The p53 complex from monkey cells modulates the biochemical activities of simian virus 40 large T antigen

Urothelial tumor initiation requires deregulation of multiple signaling pathways: implications in target-based therapies

Although formation of urothelial carcinoma of the bladder (UCB) requires multiple steps and proceeds along divergent pathways, the underlying genetic and molecular determinants for each step and pathway remain undefined. By developing transgenic mice expressing single or combinatorial genetic alterations in urothelium, we demonstrated here that overcoming oncogene-induced compensatory tumor barriers was critical for urothelial tumor initiation. Constitutively active Ha-ras (Ras*) elicited urothelial hyperplasia that was persistent and did not progress to tumors over a 10 months period. This resistance to tumorigenesis coincided with increased expression of p53 and all pRb family proteins. Expression of a Simian virus 40 T antigen (SV40T), which disables p53 and pRb family proteins, in urothelial cells expressing Ras* triggered early-onset, rapidly-growing and high-grade papillary UCB that strongly resembled the human counterpart (pTaG3). Urothelial cells expressing both Ras* and SV40T had defective G(1)/S checkpoint, elevated Ras-GTPase and hyperactivated AKT-mTOR signaling. Inhibition of the AKT-mTOR pathway with rapamycin significantly reduced the size of high-grade papillary UCB but hyperactivated mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK). Inhibition of AKT-mTOR, MAPK and STAT3 altogether resulted in much greater tumor reduction and longer survival than did inhibition of AKT-mTOR pathway alone. Our studies provide the first experimental evidence delineating the combinatorial genetic events required for initiating high-grade papillary UCB, a poorly defined and highly challenging clinical entity. Furthermore, they suggest that targeted therapy using a single agent such as rapamycin may not be highly effective in controlling high-grade UCB and that combination therapy employing inhibitors against multiple targets are more likely to achieve desirable therapeutic outcomes.

SV40: Cell transformation and tumorigenesis

The story of SV40-induced tumorigenesis and cellular transformation is intimately entwined with the development of modern molecular biology. Because SV40 and other viruses have small genomes and are relatively easy to manipulate in the laboratory, they offered tractable systems for molecular analysis. Thus, many of the early efforts to understand how eukaryotes replicate their DNA, regulate expression of their genes, and translate mRNA were focused on viral systems. The discovery that SV40 induces tumors in certain laboratory animals and transforms many types of cultured cells offered the first opportunity to explore the molecular basis for cancer. The goal of this article is to highlight some of the experiments that have led to our current view of SV40-induced transformation and to provide some context as to how they contributed to basic research in molecular biology and to our understanding of cancer.

Viruses and the cell cycle

Viruses depend on the host's machineries to replicate and express their genome. Actively replicating cells have large pools of deoxynucleotides and high levels of key enzyme activities that viruses exploit to their own needs. Some viruses have developed strategies for driving quiescent cells into the S phase of the cell cycle, e.g. adenovirus, others, such as parvovirus, wait until the host itself begins to replicate. Viruses may also force the host cell to stay in a favourable phase, e.g. Epstein-Barr virus, or, if necessary, they may inhibit apoptotic cell death, e.g. human cytomegalovirus. In this review, we focus on the different strategies that viruses use to create in infected cells an environment favourable to the accomplishment of the viral life cycle through acting on cell cycle regulators.

The initiation of simian virus 40 DNA replication in vitro

DNA replication is a complicated process that is largely regulated during stages of initiation. The Siman Virus 40 in vitro replication system has served as an excellent model for studies of the initiation of DNA replication, and its regulation, in eukaryotes. Initiation of SV40 replication requires a single viral protein termed T-antigen, all other proteins are supplied by the host. The recent determination of the solution structure of the T-antigen domain that recognizes the SV40 origin has provided significant insights into the initiation process. For example, it has afforded a clearer understanding of origin recognition, T-antigen oligomerization, and DNA unwinding. Furthermore, the Simian virus 40 in vitro replication system has been used to study nascent DNA formation in the vicinity of the viral origin of replication. Among the conclusions drawn from these experiments is that nascent DNA synthesis does not initiate in the core origin in vitro and that Okazaki fragment formation is complex. These and related studies demonstrate that significant progress has been made in understanding the initiation of DNA synthesis at the molecular level.

