (Thg1) superfamily, is required for plant growth at high temperatures. Transcriptome and gene marker analyses together with DNA content measurements show that ICA1 loss-of-function results in down regulation of cell cycle associated genes at high temperatures, which is linked with a block in G2/M transition and endoreduplication. In addition, plants with mutations in ICA1 show enhanced sensitivity to DNA damage. Characterization of additional strains that carry lesions in ICA1, but display normal growth, shows that alternative splicing is likely to alleviate the deleterious effects of some natural mutations. Furthermore, analyses of worldwide and regional collections of natural accessions indicate that ICA1 loss-of-function has arisen several times independently, and that these occur at high frequency in some local populations. Overall our results suggest that ICA1-mediated-modulation of fundamental processes such as tRNA^His maturation, modify plant growth responses to temperature changes in a quantitative and reversible manner, in natural populations.

The increase in average temperatures across the globe has been predicted to have negative impacts on agricultural productivity. Therefore, there is a need to understand the molecular mechanisms that underlie plant growth responses to varying temperature regimes. At present, very little is known about the genes and pathways that modulate thermo-sensory growth responses in plants. In this article, the authors exploit natural variation in the commonly occurring weed thale cress (Arabidopsis thaliana) and identify a gene referred to as ICARUS1 to be required for plant growth at higher ambient temperatures. Plants carrying lesions in this gene stop growing at high temperatures and revert to growth when temperatures reduce. Using a combination of computational, molecular and cell biological approaches, the authors demonstrate that allelic variation at ICARUS1, which encodes an enzyme required for the fundamental biochemical process of tRNA^His maturation, underlies variation in thermo-sensory growth responses of A. thaliana. Furthermore, the authors discover that the deleterious impact of a natural mutation in ICARUS1 is suppressed through alternative splicing, thus suggesting the potential for alternative splicing to buffer the impacts of some natural mutations. These results support that modulation of fundamental processes, in addition to transcriptional regulation, mediate thermo-sensory growth responses in plants.

Life without post-transcriptional addition of G-1: two alternatives for tRNAHis identity in Eukarya

The identity of tRNA(His) is strongly associated with the presence of an additional 5'-guanosine residue (G-1) in all three domains of life. The critical nature of the G-1 residue is underscored by the fact that two entirely distinct mechanisms for its acquisition are observed, with cotranscriptional incorporation observed in Bacteria, while post-transcriptional addition of G-1 occurs in Eukarya. Here, through our investigation of eukaryotes that lack obvious homologs of the post-transcriptional G-1-addition enzyme Thg1, we identify alternative pathways to tRNA(His) identity that controvert these well-established rules. We demonstrate that Trypanosoma brucei, like Acanthamoeba castellanii, lacks the G-1 identity element on tRNA(His) and utilizes a noncanonical G-1-independent histidyl-tRNA synthetase (HisRS). Purified HisRS enzymes from A. castellanii and T. brucei exhibit a mechanism of tRNA(His) recognition that is distinct from canonical G-1-dependent synthetases. Moreover, noncanonical HisRS enzymes genetically complement the loss of THG1 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, demonstrating the biological relevance of the G-1-independent aminoacylation activity. In contrast, in Caenorhabditis elegans, which is another Thg1-independent eukaryote, the G-1 residue is maintained, but here its acquisition is noncanonical. In this case, the G-1 is encoded and apparently retained after 5' end processing, which has so far only been observed in Bacteria and organelles. Collectively, these observations unearth a widespread and previously unappreciated diversity in eukaryotic tRNA(His) identity mechanisms.

