Multicenter performance evaluation of a new TaqMan PCR assay for monitoring human immunodeficiency virus RNA load

New design, development, and optimization of an in-house quantitative TaqMan Real-time PCR assay for HIV-1 viral load measurement

Background Viral load measurement is commonly applicable to monitor HIV infection in patients to determine the number of HIV-RNA in serum samples of individuals. The aim of the present study was to set up a highly specific, sensitive, and reproducible home-brewed Real-time PCR assay based on TaqMan chemistry to quantify HIV-1 RNA genome. Methods In this study, three sets of primer pairs and a TaqMan probe were designed for HIV subtypes conserved sequences. An internal control was included in this assay to evaluate the presence of inhibition. Standard curve and threshold cycle values were determined using in vitro transcribed RNA from int region of HIV-1. A serial dilution of RNA standards was generated by in vitro transcription, from 10 to 10⁹ copies/ml to find the sensitivity and the limit of detection (LOD) of the assay and to evaluate its performance in a quantitative RT-PCR assay. Results The assay has a low LOD equivalent to 33.13 copies/ml of HIV-1 RNA and a linear range of detection from 10 to 10⁹ copies/ml. The coefficient of variation (CV) for Inter and Intra-assay precision of this in-house HIV Real-time RT-PCR ranged from 0.28 to 2.49% and 0.72 to 4.47%, respectively. The analytical and clinical specificity was 100%. Conclusions The results indicate that the developed method has a suitable specificity and sensitivity and is highly reproducible and cost-benefit. Therefore, it will be useful to monitor HIV infection in plasma samples of individuals.

Comparative evaluation of the Aptima HIV-1 Quant Dx assay and COBAS TaqMan HIV-1 v2.0 assay using the Roche High Pure System for the quantification of HIV-1 RNA in plasma

BACKGROUND

Quantification of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) RNA in plasma has become the standard of care in the management of HIV-infected patients. There are several commercially available assays that have been implemented for the detection of HIV-1 RNA in plasma. Here, the new Hologic Aptima® HIV-1 Quant Dx assay (Aptima HIV) was compared to the Roche COBAS® TaqMan® HIV-1 Test v2.0 for use with the High Pure System (HPS/CTM).

METHODS

The performance characteristics of the assays were assessed using commercially available HIV reference panels, dilution of the WHO 3rd International HIV-1 RNA International Standard (WHO-IS) and plasma from clinical specimens. Assay performance was determined by linear regression, Deming correlation analysis and Bland-Altman analysis.

RESULTS

Testing of HIV-1 reference panels revealed excellent agreement. The 61 clinical specimens quantified in both assays were linearly associated and strongly correlated.

CONCLUSIONS

The Aptima HIV assay offers performance comparable to that of the HPS/CTM assay and, as it is run on a fully automated platform, a significantly improved workflow.

Identification and experimental validation of an HIV model for HAART treated patients

The objective of this paper is to identify the parameters of a human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) evolution model from a clinical data set of patients treated with two different highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) protocols. After introducing a model with six state variables, a preliminary step considers the reduction of the number of parameters to be identified by means of sensitivity analysis, and then identifiability items are discussed. A nonlinear optimization-based procedure for identification is developed, which divides the unknown parameters into two families: the group dependent and the patient dependent parameters. Numerical results show that the identified model can be individually adapted to each patient and this result is promising for predicting the effects (e.g., failures or successes) of therapeutic actions.

Modelling HIV-1 2-LTR dynamics following raltegravir intensification

A model of reservoir activation and viral replication is introduced accounting for the production of 2-LTR HIV-1 DNA circles following antiviral intensification with the HIV integrase inhibitor raltegravir, considering contributions of de novo infection events and exogenous sources of infected cells, including quiescent infected cell activation. The model shows that a monotonic increase in measured 2-LTR concentration post intensification is consistent with limited de novo infection primarily maintained by sources of infected cells unaffected by raltegravir, such as quiescent cell activation, while a transient increase in measured 2-LTR concentration is consistent with significant levels of efficient (R0 > 1) de novo infection. The model is validated against patient data from the INTEGRAL study and is shown to have a statistically significant fit relative to the null hypothesis of random measurement variation about a mean. We obtain estimates and confidence intervals for the model parameters, including 2-LTR half-life. Seven of the 13 patients with detectable 2-LTR concentrations from the INTEGRAL study have measured 2-LTR dynamics consistent with significant levels of efficient replication of the virus prior to treatment intensification.