Use of sequential immunoprecipitation to reveal discrete, separable populations of SV40 T-antigen binding to host cellular proteins

Sequential immunoprecipitations were carried out to determine the usefulness of this method for separating subpopulations of SV40 T-antigen complexed to various combinations of the cellular growth regulatory proteins pRB, p107, and p53. This approach was used successfully to separate discrete populations of SV40 T-antigen in a quatramolecular complex with pRB, p53, and p107, a trimolecular complex with pRB and p107, and a trimolecular complex with p107 and p53. This method was used as the first step towards isolating T-antigen for subsequent phosphopeptide mapping to address whether alterations in the overt phosphorylation of this viral oncoprotein is a major determinating factor to separation of T-antigen populations by complexing with different combinations of cellular growth regulatory proteins.

SV40 large T antigen with c-Jun down-regulates myelin P0 gene expression: a mechanism for papovaviral T antigen-mediated demyelination

Expression of myelin proteins has been shown to be altered in transgenic mice that express papovaviral large tumor (T) antigens. This paper analyzes the effect on P0 gene expression in secondary Schwann cells transfected with the SV40 T antigen gene and in Schwann cells immortalized by T antigen. In secondary Schwann cells, both T antigen and c-Jun are required for significant inhibition of the P0 promoter; expression of only one of the proteins is insufficient for repression of the P0 gene. T antigen, c-Jun (p39), and c-Jun-related protein (p47) form an immunoprecipitable complex in SV40 immortalized Schwann cell lines, and T antigen and c-Jun bind independently and as a complex to the P0 promoter. Our data suggest that the probable molecular mechanism underlying the hypomyelination observed in transgenic animals expressing T antigen may be due to the repression of the P0 gene by T antigen and c-Jun.

Two synthetic Sp1-binding sites functionally substitute for the 21-base-pair repeat region to activate simian virus 40 growth in CV-1 cells

The 21-bp repeat region of simian virus 40 (SV40) activates viral transcription and DNA replication and contains binding sites for many cellular proteins, including Sp1, LSF, ETF, Ap2, Ap4, GT-1B, H16, and p53, and for the SV40 large tumor antigen. We have attempted to reduce the complexity of this region while maintaining its growth-promoting capacity. Deletion of the 21-bp repeat region from the SV40 genome delays the expression of viral early proteins and DNA replication and reduces virus production in CV-1 cells. Replacement of the 21-bp repeat region with two copies of DNA sequence motifs bound with high affinities by Sp1 promotes SV40 growth in CV-1 cells to nearly wild-type levels, but substitution by motifs bound less avidly by Sp1 or bound by other activator proteins does not restore growth. This indicates that Sp1 or a protein with similar sequence specificity is primarily responsible for the function of the 21-bp repeat region. We speculate about how Sp1 activates both SV40 transcription and DNA replication.

Altered phosphorylation of free and bound forms of monkey p53 and simian virus 40 large T antigen during lytic infection

We have identified the phosphorylation sites in monkey p53 as well as specific changes in the phosphorylation state of free and complexed forms of simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen (T) and monkey p53 isolate from SV40 lytically infected CV1 cells. Phosphopeptide analyses of free T and p53 (To and p53o) and complexed T and p53 (T+ and p53+) fractions indicated several quantitative increases in the specific phosphorylation of complexed forms of both proteins. The N terminus of monkey p53+ is phosphorylated at Ser-9, Ser-15, Ser-20, either Ser-33 or Ser-37, and at least one of Ser-90 to Ser-99. The C-terminal sites are Ser-315 and Ser-392. On comparing p53+ with p53o, we found that labeling of the two N-terminal phosphotryptic peptides encompassing residues 1 to 20 and 33 to 101 was increased fivefold and that Ser-315 was sevenfold more labeled than was Ser-392. When T+ was compared with To, the N-terminal peptide containing phosphorylation sites Ser-106 through Thr-124 was twofold more labeled, the peptide containing Ser-657 through Ser-679 was sixfold more labeled and contained up to four phosphorylated serine residues, and Ser-639 and Thr-701 appeared unchanged. Overall, T+ molecules appeared to contain 3.5 mol more of labeled phosphate than did To, with the N-terminal peptide appearing fully phosphorylated. The phosphopeptide patterns obtained for lytic T+ and To fractions were nearly identical to those found for wild-type SV40 T (stably complexed with mouse p53) and mutant 5080 T (defective for p53 binding) expressed in transformed C3H10T1/2 cells (L. Tack, C. Cartwright, J. Wright, A. Srinivasan, W. Eckhart, K. Peden, and J. Pipas, J. Virol. 63:3362-3367, 1989). These results indicate that increases in specific phosphorylation sites in both T+ and p53+ correlate with the association of T with p53. The enhanced phosphorylation state may be a consequence of complex formation between T and p53 or reflect an increased affinity of p53 for highly phosphorylated forms of T.