Doing it in reverse: 3'-to-5' polymerization by the Thg1 superfamily

The tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (Thg1) family of enzymes comprises members from all three domains of life (Eucarya, Bacteria, Archaea). Although the initial activity associated with Thg1 enzymes was a single 3'-to-5' nucleotide addition reaction that specifies tRNA(His) identity in eukaryotes, the discovery of a generalized base pair-dependent 3'-to-5' polymerase reaction greatly expanded the scope of Thg1 family-catalyzed reactions to include tRNA repair and editing activities in bacteria, archaea, and organelles. While the identification of the 3'-to-5' polymerase activity associated with Thg1 enzymes is relatively recent, the roots of this discovery and its likely physiological relevance were described ≈ 30 yr ago. Here we review recent advances toward understanding diverse Thg1 family enzyme functions and mechanisms. We also discuss possible evolutionary origins of Thg1 family-catalyzed 3'-to-5' addition activities and their implications for the currently observed phylogenetic distribution of Thg1-related enzymes in biology.

tRNAHis-guanylyltransferase establishes tRNAHis identity

Histidine transfer RNA (tRNA) is unique among tRNA species as it carries an additional nucleotide at its 5' terminus. This unusual G(-1) residue is the major tRNA(His) identity element, and essential for recognition by the cognate histidyl-tRNA synthetase to allow efficient His-tRNA(His) formation. In many organisms G(-1) is added post-transcriptionally as part of the tRNA maturation process. tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (Thg1) specifically adds the guanylyate residue by recognizing the tRNA(His) anticodon. Thg1 homologs from all three domains of life have been the subject of exciting research that gave rise to a detailed biochemical, structural and phylogenetic enzyme characterization. Thg1 homologs are phylogenetically classified into eukaryal- and archaeal-type enzymes differing characteristically in their cofactor requirements and specificity. Yeast Thg1 displays a unique but limited ability to add 2-3 G or C residues to mutant tRNA substrates, thus catalyzing a 3' → 5' RNA polymerization. Archaeal-type Thg1, which has been horizontally transferred to certain bacteria and few eukarya, displays a more relaxed substrate range and may play additional roles in tRNA editing and repair. The crystal structure of human Thg1 revealed a fascinating structural similarity to 5' → 3' polymerases, indicating that Thg1 derives from classical polymerases and evolved to assume its specific function in tRNA(His) processing.

Change of tRNA identity leads to a divergent orthogonal histidyl-tRNA synthetase/tRNAHis pair

Mature tRNA^His has at its 5′-terminus an extra guanylate, designated as G⁻¹. This is the major recognition element for histidyl-tRNA synthetase (HisRS) to permit acylation of tRNA^His with histidine. However, it was reported that tRNA^His of a subgroup of α-proteobacteria, including Caulobacter crescentus, lacks the critical G⁻¹ residue. Here we show that recombinant C. crescentus HisRS allowed complete histidylation of a C. crescentus tRNA^His transcript (lacking G⁻¹). The addition of G⁻¹ did not improve aminoacylation by C. crescentus HisRS. However, mutations in the tRNA^His anticodon caused a drastic loss of in vitro histidylation, and mutations of bases A73 and U72 also reduced charging. Thus, the major recognition elements in C. crescentus tRNA^His are the anticodon, the discriminator base and U72, which are recognized by the divergent (based on sequence similarity) C. crescentus HisRS. Transplantation of these recognition elements into an Escherichia coli tRNA^His template, together with addition of base U20a, created a competent substrate for C. crescentus HisRS. These results illustrate how a conserved tRNA recognition pattern changed during evolution. The data also uncovered a divergent orthogonal HisRS/tRNA^His pair.

tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (THG1), a unique 3'-5' nucleotidyl transferase, shares unexpected structural homology with canonical 5'-3' DNA polymerases

All known DNA and RNA polymerases catalyze the formation of phosphodiester bonds in a 5' to 3' direction, suggesting this property is a fundamental feature of maintaining and dispersing genetic information. The tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (Thg1) is a member of a unique enzyme family whose members catalyze an unprecedented reaction in biology: 3'-5' addition of nucleotides to nucleic acid substrates. The 2.3-Å crystal structure of human THG1 (hTHG1) reported here shows that, despite the lack of sequence similarity, hTHG1 shares unexpected structural homology with canonical 5'-3' DNA polymerases and adenylyl/guanylyl cyclases, two enzyme families known to use a two-metal-ion mechanism for catalysis. The ability of the same structural architecture to catalyze both 5'-3' and 3'-5' reactions raises important questions concerning selection of the 5'-3' mechanism during the evolution of nucleotide polymerases.

