Effects of amino acid substitutions in the -10 binding region of sigma E from Bacillus subtilis

The pneumococcal σX activator, ComW, is a DNA-binding protein critical for natural transformation

Natural genetic transformation via horizontal gene transfer enables rapid adaptation to dynamic environments and contributes to both antibiotic resistance and vaccine evasion among bacterial populations. In Streptococcus pneumoniae (pneumococcus), transformation occurs when cells enter competence, a transient state in which cells express the competence master regulator, SigX (σ^Χ), an alternative σ factor (σ), and a competence co-regulator, ComW. Together, ComW and σ^X facilitate expression of the genes required for DNA uptake and genetic recombination. SigX activity depends on ComW, as ΔcomW cells transcribe late genes and transform at levels 10- and 10,000-fold below that of WT cells, respectively. Previous findings suggest that ComW functions during assembly of the RNA polymerase-σ^X holoenzyme to help promote transcription from σ^X-targeted promoters. However, it remains unknown how ComW facilitates holoenzyme assembly. As ComW seems to be unique to Gram-positive cocci and has no sequence similarity with known transcriptional activators, here we used Rosetta to generate an ab initio model of pneumococcal ComW's 3D-structure. Using this model as a basis for further biochemical, biophysical, and genetic investigations into the molecular features important for its function, we report that ComW is a predicted globular protein and that it interacts with DNA, independently of DNA sequence. We also identified conserved motifs in ComW and show that key residues in these motifs contribute to DNA binding. Lastly, we provide evidence that ComW's DNA-binding activity is important for transformation in pneumococcus. Our findings begin to fill the gaps in understanding how ComW regulates σ^Χ activity during bacterial natural transformation.

OrthoDB: the hierarchical catalog of eukaryotic orthologs

The concept of orthology is widely used to relate genes across different species using comparative genomics, and it provides the basis for inferring gene function. Here we present the web accessible OrthoDB database that catalogs groups of orthologous genes in a hierarchical manner, at each radiation of the species phylogeny, from more general groups to more fine-grained delineations between closely related species. We used a COG-like and Inparanoid-like ortholog delineation procedure on the basis of all-against-all Smith-Waterman sequence comparisons to analyze 58 eukaryotic genomes, focusing on vertebrates, insects and fungi to facilitate further comparative studies. The database is freely available at http://cegg.unige.ch/orthodb

Mutational analysis of an extracytoplasmic-function sigma factor to investigate its interactions with RNA polymerase and DNA

The extracytoplasmic-function (ECF) family of sigma factors comprises a large group of proteins required for synthesis of a wide variety of extracytoplasmic products by bacteria. Residues important for core RNA polymerase (RNAP) binding, DNA melting, and promoter recognition have been identified in conserved regions 2 and 4.2 of primary sigma factors. Seventeen residues in region 2 and eight residues in region 4.2 of an ECF sigma factor, PvdS from Pseudomonas aeruginosa, were selected for alanine-scanning mutagenesis on the basis of sequence alignments with other sigma factors. Fourteen of the mutations in region 2 had a significant effect on protein function in an in vivo assay. Four proteins with alterations in regions 2.1 and 2.2 were purified as His-tagged fusions, and all showed a reduced affinity for core RNAP in vitro, consistent with a role in core binding. Region 2.3 and 2.4 mutant proteins retained the ability to bind core RNAP, but four mutants had reduced or no ability to cause core RNA polymerase to bind promoter DNA in a band-shift assay, identifying residues important for DNA binding. All mutations in region 4.2 reduced the activity of PvdS in vivo. Two of the region 4.2 mutant proteins were purified, and each showed a reduced ability to cause core RNA polymerase to bind to promoter DNA. The results show that some residues in PvdS have functions equivalent to those of corresponding residues in primary sigma factors; however, they also show that several residues not shared with primary sigma factors contribute to protein function.

Dependence of the E. coli promoter strength and physical parameters upon the nucleotide sequence

The energy of interaction between complementary nucleotides in promoter sequences of E. coli was calculated and visualized. The graphic method for presentation of energy properties of promoter sequences was elaborated on. Data obtained indicated that energy distribution through the length of promoter sequence results in picture with minima at -35, -8 and +7 regions corresponding to areas with elevated AT (adenine-thymine) content. The most important difference from the random sequences area is related to -8. Four promoter groups and their energy properties were revealed. The promoters with minimal and maximal energy of interaction between complementary nucleotides have low strengths, the strongest promoters correspond to promoter clusters characterized by intermediate energy values.

