Structural and functional characterization of rev-like transcripts of equine infectious anemia virus

Host cell restriction factors of equine infectious anemia virus

Equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) is a member of the lentivirus genus in the Retroviridae family and is considered an animal model for HIV/AIDS research. An attenuated EIAV vaccine, which was successfully developed in the 1970s by classical serial passage techniques, is the first and only lentivirus vaccine that has been widely used to date. Restriction factors are cellular proteins that provide an early line of defense against viral replication and spread by interfering with various critical steps in the viral replication cycle. However, viruses have evolved specific mechanisms to overcome these host barriers through adaptation. The battle between the viruses and restriction factors is actually a natural part of the viral replication process, which has been well studied in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1). EIAV has the simplest genome composition of all lentiviruses, making it an intriguing subject for understanding how the virus employs its limited viral proteins to overcome restriction factors. In this review, we summarize the current literature on the interactions between equine restriction factors and EIAV. The features of equine restriction factors and the mechanisms by which the EIAV counteract the restriction suggest that lentiviruses employ diverse strategies to counteract innate immune restrictions. In addition, we present our insights on whether restriction factors induce alterations in the phenotype of the attenuated EIAV vaccine.

Identification of a Novel Post-transcriptional Transactivator from the Equine Infectious Anemia Virus

All lentiviruses encode a post-transcriptional transactivator, Rev, which mediates the export of viral mRNA from the nucleus to the cytoplasm and which is required for viral gene expression and viral replication. In the current study, we demonstrate that equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV), an equine lentivirus, encodes a second post-transcriptional transactivator that we designate Grev. Grev is encoded by a novel transcript with a single splicing event that was identified using reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) and RNA-seq in EIAV-infected horse tissues and cells. Grev is about 18 kDa in size, comprises the first 18 amino acids (aa) of Gag protein together with the last 82 aa of Rev, and was detected in EIAV-infected cells. Similar to Rev, Grev is localized to the nucleus, and both are able to mediate the expression of Mat (a recently identified viral protein of unknown function from EIAV), but Rev can mediate the expression of EIAV Gag/Pol, while Grev cannot. We also demonstrate that Grev, similar to Rev, specifically binds to rev-responsive element 2 (RRE-2, located in the first exon of mat mRNAs) to promote nuclear export of mat mRNA via the chromosome region maintenance 1 (CRM1) pathway. However, unlike Rev, whose function depends on its multimerization, we could not detect multimerization of Grev using coimmunoprecipitation (co-IP) or bimolecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) assays. Together, these data suggest that EIAV encodes two post-transcriptional transactivators, Rev and Grev, with similar, but not identical, functions. IMPORTANCE Nuclear export of viral transcripts is a crucial step for viral gene expression and viral replication in lentiviruses, and this export is regulated by a post-transcriptional transactivator, Rev, that is shared by all lentiviruses. Here, we report that the equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) encodes a novel viral protein, Grev, and demonstrated that Grev, like Rev, mediates the expression of the viral protein Mat by binding to the first exon of mat mRNAs via the chromosome region maintenance 1 (CRM1) pathway. Grev is encoded by a single-spliced transcript containing two exons, whereas Rev is encoded by a multiple-spliced transcript containing four exons. Moreover, Rev is able to mediate EIAV Gag/Pol expression by binding to rev-responsive element (RRE) located within the Env-coding region, while Grev cannot. Therefore, the present study demonstrates that EIAV encodes two post-transcriptional regulators, Grev and Rev, suggesting that post-transcriptional regulation patterns in lentivirus are diverse and complex.

Enhancement of equine infectious anemia virus virulence by identification and removal of suboptimal nucleotides

Pathogenicity was reportedly restored to an avirulent molecular clone of equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) by substitution of 3' sequences from the pathogenic variant strain (EIAV(PV)). However, the incidence of disease in horses/ponies was found to be significantly lower (P = 0.016) with the chimeric clone (EIAV(UK)) than with EIAV(PV). This was attributable to 3' rather than 5' regions of the proviral genome, where EIAV(UK) differs from the consensus EIAV(PV) sequence by having a 68-bp duplication in the 3' LTR and arginine (R(103)) rather than tryptophan (W(103)) at position 103 in the second exon of rev. In EIAV(UK) recipients the duplication was rapidly eliminated and R(103) replaced by W(103) in the viral population. Furthermore, removal of the 3' variant sequences from EIAV(UK) (EIAV(UK3)) resulted in an equivalent (P = 0.013) disease potential in Equus caballus to EIAV(PV). The 68-bp duplication and/or R(103) may limit peak viral RNA accumulation during acute infection.