Modeling uncertainty in single-copy assays for HIV

We present a simple computational model of measurement accuracy for single-copy sensitivity assays (SCA) of HIV RNA that was developed from first principles. The model shows that the SCA is significantly right-skewed. Measured virus concentrations of 1 and 10 virions/ml had overlapping 95% confidence intervals and were statistically indistinguishable.

Cross-platform analysis of HIV-1 RNA data generated by a multicenter assay validation study with wide geographic representation

HIV-1 RNA quantitation continues to be extremely important for monitoring patients infected with HIV-1, and a number of assays have been utilized for this purpose. Differences in assay performance with respect to log(10) recovery and HIV-1 subtype specificity have been well documented for commercially available assays, although comparisons are usually limited to one or two assay platforms. Two new FDA-approved assays, the Roche Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan HIV-1 test (RT) and the Abbott RealTime HIV-1 assay (AR), that utilize real-time PCR have replaced previous HIV-1 RNA platforms. Inadequate detection of some strains of HIV-1 resulted in the addition of a new primer/probe set and the introduction of a second version of the RT assay. In this study, comparisons of assay performance between the different FDA-approved HIV-1 RNA assay platforms (both new and existing) were performed by using validation data that included both well-characterized virus stock and locally collected clinical samples. Laboratories across diverse geographical regions performed the validation testing and submitted data to the Virology Quality Assurance program (VQA) for analysis. Correlation values for clinical sample testing varied across the assay platforms (r = 0.832 to 0.986), and average log(10) recoveries for HIV-1 RNA controls (compared to the nominal value) ranged from -0.215 to 0.181. These data demonstrate the need for use of one assay platform for longitudinal patient monitoring, but the data also reinforce the notion that no one assay is superior and that testing across platforms may be required for discordance reconciliation.

Measurement error robustness of a closed-loop minimal sampling method for HIV therapy switching

We test the robustness of a closed-loop treatment scheduling method to realistic HIV viral load measurement error. The purpose of the algorithm is to allow the accurate detection of an induced viral load minimum with a reduced number of samples. Therapy must be switched at or near the viral-load minimum to achieve optimal therapeutic benefit; therapeutic benefit decreases logarithmically with increased viral load at the switching time. The performance of the algorithm is characterized using a number of metrics. These include the number of samples saved vs. fixed-rate sampling, the risk-reduction achieved vs. the risk-reduction possible with frequent sampling, and the difference between the switching time vs. the theoretical optimal switching time. The algorithm is applied to simulated patient data generated from a family of data-driven patient models and corrupted by experimentally confirmed levels of log-normal noise.

Robust closed-loop minimal sampling method for HIV therapy switching strategies

The emergence of drug-resistant strains of human immunodeficiency virus during antiretroviral therapy is a major cause of treatment failure and disease progression. Development of a resistant strain necessitates switching to a new antiretroviral regimen composed of novel drugs. Recent work has shown that current methods of switching antiviral therapies carry significant unnecessary risk of subsequent failures, and optimal switching schedules to minimize this risk have been proposed. These switching schedules require frequent sampling of viral load during an induced phase of transient viral load reduction, with the goal of switching to the new antiviral regimen at an induced viral load minimum. The proposed frequent sampling carries an unacceptable level of cost both in terms of measurement expense and inconvenience to the patient. In this paper, we propose a closed-loop sampling algorithm to reduce the number of samples required to achieve the desired reduction in risk. We demonstrate through the Monte-Carlo analysis that the proposed method is able to robustly achieve an average 50% reduction in the number of required samples while maintaining a reduction in the risk of subsequent failure to under 3%, despite experimentally verified levels of model and measurement uncertainty.

Current challenges to viral load testing in the context of emerging genetic diversity of HIV-1

INTRODUCTION

One of the major characteristics of HIV-1 is its extreme genetic diversity. A key factor in assessing the sensitivity of a molecular-based assay measuring HIV-1 RNA viral load (VL) in plasma is its ability to detect/quantify all (or most of) relevant HIV-1 genetic subtype/recombinant forms accurately.