tRNA biology charges to the front

tRNA biology has come of age, revealing an unprecedented level of understanding and many unexpected discoveries along the way. This review highlights new findings on the diverse pathways of tRNA maturation, and on the formation and function of a number of modifications. Topics of special focus include the regulation of tRNA biosynthesis, quality control tRNA turnover mechanisms, widespread tRNA cleavage pathways activated in response to stress and other growth conditions, emerging evidence of signaling pathways involving tRNA and cleavage fragments, and the sophisticated intracellular tRNA trafficking that occurs during and after biosynthesis.

The requirement for the highly conserved G-1 residue of Saccharomyces cerevisiae tRNAHis can be circumvented by overexpression of tRNAHis and its synthetase

Nearly all tRNA(His) species have an additional 5' guanine nucleotide (G(-1)). G(-1) is encoded opposite C(73) in nearly all prokaryotes and in some archaea, and is added post-transcriptionally by tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (Thg1) opposite A(73) in eukaryotes, and opposite C(73) in other archaea. These divergent mechanisms of G(-1) conservation suggest that G(-1) might have an important cellular role, distinct from its role in tRNA(His) charging. Thg1 is also highly conserved and is essential in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. However, the essential roles of Thg1 are unclear since Thg1 also interacts with Orc2 of the origin recognition complex, is implicated in the cell cycle, and catalyzes an unusual template-dependent 3'-5' (reverse) polymerization in vitro at the 5' end of activated tRNAs. Here we show that thg1-Delta strains are viable, but only if histidyl-tRNA synthetase and tRNA(His) are overproduced, demonstrating that the only essential role of Thg1 is its G(-1) addition activity. Since these thg1-Delta strains have severe growth defects if cytoplasmic tRNA(His) A(73) is overexpressed, and distinct, but milder growth defects, if tRNA(His) C(73) is overexpressed, these results show that the tRNA(His) G(-1) residue is important, but not absolutely essential, despite its widespread conservation. We also show that Thg1 catalyzes 3'-5' polymerization in vivo on tRNA(His) C(73), but not on tRNA(His) A(73), demonstrating that the 3'-5' polymerase activity is pronounced enough to have a biological role, and suggesting that eukaryotes may have evolved to have cytoplasmic tRNA(His) with A(73), rather than C(73), to prevent the possibility of 3'-5' polymerization.

Template-dependent 3'-5' nucleotide addition is a shared feature of tRNAHis guanylyltransferase enzymes from multiple domains of life

The presence of an additional 5' guanosine residue (G(-1)) is a unique feature of tRNA(His). G(-1) is incorporated posttranscriptionally in eukarya via an unusual 3'-5' nucleotide addition reaction catalyzed by the tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (Thg1). Yeast Thg1 catalyzes an unexpected second activity: Watson-Crick-dependent 3'-5' nucleotide addition that occurs in the opposite direction to nucleotide addition by all known DNA and RNA polymerases. This discovery led to the hypothesis that there are alternative roles for Thg1 family members that take advantage of this unusual enzymatic activity. Here we show that archaeal homologs of Thg1 catalyze G(-1) addition, in vitro and in vivo in yeast, but only in a templated reaction, i.e. with tRNA(His) substrates that contain a C(73) discriminator nucleotide. Because tRNA(His) from archaea contains C(73), these findings are consistent with a physiological function for templated nucleotide addition in archaeal tRNA(His) maturation. Moreover, unlike yeast Thg1, archaeal Thg1 enzymes also exhibit a preference for template-dependent U(-1) addition to A(73)-containing tRNA(His). Taken together, these results demonstrate that Watson-Crick template-dependent 3'-5' nucleotide addition is a shared catalytic activity exhibited by Thg1 family members from multiple domains of life, and therefore, that this unusual reaction may constitute an ancestral activity present in the earliest members of the Thg1 enzyme family.