Wild-type but not mutant p53 immunopurified proteins bind to sequences adjacent to the SV40 origin of replication

The DNA from a wide variety of human tumors has sustained mutations within the conserved p53 coding regions. We have purified wild-type and tumor-derived mutant p53 proteins expressed from baculovirus vectors and examined their interactions with SV40 DNA. Using DNAase I footprinting assays, we observed that both human and murine wild-type p53 proteins bind specifically to sequences adjacent to the late border of the viral replication origin. By contrast, mutant p53 proteins failed to bind specifically to these sequences. SV40 T antigen prevented wild-type p53 from interacting with this region. These data show that normal but not oncogenic forms of p53 are capable of sequence-specific interactions with viral DNA. Furthermore, they provide insights into the mechanisms by which viral proteins might regulate the control of viral growth and cell division.

The zinc finger region of simian virus 40 large T antigen is needed for hexamer assembly and origin melting

Simian virus 40 large T antigen contains a single sequence element with an arrangement of cysteines and histidines that is characteristic of a zinc finger motif. The finger region maps from amino acids 302 through 320 and has the sequence C-302 L K C-305 I K K E Q P S H Y K Y H-317 E K H-320. Previous genetic analysis has shown that the cysteine and histidine sequences and the contiguous S H Y K Y region in the finger are important for DNA replication in vivo. We show here that representative mutations in either of these elements of the finger prevent the assembly of large T antigen into stable hexamers in vitro. These same mutations have a characteristic effect on the interaction of T antigen with the simian virus 40 core origin of replication. The mutant T antigens bind to the central pentanucleotide domain of the core origin but fail to melt the adjacent inverted repeat domain and to untwist the adenine-thymine domain. These defects would prevent the formation of a replication bubble and the initiation of DNA replication. Finger mutations have lesser effects on the helicase function of T antigen and no observable effect on binding of T antigen to the mouse p53 protein. We propose that the zinc finger region contributes to protein-protein interactions essential for the assembly of stable T-antigen hexamers at the origin of replication and that hexamers are needed for subsequent alterations in the structure of origin DNA. We cannot exclude the possibility that the zinc finger region also makes specific contacts with components of origin DNA.

Stable T-p53 complexes are not required for replication of simian virus 40 in culture or for enhanced phosphorylation of T antigen and p53

We generated a number of simian virus 40 (SV40) mutants with single amino acid substitutions in T antigen between residues 388 and 411. All but one mutant (398LV) replicated like wild-type SV40 and gave rise to normal-size plaques. Three different mutations at residue 402 (Asp to Glu, Asn, or His) totally prevented the formation of stable complexes with the cellular protein p53 in monkey cells but had no effect on virus replication. Only one other mutation in this region, involving residue 401 (Met to Thr), slightly inhibited the formation of T-monkey p53 complexes. The three mutant T antigens with substitutions at residue 402 also formed no stable complexes with human p53 but generated low levels of complexes with mouse p53. These results indicate that residue 402 is critical for binding to monkey and human p53 proteins and is important for binding to mouse p53. We suggest that it is one of several points of contact. In cells infected with any one of the three residue 402 mutant viruses. T antigen and p53 became increasingly phosphorylated, as they were in cells infected with wild-type virus. Our data therefore show that stable T-p53 complexes are not required for replication of SV40 in culture or for enhanced phosphorylation of either protein.

Factors contributing to the restricted DNA replicating activity of JC virus

The basis for the restricted host range behavior of JC virus (JCV) in vitro was investigated by focusing on its DNA replicating activity and comparing it to that of simian virus 40 (SV40). Prototype, mutant, and hybrid JCV and SV40 DNAs were tested for their replicating activity in cells permissive for one or both of the viruses. Results from these experiments indicated that, relative to its SV40 counterpart, the JCV T antigen functioned less efficiently and was more specific in its interactions with polyomavirus DNA replication origins. The JCV T antigen exhibited a lower specific DNA binding activity than did the SV40 T antigen, which might contribute to this virus' reduced DNA replicating activity. However, the JCV protein did bind to both the JCV and SV40 replication origins with similar efficiency, indicating that the ability of the JCV T antigen to discriminate between the JCV and SV40 origins involved a step subsequent to specific DNA binding. The results also suggested that the failure of JCV to replicate to detectable levels in monkey kidney cells was due to the inefficient interactions of its T protein with the viral origin and the host replication machinery. The inability of the JCV T antigen to carry out one or more of these DNA replication functions efficiently contributes to the restricted lytic behavior of this virus.