AREAS COVERED

This review provides an overview of the current commercially available quantitative real-time assays (the Abbott RealTime HIV-1, Roche TaqMan HIV-1 versions 1.0 and 2.0, BioMérieux Nuclisens EasyQ HIV-1, Siemens VERSANT HIV-1 RNA 1.0 kinetic PCR, and Biocentric Generic HIV Viral Load assays). For each assay, studies from 2005 to 2010 assessing the impact of HIV-1 genetic diversity on the reliability of HIV-1 RNA quantification are described.

EXPERT OPINION

In light of HIV-1 genetic diversity, a general recommendation to favor one test over the other cannot categorically be made. Larger field evaluations of HIV-1 RNA assays should be conducted in areas where HIV-1 genetic diversity is the highest. The large-scale implementation of HIV-1 VL testing is urgently required in the developing world to change HIV infection from a likely death sentence into a manageable chronic infection, as done in Northern countries.

Performance of NucliSens HIV-1 EasyQ Version 2.0 compared with six commercially available quantitative nucleic acid assays for detection of HIV-1 in China

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Six HIV-1 viral load assays have been widely used in China. These include the Cobas Amplicor HIV-1 Monitor Version 1.5 ('Amplicor'), Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan HIV-1 test Version 1.0 ('CAP/CTM'), Versant HIV-1 RNA Version 3.0 (branched DNA [bDNA]-based assay; 'Versant bDNA'), Abbott RealTime HIV-1 assay ('Abbott RealTime'), NucliSens HIV-1 QT (nucleic acid sequence-based amplification assay; 'NucliSens NASBA'), and NucliSens EasyQ HIV-1 Version 1.1 ('EasyQ V1.1'). Recently, an updated version of EasyQ V1.1, NucliSens EasyQ HIV-1 Version 2.0 ('EasyQ V2.0') was introduced into China. It is important to evaluate the impact of HIV-1 genotypes on the updated assay compared with the other commercial available assays in China.

METHODS

A total of 175 plasma samples with different HIV-1 clades prevalent in China were collected from treatment-naïve patients. The viral loads of those samples were determined with the seven HIV-1 viral load assays, and the quantitative differences between them were evaluated.

RESULTS

Overall, EasyQ V2.0 exhibited a significant correlation (R = 0.769-0.850, p ≤ 0.001) and high agreement (94.77-97.13%, using the Bland-Altman model) with the other six assays. Although no significant differences between EasyQ V2.0 and the other six assays were observed when quantifying clade B' samples, there were statistically significant differences between EasyQ V2.0 and the Amplicor, Versant bDNA, and Abbott RealTime assays when quantifying clade BC samples, and between EasyQ V2.0 and the Versant bDNA and Abbott RealTime assays when quantifying clade AE samples. For clade BC samples, the quantitative differences between EasyQ V2.0 and the Amplicor, Versant bDNA, and Abbott RealTime assays exceeded 0.5 log(10) IU/mL in approximately 50% of samples and exceeded 1 log(10) IU/mL in approximately 15% of samples. For clade AE samples, the quantitative differences between EasyQ V2.0 and the CAP/CTM, Versant bDNA, and Abbott RealTime assays exceeded 0.5 log(10) IU/mL in approximately 50% of samples, and the differences between EasyQ V2.0 and CAP/CTM exceeded 1 log(10) IU/mL in approximately 15% of samples.

CONCLUSION

Genotypes may affect the quantification of HIV-1 RNA, especially in clade BC samples with respect to EasyQ V2.0 and the Amplicor, Versant bDNA, or Abbott RealTime assays, and in clade AE samples with respect to EasyQ V2.0 and the Versant bDNA or Abbott RealTime assays. It is therefore strongly suggested that, where possible, the HIV-1 viral load in infected patients be quantified at follow-up by the same version of the same assay that was used initially.