Multiple RNA splicing and the presence of cryptic RNA splice donor and acceptor sites may contribute to low expression levels and poor immunogenicity of potential DNA vaccines containing the env gene of equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV)

The env gene is an excellent candidate for inclusion in any DNA-based vaccine approach against equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV). Unfortunately, this gene is subjected to mutational pressure in E. coli resulting in the introduction of stop codons at the 5' terminus unless it is molecularly cloned using very-low-copy-number plasmid vectors. To overcome this problem, a mammalian expression vector was constructed based on the low-copy-number pLG338-30 plasmid. This permitted the production of full-length EIAV env gene clones (plcnCMVenv) from which low-level expression of the viral surface unit glycoprotein (gp90) was detected following transfection into COS-1 cells. Although this suggested the nuclear export of complete env mRNA moieties at least two additional polypeptides of 29 and 20kDa (probably Rev) were produced by alternative splicing events as demonstrated by the fact that their synthesis was prevented by mutational inactivation of EIAV env splice donor 3 (SD3) site. The plcnCMVenv did not stimulate immune responses in mice or in horses, whereas an env construct containing an inactivated SD3 site (plcnCMVDeltaSD3) did induce weak humoral responses against gp90 in mice. This poor immunogenicty in vivo was probably not related to the inherent antigenicity of the proteins encoded by these constructs but to some fundamental properties of EIAV env gene expression. Attempts to modify one of these properties by mutational inactivation of known viral RNA splice sites resulted in activation of previously unidentified cryptic SD and slice acceptor sites.

CRM1-dependent function of a cis-acting RNA export element

Viruses often contain cis-acting RNA elements, which facilitate the posttranscriptional processing and export of their messages. These elements fall into two classes distinguished by the presence of either viral or cellular RNA binding proteins. To date, studies have indicated that the viral proteins utilize the CRM1-dependent export pathway, while the cellular factors generally function in a CRM1-independent manner. The cis-acting element found in the woodchuck hepatitis virus (WHV) (the WHV posttranscriptional regulatory element [WPRE]) has the ability to posttranscriptionally stimulate transgene expression and requires no viral proteins to function. Conventional wisdom suggests that the WPRE would function in a CRM1-independent manner. However, our studies on this element reveal that its efficient function is sensitive to the overexpression of the C terminus of CAN/Nup214 and treatment with the antimicrobial agent leptomycin B. Furthermore, the overexpression of CRM1 stimulates WPRE activity. These results suggest a direct role for CRM1 in the export function of the WPRE. This observation suggests that the WPRE is directing messages into a CRM1-dependent mRNA export pathway in somatic mammalian cells.

Equine infectious anaemia virus proteins with epitopes most frequently recognized by cytotoxic T lymphocytes from infected horses

Efficacious lentiviral vaccines designed to induce cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in outbred populations with a diverse repertoire of MHC class I molecules should contain or express multiple viral proteins. To determine the equine infectious anaemia virus (EIAV) proteins with epitopes most frequently recognized by CTL from seven horses infected for 0.5 to 7 years, retroviral vector-transduced target cells expressing viral proteins were used in CTL assays. Gag p15 was recognized by CTL from 100% of these infected horses. p26 was recognized by CTL from 86%, SU and the middle third of Pol protein were each recognized by 43%, TM by 29%, and S2 by 14%. Based on these results, it is likely that a construct expressing the 359 amino acids constituting p15 and p26 would contain epitopes capable of stimulating CTL in most horses.