Formation of intermediate transcription initiation complexes at pfliD and pflgM by sigma(28) RNA polymerase

The sigma subunit of prokaryotic RNA polymerase is an important factor in the control of transcription initiation. Primary sigma factors are essential for growth, while alternative sigma factors are activated in response to various stimuli. Expression of class 3 genes during flagellum biosynthesis in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium is dependent on the alternative sigma factor sigma(28). Previously, a novel mechanism of transcription initiation at the fliC promoter by sigma(28) holoenzyme was proposed. Here, we have characterized the mechanism of transcription initiation by a holoenzyme carrying sigma(28) at the fliD and flgM promoters to determine if the mechanism of initiation observed at pfliC is a general phenomenon for all sigma(28)-dependent promoters. Temperature-dependent footprinting demonstrated that promoter binding properties and low-temperature open complex formation are similar for pfliC, pfliD, and pflgM. However, certain aspects of DNA strand separation and complex stability are promoter dependent. Open complexes form in a concerted manner at pflgM, while a sequential pattern of open complex formation occurs at pfliD. Open and initiated complexes formed by holoenzyme carrying sigma(28) are generally unstable to heparin challenge, with the exception of initiated complexes at pflgM, which are stable in the presence of nucleoside triphosphates.

Isolation and characterization of mutations in region 1.2 of Escherichia coli sigma70

Eubacterial RNA polymerase uses the sigma (sigma) subunit for recognition of and transcription initiation from promoter DNA sequences. One family of sigma factors includes those related to the primary sigma factor from Escherichia coli, sigma70. Members of the sigma70 family have four highly conserved domains, of which regions 2 to 4 are present in all members. Region 1 can be subdivided into regions 1.1 and 1.2. Region 1.1 affects DNA binding by sigma70 alone, as well as transcription initiation by holoenzyme. Region 1.2, present and highly conserved in most sigma factors, has not yet been assigned a putative function, although previous work has demonstrated that it is not required for either association with the core subunits of RNA polymerase or promoter-specific binding by holoenzyme. We generated random single amino acid substitutions targeted to region 1.2 of E. coli sigma70 as well as a deletion of region 1.2, and characterized the behaviour of the mutant sigma factors both in vivo and in vitro to investigate the function of region 1.2 during transcription initiation. In this study, we show that mutations in region 1.2 can affect promoter binding, open complex and initiated complex formation and the transition from abortive transcription to elongation.

Combined action of two transcription factors regulates genes encoding spore coat proteins of Bacillus subtilis

During sporulation of Bacillus subtilis, spore coat proteins encoded by cot genes are expressed in the mother cell and deposited on the forespore. Transcription of the cotB, cotC, and cotX genes by final sigma(K) RNA polymerase is activated by a small, DNA-binding protein called GerE. The promoter region of each of these genes has two GerE binding sites. 5' deletions that eliminated the more upstream GerE site decreased expression of lacZ fused to cotB and cotX by approximately 80% and 60%, respectively but had no effect on cotC-lacZ expression. The cotC-lacZ fusion was expressed later during sporulation than the other two fusions. Primer extension analysis confirmed that cotB mRNA increases first during sporulation, followed by cotX and cotC mRNAs over a 2-h period. In vitro transcription experiments suggest that the differential pattern of cot gene expression results from the combined action of GerE and another transcription factor, SpoIIID. A low concentration of GerE activated cotB transcription by final sigma(K) RNA polymerase, whereas a higher concentration was needed to activate transcription of cotX or cotC. SpoIIID at low concentration repressed cotC transcription, whereas a higher concentration only partially repressed cotX transcription and had little effect on cotB transcription. DNase I footprinting showed that SpoIIID binds strongly to two sites in the cotC promoter region, binds weakly to one site in the cotX promoter, and does not bind specifically to cotB. We propose that late in sporulation the rising level of GerE and the falling level of SpoIIID, together with the position and affinity of binding sites for these transcription factors in cot gene promoters, dictates the timing and level of spore coat protein synthesis, ensuring optimal assembly of the protein shell on the forespore surface.