Correction of underquantification of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 load with the second version of the Roche Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan assay

Initial evaluations of the Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) test (CAP/CTM) demonstrated good performance but, afterwards, reports about underquantification were published. We investigated whether the problem was solved with a second version of this assay, the Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan HIV-1 test, version 2.0 (CAP/CTM v2.0). The remaining plasma of 375 consecutive HIV-1 positive samples with a viral load of >or=4,000 copies/ml was collected in three laboratories. The samples were diluted and retested with our routine method Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas Amplicor HIV-1 monitor test v1.5 in ultrasensitive mode (CAP/CA PHS), as well as with the CAP/CTM and CAP/CTM v2.0 tests. An absolute difference between the results of two methods of >or=0.71 log(10) copies/ml was defined as moderately discrepant, and an absolute difference of >or=0.93 log(10) copies/ml was defined as severely discrepant. In addition, criteria for considering the new methods equivalent to the routine method were formulated. (i) For CAP/CTM compared to CAP/CA PHS, 36 (9.5%) and 20 (5.3%) samples were, respectively, considered moderately and severely underquantified by CAP/CTM. The mean difference between CAP/CTM and CAP/CA PHS was -0.32 log(10) copies/ml. Eight of nineteen of the severely underquantified samples were from patients infected with HIV-1 subtype B strain. (ii) For CAP/CTM v2.0 compared to CAP/CA PHS, no sample was moderately or severely underquantified by CAP/CTM v2.0. A mean difference of 0.08 log(10) copies/ml was found with CAP/CTM v2.0 compared to CAP/CA PHS. The underquantification problem of the CAP/CTM kit was clearly demonstrated. The criteria for the equivalence of CAP/CTM v2.0 to the routine test CAP/CA PHS were fulfilled.

Monitoring HIV vaccine trial participants for primary infection: studies in the SIV/macaque model

OBJECTIVES

The ability to detect and quantify acute HIV-1 infection prior to seroconversion would be an important tool for use in HIV vaccine clinical efficacy trials. We have utilized the SIV/rhesus monkey model to evaluate whether samples more easily obtained than peripheral blood might be used for intensive monitoring of vaccine trial participants.

METHODS

We have evaluated viral loads in peripheral blood, saliva, feces, and urine of five rhesus monkeys during primary SIVmac251 infection by quantitative real-time PCR. As an alternative to the direct monitoring of frozen samples, we have also developed a fully quantitative viral load assay utilizing dried blood spots.

RESULTS

Although all compartments were found to harbor viral RNA during primary infection, viral RNA could be detected in the peripheral compartments only when levels of plasma viremia exceed a threshold value of 10 RNA copies/ml. We found no direct correlation between viral burden in plasma and saliva, feces, or urine viral loads. Importantly, both dried saliva and whole blood spots can be used for viral detection. Quantitative whole blood or plasma spotting correlated well with viral burden in plasma during both the acute and set point phase of infection.

CONCLUSION

Dried blood spots are amenable to rapid quantitative viral load testing. Whole blood spotting has a significant logistical benefit as it requires low blood volumes and no blood processing. Saliva or dried saliva spots or both are potential candidates for acute phase diagnostic screening. These studies indicate the feasibility of intensive monitoring of HIV-1 vaccine trial participants for virus acquisition in resource-limited settings.

Evaluation of the Abbott m2000 RealTime human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) assay for HIV load monitoring in South Africa compared to the Roche Cobas AmpliPrep-Cobas Amplicor, Roche Cobas AmpliPrep-Cobas TaqMan HIV-1, and BioMerieux NucliSENS EasyQ HIV-1 assays

The implementation of antiretroviral therapy demands the need for increased access to viral load (VL) monitoring. Newer real-time VL testing technologies are faster and have larger dynamic ranges and fully automated extraction to benefit higher throughputs in resource-poor environments. The Abbott RealTime human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) assay was evaluated as a new option for testing for HIV-1 subtype C in South Africa, and its performance was compared to the performance of existing assays (the Cobas AmpliPrep-Cobas TaqMan HIV-1, version 1, assay; the AmpliPrep-Cobas Monitor standard HIV-1 assay; and the NucliSENS EasyQ-EasyMag HIV-1 assay) in a high-throughput laboratory. The total precision of the RealTime HIV-1 assay was acceptable over all viral load ranges. This assay compared most favorably with the Cobas AmpliPrep-Cobas TaqMan HIV-1 assay (R(2) = 0.904), with a low standard deviation of difference being detected (0.323 copies/ml). The bias against comparator assays ranged from -0.001 copies/ml to -0.228 copies/ml. Variability in the reporting of VLs for a 20-member subtype panel compared to the variability of other assays was noted with subtypes G and CRF02-AG. The RealTime HIV-1 assay can test 93 samples per day with minimal manual preparation, less staff, and the minimization of contamination through automation. This assay is suitable for HIV-1 subtype C VL quantification in South Africa.