Regulation of equine infectious anemia virus expression

Equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) is an ungulate lentivirus that is related to human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Much of the understanding of lentiviral gene regulation comes from studies using HIV. HIV studies have provided insights into molecular regulation of EIAV expression; however, much of the regulation of EIAV expression stands in stark contrast to that of HIV. This review provides an overview of the current state of knowledge of EIAV regulation by comparing and contrasting EIAV gene regulation to HIV. The role of EIAV gene regulation is discussed in relation to EIAV pathogenesis.

Mutations occurring during serial passage of Japanese equine infectious anemia virus in primary horse macrophages

An attenuated equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV), named V26, was previously obtained after 50 passages of the Japanese virulent strain V70 in primary macrophage culture. To clarify the differences between both viruses, their full-length sequences were determined. There were higher mutations in S2 (6.15% amino acid difference) and LTR (10.7% nucleotide difference). The presumed initiation codon of the S2 gene was absent from the sequence of V26. There was a large insertion within the long-terminal repeat (LTR) U3 hypervariable region of V26. In addition, there were minor mutations in gag (1.22% amino acid difference), pol (1.05% amino acid difference) and env (1. 65% amino acid difference) regions, but no mutation in tat region. No mutations were observed in the principal neutralizing domain in the gp90. Thus, the mutations in the S2 and LTR might be the major target sites of mutation in EIAV during serial passages in vitro.

Suboptimal splice sites of equine infectious anaemia virus control Rev responsiveness

The Rev protein of equine infectious anaemia virus (EIAV) was shown previously to stimulate the expression of a heterologous CAT reporter gene when the 3' half of the EIAV genome was present downstream in cis. However, computer analysis could not reveal the existence of a stable RNA secondary structure that could be analogous to the Rev-responsive element of other lentiviruses. In the present study, the inhibitory RNA element designated the cis-acting repressing sequence (CRS) has been localized to the centre of the EIAV genome. The inhibition exerted by this element could be overcome by supplying Rev in trans. The ability of the EIAV CRS to function in a heterologous context suggests that it does not require interactions with other viral proteins. Site-directed mutagenesis showed that the various centrally located suboptimal splice sites of the EIAV genome function as CRS and confer Rev-dependence on the CRS-containing transcripts. In addition, the data suggest that in canine Cf2Th cells, which are highly permissive for EIAV replication, CRS prevents nuclear export of CRS-containing transcripts and the supply of Rev relieves this suppression.

Demonstration that orf2 encodes the feline immunodeficiency virus transactivating (Tat) protein and characterization of a unique gene product with partial rev activity

The long PCR technique was used to amplify the three size classes of viral mRNAs produced in cells infected by feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV). We identified in the env region a new splice acceptor site that generated two transcripts, each coding for an 11-kDa protein, p11(rev), whose function is unknown. The small-size class of mRNAs included two bicistronic orf2/rev mRNAs and two rev-like mRNAs, consisting only of the second exon of rev and coding for a 15-kDa protein, p15(rev). p15(rev) contained the minimal effector domain of Rev and was sufficient to mediate partial Rev activity. The bicistronic mRNAs encoded two distinct proteins, one of 23 kDa corresponding to Rev and a 9-kDa protein encoded by the orf2 gene. The orf2 gene product is a protein of 79 amino acids with characteristics similar to those of the Tat (transactivator) proteins of the ungulate lentiviruses. Transient expression assays, using the FIV long terminal repeat (LTR) to drive transcription of the bacterial gene for chloramphenicol acetyltransferase demonstrated that the orf2 gene transactivates gene expression an average of 14- to 20-fold above the basal level. Deletion mutants of the FIV LTR were generated to locate sequences responsive to transactivation mediated by the orf2 gene. A 5' deletion mutant that removed the AP1 site resulted in residual low-level transactivation by orf2. Further experiments using LTR mutants with internal deletions identified three regions located between positions -126 and -47 relative to the cap site that were important for orf2-directed transactivation. These regions include the AP1 site, a C/EBP tandem repeat, and an ATF site.

cDNA excision in stable retroviral cDNA transfectants is prevented by R removal

The present study provides evidence on the occurrence of DNA rearrangement between the redundant 5' and 3' R domains of equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) Tat cDNA. This was correlated with a gradual loss of cDNA copy number concomitantly with a decrease in gene expression. Removal of the 5' RU5 abolished rearrangement and stabilized Tat expression in EIAV tat cDNA transfectants. Our data suggest that prior removal of the 5' R from cloned retroviral cDNAs can impede DNA rearrangement, thus preventing cDNA excision that frequently occurs and hinders permanent expression of retroviral cDNAs in stable transfectants.