Sigma factor displacement from RNA polymerase during Bacillus subtilis sporulation

As Bacillus subtilis proceeds through sporulation, the principal vegetative cell sigma subunit (sigma(A)) persists in the cell but is replaced in the extractable RNA polymerase (RNAP) by sporulation-specific sigma factors. To explore how this holoenzyme changeover might occur, velocity centrifugation techniques were used in conjunction with Western blot analyses to monitor the associations of RNAP with sigma(A) and two mother cell sigma factors, sigma(E) and sigma(K), which successively replace sigma(A) on RNAP. Although the relative abundance of sigma(A) with respect to RNAP remained virtually unchanged during sporulation, the percentage of the detectable sigma(A) which cosedimented with RNAP fell from approximately 50% at the onset of sporulation (T(0)) to 2 to 8% by 3 h into the process (T(3)). In a strain that failed to synthesize sigma(E), the first of the mother cell-specific sigma factors, approximately 40% of the sigma(A) remained associated with RNAP at T(3). The level of sigma(A)-RNAP cosedimentation dropped to less than 10% in a strain which synthesized a sigma(E) variant (sigma(ECR119)) that could bind to RNAP but was unable to direct sigma(E)-dependent transcription. The E-sigma(E)-to-E-sigma(K) changeover was characterized by both the displacement of sigma(E) from RNAP and the disappearance of sigma(E) from the cell. Analyses of extracts from wild-type and mutant B. subtilis showed that the sigma(K) protein is required for the displacement of sigma(E) from RNAP and also confirmed that sigma(K) is needed for the loss of the sigma(E) protein. The results indicate that the successive appearance of mother cell sigma factors, but not necessarily their activities, is an important element in the displacement of preexisting sigma factors from RNAP. It suggests that competition for RNAP by consecutive sporulation sigma factors may be an important feature of the holoenzyme changeovers that occur during sporulation.

Transcription initiation at the flagellin promoter by RNA polymerase carrying sigma28 from Salmonella typhimurium

The sigma subunit of RNA polymerase is a critical factor in positive control of transcription initiation. Primary sigma factors are essential proteins required for vegetative growth, whereas alternative sigma factors mediate transcription in response to various stimuli. Late gene expression during flagellum biosynthesis in Salmonella typhimurium is dependent upon an alternative sigma factor, sigma28, the product of the fliA gene. We have characterized the intermediate complexes formed by sigma28 holoenzyme on the pathway to open complex formation. Interactions with the promoter for the flagellin gene fliC were analyzed using DNase I and KMnO4 footprinting over a range of temperatures. We propose a model in which closed complexes are established in the upstream region of the promoter, including the -35 element, but with little significant contact in the -10 element or downstream regions of the promoter. An isomerization event extends the DNA contacts into the -10 element and the start site, with loss of the most distal upstream contacts accompanied by DNA melting to form open complexes. Melting occurs efficiently even at 16 degrees C. Once open complexes have formed, they are unstable to heparin challenge even in the presence of nucleoside triphosphates, which have been observed to stabilize open complexes at rRNA promoters.

Promoter opening via a DNA fork junction binding activity

The rate-limiting step in transcriptional initiation typically is opening the promoter DNA to expose the template strand. Opening is tightly regulated, but how it occurs is not known. These experiments identify an activity, recognition of specific DNA fork junctions, and suggest that it is critical to bacterial promoter opening. This activity is both sequence and structure specific; it recognizes the bases that constitute the upstream double-stranded/single-stranded boundary of the open complex. Promoter mutations known to reduce opening rates lead to comparable reductions in fork junction binding affinity. The activity acts to establish the upstream boundary of melted DNA and works in conjunction with two single-stranded DNA binding activities that recognize separately the two melted strands. The junction binding activity is contained within the sigma factor component of the holoenzyme. The activity occurs in both a typical prokaryotic transcription system and in a eukaryotic-like bacterial system that responds to enhancers and needs ATP. Thus DNA opening catalyzed by fork junction binding may occur in a variety of systems in which DNA must be opened to be copied.

sigma factor mutations affecting the sequence-selective interaction of RNA polymerase with -10 region single-stranded DNA

Thesigmasubunit of RNA polymerase determines promoter recognition and catalyzes DNA strand separation. The -35 promoter region is recognized by a helix-turn-helix motif in region 4, while the -10 region is specified, at least in part, by an amphipathic helix in region 2. We have proposed that conserved aromatic residues insigmaregion 2.3 interact with the non-template strand of the -10 element to drive open complex formation. We now report that Bacillus subtilis sigmaA holoenzyme, but neither core nor sigmaA alone, binds with high selectivity to single-stranded (ss) DNA containing the non-template -10 consensus sequence. UV irradiation of holoenzyme-ssDNA complexes efficiently crosslinks sigmaA to DNA and protease mapping supports a primary contact site in or near region 2. Several mutations in sigmaA region 2.3, shown previously to impair promoter melting, affect ssDNA binding: Y184A decreases binding selectivity, while Y189A and W193A decrease the efficiency of photocrosslinking. These results support a model in which these aromatic amino acids are juxtaposed to ssDNA, consistent with their demonstrated role in stabilizing the open complex.