The significance of low-level plasma HIV viral load on COBAS TaqMan HIV-1 assays for patients with undetectable plasma viral load on COBAS Amplicor monitor version 1.5

BACKGROUND

COBAS TaqMan assay is a new HIV assay for measuring plasma viral load (VL). A significant number of patients with undetectable plasma VL on Amplicor assay were reported to have detectable VL with TaqMan in the study centre.

PURPOSE

The aim of the present study was to investigate the significance of detectable VL counts with TaqMan assay amongst patients who have had undetectable plasma VL with COBAS Amplicor assay.

METHOD

Observational study on patients who have had undetectable (<less than 50 copies/mL) plasma VL with COBAS Amplicor version 1.5 assay but detectable plasma VL with COBAS TaqMan assay between June 1, 2006 and April 30, 2007. All patients were on highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) for longer than 6 months before use of COBAS TaqMan assay. Patients with detectable VL were followed up on a monthly basis until their VL was <40 copes/mL or there was confirmed new resistance to HAART using genotypic and Virco resistance assay.

RESULTS

Plasma VL was detectable (>40 copies/mL) in 113 (14%) patients on 126 episodes using TaqMan assay. VL was less than 500 copies/mL in 90% of those episodes. All episodes ended with VL <40 copies/mL after a median of 117 (94-143) days without change in HAART regimes. The duration of those episodes was longer than 150 days in 75% of cases. No new mutation was detected amongst specimens with detectable VL.

CONCLUSION

Short-term detectable VL may be common with using TaqMan assay. This phenomenon did not result in new mutations or failure of HAART in study patients in the short term.

A universal real-time PCR assay for the quantification of group-M HIV-1 proviral load

Quantification of human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) proviral DNA is increasingly used to measure the HIV-1 cellular reservoirs, a helpful marker to evaluate the efficacy of antiretroviral therapeutic regimens in HIV-1-infected individuals. Furthermore, the proviral DNA load represents a specific marker for the early diagnosis of perinatal HIV-1 infection and might be predictive of HIV-1 disease progression independently of plasma HIV-1 RNA levels and CD4(+) T-cell counts. The high degree of genetic variability of HIV-1 poses a serious challenge for the design of a universal quantitative assay capable of detecting all the genetic subtypes within the main (M) HIV-1 group with similar efficiency. Here, we describe a highly sensitive real-time PCR protocol that allows for the correct quantification of virtually all group-M HIV-1 strains with a higher degree of accuracy compared with other methods. The protocol involves three stages, namely DNA extraction/lysis, cellular DNA quantification and HIV-1 proviral load assessment. Owing to the robustness of the PCR design, this assay can be performed on crude cellular extracts, and therefore it may be suitable for the routine analysis of clinical samples even in developing countries. An accurate quantification of the HIV-1 proviral load can be achieved within 1 d from blood withdrawal.

Comparative evaluation of the automated Roche TaqMan real-time quantitative human immunodeficiency virus type 1 RNA PCR assay and the Roche AMPLICOR Version 1.5 conventional PCR assay

The need to evaluate antiviral treatment response and the emergence of resistance have made the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) viral load assay a major feature of the diagnostic monitoring of HIV-infected individuals. The objective of this study was to evaluate the utility of the recently In Vitro Diagnostic Medical Devices Directive-approved Roche COBAS AmpliPrep/TaqMan96 real-time PCR assay by comparison with the existing Roche COBAS AmpliPrep/AMPLICOR MONITOR conventional PCR assay. EDTA-treated plasma samples from 191 HIV-1-infected individuals were tested for HIV-1 RNA by the AMPLICOR assay and the TaqMan assay. This was a prospective study using 191 pairs of samples from the same bleed per patient. The correlation coefficient of the assays was 98.08%. The mean difference between the assays was 0.05 log(10) copy/ml plasma, with a standard deviation (SD) of 0.27 log(10) copy/ml plasma. Thirteen samples gave results with variances greater than 0.5 log(10) copy/ml plasma, which is our clinical cutoff. Two samples were more than 3 SD different (0.81 log(10) copy/ml plasma). The TaqMan assay appeared to be slightly more sensitive at the lower end of the dynamic range. The assays correlated significantly (P > 0.95) with each other, and the regression analysis was also highly significant (R(2) > 0.95).