The Tat protein of equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) activates cellular gene expression by read-through transcription

The Tat protein of equine infectious anemia virus, EIAV, was shown to augment viral gene expression, presumably through interaction with the Tat responsive element, TAR. Recently, cell-free polyadenylation assays suggested that perturbation of the EIAV TAR secondary structure diminished polyadenylation efficiency. The present study indicates that the EIAV TAR regulates the efficiency of the 3'-end processing of viral RNA also in transfected cells. Moreover, our data suggest that the provision of the EIAV Tat protein in trans potentiates read-through transcription through the 3' viral long terminal repeat (3' LTR), thus suggesting activation of downstream-located cellular genes.

Development and characterization of an in vivo pathogenic molecular clone of equine infectious anemia virus

An infectious nonpathogenic molecular clone (19-2-6A) of equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) was modified by substitution of a 3.3-kbp fragment amplified by PCR techniques from a pathogenic variant (EIAV(PV)) of the cell culture-adapted strain of EIAV (EIAV(PR)). This substitution consisted of coding sequences for 77 amino acids at the carboxyl terminus of the integrase, the S1 (encoding the second exon of tat), S2, and S3 (encoding the second exon of rev) open reading frames, the complete env gene (including the first exon of rev), and the 3' long terminal repeat (LTR). Modified 19-2-6A molecular clones were designated EIAV(PV3.3), and infection of a single pony (678) with viruses derived from a mixture of five of these molecular clones induced clinical signs of acute equine infectious anemia (EIA) at 23 days postinfection (dpi). As a consequence of this initial study, a single molecular clone, EIAV(PV3.3#3) (redesignated EIAV(UK)), was selected for further study and inoculated into two ponies (613 and 614) and two horses (700 and 764). Pony 614 and the two horses developed febrile responses by 12 dpi, which was accompanied by a 48 to 64% reduction in platelet number, whereas pony 613 did not develop fever (40.6 degrees C) until 76 dpi. EIAV could be isolated from the plasma of these animals by 5 to 7 dpi, and all became seropositive for antibodies to this virus by 21 dpi. Analysis of the complete nucleotide sequence demonstrated that the 3.3-kbp 3' fragment of EIAV(UK) differed from the consensus sequence of EIAV(PV) by just a single amino acid residue in the second exon of the rev gene. Complete homology with the EIAV(PV) consensus sequence was observed in the hypervariable region of the LTR. However, EIAV(UK) was found to contain an unusual 68-bp nucleotide insertion/duplication in a normally conserved region of the LTR sequence. These results demonstrate that substitution of a 3.3-kbp fragment from the EIAV(PV) strain into the infectious nonpathogenic molecular clone 19-2-6A leads to the production of progeny virus particles with the ability to induce clinical signs of EIA. Therefore, EIAV(UK), which is the first pathogenic, cell culture-adapted molecular clone of EIAV to be described, should be of value in identifying viral determinants of pathogenicity.

Inhibitory activity of the equine infectious anemia virus major 5' splice site in the absence of Rev

The major 5' splice site of equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) conforms to the consensus 5' splice site in eight consecutive positions and is located immediately upstream of the gag AUG. Our results show that the presence of this 5' splice site on the EIAV gag mRNA decreases Gag production 30- to 60-fold. This is caused by inefficient nuclear mRNA export and inefficient mRNA utilization. Inhibition could be overcome by providing human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Rev/Rev-responsive element, human T-cell leukemia virus type 1 Rex/Rex-responsive element, or simian retrovirus type 1 constitutive transport element. In addition, inhibition could be abolished by introducing single point mutations in the 5' splice site or by moving the 5' splice site away from its natural position immediately upstream of the gag AUG. This demonstrates that both maintenance of a perfect consensus 5' splice site and its proper location on the mRNA are important for inhibitory activity of the EIAV major 5' splice site.