Region 1 of sigma70 is required for efficient isomerization and initiation of transcription by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

The sigma (sigma) subunit of prokaryotic RNA polymerase is essential for promoter recognition. sigma Factor directs the RNA polymerase core subunits (alpha2beta beta') to the promoter consensus elements and thereby confers selectivity for transcription initiation. The N-terminal domain (region 1.1) of Escherichia coli sigma70 has been shown to inhibit DNA binding by the C-terminal DNA recognition domains. Since DNA recognition is the first step of transcription initiation, we predicted that the N-terminal domain of sigma70 may also influence the initiation of transcription by holoenzyme (alpha2beta beta'sigma). N-terminally truncated sigma70 derivatives were used to reconstitute holoenzyme, and transcription by the mutant holoenzymes was analyzed in vitro. Deletion of the first 75 to 100 amino acids of sigma70 (region 1.1) resulted in both a slow rate of transition from a closed promoter complex to a DNA- strand-separated open complex, as well as a reduced efficiency of transition from the open complex to a ternary initiated complex. These effects were partially reversed by the addition of a polypeptide containing region 1.1 in trans. Therefore, region 1.1 not only modulates DNA binding but is important for efficient transcription initiation, once a closed complex has formed. A deletion of the first 133 amino acids, which removes regions 1.1 and 1.2, resulted in arrest of initiation at the earliest closed complex, suggesting that region 1.2 is required for open complex formation.

Bacillus subtilis SpoIIID protein binds to two sites in the spoVD promoter and represses transcription by sigmaE RNA polymerase

The Bacillus subtilis spoVD gene encodes a penicillin-binding protein required for spore morphogenesis. SpoIIID is a sequence-specific DNA-binding protein that activates or represses the transcription of many different genes. We have defined the spoVD promoter region and demonstrated that it is recognized by sigmaE RNA polymerase in vitro and that SpoIIID represses spoVD transcription. Two strong SpoIIID-binding sites were mapped in the spoVD promoter region, one overlapping the -35 region and the other encompassing the -10 region and the transcriptional start site.

Sigma domain structure: one down, one to go

The recent publication of the 2.6 A crystal structure of a portion of sigma70 provides insight into the role of sigma during transcription initiation. This high resolution picture unveils novel questions.

Potassium permanganate susceptibility of sigma E-RNA polymerase-promoter complexes

We used potassium permanganate (KMnO4) to identify unpaired thymidine (T) residues in promoter complexes formed by RNA polymerase (RNAP) associated with sigma E (sigma E-RNAP) from Bacillus subtilis. We found that a region of the spoIIID promoter from at least -10 to +1 becomes melted in the presence of this polymerase. In promoter complexes formed by RNAP associated with a mutant sigma E that melts promoter DNA inefficiently, we noted additional KMnO4 sensitivity at the -11 position of the spoIIID promoter. We suggest that the base pair at -11 is unpaired in both mutant and wild type (wt) complexes; however, close proximity of wt sigma E-RNAP with the T at -11 may protect it from KMnO4 attack. The absence of a close contact between the mutant sigma E-RNAP and the base at -11 may explain why this polymerase uses promoters less efficiently than wt sigma E-RNAP.

Base-specific recognition of the nontemplate strand of promoter DNA by E. coli RNA polymerase

RNA polymerase recognizes its promoters through base-specific interaction between defined segments of DNA and the sigma subunit of the enzyme. This interaction leads to separation of base pairs and exposure of the template strand for RNA synthesis. We show that base-specific recognition by the sigma 70 holoenzyme in this process involves primarily nontemplate strand bases in the -10 promoter region. We suggest that melting involves the persistence of these contacts as the bound duplex (closed) form is converted to the single-stranded (open) form of the enzyme-promoter complex.

sigma E changed to sigma B specificity by amino acid substitutions in its -10 binding region

The association of a sigma factor (sigma) with RNA polymerase in bacteria determines its specificity of promoter utilization. To identify amino acid residues in sigma E from Bacillus subtilis that determine the specificity of its interaction with the nucleotides at the -10 region of its cognate promoters, we tested whether base pair substitutions in the -10 region of a sigma B-dependent promoter could signal its utilization by sigma E-RNA polymerase. We found that a combination of base pair substitutions at positions -15 and -14 of the sigma B-dependent ctc promoter resulted in its utilization by sigma E-RNA polymerase in vivo. We also found that the combination of two amino acid substitutions at positions 119 and 120 in sigma E changed its specificity for promoter utilization, resulting in a sigma factor that directed transcription from the sigma B-dependent ctc promoter, but not from sigma E-dependent promoters. These results suggest that amino acid residues at positions 119 and 120 determine, at least in part, the specificity of interactions between sigma E and the nucleotides in the -10 region of its cognate promoters.