Domains required for in vitro association between the cellular p53 and the adenovirus 2 E1B 55K proteins

The 55K protein encoded by the adenovirus 2 E1B gene is required for complete cellular transformation and binds the cellular protein p53. Using an in vitro immunoprecipitation assay, we mapped the domains in both 55K and p53 required for the interaction of the two proteins. The domain in p53 mapped to the amino terminal 123 residues. There are several domains in the 495 residue 55K polypeptide which contribute to stable association with p53, with the most essential region mapping between residues 224 and 354. Mutations which prevented 55K-p53 binding were not more defective for transformation than other mutations which did not affect binding.

Wild-type, but not mutant, human p53 proteins inhibit the replication activities of simian virus 40 large tumor antigen

Murine p53 blocks many of the replication activities of simian virus 40 (SV40) large tumor antigen (T antigen) in vitro. As murine cells do not replicate SV40 DNA, it was of interest to determine how p53 from permissive human cells functions. Recombinant baculoviruses encoding either the wild-type form of human p53 or a mutant p53 cloned from a human tumor cell line were constructed, and p53 proteins were purified from infected insect cells. Surprisingly, we found that wild-type human p53 was as inhibitory to the ability of T antigen to mediate replication of an SV40 origin-containing (ori DNA) plasmid in vitro as was murine p53. Wild-type human p53 also blocked the DNA unwinding activity of T antigen, as did its murine counterpart. In contrast to murine and wild-type human p53, the mutant human p53 did not block ori DNA replication or DNA unwinding. Murine p53 formed a complex with mutant human p53 in vivo. Furthermore, mutant human p53 reduced the inhibition of SV40 ori DNA replication by murine p53 in vitro. These results provide a model for the way in which mutant p53 proteins can affect normal functions of p53.

Assembly of nascent DNA into nucleosome structures in simian virus 40 chromosomes by HeLa cell extract

A soluble system was developed that could support DNA replication in simian virus 40 (SV40) chromosomes. DNA synthesis in this system required the presence of purified SV40 large tumor antigen, SV40 chromosomes prepared from virus-infected monkey cells, a crude extract from HeLa cells, and several low-molecular-weight components. In comparison to the replication of purified SV40 form I DNA, the rate of DNA synthesis was 15 to 20% in this system. DNA synthesis started near the replication origin of SV40 and proceeded bidirectionally in a semiconservative manner. Micrococcal nuclease digestion experiments revealed that the replicated DNA produced in this system became organized into a regularly spaced array of nucleosome core particles when an appropriate amount of purified HeLa core histones was added to the reaction mixture. SV40 form I DNA replicating under the same conditions was also assembled into nucleosomes, which were arranged in a rather dispersed manner and formed an aberrant chromatin structure.

Simian virus 40 DNA replication correlates with expression of a particular subclass of T antigen in a human glial cell line

Immunocytochemistry and in situ hybridization were used to identify simian virus 40 (SV40) large T-antigen expression and viral DNA replication in individual cells of infected semipermissive human cell lines. SV40 infection aborts before T-antigen expression in many cells of each of the human cell lines examined. In all but one of the human cell lines, most of the T-antigen-producing cells replicated viral DNA. However, in the A172 line of human glial cells only a small percentage of the T-antigen-expressing cells replicated viral DNA. Since different structural and functional classes of T antigen can be recognized with anti-T monoclonal antibodies, we examined infected A172 cells with a panel of 10 anti-T monoclonal antibodies to determine whether viral DNA replication might correlate with the expression of a particular epitope of T antigen. One anti-T monoclonal antibody, PAb 100, did specifically recognize that subset of A172 cells which replicated SV40 DNA. The percentage of PAb 100-reactive A172 cells was dramatically increased by the DNA synthesis inhibitors hydroxyurea and aphidicolin. Removal of the hydroxyurea was followed by an increase in the percentage of cells replicating viral DNA corresponding to the increased percentage reactive with PAb 100. The pattern of SV40 infection in A172 cells was not altered by infection with viable viral mutants containing lesions in the small t protein, the agnoprotein, or the enhancer region. Finally, in situ hybridization was used to show that the percentage of human cells expressing T antigen was similar to the percentage transcribing early SV40 mRNA. Thus, the block to T-antigen expression in human cells is at a stage prior to transcription of early SV40 mRNA.

cis-active elements from mouse chromosomal DNA suppress simian virus 40 DNA replication