Two species of Rev proteins, with distinct N termini, are expressed by caprine arthritis encephalitis virus

Several cDNA clones representing alternatively spliced Rev-specific transcripts were isolated from a cDNA library prepared from Himalayan tahr cells infected with caprine arthritis encephalitis virus (CAEV). We previously characterized two rev-like cDNA species, d1 and d2, and a tat e1 cDNA containing the rev coding sequence downstream to the tat. In these cDNAs, the rev coding domain derives its amino terminus from the N terminus of env, which is spliced to the 3' open reading frame encoding the putative Rev protein. In this study, we report the genetic structure of a fourth rev-like cDNA (designated g1), which lacks the 5' env-derived sequences. All of these rev transcripts, including cDNA g1, increased the level of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase expression when cotransfected with a reporter plasmid containing the CAEV Rev-response element-spanning region downstream of the cat coding sequences. Western blot (immunoblot) analysis showed that each transfected cDNA species gave rise to a 16-kDa protein lacking env-encoded amino-terminal epitopes. In contrast, CAEV-infected Himalayan tahr cells expressed only a 20-kDa protein, whose N terminus, in contrast, is derived from the env. Moreover, only the 20-kDa protein was also detected in the mature CAEV virions. These observations suggest that the transcripts d1, d2, and e1 can potentially, in appropriate cellular context, encode two Rev isoforms differing in their N termini, whereas the g1 transcript encodes only the 16-kDa species. Elucidation of the significance of the 16-kDa Rev protein in CAEV biology must await further studies.

Biological activity and intracellular location of the Tat protein of equine infectious anemia virus

The Tat protein of equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) was synthesized in Escherichia coli using the inducible expression plasmid, pET16b, which contains a His.Tag leader, thus allowing for rapid and efficient enrichment of the histidine-tagged protein by metal affinity chromatography. Yields of up to 20 mg of Tat were obtained from 10(11) bacterial cells. The recombinant Tat protein was shown to potently trans-activate the EIAV long terminal repeat (LTR) following its introduction into canine cells by 'scrape loading'. The EIAV Tat protein was found to localize predominantly within the cytoplasm, in contrast to HIV-1 Tat. The availability of large amounts of purified functional EIAV Tat protein should greatly facilitate detailed structure-function analyses.

Equine infectious anemia virus trans-regulatory protein Rev controls viral mRNA stability, accumulation, and alternative splicing

The cis- and trans-acting components of the Rev regulatory pathway employed by equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) to regulate and coordinate viral gene expression were examined in complementation experiments. Viral protein expression and mRNA expression were compared in cells transiently transfected with wild-type or mutant proviruses in combination with Rev expression plasmids. Mutation of the predicted rev gene abolished Gag protein synthesis, and this defect was complemented, in trans, by Rev. Analysis of viral mRNAs from transfected cells confirmed that EIAV expresses five major mRNAs: the full-length and singly spliced mRNAs contain introns and encode viral structural proteins while the three fully spliced mRNAs, encoding nonstructural genes, are generated by alternative splicing. Compared to cells transfected with the wild-type provirus, the intron-containing mRNAs produced from the rev-minus mutant were present at reduced levels in the nuclear RNA fraction and were not detected in the cytoplasm. This pattern of viral mRNA synthesis was restored to the wild-type pattern by providing Rev in trans. In contrast to the intron-containing mRNAs, cytoplasmic accumulation of the multiply spliced class of mRNAs was independent of Rev. Closer examination of the multiply spliced class of viral mRNAs by reverse transcriptase-PCR analysis revealed a Rev-dependent alternative splicing phenomenon. In the absence of Rev, proviruses expressed a four-exon mRNA at high levels; the addition of Rev caused both a decrease in the levels of the four-exon mRNA and the appearance of a related mRNA lacking exon 3. The cis-acting RNA elements that mediate Rev responsiveness were studied with deleted proviruses, which revealed that EIAV contains at least two elements located near the ends of envelope gene. Unlike the Rev-responsive elements in other retroviruses, the cis-acting regions of EIAV do not appear to form complex secondary structures.