A single amino acid substitution in sigma E affects its ability to bind core RNA polymerase

We have examined the role of the most highly conserved region of bacterial RNA polymerase sigma factors by analyzing the effect of amino acid substitutions and small deletions in sigma E from Bacillus subtilis. sigma E is required for the production of endospores in B. subtilis but not for vegetative growth. Strains expressing each of several mutant forms of sigE were found to be deficient in their ability to form endospores. Single amino acid substitutions at positions 68 and 94 resulted in sigma factors that bind with less affinity to the core subunits of RNA polymerase. The substitution at position 68 did not affect the stability of the protein in B. subtilis; therefore, this substitution probably did not have large effects on the overall structure of the sigma factor. The substitution at position 68 probably defines a position in sigma E that closely contacts a subunit of RNA polymerase, while the substitution at position 94 may define a position that is important for protein stability or for binding to core RNA polymerase.

Open complex formation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase: the mechanism of polymerase-induced strand separation of double helical DNA

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase is able to site-specifically melt 12 bp of promoter DNA at temperatures far below those normally associated with DNA melting. Here we consider several models to explain how RNA polymerase destabilizes duplex DNA. One popular model proposes that upon binding to the promoter, RNA polymerase untwists the spacer DNA between the -10 and -35 regions, which results in a destabilization of the -10 region at a TA base step where melting initiates. Promoter untwisting may result, in part, from extensive wrapping of the DNA around RNA polymerase. Formation of the strand-separated open complex appears to be facilitated by specific protein-DNA interactions which occur predominantly on the non-template strand. Recent evidence suggests that these include important contacts with sigma factor region 2.3, which we propose binds the displaced single strand of DNA.

A Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondrial transcription factor, sc-mtTFB, shares features with sigma factors but is functionally distinct

In Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondria, sc-mtTFB is a 341-amino-acid transcription factor required for initiation of transcription from mitochondrial DNA promoters. Specific transcription in vitro requires only sc-mtTFB and the bacteriophage-related core sc-mtRNA polymerase. Mutational analysis of sc-mtTFB has defined two regions of the protein that are important for normal function both in vivo and in vitro. These regions overlap portions of the protein that exhibit similarity to conserved region 2 of bacterial sigma factors. One mutation in this region of sc-mtTFB (tyrosine 108 to arginine [Y108R]) has a defective phenotype that matches that observed for mutations in the corresponding residue of Bacillus subtilis sigma A and sigma E proteins. However, mutations in the sigma 2.4-like region, including a 5-amino-acid deletion corresponding to crucial promoter-contacting amino acids of sigma factors, did not eliminate the ability of sc-mtTFB to initiate transcription specifically in vitro. This suggests a mechanism of promoter recognition for sc-mtRNA polymerase different from that used by bacterial RNA polymerases. Two mutations in a basic region of sc-mtTFB resulted in defective proteins that were virtually dependent on supercoiled DNA templates in vitro. These mutations may have disrupted a DNA-unwinding function of sc-mtTFB that is only manifested in vitro and is partially rescued by DNA supercoiling.

Genetic and physiological studies of Bacillus subtilis sigma A mutants defective in promoter melting

The Bacillus subtilis sigA gene encodes the primary sigma factor of RNA polymerase and is essential for cell growth. We have mutated conserved region 2.3 of the sigma A protein to substitute each of seven aromatic amino acids with alanine. Several of these aromatic amino acids are proposed to form a melting motif which facilitates the strand separation step of initiation. Holoenzymes containing mutant sigma factors recognize promoters, but some are defective for DNA melting in vitro. We have studied the ability of each mutant sigma factor to support cell growth by gene replacement and complementation. The two region 2.3 mutants least impaired in promoter melting in vitro (Y180A and Y184A) support cell growth in single copy, although the Y184A allele imparts a slow-growth phenotype at low temperatures. A strain expressing only the Y189A variant of the sigma A protein, known to be defective in DNA melting in vitro, grows very slowly and is altered in its pattern of protein synthesis. Only the wild-type and Y180A sigma A proteins efficiently complement a temperature-sensitive allele of sigA. Overexpression of three of the sigma A proteins defective for promoter melting in vitro (Y189A, W192A, and W193A) leads to a decrease in RNA synthesis and cell death. These results indicate that mutations which specifically impair DNA melting in vitro also impair sigma function in vivo and therefore support the hypothesis that sigma plays an essential role in both DNA melting and promoter recognition.