Simian virus 40 (SV40)-containing DNA was rescued after the fusion of SV40-transformed VLM cells with permissive COS1 monkey cells and cloned, and prototype plasmid clones were characterized. A 2-kilobase mouse DNA fragment fused with the rescued SV40 DNA, and derived from mouse DNA flanking the single insert of SV40 DNA in VLM cells, was sequenced. Insertion of the intact rescued mouse sequence, or two nonoverlapping fragments of it, into wild-type SV40 plasmid DNA suppressed replication of the plasmid in TC7 monkey cells, although the plasmids expressed replication-competent T antigen. Rat cells were transformed with linearized wild-type SV40 plasmid DNA with or without fragments of the mouse DNA in cis. Although all of the rat cell lines expressed approximately equal amounts of T antigen and p53, transformants carrying SV40 DNA linked to either of the same two replication suppressor fragments produced significantly less free SV40 DNA after fusion with permissive cells than those transformed by SV40 DNA without a cellular insert or with a cellular insert lacking suppressor activity. The results suggest that two independent segments of cellular DNA act in cis to suppress SV40 replication in vivo, either as a plasmid or integrated in chromosomal DNA.

Mutation of the serine 312 phosphorylation site does not alter the ability of mouse p53 to inhibit simian virus 40 DNA replication in vivo

Two mutations were introduced into the wild-type mouse p53 gene by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. These mutations substituted alanine or aspartic acid for serine at position 312, which is constitutively phosphorylated. Phosphopeptide mapping of the mutant proteins, expressed in COS cells, confirmed the loss of phosphorylation at position 312. There were no changes in the ability of the mutant p53s to express the conformation-dependent epitope for monoclonal antibody PAb246 or to participate in complexes with the simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen. Replication of a plasmid containing the SV40 origin of replication was inhibited in COS cells by wild-type p53 and both of the phosphorylation site mutants with equal efficiency. A transforming mutant of p53, encoding valine at position 135, did not inhibit SV40 DNA replication in COS cells.

p53: oncogene or anti-oncogene?

Collapse

Constitutive expression of simian virus 40 large T antigen in monkey cells activates their capacity to support polyomavirus replication

Polyomavirus DNA replication is normally restricted to rodent cells, and simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA replication is restricted to primate cells. We demonstrate that DNAs containing the polyomavirus origin can be replicated in monkey cells which constitutively express SV40 large T antigen. Permissivity is most likely caused by SV40 T antigen modification of cellular protein(s) required to replicate the polyomavirus origin. A possible target for the T-antigen-induced modification is DNA polymerase alpha-DNA primase.

Effects of the cellular p53 protein on Simian-virus-40-T-antigen-catalyzed DNA unwinding in vitro

It is known that large T antigen, the regulatory protein encoded by Simian virus 40 (SV40), forms tight complexes with the cellular p53 protein in SV40-transformed rodent cells. Using immunoaffinity procedures we have purified large T antigen and, in separate experiments, the cellular p53 protein. The two proteins formed complexes in vitro which bound well to double-stranded DNA fragments although in a sequence-unspecific manner. Free, uncomplexed T antigen readily converted double-stranded DNA into a single-stranded form whereas in-vitro-formed p53-T-antigen complexes were inactive in this reaction. We conclude that one function of p53 in SV40-transformed mouse cells could be the inhibition of the replication initiating activity of T antigen.

Properties of a simian virus 40 mutant T antigen substituted in the hydrophobic region: defective ATPase and oligomerization activities and altered phosphorylation accompany an inability to complex with cellular p53

We have analyzed the biochemical properties of a nonviable simian virus 40 (SV40) mutant encoding a large T antigen (T) bearing an amino acid substitution (Pro-584-Leu) in its hydrophobic region. Mutant 5080 has an altered cell type specificity for transformation (transforming mouse C3H10T1/2 but not rat REF52 cells), is defective for viral DNA replication, and encodes a T that is unable to form a complex with the cellular p53 protein (K. Peden, A. Srinivasan, J. Farber, and J. Pipas, Virology 168:13-21, 1989). In this article, we show that 5080-transformed C3H10T1/2 cell lines express an altered T that is synthesized at a significantly higher rate but with a shorter half-life than normal T from wild-type SV40-transformed cells. 5080 T did not oligomerize beyond 5 to 10S in size compared with normal T, which oligomerized predominantly to 14 to 20S species. In addition, the 5080 T complex had significantly decreased ATPase activity and had a 10-fold-lower level of in vivo phosphorylation compared with that of normal T. Two-dimensional phosphopeptide analysis indicated several changes in the specific 32P labeling pattern, with altered phosphorylation occurring at both termini of the mutant protein compared with the wild-type T. Loss of p53 binding is therefore concomitant with changes in ATPase activity, oligomerization, stability, and in vivo phosphorylation of T and can be correlated with defective replication and restricted transformation functions. That so many biochemical changes are associated with a single substitution in the hydrophobic region of T is consistent with its importance in regulating higher-order structural and functional relationships in SV40 T.