Identification of critical residues for G-1 addition and substrate recognition by tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase

The yeast tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (Thg1) is an essential enzyme in yeast. Thg1 adds a single G residue to the 5' end of tRNA(His) (G(-1)), which serves as a crucial determinant for aminoacylation of tRNA(His). Thg1 is the only known gene product that catalyzes the 3'-5' addition of a single nucleotide via a normal phosphodiester bond, and since there is no identifiable sequence similarity between Thg1 and any other known enzyme family, the mechanism by which Thg1 catalyzes this unique reaction remains unclear. We have altered 29 highly conserved Thg1 residues to alanine, and using three assays to assess Thg1 catalytic activity and substrate specificity, we have demonstrated that the vast majority of these highly conserved residues (24/29) affect Thg1 function in some measurable way. We have identified 12 Thg1 residues that are critical for G(-1) addition, based on significantly decreased ability to add G(-1) to tRNA(His) in vitro and significant defects in complementation of a thg1Delta yeast strain. We have also identified a single Thg1 alteration (D68A) that causes a dramatic decrease in the rigorous specificity of Thg1 for tRNA(His). This single alteration enhances the k(cat)/K(M) for ppp-tRNA(Phe) by nearly 100-fold relative to that of wild-type Thg1. These results suggest that Thg1 substrate recognition is at least in part mediated by preventing recognition of incorrect substrates for nucleotide addition.

tRNAHis guanylyltransferase catalyzes a 3'-5' polymerization reaction that is distinct from G-1 addition

Yeast tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase, Thg1, is an essential protein that adds a single guanine to the 5' end (G(-1)) of tRNA(His). This G(-1) residue is required for aminoacylation of tRNA(His) by histidyl-tRNA synthetase, both in vitro and in vivo. The guanine nucleotide addition reaction catalyzed by Thg1 extends the polynucleotide chain in the reverse (3'-5') direction of other known polymerases, albeit by one nucleotide. Here, we show that alteration of the 3' end of the Thg1 substrate tRNA(His) unleashes an unexpected reverse polymerase activity of wild-type Thg1, resulting in the 3'-5' addition of multiple nucleotides to the tRNA, with efficiency comparable to the G(-1) addition reaction. The addition of G(-1) forms a mismatched G.A base pair at the 5' end of tRNA(His), and, with monophosphorylated tRNA substrates, it is absolutely specific for tRNA(His). By contrast, reverse polymerization forms multiple G.C or C.G base pairs, and, with preactivated tRNA species, it can initiate at positions other than -1 and is not specific for tRNA(His). Thus, wild-type Thg1 catalyzes a templated polymerization reaction acting in the reverse direction of that of canonical DNA and RNA polymerases. Surprisingly, Thg1 can also readily use dNTPs for nucleotide addition. These results suggest that 3'-5' polymerization represents either an uncharacterized role for Thg1 in RNA or DNA repair or metabolism, or it may be a remnant of an earlier catalytic strategy used in nature.

Depletion of Saccharomyces cerevisiae tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase Thg1p leads to uncharged tRNAHis with additional m(5)C

The essential Saccharomyces cerevisiae tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (Thg1p) is responsible for the unusual G(-1) addition to the 5' end of cytoplasmic tRNA(His). We report here that tRNA(His) from Thg1p-depleted cells is uncharged, although histidyl tRNA synthetase is active and the 3' end of the tRNA is intact, suggesting that G(-1) is a critical determinant for aminoacylation of tRNA(His) in vivo. Thg1p depletion leads to activation of the GCN4 pathway, most, but not all, of which is Gcn2p dependent, and to the accumulation of tRNA(His) in the nucleus. Surprisingly, tRNA(His) in Thg1p-depleted cells accumulates additional m(5)C modifications, which are delayed relative to the loss of G(-1) and aminoacylation. The additional modification is likely due to tRNA m(5)C methyltransferase Trm4p. We developed a new method to map m(5)C residues in RNA and localized the additional m(5)C to positions 48 and 50. This is the first documented example of the accumulation of additional modifications in a eukaryotic tRNA species.